School Teachers
学校的老师
A teacher sits in a position at school and holds the accountabilities of teaching, care and evaluation. This paper states five propositions. Whether a teacher faces toward treating students as ends the school does not inspect and accept, and does not write into appointment and assessment; leading is not assessed. Education as Subject-Condition puts the core of reform in teachers; at the level of the school, that becomes giving conditions for teachers: their time is not filled up, their judgment has room, and the work of guidance and care that is needed is counted in the workload and not left to them to carry without limit. Common textbooks, lesson plans, pacing and marking rubrics can enter a teacher's judgment; they do not complete it. The teacher answers for his choices; the judgment is open to questioning, with a road of review not wholly controlled by himself. The number and quality of teachers are to be secured: the public side and the school keep separate accounts; quality is checked by what lies in the position, and students' scores are not registered as having replaced judgment of a teacher's work. Teachers too are among those cultivated. This paper does not write what a good teacher looks like, does not set teachers' pay, does not design teacher qualifications, and does not judge whether any particular teacher is in the direction.
Writing Declaration: This paper was co-drafted with Claude (Anthropic). All intellectual decisions, framework design, and final editorial judgments were made by the author.
Introduction
Education as Subject-Condition has a sentence: "The real reform is not about curriculum or exams but about the teaching force". It also weighed Finland's approach: fewer tests and more autonomy lightened the suppression of "everything measurable" and left space for the child's own stretch; yet at the institutional level it was still the framework built around what can be predicted and measured, only pressing more lightly. The core of reform, it said, is the teaching force.
The judgment of this series is that a society whose consensus includes "a human being is an end" is to secure its teachers. Secure what? This paper speaks of the share that lies at the level of the school: what it can do, and what it has to answer for.
England's School Teachers' Pay and Conditions Document, 2026 edition, sets out the working year of a full-time teacher to whom it applies: the teacher "must be available for work for 195 days"; directed time, in which the school may specify when and where the teacher works, is 1265 hours a year; planning and preparation time is "not less than 10% of the teacher's timetabled teaching time". Time has been written into rules. This paper asks whether a teacher's judgment has room, and who answers for that room.
§1 Direction Is Not Written into Appointment and Assessment
What the school can require. The school can require the teacher's position to teach, to look after and to evaluate: which courses to give, by when homework is to be marked, who is on duty at break, what comments are due at the end of term. These lie in the position. Institution Theory quotes How Is Institution Possible: "A construct may require a position to do something; it may not require a person to think something."
What the school does not inspect and accept. Whether, in one matter after another, a teacher faces toward treating this student as an end the school does not inspect and accept, and does not write into appointment and assessment. Of leading, Education as Subject-Condition says: "Leading is possible only by personal demonstration"; it is not registered as the accountability of any position, and it is not assessed. At the level of the university the Theory of the University said two things of the same shape: leading is neither a power of the teaching position nor its accountability; and the positions that set rules "do not write leading into the rules of appointment, promotion and course evaluation, and do not assess it."
The same direction on the relational side. Teacher-Student Theory, reading the relation between teacher and student, does not read this stretch either: "where someone who teaches a course only teaches the course well, it cannot be read which kind this is; it is not judged, nor is it within scope". The relational side cannot read it, so it does not judge; the school's side does not inspect and accept. The two point the same way, each for its own reason: on the relational side it cannot be read; on the school's side one cannot require a person to think something.
XX21 Direction is not written into appointment and assessment. The school may require the teacher's position to teach, to look after and to evaluate; it does not inspect and accept a teacher's facing toward treating students as ends, and does not assess leading.
§2 Giving Conditions for Teachers
Extended to the school. Education as Subject-Condition puts the core of reform in the teaching force. At the level of the school this sentence extends to: the school gives conditions for teachers. This extension is this series' own undertaking, and the reason is this: whether a teacher can teach, and whether he can cultivate or not, lies not only in him as a person but also in what the school has left him: time, room for judgment, and work that is not piled on without limit.
Which conditions. Teachers, and staff who deal with children directly, in childcare, the school clinic and the like, do not have their time filled up, and have room for judgment. The guidance of Paper 2, the care of Paper 3 and the answering of Paper 4 all take time; this work is counted in the workload and is not left to them to carry without limit. At the level of the university the Theory of the University said that the university provides time and resources in which advising can actually be carried out, and does not leave the needed work to those who carry it without limit. On a person's own side, Action Theory said: "Self-preservation rests first of all on this: one is also an end. It includes not cultivating to excess, and not wearing oneself out in a relationship one cannot cultivate." A teacher may judge so on his own side; what the school has to do on its side is not to place him in arrangements where he can only wear himself out.
Two sets of rules. The English document sets directed time at 1265 hours, with planning and preparation time not less than ten per cent of timetabled teaching time; these working-time provisions do not apply to head teachers, deputy head teachers and certain leadership posts. Two sides: the number of hours is written into the rules, and so is a block of time with no teaching; the document also has a provision on reasonable additional hours, so it is not read as capping all of a teacher's working hours; and a number of hours does not prove that his judgment has room.
Japan's Special Act for Education Public Service Personnel, Article 22, says: "education public service personnel must be given opportunities to receive training" (my translation; 教育公務員には、研修を受ける機会が与えられなければならない。). It also says: "teachers may, insofar as it does not interfere with their classes and with the approval of the head of their institution, leave their place of work to undertake training" (my translation; 教員は、授業に支障のない限り、本属長の承認を受けて、勤務場所を離れて研修を行うことができる。). One block of a teacher's time has been written as an opportunity for training. It does not prove autonomy in teaching in the general sense.
The Shanghai all-staff tutor plan read in Paper 2 wrote that every student is assigned a tutor, set a ceiling on the number under each tutor, and wrote performance and incentives as well; in the document as checked, no conversion of guidance into workload appears. A rule that counts the work of guidance and care in a teacher's workload, this paper has not yet found.
XX22 The school gives conditions for teachers. The school ought to see to it that teachers, and staff who deal with children directly (in childcare, the school clinic and the like), do not have their time filled up and have room for judgment; the work of guidance and care that is needed is counted in the workload, and is not left to them to carry without limit.
§3 Judgment Is Not Replaced, and Is Open to Questioning
Rules enter judgment. Common textbooks, lesson plans, pacing and marking rubrics can enter a teacher's judgment; they do not complete it. A marking rubric tells a teacher how to give marks; how many marks this essay gets is still his judgment. The teacher answers for his choices: why he taught this way, judged this way. At the level of the university the Theory of the University said a proposition of the same shape: a common syllabus, standard lesson plans and grading rubrics can enter the judgment of the teaching position; they do not complete it.
This judgment is open to questioning. Teacher-Student Theory says that for this one student, whether this occasion counts as hurried or as filled to the brim is for the teacher to judge by this student, and "This judgment is not made at will: it is open to questioning, and is not exempt from being looked at again because it comes from the teacher himself; who supervises it, and how, belongs to the institutional side." What the school has to give on its side is a road of review not wholly controlled by the teacher himself: students and parents can ask, someone answers, and answers to the matter (Paper 4); another teacher in the same school, or some place outside the school, can look at the judgment.
Neither end is cancelled. That judgment has room does not mean it is exempt from questioning; that judgment is questioned does not mean the questioning side judges. Where rules replace judgment, the teacher is left only to carry out; where the way to ask is controlled by the teacher alone, judgment is left only to the teacher himself. This section cancels neither end.
For this proposition this paper has not yet found a suitable rule text to show.
XX23 A teacher's judgment is not replaced by rules, and is open to questioning. Common textbooks, lesson plans, pacing and marking rubrics can enter a teacher's judgment; they do not complete it; the teacher answers for his choices; this judgment is open to questioning, and has a road of review not wholly controlled by himself.
§4 Number and Quality Are to Be Secured
Teaching staff are a supply of the Base Layer. Political Economy says: "the Base Layer is to be secured, the Emergence Layer supported". The school's teaching, care and giving of conditions all need people; whether there are teachers, how many, and whether they are qualified are matters of the Base Layer. Securing teaching staff is entered at three ends separately. The position that carries public securing answers for gaps beyond one school's authority and resources; the school answers for appointment, deployment and scheduling within its accountability and the resources at its disposal; neither one school nor an individual teacher covers it alone. Where it is unclear to which end a gap belongs, each of the two answers for its own stretch, and pointing to the other is not an answer.
China's Compulsory Education Law, Article 31, says: "people's governments at every level secure teachers' wages, benefits and social insurance" (my translation; 各级人民政府保障教师工资福利和社会保险待遇); and "the average wage level of teachers shall not be lower than the average wage level of local civil servants" (my translation; 教师的平均工资水平应当不低于当地公务员的平均工资水平。). The securing of teaching staff is written as a matter for the public side.1
What number is checked by. Number is checked by the people and time that three things require: teaching, care and questioning. Paper 2 said the ground of the student-to-teacher ratio is the time for questioning; the care of Paper 3 and the answering of Paper 4 also need people and time.
Quality is checked by what lies in the position. Whether he can teach; whether he can look after; whether evaluation can state its grounds; whether the questions and objections students raise about teaching, evaluation and handling are answered to the matter questioned. The last is checked by event, and not made into an indicator such as a response rate. Crossing the line is checked by event (Paper 3).
What is not inspected and accepted. Whether cultivation has been achieved, and whether a teacher faces some direction, are not objects of quality inspection and acceptance; this follows §1. The registered accountabilities, teaching, care, guidance, and explaining and answering for evaluation, are checked by their actual performance. Institution Theory said that being cultivated may not be made a result to be obtained by compulsion, while demands for task output, operational capability and particular actions are checked separately by accountability and by limit and violation. Taken together, the two sentences are the edge of this section.
Scores do not replace judgment. The school does not register students' scores as having replaced judgment of a teacher's work, nor use scores to exempt the evaluating position from explaining and answering. Institution Theory says: "Forms such as appraisal metrics, rankings and grades are signals, not criteria." At the level of the university the Theory of the University said a proposition of the same shape: evaluation does not turn judgment back into rules. What the school checks separately is whether it has itself given teachers conditions (§2).
Two sets of rules. China's 2020 Overall Plan for Deepening the Reform of Educational Evaluation in the New Era requires that schools and teachers not be assessed by progression rates, and that teachers and students not be rewarded with the results of the secondary-school and university entrance examinations as the standard.2 This is one way of writing that assessment and reward do not take progression rates and examination results as the standard; here only the structure of the half that concerns schools and teachers is taken. What the rule prohibits is taking them as the standard; how much was done is checked separately.
Colorado's SB22-070 of 2022: the summary of the bill on the state legislature's website says that from evaluations completed in the 2023-24 school year, "30% of a teacher's or principal's evaluation is based on the academic growth of students"; within that part, collective measures of growth at grade or school level may make up at most ten per cent of the total evaluation; there are separate quality standards for professional practice.3 This serves as a contrast: students' academic growth has been written as a statutory share of a teacher's evaluation. This paper takes only the structure "a share written into law." Whether it lets an indicator replace judgment of particular work has to be checked together with the other standards, the evidence and the procedure of evaluation, and is not judged by one figure of thirty per cent.
An objection. One line of argument holds teachers accountable by students' results: without a measure of outcomes, accountability is only words.4 Its force lies in this: "checking by what lies in the position" may turn into impressions no one can pin down, into favoritism, or into a school vouching for itself. This paper does not exclude students' learning performance as one of the materials of evaluation; the disagreement is over whether it can replace judgment of a teacher's particular work. How judgment of particular work keeps from going astray: it is checked by event, each with grounds that can be stated; the evaluating position is itself open to questioning, with a road of review it does not alone control (§3); whether the school gave conditions is checked at the same time. The cost has to be stated too: checking by event takes longer than reading one score, and that time is counted in the workload of the evaluating side.
One way to do it is: students' learning performance serves as one of the materials of evaluation; how much it counts for, and how it is reviewed, are set at the rule layer.
XX24 The number and quality of teachers are to be secured. Teaching staff are a supply of the Base Layer. In securing it, three ends are entered separately: the position that carries public securing answers for gaps beyond one school's authority and resources; the school answers for appointment, deployment and scheduling within its accountability and the resources at its disposal; neither one school nor an individual teacher covers it alone; where it is unclear to which end a gap belongs, each of the two answers for its own stretch, and pointing to the other is not an answer. Number is checked by the people and time that teaching, care and questioning require. Quality is checked by what lies in the position: whether he can teach, whether he can look after, whether evaluation can state its grounds, whether questions and objections students raise about teaching, evaluation and handling are answered to the matter questioned (checked by event, not made into an indicator such as a response rate); crossing the line is checked by event. Whether cultivation has been achieved, and whether a teacher faces some direction, are not objects of quality inspection and acceptance; the registered accountabilities of teaching, care, guidance, and explaining and answering for evaluation are checked by their actual performance. Students' scores are not registered as having replaced judgment of a teacher's work, nor used to exempt the evaluating position from explaining and answering. What the school checks is whether it has given him conditions. Staff who deal with children directly (in childcare, the school clinic and the like) are treated the same way, each checked by the content of his own post.
§5 Teachers Too Are Among Those Cultivated
The school gives conditions for the people within it, and teachers are among them. Action Theory says: "The one who cultivates can also be cultivated; the two sides are not fixed as giver and receiver." Teacher-Student Theory says that there is mutual chiseling between teacher and student too: "Mutual chiseling is judged by process, not by identity"; where a student chisels something open in a teacher, it is read by that process. The Theory of the University said something of the same shape about university advisors.
At the level of the school, this means that teachers themselves also need conditions to be questioned, to be chiseled open, to move forward: time for training, dealings among colleagues, a term not filled up by assessment. The Japanese article read in §2, which writes the opportunity for training into law, counts here as one way of writing it. Paper 7 of Teacher-Student Theory read the letter between the primary-school teacher Germain and Camus; it is pointed back to here, not read again.
XX25 Teachers too are among those cultivated. The school gives conditions for the people within it, teachers included: the one who cultivates can also be cultivated, and the two sides are not fixed as giver and receiver.
§6 Teachers in Three Stages
This section follows the axis of stages and writes only the arrangements the school mainly handles at each stage. That a matter is written at some stage does not mean it appears only there, nor is the stage used to judge where a particular child has got to.
Kindergarten. Childcare staff and teachers face children together, each checked by his own post; the workload of care is counted.
Primary school. Positions of the homeroom-teacher kind hold teaching, care and evaluation at once; how these are read apart follows Paper 3.
Secondary school. Subject teaching; how preparation for the next stage takes up teachers' time is written in Paper 6.
Where This Paper Stops
What it has not done: it has not written what a good teacher looks like; it has not set teachers' pay; it has not designed teacher qualifications; it has not judged whether any particular teacher is in the direction.
Notes
- The 2014 notice unifying staffing standards for primary and secondary schools in town and country, which gives the student-to-staff ratios used for setting establishment by stage, is known to this paper through secondary material; it has not gone back to the original and does not write it. ↩︎
- Paraphrased from a reprint of the full text released by Xinhua News Agency. ↩︎
- That this amendment lowered the share from one half is known from news reports; this paper has not gone back to the original legislative record. ↩︎
- This paper writes only the structure of this line of argument, and does not report any particular author's words. ↩︎
The Five Propositions of This Paper
XX21 Direction is not written into appointment and assessment. The school may require the teacher's position to teach, to look after and to evaluate; it does not inspect and accept a teacher's facing toward treating students as ends, and does not assess leading. (Normative; taking over How Is Institution Possible, §3.3, as quoted in Institution Theory, Paper 1; same shape as Theory of the University DX6 and DX36; Teacher-Student Theory TS1 points the same way on the relational side)
XX22 The school gives conditions for teachers. The school ought to see to it that teachers, and staff who deal with children directly (in childcare, the school clinic and the like), do not have their time filled up and have room for judgment; the work of guidance and care that is needed is counted in the workload, and is not left to them to carry without limit. (Normative; Education as Subject-Condition 5.4 and its sixth contribution, the last sentence of Theory of the University DX3, and Action Theory D23, extended to the school, this series' own undertaking)
XX23 A teacher's judgment is not replaced by rules, and is open to questioning. Common textbooks, lesson plans, pacing and marking rubrics can enter a teacher's judgment; they do not complete it; the teacher answers for his choices; this judgment is open to questioning, and has a road of review not wholly controlled by himself. (Normative; taking over Theory of the University DX7; taking up "who supervises it, and how," which Teacher-Student Theory TS11 hands to the institutional side)
XX24 The number and quality of teachers are to be secured. Teaching staff are a supply of the Base Layer. In securing it, three ends are entered separately: the position that carries public securing answers for gaps beyond one school's authority and resources; the school answers for appointment, deployment and scheduling within its accountability and the resources at its disposal; neither one school nor an individual teacher covers it alone; where it is unclear to which end a gap belongs, each of the two answers for its own stretch, and pointing to the other is not an answer. Number is checked by the people and time that teaching, care and questioning require. Quality is checked by what lies in the position: whether he can teach, whether he can look after, whether evaluation can state its grounds, whether questions and objections students raise about teaching, evaluation and handling are answered to the matter questioned (checked by event, not made into an indicator such as a response rate); crossing the line is checked by event. Whether cultivation has been achieved, and whether a teacher faces some direction, are not objects of quality inspection and acceptance; the registered accountabilities of teaching, care, guidance, and explaining and answering for evaluation are checked by their actual performance. Students' scores are not registered as having replaced judgment of a teacher's work, nor used to exempt the evaluating position from explaining and answering. What the school checks is whether it has given him conditions. Staff who deal with children directly (in childcare, the school clinic and the like) are treated the same way, each checked by the content of his own post. (Normative; this series' stance; taking over Political Economy E35, extended to teaching staff, this series' own undertaking; the sentence on scores takes over Theory of the University DX23 and Institution Theory Z13; the sentence on performance takes over Institution Theory Z5)
XX25 Teachers too are among those cultivated. The school gives conditions for the people within it, teachers included: the one who cultivates can also be cultivated, and the two sides are not fixed as giver and receiver. (Conceptual distinction and normative; taking over Action Theory D37 and Teacher-Student Theory TS31; same shape as the section on advisors in Theory of the University, Paper 7)
References
All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version.
I · This system
- Qin, H. (2026). School Cultivation (SAE Theory of the School, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24382571
- Qin, H. (2026). Education as Subject-Condition: A Philosophy of Education [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18867389
- Qin, H. (2026). The Place of Teacher-Student Theory (SAE Teacher-Student Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24267256
- Qin, H. (2026). Can and Cannot (SAE Action Theory, Paper 4) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22970769
- Qin, H. (2026). Not Legislating for Others (SAE Action Theory, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22970777
- Qin, H. (2026). To Whom the Ought Is Addressed (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23269635
- Qin, H. (2026). Not Crossing the Line (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23270384
- Qin, H. (2026). Support (SAE Political Economy, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874154
- Qin, H. (2026). University Teaching (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293737
- Qin, H. (2026). University Evaluation (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293751
- Qin, H. (2026). University Governance (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 7) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293757
II · Rule texts
- England. Department for Education. School Teachers' Pay and Conditions Document 2026, paras. 52.2, 52.4, 52.5, 53.4.
- Japan. Special Act for Education Public Service Personnel (教育公務員特例法), Article 22.
- Compulsory Education Law of the People's Republic of China (中华人民共和国义务教育法), as amended for the second time in 2018, Article 31.
- Central Committee of the Communist Party of China and the State Council. 2020. Overall Plan for Deepening the Reform of Educational Evaluation in the New Era (深化新时代教育评价改革总体方案). 2020-10-13.
- Colorado. SB22-070. Signed 2022-05-24.
- Shanghai Municipal Education Commission. 2023. Work Plan for the All-Staff Tutor System for Primary and Secondary School Students in Shanghai (上海市中小学生全员导师制工作方案), Hujiaoweide [2023] No. 25.
Interfaces
This series: XX21 to XX25.
Handed to Paper 6: the evaluation in a teacher's hands is also a kind of power.
Handed to other papers: gaps on the public side among the three ends, Paper 7 (XX31, XX32); how preparation for the next stage takes up the school's time, Paper 6 (XX29); leaving room for leading, Paper 8 (XX38).