Self-as-an-End
SAE Theory of the University · Paper 1

University Teaching
大学的教学

Han Qin (秦汉) · Independent Researcher · 2026
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24293737 · Full PDF on Zenodo · CC BY 4.0
Abstract

The Prequel said that the university fosters judgment, and that knowledge is the material of judgment. This paper writes about teaching. It begins with the tutorial at an Oxford college: two students, an essay written beforehand, a tutor, a discussion. What this hour gives the students is a place to practice and someone who questions their judgments. The paper states eight propositions. Knowledge, skills and craft enter teaching so that judgment has material; this does not mean teaching less knowledge. Judgment cannot be handed over along with rules: teaching lets students go through application, choice, explanation and revision for themselves; a student's conclusion agreeing with the teacher's does not prove that he has completed the judgment. The university ought to see to it that every student has an advisor of his own, a position accountable for questioning him and responding to his judgment; whether the relationship becomes cultivation is not in the university's hands; several powers of decision are not bundled in the advisor, the student can change advisors and has a place to appeal, and the university gives this arrangement time and resources. When tools are used, the judgment still has to be completed by a person. The teaching position does not put its own judgment in place of the student's judgment on his own matters; evaluating a piece of coursework is not substitution. Leading can happen only by personal demonstration; it is neither a power of the teaching position nor its accountability. A common syllabus and grading rubrics do not judge in the teacher's place either. The teaching assistant is led and teaches others, and teaching too is practicing judgment. The paper also sets out its own limits: once practice is written into course arrangements, it too can turn into a format for meeting a standard; having an advisor does not prove that cultivation has occurred.

Writing Declaration: This paper was co-drafted with Claude (Anthropic). All intellectual decisions, framework design, and final editorial judgments were made by the author.

Introduction

In its guide for new students, St Hugh's College, Oxford, describes its tutorials like this: usually two students to a group, most students at least once a week; before the tutorial the student writes an essay or works through a set of problems; what the tutor leads is an intellectual discussion, not a lecture.

The opening asks one question only: what does this hour give the student?

The knowledge is in the reading list. The student read and wrote before coming. What the hour gives is a place: he sets out his own judgment, someone questions it, and he has to answer and has to revise, or he may leave it unrevised but has to say why. It also gives a person: a tutor who has read his essay and knows where he is stuck.

This guide is only an arrangement one college wrote down. It is not generalized into a rule for all of Oxford, and it does not prove that people taught this way judge better. What it proves is one thing: a place to practice and someone who questions the student's judgments can be written down as a concrete arrangement. The main sentence of this paper is:

Judgment cannot be taught by rules, only practiced: what the university gives is a place to practice and people who question students' judgments.

The paper has nine sections. §1 says that knowledge is the material of judgment; §2, that judgment cannot be handed over along with rules; §3, that every student has an advisor of his own; §4, that practice too can turn into a format; §5, that tools are used; §6, non-substitution; §7, leading; §8, the teaching position's own judgment; §9, teaching assistants. §4 qualifies §2 and states no proposition of its own; each of the other sections states one at its end, and all are listed together at the end of the paper.


§1 Knowledge Is the Material of Judgment

The Prequel quoted a sentence of Action Theory: "Rules can come in, facts can come in, reasons and feelings can all come in; they are all material for his judgment" (Action Theory, Paper 1, §5). That sentence speaks of the one judgment before a person. Extended to teaching: knowledge, skills and craft enter a course so that the students' judgment has material.

This does not mean teaching less knowledge. Judgment without knowledge is empty. A medical student who does not know anatomy is in no position to speak of clinical judgment; a reader of poetry who does not know meter cannot judge whether a broken line is deliberate or a slip. The framework's Learning Series has said the same: the capacity to scrutinize is not a general skill that can be taught apart from content (Learning, II, §6.1). Some object on these grounds to talk of "teaching judgment": critical thinking cannot do without knowledge of a particular field, and cannot be taught as a general skill.1 This section agrees. The disagreement is not over whether knowledge is needed, but over whether knowledge is the end point of teaching.

Knowledge is now at hand everywhere. What is scarce is taking it up to judge matters for which rules give no answer: two principles collide in this one case, one set of data admits two readings, one passage has two interpretations that both hold up. Teaching is to let students use their knowledge in places like these.

Cultivation Theory, speaking from the giving side, said something close: if difficult feedback, other people's objections and the real consequences of choices are all kept away from him, they cannot become material for his judgment (Cultivation Theory, Prequel, §2). When a course pairs every question with its answer, the knowledge in the students' hands is only stored, and cannot be used.

Schools grounded in a craft are included. In music, clinical practice and engineering design, judgment is already inside the practice of the craft: the tempo of a phrase in performance, a choice at one point on the operating table, the trade-offs of a structural scheme. One need not first leave practice and add a class in reflection before it counts as practicing judgment. Training whose condition of completion is operational ability, such as a clinical procedure, a performance or a piece of design, is checked separately by its own accountability, and is not thereby judged to treat a means as an end point.

DX1 Knowledge is the material of judgment. Teaching does not take the delivery of knowledge as its end point; knowledge, skills and craft enter teaching so that judgment has material. This is no claim for teaching less knowledge: judgment without knowledge is empty.


§2 Judgment Cannot Be Handed Over Along with Rules

Rules cannot do judgment in anyone's place. Action Theory says: "Judgment cannot be done by rules in anyone's place: rules, facts, reasons and feelings can all enter a judgment, yet applying, weighing and taking up remain the work of the one who judges." (Action Theory D6) The Theory of Government says the same of those who execute: "Rules can enter a judgment, yet applying, weighing and taking up remain the work of the one who judges; rules cannot do judgment in anyone's place." (Theory of Government G3) The step of bringing a rule to bear on the matter at hand cannot itself be supplied by a rule.

In the Critique of Pure Reason, Kant gives this paper its root:2 judgment cannot be taught by rules, only practiced; the capacity to use rules correctly has to belong to the student himself. Rules can be taught to him; the step of using them only he can take.

So teaching is to let students go through application, choice, explanation and revision for themselves, rather than having the teacher complete them and the students only reproduce them. This does not mean the teacher cannot lecture. The teacher can present a conclusion together with the reasons for reaching it; a good example is precisely what sharpens judgment. What is to be guarded against is something else: the teacher walks the whole way, the students walk it once after him, and they are then treated as having learned it.

A common misreading also has to be blocked: a student's conclusion agreeing with the teacher's does not prove that the student has completed the judgment. Exercises and Games of Judgment says: "What is practiced is judgment, not the same judgment. So whether practice has occurred cannot be settled merely by whether what was judged before and after is the same or different" (Overview). The same conclusion may be one he judged for himself, or merely one he copied; a different conclusion may also be one he judged more finely. What is looked at is not whether the conclusions are the same, but whether he took that step himself.

Arranging practice is the university's giving of conditions; the result, the practicing itself, is the student's own to take up. It does not follow that those who arrange contribute nothing. The two students in the tutorial, the reading list, that hour: all were arranged by someone, and whether they were arranged well can be evaluated. It is only that arranging cannot practice in anyone's place.

Some question this kind of teaching on empirical grounds: for novices, minimally guided instruction does worse than full guidance.3 This section does not ask for less guidance. The teacher can demonstrate, explain and give examples; what this proposition says is that after the explaining, the students are to have the chance to use it themselves. Which method of teaching is most effective this paper does not prove; this proposition is normative, not an empirical claim that some method is better.

Lecturing can be one to many. A hundred people can hear a good lecture at once. But each person setting out his own judgment and having someone question it cannot be done one to many. §3 writes this.

DX2 Judgment cannot be handed over along with rules. Rules cannot do judgment in anyone's place; so teaching ought to let students go through application, choice, explanation and revision for themselves, rather than having the teacher complete them and the students only reproduce them. The teacher may present conclusions and their reasons; a student's conclusion agreeing with the teacher's is not taken as proof that the student has completed the judgment.

Suggestion (rule layer): case-centered courses that choose matters where rules run out; tutorials in small groups; problem-based learning.


§3 Every Student Has an Advisor of His Own

A place to practice needs people who question students' judgments. Those who question are not only advisors: teachers also press questions (§7), and students ask one another. But there is one point at which this series asks the university to take specific responsibility: every student ought to have an advisor of his own. ("Advisor" here covers the tutor, the academic advisor and the thesis supervisor alike.)

The advisor is a position. The advisor is a position the student knows he can go to, accountable for questioning him and responding to his judgment. Where Action Theory writes of the direction one can take toward another, it speaks of "presenting, asking, clarifying, thinking together and providing conditions" (Action Theory, Paper 6); the accountability of the advisor's position lies in those of these that can be registered: asking, responding. "Of his own" means that the student knows whom to go to, can get a specific response to his own judgment, and can also change advisors.

Why every student. Setting out one's own judgment and having someone question it cannot be done one to many; cultivation can happen only one-on-one. So when the university gives conditions, it has to give them to a designated position, so that the student knows whom to go to. The conditions the university gives for practicing judgment cannot fall only to those students who happen to have found someone willing to advise them: to whom a student can bring his judgment, and who is accountable for responding, has to become a condition the university actually gives to every student. That is why it says here that every student has an advisor of his own. This does not guarantee that the relationship will become cultivation; whether to use it is up to him. This step is this series' own undertaking.

Whether it becomes cultivation is not in the university's hands. Whether a relationship of cultivation forms between advisor and student, the university cannot decide. Cultivation Theory says: "What is given is conditions, not results" (Cultivation Theory, Prequel). What the advisor gives is conditions; whether and how to use them is up to the student. What the university can answer for is that the position is there, the person is there, and the time is there.

Several powers of decision are not bundled in the advisor. If one advisor holds a student's academic evaluation, funding and recommendations at once, every one of these paths needs his consent; when the student wants to say he disagrees, the cost lands somewhere else. Cultivation Theory says that a person cannot, by a sincere declaration, remove all the pressure a position brings; separating assessment, appeal and exit belong to the institutional side (Cultivation Theory, Paper 5). So the university does not bundle the powers of decision over a student's academic evaluation, funding and recommendations in the hands of the advisor's single position; the channels for objections to evaluation, for review and for changing advisors are not controlled by the advisor alone; the student can change advisors and has a place to appeal. That recommendations are not bundled means that the rules do not recognize the advisor's letter alone, and the student can obtain recommendations from other positions; whether to recommend, and how to write, remains the letter writer's judgment (Paper 5, §7). How conclusions such as degrees and qualifications are reached is written in Paper 5: by assessing positions separate from the advisor, with the advisor submitting only an opinion.

The advisor's side can also end it. The end of a stretch of mentoring does not in itself cross the line. An advisor can say he cannot advise any further, or that he cannot help with this direction. After the relationship ends, the university still answers for the advising available to the student, the transition needed, and its limits (Paper 2); the advisor's handover within his existing accountability is done as that accountability requires. Action Theory says: "not cultivating this time is not losing one's ground; this judgment can also be questioned" (Action Theory, Paper 6).

The university gives it time and resources. Every student having an advisor of his own is an arrangement that takes time. The university provides time and resources that make the advisory accountability actually possible to carry out; it does not let nominal pairing stand in for advising that can be used, and does not leave the work needed to unlimited bearing by those who take it on. How the money is found is written in Paper 6; who arranges it, in Paper 7.

Existing forms. Reality already has several near neighbors of such an arrangement, and they have to be read apart. One-on-one teaching is a form; a one-on-one relationship is another matter, and a tutorial with two students holds two relationships; a designated advisor is a position. Oxford's tutorial is a near neighbor of the first. Of Cambridge supervisions, the collegiate guidance says they "often have 2-3 students and one teacher in a weekly session"; colleges usually arrange supervisors for students, and supervisors write reports that give the student feedback. Two or three to a group is not one-on-one teaching; what it shows is that every student has arranged small-group teaching and feedback. Princeton requires undergraduates to complete independent work and a senior thesis, and the university's news page speaks of "one-on-one interactions" with an advisor in the course of the thesis, which is one stretch of the third kind. Graduate advising comes closest to the position this proposition speaks of; Paper 2 writes its two faces. These arrangements show that individual response, sustained advising and students setting out their own judgments already have real organizational forms; "every student," together with the conditions of changing, appeal and continuation, is this series' own undertaking.

Some will say that every student having an advisor of his own costs too much. This series does not rest its case on "winning": it does not say the arrangement is more cost-effective, nor does it say that, because it is expensive, it ought not to exist.

DX3 Every student has an advisor of his own. The university ought to see to it that every student has an advisor of his own: a position he knows he can go to, accountable for questioning him and responding to his judgment. Whether a relationship of cultivation forms between advisor and student is not in the university's hands: what the advisor gives is conditions, and whether and how to use them is up to the student. The university does not bundle the powers of decision over a student's academic evaluation, funding and recommendations in the hands of the advisor's single position in a way that makes all these paths depend on his consent; the channels for objections to evaluation, for review and for changing advisors are not controlled by the advisor alone; the student can change advisors; there is a place to appeal. The advisor's side can also end the relationship, and the end of a stretch of mentoring does not in itself cross the line; after the relationship ends, the university still answers for the advising available to the student, the transition needed, and its limits; the advisor's handover within his existing accountability is checked by that accountability, and the duties of his post are carried out. The university provides time and resources that make the advisory accountability actually possible to carry out; it does not let nominal pairing stand in for advising that can be used, and does not leave the work needed to unlimited bearing by those who take it on.

Suggestion (rule layer): the forms of advising (tutorials, academic advisors, thesis supervisors); one advisor or several, how many students one advisor takes, how often they meet; how students are heard when advisors are chosen.


§4 Practice Too Can Turn into a Format

What the first three sections said has its limits, and this section sets them out.

Kant himself said that examples sharpen judgment and also often lead people to use rules as formulas.2 Practice is the same. A course writes down "raise one counterexample in each discussion, write three reflections a week"; at first this leaves room for judgment, and over time it can turn into a format for meeting a standard: counterexamples are raised from a template, reflections are written to a word count. A process format does not on its own certify that judgment has occurred. The evaluator still has to make a limited judgment about a particular piece of work, and state the grounds.

Exercises and Games of Judgment defines only one kind of training: "repetition that is not itself a game and whose focal point is the next game or the next assessment leans toward work," and it says "this is not a common definition of all training" (Overview, §9). What this divides by is focus, not whether judgment is practiced. Drilling again and again for the next exam leans toward work by that sentence, and need not be disparaged; this does not prove that judgment has been practiced, nor does it rule out that it actually happens. The sentence this paper adds is its own: such drilling is not registered as practice of judgment having occurred. Whether practice happened still depends on whether the student, that time, carried out application, choice, explanation and revision for himself.

So adopting the forms of tutorials, case teaching or problem-based learning cannot, on its own, prove that judgment has occurred, nor that cultivation has occurred. Having an advisor does not prove it either.

One more thing has to be guarded against: arranging every meeting as a lesson. Cultivation Theory says: "A person can come just for a meal, just to talk. To arrange every meeting as a lesson amounts to not letting him simply be there." (Cultivation Theory, Prequel, §2) Between advisor and student, too, there can be just talk.

This section states no proposition of its own; it qualifies §2 and §3.


§5 When Tools Are Used

Students may use tools, AI included. Tools can enter a judgment; they do not complete it for him, and the bearing is not handed over with them. The Theory of Government says: "When judgment is handed to a machine, the bearing is not handed over with it." (Theory of Government G8) That sentence speaks of government's judgment; extended to learning, it holds just the same.

Both ends have to be blocked. "He used AI" is not taken to mean that the student exercised no judgment in producing the work: he may have used it to look up material and compare several accounts, and in the end made the choice himself. Nor is "a person clicked confirm at the end" taken to mean the judgment has been completed: a confirmation can be only a click. What is looked at is who took the step of choosing.

Education left a question: machines can teach, but can they nurture? This paper registers the question and does not answer it.

DX4 When tools are used, the judgment still has to be completed by a person. Tools can enter a judgment; they do not complete it for him, and the bearing is not handed over with them. "He used AI" is not taken to mean there was no judgment, nor is "a person clicked confirm at the end" taken to mean the judgment has been completed.

Suggestion (rule layer): a course states which step of judgment it requires students to complete themselves.


§6 Non-Substitution

Cultivation Theory has an example. Suppose an advisor gives a student a book he wrote himself and says: read it, and tell me where you disagree. Another advisor gives the same book and says: hand in a response next week, which counts toward assessment; write only about where the book is right; disagreement and restatement in other words do not count. The book is the same. The second advisor has made the student's acceptance of the book's conclusions a condition of assessment, and has removed the positions of objection and restatement (Cultivation Theory, Paper 1).

This is substitution: the teaching position puts its own judgment in place of the student's judgment on his own matters. His own matters means what he avows, which direction he takes, and how he revises his own conclusions. The Theory of Inter-State Cooperation wrote the same structure between states: coercion is using one's own judgment to judge for the other on its own matters (Theory of Inter-State Cooperation, Prequel). Here it is extended to the teaching position and the student.

Evaluating a piece of coursework is not substitution. What the teacher judges lies within his accountability: whether this coursework meets the requirements, whether the argument holds up; and he answers for that evaluation. A genuine "no" in an evaluation can also be a condition given to the student: it lets him know that here he does not yet stand firm.

Two things count as substitution. One is making arrival at the teacher's conclusion a condition of assessment while removing the positions of objection and restatement; that is the second advisor with the book. The other is registering agreement of answers as the student having completed the judgment himself: the answers on the exam paper are right, so he is taken to have thought it through.

The content being right does not change this. Cultivation Theory says: "It does not stand in for the other. Correct indoctrination is not cultivation either." And: "What this item blocks is using the correctness of the content to avow it in his place." (Cultivation Theory, Prequel, §2) The teacher can be right; he still cannot avow in the student's place.

DX5 Non-substitution. The teaching position does not put its own judgment in place of the student's judgment on his own matters. His own matters means what he avows, which direction he takes, and how he revises his own conclusions. Evaluating a piece of coursework is not substitution: the teaching position judges what lies within its accountability, and answers for the evaluation. Two things count as substitution: making arrival at the teacher's conclusion a condition of assessment while removing the positions of objection and restatement; and registering agreement of answers as the student having completed the judgment himself.


§7 Leading

The Prequel said that leading can happen only by personal demonstration. How the teacher himself treats a problem, and how he treats a student who disagrees with him, the student can see. Having seen it, he knows that such a way of standing exists.

So leading is neither a power of the teaching position nor its accountability. It is not registered and not assessed. Education said that doing leading by way of teaching, assessing "respect others" as a rule, yields obedience, not recognition.

The university can require the teaching position to offer courses, press questions and evaluate; it can also require students to complete agreed course activities. These are accountabilities; they can be registered and assessed. But whether a student avows that way of standing is not a result to be obtained by compulsion; if he avows it, he can also take it back. The Prequel of the Theory of the Company quotes the sentence: "A construct may require a position to do something; it may not require a person to think something." Cultivation Theory says: "Outward compliance cannot vouch for avowal: under one's position, the other's 'yes' is only a clue." (Cultivation Theory, Paper 5)

Those who are led are led because they themselves are willing. The Prequel said that this series begins from a student like this: he is willing to grow and willing to be led. That willingness lies with the student, not in the university's rules.

With an advisor, leading has one more place where it can be shown by personal demonstration. This does not make leading the advisor's accountability, nor is the advisor written as the one who leads.

This section is a premise of Paper 7: the positions in the university that set rules are to leave space for leading, which cannot be institutionalized.

DX6 Leading is neither a power of the teaching position nor its accountability. Following Education, leading can happen only by personal demonstration; it is not registered as the accountability of any position, and it is not assessed. The university can require the teaching position to offer courses, press questions and evaluate, and can require students to complete agreed course activities; avowal of what is led is not made a result to be obtained by compulsion, and the student can take this avowal back. Under a position, a student's "yes" is only a clue.


§8 The Teaching Position's Own Judgment

Teachers too are under rules. A course has a common syllabus, standard lesson plans and grading rubrics. These can enter the teacher's judgment; they do not complete it for him. The Theory of Disciplines said: "Standards do not judge in place of those present, and neither do seats." (Theory of Disciplines, Paper 9, S53) That sentence speaks of standards and seats; extended to the rules of teaching, it holds just the same.

A grading rubric says "complete argument: five points"; what counts as complete still has to be judged by the person teaching the course. A common syllabus lays out each week's content; where this class is stuck this week, and whether to stay on it another week, he still has to judge. He answers for his own choices in teaching: why he graded this way, why he stopped here.

Teachers too are within the conditions the university gives for cultivation. Action Theory says: "The one who cultivates can also be cultivated; the two sides are not fixed as giver and receiver" (Action Theory, Paper 6). The teacher judges in a course, and also practices in it.

DX7 The teaching position's own judgment is not stood in for by rules either. A common syllabus, standard lesson plans and grading rubrics can enter the judgment of the teaching position; they do not complete it; the teaching position answers for its choices in teaching.


§9 Teaching Too Is Practicing Judgment: Teaching Assistants

The teaching assistant stands at both ends. He is led, and he teaches others. To teach someone, one has to judge where he is stuck, and judge how far to go in giving: give too little, and he cannot move; give too much, and the step has been taken for him. This in itself is practicing judgment.

The position of teaching assistant may at the same time be a position of employment. He draws a wage, has working hours, and is assessed. The side of teaching and the side of employment are to be registered separately: which requirements come from teaching, which from employment, and where each consequence belongs. Paper 2 writes this.

Providing the chance to practice and the growth that actually occurs are spoken of separately. The university can give the teaching assistant a place to practice; it cannot guarantee what his practice will make of him.

DX8 Teaching too is practicing judgment. The teaching assistant is led, and teaches others; to teach someone, one has to judge where he is stuck and how far to go in giving. The position of teaching assistant may at the same time be a position of employment, and the two are registered separately. Providing the chance to practice and the growth that actually occurs are spoken of separately.


Where This Paper Stops

What it has not done: it has not said what good judgment is, nor how to judge well; it has not judged how much judgment anyone has; it has not said what practice leaves behind, or whether it carries beyond the classroom, of which Exercises and Games of Judgment says "all of these need separate testing"; it has not said that any method of teaching is best; it has not laid out particular courses; it has not fixed the forms of advising or the student-to-teacher ratio; it has not written how leading is done, which Education has already written: only by personal demonstration.


Notes

  1. For one statement of this view, see Willingham 2007. ↩︎
  2. The introduction to the transcendental power of judgment in the Kritik der reinen Vernunft, A133–134/B172–173; Akademie-Ausgabe III, 131–132. ↩︎
  3. For one statement of this challenge, see Kirschner, Sweller and Clark 2006. Whitehead's discussion of "inert ideas" (The Aims of Education, 1929) is close to §1 of this paper; it is only pointed to here. ↩︎

The Eight Propositions of This Paper

  • DX1 Knowledge is the material of judgment. Teaching does not take the delivery of knowledge as its end point; knowledge, skills and craft enter teaching so that judgment has material. This is no claim for teaching less knowledge: judgment without knowledge is empty. (Normative; "material" as in Action Theory, Paper 1, §5, which speaks of one person's judgment at hand, extended to teaching; Learning, II, §6.1, and Cultivation Theory, Prequel, §2, point the same way)
  • DX2 Judgment cannot be handed over along with rules. Rules cannot do judgment in anyone's place; so teaching ought to let students go through application, choice, explanation and revision for themselves, rather than having the teacher complete them and the students only reproduce them. The teacher may present conclusions and their reasons; agreement of conclusions is not taken as proof that the student has completed the judgment. (First sentence: conceptual distinction, taking over Action Theory D6 and Theory of Government G3. The last two sentences: normative, rooted in Kant, extended to teaching, this series' own undertaking; the final sentence also takes over the Overview of Exercises and Games of Judgment)
  • DX3 Every student has an advisor of his own. The university ought to see to it that every student has an advisor of his own: a position accountable for questioning him and responding to his judgment. Whether it becomes cultivation is not in the university's hands. Several powers of decision are not bundled in the advisor; the channels for objections to evaluation, for review and for changing advisors are not controlled by the advisor alone; the student can change advisors; there is a place to appeal. The advisor's side can also end it, and the university still answers for the advising available and the transition. The university provides time and resources that make this arrangement actually possible to carry out. (First sentence: normative, "every student" being this series' own undertaking, the accountability taking over Action Theory, Paper 6, D32, and Institution Theory Z23. Second sentence: conceptual distinction, taking over Cultivation Theory, Prequel, §1, and Action Theory, Paper 6, D34. Third sentence: normative, taking over appeal and exit from among the three in Cultivation Theory, Paper 5, HY29, together with HY26, HY27, HY31 and Institution Theory Z34; the item of assessment is written by Paper 5, DX22. The sentence on ending: taking over Action Theory, Paper 6, D35, and Institution Theory Z30. Final sentence: normative, extending Action Theory, Paper 4, D23 (quoted in Cultivation Theory, Prequel), which speaks of a person's self-preservation, with the subject changed to the university, this series' own undertaking)
  • DX4 When tools are used, the judgment still has to be completed by a person. Tools can enter a judgment; they do not complete it for him, and the bearing is not handed over with them. "He used AI" is not taken to mean there was no judgment, nor is "a person clicked confirm at the end" taken to mean the judgment has been completed. (Normative; extending Action Theory D6 and Theory of Government G8, which speaks of government's judgment, to learning, this series' own undertaking)
  • DX5 Non-substitution. The teaching position does not put its own judgment in place of the student's judgment on his own matters. Evaluating a piece of coursework is not substitution. Two things count as substitution: making arrival at the teacher's conclusion a condition of assessment while removing the positions of objection and restatement; registering agreement of answers as the student having completed the judgment himself. (Normative; taking over Institution Theory Z5 and Z30; based on Cultivation Theory, Prequel, §2, and the example of the book in Paper 1; the structure compared with the Prequel of the Theory of Inter-State Cooperation, which speaks of relations between states, extended to the teaching position, this series' own undertaking)
  • DX6 Leading is neither a power of the teaching position nor its accountability. Leading can happen only by personal demonstration; it is not registered as an accountability and not assessed. The university can require courses to be offered, questions pressed and evaluation made, and can require students to complete course activities; avowal of what is led is not made a result to be obtained by compulsion, and the student can take it back. Under a position, a student's "yes" is only a clue. (Conceptual distinction: leading is not a power and not an accountability, taking over Education. Normative: avowal cannot be compelled, taking over Institution Theory Z5, F6 §3.3, Cultivation Theory, Paper 5)
  • DX7 The teaching position's own judgment is not stood in for by rules either. A common syllabus, standard lesson plans and grading rubrics can enter the judgment of the teaching position; they do not complete it; the teaching position answers for its choices in teaching. (The first sentence a conceptual distinction, the second normative; extending Action Theory D6 and Theory of Disciplines S53, which speak of standards and seats, to the rules of teaching, this series' own undertaking)
  • DX8 Teaching too is practicing judgment. The teaching assistant is led, and teaches others; to teach someone, one has to judge where he is stuck and how far to go in giving. The position of teaching assistant may at the same time be a position of employment, and the two are registered separately. Providing the chance to practice and the growth that actually occurs are spoken of separately. (Descriptive)

References

All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version.

I · This system

  • Qin, H. (2026). What a University Is Not (SAE Theory of the University, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293733
  • Qin, H. (2026). University Evaluation (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293751
  • Qin, H. (2026). Education as Subject-Condition: A Philosophy of Education [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18867389
  • Qin, H. (2026). What Cultivation Is Not (SAE Cultivation Theory, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154492
  • Qin, H. (2026). How Is Cultivation Possible? (SAE Cultivation Theory, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154499
  • Qin, H. (2026). When One Holds Power (SAE Cultivation Theory, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154515
  • Qin, H. (2026). The Place of Judgment (SAE Action Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22974154
  • Qin, H. (2026). Not Doing and Cannot-Not-Doing (SAE Action Theory, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22970752
  • Qin, H. (2026). Can and Cannot (SAE Action Theory, Paper 4) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22970769
  • Qin, H. (2026). Not Legislating for Others (SAE Action Theory, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22970777
  • Qin, H. (2026). Judgment (SAE Theory of Government, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23412130
  • Qin, H. (2026). To Whom the Ought Is Addressed (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23269635
  • Qin, H. (2026). Conditions (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 4) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23270922
  • Qin, H. (2026). Between One Another (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23271072
  • Qin, H. (2026). Open to Questioning (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23271324
  • Qin, H. (2026). What a Company Is Not (SAE Theory of the Company, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24045716
  • Qin, H. (2026). What Cooperation Is Not (SAE Theory of Inter-State Cooperation, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23815735
  • Qin, H. (2026). Non-Substitution (SAE Theory of Disciplines, Paper 9) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24177799
  • Qin, H. (2026). Learning to Scrutinize and Correct: The Emergence, Operation, and Cost of 13DD (SAE Learning, II) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19436811
  • Qin, H. (2026). SAE Exercises and Games of Judgment · Overview [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23609837

II · Rule texts and institutional documents (original language)

  • St Hugh's College, Oxford. "The Tutorial System." https://www.st-hughs.ox.ac.uk/prospective-students/prospective-undergraduates/the-tutorial-system/
  • University of Cambridge, Senior Tutors' Committee. "Undergraduate Supervisions at Cambridge." https://www.seniortutors.admin.cam.ac.uk/academic-support/undergraduate-supervisions-cambridge (accessed 2026-11-14)
  • Princeton University. "New independent work guides help students complete 'signature' Princeton experience." 2013-11-05. https://www.princeton.edu/news/2013/11/05/new-independent-work-guides-help-students-complete-signature-princeton-experience

III · External literature

  • Kant, I. Kritik der reinen Vernunft. A133–134/B172–173; Akademie-Ausgabe III, 131–132.
  • Kirschner, P. A., Sweller, J., & Clark, R. E. (2006). Why minimal guidance during instruction does not work. Educational Psychologist, 41(2), 75–86.
  • Whitehead, A. N. (1929). The Aims of Education and Other Essays. New York: Macmillan.
  • Willingham, D. T. (2007). Critical thinking: Why is it so hard to teach? American Educator, 31(2), 8–19.

Interfaces

This series: DX1 to DX8.

Handed to Paper 2: the one who is led does not only sit in the classroom. The teaching assistant who is also employed (DX8), and leaving and appeal in the advising relationship (DX3), are extended in Paper 2 to the several positions every student passes through.