Self-as-an-End
SAE Parent-Child Theory · Paper 1

Another End
另一个目的

Han Qin (秦汉) · Independent Researcher · 2026
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24121537 · Full PDF on Zenodo · CC BY 4.0
Abstract

This paper reads what the parent-child relation this series speaks of looks like. The series does not define all parent-child relations; the parent-child relation it reads has as its premise that the end of the father or the mother is headed in the 15DD direction: across one matter after another, headed toward treating the child as an end, and not merely as a means. This direction is a premise, not a component of the parent-child relation; the child never chose to enter this relation, and no further requirement is made here that both sides avow it. There is no parent who stands purely at 15DD; people are all mixed; the direction is read by one operation at a time, falling back is read as it occurs, and it does not overturn the direction. After falling back, this end can turn back: own up to that occasion, and make some change in the arrangements and dealings that follow; where there is persistent refusal to turn back, the direction is no longer at 15DD. Reflection is read from words and deeds, and is confirmed only at the parent's own end; it does not cancel what has already been read, nor does it leave the child owing forgiveness.

The series reads relation by relation: father and child are one relation, mother and child another, and a single parent is read the same way. The three kinds apply to a relation as a whole; they are not a sieve that lets each matter in or out of scope one by one. A relation headed toward treating the child as an end is within scope, and every matter within it is read; the relation that treats the child merely as a means, and the relation that does not treat him merely as a means yet is not headed toward treating him as an end either, are both relations that on the whole remain in the 14DD direction and are not headed toward 15DD (this says where a relation is headed; it does not grade a person), and neither is within the parent-child relation this series reads. In whichever kind, the occasion that crosses basic rights is, separately, a violation at the layer of basic rights. The child's standing as an end is full from the start; it is not conferred by the parents, nor revoked by them; what he can do grows, layer by layer, with his phase transitions. The two books are kept apart: "He's still little, he doesn't understand" at most describes what, in some matter, he cannot yet do. He never chose which conditions he first entered, and his own constitutive position does not on that account pass to the parents.

DD has two uses for parents and for the child: at the parent's end, 15DD is a stance; at the child's end, DD reads emergence and maturation, and does not become a label; the maturation of the first-person position is checked by content-domain, and the present operation is read separately. The object layer and the operation layer are kept apart: the parent confirms only his own end; if it is later confirmed that the direction premise of the relation being read did not obtain, the series does not unfold it as an object within scope, and does not turn and judge. This paper interfaces with Kant, Hegel and Locke. It does not prove that parents headed in the 15DD direction are better than other parents, nor that this is the only kind of parent-child relation, nor that parents ought to treat the child as an end.

Introduction

He Zhou had been learning the piano for a while and could play a few short pieces from beginning to end. One evening, several old classmates of his father, He Chuan, came to the house for dinner. After the meal someone asked what the children were learning, and He Chuan said: "Zhouzhou, go and play that piece for the uncles." He Zhou was lying on the floor putting together a model plane, and said he didn't want to play. He Chuan said it again, a little louder: "Just play the one you know, it'll only take a minute." He Zhou went and played; halfway through he hit two wrong notes, and when he finished he did not wait for anyone to speak, but went back to his room.

After the guests had left, his mother, Lin Wan, asked He Chuan: "When you made him play just now, who was that for?" He Chuan did not answer. The next morning, seeing He Zhou off at the door, he said: "Yesterday it was Dad wanting to show off in front of his classmates. You said you didn't want to play, and I still made you." He Zhou said "Mm," and nothing more. Later, when guests came again, He Chuan did not ask him to play.

That evening, He Zhou said he did not want to play, and in the end played anyway; the next day, He Chuan owned up to having wanted to show off, and to not having taken in He Zhou's refusal. He Zhou only made a sound in reply. Between that evening and the next morning there are several things to be read apart: what He Chuan took He Zhou to be that evening; what that sentence the next day was; whether, because of that evening, the relation between He Chuan and He Zhou turned into a different kind of relation; whether He Zhou's "I don't want to play" counts; and what the words "he's still little" can show.

What this paper reads. This series does not define all parent-child relations. What it reads is the parent-child relation whose premise is that the end of the father or the mother is headed in the 15DD direction. In SAE's levels, the layer at which the other is recognized as an end too is written 15DD. 15DD is non dubito: "it is not only I who am an end; the other, too, is an end in itself."1 A layer records one operation; it does not record a person, nor a parent-child relation.2

This paper reads seven things. First, the premise: why the end of the father or the mother, why the direction is a premise rather than a component, how falling back is read, and what turning back after falling back is. Second, reading relation by relation: father and child one relation, mother and child another. Third, the three kinds applied to a relation: the one within scope, and the two outside it. Fourth, the two books at the child's end: his standing as an end, and what he can do. Fifth, that the child never chose to enter this relation. Sixth, how DD is used for parents and for the child. Seventh, the object layer and the operation layer.

On each of these, the direction of colonization can be read. Colonization, in this series, names the direction of one effect: toward pouring in and occupying; the other direction is cultivation, toward making space. The two are not the two extremes of one scale; the same act can carry both directions, and can also carry no direction at all; the direction is read on this one effect, and whether it took hold is seen in the other party's later understanding and action.3 Violation is judged separately, and only at the layer of basic rights.4

Shared words. "The child" appears elsewhere in SAE too. The education paper, the two papers on the Terrible Twos and the Terrible Teens, and the Learning series read how a person grows and how he learns; the specialist study on rights and entitlements reads the several rights that coexist in an infant, and by whom they are held and by whom exercised.5 This series reads the side between the parent and the child: the dealings between person and person. Guardianship, the side of the family as a construct, and how the child's basic rights are protected and by what rules, belong to the institutional side; this series only registers them.6

"Direction" has three senses in this paper. To speak of the 15DD direction is to speak of where one is heading and has not yet arrived. To speak of treating the child as an end, or merely as a means, is the axis of scope: which way a relation is headed. To speak of the two directions of cultivation and colonization is another axis: whether one effect goes toward making space, or toward pouring in and occupying. The axis of scope borrows only the way the latter is read: a direction is not a label, and is read on this one effect. The two axes are not one: feeding him once, getting up once in the night to look in on him, can carry no direction of cultivation at all, and still be headed toward treating the child as an end.

"Coming of age" is not read in this series by the line of law; Paper 7 sets this out. Before that, "the child" means the person, still growing, with whom the parents have their dealings; when he counts as an adult in law, this series acknowledges but does not judge.

Method. As in Marriage Theory and Cooperation Theory: the conclusions of upstream papers are said in plain words; sources, the proposition numbers of other papers, and the places where upstream words are carried beyond their original place all go in the notes, and what is carried over is this series' own undertaking. What has already been said at the layer of relation is used here directly, and not rewritten.7 This paper speaks only of structure, not of good and bad, and issues no ought. What this series reads is how the end of the father or the mother acts; the child's development is read only as a condition of that end's acting, not as a study of developmental stages, and so the main text gives no particular ages.

A single family runs through the whole series: He Chuan, Lin Wan, and their child He Zhou. This is a made-up example, used only to see structure: in the example, that He Chuan and Lin Wan are headed in the 15DD direction is a premise set by the example; it writes their falling back, and also their turning back afterward. When the child appears, only what he says and does is written, and not what goes on inside him. From outside, a person's words and deeds are only clues; they do not certify who is at which layer.

§1 The Premise

PC1 This series does not define all parent-child relations. The parent-child relation it reads has as its premise that the end of the father or the mother is headed in the 15DD direction: across one matter after another, headed toward treating the child as an end, and not merely as a means. The 15DD direction is a premise, not a component of the parent-child relation; the child never chose to enter, and no further requirement is made here that both sides avow it. There is no parent who stands purely at 15DD; people are all mixed; the direction is read by one operation at a time, falling back is read as it occurs, and it does not overturn the direction; after falling back, this end can turn back, own up to that occasion, and make some change in the arrangements and dealings that follow; where there is persistent refusal to turn back, the direction is no longer at 15DD

This proposition marks out what the series reads. It says five things: it does not define all parent-child relations; the end of the father or the mother; a premise, not a component; the direction read by one operation at a time; turning back after falling back.

Not defining all parent-child relations

The parent-child relation is the first relation in a person's life, and it takes every shape. Some parents see the child as the continuation of the family line, some as the road they themselves did not finish, some simply raise him and think little more about it. The series does not adjudicate among these which is the true parent-child relation; it marks out a range and reads only one kind within it.

So when the series says that a relation is not within the parent-child relation it reads, it does not say that the relation is not a parent-child relation. To say "not within the parent-child relation this series reads" is to speak of the series' scope; to say "not a parent-child relation" would be to define the word, and to pass a verdict on that family besides. The series says the first, and not the second.

The end of the father or the mother

The parent-child relation this series reads has as its premise that the end of the father or the mother is headed in the 15DD direction. Two things in this sentence need saying: why the end of the father or the mother, and why a direction.

Why the end of the father or the mother. The marriage that Marriage Theory reads has as its premise that both parties are headed in this direction; the cooperation Cooperation Theory reads requires at least one party. Parent-Child Theory falls at the parents' end because the two ends of this relation do not start symmetrically: the parents already have laws of their own, and the child's law is still growing. Recognizing the child as an end too can, at the starting point of this relation, be spoken of only from the parents' end; how things stand at the child's end, §4 reads.

A single parent is read the same way. Where only the father or only the mother lives with the child, that relation is within the parent-child relation this series reads so long as that end is headed in the 15DD direction. In a two-parent household, too, the reading is relation by relation: He Chuan and He Zhou are one relation, Lin Wan and He Zhou another (§2).

Why a direction. There is no parent who stands purely at 15DD. People are all mixed: a person may, in this matter, recognize the child as an end too, in the next matter look out only for his own face, and in the one after that come back again.8 So what the series speaks of is not a state already arrived at, but which way one is headed: across one matter after another, headed toward treating the child as an end, and not merely as a means. This direction has no quantity; one cannot say what fraction of the way has been covered; nor does the series give parents a score.

A premise, not a component

Counting the 15DD direction as one of the components of the parent-child relation looks tidier: there is blood or adoption, there is care, there are dealings, and to these one adds a direction. The series does not count it that way. It first marks out which kind of parent-child relation it reads, and then, within that range, reads what structure this relation has.

The direction settles how the rest is read. At the end headed in the 15DD direction, the care given to the child is read as care given to an end, not as an investment in one's own future; the "no" the child says is read as a person's "no," not as a noise from something not yet properly adjusted. The direction lies beneath these, not alongside them. So the series does not argue that all parent-child relations are headed in this direction, nor that they ought to be; what it says is what this relation is like, and how it runs, when the end of the father or the mother is headed in this direction.

Here there is one difference from Cooperation Theory. The scope of Cooperation Theory requires, besides the direction, that both people avow this undertaking and actually take part. Parent-Child Theory makes no such further requirement: the child never chose to enter this relation (§4). This relation does not begin with both sides avowing it; it begins with one person arriving in another person's life.

The direction, read by one operation at a time

The direction is read by one operation at a time; falling back is read as it occurs, and it does not overturn the direction.9

That evening He Chuan made He Zhou play the piano in front of everyone. He Zhou said he did not want to play, and He Chuan repeated the demand; he made the demand in order to keep face in front of his classmates. In this one effect, He Chuan took He Zhou to be something that could be brought out and shown to people: in one operation, he treated the child merely as a means. This is a falling back.

Falling back is read as it occurs: it is material for the series, not an exception at the edge of scope. Nor does it overturn the direction: that evening does not turn the relation between He Chuan and He Zhou, from then on, into another kind of relation. To say that a relation is headed in the 15DD direction never meant that every matter within it is headed toward the end; it means which way that relation is headed.

Turning back after falling back

Then how many times can one fall back before it no longer counts as a direction? The series does not ask this, because this question yields no number. It looks at something else: after falling back, can this end turn back?

The next morning, He Chuan told He Zhou that the evening before it had been himself wanting to show off; He Zhou had said he did not want to play, and he had still made him. Later, when guests came again, he did not make He Zhou play. This is turning back: owning up to that occasion, and making some change in the arrangements and dealings that follow.10 Being able to turn back after falling back is what the 15DD direction looks like after a falling back. Where there is persistent refusal to turn back, the direction is no longer at 15DD, and that relation is not within the parent-child relation this series reads.

This sentence carries three qualifications.

First, reflection is read from words and deeds. Owning up and changing an arrangement are clues visible from outside; whether that sentence was a turning back is confirmed only at He Chuan's own end. From He Zhou's end, from Lin Wan's, from the reader's, what is seen is only what he said and what he did afterward. The series does not determine from outside, for real parents, whether they are headed in this direction; in the example, falling back and turning back are both written by the author.

Second, reflection does not cancel what has already been read. That evening was a falling back, and the words the next day do not make it not have happened. If that occasion had crossed basic rights, it would still be a violation after the turning back, and protection and disposition after the violation would be handed to the institutional side (§3). Nor, because the parent has turned back, does the child's end come to owe a share of forgiveness: He Zhou can say "Mm," can say nothing, can wait a long time before playing for anyone again. Turning back is the parent's own matter, and does not need the child to cooperate in closing the account.11

Third, "persistent" means continuing not to turn back, not "has not yet turned back." After a falling back, not yet having turned back for now does not on that account push that relation out of scope.

One sentence for the entrance. Taken together, the entrance to the parent-child relation this series reads can be put in one ordinary sentence: at least one father or mother, across one matter after another, is headed toward treating the child as an end; and having fallen back, can turn back. This sentence sums up the entrance; it is not an equivalent substitute for all the conditions of scope.

§2 Each Relation

PC2 Read relation by relation: father and child one relation, mother and child another; a single parent is read the same way. The relation headed in the 15DD direction is within scope; effects between the two relations are read by pairwise accounting, and the actual effect by which the other relation enters this one is entered in the instigator's relation

The father's relation, the mother's relation

A child has a father and also a mother, and the series does not read "the parents" as one person. He Chuan and He Zhou are one relation; Lin Wan and He Zhou are another. In one and the same matter, the direction can differ between the two relations: that evening He Chuan made He Zhou play the piano, and Lin Wan said nothing; later she asked He Chuan who it had been for. The piano, in He Chuan's relation, was a falling back; Lin Wan's question, in Lin Wan's relation, is read as her own one effect.

Dividing things this way follows the reading already established at the layer of relation: where three or more are involved, dealings that do not pass through an institution are broken down into effects between pairs and entered on separate accounts.12 A family of three is three relations: father and child, mother and child, father and mother.

A single parent

Song Lan lives on her own with her daughter Song Nian; here the relation between Song Lan and Song Nian is read first, by the same scope and written in the same way. The series does not read a single-parent household as lacking something; whether something is lacking is a matter of actual effects, one matter after another, and is not inferred from how many people are in the house.

Between the two relations

Reading the two relations apart does not mean they have nothing to do with each other. An effect in one relation can reach the child by way of the other: a sentence the father says to the mother, and something the mother then does to the child. Here it is read by pairwise accounting: the effect is entered in the instigator's relation, and passing through a third person does not release the instigator from his part.12 The actual effect by which the other relation enters this one is read by where it actually lands.

In a family where one end is headed in the 15DD direction and the other treats the child merely as a means, the reading is the same: the relation headed in the 15DD direction is read; the other is not within the parent-child relation this series reads, and is only registered; registering the other relation only does not mean that the conditions it creates for the child stay out of this paper; the actual effect by which it enters this relation is read by pairwise accounting. How the accounts are kept among several caregivers, Paper 6 reads.

The side between husband and wife

The relation between He Chuan and Lin Wan is that of husband and wife; the side of shared child-rearing between the two is read in Marriage Theory.13 The series reads only each person's relation with the child. An arrangement the two have set together is still read person by person once it reaches the child: in He Chuan's relation by He Chuan's end, in Lin Wan's relation by Lin Wan's end.

§3 The Three Kinds in a Relation

PC3 The three kinds apply to a relation as a whole: a relation headed toward treating the child as an end is within scope, every matter within it is read, and the matter that falls back is read by its own direction and does not exit scope; a relation that treats the child merely as a means is not within scope, and the direction of colonization is read out by the reading of "only as"; a relation that does not treat him merely as a means, yet is not headed toward treating him as an end either, is also not within scope, and is only registered; these two kinds are both relations that on the whole remain in the 14DD direction and are not headed toward 15DD. In whichever kind, the occasion that crosses basic rights is, separately, a violation at the layer of basic rights. Scope is not the whole definition of the parent-child relation: not being unfolded in this series is no denial that it is a parent-child relation

Applied to a relation, not to a matter

Applying the three kinds to matters one by one looks finer: this matter is headed toward the end, so it is within scope; that one treats him only as a means, so it is outside. But then the evening He Chuan made He Zhou play the piano would leave scope; every falling back would become a registration at the edge of scope, and what the series could read would be only those moments headed toward treating the child as an end.

The series does not divide things this way. The three kinds apply to a relation, as the premise of scope. When a relation is within scope, every matter in it is read; the matter that falls back is read out by its own direction: that evening, He Chuan's one effect was to treat He Zhou merely as a means, and the direction of colonization is read out; it is still within the relation between He Chuan and He Zhou, and is material of that relation.

The two kinds outside scope

Outside scope there are two kinds.

One is the relation that treats the child merely as a means. The child figures only as the continuation of the two, a link in continuing the line, a security for old age, or a condition for keeping the other party; to fall to "only as" is to treat the child only as a condition, and it carries the direction of colonization.14 "Only as" is read from the parents' arrangements, and a sentence is read by that sentence itself: a father who says "you raise a son to look after you in old age" has not, by that sentence alone, been read as "only as"; what would read it out is that, in his arrangements, the child is nothing apart from this one thing.

The other is distinguished at the object layer in this way: a relation that does not treat the child merely as a means, yet is not headed toward treating him as an end either. It is not within the parent-child relation this series reads, and is only registered. That the child lacks nothing to eat or wear and goes to school as usual is not enough to confirm these two conditions; nor can a relation be placed here because, beyond these arrangements, there is no further visible material.

These two kinds are both relations that on the whole remain in the 14DD direction and are not headed toward 15DD. "Remaining in the 14DD direction" says where this relation is headed; it does not grade a person; what a father is like in other matters, in other relations, this sentence does not say.

Violation is judged separately

Violation and the direction of colonization are two lines.4 In whichever kind, the occasion that crosses the child's basic rights is, separately, a violation at the layer of basic rights. A falling back in a relation within scope that crosses this line is likewise a violation; an effect in a relation outside scope that crosses this line is a violation too. Protection and disposition after the violation are handed to the institutional side; the series reads as far as "this is a violation" and the boundary crossed; what that effect left in these dealings is still read by this relation (Paper 2).

Scope is not a definition

Of the relation outside scope, the series writes "not within the parent-child relation this series reads"; the subject of this sentence is that relation, not that father or that mother. Not being unfolded in this series is no denial that it is a parent-child relation.

The middle kind is not a catch-all

The three kinds are a distinction at the object layer, stated conditionally: if a relation is like this, it is read like this. From outside, one cannot tell to which kind a relation in a real family belongs. Not seeing evidence that a father is headed in the 15DD direction is no ground for placing his relation in the middle kind; the middle kind is registered only where it can be read from the words or arrangements the person himself has left.

§4 Two Books

PC4 The child's standing as an end is full from the start; it is not conferred by the parents, nor revoked by them; what he can do grows, layer by layer, with his phase transitions. The two books are kept apart: "He's still little, he doesn't understand" at most describes what, in some matter, he cannot yet do; it does not lower his standing as an end, nor is it used to read his refusals uniformly as not yet understanding; nor, for the sake of recognizing the child, are the parents' own positions as subjects cancelled

Full from the start

On the day He Zhou was born he was already an end. This sentence does not wait for him to speak, to refuse, to make up his own mind. His standing as an end is grounded in his already being an end, not in what he will grow into.15 This standing is not conferred by the parents: it is not that he is an end because He Chuan and Lin Wan acknowledged him; nor is it revoked by them: should they one day treat him merely as a means, he would not be any less an end for it.16

This sentence is kept apart from what he can actually do. An infant cannot do without the people who care for him; this is true; and it does not give the caregivers the constitutive right over his value.17 Illness and injury can lower the bandwidth with which a person exercises something without lowering the thickness of his standing;18 a person who is still small is the same.

What he can do grows with his phase transitions

The other book records what he can do. He Zhou first cries, then points, then says "no," then says "I want that," then says why he does not want something. What he can do grows layer by layer, and not in step across matters. He has picked his own clothes for a long time; how to spend the pocket money he has saved, he still asks his parents' advice about. These are clues in words and deeds; how each domain has matured is checked separately, and is not settled by his choosing for himself or by his coming to ask. How this book is read, §5 says.

"He's still little, he doesn't understand"

He Chuan's company was going to transfer him to another city. While the family discussed whether to move, He Chuan's mother said: "Why tell Zhouzhou anything? He's still little, he won't understand." Lin Wan told He Zhou anyway: they were going to move, he would change schools, the new home was near the sea. He Zhou asked whether he could bring his fish tank.

The sentence "he's still little, he doesn't understand" can be saying something true: he does not understand transfers, mortgages, the difference between two cities. It can describe what, in some matter, he cannot yet do, and it stops there. It does not lower his standing as an end: the move lands in his life, and he is the person this matter will land on; not understanding a transfer does not take him out of the matter. Nor is it used to read his refusals uniformly as not yet understanding: should he say he does not want to move, that "no" is his, and how it is read, Paper 4 reads.19

Two ways of mixing the books

When the two books are mixed, it takes two shapes. One shape requires the child first to have capacity before he is acknowledged: once he understands, he will be taken seriously. The other runs the opposite way: for the sake of acknowledging the child, the parents' own position as subjects is cancelled; whatever the child wants is what goes, and the parents' own law no longer counts. Both are blocked.20 Basic rights stand on the side of the first book: they do not wait on capacity.

PC5 The child never chose to enter this relation, nor which conditions he would first enter; his own constitutive position does not on that account pass to the parents. That in reality he cannot do without the people who care for him does not give the caregivers the constitutive right over his value

Never having chosen

He Zhou never chose to be born into this family, never chose to be called He Zhou, never chose what his parents would say or which city they would live in. The asymmetry of this relation lies at the starting point: the parents' end has avowed it; the child's end never chose.

This sentence does not yield that the child from then on owes the parents something, nor that the parents from then on owe the child something. It says something else: his own constitutive position does not pass to the parents because he could not choose which conditions he first entered.21 The parents gave him those first conditions, and those conditions are the parents' giving; who he is is not on that account settled by the parents.

Not being able to do without is not passing over

A person who is still small cannot, in reality, do without the people who care for him: when hungry he must be fed, when ill he must be taken to be seen. Not being able to do without is a matter of reality; where his value comes from, and who he is, is another matter. The first does not yield the second: because he cannot do without them, the caregivers do not thereby obtain the constitutive right over his value.22

§5 DD at the Two Ends

PC6 DD has two uses for parents and for the child: at the parent's end, 15DD is a stance, the direction in which one operation goes; at the child's end, DD reads emergence and maturation, and does not become a label. Whether the first-person position can already run of itself in a given domain is checked by domain; how a layer that has already emerged operates on the present occasion, facing this object, is read separately. The layer of a present operation is not used to judge maturation in its place, nor is it concluded from maturation by domain that the emergence of 13DD itself is by domain

At the parent's end: a stance

To say that He Chuan is headed in the 15DD direction is to say which way he is headed across one matter after another: the direction in which one operation goes. This is a stance, not a layer stuck on him; that evening's falling back was also one operation.

At the child's end: emergence and maturation

When it comes to the child, DD has another use: it reads which layer has already emerged in him, and where he has already matured. This use does not become a label either. The series does not write "this is a 13DD child"; it writes "in this matter, his cannot-not has already come to stand."

In this use, three things are asked apart.

First, in this matter, can his first-person position already run of itself? If He Zhou's first-person position can already run of itself in the domain of picking clothes, that domain is already his; picking for himself and bearing the consequences of picking wrong are visible clues. His position in spending his pocket money is checked separately, and is not settled by the fact that he still asks his parents. This question is checked by content-domain: the judgment is by domain, not over the whole person.23

Second, on this occasion, facing this object, which layer is at work? A child who already has a cannot-not of his own in some matter hears one sentence from his mother and talks back at once; the speed of it does not by itself certify which layer is operating, nor does it prove that his maturation in this domain has slipped back. The several layers of operation a person already has are activated differently by different objects; this was first said of adults, and here it is used at the grown-ups' end, and also for the layers that have already emerged in the child.24 The layer of one operation is not used to judge, in its place, how far he has matured.

Third, is some piece of learning still within the direct-write window? This is read separately, by the Learning series; the model there is listed by its own paper as a structural hypothesis, and the series keeps that limit.25

The three questions do not certify one another. There is one more thing the series does not settle: whether the emergence of 13DD itself arrives at once, or domain by domain. Here only the upstream description is cited: negation first targets the other, thereby chiseling out the "I."26

The order is only an example

In the later papers, when reading a matter, an order will be given according to the child's phase transitions: before 13DD; the emergence of 13DD; 13DD in operation and 14DD budding; the 14DD turn; 14DD established. This order is only one example; it is not a definition of development, nor does it sort the child into cells. A child need not walk through this order in every matter; nor does the series use this order to judge which cell a child has reached.

What is read is the parent's end

What the series reads is how the end of the father or the mother acts. How far the child has grown is read only as a condition of that end's acting. If, in the matter of picking clothes, He Zhou already has it as his own, then how He Chuan and Lin Wan act in this matter is read differently accordingly; it is the latter that the series reads.

§6 The Object Layer and the Operation Layer

PC7 The object layer reads the relation in which the end of the father or the mother is headed in the 15DD direction; at the operation layer, the parent confirms only his own end. Which layer the child has reached in some matter is, from the parents' end, seen only in clues. If it is later confirmed that the direction premise of the relation being read did not obtain, the series does not unfold it as an object within scope, and does not turn and judge the other; one falling back within the relation is no ground for this exit, and the effects already read are kept on the books as before

Two layers

The object layer is what the series reads: what the relation in which the end of the father or the mother is headed in the 15DD direction looks like. The operation layer is what one person in a relation can confirm. The two layers are kept apart.27

Confirming only one's own end

At the operation layer, He Chuan can confirm only his own end: what he was after that evening, whether the sentence the next morning was a turning back. Of Lin Wan's end he sees only clues; of He Zhou's end, too, he sees only clues. He Zhou's "Mm" can be acceptance, can be not wanting to bring it up again, can be something else; He Chuan does not certify it for him.

Which layer the child has reached in some matter is, seen from the parents' end, likewise only clues. That He Zhou packed his own schoolbag this time does not prove that he has come to stand in this matter; that he forgets next time does not prove that he has not. Parents arrange things by clues, and arrangements can be changed (Paper 4).

The care seen from outside is also only clues. A father who takes his child to school and back every day is not thereby certified as headed in the 15DD direction; a father who has said nothing pleasant is not thereby certified as not.

Exiting this relation, without turning and judging

The object layer is stated conditionally. If it is later confirmed that the direction premise of the relation being read did not obtain, the series does not unfold it as an object within scope, and does not turn and judge the other.28 The unit of exit here is this relation, not this matter: one falling back within the relation is no ground for exit; falling back is read as it occurs (§1). The effects already read are kept on the books as before: that evening was that evening, and it is not wiped from the books because of how this relation is later read.

§7 Interfacing with the Tradition

Kant: brought into the world without consent. In the section on the right of the household in the Doctrine of Right (§28), Kant says that the parents, by their own decision and without the child's consent, have brought a person into the world; this act places on the parents' side an obligation to do what they can to make the child content with his condition; the child, as a person, is not the parents' thing, and cannot be disposed of as a thing.29 The common question: the child never chose to enter; what follows from this? Where they shed light on each other: the child is a person, not a thing, and his standing is not given him by the parents; this is exactly what §4 reads. Where they part: Kant sets this asymmetry down as an obligation of right; this series has no concept of a duty toward others, and what the parent's end gives is read as that end's own cannot-not (Paper 2); obligations of right belong to the institutional side. Marriage Theory, in reading preparation for a child, has already interfaced with this section of Kant, and it is pointed back to here.30

Hegel: children are not things. In the part of the Philosophy of Right on the family (§175), Hegel says that children are in themselves free, and that their life is only the immediate existence of this freedom; so they are not things, and belong neither to others nor to their parents.31 The common question: the child has not yet grown up; where does his standing come from? Where they shed light on each other: his standing does not wait for him to grow up; this runs the same way as the first book in §4. Where they part: Hegel writes the end of education as raising the child out of natural immediacy into an independent and free personality; this series sets no end for education, and reads only how the end of the father or the mother acts. Marriage Theory has already cited Hegel's sections on the family, and they are pointed back to here.

Locke: not born in equality, though born to it. In Chapter 6 of the Second Treatise of Government, on paternal power, Locke says that children are not born in this full state of equality, though they are born to it; the power parents have over their children is to take care of them while they cannot yet use their own reason, and it ends as the child grows up.32 The common question: how are the things a child cannot yet do, and who he is, to be spoken of together? Where they shed light on each other: Locke separates "born in" from "born to," which is close to the two books. Where they part: Locke begins from the parents' power; this series does not read power: the power over the side of caring for the child belongs to the institutional side; what is read here is the dealings between the parent and the child.

§8 Drawing Together, and Downstream

This paper has established seven propositions. Taken together, they say: this series does not define all parent-child relations; the parent-child relation it reads has as its premise that the end of the father or the mother is headed in the 15DD direction; the direction is a premise, not a component, and no further requirement is made here that both sides avow it; people are all mixed, the direction is read by one operation at a time, and falling back is read as it occurs; after falling back one can turn back, own up to that occasion and make some change afterward, and where there is persistent refusal to turn back, the direction is no longer at 15DD. The reading is relation by relation: the father's relation, the mother's relation, a single parent the same way, and pairwise accounting between the two relations. The three kinds apply to a relation: in the relation within scope, every matter is read, and falling back does not exit scope; the two kinds outside scope are both relations that on the whole remain in the 14DD direction and are not headed toward 15DD; the occasion that crosses basic rights is, separately, a violation; scope is not a definition. At the child's end the two books are kept apart: his standing as an end is full from the start, and what he can do grows with his phase transitions; "he's still little, he doesn't understand" only describes what he cannot yet do. The child never chose to enter, and his constitutive position does not pass to the parents; not being able to do without care does not mean that the caregivers obtain the constitutive right. At the parent's end DD is a stance, at the child's end it reads emergence and maturation, and does not become a label; maturation by domain, the present operation and the learning window are read apart, and the order is only an example. The object layer and the operation layer are kept apart, and the parent confirms only his own end; the unit of exit is this relation, and there is no turning and judging.

This paper does not prove that parents headed in the 15DD direction are better than other parents, nor that this is the only kind of parent-child relation, nor that parents ought to treat the child as an end.

What the next paper reads. For the few days He Zhou was ill, He Chuan took leave and stayed home. Where does this care come from: is it something He Chuan owes He Zhou, or something else? He Chuan's mother helps look after the child; how is her relation read? That evening He Zhou said "I don't want to play": had he gone on saying it, how much could that "no" have changed? This paper has said only that the child is another end; it has not said what the parents give him, or how.

Downstream. What this paper establishes is used in the later papers as follows. The premise, each relation, the three kinds in a relation, the two books, the two uses of DD, and the object layer and the operation layer are the scope and the way of reading of the whole series. The Base Layer: where the securing parents give comes from, the child's standing and the institutional side, the two senses of dependency, and the child's signals before 13DD, Paper 2 reads. The Emergence Layer: teaching, nurturing and leading within support, the direct-write window, and "for your own good," Paper 3 reads. The household's rules and today's arrangements for tomorrow, the domain-by-domain handing over of the authority to interpret, and that "no," Paper 4 reads. The meeting of the child's own cannot-not, once it has grown, with the parents' law, Paper 5 reads. Several caregivers, what lies between two relations, and mutual questioning, Paper 6 reads. Coming of age, handing over and leading, Paper 7 reads.

Acknowledgments

This paper is signed by Han Qin alone; the author decided every argument and choice and bears sole responsibility for the text. In drafting, the author used AI models from various developers as tools. The English edition is an independent rewrite of the Chinese text, not a translation; where the two differ, the Chinese governs.

Notes

  1. Laughter IV, Abstract: "15DD is non dubito: it is not only I who am an end; the other, too, is an end in itself. This acknowledgment is unidirectional: it is one subject's not doubting that the other is an end in itself (Methodological Overview, §1.7)". ↩︎
  2. Love Theory Paper 0, §4: "A layer records one operation. It does not record a person, nor a love." Here, likewise, it does not record a parent-child relation; carrying this from love to parent and child is an extension, this series' own undertaking. ↩︎
  3. Relation Theory Paper 1, Abstract and H8: "Cultivation and colonization are two directions: cultivation goes toward making space, colonization toward pouring in and occupying; the direction is read on this one effect, and whether it took hold is seen in the other party's later understanding and action; the two are not the two extremes of one scale, and the same act can carry both directions, and can also carry no direction at all; they are directions, not labels". ↩︎
  4. Relation Theory H9: "Violation is judged separately, and only at the layer of basic rights; it and the direction of colonization are two lines". ↩︎
  5. Education as Subject-Condition; the papers on the Terrible Twos and the Terrible Teens; Learning I to IV; On Rights and Entitlements, F34, which reads the three things that coexist in an infant: "in the infant three things coexist, each with its own host". ↩︎
  6. Relation Theory Paper 0, §16: "The layer of guardianship belongs to institutions; it is between person and construct." Relation Theory H11: "within an institution, the part of what passes between persons that the institution does not provide for, or that goes beyond its provisions, is within range; the relation between persons and constructs is not; the provisions themselves are acknowledged but not judged". ↩︎
  7. Relation Theory Paper 0, §16, lists the upstream pieces handed to Parent-Child Theory, and writes "The layer of guardianship belongs to institutions; it is between person and construct"; Marriage Theory Paper 6, MA34: "What lies between the child and the parents is handed to Parent-Child Theory; where three or more are involved, dealings are entered on separate accounts, pair by pair"; Cooperation Theory Paper 0, §1: "Of a thing parents and their adult children do together, the face of doing it together is here; what lies between parents and child belongs to Parent-Child Theory." ↩︎
  8. Marriage Theory Paper 1, MA2: "The 15DD direction is a direction, not a state. People are all mixed; a layer records one operation, and falling back is read as it occurs." ↩︎
  9. Cooperation Theory Paper 1, CO1: "falling back is read as it occurs, and does not overturn the direction". ↩︎
  10. Education as Subject-Condition, §3.2, originally reads recognition after the parents' conflict with each other: "Only when parents themselves stand at the 15DD position (able to reach recognition after conflict) can the child see the complete arc. Recognition is visible: restating the other's purpose, acknowledging its legitimacy, and adjusting one's own actions accordingly". Borrowing it here to read a parent's looking back on one effect of his own toward the child is an extension, this series' own undertaking. "Being able to turn back after falling back," as this series' direction premise, is this series' own undertaking; owning up and changing are taken only as clues visible from outside. ↩︎
  11. Relation Theory Paper 3, H23: "Leaving is entered on the books, and revising keeps the books on the change". What that place reads is standing, revising and the effects already left in a commitment; it is borrowed here only as a side light: turning back still owns the effects left earlier, and owning them does not wipe away what that occasion left. This extension is this series' own undertaking. ↩︎
  12. Relation Theory H12: "Where three or more are involved, dealings that do not pass through an institution are broken down into effects between pairs and entered on separate accounts; passing through a third person does not release the instigator from his part". ↩︎
  13. Marriage Theory Paper 6, MA34: "What lies between the child and the parents is handed to Parent-Child Theory; where three or more are involved, dealings are entered on separate accounts, pair by pair"; MA36: "'For the child's sake' cannot legislate for the two people". Marriage Theory Paper 6 reads the side between the two people when husband and wife and child are in one household. ↩︎
  14. Marriage Theory Paper 5, MA31: "He does not figure only as the continuation of the two, a link in continuing the line, a security for old age, or a condition for keeping the other party; 'only as' is read from the two people's arrangements, and a sentence is read by that sentence itself; to fall to 'only as' is to treat the child only as a condition, and carries the direction of colonization; the child's side is handed to Parent-Child Theory". Carrying this from the two people to the end of the father or the mother, by the same reading, is an extension, this series' own undertaking. ↩︎
  15. On Rights and Entitlements, F33: "the rights of the subject-to-be are grounded in its already being an end, not in its coming-to-be". Value Theory P1, V3: "A subject-to-be enters the domain of bearers on the equal standing of already being an end, its negation-gate's function still in genesis." The child is within the domain of bearers: Relation Theory H2, "The other side of a relation must be a bearer"; Value Theory P1, V14, includes the subject-to-be (by way of Relation Theory Paper 0, §16). ↩︎
  16. Meaning Theory P3, Y26: "the other's constitutive position is neither conferred by me nor withdrawn by me on account of his refusal". ↩︎
  17. Meaning Theory P3, Y26: "Ability is limited to constitutive independence, not to real-world self-sufficiency. Infants, the severely disabled, and the subjects of long-term care cannot in reality do without those who support them, and this never gives the supporter the constitutive right over their values". ↩︎
  18. Rights Theory P2: "Physiological or cognitive damage can lower exercise-bandwidth without lowering station-thickness." Carrying this to a person who is still small is an extension, this series' own undertaking. ↩︎
  19. Value Theory P3, V38, the second signal: "whether the refusals, deviations, and restructurings that a subject-to-be gradually produces can really alter that arrangement, or are read uniformly as not yet understanding". ↩︎
  20. Relation Theory H13: "Acknowledgment that requires no qualification and the realization of recognition are kept on separate books: wherever the former is used, it borrows none of the latter's conditions; wherever the latter is used, it borrows none of the former's conclusions"; Relation Theory Paper 1, in the section under H13: "Both ways of mixing the books must be blocked: requiring a child first to have capacity before being acknowledged; or, for the sake of acknowledging the child, cancelling the parents' own position as subjects." H13's second book originally speaks of the realization of recognition; the two books here, "standing as an end" and "what he can do," are an applied division of accounts made on this basis, which does not shrink the second book into the child's capacity; this application is this series' own undertaking. ↩︎
  21. Marriage Theory Paper 5, MA31: "The child's standing as an end is not created by this undertaking of preparation; nor does his own constitutive position pass to the two because he cannot choose which conditions he first enters". ↩︎
  22. Meaning Theory P3, Y26; for the whole sentence, see note 17. The same proposition: "For an other not yet within that domain, what this proposition protects is his existing standing as an end, that the source of his value is not placed outside him, and the openness of the conditions of first-person running". ↩︎
  23. Value Theory P3, V38: "The judgment is by domain and not over the whole subject"; the same place says that it and On Rights and Entitlements, F34a, "are one mechanism read out in two places". On Rights and Entitlements, F34a: "to impose on a maturing subject-to-be an externally fixed binary threshold systematically produces a risk of misclassification". ↩︎
  24. SAE Psychoanalysis I, the series' first theorem: "the object determines the layer, not the developmental stage". The subject there is the several modes of operation an adult already has; here it is used at the grown-ups' end, and also for the layers that have already emerged in the child, not to certify how far the child has matured; applying it to the layers already emerged in the child is an extension, this series' own undertaking. ↩︎
  25. Learning I, §8.4: "12DD's 'direct-write mode' versus 'consolidated mode' is this paper's central model, currently a structural hypothesis rather than a confirmed neural mechanism." ↩︎
  26. The Terrible Twos paper reads the terrible twos as "the structural site where negation first targets the other, thereby chiseling out the 'I'". It is cited here only as an upstream description, not as a developmental claim of this series. ↩︎
  27. Conflict Treatise §2: "Operation layer. I can confirm only my own end." ↩︎
  28. Conflict Treatise §2: "If it is later confirmed that the object type never obtained, one exits — one does not turn and judge the other"; Cooperation Theory Paper 1, CO4: "If it is later confirmed that the object did not obtain, this series exits this case, and does not turn and judge the other end". In those two places the unit of exit is one matter; here the unit of exit is this relation, by this series' scope; this extension is this series' own undertaking. ↩︎
  29. Kant, Metaphysik der Sitten, Rechtslehre, §28, AA 6:280–281. Paraphrased; Hastie's translation (1887), as cited in Marriage Theory Paper 5: "a person is brought without his consent into the world and placed in it by the responsible free will of others". ↩︎
  30. Marriage Theory Paper 5, reading this section of Kant, writes that "whether the parents' duty holds is a matter of right". This series has no concept of a duty toward others: Rights Theory Paper 0, M1, "SAE Rights Theory has no concept of a duty toward others; it has only one inward duty, the subject's answerability to its own law". ↩︎
  31. Hegel, Grundlinien der Philosophie des Rechts, §175. Paraphrased. The English is checked against the electronic transcription of T. M. Knox's translation (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1952); located by section number. ↩︎
  32. Locke, Two Treatises of Government, Second Treatise, ch. 6, §§55, 58–61, 65. Paraphrased after the Liberty Fund electronic text of the edition by T. Hollis (London: A. Millar et al., 1764). ↩︎

References

All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version.

I · SAE works directly cited in this paper

Qin, H. (2026). The Place of Relation Theory (SAE Relation Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545115

Qin, H. (2026). What a Relation Is, and What It Is Not (SAE Relation Theory, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545047

Qin, H. (2026). Commitment (SAE Relation Theory, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545023

Qin, H. (2026). The Place of Love Theory (SAE Love Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23627790

Qin, H. (2026). The Place of Marriage Theory (SAE Marriage Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23819201

Qin, H. (2026). Joined (SAE Marriage Theory, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23819212

Qin, H. (2026). For One Not Yet Here (SAE Marriage Theory, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23819245

Qin, H. (2026). Three (SAE Marriage Theory, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23819255

Qin, H. (2026). The Place of Cooperation Theory (SAE Cooperation Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24029128

Qin, H. (2026). Doing Together (SAE Cooperation Theory, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24029132

Qin, H. (2026). How Subjecthood Is Not Swallowed by Conflict Itself (SAE Conflict Treatise) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22313628

Qin, H. (2026). On How Rights Presuppose No Duty (SAE Rights Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21285136

Qin, H. (2026). On the Thickness and Boundary of Basic Rights (SAE Rights Theory, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20769253

Qin, H. (2026). On Rights and Entitlements (SAE Rights Theory, Special Study) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21314907

Qin, H. (2026). On the Source of Value (SAE Value Theory, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21405207

Qin, H. (2026). On the Colonization of Value (SAE Value Theory, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21611154

Qin, H. (2026). The Half That Is Not Mine to Settle (SAE Meaning Theory, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22731235

Qin, H. (2026). The Laughter of Despair and the Knowing Smile (SAE Laughter, IV) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23287669

Qin, H. (2026). Education as Subject-Condition: A Philosophy of Education [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18867389

Qin, H. (2026). Learning Through Memory and Prediction: The Construction, Window, and Cost of 11DD and 12DD (SAE Learning, I) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19426123

Qin, H. (2026). Learning to Scrutinize and Correct: The Emergence, Operation, and Cost of 13DD (SAE Learning, II) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19436811

Qin, H. (2026). Purpose-Driven Learning (SAE Learning, III) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19490707

Qin, H. (2026). Learning to Recognize the Other's Purpose: The Bridge from 14DD to 15DD (SAE Learning, IV) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19491926

Qin, H. (2026). What Terrible Twos Actually Is: The Structural Genesis of Self-Awareness [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19044827

Qin, H. (2026). What Terrible Teens Actually Is: The Structural Genesis of Purpose [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19201631

Qin, H. (2026). Id — The Me Without a Self (SAE Psychoanalysis, I) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19321143

II · External works

Hegel, G. W. F. (1820). Grundlinien der Philosophie des Rechts. (cited by section number; English after Philosophy of Right, trans. T. M. Knox, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1952, electronic transcription)

Kant, I. (1797). Die Metaphysik der Sitten, Part One: Metaphysische Anfangsgründe der Rechtslehre. AA 6. (Academy edition; English after W. Hastie, trans., The Philosophy of Law: An Exposition of the Fundamental Principles of Jurisprudence as the Science of Right, Edinburgh: T. & T. Clark, 1887, as cited in Marriage Theory Paper 5)

Locke, J. (1764). Two Treatises of Government (T. Hollis, Ed.). London: A. Millar et al. (first published 1689; Liberty Fund electronic text)

Interfaces

  • Main upstream: Relation Theory Paper 0 (§16), Paper 1 (Abstract, H2, H8, H9, H11, H12, H13; the section under H13); Marriage Theory Paper 1 (MA2), Paper 5 (MA31), Paper 6 (MA34, MA36); Meaning Theory P3 (Y26); On Rights and Entitlements (F33, F34, F34a).
  • Also used: Cooperation Theory Paper 0 (§1), Paper 1 (CO1, CO4); the Conflict Treatise (§2); Value Theory P1 (V3; V14, by way of Relation Theory Paper 0, §16), P3 (V38); Rights Theory Paper 0 (M1), P2; Laughter IV (Abstract); Love Theory Paper 0 (§4); Education as Subject-Condition (§3.2); Relation Theory Paper 3 (H23); Learning I (§8.4); the Terrible Twos paper; SAE Psychoanalysis I (first theorem); Marriage Theory Paper 5 (the passage on Kant), Paper 6.
  • This series: Paper 2 takes up where securing comes from, standing and the institutional side, the two senses of dependency, and the signals before 13DD; Paper 3 takes up the three things in support; Paper 4 takes up the household's rules, the handing over of the authority to interpret, and that "no"; Paper 5 takes up the meeting of two laws; Paper 6 takes up several caregivers and mutual questioning; Paper 7 takes up coming of age, handing over and leading.