Self-as-an-End
SAE Propagation of Cultivation · Paper 3

The Propagation of Cultivation: Breaking
涵育的传播:打断

Han Qin (秦汉) · Independent Researcher · 2026
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24351765 · Full PDF on Zenodo · CC BY 4.0
Abstract

The previous paper read how a practice headed toward colonization passes downstream. This paper reads how it stops with one person: breaking. Breaking has two sides, both in the first person. The receiving side is not letting what lands on me occupy the place of my own judgment. The giving side is not colonizing others, whether by pouring in the same thing or its opposite. Merely having no occasion, pausing for a while, or switching to another way of managing people is not recorded as breaking on appearance alone.

The two sides need not arrive together: what took hold in a person may still be there while he no longer pours it into the next person. Not pouring in does not by itself mean being able to recognize the other. Their sources are read apart and do not exclude each other. The giving side is a choice a person makes when facing another person; declining to pass it on this time need not come from having been cultivated earlier. On the receiving side, where something has already taken hold, upstream writes that internal colonization cannot be broken from within alone; here conditions given by another person can be read. Either side may have conditions given by someone else, and on either side the step remains the person's own.

Breaking is not, in itself, cultivation; structurally it is read as a step in the 15DD direction. That is a reading of one operation and certifies nothing about which layer the whole person is at. On the receiving side there is no criterion guaranteed to close the question of how one knows that such a place in oneself has been occupied; the way of looking back can be mistaken, and no one else makes the judgment.

The paper uses one passage from Frederick Douglass's autobiography as historical material, reading his end only. It does not show that someone who has made such a break will go on to cultivate, does not say what kind of person someone is who has not, gives no method for breaking, and does not tell anyone what he ought to break.

Introduction

The example continues from the previous paper. On the sales team, Wei Heng sent Zhu Cheng's note back and said: "If the number looks bad, the person is no good." Two courses were stipulated.

On the second, Zhu Cheng said on the spot: "I don't accept that. A long cycle doesn't mean I'm no good."

On the first, she rewrote the note as "I didn't work hard enough," and from then on reckoned the week's number first whenever she looked at a client. The stipulation continues from there. A year later an intern joins and is assigned to her. In his first week the intern is at the bottom, and comes to her with the table in his hand. The line is on the tip of Zhu Cheng's tongue. She does not say it. She looks at the table for a while and says: "Come along with me for two weeks." In those two weeks she does not mention numbers. She herself, every Monday, still sees the table and still hears the line in her own head.

Now another place. Paper 1 said that Cheng Xi was assigned to Su Yao when he joined the company. Suppose that before this company he spent two years on the repair crew of another. The rule on that crew was: after a mistake, write a self-criticism first, and open it with "I was not responsible enough." That was not that company's policy; the crew chief set it himself. In his first month with Su Yao, Cheng Xi repairs something wrongly, writes the self-criticism that same night, and hands it to her the next day. She does not take it. She says: "No need for this. Tell me how you were judging at the time." He cannot; all he remembers is that he "wasn't careful enough." She says: "I'm not asking whether you were careful. What did you see, and why did you open that end first?"

She asks this way several times. Then Cheng Xi makes another mistake. This time he writes no self-criticism. He pulls the machine's log, goes through it himself, and tells Su Yao the next day: "I read the self-test error the wrong way round. For this kind of error I'll check the manual first from now on." Su Yao asks: "And the self-criticism?" He says: "I misread one error code. Whether I'm responsible enough is a separate matter."

Several things here need to be read apart. Is Zhu Cheng's refusing on the spot, on the second course, the same thing as her not saying the line a year later, on the first? With the line still occupying her, can she decline to say it to the intern first? If she does not say it, is she already cultivating the intern? When Cheng Xi stops writing self-criticisms, whose step is that, and what is Su Yao's part in it? And Zhu Cheng, hearing the line in her head every Monday: how would she herself know whether it is hers?

What this paper reads. The series is against the propagation of colonization, and "against" rests on two things in the first person: not letting it occupy me, and not doing it to others. Together these two are what the series calls breaking: a practice headed toward colonization stops with this person. Five things are read: the two sides of breaking; that they need not arrive together; the source of each; how breaking stands to cultivation, and whether it counts as heading in the 15DD direction; and how the receiving side would know.

Stance. From beginning to end this paper reads in the first person: what is read is how things stand at a person's own end. It does not tell anyone "you have been occupied," and does not say what anyone ought to break.

Stipulations. What has taken hold in whom is stipulated by the example. Two further stipulations: when Zhu Cheng did not say the line, she withdrew the step of defining the intern for him, and did not merely put it off; and Cheng Xi separated "I misread this one" from "whether I am any good." The sections below make explicit that what can be seen from outside does not by itself deliver either of these.

Shared words. Breaking in this series means the two sides just named. An upstream paper writes of "breaking intergenerational transmission," where breaking falls within a conflict: choosing, for the first time, not to colonize and not to withdraw recognition of the other;1 the two usages connect but are not the same, and §4 tells them apart. Taking hold is used as in the previous paper.

§1 Two Sides

CB13 Breaking has two sides, both in the first person: not letting what lands on me occupy the place of my own judgment; and not colonizing others, whether by pouring in the same thing or its opposite. Merely having no occasion, pausing for a while, or switching to another way of managing people is not recorded as breaking on appearance alone

The receiving side

The receiving side is not letting what lands on me occupy the place of my own judgment. It has two forms, which need telling apart. The proposition's wording covers both: in the first, it is kept from landing; in the second, what already occupies is kept from going on occupying.

The first form is refusal before it takes hold. On the second course Wei Heng's line comes across and Zhu Cheng says, "I don't accept that." The line does not land. Her own reading, "a long cycle doesn't mean I'm no good," is still in her hands.

The second form is loosening after it has taken hold. By the time Cheng Xi came to Su Yao, "a mistake means I was not responsible enough" was already in him: he made a mistake and, unasked, wrote the self-criticism that night. Later he stops writing them, goes to the log first, and says that misreading one error code and being up to the job are separate matters. As the example stipulates, a place that had been occupied has loosened in this matter.

That he stopped writing self-criticisms and turned to the log is not, on its own, enough to read this. A person can simply have found a more efficient way of meeting the old yardstick: fix it well, and that proves I am not someone who is no good. What is read is the separation he put into words, and that it landed with Su Yao. Whether the yardstick is still there in other matters is checked separately.

In both forms the same position is being read for whether it is open or sealed: in the domain "something happened; what does it say about what kind of person I am," can this person's own reading still come out? In refusal, the position was never occupied. In loosening, it was occupied and, in this matter, has opened again.

The giving side

The giving side is not colonizing others. On the first course, with the line on the tip of her tongue, Zhu Cheng does not say it to the intern; by stipulation she withdrew that step.

Not colonizing others rules out two things. One is pouring in the same thing: saying Wei Heng's line to the intern as it stands. The other is pouring in its opposite: as the previous paper said, suppose someone has had enough of all that and does the reverse, likewise fixing for the other what a matter can only mean and likewise leaving no place for the other to say otherwise; the direction is the same direction. So the giving side is not "not doing it in the same form." It is not pouring in.

Action Theory has two sentences that belong here. For a person who stands in the position of treating people as ends, two things cannot be cancelled toward anyone: "not legislating for him; not closing his ways to refuse, revise, exit and change course."2 And: cultivation may not happen; there is no time at which not colonizing does not apply.2 Those sentences are about someone already standing there. The giving side this series reads is the step by which a person, in one matter, arrives at those two things.

Not on appearance

Three situations also look, from outside, like "it did not go downstream," and are not recorded as breaking.

No occasion. If Zhu Cheng had never been given anyone to train, the line would not have left her, but not because she declined to do it.

A pause. Having the line on one's tongue and not saying it can be a withdrawal, and can be a postponement; from outside they cannot be told apart. Suppose that after the two weeks she says to the intern: "I gave you two weeks. Now look at your number and tell me yourself whether you're any good." Then those two weeks were only a pause.

Another way of managing. In the previous paper Wei Heng dropped the wall and the standing for a written note; the look changed and the line passed unchanged.

So what is read is still the position: on this occasion, did she fix for the other what the matter means for him, and did she leave a place for the other to say otherwise?

§2 The Two Sides Need Not Arrive Together

CB14 The two sides need not arrive together. What took hold in a person may still be there while he no longer pours it into the next person: the giving side can come first. Not pouring in does not by itself mean being able to recognize the other

The giving side first

On the first course, the receiving side has not arrived for Zhu Cheng: every Monday she sees the table and hears the line; she still does not pursue long-cycle clients. That line still holds sway over her judgment in this matter.

The giving side has arrived: she did not say it to the intern.

Both can be true at once. What took hold in a person may still be there while he no longer pours it into the next person. The series therefore does not make "clear out what is in yourself first" a condition of "not doing it to others." A person does not have to wait until his own place has loosened before he is entitled not to hand it on.

The reverse order occurs too. Cheng Xi's place loosened; whether he later trains anyone, and how, is another matter, which the example does not give.

Not pouring in does not by itself mean being able to recognize the other

Zhu Cheng did not say the line. She had nothing else to say either; what she said was, "Come along with me for two weeks." She did not ask the intern what had happened that week, and did not hear how he himself read the table.

Upstream describes a situation: a person whose own direction was never recognized does not know what recognizing another's direction would be; this is not malice but a structural lack.3 The passage goes on to say that he will colonize. This series does not adopt its tone that each ring necessarily produces the next: Zhu Cheng did not colonize the intern. But the other half still has to be faced: a person who did not pour in may still not know how to recognize. She had only that line in her hands; having put it down, her hands were empty.

So the proposition has two sentences: the giving side can come first; not pouring in does not by itself mean being able to recognize the other. The second is not a reproach. It is recorded as it is.

§3 The Sources of the Two Sides

CB15 The sources of the two sides are read apart, and do not exclude each other. The giving side is a choice a person makes when facing another person; declining to pass it on this time need not come from having been cultivated earlier. On the receiving side, where something has already taken hold, upstream writes that internal colonization cannot be broken from within alone; here conditions given by another person can be read. Either side may have conditions given by someone else, and on either side the step remains the person's own

The giving side: a choice

Zhu Cheng had the line on her tongue and did not say it. On the path being read, this step was not received from an earlier relation: Wei Heng never treated her that way, nor did Lao Guo. What she received in other relations the example does not say, and this paper does not say either.

The upstream paper on breaking intergenerational transmission describes exactly this shape: what is needed is one person who, facing another, chooses for the first time not to colonize; that first time need not be a mature state, only the entry.1 It is a choice. It need not be preceded by an act of cultivation.

Paper 1 said a chain has a starting point. This is the same thing seen from the other side: declining to pass it on this time need not come from having been cultivated earlier.

That is not to say it can do without dealings with people. Zhu Cheng did not say the line while facing the intern; without the intern standing in front of her with the table, there would have been no such occasion. The source lies in actual dealings; it need not lie in an occasion of "being cultivated."

Need not; it still can. The giving side, too, may have conditions given by someone else: in Paper 5, Zhu Cheng later sees how another team lead puts a question to the person at the bottom. The two sides are read apart; they are not two mutually exclusive sets of sources.

The receiving side: not from within alone

On the receiving side, the two forms from §1 have to be kept apart.

In refusal, the line has not yet taken hold. On the second course Zhu Cheng pushed it back with the reading she had in her own hands.

In loosening, the place has already been occupied. A foundation paper has a finding here: "Internal colonization cannot be broken from within alone." The reason is structural: "when the subject's self-understanding framework has been deeply permeated by systemic logic, the tools available for self-reflection have already been colonized."4 The yardstick Cheng Xi uses to think "where did I go wrong" is "I was not responsible enough." Measure with that yardstick and the result is the same sentence. That paper says a turn of this kind therefore "typically requires an external perspective from the relational layer": a person who stands outside his existing framework.5

For Cheng Xi that person is Su Yao. She did not take the self-criticism. Her question, "what did you see at the time," does not lie on his old yardstick. That paper lists three conditions under which such an intervention holds: the relation has enough depth, the other is treated as an end, the view is a different one.6 The second is drawn finely: what is recognized is this person's standing as an end, not how well he does. The example carries a stipulation on this point: Su Yao does not ask whether he repaired it well; she asks how he was judging; and what Cheng Xi later separates is exactly these two.

Whether all three conditions hold in this example is not checked here item by item. So the reading goes only this far: Su Yao gave a condition; under that condition the old self-criticism no longer has sole possession of the account of this mistake, and Cheng Xi can state a specific judgment of his own.

The step remains his own

That a condition given by another person can be read does not mean the step was taken by the other person.

Su Yao asked several times. The one who did not write the self-criticism and went to the log was Cheng Xi. No one required him not to write it that time; "I read the self-test error the wrong way round" is something he worked out himself, and "whether I'm responsible enough is a separate matter" is something he said himself. Action Theory writes: "What a person gains from others, once avowed by his own law, is his; those who provided the conditions do not thereby become the ones who completed that step for him."7

Another upstream paper, writing about the household, says that what breaking takes is not a better technique but the person's facing his own cannot-not again.8 It speaks of parents; only the shape is taken here. What Cheng Xi came to face was how he himself looks at a machine, something he cannot set aside. Where the yardstick loosened is where his own judgment came back out.

At this point Papers 3 and 4 join. The condition read on the receiving side can itself be an act of cultivation. What Su Yao did for Cheng Xi on those occasions is read in Paper 4 as cultivation carried out; it is at the same time the condition under which his place loosened. Breaking and a link are here two readings of one stretch of dealings.

§4 A Step in the 15DD Direction

CB16 Breaking is not, in itself, cultivation; structurally it is read as a step in the 15DD direction. The breaking that upstream describes falls within a conflict: choosing, for the first time, not to colonize and not to withdraw recognition of the other; it requires only the entry, not maturity. Breaking in this series is further divided into a receiving side and a giving side, with direction read by one operation at a time; no single instance of declining to repeat certifies which layer the whole person is at. His own end is for him to confirm

Not yet cultivation

Zhu Cheng did not say the line to the intern. She did not colonize him. She did not cultivate him either: her act did not open conditions for him to form, avow and revise a judgment of his own; she merely did not seal them.

Cultivation Theory reads a stance it calls respectful but indifferent: recognizing that the other's law is his, and therefore leaving it alone. It writes that "the series does not criticize someone who is not standing here."9 Zhu Cheng's act on this occasion can fall in that box. This series does not criticize it, and does not record it as cultivation.

So the proposition begins: breaking is not, in itself, cultivation.

A step

Structurally it is read as a step in the 15DD direction.

15DD is recognizing the other as an end too. Zhu Cheng had the line on her tongue and did not say it; by stipulation she withdrew the step of defining the intern for him. What she did is one of the two things Action Theory says cannot be cancelled: not legislating for the other.2 A person who does only that can fall in the box of respectful but indifferent just mentioned, which Cultivation Theory describes as not standing here. So this paper says only: it is a step in that direction. It does not say she already stands there.

The two usages of "breaking" have to be told apart. Upstream, breaking falls within a conflict: my direction and yours clash, I could withhold recognition, and I choose not to withdraw it. It is positive; it is the first real act of recognition. Breaking in this series is wider: it has a receiving side and a giving side, and on the giving side there was no clash of two directions between Zhu Cheng and the intern; she simply did not hand the line across. So this paper does not say Zhu Cheng has arrived at the entry upstream speaks of; it says only that this operation of hers heads that way.

No certifying of layers

This is a reading of one operation. It does not certify which layer Zhu Cheng as a whole person is at.

The upstream paper on positive-sum holds that such readings do not "certify who is at which layer."10 The layer is recorded by a single operation: this time she did not say it; next time the intern is at the bottom, she may. Nor is this occasion used to infer backward: it is not said that she "really always was" some kind of person.

Her own end is for her to confirm. What can be read from outside is what she said and did not say on that occasion, and whether the intern's position is open or sealed. Why she did not say it, and what she holds in her own mind, are not read.

§5 No Criterion Guaranteed to Close

CB17 On the receiving side, there is no criterion guaranteed to close the question of how one knows that such a place in oneself has been occupied. The way of looking back follows Aesthetics Ray 13: try taking away the yardstick that person gave; this can be mistaken. No one else makes the judgment for him

How she herself would know

On the first course Zhu Cheng sees the table every Monday and hears the line: if the number looks bad, the person is no good. Was that given to her by Wei Heng, or has she avowed it as her own? A line that came from outside is the person's own once avowed by his own law;7 so "it came from Wei Heng" does not answer the question.

The Conflict Treatise is direct on the same question: whether this is a revision I endorse or I have been colonized is for the subject himself to judge, by his own judgment; no criterion guaranteed to close the question is given, and the subject can judge wrongly.11 That paper separates three levels: there are clues; there is no final criterion guaranteed to close; and there are traces visible from outside.12

This series writes accordingly: on the receiving side, there is no criterion guaranteed to close the question of how one knows that such a place in oneself has been occupied.

A way of looking back

No criterion does not mean no way. One of the Aesthetics papers has a way of looking back: try taking away the yardstick that person gave; away from that person, do you still hold that this is yours, and can you change it yourself?13

Zhu Cheng can try it. Suppose Wei Heng is transferred and the table is gone: when she looks at a long-cycle client, does she still reckon the week's number first? Can she change the line, say to "the week's number says something about the week"? What she can change can be hers. What sends her into a panic at a touch, what she cannot put down and cannot say why, can be what is occupying her.

The same paper adds at once that this is a looking-back after the fact, not a criterion, and can be mistaken.13 So the method only supports or weakens her own judgment; it does not make the judgment for her.

Cheng Xi's occasion can be read as one such looking-back. He wrote no self-criticism and went to the log first: away from that crew chief, he did not follow "write a self-criticism first," and changed it to "check the manual first." That is a clue. It does not guarantee the place is gone for good.

No one else judges for him

What the third person can read is whether positions are open or sealed: whether his denial can land, whether his restatement was voided in advance.14 What cannot be read is what he really holds.

So no one else makes the judgment for him. Su Yao did not say to Cheng Xi, "your last crew ruined you." She did something else: she declined the self-criticism and asked a different question. She gave a condition and passed no verdict. The Conflict Treatise says that using those clues to check whether the other's own account is true is legislating for him.12

This is also the ground of the series' refusal to pin labels on people. To say that a person "has been colonized" is to complete for him a judgment that only his own end can confirm. What can be read is written out: which domain, which period, how which position stands. What cannot be read stays undetermined.

§6 Historical Material: Douglass Writes "I Was Growing"

In Life and Times, Frederick Douglass writes about his first months as a lecturer for an anti-slavery society. When he was invited to lecture, he was less than three years out of slavery. For the first three or four months his speeches were almost entirely the story of his own life as a slave. The audiences said: give us the facts. The friends who travelled with him asked the same; one of them told him: give us the facts, we will take care of the philosophy. Here, he writes, an embarrassment arose: he could not go on telling the same story month after month; and he could not always hold back his indignation at the wrongs of slavery long enough to go once more through a detailed account of facts he thought his hearers already knew. He adds a sentence: besides, he was growing, and needed room. Someone else warned him that if he kept on this way people would not believe he had ever been a slave.15

Only how he wrote it is read here, and only his end. Those pieces of advice divided what he might say into two parts: the facts were his, the reasoning was someone else's. What he sets down is this: for the first three or four months he spoke that way; later he did not go on treating that division as the rule of his own speaking, and he writes that he was growing and needed room.

How he first took up that division, and from what day he stopped speaking by it, the passage does not say in detail. So it is not assigned here to either form in §1, refusal before it takes hold or loosening after it has taken hold. What can be read is one appearance of the receiving side: later, he did not go on confining his own speech by that division.

The people on the other side are not judged here. The material was written by him alone; which way their advice was headed, and how it stood with other people, cannot be read from this passage. The series' rule for historical material is: nothing is filled in on anyone's behalf, no one is rated, and no faction within a movement is assigned a direction.

§7 Drawing Together, and Downstream

This paper has set out five propositions. Together they say: breaking has two sides, both in the first person; the receiving side is not letting what lands on me occupy the place of my own judgment, and the giving side is not colonizing others, by the same thing or its opposite; no occasion, a pause, or another way of managing is not recorded as breaking on appearance alone. The two sides need not arrive together, and the giving side can come first; not pouring in does not by itself mean being able to recognize the other. Their sources are read apart and do not exclude each other: the giving side is a choice, and declining to pass it on this time need not come from having been cultivated earlier; on the receiving side, what has already taken hold cannot be broken from within alone, and here conditions given by another person can be read; either side may have conditions given by someone else, and on either side the step remains the person's own. Breaking is not, in itself, cultivation; structurally it is read as a step in the 15DD direction, a reading of one operation that certifies nothing about the whole person. On the receiving side there is no criterion guaranteed to close; looking back can be mistaken, and no one else judges for him.

The paper does not show that someone who has made such a break will go on to cultivate, does not say what kind of person someone is who has not, gives no method for breaking, and does not tell anyone what he ought to break.

What the next paper reads. Su Yao declined the self-criticism and asked, "What did you see at the time?" How did she become someone who could ask that? Fang Yan taught her; she was willing to receive, and changed one of his steps. Is being willing to receive the same as taking everything as given? When she later trains Cheng Xi, at what point does it count as carried out? And whether she trains him or not, does she owe anyone?

Downstream. Being willing to receive, judgment opening up, going on to give: Paper 4. What the person who did not pour in, and whose hands were empty, later saw: Paper 5.

Acknowledgments

This paper is signed by Han Qin alone; the author decided every argument and choice and bears sole responsibility for the text. In drafting, the author used AI models from various developers as tools. The English edition is an independent rewrite of the Chinese text, not a translation; where the two differ, the Chinese governs.

Notes

  1. Terrible Telos, §4.3. The original speaks of generations; this series reads between adults, cites it as it stands, and does not turn it into a criterion. ↩︎
  2. Action Theory D35: "Two things still cannot be cancelled: not legislating for him; not closing his ways to refuse, revise, exit and change course." The sentence on not colonizing is from the body text of Action Theory, Paper 6. ↩︎
  3. Terrible Telos, §3.5. The original speaks of raising the next generation; this series does not adopt its tone of necessity. ↩︎
  4. Foundation Paper 2. The original speaks of systemic logic permeating a subject's framework of self-understanding; applying it to what one crew chief's line has come to occupy in one person is this series' extension. ↩︎
  5. Foundation Paper 2, the same passage. ↩︎
  6. Foundation Paper 2: depth at the emergent layer, recognition of standing as an end, an outside and different view. ↩︎
  7. Action Theory D36. ↩︎
  8. Terrible Teens, §4.3. ↩︎
  9. Cultivation Theory, Paper 2, Abstract: "the series does not criticize someone who is not standing here; standing here and cancelling this direction does not hold together." ↩︎
  10. Positive-Sum, Unsought, PS13. ↩︎
  11. The Conflict Treatise, §9. ↩︎
  12. The Conflict Treatise, §3. ↩︎
  13. Aesthetics, Ray 13. The published English of that paper says "ruler"; this series says yardstick throughout. ↩︎
  14. Value Theory, Paper 3, V35. ↩︎
  15. Douglass, Life and Times of Frederick Douglass (1881; enlarged 1892), Second Part, ch. III, "Introduced to the Abolitionists." Paraphrased from the Yale critical edition (The Frederick Douglass Papers, Series Two, vol. 3), pp. 169–170, and the Project Gutenberg text (eBook No. 71893). ↩︎

References

All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version.

I · SAE works directly cited in this paper

Qin, H. (2026). What Terrible Telos Actually Is: The Structural Genesis of Non Dubito [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19248039

Qin, H. (2026). What Terrible Teens Actually Is: The Structural Genesis of Purpose [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19201631

Qin, H. (2026). Internal Colonization and the Reconstruction of Subjecthood (SAE Foundation Papers, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18666588

Qin, H. (2026). Not Legislating for Others (SAE Action Theory, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22970777

Qin, H. (2026). Once Seen, No Going Back (SAE Cultivation Theory, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154504

Qin, H. (2026). Positive-Sum, Unsought (SAE Relation Theory, Special Paper) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24270580

Qin, H. (2026). How Subjecthood Is Not Swallowed by Conflict Itself (SAE Conflict Treatise) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22313628

Qin, H. (2026). The Beauty of Mutual Non Dubito (SAE Aesthetics, Ray 13) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23000910

Qin, H. (2026). On the Colonization of Value (SAE Value Theory, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21611154

II · External works

Douglass, F. (1892). Life and Times of Frederick Douglass, Written by Himself (enlarged ed.). Boston: De Wolfe & Fiske. (After The Frederick Douglass Papers, Series Two: Autobiographical Writings, vol. 3, New Haven: Yale University Press; and Project Gutenberg eBook No. 71893.)

A note on this source. External works are paraphrased here, not quoted. The paraphrases were made from the Chinese text of this paper and have not been checked word by word against published English editions or translations. The Douglass passage was read in a transcription of the Yale critical edition and in the 1892 edition as reproduced online, not in a printed copy. Corrections from readers are welcome.

Interfaces

Main upstream: Terrible Telos (§3.5, §4.3); Foundation Paper 2; the Conflict Treatise (§3, §9); Action Theory, Paper 6 (D35, D36).

Also used: Terrible Teens (§4.3, for its shape); Cultivation Theory, Paper 2 (Abstract); Positive-Sum, Unsought (PS13); Aesthetics, Ray 13; Value Theory, Paper 3 (V35).

This series: follows Paper 1, CB3 (a chain has a starting point), and Paper 2, CB10 to CB12. Paper 4 takes up how what Su Yao did for Cheng Xi is read as cultivation carried out; Paper 5 takes up what the person who did not pour in, and whose hands were empty, later saw.