Self-as-an-End
SAE Theory of the University · Paper 2

University Students
大学的学生

Han Qin (秦汉) · Independent Researcher · 2026
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24293740 · Full PDF on Zenodo · CC BY 4.0
Abstract

A student in a university does not only sit in a classroom. He may do research in a laboratory, serve as a teaching assistant for undergraduates, draw a research assistant's wage, and have an advisor too. This paper writes about such a person. It begins with a rule of MIT's Office of Graduate Education: a doctoral student who wants to leave an unhealthy advising relationship can receive transitional funding that does not depend on the original advisor. Why does changing advisors need the university to write a separate funding rule? Because changing advisors may at once disturb research, funding and academic arrangements, and if all these paths are concentrated in the advisor's position, leaving needs the university to make a separate arrangement for continuation. The paper states five propositions. Several positions are registered separately: each requirement and each consequence has to have its own source, and does not fall, beyond authority, from one position onto another. Declining and changing direction are preserved: a student may decline the teacher's judgment, and may change major, advisor or topic; the consequences refusal brings and the end of a stretch of mentoring do not, each on its own, amount to crossing the line. The way out of an advising relationship is usable: whether an advisor's powers form a chokepoint others cannot get around is checked by the actual alternative paths; this way is not controlled by the original advisor alone. The position after an event: academic misconduct is handled by event, and no identity is fixed on the person. Students' voices: students can question the rules that affect them through an independent channel, and the party questioned has to answer the very matter it was asked about. The paper ends with a constructed case to see, as one student passes through several positions, which stretch is decided by whom.

Writing Declaration: This paper was co-drafted with Claude (Anthropic). All intellectual decisions, framework design, and final editorial judgments were made by the author.

Introduction

MIT's Office of Graduate Education has a rule called "Guaranteed Transitional Support." A doctoral student who wants to change advisors because of an unhealthy advising relationship can receive transitional funding that does not depend on the original advisor, for up to one full semester. The rule states: "no proof of an unresolved conflict is required"; the student need not first prove that the conflict has not been resolved. Each department has a coordinator for transitional support.

The opening asks one question only: why does changing advisors need the university to write a separate funding rule?

Because changing advisors may at once disturb research, funding and academic arrangements. A doctoral student's project is in the advisor's laboratory, his wage comes from the advisor's grants, and his qualifying examination and thesis progress need the advisor's signature. When these paths are concentrated in the advisor's position, leaving is not just a matter of talking to a different person; without a separate arrangement for continuation, he cannot leave.

This rule proves only one point: in limited circumstances and for a limited term, there is support that does not depend on the advisor. Further support and academic adjustments are handled case by case; it does not prove that any change of group comes without loss.

This paper writes from here: a person carries several positions, which requirements and consequences may not be borrowed from one to another, and who keeps open the way out of a position.

The paper has six sections. §1 says one person, several positions; §2, declining and changing direction; §3, the way out of an advising relationship; §4, the position after an event; §5, students' voices; §6 walks through a constructed case. Each of the first five sections states one proposition at its end, and all are listed together at the end of the paper.


§1 One Person, Several Positions

A student can sit in several positions at once: the position of studying, taking courses, sitting exams, writing a thesis; the position of research, running experiments and recording data in a research group; the position of teaching assistant, leading discussion sections and marking assignments; the position of employment, drawing a research or teaching assistant's wage, with working hours. Paper 1 gave him one more position: having an advisor of his own.

Rules are written for positions, and a person carries several positions with him. How Is Institution Possible says that accountability "binds the position and not the subject itself" (§1.3). Whichever position a requirement falls on, it is checked by that position's accountability and limits. A requirement within the limits is a limit; one that goes beyond them and falls where it ought not to is a violation. This is the boundary Institution Theory calls "the boundary between limit and violation" (Institution Theory Z13); "limit and violation" in the propositions is read this way.

One piece of work can count at the same time toward academic and employment tasks. The experiments a research assistant runs are both his job and material for his thesis, and that is no problem. The problem is when a requirement in one position borrows the weight of another: using the research assistantship to demand academic obedience, for example, "if you don't write it my way, there will be no assistantship next semester." Then an academic requirement carries the weight of employment, and a consequence of employment lands on academic standing. Each requirement and each consequence has to have its own source.

One person holding several positions is not a problem. The advisor himself may be like this: when the advisor is an employed graduate student, he too carries several positions, registered separately in the same way.

Some will say that advising is of one piece by nature. In an apprenticeship, the same master gives the topic, the money, the evaluation and the recommendation, and that is what makes the training deep. This section does not forbid one person holding several positions. It asks two things: each requirement and consequence has its own source; the way out is not controlled by one person (§3). Deep training does not need every other road to be closed.

DX9 Several positions, registered separately. Studying, research, teaching assistance and employment are each checked by their own accountability and by limit and violation. One piece of work can count at the same time toward academic and employment tasks, but each requirement and each consequence has to have its own source, and does not fall, beyond authority, from one position onto another (as when the employment relation of a research assistantship is used to demand academic obedience).


§2 Declining and Changing Direction

Paper 1 said that those who are led are led because they themselves are willing. Willingness can be withdrawn. When it is withdrawn, he is still a student of this university, and the line still protects him.

This section brings it down to matters: a student may decline the teacher's judgment; he may change major, advisor or topic. The university's arrangements do not, because he declines or raises an objection, seal off his positions of expression, revision, exit or change of direction. Institution Theory says: "If a support arrangement, because the other refuses or raises dissent, seals off his positions of expression, revision, exit or change of direction; … then it has overstepped the blank that support leaves" (Institution Theory Z30). Cultivation Theory says from the giving side: "If he does not accept, one does not add disadvantages in other matters; the cost of refusal is not added by the giving side" (Cultivation Theory, Paper 5).

This does not mean declining has no consequences. Declining the topic an advisor suggests may mean finding materials on one's own; changing major may mean an extra year of courses. The same proposition of Institution Theory also says: "A consequence that a refusal brings, the end of a stretch of mentoring, and limited help do not, any of them on its own, amount to this." Whether a consequence is brought by the matter itself, or added by someone using a position: this proposition looks at the latter.

Three things also have to be kept apart: expecting an output; requiring an action by agreement; compelling avowal of a direction in life. An advisor can expect a student to produce a result; a research group can require him by agreement to hand in data on time; no one can require him to avow "this is the road you are to take." The first two may be; the third may not (Institution Theory Z7c).

DX10 Declining and changing direction are preserved. A student may decline the teacher's judgment, and may change major, advisor or topic. The university's arrangements do not, because of a refusal or an objection as such, seal off his positions of expression, revision, exit or change of direction; the consequences refusal brings and the end of a stretch of mentoring do not, each on its own, amount to crossing the line.


§3 The Way Out of an Advising Relationship

Political Economy has a word: chokepoint. A chokepoint is the position others cannot get around. It says that small power can run deep, and that recognizing a chokepoint only recognizes where questions are to be asked; it does not judge that the line has been crossed (Political Economy E7). An advisor does not oversee many people, but over his own students what he holds can press very deep.

Whether the powers an advisor holds over teaching, research, funding, evaluation and recommendation form a chokepoint is checked not by name but by the actual alternative paths, looking at four things:

  1. whether leaving or changing groups needs the original advisor's consent;
  2. whether alternative funding, advising, evaluation and recommendation are actually available;
  3. whether there are exits that are allowed on the surface but blocked in practice by time or resources;
  4. whether the original advisor can decide on his own whether a related objection is taken up.

The four are to be read together: do these arrangements leave an alternative road that can actually be walked? If leaving is allowed in name, but the needed funding, advising or assessment cannot be connected, or the exit can still be sealed by the original advisor alone, the way out exists only on paper.1

So the university ought to make the way out of the original advising relationship usable, and answer for the transitional support needed, the academic continuity, and their limits; this way is not controlled by the original advisor alone. The MIT rule is one way of writing it: in limited circumstances and for a limited term, the money does not depend on the original advisor.

Paper 1 said that every student has an advisor of his own. This way out therefore holds for every student's advising relationship, not only for doctoral students. When the advisor's side ends the relationship, the university's arrangement for continuation follows Paper 1, DX3.

Whether the advisor and the research supervisor are the same person is taken up again in Paper 3: where they are the same person, this way out matters all the more.

DX11 The way out of an advising relationship is usable. A chokepoint is the position others cannot get around, and small power can run deep; recognizing a chokepoint only recognizes where questions are to be asked; it does not judge that the line has been crossed. Whether the powers an advisor holds over teaching, research, funding, evaluation and recommendation form a chokepoint is checked by the actual alternative paths: whether leaving or changing groups needs the original advisor's consent; whether alternative funding, advising, evaluation and recommendation are actually available; whether there are exits allowed on the surface but blocked in practice by time or resources; whether the original advisor can decide on his own whether a related objection is taken up. The university ought to make the way out of the original advising relationship usable, and answer for the transitional support needed, the academic continuity, and their limits; this way is not controlled by the original advisor alone.

Who reaches the conclusions on degrees and qualifications has already been fixed by Paper 5 (DX22): assessing positions separate from the advisor. It is not among the suggestions.

Suggestion (rule layer): transitional funding that does not depend on the advisor; committees for assessing degrees and qualifications; recommendation letters from more than one source.


§4 The Position After an Event

The Prequel said that practices such as resorting to any means for the sake of grades are not taken as the starting point of discussion. Not being the starting point does not mean they do not happen; it means that when they happen, they are handled by event.

Institution Theory says: "An institution does not presuppose that its internal subjects are all acting by their own law; its presupposition is mixed reality. What is mixed is realization, not standing. Guarding the line does not wait until the parties already hold non dubito toward one another to begin; it is triggered by events, not prejudged by a person's tier. An institution's identification of a person goes no further than the event and does not become an identity; this does not cancel the checking of particular facts." (Institution Theory Z3)

Brought down to academic misconduct: once a case of plagiarism is established, it is handled as this one case; once it is handled, his position in the university is restored or ended according to the rules, carrying no mark of identity; this one handling is not registered as a final verdict on the person; his later applications and defenses are handled by the particular conditions.

This does not mean the handling has no consequences. A course can be graded zero, a term of suspension can be imposed, repeated violations can lead to expulsion, and none of this goes against the proposition. What it blocks is something else: turning one event into a person's identity, so that in every position afterwards he is treated by that identity.

The University of Maryland has a grade called XF, which records that a course was failed for a violation of academic integrity. Its rules distinguish two kinds: one can be converted, the other is kept permanently. The Office of Student Conduct's page says that from Fall 2023 the petition process for removing an XF was discontinued, and that for those who qualify the office changes it to an F. How the mark stays and when it is removed are written in the rules; how the rules are carried out is checked separately. This case too has to be read both ways: keeping a record of an event permanently does not automatically amount to fixing a person into an identity; it depends on what the record says, whom it is used by, and whether it can be questioned.

Some will say that handling by event without fixing an identity weakens the deterrence of academic integrity. This proposition does not say there are no consequences; it says that after the handling, the person is not registered as an identity.

DX12 The position after an event. Arrangements for handling academic misconduct handle it by event, and fix no identity on the person; once the event has been handled, his position in the university is restored or ended according to the rules, carrying no mark of identity; one handling is not registered as a final verdict on the person, and later applications and defenses are handled by the particular conditions.


§5 Students' Voices

Students can question the rules that affect them through an independent channel; the party questioned has to answer the very matter it was asked about.

On what grounds do students ask? What these rules handle is exactly the entanglement students are in; by Institution Theory, they are on the inside (Institution Theory Z4).

"Independent" is checked by Institution Theory: independent of the party questioned, actually open to initiation by those inside, and bringing no retaliation on those who initiate it (Institution Theory Z34). "Answering the matter" is not sending back a letter: if the question is why the grading rules for this course were changed, the answer has to be about that, not a university-wide grading policy.

Whether a question, once asked, has actual efficacy is checked by three further questions: "who can activate it; what actual efficacy it has on reasons, actions, rules, or the holding of office; how the party questioned cannot cancel it on its own." (Theory of Government, Paper 6, §2)

England and Wales have a position outside the universities, the Office of the Independent Adjudicator for Higher Education (OIA). Its quick guide for student advisers says: it describes itself as independent and free for students; students usually first complete the provider's internal procedures, obtain a letter saying the procedures are complete, and bring a complaint within twelve months; it does not review academic judgment itself, such as the final mark of an assignment, but can review the marking process, for instance whether there was bias; its decisions are justified, partly justified or not justified, and when a complaint is justified it usually makes recommendations to the provider. Read by the three questions: activation lies with the student; the efficacy is a decision and recommendations; whether providers have to comply, and whether membership is statutory, the guide does not say, and that is checked separately. It is not written as a position that re-marks work, nor does it support saying that every complaint has been put right.

That it does not review academic judgment itself is worth noting. Some will say that students' voices would turn academic judgment into a vote. This proposition asks only that the answer reach the matter asked about; the right to question does not confer the power to replace academic conclusions. Paper 7 unfolds these two lines of boundary.

DX13 Students' voices. Students can question the rules that affect them through an independent channel; the party questioned has to answer the very matter it was asked about. Whether a question has actual efficacy is checked by three further questions: who can activate it; what actual efficacy it has on reasons, actions, rules or the holding of office; how the party questioned cannot cancel it on its own.


§6 A Constructed Case

This is a constructed case, not a real one.

A doctoral student works as a research assistant in a research group and draws a wage. The project is close to becoming a paper; he judges that the data are not enough to support the expected conclusion, refuses to put his name on the paper, and applies to change advisors.

His wage, his course grades, the authorship, his degree progress, transitional support and the channel for the dispute: who decides each of these, and on what basis?

This paper reads only positions and exits. His wage belongs to the position of employment and his course grades to the position of studying, and the two are registered separately (DX9); his refusal to put his name on the paper is not taken as a reason for imposing disadvantages in another position (DX9; Cultivation Theory, Paper 5); if he wants to change advisors, the way out has to be usable and not controlled by the original advisor alone (DX11), and money for the transition that does not depend on the original advisor is that proposition's suggestion; if he thinks any decision is wrong, he can question it through an independent channel (DX13).

The other stretches are read in the other papers. Authorship and his judgment in research are read in Paper 3; who assesses his degree progress and how evaluation is checked, in Paper 5; the money for the transition, in Paper 6; in which kinds of accountable positions these decisions fall and how they are questioned, Paper 7 brings together. Only if he changed topic and crossed disciplines as well would Paper 4 come in; that is not in this case, and it is not forced in.

One point has to be held first: that refusal itself cannot be a reason for disadvantages in wages, grades and the like does not mean that all consequences are frozen. If the employment tasks really cannot go on, or the degree requirements really have not been met, an independent ground has to be stated in the corresponding position, and it can be questioned.


Where This Paper Stops

What it has not done: it has not written about admission qualifications; it has not written about the legal form of graduate labor relations, nor the legal status of student organizations and unions; it has not judged that any advisor did anything wrong; it has not said that changing groups can come without any cost; it has not said that handling academic misconduct can be without consequences.


Notes

  1. For the distinction between exit and voice, see Hirschman, Exit, Voice, and Loyalty (1970); the "freedom of learning" usually attributed to Humboldt is close to §2. Both are only pointed to here. ↩︎

The Five Propositions of This Paper

  • DX9 Several positions, registered separately. Studying, research, teaching assistance and employment are each checked by their own accountability and by limit and violation. One piece of work can count at the same time toward academic and employment tasks, but each requirement and each consequence has to have its own source, and does not fall, beyond authority, from one position onto another. (Conceptual distinction; the normative half: taking over Institution Theory Z5 and How Is Institution Possible §1.3)
  • DX10 Declining and changing direction are preserved. A student may decline the teacher's judgment, and may change major, advisor or topic. The university's arrangements do not, because of a refusal or an objection as such, seal off his positions of expression, revision, exit or change of direction; the consequences refusal brings and the end of a stretch of mentoring do not, each on its own, amount to crossing the line. (Normative; taking over Institution Theory Z7c and Z30)
  • DX11 The way out of an advising relationship is usable. Whether an advisor's powers form a chokepoint is checked by the actual alternative paths, on four items; the university ought to make the way out of the original advising relationship usable, and answer for the transitional support needed, the academic continuity, and their limits; this way is not controlled by the original advisor alone. (Normative; taking over Political Economy E7 and Institution Theory Z30, Z34; picking up the three things Cultivation Theory, Paper 5, handed to the institutional side)
  • DX12 The position after an event. Arrangements for handling academic misconduct handle it by event, and fix no identity on the person; once it has been handled, the position is restored or ended according to the rules, carrying no mark of identity; one handling is not registered as a final verdict on the person. (Normative; taking over Institution Theory Z3)
  • DX13 Students' voices. Students can question the rules that affect them through an independent channel; the party questioned has to answer the very matter it was asked about; actual efficacy is checked by the three questions. (Normative; taking over Institution Theory Z34 and Z4; the three questions come from Theory of Government, Paper 6, §2, extended through Political Economy E16 to economic positions, and here to the university's rules, this series' own undertaking)

References

All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version.

I · This system

  • Qin, H. (2026). What a University Is Not (SAE Theory of the University, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293733
  • Qin, H. (2026). University Teaching (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293737
  • Qin, H. (2026). University Evaluation (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293751
  • Qin, H. (2026). To Whom the Ought Is Addressed (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23269635
  • Qin, H. (2026). Between One Another (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23271072
  • Qin, H. (2026). Open to Questioning (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23271324
  • Qin, H. (2026). How Is Institution Possible: From Inter-Ontological Remainder to Co-Constructive Framework (SAE Foundational Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19328662
  • Qin, H. (2026). When One Holds Power (SAE Cultivation Theory, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154515
  • Qin, H. (2026). Questioning and Bearing (SAE Theory of Government, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23413511
  • Qin, H. (2026). Chokepoints (SAE Political Economy, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874140
  • Qin, H. (2026). Checks (SAE Political Economy, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874142

II · Rule texts and institutional documents (original language)

  • MIT Office of Graduate Education. "Guaranteed Transitional Support." https://oge.mit.edu/finances/financial-assist/guaranteed-transitional-support/
  • University of Maryland, Office of Student Conduct. "The 'XF' Removal Petition Process." https://studentconduct.umd.edu/you/students/xf-removal-petition-process (accessed 2026-11-15)
  • Office of the Independent Adjudicator for Higher Education. "Quick guide for new student advisers." https://www.oiahe.org.uk/media/vxhgo54a/quick-guide-for-new-student-advisers.pdf

III · External literature

  • Hirschman, A. O. (1970). Exit, Voice, and Loyalty. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Interfaces

This series: DX9 to DX13.

Handed to Paper 3: the position a student holds in research, and how credit is counted.