School Students
学校的学生
A student may never have chosen his school or his teachers, and he cannot decide for himself to walk away. This paper states four propositions. Never having chosen and not being able to walk away do not give the school the position of deciding his direction for him, nor do they place his asking, refusing and not avowing in particular matters at the school's disposal; what has to be checked at the level of the school is whether alternative roads can actually be used. Where the way out is missing, the way to change and the way to ask make up for it. The way to change teacher or class can be used and is not controlled by the original teacher alone. Rules that affect students can be questioned by students through a channel the party questioned does not control, and whether questioning has efficacy is checked by three questions. The way to ask has to be usable by children who cannot yet say no and children who do not use spoken language, and it can also be started through the parents, which is acting on the child's behalf. Where a student can already act on his own in a matter, the position in that matter becomes his own at once. Harm between classmates lies within the school's accountability for care: the school answers for its arrangements, and adds no cost for the child who speaks up. This paper does not write the design of admission eligibility or school choice, does not write the legal standing of student organizations, and does not judge whether any particular change of class was right.
Writing Declaration: This paper was co-drafted with Claude (Anthropic). All intellectual decisions, framework design, and final editorial judgments were made by the author.
Introduction
China's Compulsory Education Law, Article 12(1), says: "children and adolescents of school age are enrolled without examination. Local people's governments at every level shall ensure that children and adolescents of school age are enrolled in a nearby school in the place of their household registration" (my translation; 适龄儿童、少年免试入学。地方各级人民政府应当保障适龄儿童、少年在户籍所在地学校就近入学。).
This is a securing. A child enrolled near home by household registration has a school to attend; that school, too, is not one he chose. Article 4 of the same law says that children of school age "enjoy by law the equal right to receive compulsory education, and fulfil the obligation to receive compulsory education" (my translation; 依法享有平等接受义务教育的权利,并履行接受义务教育的义务). Right and obligation are written in one sentence: he has a school to attend, and he cannot decide for himself not to attend.
Between teacher and student, Teacher-Student Theory said: that the student never chose this teacher does not give the teacher the position of deciding his direction for him. This paper extends that sentence to the construct called the school.
§1 Never Chose, Cannot Walk Away
That sentence in Teacher-Student Theory. Teacher-Student Theory writes: "Where the student never chose this teacher, that does not give the teacher the position of deciding his direction for him. Where the student cannot decide for himself to walk away, that does not place his asking, his refusing and his not avowing, in particular matters, at the teacher's disposal." The same proposition says that who made the arrangement is acknowledged but not judged, and that what belongs to the school is on the institutional side.
Extended to the school. What leaves him never having chosen and unable to walk away may be precisely the school and the rules above it: enrollment near home, class assignment, timetabling, an assigned homeroom teacher. The construct that arranged for him not to be able to walk away likewise does not thereby gain the position of deciding his direction for him; his asking, refusing and not avowing, matter by matter, are not thereby placed at the school's disposal. This extension is this series' own undertaking, and the reason is this: the ground of that sentence in Teacher-Student Theory does not lie in the teacher as a person, but in the situation of "never chose, cannot walk away" itself; the situation is arranged by the school, so the ground falls on the school.
Checking the actual roads. Institution Theory says that an arrangement of support oversteps the blank that support leaves "if the arrangement itself keeps up a dependence in which he has no road that works without going through the giver". Political Economy calls a position others cannot get around a chokepoint, and says: "Whether it is a chokepoint depends on whether it can actually be got around, not on whether there is nominally another way." What has to be checked at the level of the school is whether the alternative roads can actually be used: transfer, change of class, change of teacher, present on paper; whether they can be walked in fact.
An obligation is not staying in this place. Being obliged to receive education is not being obliged to stay at this school, with this teacher. The first is an obligation the law sets; the second is an arrangement, and an arrangement can be questioned and changed.
XX17 Never chose, cannot walk away. For a student who cannot choose his school and teachers for himself, and cannot decide for himself to walk away, this does not give the school the position of deciding his direction for him, nor does it place his asking, refusing and not avowing in particular matters at the school's disposal. What is to be checked at the level of the construct is whether alternative roads can actually be used: whether this school and this teacher can actually be got around, not whether there is nominally another way. Being obliged to receive education is not being obliged to stay at this school, with this teacher.
§2 The Way to Change
The way out is missing. An adult who cannot go on in a relation can leave. A student cannot walk away; the way out is missing, and other roads have to make up for it. The first is the way to change: change of teacher, change of class. This road has to be usable, and not controlled by the original teacher alone. The Theory of the University said a proposition of the same shape at the level of the university: the way out of an advising relationship has to be usable.
A rule that writes one case. The Provisions on the School Protection of Minors say that where a student who has suffered physical or psychological harm from bullying cannot continue studying in his original class, and his parents request a change of class, the school, if it judges after assessment that this is necessary, is to support it.1 Two sides: the way to change class is written into a rule, it is started by the parents, and it is not controlled by the original teacher; but it covers only the aftermath of bullying, not changing class in general. How to apply to change teacher or class in ordinary circumstances, this paper did not find in the national and provincial rules it checked.
There in name, unusable in fact. The class is full, several classes are full; the way to change is there in name and cannot be walked in fact. That entry is made against the school, as in §1; the part that goes beyond one school's authority and resources is answered by the position that carries public securing (Papers 5 and 7). Where changing is not possible, the way to ask is not thereby set aside. The way to ask and the way to change each have their own work; a letter of reply to the parents does not settle the way to change. Where there is no place in another class for now, the school explains what the constraint is, what workable arrangement there is for the moment, and when and through what entrance the matter will be judged again. Where for a long time all that remains is one explanation, the road still has a gap; and this gap is not turned into unlimited extra hours for the current teacher.
When parents raise it. When parents ask for a change of class, has the school listened to what the child himself says? Paper 3 said that standing does not change with whether one can refuse; Paper 8 writes school and home: where the parents' requirement reaches the child by way of the school, the school's passing it on is entered against the school.
XX18 The way to change and the way to ask make up for the way out. Where a student cannot walk away, the school ought to see to it that the way to change teacher or class can be used, and is not controlled by the original teacher alone;
§3 The Way to Ask, and Three Questions
The way to ask. Rules that affect students can be questioned by students through a channel the party questioned does not control. Institution Theory set three conditions for such a channel: "it is independent of the party questioned, internal subjects can actually initiate it, and initiating it brings no retaliation". The party questioned has to answer to the matter it was questioned on.
Three questions. Once asked, does the questioning have any actual efficacy? The Theory of Government asks the same three things of every function of control: "who can activate it; what actual efficacy it has on reasons, actions, rules, or the holding of office; how the party questioned cannot cancel it on its own." The Theory of the University extended them to the university's rules; this paper extends them to the school's rules, and that step is this series' own undertaking.
Two sets of rules. China's Rules on Educational Discipline in Primary and Secondary Schools (for Trial Implementation), the Discipline Rules for short, say in Article 17 that students and their parents "may appeal to the school within 15 working days after the educational discipline or disciplinary sanction is made" (my translation; 可以在教育惩戒或者纪律处分作出后15个工作日内向学校提起申诉), and that the school "shall set up a student appeals committee composed of the school's responsible persons, teachers, students, and representatives of parents, the vice-principal for rule of law and other relevant parties from outside the school" (my translation; 应当成立由学校相关负责人、教师、学生以及家长、法治副校长等校外有关方面代表组成的学生申诉委员会). Article 18: those dissatisfied with the decision on an appeal "may apply for review to the school's competent education department" (my translation; 可以向学校主管教育部门申请复核). Read by the three questions: the subject of Article 17 is "students and their parents," that of Article 18 "students or parents," so whether a student can bring the first-level appeal on his own can be read two ways on its face; the second level goes outside the school; the first level sits inside the school, and how independent it is has to be checked separately by those three conditions. What can be appealed is the discipline and the sanctions the rules list; a parent's complaint or report about a teacher's conduct is another road, read in Paper 3.
England's Education Act 2002, section 29(1), requires the governing body of a maintained school to "establish procedures for dealing with all complaints relating to the school" and to publicize them; complaints handled under other statutory procedures fall outside this section. Under section 51A, what an independent review panel reviews is the responsible body's decision not to reinstate a pupil; by subsection (4) it may uphold the decision, may recommend that the matter be reconsidered, or, where it considers the decision flawed when judged by the principles of judicial review, may "quash the decision of the responsible body" and direct the responsible body to reconsider. Read by the three questions: there is a layer of review outside the school, and its efficacy is to order reconsideration.
What procedure there is for a student to object to a school's general rules, this paper has not yet found a suitable rule text to show.
For children who cannot yet say no. The way to ask also has to be usable by children who do not express themselves in spoken language, and by children who need someone's help to start it.2 How young children and children who cannot fully express themselves start the way to ask, this paper has not yet found in any rule; it is the place most in need of filling.
Asking through the parents. Questioning can also go through the parents. On Rights and Entitlements calls this acting on his behalf: the child's share of position lies in himself, and its running is held for him for a time by the guardian's side; once the gate can run of itself, the initiative of questioning returns to him at once. So asking through the parents withdraws as the child becomes able to act on his own, matter by matter. Where the parents are unwilling to ask, or their wishes are at odds with the child's, the child still needs a road he can use.
An objection. One line of argument runs: once students' appeals and voice expand, the teacher's authority and order in the classroom are weakened.3 Its force lies in this: a classroom needs someone to judge what to teach and how, and that judgment has to be able to land. The way to ask in this paper asks that the party questioned answer to the matter it was questioned on; it does not let the student decide; being able to raise something is not the same as having it come to stand (Paper 3). What questioning can do is put reasons under scrutiny and bring an arrangement into rejudgment; the teacher's judgment in teaching remains the teacher's, open to questioning, not replaced by a student's "no" (Paper 5). Lodging an appeal does not of itself suspend teaching; whether things have to stop on the spot, for protection or adjustment, is checked separately by the relevant accountability. The cost has to be stated too: answering takes time, and that time is counted in the workload of teachers and the school.
XX18 (continued) rules that affect students can be questioned by students through a channel the party questioned does not control; whether questioning has actual efficacy is checked by the three questions: who can activate it, what actual efficacy it has on reasons, actions, rules or the holding of office, and how the party questioned cannot cancel it on its own. The party questioned answers to the matter it was questioned on. The way to ask also has to be usable through non-spoken expression and assisted initiation. Questioning can also go through the parents: this is acting on his behalf, and it withdraws as the child becomes able to act on his own; where the parents are unwilling to ask, or are at odds with the child, the child still has a road he can use.
§4 What He Can Do on His Own
Teacher-Student Theory writes: "Where, in this matter, the student can already raise, refuse and revise for himself, that position becomes his own at once; it is not conferred by the teacher, and does not wait for his cannot-not to come to stand." Parent-Child Theory says the same thing between parents and a child: "Where, in some matter, his negation-gate can already run of itself, the position of raising and refusing in that matter becomes his own at once, and no one may seal it".
The same holds at the level of the school. Where a student can already raise, refuse and revise for himself in a matter, the position in that matter becomes his own at once; it is not conferred by the school, and does not wait for him to come of age. Teacher-Student Theory draws this boundary by the matters he avows, domain by domain, not by the subjects taught.
That the position has become his does not withdraw the school's supply and accountability to questioning in that matter. That he can judge for himself which elective to choose does not mean the school may stop offering the course, or stop answering his questions about it.
Age lines of the kind "at what age one may do what" are forms at the rule layer and do not make this judgment in its place. Paper 3 said that a line that can be overturned by the facts of an individual case, is judged matter by matter, and keeps review is not among the lines drawn once and for all.
XX19 What he can do on his own: the position is his at once. Where a student can already raise, refuse and revise for himself in a matter, the position in that matter becomes his own at once; it is not conferred by the school, and does not wait for him to come of age. The school's supply and its accountability to questioning in that matter are not thereby withdrawn.
§5 Between Classmates
How far the relational side reads. Teacher-Student Theory registered a remainder: "Dealings among fellow students are read by Relation Theory". The dealings between classmates in themselves are not judged at the level of the school. What the school answers for at its level is its arrangements: whether one child's harm to another has somewhere to be told and someone who deals with it; whether the child who spoke up has had a cost added for it. Paper 5 of Cultivation Theory said: "the cost of refusal is not added by the giving side." This paper takes over its shape: the cost of speaking up is not added by the school's arrangements. This extension is this series' own undertaking.
Scope. The scope of care follows Paper 3, §1: the stretch the school actually carries. Settings the school itself creates are inside it: class chat groups, platforms the school requires, the school bus, boarding, off-site activities the school organizes. A setting the school arranges for or requires children to enter does not leave the scope because a third party runs it; and the school's absence does not make a scope it ought to carry disappear. On commissioning, the Theory of Government said: "the contractor holds its own accountability toward the contracting construct, and does not answer, in the contracting construct's place, to those the decision acts on." The original speaks of governments and contractors; this paper changes the subject to the school, and that step is this series' own undertaking. Where the school hands a platform to someone else to run, the operator holds its accountability toward the school, and the school still answers to children for its own arrangements, requirements and existing accountabilities; what each side carries is entered separately. For what happens outside school or online and is brought into the school, the school answers for the side that lies in school and for the protection, response and referral it can give; it does not stretch care into managing the child's life outside school.
Chinese rules. The Law on the Protection of Minors requires schools to set up a system for preventing and controlling bullying among students, to stop bullying at once, and to notify the parents on both sides to take part in determining and handling it. The Provisions on the School Protection of Minors require schools to set up a body for dealing with bullying among students, with parents' and students' representatives in it; require staff who discover bullying to report it; and list the conduct staff are to stop promptly, one item being spreading rumors or maliciously spreading others' private information online and the like. The last paragraph of the same article separately sets the threshold for determining that conduct constitutes bullying. Stopping promptly and determining are two thresholds, not merged into one. The scope of care is thereby stretched to the online side.1 In the articles checked, no prohibition on retaliation for reporting or for taking part in an investigation appears.
Swedish rules. Sweden's Education Act, Chapter 6, applies in a newly amended text from 1 August 2026. Taking only the branch on degrading treatment of students: the organizer is to ensure that measures are taken to "prevent and hinder" (my translation; förebygga och förhindra) degrading treatment of students; where a student feels subjected to "serious or repeated degrading treatment" (my translation; allvarlig eller upprepad kränkande behandling), staff are to report to the head, and where the treatment comes from staff, there is no such threshold; the new section 10a requires the organizer to "investigate promptly" (my translation; skyndsamt utreda); section 11 says that a child or student may not be subjected to "reprisals" (my translation; repressalier) for reporting or for taking part in an investigation. "No cost added for the child who speaks up" is here an express provision. The thresholds for reporting and investigation are read clause by clause, and are not stretched into a license to leave other degrading treatment unhandled.
Japanese rules. Japan's Act on the Promotion of Measures to Prevent Bullying, Article 8, says that schools and school staff, "while working on the prevention and early detection of bullying as a whole school" (my translation; 学校全体でいじめの防止及び早期発見に取り組むとともに), and when a child is considered to be bullied, "have the responsibility to deal with it appropriately and promptly" (my translation; 適切かつ迅速にこれに対処する責務を有する). Article 22 has schools set up a body "composed of several members of staff, persons with specialist knowledge of psychology, welfare and the like, and other relevant persons" (my translation; 複数の教職員、心理、福祉等に関する専門的な知識を有する者その他の関係者により構成される). Article 28(1): where it is considered that there is suspicion that a child has suffered serious harm to life, mind and body or property because of bullying, or suspicion that a child has been forced to be absent from school for a considerable period, the body that establishes the school, or the school itself, sets up a body and investigates "promptly" (my translation; 速やかに).4 Two sides: responsibilities and bodies are written into law; how much was done is checked separately.
A contrast. England's Education and Inspections Act 2006, section 89(1), requires that the measures the head teacher determines on behavior include "preventing all forms of bullying among pupils". It writes the head teacher's duty to determine measures; investigation and retaliation this paper did not check in that section.
How the school's responsibility for outsourced platforms and settings run by third parties is written into rules, this paper has not yet found.
XX20 Between classmates. Dealings among students are read by Relation Theory; within its accountability for care, the school answers for how its arrangements let one child's harm to another be told and dealt with, and adds no cost for the child who speaks up. The accountability of care is drawn by the scope the school actually carries: settings the school itself creates (class chat groups, platforms the school requires, the school bus, boarding, off-site activities the school organizes) are inside it; settings the school arranges for or requires children to enter do not leave the scope because a third party runs them, and the school's absence does not make a scope it ought to carry disappear; for what happens outside school or online and is brought into the school, the school answers for the side that lies in school and for the protection, response and referral it can give; care is not stretched into managing the child's life outside school (reach of influence is not reach of authority).
§6 Students in Three Stages
This section follows the axis of stages and writes only the arrangements the school mainly handles at each stage. That a matter is written at some stage does not mean it appears only there, nor is the stage used to judge where a particular child has got to.
Kindergarten. The way to ask mostly runs through the parents, acting on the child's behalf; non-spoken expression needs someone to take it up. Acting on his behalf withdraws as the child becomes able to act on his own, matter by matter.
Primary school. Rules on changing class and changing teacher; how positions of the homeroom-teacher kind are changed (Paper 2).
Secondary school. Channels students can start for themselves, appeal and review; platforms the school requires students to use, within the scope of care.
Boarding. How the way to change and the way to ask can be used at night and in shared living, this paper only registers.
Where This Paper Stops
What it has not done: it has not written the design of admission eligibility or school choice; it has not written the legal standing of student organizations; it has not judged whether any particular change of class was right; it has not set where age lines are drawn.
Notes
- The provisions of the Provisions on the School Protection of Minors and the Law on the Protection of Minors are given here in paraphrase, from reprinted copies. ↩︎
- General Comment No. 12 of the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child, on the child's right to be heard, discusses non-verbal expression; this is known to this paper through secondary material, and it has not gone back to the original. ↩︎
- This paper writes only the structure of this line of argument, and does not report any particular author's words. For the division between exit and voice, see also Hirschman; listed only as a lead, the book not consulted. ↩︎
- Article 2 defines bullying by the mental or physical distress felt by the child subjected to the act, and states that it includes acts carried out through the internet; this is known to this paper through secondary material, and it has not gone back to the original. ↩︎
The Four Propositions of This Paper
XX17 Never chose, cannot walk away. For a student who cannot choose his school and teachers for himself, and cannot decide for himself to walk away, this does not give the school the position of deciding his direction for him, nor does it place his asking, refusing and not avowing in particular matters at the school's disposal. What is to be checked at the level of the construct is whether alternative roads can actually be used: whether this school and this teacher can actually be got around, not whether there is nominally another way. Being obliged to receive education is not being obliged to stay at this school, with this teacher. (Normative; Teacher-Student Theory TS6, which speaks of the teacher, extended to the school, this series' own undertaking; taking over Institution Theory Z30 and Political Economy E7)
XX18 The way to change and the way to ask make up for the way out. Where a student cannot walk away, the school ought to see to it that the way to change teacher or class can be used, and is not controlled by the original teacher alone; rules that affect students can be questioned by students through a channel the party questioned does not control; whether questioning has actual efficacy is checked by the three questions: who can activate it, what actual efficacy it has on reasons, actions, rules or the holding of office, and how the party questioned cannot cancel it on its own. The party questioned answers to the matter it was questioned on. The way to ask also has to be usable through non-spoken expression and assisted initiation. Questioning can also go through the parents: this is acting on his behalf, and it withdraws as the child becomes able to act on his own; where the parents are unwilling to ask, or are at odds with the child, the child still has a road he can use. (Normative; taking over Institution Theory Z34; the three questions come from Theory of Government, Paper 6, with the same shape as Theory of the University DX11 and DX13, extended to the school, this series' own undertaking; the sentence on acting on his behalf takes over On Rights and Entitlements F34, its withdrawal F35)
XX19 What he can do on his own: the position is his at once. Where a student can already raise, refuse and revise for himself in a matter, the position in that matter becomes his own at once; it is not conferred by the school, and does not wait for him to come of age. The school's supply and its accountability to questioning in that matter are not thereby withdrawn. (Normative; taking over Teacher-Student Theory TS16 and Parent-Child Theory PC39)
XX20 Between classmates. Dealings among students are read by Relation Theory; within its accountability for care, the school answers for how its arrangements let one child's harm to another be told and dealt with, and adds no cost for the child who speaks up. The accountability of care is drawn by the scope the school actually carries: settings the school itself creates (class chat groups, platforms the school requires, the school bus, boarding, off-site activities the school organizes) are inside it; settings the school arranges for or requires children to enter do not leave the scope because a third party runs them, and the school's absence does not make a scope it ought to carry disappear; for what happens outside school or online and is brought into the school, the school answers for the side that lies in school and for the protection, response and referral it can give; care is not stretched into managing the child's life outside school (reach of influence is not reach of authority). (Normative; taking up the fifth remainder of Teacher-Student Theory; the shape of Cultivation Theory HY27 extended, this series' own undertaking; the scope extends Institution Theory Z4 (see Paper 3, §1), this series' own undertaking; the sentence on third parties: the commissioning side of Theory of Government G8, which speaks of government, with the subject changed to the school, this series' own undertaking)
References
All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version.
I · This system
- Qin, H. (2026). School Care (SAE Theory of the School, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24382574
- Qin, H. (2026). The Place of Teacher-Student Theory (SAE Teacher-Student Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24267256
- Qin, H. (2026). The Place of Parent-Child Theory (SAE Parent-Child Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24121569
- Qin, H. (2026). When One Holds Power (SAE Cultivation Theory, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154515
- Qin, H. (2026). On Rights and Entitlements (SAE Rights Theory, Special Study) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21314907
- Qin, H. (2026). To Whom the Ought Is Addressed (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23269635
- Qin, H. (2026). Between One Another (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23271072
- Qin, H. (2026). Open to Questioning (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23271324
- Qin, H. (2026). Judgment (SAE Theory of Government, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23412130
- Qin, H. (2026). Questioning and Bearing (SAE Theory of Government, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23413511
- Qin, H. (2026). Chokepoints (SAE Political Economy, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874140
- Qin, H. (2026). University Students (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293740
II · Rule texts
- Compulsory Education Law of the People's Republic of China (中华人民共和国义务教育法), as amended for the second time in 2018.
- Law of the People's Republic of China on the Protection of Minors (中华人民共和国未成年人保护法), as revised in 2020.
- Ministry of Education (China). 2020. Rules on Educational Discipline in Primary and Secondary Schools (for Trial Implementation) (中小学教育惩戒规则(试行)), Ministry of Education Order No. 49. In force 2021-03-01.
- Ministry of Education (China). 2021. Provisions on the School Protection of Minors (未成年人学校保护规定), Ministry of Education Order No. 50. In force 2021-09-01.
- England. Education Act 2002, ss. 29, 51A.
- England. Education and Inspections Act 2006, s. 89.
- Sweden. Skollag (2010:800), ch. 6 (as amended by SFS 2026:1096, in force 2026-08-01).
- Japan. Act on the Promotion of Measures to Prevent Bullying (いじめ防止対策推進法) (Act No. 71 of Heisei 25), Articles 8, 22 and 28.
Interfaces
This series: XX17 to XX20.
Handed to Paper 5: these conditions fall on the person who faces them every day.
Handed to other papers: where the way to change is missing, the part beyond the school, Paper 5 (XX24) and Paper 7 (XX31, XX32); the teacher's judgment, open to questioning and not replaced, Paper 5 (XX23); the way to ask and the school's channels of governance, Paper 8 (XX36); the parents' requirement reaching the child by way of the school, Paper 8 (XX37).