Self-as-an-End
SAE Theory of the School · Paper 3

School Care
学校的照看

Han Qin (秦汉) · Independent Researcher · 2026
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24382574 · Full PDF on Zenodo · CC BY 4.0
Abstract

Looking after a person who cannot yet say no cannot do without compulsion, and the school is no exception. This paper states five propositions. Compulsion in a school has three sources: what care requires, what teaching requires, and what is set up to make quiet and room; each is checked by its own limits, and none is called cultivation or giving conditions. Which measure counts as required is explained by the position that exercises the compulsion, and the explanation is reviewed through a road that position does not alone control; the line that separates acting on his behalf from his acting on his own is not drawn once and for all by grade. Alongside compulsion, the school's arrangements let a child's "no" land. A child's standing does not change with whether he can refuse. Discipline is handled by event and fixes no identity on the child; records may be kept, and how they are kept has to be stated. Where something in a school crosses a child's basic rights, the school answers for protection and disposition, and the child has a road the party involved does not control; a child whose rights have been violated at home or elsewhere and who comes for help is not pushed away. This paper does not say which way of discipline is good, does not write the particular rules of school safety, and does not write the legal forms of guardianship.

Writing Declaration: This paper was co-drafted with Claude (Anthropic). All intellectual decisions, framework design, and final editorial judgments were made by the author.

Introduction

Paper 4 of Cultivation Theory has a sentence: "Looking after a person who cannot yet say no cannot do without compulsion; this compulsion is not called cultivation, and guardianship belongs to the institutional side."

The school is one place on the institutional side. While a child is at school, the school decides many things for him: when he arrives, where he sits, where he may go at break, where his phone is kept.

China's Rules on Educational Discipline in Primary and Secondary Schools (for Trial Implementation), in force since 2021 and the Discipline Rules for short, say in Article 11: "where a student disrupts the classroom or the order of education and teaching, affecting others or possibly causing harm to himself or others, the teacher may take necessary measures to remove the student from the classroom or the teaching site, and subject him to educational management" (my translation; 学生扰乱课堂或者教育教学秩序,影响他人或者可能对自己及他人造成伤害的,教师可以采取必要措施,将学生带离教室或者教学现场,并予以教育管理). The same article says that where a student is found hiding unlawful or dangerous items, the desks and lockers where they may be hidden may be searched, and items that break the rules may be held for a time. The next article lists what teachers "shall not do" (my translation; 不得有下列行为): corporal punishment, disguised corporal punishment, insults to personal dignity, disciplining students because of their academic results, and more. The same rules that grant the authority also draw its limits.

This paper asks where compulsion in a school comes from and where it stops, and whether, alongside it, a child's "no" can land.


§1 While He Is at School

The scope of the school's care. The school looks after a child while he is at school. "While he is at school" is not drawn by the school gate. Institution Theory draws the interior of a construct by entanglement, not by status; whether a construct is organizing a person's life is judged by the actual relation; and reach of influence is not reach of authority (Institution Theory, Paper 1, §4). This paper extends that to care: the scope of the school's care follows the stretch in which the school actually organizes a child's life. Off-site activities the school organizes, the school bus, boarding, and online platforms the school requires children to use are all inside it; arrangements that lengthen time at school, such as staying behind to finish homework, lengthen the scope of care with them.

The reverse holds too. The school's effect can reach into the home, through homework for instance; the accountability of care does not thereby reach into the home, nor does the school thereby gain authority over the child's life outside school. This extension is this series' own undertaking.

What this section does not write. In a boarding school care runs all day, and "while he is at school" has to be read again; this paper only registers it. The legal forms of guardianship this paper does not write. This section states no proposition; it sets the scope for the sections that follow. The side that lies between classmates is read by Paper 4 within this scope.


§2 Three Sources

Where compulsion comes from. Compulsion in a school can come from three places. What care requires: not letting a child run into the road, taking a sick child to the school clinic. What teaching requires: attendance, order in class, homework. What is set up to make quiet and room: collecting phones and the like. Education as Subject-Condition says that when a child first meets something he cannot explain, he has no stretch in which to stop if he is surrounded by unceasing high-frequency, high-certainty stimulation; that stretch needs quiet. Rules such as collecting phones claim this source.

Each by its own limits. What care requires is limited to what care requires; what teaching requires is limited to what teaching requires; what is set up to leave room is checked by what it actually freed and what it sealed. Taking a child's phone can free a lesson's worth of quiet; it can also take away, at the same stroke, his line of contact with home, or an assistive device he needs.

A name is not an authorization. The three categories are for analysis. A measure called "safety" or "order" does not gain authority by that name. Where one measure claims several purposes, it does not settle its limits by picking the widest of them.

England's Education and Inspections Act 2006, section 93(1), allows school staff to use "such force as is reasonable in the circumstances" for three purposes: preventing a pupil from committing an offence; preventing injury to persons or damage to property; and preventing a pupil from "prejudicing the maintenance of good order and discipline". The statute gives the three one and the same standard. The first two concern care; the last concerns order in teaching; they can also overlap. This paper reads it this way: where the requirements differ, the limits differ too, and the particular limits are still checked against the accountability, the circumstances and the means used. Sweden's Education Act, Chapter 5, section 6, allows the school to take "an immediate and temporary measure" (my translation; omedelbar och tillfällig åtgärd); the authority carries a limit in time.1 All of these show only that where there is authority, there is still a scope. They do not judge any particular act of compulsion to be justified. In the category of what care requires, this paper has the first two purposes of section 93 and the two places in Article 11 of the Discipline Rules cited in the introduction. It has not yet found a rule text that deals specifically with how the boundaries of compulsion for safety and health are drawn, compulsion in health care for instance; that is left open.

The category of leaving room. In 2021 the General Office of China's Ministry of Education issued a notice on managing phones, which says: "schools shall inform students and parents that, in principle, personal mobile phones may not be brought onto campus" (my translation; 学校应当告知学生和家长,原则上不得将个人手机带入校园。). It goes on: "where a student truly needs to bring a mobile phone onto campus, the parent's consent is required and a written application is to be made; after entering school the phone is to be handed to the school for unified safekeeping, and bringing it into the classroom is prohibited" (my translation; 学生确有将手机带入校园需求的,须经学生家长同意、书面提出申请,进校后应将手机交由学校统一保管,禁止带入课堂。). The Provisions on the School Protection of Minors, in force the same year, allow schools to prohibit students from bringing phones into school or using them there, and to manage centrally those brought in with permission; another article says that, except for statutory reasons, students' letters, diaries, emails or other online communications may not be read.2 Here keeping and looking are two things. England's Children's Wellbeing and Schools Act 2026, section 36, requires schools to have regard to the Secretary of State's guidance on phones; that guidance "became statutory on 29 June 2026" and covers the time "throughout the school day, including during lessons, the time between lessons, breaktimes and lunchtime", with separate exceptions for disability and medical needs. Finland's Basic Education Act, section 29(4) as amended in 2025, says: "a pupil may not use a phone or other mobile device during a lesson" (my translation; Oppilas ei saa käyttää puhelinta tai muuta mobiililaitetta oppitunnin aikana). It has three exceptions: learning uses a teacher permits, health care a head teacher or teacher permits, and assistive devices. The exceptions are written into the rule.

None of them is called cultivation. None of these kinds of compulsion is renamed cultivation, nor renamed giving conditions, and none is used to prove that cultivation has happened. The quiet a lesson gains when phones are collected can be a condition of cultivation; collecting the phones is compulsion. Conditions given separately in the same arrangement, an afternoon with no classes for instance, are checked separately.

The source is acknowledged but not judged. Where law and higher rules lay a measure down and the school carries it out, the school answers for the scope and manner of its carrying out; whether that rule ought to exist this paper acknowledges but does not judge. Compulsion whose source cannot be stated has no ground.

XX12 Compulsion in a school is not called cultivation. This paper distinguishes three sources of compulsion in a school, each checked by the accountability it claims and by its actual limits: what care requires, limited to what care requires; what teaching requires (attendance, order, homework), limited to what teaching requires; what is set up to make quiet and room (such as collecting phones), checked by what it actually freed and what it sealed. The name of a category is not in itself an authorization; a measure that claims several purposes does not settle its limits by picking the widest of them. Where law and higher rules lay it down and the school carries it out, the school answers for the scope and manner of its carrying out, and the source is acknowledged but not judged; compulsion whose source cannot be stated has no ground. None of them is renamed cultivation or renamed giving conditions, nor used to prove that cultivation has happened; conditions given separately in the same arrangement are checked separately.


§3 Explanation, Review and the Line

Who explains. Which measure counts as required is explained by the position that exercises the compulsion: by what accountability, what is required, why it stops at this scope, when it stops, when it changes. On Rights and Entitlements, reading care for an infant, divides one and the same act of care into two faces. The face of giving does not converge the child's action. The face of the actual arrangement, where it compels or converges his action, is power, and the position of refusing and exiting in the face of that power is kept for him by the guardian-network. If it is power, it has to be able to say on what ground.

A road it does not alone control. On Rights and Entitlements also keeps three positions apart: the caregiver, the guardian-network, and the reviewing node. In fact they may coincide; in analysis they are kept apart. A party that has crossed the bound cannot, while crossing it, be the one that alone removes its own power over the child; removal has to land on another position that has not crossed it. This paper takes over that division. In the school: when the position that exercises compulsion has explained itself, there still has to be a road it does not alone control by which its explanation is reviewed.

The line. A school always has to separate which matters adults still decide on a child's behalf from which he can already do himself, and, in a given matter, where the position of raising and refusing lies. On Rights and Entitlements said something of the same shape: in a maturing child the negation-gate comes to run of itself bit by bit, and the line between entitlement and recognition-based right moves with it; imposing on him an externally fixed binary threshold, irrefutable and applied uniformly across situations, will at some point put some child, growing faster or slower, on the wrong side. The original speaks of the subject-to-be, and of the line between entitlement and recognition-based right. This paper extends it to the line by which the school separates acting on his behalf from his acting on his own, on the ground that both lines follow the same thing: whether a child can walk on his own in one matter after another goes matter by matter and by degrees, and a school's line that cannot keep up with it will likewise put children on the wrong side. So in separating acting on his behalf from his acting on his own, and in deciding where the position of raising and refusing belongs, the school does not set by grade a line that is externally fixed, cannot be overturned by the facts of an individual case, and is applied uniformly across matters. A line that can be overturned by the facts of an individual case, is judged matter by matter, and keeps appeal and review is not of this kind; On Rights and Entitlements itself keeps this kind apart from a dead line. The rules of curriculum, timetable, facilities and stages are not thereby all required to admit overturning in individual cases; whether they seal positions a child has already gained is checked by their actual effect.

Two things cannot be argued backward. Paper 4 of Cultivation Theory says of guardianship: "that he later grew up well does not prove the guardianship was all justified; that the guardianship had grounds does not show that cultivation took place." The same holds for compulsion in a school: that he later grew up well does not prove the school's earlier compulsion was all justified; that the earlier compulsion had grounds does not show that cultivation took place.

An objection. One line of thinking on discipline puts order first, with zero tolerance: uniform, strict, predictable discipline protects the learning of most children, and explaining and reviewing matter by matter slows handling down.3 Its force lies in two places: order itself is something teaching requires; and when handling is slow, the child who was harmed cannot wait. This paper does not deny compulsion that teaching requires; §2 has already counted it as a source. What it asks is that source and limits can be stated, and that there be a road of review. The side of a classmate who has been violated is taken up in §7 of this paper and in §5 of Paper 4. Stopping something in time and explaining and reviewing can go together: urgent protection can come first, and afterward the grounds and scope are still to be explained and remain open to later questioning; review is not written as a procedure to be completed before every act. The cost has to be stated too. Explaining and reviewing take teachers' and the school's time, and that time is counted in the workload Paper 5 speaks of.

XX12 (continued) Which measure counts as required is explained by the position that exercises the compulsion: by what accountability, what is required, why it stops at this scope, when it stops or changes; and the explanation is reviewed through a road that position does not alone control. Who still has others act on his behalf, who can already act on his own, and where the position of raising and refusing belongs, are not settled by a line drawn by grade that is externally fixed, cannot be overturned by the facts of an individual case, and is applied uniformly across matters (a line that can be overturned by the facts of an individual case, is judged matter by matter, and keeps appeal and review is not of this kind). Two things cannot be argued backward: that he later grew up well does not prove the earlier compulsion was all justified; that the earlier compulsion had grounds does not show that cultivation took place.


§4 The Share Beyond Compulsion

Three places in Cultivation Theory. Paper 4 of Cultivation Theory says that alongside guardianship and beyond it there is a share of cultivation: "his 'no' can land, that is, it is heard, not punished, not laughed at; his later looking back is not sealed; his future 'no' is not made costly." It also says: "In matters he cannot yet avow for himself, the form of sealing is pre-occupation, readable in the present by three signals: whether there is an arrangement for handing over the authority to interpret as he grows; whether the refusals, deviations and restructurings that gradually appear in him can really change the arrangement; whether the present arrangement is marked as changeable or as a conclusion that cannot be refuted in future."

In the school. The original speaks of the guardian's side. While a child is at school the school also holds a share of care and compulsion, so the three places and the three signals can be read just as well in the school's arrangements. A child says "no," and someone listens; he is not punished for saying "no," nor laughed at in front of others. The judgments written in his file: who interprets them, and whether there is an arrangement to hand that over to him as he grows. The objections he raises: whether they can enter a real rejudgment and really change an arrangement, or are all read as his not yet understanding. The present class assignment, seating and timetable: whether they are marked as this term's arrangement, or as a settled verdict on him as a person. This extension is this series' undertaking.

Being able to raise something is not the same as having it come to stand. Parent-Child Theory said, between parents and a child: "Being able to raise something is not the same as having it come to stand"; whether the arrangement in a matter changes, if it also involves others, is read by each party's own law, and is not decided by any one party alone. The same holds in school. A child's "no" to an arrangement that also involves classmates or the whole class does not mean the arrangement changes; that his "no" entered a rejudgment is the share that is there.

The cost of refusal. Compulsion follows the limits of §2. A stretch added because he said "no" puts a cost on refusal; Paper 5 of Cultivation Theory said that "the cost of refusal is not added by the giving side." A requirement that has independent grounds does not vanish automatically because he said "no"; but calling something "making up the work" does not prove that his refusal was not punished.

One way of writing it. Sweden's Education Act, Chapter 4, section 9, says: "The information and the forms of the children's and pupils' influence shall be adapted to their age and maturity." (my translation; Informationen och formerna för barnens och elevernas inflytande ska anpassas efter deras ålder och mognad.) The forms of participation are written into a rule and adjusted by age and maturity; this does not prove that any particular child's "no" actually lands.

XX13 The share beyond compulsion. Alongside compulsion, the school's arrangements let his "no" land: it is heard, not punished, not laughed at; his later looking back is not sealed; his future "no" is not made costly. There is an arrangement for handing over the authority to interpret as he grows; his refusals and deviations can enter a real rejudgment and really change the arrangement, and are not all read as his not yet understanding; being able to raise something is not the same as having it come to stand, and matters that involve others or shared arrangements are read by each party's own law, not decided by any one party alone; the present arrangement is marked as one that can be changed.


§5 Standing Does Not Change with the Ability to Refuse

Teacher-Student Theory says: "The student's standing as an end is full from the start, and is not conferred by the teacher; what he can do and how much he understands grow as he learns." It also says: "The two books are kept apart: 'he doesn't understand yet' at most describes what, in this matter, he cannot yet do; it does not lower his standing, nor is it used to read all his questions and his 'no' as signs of immaturity."

Paper 4 of Cultivation Theory says: "Not yet being able to say no does not mean having no preferences or refusals in any matter. One judges by domain, not the whole person." A child who cannot yet judge how fractions are worked out already has preferences, and refuses, in matters such as whether to eat the greens at lunch or whether he is willing to speak in front of the class. When the school weighs a matter that concerns him, it does not leave him out on the ground that "he's still little, he doesn't understand."

The Convention on the Rights of the Child, Article 12(1), requires States Parties to assure to a child capable of forming his own views the right to express those views freely in all matters affecting him, the views being given due weight according to his age and maturity.4 How judging by domain is written into a school's rules, this paper has not found a suitable rule text to show.

Age lines of the kind "at what age one may do what" are one form at the rule layer. Judging by domain is read by this section; an age line that can be overturned by the facts of an individual case, is judged matter by matter, and keeps review is not among the lines of §3.

XX14 Standing does not change with the ability to refuse. He is not excluded from the consideration of a matter concerning him on the ground that "he's still little, he doesn't understand." Not yet being able to say no does not mean having no preferences or refusals in any matter; one judges by domain, not the whole person.


§6 Discipline by Event

Handled by event. A child did something; the school handles that one thing. Once it is handled, no mark of identity is left, and one handling is not registered as a final verdict on this child. Institution Theory says the same: an institution's identification of a person goes no further than the event and does not become an identity; "this does not cancel the checking of particular facts." Facts that still matter for protection are not erased for the sake of "leaving no mark": that a child once hurt another child remains a fact that is still of use for protection. The Theory of the University said a proposition of the same shape at the level of the university.

A rule that writes a procedure. The Discipline Rules, Article 14: where educational discipline or a disciplinary sanction listed in Article 10 is to be imposed on a student, the school "shall hear the student's statement and defense" (my translation; 应当听取学生的陈述和申辩); "where the student or parent applies for a hearing, the school shall organize a hearing" (my translation; 学生或者家长申请听证的,学校应当组织听证); "where the student can sincerely admit the mistake and actively correct it, the educational discipline or disciplinary sanction may be lifted early" (my translation; 能够诚恳认错、积极改正的,可以提前解除教育惩戒或者纪律处分). The handling is written as one matter, with a procedure, and it can be lifted.

Sanctions have terms. The Provisions on the School Protection of Minors say: except for expulsion, every sanction is to have a term; students under sanction are followed and observed and given targeted education; those who have truly corrected themselves have the sanction lifted at the end of its term; once it is lifted, their eligibility for commendations, awards and other benefits is no longer affected by the original sanction.2 This comes close to "once handled, no mark of identity is left." The provision writes the term and the benefits; it does not write how the record of the sanction is handled after it is lifted. Lifting is not deleting.

Records may be kept. A record of the event may be kept, and how it is kept has to be stated: what it is for, who can see it, the child himself and his parents included, how long it is kept, and how it is corrected. When an old record is used in a new decision, its relevance to this matter is stated; it does not enter every later decision without explanation.

The Shaanxi Province Measures for the Management of Student Status Records in Compulsory Education (2019), Article 25, say: "decisions on a student's sanction are placed in the student's status file; after the sanction is revoked, the record of the sanction shall be promptly withdrawn from the student's status file" (my translation; 学生处分决定存入学生学籍档案,处分撤销后,应及时将处分记录从学生学籍档案中撤出。). The same article goes on: "decisions on sanctions, decisions revoking sanctions, and related materials are kept on file by the school" (my translation; 处分决定、撤销处分决定及有关材料由学校存档。). Withdrawn from the status file, the materials are still kept by the school. Both faces are in one article.5 In the full text of the Ministry of Education's 2025 Measures for the Management of Student Status Records of Primary and Secondary School Students, as checked in a reprinted copy, no article on records of sanctions appears. The United States' federal FERPA writes who can see and how to correct: when a parent or a student who has reached the age requests to inspect records, the school provides access within the set number of days; one who believes a record inaccurate or misleading may request amendment, and if the school declines, it has to inform him of the right to a hearing.6 Amendment here concerns whether the record is accurate, not a rehearing of the handling itself.

Records leaving the school. Where a record is given outside the school, for transfer, progression or employment, the giving side states what it gave and on what ground; the adopting side answers for its adoption. On the uses and limits of records once they leave the school, this paper has not yet found suitable rules; Paper 6 reads this again on the side of evaluation.

XX15 Discipline by event; no identity is fixed on the child. A matter is handled as an event; once handled, no mark of identity is left; one handling is not registered as a final verdict on this child. A record of the event may be kept: its keeping states the purpose, who can see it (the child himself and his parents included), until when, and how it is corrected; when an old record is used in a new decision, its relevance to this matter is stated, and it does not enter every later decision without explanation. Where a record is given outside the school (transfer, progression to the next stage, employment), the giving side states what it gave and on what ground, and the adopting side answers for its adoption. This does not cancel the checking of particular facts, nor, for the sake of "leaving no mark," erase facts that still matter for protection.


§7 After the Line Is Crossed

How far the relational side reads. Teacher-Student Theory reads what lies between a teacher and a student: "where the teacher's effect crosses the student's basic rights, this series reads as far as 'this is violation,' and protection and disposition after the violation lie on the institutional side." Parent-Child Theory hands over the same thing from between parents and a child: "The child's basic rights have their standing in himself and are not conferred by the parents; how they are protected and by what rules belongs to the institutional side, and applies whichever direction the parents are headed in." What the two hand to the institutional side is taken up at the level of the school.

The school answers for protection and disposition. Where something in a school crosses a child's basic rights, whether it comes from a teacher, a staff member or another child, the school answers for protection and disposition. China's Compulsory Education Law, Article 29(2), says: "teachers shall respect students' personal dignity, shall not discriminate against students, shall not inflict corporal punishment, disguised corporal punishment or other acts insulting personal dignity on students, and shall not infringe students' lawful rights and interests" (my translation; 教师应当尊重学生的人格,不得歧视学生,不得对学生实施体罚、变相体罚或者其他侮辱人格尊严的行为,不得侵犯学生合法权益。). The Preschool Education Law lists corporal or disguised corporal punishment of children among the unlawful acts of kindergarten teachers and other staff.2 The Convention on the Rights of the Child, Article 28(2), requires States Parties to take all appropriate measures to ensure that school discipline is administered in a manner consistent with the child's human dignity.4 The prohibitions are written into law.

A road the party involved does not control. The child has to have a road for telling, one the party involved does not control; his parents can tell too. Institution Theory set three conditions for such a channel: "it is independent of the party questioned, internal subjects can actually initiate it, and initiating it brings no retaliation". The Discipline Rules, Article 16, say: "where a parent objects to educational discipline imposed by a teacher, or considers that the teacher's conduct violates Article 12 of these Rules, the parent may complain or report to the school or to the competent education administrative department" (my translation; 家长对教师实施的教育惩戒有异议或者认为教师行为违反本规则第十二条规定的,可以向学校或者主管教育行政部门投诉、举报。). Replying to a public message in 2022, the Ministry of Education made clear that complaints and reports and appeals "are different matters" (my translation; 是不同的事项), and that "complaints and reports concern teachers' conduct and are not subject to time limits" (my translation; 投诉、举报针对的是教师行为,不受时间限制). The party this article sets in motion is the parent. It shows that "parents can tell too" has been written into a rule; it does not show that the child has a road of his own. The roads a child can start himself are written in Paper 4.

Two entrances. One is asking for help. A child who suffers an effect that crosses the line at home or elsewhere and comes to the school for help is not pushed away; the school answers for the protection and referral it can give. The Provisions on the School Protection of Minors say that where a student asks the school for protection because of abandonment or abuse, the school may not refuse or shift the matter off, and where rescue is needed, it gives rescue first.2

The other is discovery. Where the school, within its accountability, finds that a child has suffered a violation of his rights, may have suffered such a violation, or faces danger, it reports as the rules require; it does not require young children, or children who cannot fully express themselves, first to complete a formal request for help. China's Law on the Protection of Minors requires units and staff in close contact with children who discover such circumstances in their work to report at once to the public security, civil affairs, education and other relevant departments; the Provisions on the School Protection of Minors require schools and staff who discover them to report promptly as provided.2 Japan's Child Abuse Prevention Act, Article 5, says that schools and school staff "must endeavor to detect child abuse early" (my translation; 児童虐待の早期発見に努めなければならない); Article 6 says that one who discovers it "must notify" (my translation; 通告しなければならない). Abuse here is limited to what Article 2 of that Act defines: certain kinds of acts done by a guardian, that is, a person exercising parental authority, a guardian of a minor or another person actually taking care of the child, toward the child in his care. Article 5 is a duty to endeavor toward early detection; Article 6 is a duty to notify on discovering a child who appears to have been abused, and does not presuppose that the abuse has been proved. Sweden's Social Services Act, Chapter 19, section 1, requires schools and their staff to report "immediately" (my translation; genast).

Three things written apart. Protection, handling within the school, and reporting are three things. Having reported does not by itself settle the protection the school can still give; nor does the school, by having reported or by having been present, gain the whole power to investigate and decide the matter.

When parents keep the child from using it. There is a case in which an institution gives a child a share and his parents do not let him use it. What the school can do at its end is protect, respond and refer; what it did and did not do is questioned by the school's accountability. How the parents' end is read lies in Parent-Child Theory, not here.

XX16 After the line is crossed. Where something in a school crosses a child's basic rights, whether it comes from a teacher, a staff member or another child, the school answers for protection and disposition; the child has a road for telling that the party involved does not control, and so do his parents. Where a child suffers an effect that crosses the line at home or elsewhere and comes to the school for help, the school does not push him away, and answers for the protection and referral it can give; where the school, within its accountability, finds that a child has suffered a violation of his rights, may have suffered such a violation, or faces danger, it reports as the rules require, and does not require young children or children who cannot fully express themselves first to complete a formal request for help.


§8 Care in Three Stages

This section follows the axis of stages and writes only the arrangements the school mainly handles at each stage. That a matter is written at some stage does not mean it appears only there, nor is the stage used to judge where a particular child has got to.

Kindergarten. Care is the main item. The three signals are read in the arrangements of childcare: a child's "no" may not be a sentence; it may be crying, turning away, holding back. Whether such a "no" is taken up. The entrance of reporting on discovery matters at this stage: the child is not required first to complete a formal request for help.

Primary school. Rules for what teaching requires, such as attendance, order and homework; the authority and limits of discipline.

Secondary school. Rules on phones; online platforms the school requires students to use; channels students can start for themselves (Paper 4).

Boarding. Care runs all day; "while he is at school" has to be read again. This paper only registers it.


§9 Back to Kant's Question

Paper 4 of Cultivation Theory cites a question from Kant's lectures on pedagogy: "For compulsion is necessary! How do I cultivate freedom under compulsion?" That paper gave only the direction of an answer: "freedom grows in the share compulsion did not occupy, on the road along which guardianship is handed back." It also says: "This paper does not deny that compulsion is necessary; nor does it say that the formation of freedom will happen of itself." It does not take compulsion as a means of forming freedom.

The same holds at the level of the school. The share compulsion did not occupy is what §4 described: his "no" can land, the road of looking back is not blocked, his future "no" is not made costly. The road along which guardianship is handed back is the line of §3 not being drawn once and for all: in a matter where he can already walk on his own, the position of raising and refusing in that matter is his. This paper does not deny that compulsion is necessary; §2 divided it into three sources, each with its limits. Compulsion itself is not called cultivation.


Where This Paper Stops

What it has not done: it has not said which way of discipline is good; it has not written the particular rules of school safety; it has not written the legal forms of guardianship; it has not judged whether any particular sanction was right.


Notes

  1. The guidance on restrictive intervention issued by England's Department for Education, in force from 1 April 2026, and the 2013 notice of Japan's Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology on the prohibition of corporal punishment are known to this paper only through secondary material; it has not gone back to the originals and does not write them. ↩︎
  2. The provisions of the Provisions on the School Protection of Minors, the Preschool Education Law and the Law on the Protection of Minors are given here in paraphrase, from reprinted copies. ↩︎
  3. This paper writes only the structure of this line of thinking, and does not report any particular author's words. ↩︎
  4. The Convention is paraphrased here on the basis used in the Chinese edition: UNICEF's Chinese-language page, which does not state whether it reproduces the official UN Chinese text. This paper has not quoted the official English text. ↩︎
  5. Whether the Shaanxi measures were revised after the national measures on student status records were issued in 2025, this paper has not checked. ↩︎
  6. FERPA is paraphrased from Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations, Part 99, as published by the Legal Information Institute at Cornell University. ↩︎

The Five Propositions of This Paper

XX12 Compulsion in a school is not called cultivation. This paper distinguishes three sources of compulsion in a school, each checked by the accountability it claims and by its actual limits: what care requires, limited to what care requires; what teaching requires (attendance, order, homework), limited to what teaching requires; what is set up to make quiet and room (such as collecting phones), checked by what it actually freed and what it sealed. The name of a category is not in itself an authorization; a measure that claims several purposes does not settle its limits by picking the widest of them. Where law and higher rules lay it down and the school carries it out, the school answers for the scope and manner of its carrying out, and the source is acknowledged but not judged; compulsion whose source cannot be stated has no ground. None of them is renamed cultivation or renamed giving conditions, nor used to prove that cultivation has happened; conditions given separately in the same arrangement are checked separately. Which measure counts as required is explained by the position that exercises the compulsion: by what accountability, what is required, why it stops at this scope, when it stops or changes; and the explanation is reviewed through a road that position does not alone control. Who still has others act on his behalf, who can already act on his own, and where the position of raising and refusing belongs, are not settled by a line drawn by grade that is externally fixed, cannot be overturned by the facts of an individual case, and is applied uniformly across matters (a line that can be overturned by the facts of an individual case, is judged matter by matter, and keeps appeal and review is not of this kind). Two things cannot be argued backward: that he later grew up well does not prove the earlier compulsion was all justified; that the earlier compulsion had grounds does not show that cultivation took place. (Conceptual distinction and normative; Cultivation Theory HY20 and HY23, which speak of guardianship, extended to compulsion in the school, this series' own undertaking; explanation and review take over On Rights and Entitlements F34 and F35; the line extends On Rights and Entitlements F34a, whose subject is the subject-to-be and whose line lies between entitlement and recognition-based right, this series' own undertaking; the category of leaving room points the same way as Education as Subject-Condition 3.3)

XX13 The share beyond compulsion. Alongside compulsion, the school's arrangements let his "no" land: it is heard, not punished, not laughed at; his later looking back is not sealed; his future "no" is not made costly. There is an arrangement for handing over the authority to interpret as he grows; his refusals and deviations can enter a real rejudgment and really change the arrangement, and are not all read as his not yet understanding; being able to raise something is not the same as having it come to stand, and matters that involve others or shared arrangements are read by each party's own law, not decided by any one party alone; the present arrangement is marked as one that can be changed. (Normative; Cultivation Theory HY21 and its three signals, which speak of the guardian's side, extended to the school's arrangements, this series' own undertaking; "being able to raise something is not the same as having it come to stand" takes over Parent-Child Theory PC39; the sentence on the cost of refusal takes over Cultivation Theory HY27)

XX14 Standing does not change with the ability to refuse. He is not excluded from the consideration of a matter concerning him on the ground that "he's still little, he doesn't understand." Not yet being able to say no does not mean having no preferences or refusals in any matter; one judges by domain, not the whole person. (Normative; taking over Cultivation Theory HY22 and HY24, and Teacher-Student Theory TS5)

XX15 Discipline by event; no identity is fixed on the child. A matter is handled as an event; once handled, no mark of identity is left; one handling is not registered as a final verdict on this child. A record of the event may be kept: its keeping states the purpose, who can see it (the child himself and his parents included), until when, and how it is corrected; when an old record is used in a new decision, its relevance to this matter is stated, and it does not enter every later decision without explanation. Where a record is given outside the school (transfer, progression to the next stage, employment), the giving side states what it gave and on what ground, and the adopting side answers for its adoption. This does not cancel the checking of particular facts, nor, for the sake of "leaving no mark," erase facts that still matter for protection. (Normative; taking over Institution Theory Z3, the last sentence following its original wording; same shape as Theory of the University DX12; the sentence on records leaving the school extends Theory of Disciplines, Paper 6, S34, which speaks of standards, to records, with the same shape as Theory of the University DX26, this series' own undertaking)

XX16 After the line is crossed. Where something in a school crosses a child's basic rights, whether it comes from a teacher, a staff member or another child, the school answers for protection and disposition; the child has a road for telling that the party involved does not control, and so do his parents. Where a child suffers an effect that crosses the line at home or elsewhere and comes to the school for help, the school does not push him away, and answers for the protection and referral it can give; where the school, within its accountability, finds that a child has suffered a violation of his rights, may have suffered such a violation, or faces danger, it reports as the rules require, and does not require young children or children who cannot fully express themselves first to complete a formal request for help. (Normative; taking up Teacher-Student Theory, Paper 0, §1, and Paper 2, §4, which read as far as "this is violation"; taking up what Parent-Child Theory PC10 hands to the institutional side; the road the party involved does not control takes over Institution Theory Z34)


References

All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version.

I · This system

  • Qin, H. (2026). What a School Is Not (SAE Theory of the School, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24382559
  • Qin, H. (2026). Education as Subject-Condition: A Philosophy of Education [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18867389
  • Qin, H. (2026). Those Who Cannot Yet Say No (SAE Cultivation Theory, Paper 4) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154511
  • Qin, H. (2026). When One Holds Power (SAE Cultivation Theory, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154515
  • Qin, H. (2026). The Place of Teacher-Student Theory (SAE Teacher-Student Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24267256
  • Qin, H. (2026). The Place of Parent-Child Theory (SAE Parent-Child Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24121569
  • Qin, H. (2026). On Rights and Entitlements (SAE Rights Theory, Special Study) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21314907
  • Qin, H. (2026). To Whom the Ought Is Addressed (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23269635
  • Qin, H. (2026). Open to Questioning (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23271324
  • Qin, H. (2026). Withdrawal (SAE Theory of Disciplines, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24177783
  • Qin, H. (2026). University Students (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293740
  • Qin, H. (2026). University Evaluation (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293751

II · Rule texts

  • Ministry of Education (China). 2020. Rules on Educational Discipline in Primary and Secondary Schools (for Trial Implementation) (中小学教育惩戒规则(试行)), Ministry of Education Order No. 49. In force 2021-03-01.
  • Ministry of Education (China). 2021. Provisions on the School Protection of Minors (未成年人学校保护规定), Ministry of Education Order No. 50. In force 2021-09-01.
  • General Office of the Ministry of Education (China). 2021. Notice on Strengthening the Management of Mobile Phones of Primary and Secondary School Students (关于加强中小学生手机管理工作的通知), Jiaojitinghan [2021] No. 3. 2021-01-15.
  • Compulsory Education Law of the People's Republic of China (中华人民共和国义务教育法), as amended for the second time in 2018.
  • Preschool Education Law of the People's Republic of China (中华人民共和国学前教育法). In force 2025-06-01.
  • Law of the People's Republic of China on the Protection of Minors (中华人民共和国未成年人保护法).
  • Shaanxi Provincial Department of Education. 2019. Shaanxi Province Measures for the Management of Student Status Records in Compulsory Education (陕西省义务教育阶段学生学籍管理办法), Shanjiaoguifan [2019] No. 18.
  • Ministry of Education (China). 2025. Measures for the Management of Student Status Records of Primary and Secondary School Students (中小学生学籍管理办法), Jiaoji [2025] No. 1.
  • United Nations. 1989. Convention on the Rights of the Child.
  • England. Education and Inspections Act 2006, s. 93.
  • England. Children's Wellbeing and Schools Act 2026, s. 36; Department for Education, mobile phones in schools statutory guidance (2026).
  • Sweden. Skollag (2010:800), ch. 4, s. 9; ch. 5, s. 6.
  • Sweden. Socialtjänstlag (2025:400), ch. 19, s. 1.
  • Finland. Perusopetuslaki 628/1998, s. 29(4) (as amended by 245/2025).
  • Japan. Act on the Prevention, etc. of Child Abuse (児童虐待の防止等に関する法律), Articles 5 and 6.
  • United States. Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act, 34 CFR Part 99.

III · Other literature

  • Kant, I. (1803). Über Pädagogik. Akademie-Ausgabe 9:453, as quoted in Cultivation Theory, Paper 4.

Interfaces

This series: XX12 to XX16.

Handed to Paper 4: the child being looked after cannot walk away on his own.

Handed to other papers: appeals and reviews the child can start himself, Paper 4 (XX18, XX19); harm between classmates, within the scope of §1, Paper 4 (XX20); the time explanation and review take, Paper 5 (XX22); records as a limited proof, and records leaving the school, Paper 6 (XX30); how the roads of review match the school's several accountabilities, Paper 8.