School Cultivation
学校的涵育
Self-consciousness and ends cannot be taught; a child has to chisel them out for himself. What the school, at its level, can do is give conditions for cultivation. This paper states six propositions. The school gives conditions for cultivation; it does not manufacture it, and does not inspect and accept it. The school's arrangements do not avoid the death and the "why" a child asks about, do not exchange the thing he cannot not do for homework he cannot not do, and, seeing that signal, do not block it. Curriculum, activities and environment face many, and create conditions for cultivation; questioning can face only one person. The ground of the student-to-teacher ratio is the teacher's time to question and respond to every student under him; when that time cannot be given, the teacher's judgment and the school's arrangements are entered separately. Every child has at least one teacher who can be identified, can be contacted, and can take up his matters continuously. The school does not lay out every stretch of a child's time as growth. This paper does not say that one-to-one is better than one-to-many, nor what class sizes and student-to-teacher ratios ought to be. The word "cultivation" here takes the usage of Cultivation Theory and Teacher-Student Theory; the English edition of Education as Subject-Condition writes "nurturing" in its threefold, and the English edition of this series writes "cultivation."
Writing Declaration: This paper was co-drafted with Claude (Anthropic). All intellectual decisions, framework design, and final editorial judgments were made by the author.
Introduction
The Prequel of Cultivation Theory has a sentence: "thirty students cannot be nurtured at once by one method; one method for one student, teaching each according to his aptitude."
Paper 1 said that teaching is the thing a school does best, and that it can be done for thirty people at once. This paper takes up the thing that comes next. That thing the school cannot make; it can only give conditions for it. And among the conditions is one person facing one child and asking.
In 2023 the Shanghai Municipal Education Commission issued a work plan for an all-staff tutor system: "primary and secondary schools are to assign a tutor to every student; teachers are in principle all to serve as student tutors, and the number of students each tutor guides is in principle not to exceed 15" (my translation; 中小学校要为每一个学生配备导师,教师原则上都要担任学生导师,每位导师指导学生数原则上不超过 15 名). A construct had written "one person to one person" as a form of staffing, and had given it a ceiling on numbers. This paper asks exactly that: how far a construct can give, and where it cannot.
§1 Giving Conditions, Not Manufacturing, Not Inspecting
The thing that cannot be taught. Teacher-Student Theory says: "The student's own purpose and his cannot-not cannot be taught; he has to chisel them out himself. What the teacher's end can do is give space: not suppress, and not block that signal." This is what the threefold of Education as Subject-Condition calls nurturing. It is not a harder kind of teaching; it is another kind of thing. Its result lies with the child, and he brings it about himself.
What the school can give. What the school can give is conditions. The Prequel listed them: time, room; someone who asks him and responds to him; a place where his questions and his "no" can land, be heard, and be neither punished nor laughed at. All of these can be arranged by the school, and all of them can be checked: whether the time is in the timetable, whether the person is there, whether anyone took up the question when he asked.
Not manufacturing, not inspecting and accepting. The school does not treat a child's being cultivated as a result that can be demanded. Institution Theory says that when a construct places demands on people, "The other party's being cultivated, his avowing his own law, or his producing a designated outcome of self-avowal or self-constitution may not be made a result to be obtained by compulsion". Nor does the school inspect and accept it: it does not assess which child has been cultivated, and does not assess teachers by it. That these arrangements are in place does not prove that cultivation has happened; that it did not happen does not by itself judge the school a failure. Whether the school has met its accountability for the conditions it undertook is checked separately: which conditions it gave, and whether they could be reached. The Theory of the University set the same limit at the level of the university.
XX6 The school gives conditions for cultivation; it does not manufacture it, and does not inspect and accept it. What the school can give is conditions: time, room, someone who asks him questions, a place where his questions and his "no" can land. The school does not make being cultivated a result to be obtained by compulsion, nor does it inspect and accept it; that these arrangements are in place does not prove that cultivation has happened.
§2 Not Avoiding, Not Suppressing, Not Blocking
Two stretches of cultivation in the threefold. Education as Subject-Condition says that adults can do only two things in cultivation. Facing the stretch of self-awareness: not avoiding; when a child first asks "why will I die," not changing the subject. Facing the stretch of ends: not suppressing; seeing the thing a child cannot not do surface in him, not blocking it. It also says that adults need not encourage him, nor plan for him; they need only not block.
In the school. These two things were said of adults toward children; this section extends them to the school's arrangements. A school's arrangements can avoid: a class permits only questions that will be tested; a child asks about death, and the teacher is required to pull the talk back to the syllabus. A school's arrangements can also block. Education says that for children of eight to ten, as academic pressure mounts, "'the thing I cannot not do' is replaced by 'homework I cannot not do.'" When what a child has to attend after school is laid out to the full, the thing that surfaces in him has nowhere to go. So this section says: the school's arrangements do not avoid the death and the "why" a child asks about; they do not exchange the thing he cannot not do for homework he cannot not do; seeing that signal, they do not block it.
Not blocking is not encouraging. Not blocking does not mean the school is to make that thing into a course for him, nor that it is to fix a direction and plan for him. Planning for him is another way of blocking.
This section gives no case. The material at hand is not yet enough to form a suitable example. If rule material is found later, say a rule that keeps time with no set use, or one that lets students choose an activity for themselves, it will show only how the relevant conditions were written into rules. The rule alone will not prove that there was in fact no blocking, still less that cultivation happened.
XX7 Not avoiding, not suppressing, not blocking. The school's arrangements do not avoid the death and the "why" a child asks about; they do not exchange his "thing he cannot not do" for homework he cannot not do; seeing that signal, they do not block it. Not blocking is not encouraging, nor planning for him.
§3 Facing Many, Addressing One
Two kinds of act. Cultivation Theory drew a division: "A concrete relation of cultivation is one-to-one: one who gives, and one who receives. An act of cultivation, though, can be sent out by one person toward many." Curriculum, activities and environment in a school are all arrangements that face many: a library, an afternoon with no classes, an assignment on which children choose their own topic. These create conditions for cultivation, and they can face many.
Questioning can face only one person. Teacher-Student Theory says: "Creating conditions can face many; questioning is put to one person who can hear and can answer, and how one responds after he has answered falls in his relation." It also says: "A shared arrangement cannot take the place of a response to a particular question, and one method cannot vouch for, or complete, the growing and the avowing of many." An afternoon with no classes does not mean that anyone has asked this child what he did that afternoon, and why.
"Can hear and can answer" is not a threshold. Some children do not use spoken language; some can express themselves only with help. "Can hear and can answer" says that questioning faces a particular person; it does not say that the person has to answer in spoken words. For such a child, the way of asking changes; the questioning remains.
XX8 Creating conditions can face many; questioning can face only one person. Curriculum, activities and environment are arrangements that face many, creating conditions for cultivation; questioning needs one person who can hear and can answer, and how one responds after he has answered falls in his relation. A shared arrangement cannot take the place of a response to a particular question; one method cannot vouch for the growing of many.
§4 The Ground of the Student-to-Teacher Ratio
The ground is the time for questioning. How many children a teacher has decides whether he can question each child and respond to each. Here lies the ground of the student-to-teacher ratio. This series does not say the fewer children the better, and gives no number; what it says is that the school is to see to it that teachers have this time.
Two entries, kept apart. A child asks and no one responds: there may be two entries. At the teacher's end Teacher-Student Theory has said that the teacher's time and strength are limited, and that where "he judges that this time he cannot give, not giving this time is not losing one's ground, and this judgment too can be questioned". That entry is made against the teacher. The other is made against the school: where a teacher has so many children that he cannot give however he judges, that part is not the teacher judging wrong; it is the school's arrangements leaving that judgment no room. The two entries are kept apart and do not offset each other. That the school's arrangements are tight does not exempt the teacher's judgment from being questioned; that the teacher's judgment can be questioned does not exempt the school's arrangements from being questioned.
One missing response does not prove a shortage of staff. That on some occasion there was no response does not by itself prove that the school is short of staff. A structural gap is checked by how the arrangements make this accountability impossible to carry out: how many children a teacher has, where the time is laid out, whether it is counted in the workload. The part that goes beyond one school's authority and resources goes to Paper 5: it is answered by the position that carries public securing, and is not covered by the school or by individual teachers.
The other children's share. Cultivation Theory says: "When one gives with shared resources or other people's time, the share of third parties is in it too, and is not settled merely by the recipient's benefit." When a teacher gives this one child an extra hour, the other children's share is in it too. If that hour is not to come out of the other children's share, it has to be counted in beforehand when staff are allotted. So staffing is not reckoned by the needs of one kind of child: some children need more time, some need another form of response, and the school counts all of this when it allots staff.
Several ways of writing it. One way to do it is: set ceilings on class size and on the student-to-teacher ratio; grade the kindergarten by age; do not fill the teaching hours of subject teachers and homeroom teachers; let the school be able to say how many students each teacher has and how much of his working time is kept for responding to them, with both numbers public and open to questioning. In 2026 Japan amended its standards act on class formation for public compulsory-education schools, lowering the standard class size for lower secondary schools from forty to thirty-five, phased in over years: until 31 March 2028, the grades set by cabinet order, and lower secondary schools with special circumstances, may still use forty. Finland's decree on early childhood education and care sets staff ratios by age: under three, one qualified staff member looks after at most four children; aged three and over, for children attending more than five hours a day, at most seven. In China it is kindergarten class size that is graded by age: twenty-five in the youngest class, thirty in the middle class, thirty-five in the oldest.1 Both sides need looking at. Class size written into law and staff ratios graded by age are a step; a number for class size is not the same as each child having time to be questioned.
An objection. One objection runs: even if smaller classes add time for response, the gain may not cover the cost; the same resources have other uses.2 Its force lies in opportunity cost. This series answers on three levels. First, its ground is not results. It does not say that children in smaller classes will score better; it says that the time for questioning has to be there, and the size of any effect on results does not change the ground of this claim. Second, it has to answer which forms of organization actually free time for response, and at what price. Smaller classes are one way; cutting teachers' administrative work, setting aside periods with no classes for response, several teachers sharing a grade, are also ways. Which is better in a given place is a matter for the rule layer, which has to be able to state the cost, and to make clear whether it squeezes out the other children's share. Third, this series wants both the number and the quality of teachers secured (Paper 5). When resources are limited, which comes first is a choice at the rule layer, entered at the three ends separately and not covered by any one school.
XX9 The ground of the student-to-teacher ratio is the time for questioning. The school ought to see to it that teachers have time to question and respond to every student under them. When a teacher has so many students that this cannot be done, two entries are kept apart: where this time he cannot give, the teacher's judgment can still be questioned as before; the part where staffing and time leave that judgment no room is entered separately against the school's arrangements, and the school answers for it; the two do not offset each other. One occasion without a response does not by itself prove a shortage of staff; a structural gap is checked by how the arrangements make the accountability impossible to carry out. Where everyone's time is given to this one, the other children's share is in it too. It does not hold that fewer students is always better, and gives no number. The part that goes beyond the school's authority and resources is answered by the position that carries public securing.
§5 A Teacher Who Knows Him
Every child is to have one. Every child is to have at least one teacher: one he knows he can go to; one who holds the accountability of asking him questions and responding to his judgments; one who can take up his matters continuously. Whether this person is called a homeroom teacher, a tutor or an academic advisor, how the pairing is made, and how several people work together, are at the rule layer. The Theory of the University said at the level of the university that every student has an advisor of his own. What has the same shape here is the conditions of guidance, not a post.
What "knows him" checks. It does not check how much the teacher knows of him in his heart. It checks what lies in the position: the child knows who the teacher is; the teacher can be found at registered times; how many children the teacher has; the child can change teachers. These four are forms. Whether the arrangement can be used is seen in whether the children who go to the teacher are taken in; this serves only as a clue for checking, not as a measure. For young children, and for children who cannot fully express themselves, "being able to say who the teacher is" is not a threshold for receiving guidance; where he cannot say it, the school still has to see to it that such a teacher is there.
The edges of this position. This teacher does not alone control the child's evaluation and his way forward: evaluation, recommendation for the next stage and disciplinary sanctions are not all tied into one person's hands. The child can change teachers; when he does, the handover does not leave him without guidance. Where the same teacher also holds care, discipline and evaluation, it is read by Paper 3.
Time and gaps. The school provides time in which this accountability can actually be carried out, and does not let a nominal pairing stand in for usable guidance. Where resources fall short, it registers the gap as it is, which goes to Paper 5; it does not press it onto the existing teachers. Whether this relation becomes cultivation is not in the school's hands.
A case. The Shanghai plan from the introduction set out the assignment and a ceiling on numbers. It also says that "schools are to match tutors and students according to actual circumstances, on the basis of respecting students' autonomy and right to choose" (my translation; 学校应在尊重学生自主权和选择权基础上,根据实际情况做好导师与学生的匹配), and that it will "establish and improve a system of performance allocation and incentives for tutors, taking teachers' experience and results as tutors as an important reference for promotion in professional title and for selection as advanced or outstanding" (my translation; 建立和完善导师的绩效分配和激励制度,将教师担任导师的经历和成效作为教师职称晋升、评先评优等重要参考). In the document as checked, no procedure for changing tutors appears, nor any conversion of guidance into workload, nor any account of how time is freed. Two things have to be checked separately: having a choice when the match is made, and being able to change once the relation has formed. What the document does not say is not thereby absent in practice. This paper did not find a national rule requiring every student to have a designated teacher.
XX10 Every child has a teacher who knows him. The school ought to see to it that every child has at least one teacher who can be identified, can be contacted, and can take up his matters continuously: he knows he can go to this teacher; this teacher holds the accountability of asking him questions and responding to his judgments; this position does not alone control his evaluation and his way forward; he can change teachers, and the handover does not leave him without guidance. "Knows him" does not check how much the teacher knows of him in his heart; it checks what lies in the position: the child knows who it is; the teacher can be found at registered times; how many children the teacher has; he can change teachers. The school provides time in which this accountability can actually be carried out, and does not let a nominal pairing stand in for usable guidance; where resources fall short, it registers the gap as it is and does not press it onto the existing teachers. Whether this relation becomes cultivation is not in the school's hands. The four are forms; whether the arrangement is usable is checked by whether those who come looking are taken in, as a clue, not as a measure; for young children and children who cannot fully express themselves, "being able to say who the teacher is" does not become a threshold for receiving guidance. Where the same teacher also holds care, discipline and evaluation, it is read by Paper 3.
§6 Not Turning Every Time Together into an Occasion for Growth
Teacher-Student Theory and Cultivation Theory both said one thing: one does not turn every time together into an occasion for growth; the other may refuse to be treated continually as someone yet to grow.
The same holds at the level of the school. After-school activities, integrated practical activities and growth portfolios are all conditions given for cultivation. Given in excess, conditions can also lay out every free stretch of a child's time as output: every afternoon has a project, every activity calls for a page of reflection, every game is entered into the portfolio. A child spending an afternoon on nothing in particular does not count as the school failing in its accountability. Education as Subject-Condition says of the stretch of self-awareness that it requires quiet.
XX11 Not turning every time together into an occasion for growth. The school does not lay out every stretch of a child's time as growth that has to produce something; he may refuse to be treated continually as someone yet to grow.
§7 Cultivation in Three Stages
This section follows the axis of stages and writes only the arrangements the school mainly handles at each stage. That a matter is written at some stage does not mean it appears only there, nor is the stage used to judge where a particular child has got to.
Kindergarten. Conditions of care and play; staff ratios graded by age (§4). "A teacher who knows him" does not make the child's being able to say so a threshold; handover runs through the childcare staff and the family.
Primary school. Positions of the homeroom-teacher kind. Such a position can hold teaching, care and evaluation at once; how these are read apart is written in Paper 3.
Secondary school. How the arrangements for guidance meet preparation for the next stage: in the same stretch of time, someone is asking him what he wants to do, and someone is arranging what he ought to sit for. The side of the gate is written in Paper 6.
Where This Paper Stops
What it has not done: it has not said that one-to-one is better than one-to-many; it has given no method of cultivation; it has judged no child to have been cultivated; it has not said what class sizes and student-to-teacher ratios ought to be.
Notes
- Japan's amendment is given from the record of the bill in the House of Representatives and from the explanation of the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology; the class of thirty-five in primary schools was completed in phases under an amendment of 2021, the text of which this paper has not gone back to. Finland's staff ratios are from Government Decree 753/2018, section 1, and amending decree 1586/2019. China's kindergarten class sizes are from a reprinted copy of Article 11 of the Regulations on Kindergarten Work. Finland's band for children attending no more than five hours a day, and the ratios in China's 2013 staffing standard for kindergarten staff, this paper has not checked against the originals and does not give. ↩︎
- For empirical research on class size, one can look at Hanushek (1999), "Some Findings from an Independent Investigation of the Tennessee STAR Experiment and from Other Investigations of Class Size Effects"; Mosteller (1995), "The Tennessee Study of Class Size in the Early School Grades"; and Krueger (1999), "Experimental Estimates of Education Production Functions." All three concern Tennessee's STAR class-size experiment. This paper has not gone back to the originals, lists them only as leads, and does not report their conclusions. ↩︎
The Six Propositions of This Paper
XX6 The school gives conditions for cultivation; it does not manufacture it, and does not inspect and accept it. What the school can give is conditions: time, room, someone who asks him questions, a place where his questions and his "no" can land. The school does not make being cultivated a result to be obtained by compulsion, nor does it inspect and accept it; that these arrangements are in place does not prove that cultivation has happened. (Normative; taking over the threefold of Education as Subject-Condition, Teacher-Student Theory TS24, and Institution Theory Z5 and Z23; the last sentence has the same shape as the qualification in Theory of the University DX2)
XX7 Not avoiding, not suppressing, not blocking. The school's arrangements do not avoid the death and the "why" a child asks about; they do not exchange his "thing he cannot not do" for homework he cannot not do; seeing that signal, they do not block it. Not blocking is not encouraging, nor planning for him. (Normative; Education as Subject-Condition 3.3, 4.1 and 4.3, which speak of adults toward children, extended to the school's arrangements, this series' own undertaking)
XX8 Creating conditions can face many; questioning can face only one person. Curriculum, activities and environment are arrangements that face many, creating conditions for cultivation; questioning needs one person who can hear and can answer, and how one responds after he has answered falls in his relation. A shared arrangement cannot take the place of a response to a particular question; one method cannot vouch for the growing of many. (Conceptual distinction and normative; taking over Teacher-Student Theory TS25 and Cultivation Theory, Prequel, §4)
XX9 The ground of the student-to-teacher ratio is the time for questioning. The school ought to see to it that teachers have time to question and respond to every student under them. When a teacher has so many students that this cannot be done, two entries are kept apart: where this time he cannot give, the teacher's judgment can still be questioned as before; the part where staffing and time leave that judgment no room is entered separately against the school's arrangements, and the school answers for it; the two do not offset each other. One occasion without a response does not by itself prove a shortage of staff; a structural gap is checked by how the arrangements make the accountability impossible to carry out. Where everyone's time is given to this one, the other children's share is in it too. It does not hold that fewer students is always better, and gives no number. The part that goes beyond the school's authority and resources is answered by the position that carries public securing. (Normative; this series' stance; the step from what one person can give to what a construct ought to supply takes over Institution Theory Z23 and the last sentence of Theory of the University DX3, this series' own undertaking; the individual side follows Teacher-Student Theory TS25; the other children's share takes over Cultivation Theory HY18)
XX10 Every child has a teacher who knows him. The school ought to see to it that every child has at least one teacher who can be identified, can be contacted, and can take up his matters continuously: he knows he can go to this teacher; this teacher holds the accountability of asking him questions and responding to his judgments; this position does not alone control his evaluation and his way forward; he can change teachers, and the handover does not leave him without guidance. "Knows him" does not check how much the teacher knows of him in his heart; it checks what lies in the position: the child knows who it is; the teacher can be found at registered times; how many children the teacher has; he can change teachers. The school provides time in which this accountability can actually be carried out, and does not let a nominal pairing stand in for usable guidance; where resources fall short, it registers the gap as it is and does not press it onto the existing teachers. Whether this relation becomes cultivation is not in the school's hands. The four are forms; whether the arrangement is usable is checked by whether those who come looking are taken in, as a clue, not as a measure; for young children and children who cannot fully express themselves, "being able to say who the teacher is" does not become a threshold for receiving guidance. Where the same teacher also holds care, discipline and evaluation, it is read by Paper 3. (Normative; this series' stance; Theory of the University DX3 speaks of the university's advisors, with the subject changed to the school, and what has the same shape is the conditions of guidance, not a post, this series' own undertaking; the sentence on clues takes over Institution Theory Z24)
XX11 Not turning every time together into an occasion for growth. The school does not lay out every stretch of a child's time as growth that has to produce something; he may refuse to be treated continually as someone yet to grow. (Normative; taking over Teacher-Student Theory TS28 and Cultivation Theory HY16)
References
All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version.
I · This system
- Qin, H. (2026). What a School Is Not (SAE Theory of the School, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24382559
- Qin, H. (2026). School Teaching (SAE Theory of the School, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24382568
- Qin, H. (2026). Education as Subject-Condition: A Philosophy of Education [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18867389
- Qin, H. (2026). What Cultivation Is Not (SAE Cultivation Theory, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154492
- Qin, H. (2026). How Far to Give (SAE Cultivation Theory, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154506
- Qin, H. (2026). The Place of Teacher-Student Theory (SAE Teacher-Student Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24267256
- Qin, H. (2026). To Whom the Ought Is Addressed (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23269635
- Qin, H. (2026). Conditions (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 4) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23270922
- Qin, H. (2026). What a University Is Not (SAE Theory of the University, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293733
- Qin, H. (2026). University Teaching (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293737
II · Rule texts
- Shanghai Municipal Education Commission. 2023. Work Plan for the All-Staff Tutor System for Primary and Secondary School Students in Shanghai (上海市中小学生全员导师制工作方案), Hujiaoweide [2023] No. 25. 2023-07-19.
- Japan. Act on Standards for Class Formation and Fixed Numbers of School Personnel in Public Compulsory Education Schools (公立義務教育諸学校の学級編制及び教職員定数の標準に関する法律), as amended in 2026 (Act No. 7 of Reiwa 8).
- Finland. Government Decree on Early Childhood Education and Care (Valtioneuvoston asetus varhaiskasvatuksesta) 753/2018, section 1; amending decree 1586/2019.
- Ministry of Education (China). 2016. Regulations on Kindergarten Work (幼儿园工作规程), Ministry of Education Order No. 39.
Interfaces
This series: XX6 to XX11.
Handed to Paper 3: beyond giving conditions, the school also exercises compulsion, in care, in teaching and in leaving room.
Handed to other papers: teachers' time counted in the workload, Paper 5 (XX22); gaps that go beyond one school, Paper 5 (XX24) and Paper 7 (XX31, XX32); "not blocking" and the gate of progression, Paper 6 (XX29).