Self-as-an-End
SAE Theory of the School · Paper 1

School Teaching
学校的教

Han Qin (秦汉) · Independent Researcher · 2026
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24382568 · Full PDF on Zenodo · CC BY 4.0
Abstract

Teaching is the thing a school does best: it can be designed, and it can be done for many at once. This paper asks where the school's teaching stops, and which step has to be left to the student himself. It states five propositions. Teaching can be designed by the school; the school ought to see to it that teaching reaches every child, a supply to be secured in the Base Layer; teaching does not by itself give understanding and checking, nor self-consciousness and ends. Some of what the school teaches students cannot check for the present, and they take it in first; the school's arrangements do not create or add to obstacles to checking, and do not set up the textbook or the teacher's word as a ground that cannot be refuted. The school's uniform pace, class hours and amount of homework do not take up beforehand the teacher's room to judge whether teaching is hurried or filled to the brim. For young children, situation and content are written in together; arrangements in a school that teach fear in along with the content are checked by what they actually wrote in. Tools the school adopts can enter teaching; the step of understanding and checking is still the student's to take. This paper does not say which method of teaching is best, and lays out no curriculum.

Writing Declaration: This paper was co-drafted with Claude (Anthropic). All intellectual decisions, framework design, and final editorial judgments were made by the author.

Introduction

Education as Subject-Condition says that teaching can be designed, planned and scaled: "a single teacher can teach thirty students mathematics simultaneously". This is the thing a school does best, and a thing it ought to do well. A child learning to read, write and count, learning a language, coming to know a stretch of history, may well have been taught all this at school, by one teacher in front of a roomful of children.

The same timetable that can lay teaching out in batches can also fill every stretch of time. In 2021 the General Office of China's Ministry of Education sent compulsory-education schools a notice on managing homework. One sentence reads: "schools are to ensure that no written homework is assigned in the first and second grades of primary school" (my translation; 学校要确保小学一二年级不布置书面家庭作业). For the other grades it set limits on the time written homework takes: in primary school, "on average no more than 60 minutes a day to complete written homework" (my translation; 每天书面作业完成时间平均不超过60分钟); in lower secondary school, "on average no more than 90 minutes" (my translation; 平均不超过90分钟). It also said: "assigning repetitive or punitive homework is strictly prohibited" (my translation; 严禁布置重复性、惩罚性作业). A rule had already drawn a line around children's time.

This paper is about that line. Where does the school's teaching stop; which step has to be left to the student himself?


§1 Teaching Can Be Designed by the School

What teaching is. Teaching is the transmission of knowledge, skills and predictive capacity. Teacher-Student Theory says: "Teaching is passing knowledge, skill and predictive capacity on to the student. What teaching reaches has two layers: remembering, and having learned; remembering does not of itself lead on to having learned. Understanding is not given directly by teaching: that step the student has to take himself, and what the teacher gives is conditions. Teaching can be designed, and can be done for many at once". That passage is about what lies between a teacher and a student. Brought to the level of the school, both its halves still hold. Teaching can be designed by the school: what to teach, in what order, with what materials, how a whole grade is laid out. Teaching can also be done for many at once: one textbook, one timetable, one classroom.

Reaching every child. Of the school's four things in the Base Layer, teaching is one. So the school's teaching is not merely offered; it is to reach every child. This has two senses. One: where a class has been held and some child did not receive it, the school cannot close the account with "the lesson has been given"; Paper 7 writes who carries this securing. The other: reaching every child is not reckoned by one kind of child. Some children sign; some need another form before they can receive the same content. Whether a child received it, and how that is checked, is left to the measure the Theory of Fairness sets; this series does not set up another.

What teaching cannot give. What teaching gives has two layers, remembering and having learned, and remembering does not of itself lead on to having learned. Teaching does not by itself give understanding and checking: that step the student has to take himself. Nor does teaching give self-consciousness and ends: he has to chisel those out himself. For both, what the school can give is conditions; Paper 2 writes them.

Not against knowledge, not against tests. This paper does not argue for teaching less. One position holds that the school's first accountability is to teach children knowledge systematically; leaving room, questioning and "letting children explore for themselves" crowd knowledge out, and those who lose most are the children whose homes cannot give them this knowledge.1 The position has weight. Knowledge is not the enemy of judgment but its material; what a child never learned he can never check later. This series agrees that teaching is the thing a school does best and most ought to do well. "Reaching every child" is exactly what the Base Layer requires of teaching; what a home cannot give, the school has all the more to give. Granting that weight, two boundaries still hold. Knowledge does not thereby become the whole of the school. And a uniform pace does not take up beforehand the teacher's room to judge whether this child can take this in now. Tests are the same: testing is a necessary tool; what this series aims at is taking what can be measured for the whole (Paper 6).

XX1 Teaching can be designed by the school. Teaching, the transmission of knowledge, skills and predictive capacity, can be designed and can be done for many at once. The school ought to see to it that teaching reaches every child: it is one of the supplies to be secured in the Base Layer. Teaching does not by itself give understanding and checking, nor does it give self-consciousness and ends.


§2 Taking In First, Checking Later, at the Level of the School

Taking in first. Some of what the school teaches students cannot check for the present. A ten-year-old learns that the earth goes round the sun; he cannot test it himself. He takes it in first. Teacher-Student Theory says: "Taking in first, checking later. Some of what is taught the student cannot check for the present, and he takes it in first." It also says: "Taking in is not holding it to be true, nor avowing it as his own." To take in is first to enter what he remembers and what he has learned. What has not been checked is not thereby counted as held to be true, or as avowed as his own; when he has the ability later, he goes back and looks.

Arrangements at the level of the school. Teacher-Student Theory reads the teacher's end: whether the teacher created or added to obstacles to checking. This paper extends that to the level of the school. The school holds and arranges certain conditions: how the textbook is used, how the pace is laid out, whether sources can be traced, whether the road for going back to check later is left open. Because it holds these conditions, it answers for them. In particular, four things:

  • The school's arrangements do not set up "what the textbook says" or "what the teacher said" as a ground that cannot be refuted. A textbook can be an authority; authority and irrefutability are two things.
  • Reasons, sources and ways of testing are given where students can reach them. Not everything has to be tested on the spot; the road for testing has to be set out.
  • The road for going back to check later is left open. Teacher-Student Theory says: "Not yet having the ability to check does not count as the teacher's having sealed the path; 'left open' requires particular conditions, not a sentence like 'you'll understand when you're older.'"
  • What goes into the textbook may be determined elsewhere, by the position that sets textbooks. For that share, the position that sets textbooks answers; the school answers for how it uses the textbook: whether it has set it up as a ground that cannot be refuted.

Two entries, kept apart. When a student cannot check something for the present, there may be two reasons, and they are entered separately. One is the original gap: he is young, and has not yet learned the things he would need to test it. On this alone, nothing can be judged about the school's direction. The other is the school's arrangements: the textbook gives no sources, the timetable leaves no time to go back, asking "why" is treated as talking back. That part is entered against the school. That the original gap is there does not excuse the school from giving the conditions it has already undertaken.

This is no argument for less guidance. One objection runs: full guidance teaches better than little guidance; better to explain things clearly than to send students off to grope on their own.2 The objection is aimed at teaching with no guidance or minimal guidance; this section is not about that. Setting out reasons, sources and ways of testing is itself a kind of guidance, and a strong one. What this section separates is the strength of guidance from whether things can be checked: the clearer the explanation the better, and once it has been explained clearly, his road for going back to check is still to be left open. This section is a norm, not an empirical claim that some method of teaching is more effective.

XX2 Taking in first, checking later, at the level of the school. Some of what the school teaches students cannot check for the present, and they take it in first. The school's arrangements do not create or add to obstacles to checking; they do not set up "what the textbook says" or "what the teacher said" as a ground that cannot be refuted; reasons, sources and ways of testing are given where students can reach them; the road for checking later is left open, and leaving it open requires particular conditions, not a sentence like "you'll understand when you're older." What the textbook says lies with the position that sets textbooks; the school answers for how it uses the textbook, and for whether it has set it up as a ground that cannot be refuted.


§3 Hurried, and Filled to the Brim

Two words. Between teacher and student, Teacher-Student Theory used two words. "'Hurried' means leaving no time for the passage from remembering to having learned: this thing is not yet learned, and the next is already being taught." "'Filled to the brim' means leaving no moments of stopping: his time is filled with new input, and the room for looking back is gone." It also says: "Hurried teaching, and teaching filled to the brim, are not the direction of cultivation".

Who judges. For a given student, whether this occasion counts as hurried or as filled to the brim Teacher-Student Theory leaves to the teacher: "For this one student, whether this occasion counts as hurried or as filled to the brim, and how to teach this time, is for the teacher's end to judge by this student's situation". The judgment is open to questioning, and "who supervises it, and how, belongs to the institutional side"; this series takes that up in Paper 5.

At the level of the school. That the teacher can judge presupposes room to judge in. A school's uniform pace, class hours and amount of homework can take up that room before the teacher judges anything. The whole grade sits a test on the same chapter on the same day; a child who has not learned this chapter starts the next one all the same; every lesson is laid out with input, and no stretch of the day is kept for looking back. However well the teacher judges then, the judgment has nowhere to go. So this section is about the school's arrangements: they do not take up beforehand the teacher's room to judge whether teaching is hurried or filled to the brim.

One way to do it is: set an upper limit on the time written homework takes; give no written homework to the first and second grades of primary school; keep a stretch in the timetable with no input laid out. The notice in the introduction is one way of writing the first two. Both sides need looking at. A rule that writes "filled to the brim" as a number has taken a step. But a ceiling is a number; on its own it does not prove that room for looking back has been left for any particular child. Less homework, and the time can still be filled with something else. These are forms, not evidence.

XX3 The school's arrangements do not make teaching hurried or filled to the brim. Hurried is leaving no time for the passage from remembering to having learned; filled to the brim is leaving no moments to stop and scrutinize. Whether it counts as hurried or filled to the brim for a given student is for the teacher to judge by him; the school's uniform pace, class hours and amount of homework do not take up beforehand the room for that judgment.


§4 The Direct-Write Window and the Kindergarten

The direct-write window. The Learning series put forward a structural hypothesis: when young children learn something, situation and content are written in together; a child does not yet have the ability to separate content from situation and scrutinize it, and can only take both in at once. The Learning series and Teacher-Student Theory call this stretch the direct-write window; it is not the window of cultivation spoken of in the Prequel. Teacher-Student Theory borrows the hypothesis and says: "In the stretch that is still within the direct-write window, situation and content are written in together when he is taught, and he can only take it in. The occasion on which fear is taught in along with the content is read by what it actually wrote in; it is not closed out on the strength of 'he learned it.'" It also states that "What this proposition borrows is the direct-write mode, kept within the limits the original paper sets". This paper uses it within the same limits: it is a hypothesis, and this paper does not vouch for it.

At the level of the school. Some arrangements in a school teach fear in along with the content: discipline that teaches by frightening, public humiliation, being made to stand for a wrong answer. A child who learned the multiplication table under such arrangements learned more than the multiplication table. What this section says is: such arrangements are checked by what they actually wrote in; "he learned it" cannot close that entry. How discipline itself is read is in Paper 3; this section writes only the face of what was written in during teaching.

The kindergarten. In the stretch of the kindergarten, the school's four things in the Base Layer weigh differently: care, and the conditions for play as the basic activity, are the main items; teaching is not. One way to do it is: the kindergarten takes play as its basic activity and does not teach primary-school lessons ahead of time; it organizes no subject-style tests or rankings for young children. The curriculum itself is at the rule layer; here there are only suggestions.

China's Preschool Education Law of 2024 wrote these things into law. The kindergarten is to take the life of preschool children as its basis and play as its basic activity; it may not use primary-school-style methods of education, and may not teach the curriculum of the primary stage; no unit or individual may organize preschool children to take part in competitions and similar activities that do not fit their age; organizing entrance examinations and teaching primary-school lessons are listed as unlawful conduct by a kindergarten. The clause on tests speaks first of entry: on admission, apart from the necessary physical examination, a kindergarten may not organize any form of examination or test. Whether it also governs tests during the kindergarten years can be read two ways on its face. Before the law, the Ministry of Education had in 2018 already listed, as tasks of a special campaign, the strict prohibition on teaching primary-school curriculum content and the correction of intensive drills in mechanical recitation, memorizing, copying and calculation.3 Both sides need looking at: these texts say what is prohibited; that the prohibitions held does not prove what children received in play.

XX4 What is written in within the direct-write window is checked by what was actually written in. In the stretch still within the direct-write window, situation and content are written in together, and he can only take it in. Arrangements in a school that teach fear in along with the content (discipline that teaches by frightening, public humiliation) are checked by what they actually wrote in, and are not closed out on the strength of "he learned it."


§5 When Tools Are Used

Tools can teach. A school can adopt teaching tools, AI included: a program can set exercises, mark them, explain, and push the next exercise according to where a child went wrong. Teaching could always be designed; tools make the design finer and faster. This section does not oppose them.

That step is still the student's to take. Tools can enter teaching; they do not take the step of understanding and checking for the student. Even if the answer a child hands in from a program is correct, that does not show that he has learned; however clearly the program explained, if he has not gone back and checked for himself, that step has still not been taken. The Theory of the University said a sentence of the same shape at the level of the university: "Tools can enter a judgment; they do not complete it for him, and the bearing is not handed over with them."

The school answers for its adoption. Adopting a tool is a decision of the school. It has to be able to say what it uses the tool to teach, and which step is left to the student. It does not take "a tool was used" to mean the child did not learn, nor "the program shows mastery" to mean he has learned.

A registration. Among its open questions Education as Subject-Condition asked: AI can teach, but can it nurture? This paper does not answer. It answers only a narrower matter: after a tool has been used, the step of understanding and checking is still the student's to take.

XX5 Tools can teach; they do not take that step for the student. Teaching tools the school adopts, AI included, can enter teaching; the step of understanding and checking is still the student's to take; the school answers for its adoption: what it uses the tool to teach, and which step is left to the student.


§6 Teaching in Three Stages

This section follows the axis of stages. It writes only the arrangements the school mainly handles at each stage, not what the child adds at that stage; that a matter is written at some stage does not mean it appears only there.

Kindergarten. What the school mainly handles here is the arrangement of play as the basic activity, and care. Not teaching primary-school lessons ahead of time is a matter for this stage's rules (§4).

Primary school. Written homework and the uniform pace are what this stage's rules mainly handle; the school-level arrangements behind hurried teaching and teaching filled to the brim are mostly written from here (§3). Education as Subject-Condition says that for children of eight to ten, as academic pressure mounts, "'the thing I cannot not do' is replaced by 'homework I cannot not do.'"

Secondary school. Separate subjects and the gate of progression are what this stage's rules mainly handle. How preparation for the gate takes up the time of teaching is written in Paper 6.

This section does not assign children to levels by grade. Grades are cut by institutions according to age; how far a child has got in a matter has to be seen in that matter.


Where This Paper Stops

What it has not done: it has not said which method of teaching is best; it has laid out no curriculum and judged no textbook right or wrong, since the curriculum is at the rule layer; it has not written how a teacher teaches in the classroom, which Teacher-Student Theory has read; it has not said that teaching less is better, nor that arranging things this way will produce better results; it has not answered whether AI can cultivate.


Notes

  1. For one statement of this position, see Hirsch (1996), The Schools We Need and Why We Don't Have Them. This paper has not gone back to the original and lists it only as a lead. ↩︎
  2. For one review-style statement of this objection, see Kirschner, Sweller and Clark (2006), "Why Minimal Guidance During Instruction Does Not Work." This paper has not gone back to the original and lists it only as a lead. ↩︎
  3. The contents of the Preschool Education Law and of the 2018 notice on the special campaign are given here in paraphrase, from reprinted copies. ↩︎

The Five Propositions of This Paper

XX1 Teaching can be designed by the school. Teaching, the transmission of knowledge, skills and predictive capacity, can be designed and can be done for many at once. The school ought to see to it that teaching reaches every child: it is one of the supplies to be secured in the Base Layer. Teaching does not by itself give understanding and checking, nor does it give self-consciousness and ends. (First sentence: descriptive. Middle sentence: normative, this series' stance that teaching lies in the Base Layer. Last sentence: conceptual distinction, taking over the threefold of Education as Subject-Condition and Teacher-Student Theory TS8)

XX2 Taking in first, checking later, at the level of the school. Some of what the school teaches students cannot check for the present, and they take it in first. The school's arrangements do not create or add to obstacles to checking; they do not set up "what the textbook says" or "what the teacher said" as a ground that cannot be refuted; reasons, sources and ways of testing are given where students can reach them; the road for checking later is left open, and leaving it open requires particular conditions, not a sentence like "you'll understand when you're older." What the textbook says lies with the position that sets textbooks; the school answers for how it uses the textbook, and for whether it has set it up as a ground that cannot be refuted. (Normative; Teacher-Student Theory TS9 and TS10, which speak of the teacher's end, extended to the school as a kind of construct, this series' own undertaking: the school answers for these conditions because it holds and arranges them)

XX3 The school's arrangements do not make teaching hurried or filled to the brim. Hurried is leaving no time for the passage from remembering to having learned; filled to the brim is leaving no moments to stop and scrutinize. Whether it counts as hurried or filled to the brim for a given student is for the teacher to judge by him; the school's uniform pace, class hours and amount of homework do not take up beforehand the room for that judgment. (Normative; the definitions of hurried and filled to the brim follow Teacher-Student Theory, Paper 2, §4; TS11, which speaks of the teacher's end, extended to the school, this series' own undertaking; same shape as Theory of the University DX7)

XX4 What is written in within the direct-write window is checked by what was actually written in. In the stretch still within the direct-write window, situation and content are written in together, and he can only take it in. Arrangements in a school that teach fear in along with the content (discipline that teaches by frightening, public humiliation) are checked by what they actually wrote in, and are not closed out on the strength of "he learned it." (Normative; Teacher-Student Theory TS12, which speaks of the teacher's end, extended to the school, this series' own undertaking; the direct-write mode is a structural hypothesis of the Learning series, used within the limits of the original paper)

XX5 Tools can teach; they do not take that step for the student. Teaching tools the school adopts, AI included, can enter teaching; the step of understanding and checking is still the student's to take; the school answers for its adoption: what it uses the tool to teach, and which step is left to the student. (Normative; Theory of the University DX4 and DX24, which speak of the university's judgment and evaluation, extended to teaching in the school, this series' own undertaking)


References

All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version.

I · This system

  • Qin, H. (2026). What a School Is Not (SAE Theory of the School, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24382559
  • Qin, H. (2026). Education as Subject-Condition: A Philosophy of Education [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18867389
  • Qin, H. (2026). The Place of Teacher-Student Theory (SAE Teacher-Student Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24267256
  • Qin, H. (2026). Teaching (SAE Teacher-Student Theory, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24267232
  • Qin, H. (2026). Learning Through Memory and Prediction: The Construction, Window, and Cost of 11DD and 12DD (SAE Learning Series, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19426123
  • Qin, H. (2026). What a University Is Not (SAE Theory of the University, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293733
  • Qin, H. (2026). University Teaching (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293737
  • Qin, H. (2026). University Evaluation (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293751

II · Rule texts

  • General Office of the Ministry of Education (China). 2021. Notice on Strengthening the Management of Homework in Compulsory Education Schools (关于加强义务教育学校作业管理的通知), Jiaojitinghan [2021] No. 13. 2021-04-08.
  • Preschool Education Law of the People's Republic of China (中华人民共和国学前教育法). Adopted 2024-11-08; in force 2025-06-01.
  • General Office of the Ministry of Education (China). 2018. Notice on Launching Special Action to Remedy the "Primary-Schooling" of Kindergartens (关于开展幼儿园"小学化"专项治理工作的通知), Jiaojitinghan [2018] No. 57. 2018-07-04.

Interfaces

This series: XX1 to XX5.

Handed to Paper 2: teaching can address thirty people; the thing that comes next can address only one.

Handed to other papers: discipline that teaches by frightening, and the sources of compulsion, Paper 3 (XX12, XX15); questioning of the teacher's judgment of hurried and filled to the brim, and the time taken up by homework, Paper 5 (XX22, XX23); "not against tests," Paper 6 (XX27); who secures teaching reaching every child, Paper 7 (XX31).