Self-as-an-End
SAE Theory of the University · Paper 4

University Disciplines
大学的学科

Han Qin (秦汉) · Independent Researcher · 2026
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24293746 · Full PDF on Zenodo · CC BY 4.0
Abstract

The discipline remains. A body of people, a course of training, a set of journals and societies, a chain of credentials by which people recognize one another as peers: all of these span universities; what divides a university into departments is that university itself. This paper begins with Arizona State University's guide to joint appointments: a scholar belongs to two units at once, and which of them holds tenure, how the other gives its evaluation, and how work and salary are shared are all written into rules. The paper asks: if the discipline remains here, where then is the wall? Its answer: the wall is not the discipline itself. The wall stands where a university treats its own division as exhaustive: work that does not fit into the boxes has nowhere to be taken in, no one explains why, it is not referred elsewhere, and there is no review. The paper states three propositions. The discipline remains, but is no longer a wall: the residue produced by the division into departments is explained by the university; having no ready-made home does not on that account seal off the paths of intake, explanation, referral and review. Departmental rules: who reviews interdisciplinary work, how standards are combined, where results are recorded, and where funding comes from ought to be settled in the rules; having a procedure in form is not the same as acknowledging the remainder. Practicing judgment at the borders: when the standards of two disciplines give different answers, the rules of neither side can judge in anyone's place. The paper ends with a dialogue with Kant's The Conflict of the Faculties.

Writing Declaration: This paper was co-drafted with Claude (Anthropic). All intellectual decisions, framework design, and final editorial judgments were made by the author.

Introduction

On the website of Arizona State University's academic personnel office there is a guide to joint appointments, dated 25 February 2008 and grounded in ACD 506-09 of the university's Academic Affairs Manual. It handles one concrete matter: what to do when a scholar belongs to two units at once.

The guide is very practical. Tenure resides in one unit only; promotion and tenure are decided by the college in which tenure resides, taking into account the views of the heads of the related units. The other unit takes part in annual review, third-year review and promotion review by letter, giving its evaluation of the part of the work the memorandum assigns to it. The two sides sign a memorandum setting out an annual work plan, which serves as the basis for each year's evaluation; how salary is shared and how teaching loads are reduced are written into it too. The guide also says: "Interdisciplinary tenure and promotion guidelines can be developed by pairs of units," that is, pairs of units may jointly draft interdisciplinary guidelines for promotion and tenure.

Paper 3 handed over a question: when a piece of research crosses disciplines, whose standards evaluate it? This guide gives no set of interdisciplinary standards. What it writes into rules first is who evaluates, who gives views, and how work is divided; joint guidelines, it says, can be drafted, not that they have to be.

The opening asks one question only: if the discipline remains here, where then is the wall?

The guide proves only one point: home units, evaluative views, work plans and the sharing of work can be written as rules. Whether common standards suited to interdisciplinary work are formed depends on the particular arrangements; how these arrangements are carried out today, this page cannot vouch for either.

The paper has five sections. §1 says disciplines and departments; §2, the discipline remains, but is no longer a wall; §3, departmental rules; §4, judgment at the borders; §5 is a dialogue. Sections 2 to 4 each state one proposition at the end, and all are listed together at the end of the paper.


§1 Disciplines and Departments

Paper 1 of the Theory of Disciplines listed what the establishment of a discipline is: "The establishment of a discipline is a construct: a body of people, a course of training, a set of journals and societies, a curriculum, a chain of credentials by which people recognize one another as peers." There is no department in this list.

A chemist's peers are mostly not in his own university. Those who review his manuscripts, cite his papers and attend the same society's meetings are spread over many universities. The network of peers that journals and societies connect is not bounded by any one university. The establishment of a discipline spans universities.

A department is something else. It is a unit inside one university, and several kinds of unit at once: budgets are divided through it, appointments are proposed by it, reviews start from it, degree programs are listed under its name. The same discipline may be one department at this university, two departments at that one, and a concentration within some school at a third. Universities divide differently. What divides a university into departments is that university.

The division into disciplines is not itself wrong. In the introduction to The Conflict of the Faculties, Kant says that the whole of learning in the university is handled "gleichsam fabrikenmäßig, durch Vertheilung der Arbeiten": as it were in the manner of a factory, through the division of labor.1 Only with labor divided can each field go far on its own. The Theory of Disciplines puts it more directly: "This series does not oppose the division into disciplines, and does not propose abolishing boundaries." (Theory of Disciplines, Paper 1, §1) Neither does this paper. It does not ask whether to divide, only what to do with what cannot be divided in once the division is made.


§2 The Discipline Remains, but Is No Longer a Wall

The Theory of Disciplines set down one sentence for the establishment of a discipline: "The establishment of a discipline is a construct; it is a means, not an end." (Theory of Disciplines, S1) A means has its remainder. The Theory of Disciplines goes on to say that a division leaves its own unaccommodated residue, which is the normal state, not a fault; the residue falls into two kinds by how it forms: "what the rules do not cover, raised by people; what the division itself produces, explained by the establishment that drew it" (Theory of Disciplines, S2).

Carried over to the university, the shape is unchanged and the subject is different. The boundary of a discipline is drawn by the establishment of that discipline; the gap between departments in a university is cut by the university. A question falls between two departments, and neither department will own it. The gap was not brought by the question itself; it was cut by this knife. So the residue produced by the division into departments is explained by the university.

Having no ready-made home is common, and it is not on that account judged that the university fails to acknowledge the remainder. The Theory of Disciplines gives the criterion of parochialism: "the criterion is that a construct is registered as complete" (Theory of Disciplines, S3). That a piece of work has, for now, no department to belong to is not itself such a registration. Being registered as complete looks different: whatever does not fit into the existing boxes is treated as not there; it has nowhere to be taken in, no one explains why it is not taken in, it is not referred to a place that might take it in, and once refused, it has nowhere to be reviewed. That is where the wall is. This is this paper's reading, extended from that criterion of the Theory of Disciplines to the university; to establish whether a given place is like this, the Theory of Disciplines requires all four steps to be present, and these few signs alone do not settle the case.

So the weight of this proposition falls on the paths, not on the outcome. The university may not treat its existing divisions as an exhaustive classification of what can be researched and evaluated, and on that basis seal off the paths of intake, explanation, referral and review. A path not being sealed does not mean that there is surely someone at its end to take the work in, or surely money to give. Who evaluates, and whether resources are given, are explained separately by accountability and grounds. An application can be refused; the reasons for refusal have to be stated, and after refusal one can still ask.

The University of Washington Graduate School has such a path. Its "Individual Interdisciplinary Ph.D." is for students whose research goals "cannot be met within one of the University units authorized to grant the Ph.D. degree." The dissertation topic has to be jointly supervised by people from two or more doctoral programs, and the degree is recorded as "Doctor of Philosophy (Individual Ph.D.)." Research with no ready-made home has a path here. The same page also says that this path is open only to "exceptionally able students in high academic standing." That threshold is itself a kind of division: it has qualifying conditions of its own, and the conditions and their use remain open to questioning. This page does not say who approves applications, and this paper does not supply it.

More than a hundred years ago, someone in a university also wrote a threshold that was not drawn by school of thought. Cultivation Theory, Paper 5, quotes Cai Yuanpei's 1919 reply to Lin Shu; in its paraphrase: in matters of doctrine, he followed the principle of freedom of thought and took the policy of including and embracing all; whatever the school, so long as it spoke with reason and held its views on grounds, even where schools opposed one another, each was left to develop freely. The threshold was speaking with reason and holding views on grounds; not "agree with my doctrine," nor "belong to a certain school." A school of thought is not a department; what is borrowed here is only its shape: the threshold falls on reasons and grounds, not on belonging. Cultivation Theory, Paper 5's reading is used here as it stands: "This gave those who came after a standard by which they could press questions; whether it could bind the president in concrete appointments depends on how it was actually carried out, and this letter cannot certify that as well." This is a historical example, not a rule text.

The strongest opponent will say: a discipline was always a web of exchange, not a wall; peers read one another, borrow methods, borrow problems, and the slogan of interdisciplinarity has made the wall out to be bigger than it is. This paper agrees with the first half. The discipline remains, and ought to; this paper does not propose abolishing departments, nor does it say that walls are mostly made by departments, which is an empirical question of more or less that has not been checked here. It asks about one point only: who explains the residue that division produces, and whether the paths of intake, referral and review are sealed or not. However open the web, what falls outside its mesh still needs somewhere to go.

DX19 The discipline remains, but is no longer a wall. The establishment of a discipline is a means, not an end. What divides the university into departments is the university; the residue produced by the division into departments is explained by the university. Having no ready-made home is not on that account judged a failure to acknowledge the remainder. The university may not treat its existing divisions as an exhaustive classification of what can be researched and evaluated, and on that basis seal off the paths of intake, explanation, referral and review; who evaluates, and whether resources are given, are explained separately by accountability and grounds.


§3 Departmental Rules

A department and the establishment of a discipline that spans universities are not the same kind of construct. The establishment of a discipline provides peers and standards; a department provides budgets, appointments, reviews and degrees. When a piece of interdisciplinary work meets departments, it meets four concrete questions: who reviews it, how standards are combined, where results are recorded, and where funding comes from.

The guide in the introduction has settled some of these. Who reviews: the college in which tenure resides decides, and the other unit gives its evaluation by letter. Where results are recorded: the annual work plan in the memorandum states which part of the work belongs to which unit, as the basis for each year's evaluation; each unit gives its evaluation of the part assigned to it. How the results of a collaboration are recorded under the two units, the guide does not say. How money is found: salary sharing and teaching-load reduction follow the memorandum. It also sees the real burden of a person split between two places: such a person "cannot be reasonably expected to participate fully in all faculty meetings and service assignments," that is, he cannot be expected to take full part in the meetings and service of both units. The committee that reviews him also has to evaluate him by his split assignment, not treat him as a full-time member of its own unit.

On how standards are combined, the guide says only that pairs of units can draft joint guidelines. Can, not have to.

So writing it into rules is not the whole of it. Having an interdisciplinary procedure in form is not enough to prove that the remainder is acknowledged. If all work still has to be filed under an existing category before it can be taken in, the procedure has only given the classification a new entrance, and it is checked by the proposition of §2. Tenure residing in one unit is not itself a wall: a home has to fall somewhere. What has to be looked at is whether, once the home is settled, that unit's existing standards have completed the judgment for the whole of the work. §4 takes up this layer.

Nor is the wall torn down by reorganization. In 2021 the University Design Institute of Arizona State University published a report on the university's interdisciplinary building: since 2002 the university has set up twenty-five new interdisciplinary schools;2 the School of Life Sciences began operating in 2003, merging three departments, biology, plant biology and microbiology. The same report quotes a professor of education at the university, to the effect that if the ways of evaluating teaching and research do not change, interdisciplinarity remains only an aspiration, and that current academic evaluation looks fundamentally at individual contribution. Both faces are in this one report: reorganization happened, and evaluation did not necessarily keep up. Reorganization does not announce that the wall has been torn down.

The reverse holds too: an interdisciplinary school can also become a new wall. Theory of Disciplines S1 says that a construct can be chiseled further, chiseling out new constructs; a new construct is still a construct, and the proposition of §2 applies to it just the same. It too has to explain the residue its division produces; it too may not treat its own boxes as an exhaustive classification of what can be researched.

Several practices this paper offers only as suggestions, not requirements: a memorandum for joint appointments stating which unit holds tenure, how the other unit gives its evaluation, and how the annual work plan and salary are shared; degrees across departments; interdisciplinary schools. These are some of the ways to give questions somewhere to land; with them in place, things are still checked by §2.

DX20 Departmental rules. A department and the establishment of a discipline that spans universities are not the same kind of construct; a department is at once a unit of budget, appointment, review and degree. For interdisciplinary work, who reviews it, how standards are combined, where results are recorded and where funding comes from ought to be settled in the rules. Having an interdisciplinary procedure in form is not enough to prove that the remainder is acknowledged: if all work still has to be filed under an existing category before it can be taken in, it is checked by DX19.


§4 Judgment at the Borders

The standards of two disciplines can give different answers about the same piece of work. Take a paper in economic history. The standards of economics ask whether the causal identification holds up; the standards of history ask where the materials come from, and whether they are read correctly. One archive the historian thinks sufficient, the economist thinks too small a sample; one model the economist thinks clean, the historian thinks reads the people of that time as people of today. The rules of each side make sense on their own, and together they give no answer.

At this point, the rules of neither side can judge in anyone's place. Paper 1 said that judgment cannot be handed over along with rules (DX2). In Action Theory's words: "Judgment cannot be done by rules in anyone's place: rules, facts, reasons and feelings can all enter a judgment, yet applying, weighing and taking up remain the work of the one who judges." (Action Theory D6) The border is what that sentence looks like when it falls between two sets of rules. When one set of rules runs out, one can still say "the rules don't say"; when two sets of rules say opposite things at the same point, one cannot even say "follow the rules." Someone has to make the choice, state the grounds and bear the consequences.

So the border is not only a hard place; it is also a place to practice. Teaching and research ought both to let people practice judgment at the borders. If a course offered across departments is just two teachers each teaching their half, what the students get is two sets of rules. If the two teachers set out why their respective standards require what they require, and let the students make choices about a particular piece of work, what the students practice is judgment. The Individual Ph.D. of §2 requires the dissertation to be jointly supervised by people from two or more programs: this is one arrangement that writes the border into mentoring. An arrangement is a form; it does not guarantee that judgment happens at the border; it leaves judgment a place.

Brought down to rules, there are two sentences. A piece of work is not sent back or refused intake merely because it has no ready-made home. The home can fall in some department, but that department's existing standards may not on that account complete the judgment of the question. The first sentence governs the doorway, the second what lies inside the door: once inside a department, the department's standards are material for judgment, not the judgment itself.

The strongest opponent will say: at the borders there is no common standard, and so-called judgment is everyone saying their own thing, until in the end whoever holds the higher position decides. This paper's answer: at the borders it is not that there is no standard, but that two standards are both present, and both have to be set out; choices have to state their grounds, and the grounds can be questioned. Whoever holds the higher position deciding is exactly what it looks like when a position completes the judgment in everyone's place; by this proposition, it is open to questioning.

DX21 Practicing judgment at the borders. When the standards of two disciplines give different answers, the rules of neither side can judge in anyone's place. Teaching and research ought both to let people practice judgment at the borders; work is not sent back or refused intake merely because it has no ready-made home; the home can fall in some department, but that department's existing standards may not on that account complete the judgment of the question.


§5 Dialogue: Kant

Kant's The Conflict of the Faculties of 1798 is about the conflict among the faculties of the university. It points the same way as this paper in two places, and parts from it in one.

The first place where they point the same way was quoted in §1: dividing disciplines is dividing labor. The second is here. Kant wants the university to have one place which, in its teaching, is not under the commands of the government, one that "keine Befehle zu geben, aber doch alle zu beurtheilen die Freiheit habe": that gives no commands, yet has the freedom to judge all (Part One, "Division of the Faculties in General"; Akademie-Ausgabe VII, 19–20). This place takes the teachings of the other faculties "zum Gegenstande ihrer Prüfung und Kritik," as the object of its examination and critique (Section II, "Concept and Division of the Lower Faculty"; Akademie-Ausgabe VII, 28). This paper's saying that someone has to ask at the borders, and that both standards are set out to be questioned, points the same way: the university needs a place where questions are put, and what is asked about includes teachings already settled elsewhere.

Where they part is in where the questioning position is placed. Kant assigns this place to one faculty: the faculty of philosophy, then called the "lower faculty," on the grounds that its teaching is not under the commands of the government. This series does not fix the questioning position in the establishment of any one faculty. Theory of Disciplines, Paper 1, §9, already said: "It does not look down on any discipline, does not rank philosophy above the others, and does not assign the position that questions the ought to philosophy." (Theory of Disciplines, S8) Theory of Disciplines, Paper 9, also said: "which discipline, which kind of people, which institution occupies it, this series does not answer." Everyone present at the borders can ask.

This parting is not a quarrel between the philosophy department and other departments. Kant's faculty of philosophy comprised a department of historical knowledge (history, geography, philology, the humanities, natural knowledge) and a department of pure rational knowledge (pure mathematics, pure philosophy),3 and does not line up with today's philosophy department. They part on one point only: Kant put the questioning place under the name of one faculty; this paper lets it fall at the borders, on those present.

Kant's saying that this place is "not under the commands of the government in its teaching" belongs to another layer: who can command the university, and who in the university sets the rules. That belongs to governance, and is left to Paper 7.


Where This Paper Stops

What it has not done: it has given no scheme for dividing disciplines, only conditions for after the division; it has not said that departments ought to be abolished; it has not said that organizational reorganization tears down the wall; it has not said that walls are mostly made by departments, which is an empirical question of more or less that has not been checked here; it has not judged whether any university's way of dividing is right. How interdisciplinary work is evaluated is handed to Paper 5; when interdisciplinary work obtains funding, the conditions of use, allocation and questioning are checked together with Paper 6; who sets the division into departments, and the layer of Kant's "not under the commands of the government in its teaching," are handed to Paper 7.


Notes

  1. Kant, Der Streit der Facultäten, Introduction, Akademie-Ausgabe VII, 17. Literally, "as it were in the manner of a factory, through the division of labor." ↩︎
  2. The report has "transdisciplinary schools." The report is an introductory document of the university's University Design Institute, not a rule text of the university; the numbers and years follow the report. ↩︎
  3. Kant, Der Streit der Facultäten, Part One, Section II, "Concept and Division of the Lower Faculty," Akademie-Ausgabe VII, 28. ↩︎

The Three Propositions of This Paper

  • DX19 The discipline remains, but is no longer a wall. The establishment of a discipline is a means, not an end. What divides the university into departments is the university; the residue produced by the division into departments is explained by the university. Having no ready-made home is not on that account judged a failure to acknowledge the remainder. The university may not treat its existing divisions as an exhaustive classification of what can be researched and evaluated, and on that basis seal off the paths of intake, explanation, referral and review; who evaluates, and whether resources are given, are explained separately by accountability and grounds. (Normative; extending Theory of Disciplines S1, S2 and S3, which spoke of the establishment of a discipline, with the subject changed to the university, this series' own undertaking)
  • DX20 Departmental rules. A department and the establishment of a discipline that spans universities are not the same kind of construct; a department is at once a unit of budget, appointment, review and degree. For interdisciplinary work, who reviews it, how standards are combined, where results are recorded and where funding comes from ought to be settled in the rules. Having an interdisciplinary procedure in form is not enough to prove that the remainder is acknowledged: if all work still has to be filed under an existing category before it can be taken in, it is checked by DX19. (The first half descriptive, interfacing with the list of the establishment in Theory of Disciplines, Paper 1, §1; the second half normative, extending the duty of explanation in Theory of Disciplines S2, this series' own undertaking)
  • DX21 Practicing judgment at the borders. When the standards of two disciplines give different answers, the rules of neither side can judge in anyone's place. Teaching and research ought both to let people practice judgment at the borders; work is not sent back or refused intake merely because it has no ready-made home; the home can fall in some department, but that department's existing standards may not on that account complete the judgment of the question. (Normative; taking over DX2 and Action Theory D6)

References

All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version.

I · This system

  • Qin, H. (2026). University Teaching (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293737
  • Qin, H. (2026). University Research (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293742
  • Qin, H. (2026). Not Doing and Cannot-Not-Doing (SAE Action Theory, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22970752
  • Qin, H. (2026). Parochialism (SAE Theory of Disciplines, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24177748
  • Qin, H. (2026). Non-Substitution (SAE Theory of Disciplines, Paper 9) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24177799
  • Qin, H. (2026). When One Holds Power (SAE Cultivation Theory, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154515

II · Rule texts and institutional documents (original language)

  • Arizona State University, Academic Personnel. "Joint Appointments." 2008-02-25 (citing ACD 506-09). https://academicpersonnel.asu.edu/resources-chairs-directors/joint-appointments
  • University of Washington Graduate School. "Individual Interdisciplinary Ph.D." https://grad.uw.edu/programs/interdisciplinary-programs/individual-interdisciplinary-phd

III · External literature

  • Fain, P. (2021). Embedding Interdisciplinarity at Arizona State University (ASU). Blueprints for University Design. University Design Institute, Arizona State University. https://udi.asu.edu/sites/default/files/2022-06/bud_interdisciplinarity_asu_jan2022.pdf
  • Kant, I. (1798). Der Streit der Facultäten. Königsberg: Nicolovius. Akademie-Ausgabe VII. German text, Projekt Gutenberg.
  • Cai Yuanpei (1919). 致《公言报》函并答林琴南函 [Letter to the Gongyan Bao, with a reply to Lin Qinnan]. Gongyan Bao, 1 April 1919. Cited via Cultivation Theory, Paper 5 (from Cai Yuanpei quanji, vol. 3, Hangzhou: Zhejiang Education Press, 1997, p. 576).

Interfaces

This series: DX19 to DX21.

Handed to Paper 5: how to evaluate a person is equally hard for students and professors; how interdisciplinary work is evaluated is part of it.