Self-as-an-End
SAE Theory of the University · Paper 3

University Research
大学的科研

Han Qin (秦汉) · Independent Researcher · 2026
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24293742 · Full PDF on Zenodo · CC BY 4.0
Abstract

The university does not only teach; it also does research, and students too practice judgment in research. This paper writes about research. It begins with a change in a Norwegian rule: in September 2024 the Norwegian Directorate for Higher Education and Skills announced that from 2025 publication points would no longer be part of the funding of higher education institutions. A paper is first converted into points, and points into money: this is a written conversion; it can be written into rules, and it can be taken out of them. This paper asks: when the university itself adopts research standards as gates for appointment, promotion and resources, who answers for this conversion, and what has to be answered? The paper states five propositions. The university answers for its adoption and conversion: why it adopts, how it converts, what consequences it attaches, whether there is review, whether it can withdraw. Authorship records doing and being responsible: the author list does not say what each person contributed, and contributions are recorded separately; those who cannot be responsible for the work are not listed as authors; what students and staff did is recorded under the names of those who did it. The credit standard of mathematics: when the university adopts it as a gate, it asks whether understanding has advanced, without judging for mathematics whether its standard is right or wrong. Judgment in research is not stood in for by standards. In research, a student can raise questions, disagree with an interpretation of the data, and refuse to put his name to conclusions he cannot be responsible for, without suffering retaliation for it.

Writing Declaration: This paper was co-drafted with Claude (Anthropic). All intellectual decisions, framework design, and final editorial judgments were made by the author.

Introduction

On 18 September 2024 the Norwegian Directorate for Higher Education and Skills issued an announcement: "Publication points will no longer be part of the funding of the higher education institutions in Norway," effective from 2025. Until then, the part of state funding to institutions that was allocated by results worked this way: "The funding is calculated based on the number of publication points."

A paper is first converted into points, and points into money. This is a written conversion. It can be written into rules, and it can be taken out of them.

The opening asks one question only: when the university itself adopts research standards as gates for appointment, promotion and resources, who answers for this conversion, and what has to be answered?

The announcement proves only one point: the national funding model once had such a conversion, and withdrew it. Whether individual universities still allocate internally by points, the announcement does not say.

The paper has seven sections. §1 says that research standards are kept in two ledgers; §2, adoption and conversion; §3, authorship; §4, the credit standard of mathematics; §5, judgment in research; §6, students' judgment in research; §7 is a dialogue. Sections 2 to 6 each state one proposition at the end, and all are listed together at the end of the paper.


§1 Two Ledgers

The Theory of Disciplines reads a standard in two ledgers: "The descriptive ledger records how a standard says the world is: whether it measures accurately, whether it classifies stably, whether the evidence is sufficient. The normative ledger records what it presupposes: what counts as harm, what counts as health, what counts as fair, what counts as success, whether gains and losses may be offset against one another." (Theory of Disciplines, Prequel, §2)

Research standards are the same. Whether a standard for evaluating research measures accurately and classifies stably is recorded in the descriptive ledger: whether journal quartiles, say, really sort papers by quality. What counts as a research output, how credit is counted, how many conference papers one journal article is worth, how large a share goes to the first author: these are recorded in the normative ledger. An entry in the normative ledger does not become a description because it is written as a number.

Some of these entries are written: a quartile table of academic journals and a points scheme in promotion regulations each have a party that wrote them. Others are unwritten, customs of a trade: in one field, the corresponding author gets the largest credit; in another, one monograph outweighs ten articles. A custom has no party that wrote it. When the university writes a custom into its own rules for appointment and promotion, the university becomes the party that wrote it.

Research lives in the university, as disciplines do. The Theory of Disciplines asked how a discipline treats its standards; brought down to the university, the question is how the university applies these standards to people.

Here the series parts from Newman once more. Newman said the university is a place of teaching: "If its object were scientific and philosophical discovery, I do not see why a University should have students" (The Idea of a University, Preface). This series writes about research because disciplines live here, and because students also practice judgment in research (Paper 2).

This section states no proposition of its own; it prepares §2.


§2 Adoption and Conversion

The Theory of Disciplines says that a construct that adopts a standard as a gate answers for its adoption (Theory of Disciplines, S34). That proposition spoke of insurance, regulation, courts, platforms and admissions. Brought down to the university: when the university adopts research standards as gates for appointment, promotion and resources, it answers for its adoption.

Answers what? At least five questions. Why this standard is adopted. How it is converted: how journal quartiles become qualifications for appointment, how the order of authors becomes shares of contribution, how a certain kind of output becomes a budget. What consequences it is given: whether one quartile lower means promotion delayed by a year, or a contract not renewed. Whether there is review. Whether it can withdraw: whether the university can stop adopting this standard, and how. When the research of those evaluated does not produce that kind of output, whether there is another path by which they can be evaluated: that is a question this paper adds.

The Norwegian rule was a conversion written in at the national level and then taken out. Conversions inside a university can be written just the same, and questioned just the same.

At times the university is at once the party that writes a standard and the party that adopts it: it draws up its own list of journals and then uses it to evaluate its own people. The two accounts of writing and adopting (not the two ledgers of §1) are not merged into one because they belong to one institution. The party that writes explains what it wrote in, what it guaranteed and what it did not; the party that adopts answers for the trade-offs it adds. The layer added in adoption is not booked back to the party that wrote.

Some will say that the order of authors and the way of counting credit are a discipline's own conventions, and that the university's stepping in exceeds its authority. This proposition does not set conventions for disciplines. It asks only that when the university converts conventions into consequences for appointment, promotion and resources, it answer for this conversion.

DX14 The university answers for its adoption and conversion. What counts as an output and how credit is counted are entries in the normative ledger of standards; written ones have a party that wrote them, unwritten ones are customs of a trade with no party that wrote them, and when the university writes a custom into its rules for appointment and promotion, the university is the party that wrote it. When the university adopts these standards as gates for appointment, promotion and resources, it answers for its adoption: why it adopts, how it converts (how journal quartiles become qualifications for appointment, how the order of authors becomes shares of contribution, how a certain kind of output becomes a budget), what consequences it gives, whether there is review, whether it can withdraw. When the university both draws up and adopts a standard, the two accounts are not merged into one because the organization is the same.


§3 Authorship

Authorship records two things: who did what; who is responsible for it. This section is addressed to the university: in its own rules, evaluations and handling of disputes, the university reads authorship this way; how journals and disciplines define authorship remains their affair.

The author list by itself does not say what each person contributed. The authorship recommendations of the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors put it plainly: "authorship does not communicate what contributions qualified an individual to be an author." So contributions are recorded separately. The CRediT Contributor Roles Taxonomy lists fourteen roles, from conceptualization through data curation to writing and revision; it also states: "CRediT roles do not determine authorship eligibility." Contributions can be recorded separately, and authorship has conditions of its own.

Those who cannot be responsible for the work are not listed as authors. Several major publishers and preprint platforms provide that AI may not be listed as an author, on the grounds that it cannot take responsibility for the work; the Theory of Disciplines says this provision is one place where "judgment is not cancelled" lands, in authorship (Theory of Disciplines, Paper 9). The reason lies precisely here: authorship records being responsible.

Those who have already made substantial contributions ought to have the chance to take part in revision and final approval. Among the conditions of authorship is something like "taking part in revising and approving the final version"; one cannot first keep a person out of revision and then exclude him from authorship on the grounds that he does not meet that condition.

What students and staff did is recorded under the names of those who did it, either by listing them as authors or by writing it into the record of contributions; it is not taken away, nor diluted, because of high or low position. The record of contributions does not avow the conclusions of the whole work in his place: what he did, and whether he approved the published version and is responsible for its conclusions, are registered separately. Being publicly named as an author or in the acknowledgments is checked separately against the corresponding conditions and his own consent; being unwilling to put his name to the conclusions does not erase the contributions he has already made. The Theory of the Company has a sentence: the price falls on what is done, not on the person. Extended to credit: credit falls on what is done, not on position.

DX15 Authorship records doing and being responsible. Authorship records who did what and who is responsible for it. The author list by itself does not say what each person contributed, and contributions are recorded separately. Those who cannot be responsible for the work are not listed as authors: the reason AI is not listed as an author lies precisely here. Those who have already made substantial contributions ought to have the chance to take part in revision and final approval; the chance is not first blocked and the person then excluded for not meeting the condition. What students and staff did is recorded under the names of those who did it (as authors or in the record of contributions), and is not taken away or diluted because of high or low position.


§4 The Credit Standard of Mathematics

In mathematics, having proved something has been made into the measure. Whoever first proves a theorem gains standing and reputation. Since AI began to take part in proofs, this question has been pushed to the forefront: if a theorem is proved with a machine's help, whose is the credit, and has understanding advanced?

Paper 1 of the Theory of Disciplines raised this point. Thurston set out "progress made by mathematicians consists of proving theorems" as an assumption to be examined; he said that what mathematicians really aim to do is "advance human understanding of mathematics," and that "our strong communal emphasis on theorem-credits has a negative effect on mathematical progress." Merton analyzed disputes over priority in science; Voevodsky wrote about how proofs are verified, and about his own concerns. There the Theory of Disciplines only interfaced with this, saying that how research is evaluated is a matter for the Theory of the University (Theory of Disciplines, Paper 1).

This section takes it up. The descriptive half: the credit standard in mathematics is an entry in the normative ledger, in which "how many theorems were proved" has been taken for "how much was advanced." The normative half: when the university adopts this credit standard as a gate for appointment and promotion, it answers for this adoption and asks one thing: whether understanding has advanced. It does not judge for mathematics whether its credit standard is right or wrong. That is mathematics' own affair. Whether understanding has advanced is answered by peers with the corresponding competence (Paper 7, DX35); the university requires only that the question be part of the review.

Some will say that priority is exactly the incentive that drives discovery. This section does not deny the role of priority. What it asks is what the university looks at when it adopts priority as a gate.

DX16 The credit standard of mathematics. Descriptive: having proved something has been made into the measure, and whoever proves first gains standing and reputation; AI taking part in proofs has pushed this question to the forefront. Normative: when the university adopts the credit standard as a gate for appointment and promotion, it answers for this adoption and asks whether understanding has advanced; it does not judge for mathematics whether its credit standard is right or wrong.


§5 Judgment in Research

In a piece of research there is judgment everywhere: what question to ask, what data to use, how large a sample to take, when to stop, how far the conclusion goes. These choices are judged by those who do the research, and borne by them too.

Besides those doing the research, other positions judge: the ethics review judges whether the research may be done, the party allocating resources judges whether it is worth funding, the journal's reviewers judge whether it can be published. Each answers for its own judgment. "Passed review" does not stand in for any of them: passing ethics review does not mean that the researcher's choices about the data have been checked by anyone; receiving funding does not mean the conclusions have been endorsed.

The Theory of Disciplines says: "Standards do not judge in place of those present, and neither do seats." (Theory of Disciplines, Paper 9, S53) Extended to those who do research, it holds just the same.

When researchers and reviewers use AI, Paper 1, DX4, and Paper 5, DX24, apply: tools can enter a judgment; they do not complete it, and the bearing is not handed over with them.

DX17 Judgment in research is not stood in for by standards. The choices in research (what to ask, what data to use, when to stop) are judged and borne by those who do the research; the party that grants permission and the party that allocates resources each answer for their own judgment, and "passed review" does not stand in for any of them. When researchers and reviewers use AI, DX4 and DX24 apply.


§6 Students' Judgment in Research

Students in research are judging too. A student can propose his own research question; he can disagree with his advisor's interpretation of a set of data; he can refuse to put his name to conclusions he cannot be responsible for.

He does not suffer retaliation for these acts as such. Nor are these acts as such taken as reasons for imposing disadvantages in other positions: wages, course grades, recommendations and degree progress unrelated to this research are not used to put pressure on him to withdraw his judgment. Cultivation Theory's criterion is: "If he does not accept, one does not add disadvantages in other matters" (Cultivation Theory, Paper 5). What is looked at is "other matters."

The position within this research itself is different. If a student is a research assistant on this project and the project changes, or he leaves it, his employed position in this research changes accordingly; the same holds when a stretch of mentoring ends. These are read by Paper 2, DX10 and DX11: the consequences refusal brings and the end of a stretch of mentoring do not, each on its own, amount to crossing the line; the way out has to be usable and not controlled by the original advisor alone; money for the transition that does not depend on the original advisor is that proposition's suggestion. The requirements and consequences in each position are stated separately by Paper 2, DX9, and can be questioned.

Paper 2 left a question: are the advisor and the research supervisor the same person? Where they are the same person, the unbundling of Paper 1, DX3, and the way out of Paper 2, DX11, matter all the more, since the topic, the money and the evaluation may all pass through him. Where they are not the same person, requirements on the research side are recorded separately by DX9.

Montana State University has a page on determining authorship and resolving disputes. First go to the corresponding author and the project lead; failing that, notify the department head; the department head may, as appropriate, ask the dean of the college; where graduate students are involved, the dean is advised to consult the dean of the graduate school; if the matter is still unresolved, it can be reported to the research integrity officer. Both faces have to be read. There is a road that can be walked, written into the rules; the first stop on the road can be a party to the dispute. That page says nothing about freedom from retaliation, and has no section on students; what this page does not say does not mean that none of the university's rules say it.

Some will say that a student's refusal to put his name to a paper will be used as leverage. This proposition says that these acts "as such" bring no retaliation; the end of mentoring or change of project that follows is read by Paper 2, and does not automatically amount to crossing the line.

In Paper 2's constructed case, the stretch on authorship is read here: the student who refused to put his name to the paper suffers no retaliation for it; his judgment is recorded under his name, and conclusions he is unwilling to bear are not avowed in his place.

DX18 Students' judgment in research. In research a student can propose research questions, disagree with an interpretation of the data, and refuse to put his name to conclusions he cannot be responsible for. He does not suffer retaliation for these acts as such; nor are these acts as such taken as reasons for imposing disadvantages in other positions (wages, grades, recommendations and degree progress unrelated to this research), and these positions are not used beyond their authority to put pressure on him to withdraw his judgment. Changes in his employed position in this research that come with a change of project, and the end of mentoring or change of project that follows, are read by DX10 and DX11; money for the transition follows DX11; the requirements and consequences in each position are stated separately by DX9, and remain open to questioning.


§7 Dialogue: Thurston

Thurston's essay is titled "On Proof and Progress in Mathematics," and the three sentences quoted in §4 all come from it. This paper does not read it as opposing proof. Read by those three sentences, and this is this paper's reading, what he asked was whether, once what mathematicians do has been recorded by a way of keeping score, what is recorded is what they are really advancing.

Where they point the same way is §4: the credit standard is an entry in the normative ledger, and it can be questioned. Where they part is that this paper does not draw conclusions for mathematics. Thurston spoke from inside mathematics about what mathematics ought to value; this paper stands on the university's side and asks only what the university looks at when it adopts this standard as a gate. Nor does this paper read "advancing understanding" as lowering the demands of proof. For work that offers a proof, asking what understanding it advanced does not exempt the proof itself from verification; for other mathematical work, it is not concluded that understanding was not advanced merely because no new theorem was added. What standards the university adopts, and what consequences it gives them, it still answers for by DX14.


Where This Paper Stops

What it has not done: it has not judged whether any discipline's credit standard is right or wrong; it has not written the design of research ethics review, which the Theory of Disciplines has written; it has not written the amounts of research funding, as Paper 6 writes only grounds and conditions; it has not judged who is right in any authorship dispute.


The Five Propositions of This Paper

  • DX14 The university answers for its adoption and conversion. What counts as an output and how credit is counted are entries in the normative ledger; when the university writes a custom into its rules, it is the party that wrote it. When the university adopts these standards as gates for appointment, promotion and resources, it answers for its adoption: why it adopts, how it converts, what consequences it gives, whether there is review, whether it can withdraw. When it both draws up and adopts, the two accounts are not merged into one. (Normative; taking over Theory of Disciplines S34, which spoke of insurance, regulation, courts, platforms and admissions, with the subject brought down to the university and the object extended to unwritten customs, this series' own undertaking; Theory of Disciplines S46 brought down to the university)
  • DX15 Authorship records doing and being responsible. Authorship records who did what and who is responsible for it; contributions are recorded separately; those who cannot be responsible for the work are not listed as authors; those who have already made substantial contributions have the chance to take part in revision and final approval; what students and staff did is recorded under the names of those who did it, and is not taken away or diluted because of high or low position. (Normative; the authorship criteria of the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors and the sentence on AI serve as examples and evidence at the rule layer, and the sentence on "the chance to take part in revision and final approval" points the same way as its recommendations; this proposition is addressed to the university; extending the Theory of the Company's "the price falls on what is done," this series' own undertaking)
  • DX16 The credit standard of mathematics. Descriptive: having proved something has been made into the measure, and whoever proves first gains standing and reputation; AI taking part in proofs has pushed this question to the forefront. Normative: when the university adopts the credit standard as a gate, it answers for this adoption and asks whether understanding has advanced; it does not judge for mathematics whether its credit standard is right or wrong. (The first half descriptive, interfacing with Theory of Disciplines, Paper 1; the second half normative, taking over DX14, this series' own undertaking)
  • DX17 Judgment in research is not stood in for by standards. The choices in research are judged and borne by those who do the research; the party that grants permission and the party that allocates resources each answer for their own judgment, and "passed review" does not stand in for any of them. (Normative; extending Theory of Disciplines S53 to those who do research, this series' own undertaking)
  • DX18 Students' judgment in research. In research a student can propose research questions, disagree with an interpretation of the data, and refuse to put his name to conclusions he cannot be responsible for; he does not suffer retaliation for these acts as such, nor disadvantages in positions unrelated to this research. Changes in the employed position in the research itself and in mentoring are read by DX10 and DX11. (Normative; taking over DX9 and Institution Theory Z30; the criterion takes over Cultivation Theory, Paper 5, "one does not add disadvantages in other matters"; the fourth authorship criterion of the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors serves as an example)

References

All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version.

I · This system

  • Qin, H. (2026). What a University Is Not (SAE Theory of the University, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293733
  • Qin, H. (2026). University Teaching (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293737
  • Qin, H. (2026). University Students (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293740
  • Qin, H. (2026). University Evaluation (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293751
  • Qin, H. (2026). University Governance (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 7) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293757
  • Qin, H. (2026). What a Discipline Is Not (SAE Theory of Disciplines, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24177508
  • Qin, H. (2026). Parochialism (SAE Theory of Disciplines, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24177748
  • Qin, H. (2026). Withdrawal (SAE Theory of Disciplines, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24177783
  • Qin, H. (2026). Non-Substitution (SAE Theory of Disciplines, Paper 9) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24177799
  • Qin, H. (2026). When One Holds Power (SAE Cultivation Theory, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154515
  • Qin, H. (2026). Between One Another (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23271072
  • Qin, H. (2026). Theory of the Company and the Tradition: The Price Falls on What Is Done (SAE Theory of the Company, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24045743

II · Rule texts and institutional documents (original language)

  • Norwegian Directorate for Higher Education and Skills (HK-dir). "Academic publishing is no longer part of the funding of higher education institutions in Norway." 2024-09-18. https://kanalregister.hkdir.no/en/aktuelt/academic-publishing-is-no-longer-part-of-the-funding-of-higher-education-institutions-in-norway
  • International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. "Defining the Role of Authors and Contributors." https://www.icmje.org/recommendations/browse/roles-and-responsibilities/defining-the-role-of-authors-and-contributors.html
  • NISO. "CRediT (Contributor Roles Taxonomy)," ANSI/NISO Z39.104-2022. https://credit.niso.org/implementing-credit/
  • Montana State University. "Determining Authorship and Resolving Disputes." https://www.montana.edu/ric/responsible-conduct/determining-authorship-and-resolving-disputes.html

III · External literature

  • Merton, R. K. (1957). Priorities in scientific discovery. American Sociological Review, 22(6), 635–659.
  • Newman, J. H. The Idea of a University, Preface. 1852; 1873 edition. Newman Reader.
  • Thurston, W. P. (1994). On proof and progress in mathematics. Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society, 30(2), 161–177.
  • Voevodsky, V. (2014). The origins and motivations of univalent foundations. The Institute Letter (Institute for Advanced Study), Summer 2014.

Interfaces

This series: DX14 to DX18.

Handed to Paper 4: when a piece of research crosses disciplines, whose standards evaluate it.