The Place of Parent-Child Theory
亲子论的位置
This paper is Paper 0 of Parent-Child Theory: written last, placed first. It lays down no propositions; it only does a few things for those who read this series: it states this series' place in SAE, sets out how far it reads and what its main line is, gives the method and the shared words the papers have in common, interfaces as a whole with several traditions, says once, all together, the directions of colonization read in the papers, lists together the forty-two propositions the whole series has established, and registers the remainders that are left over and not closed out, and the questions that still await proof.
Parent-Child Theory is the last branch downstream of SAE Relation Theory, following Love Theory, Marriage Theory and Cooperation Theory. This series does not define all parent-child relations; the parent-child relation it reads has as its premise that the end of the father or the mother is headed in the 15DD direction: across one matter after another, headed toward treating the child as an end, and not merely as a means; people are all mixed, falling back is read as it occurs, and having fallen back, one can turn back. It reads relation by relation: father and child one relation, mother and child another. It borrows the two layers of the institutional side to read what parents give the child: the Base Layer is to be secured, the Emergence Layer supported; it takes the child's phase transitions as one axis along which to read how the parents' end acts, the order being only an example; it reads until the child's cannot-not has come to stand in one matter after another, until handing over and leading. The main line, put plainly: from the start he is another end; the parents guard him, give him conditions, and one matter at a time give back to him what they held for him. The seven papers read, in order: Another End; securing; support; arrangements; collisions; several caregivers; handing over and leading.
This paper interfaces as a whole with Locke, Rousseau, Kant, Hegel, the Analects and the Mencius, and Gibran; developmental psychology is not interfaced with, and the several SAE papers on the developmental side are pointed back to. The directions of colonization read in the papers borrow things that are, or may come to be, between parents and child: the child's standing, securing, dependency, the window, "for your own good," the parents' meaning, giving, arrangements, the child's "no," resistance, a third person, leading. These things carry no direction in themselves; the direction is read on the one effect in which they are taken up to do something. This paper proves no proposition at the object layer.
Introduction
The seven papers that follow each read one thing. Paper 1, Another End, reads what the parent-child relation this series speaks of looks like: the premise, falling back and turning back, relation by relation, the three kinds in a relation, the two books at the child's end, his never having chosen to enter, the two uses of DD for parents and for the child, the object layer and the operation layer. Paper 2, Securing in the Parent-Child Relation, reads the Base Layer: where the shape of the two layers is borrowed from, where the securing parents give comes from, the child's standing and violation, securing not made conditional, the two senses of dependency, the child's signals before 13DD, and how securing shifts with the phase transitions. Paper 3, Support in the Parent-Child Relation, reads the Emergence Layer: setting, not source; the three things, teaching, nurturing and leading; the direct-write window; "for your own good"; meaning not copied; support not entered as repayment. Paper 4, Arrangements in the Parent-Child Relation, reads the household's rules: today's arrangements for tomorrow, the three questions by which an arrangement is read, the domain-by-domain handing over of the authority to interpret, that "no," the ex ante structural condition, and pre-occupation. Paper 5, Collisions in the Parent-Child Relation, reads the meeting of the child's own cannot-not, once it has grown, with the parents' law: the 14DD turn and rebellion, what the parents' end looks like in this stretch, the three forms of colonization at 14DD, the threshold of the Conflict Treatise, mutual chiseling, and collision running two ways. Paper 6, Several Caregivers, reads the case in which a child has more than one caregiver: each its own relation, by way of a third person, caregivers questioned and mutual questioning, one party treating the child merely as a means, the child brought in by remarriage and grandparents. Paper 7, Handing Over and Leading, reads the last stretch: coming of age, raising and having it come to stand, "being able to unfold without revolving around me" on the child's side, leading, and the turn to family affection.
Written this way, several things are left that no single paper takes care of: why this series is here, and how far it reads; how the main line strings the seven papers together; the method the papers share, and what the same word means in which paper; several traditions whose questions concern the whole series; what the directions of colonization read in the papers look like when set side by side; and which questions still await proof. This paper takes care of these.
Method as in the papers: the conclusions of upstream papers are said in plain words, and sources and extensions go in the notes. This paper lays down no propositions, and alters no sentence of the papers that follow. How the pieces upstream handed to this series are placed goes in the appendix at the end.
§1 Place: The Last Branch Downstream on the Relational Side
SAE has three sides: the subject side, the relational side and the institutional side. The relational side is unfolded by Relation Theory; once Relation Theory is written, there are several branches downstream: Love Theory, Marriage Theory, Parent-Child Theory and Cooperation Theory.1 Love Theory, Marriage Theory and Cooperation Theory come first; this series is the branch written last.
The division of labor between the two layers Relation Theory has written out: Relation Theory in the abstract establishes only what all relations have; what holds only in one kind of relation is handed to the series on that kind of relation to argue.2 Whatever has already been laid down at the layer of relation, this series uses directly and does not rewrite: the minimal condition of a relation, the two directions of cultivation and colonization, expectation, commitment, the sediment of dealings and ending are all read by Relation Theory. Of what Relation Theory handed to this series, several things it gave first itself: acknowledgment that requires no qualification and the realization of recognition kept on separate books; the two senses of dependency; today's arrangements for tomorrow; effects that carry the direction of colonization without passing through conflict (Appendix).
With Marriage Theory. Marriage Theory reads two people; once the two have a child, the side of shared child-rearing between the two is in Marriage Theory; what lies between the child and the parents is handed to this series; where three or more are involved, accounts are kept pair by pair.3 Marriage Theory reads preparing for someone who has not yet come; once the child has come, the relation between the father or the mother and the child is read from this series on. Marriage Theory's scope takes both parties headed in the 15DD direction; this series takes the end of the father or the mother; this difference can be traced to the kind of relation: the two ends of the parent-child relation do not start symmetrically, and the child never chose to enter (Paper 1).
With Cooperation Theory. Of a thing parents and their adult children do together, the face of doing it together is in Cooperation Theory; what lies between parents and child belongs here.4 Cooperation Theory's scope further requires that both avow this undertaking and actually take part; this series makes no further requirement that both sides avow it, for the same reason.
With Rights Theory and the institutional side. The child's basic rights have their standing in himself; how they are protected and by what rules belongs to the institutional side; guardianship, recognition-based rights held on his behalf, and the delegated holding and replacement on the side of caregivers' converging the child's action belong to Rights Theory and the institutional side.5 This series reads only the side between person and person: the part the institution does not provide for, or that goes beyond its provisions. On the occasion when a parent's effect crosses the child's basic rights, this series reads as far as "this is a violation" and the boundary crossed; protection and disposition after the violation are handed over there, and what that effect left in the dealings is still read here (Paper 2).
With Political Economy. The two layers, the Base Layer to be secured and the Emergence Layer supported, were written out by Political Economy for institutions;6 this series borrows their shape to read what lies between the parent and the child, and the step of carrying it over is this series' own undertaking. Political Economy writes that cultivation on the side of the institution and on the side of the person are read apart; this series reads the side of the person (Paper 2).
With the several papers on the developmental side. SAE has already read the child from the side of development and learning: the education paper divides teaching, nurturing and leading; the three papers on the Terrible Twos, the Terrible Teens and Terrible Telos read the genesis of 13DD, 14DD and 15DD; the Learning series reads how each layer learns.7 This series does not read these again, and calls on them where they are used; what it reads is how the end of the father or the mother acts, and how far the child has grown is only a condition of that end's acting.
With a future series on relations of care. Cases needing long-term care after coming of age, and parents grown old needing care from their adult children, this series does not read; they are handed to a future series on relations of care (Paper 7).
§2 Scope and Main Line
Scope. There are six items.
First, it does not define all parent-child relations. To say that a relation is not within the parent-child relation this series reads is not to say that it is not a parent-child relation; the subject is that relation, not that person (Paper 1, PC1, PC3).
Second, the end of the father or the mother headed in the 15DD direction. In SAE's levels, the layer at which the other is recognized as an end too is written 15DD. 15DD is non dubito: "it is not only I who am an end; the other, too, is an end in itself."8 The parent-child relation this series reads has as its premise that the end of the father or the mother is headed in this direction: across one matter after another, headed toward treating the child as an end, and not merely as a means. The direction is a premise, not a component; the child never chose to enter, and no further requirement is made here that both sides avow it (Paper 1).
Third, direction, falling back, and turning back. There is no parent who stands purely at 15DD; people are all mixed; the direction is read by one operation at a time, falling back is read as it occurs, and does not overturn the direction. After falling back, this end can turn back, own up to that occasion, and make some change in the arrangements and dealings that follow; where there is persistent refusal to turn back, the direction is no longer at 15DD. Reflection is read from words and deeds, and is confirmed only at the person's own end; it does not cancel a violation already read, nor leave the child owing forgiveness; "persistent" means continuing not to turn back (Paper 1, PC1).
Fourth, relation by relation, and the three kinds in a relation. Father and child one relation, mother and child another, grandparents and other caregivers each their own; a single parent is read the same way. The three kinds apply to a relation as a whole, not as a sieve that lets each matter in or out of scope: a relation headed toward treating the child as an end is within scope, and every matter in it is read; the relation that treats the child merely as a means, and the relation that does not treat him merely as a means yet is not headed toward treating him as an end either, are both relations that on the whole remain in the 14DD direction and are not headed toward 15DD (this says where a relation is headed; it does not grade a person); they are not within scope, and are only registered; the occasion that crosses basic rights is, separately, a violation (Paper 1, PC2, PC3; Paper 6).
Fifth, the object layer and the operation layer. The object layer reads the relation within scope; at the operation layer the parent confirms only his own end, and of the child's end, and of another caregiver's end, sees only clues. If it is later confirmed that the direction premise of the relation being read did not obtain, the series does not unfold it as an object within scope, and does not turn and judge; one falling back within the relation is no ground for exit (Paper 1, PC7).
Sixth, the upper bound and the edges. This series reads until the child's cannot-not has come to stand in one matter after another, until handing over and leading, until this relation becomes one face of family affection between adults; the child's own 15DD is his own affair, and is not in this series (Paper 7). What this series does not read: guardianship, and the side of the family as a construct; the protection of the child's standing and its rules; disposition after a line has been crossed; the side between husband and wife; long-term care after coming of age.
Main line. In plain prose it is one sentence: from the start he is another end. The parents guard him, give him conditions, and one matter at a time give back to him what they held for him.
Put technically, as the main text and the abstracts of the papers use it: the father or the mother, headed in the 15DD direction, secures the child's Base Layer and supports his Emergence Layer; from before his own cannot-not has come to stand, the reading goes on to handing over and leading once it has come to stand domain by domain. His standing as an end is not conferred by the parents; what he can do grows with his phase transitions; the conditions the parents give do not avow his direction for him. The first half is Papers 2 and 3: the two layers. The middle is Papers 4 and 5: arrangements and collisions, and the domain-by-domain handing over of the authority to interpret. The second half is the two books of Paper 1 and the handing over and leading of Paper 7.
At the core of the passage on scope in Paper 1 is the one sentence that states scope: at least one father or mother, across one matter after another, is headed toward treating the child as an end; and having fallen back, can turn back. This sentence sums up the entrance; it is not an equivalent substitute for all the conditions of scope.
What also strings the seven papers together is the division into two books: the child's standing as an end is full from the start; what he can do grows layer by layer with his phase transitions. The first book does not wait for the second; the second does not lower the first. Every effect of the parents' end that the papers read is read under these two books.
§3 Method
A layer records one operation; stance, and emergence. DD has two uses for parents and for the child: at the parent's end, 15DD is a stance, the direction in which one operation goes; at the child's end, DD reads emergence and maturation, and does not become a label. The maturation of the first-person position is checked by content-domain; the present operation follows its object, and is read separately; whether a piece of learning is still within the direct-write window is read separately again; the three do not certify one another. Whether the emergence of 13DD itself arrives at once or domain by domain, this series does not settle (Paper 1, PC6).
The order is only an example; what is read is the parents' end. The papers take the child's phase transitions as one axis: before 13DD, the emergence of 13DD, 13DD in operation and 14DD budding, the 14DD turn, 14DD established. This order is only one example, not a definition of development, nor does it sort the child into cells. What this series reads is how the end of the father or the mother acts; the child's development is read only as a condition of that end's acting, not as a study of developmental stages. So the main text gives no particular ages; ages in upstream papers and in research material appear only in the notes, as a posterior reference.
Speak of structure, not of good and bad; issue no ought. A parent-child relation is not scored by its length, by success and failure, or by what the child later became. The main text is not written as "what parents should do," but as how the parents' end acts.
Do not read minds; do not predict. Inference goes by structure, or by the original sentences of upstream; how a person thinks is not said for him. Of the child, only what he says and does is written. No prediction is made about how one kind of parent or one child will turn out. The care seen from outside does not certify the parents' inner direction.
Only the layer between person and person. Guardianship, the family as a construct, the legal duty of maintenance, and the protection of the child's standing and its rules belong to the institutional side; they are acknowledged but not judged, and registered as conditions of the effect.
"Cannot-not," not "duty." The care and support a father or mother gives come from this end's own cannot-not, and are this end's answering to its own law; this series has no concept of a duty toward others. The face of giving is read as entitlement, anchored in the giving (Paper 2).
Cultivation and colonization in the broad sense. They name the direction of one effect, not labels stuck on persons or on a relation; the direction is read on this one effect, and whether it took hold is seen in the child's later understanding and action; the measure of outcomes is not used to judge direction. Where the reading reaches the value layer (incomplete cultivation is not colonization; pre-occupation), colonization takes the value layer's narrow sense instead, marked on the spot.9 Violation is judged separately, and only at the layer of basic rights.
Examples. A single family runs through the whole series: He Chuan, Lin Wan, and their child He Zhou; side examples are Song Lan and her daughter Song Nian, and Xu Ning, Ji Ping and Xu Dong. These are made-up examples, used only to see structure: in the examples, that He Chuan and Lin Wan are headed in the 15DD direction is a set premise; the examples write their falling back, and also their turning back afterward, and the two can question each other. When the child appears, only words and deeds are written; harm is only registered structurally, not written as plot or detail. Historical examples do not use children in history as the persons concerned; they may use the childhoods that adults have themselves written down and that have been made public, read only for how the adult later wrote, not rewritten as a record of the child's inner life at the time, nor used to certify the parents' direction; private letters and diaries published after death are marked as such in the notes. Only the deceased, whose records are public, are used; living real persons are not.
Research material. Where no suitable example is to hand, research in developmental psychology can serve as material: following published reports, naming no living individual, giving the source in the notes, and reporting sample ages truthfully; findings are not used as a step of argument, and the structural reading is this series' own undertaking.
Interfacing with the tradition. The papers each interface with figures by question, and this paper interfaces as a whole. Interfacing reads only structure, and does not evaluate traditions. Developmental psychology is not interfaced with: the several SAE papers on the developmental side have already been in conversation with it, and they are pointed back to here (§5).
Sources and extensions. The conclusions of upstream papers are said in plain words in the main text; sources, original sentences and the proposition numbers of other papers go in the notes. Where upstream words are carried beyond their original place, from institutions toward persons to parents toward the child, from between adults to before adulthood, from one and the same bearer to the parents' today and the child's tomorrow, from the gate of recognition-based rights to what lies between parents and child, it is stated on the spot to be an extension, this series' own undertaking.
§4 Shared Words
Securing, support; protection. Used apart, as in Political Economy: "securing" is used for supply in the Base Layer, and giving conditions for a person's emergence is called "support."10 The "negative boundaries of support" Marriage Theory speaks of are the same "support." The institution's guarding of the child's basic rights is written "protection," not "securing."
Entitlement; duty. "Entitlement" follows the usage on the side of rights: anchored in the giving end, in the giving; the child is the end this giving is directed at, and does not hold it.11 "Duty" this series does not use between parents and child: there is only one inward duty, the subject's answerability to its own law.12 A legal duty of maintenance belongs to the institutional side.
15DD, 14DD, 13DD; coming to stand. At the parents' end, these speak of stance; at the child's end, of the layer that has already emerged, or already matured, in some matter. The main text writes "in this matter, his cannot-not has already come to stand," not "this is a 13DD child."
Coming of age. Coming of age structurally is read as the child's 14DD coming to stand, arriving domain by domain; coming of age in law is a line drawn by institutions, acknowledged but not judged (Paper 7).
Cultivation; teaching, nurturing, leading. Where not otherwise marked, cultivation follows Relation Theory's broad sense: one effect goes toward making space. Where the education paper's tripartite division of "teaching, nurturing, leading" is cited, its "nurturing" follows that paper's special usage: giving space for the subject to chisel out self-awareness and purpose on its own. What the Learning series calls nurturing during the window period is that series' usage. The tripartite division says that what is done differs, and is not used to cancel cultivation in the broad sense elsewhere. "Leading" is not leadership, not a position with authority: the adult lives out recognition, the child sees the direction, and it can be done only by personal demonstration.
Arrangement; rules. An arrangement is something parents set for a child that governs him for some time afterward; rules are the kind of arrangement a household states out loud and follows again and again. Both are read as the parents' today's arrangements for the child's tomorrow (Paper 4).
The authority to interpret; handing over; raising and having it come to stand. The authority to interpret is who says how a matter is to be read and what it counts as. "Handing over" means the interpretations and avowals the parents' end used to hold for the child being transferred domain by domain; the initiation of questioning is not within "handing over": it becomes his own as soon as the negation-gate runs of itself in a matter. Being able to raise something is not the same as having it come to stand (Paper 4, Paper 7). "Handing over" differs from "withdrawing" in Cooperation Theory: withdrawing is a party withdrawing his own side.
Pre-occupation. Following the usage at the value layer: a not-yet-running position filled before it begins to run. Marking an arrangement as a final content the child will be unable to refute in future is a signal of pre-occupation, not a judgment of it (Paper 4).
The gate: the negation-gate; running of itself, exercise on his behalf. Following the usage on the side of value and of rights: the negation-gate is the link in a person's own law by which he says no to content imposed on him, and questions and negates what has been produced.13 Where, in a matter, this gate can be run by himself in the first person, it is said to run of itself; the side that cannot yet, and is exercised for him by those who care for him, is exercise on his behalf; the range in which it runs of itself shifts gradually with the matter and over time.14 Where the gate runs of itself in a matter, the position of raising and refusing in that matter becomes his own at once (Paper 7).
Collision: conflict, mutual chiseling. Following the usage at the layer of relation: collision has two subclasses, conflict and mutual chiseling. "Conflict" is used only after the two gates of the Conflict Treatise have been passed; what has not passed them is read as dealings and collision. Mutual chiseling is judged by process, not by identity (Paper 5).
Guardianship. A word of the institutional side, not read by this series.
Family. This series does not read the family as a construct, nor does it merge a family into one bearer for the purpose of keeping accounts; the family and the interests of its members are not read as one indivisible whole.15 The effects that the rules "our family" has set have on the child are still read separately in each person's relation. Whether a family can separately be established as a bearer is left as a remainder (§7).
Caregiver. Said on its own, it refers broadly to whoever actually cares for a child, parents included; said alongside the parents, as "other caregivers," it refers to grandparents on either side, nannies, relatives and the like, and also includes the party who, after remarriage, actually takes on care. Each has a relation with the child (Paper 6).
Subject-to-be. Following the usage of Value Theory and of the side of rights: a bearer whose equal standing as an end is already in place, while the first-person running of its negation-gate is still in genesis. When applied to particular matters, it is checked by domain; his standing as an end does not wait for him to grow up.16
Family affection. Only a name: the dealings between parents and adult children, read by Relation Theory and Cooperation Theory; this series gives it no definition of its own.
§5 Interfacing as a Whole
Locke: paternal power. In Chapter 6 of the Second Treatise of Government, on paternal power, Locke says that children are not born in this full state of equality, though they are born to it; the power parents have over their children is to take care of them while they cannot yet use their own reason, and it ends as the child grows up.17 This series and Locke shed light on each other at two points: the two books, being born in and being born to; and the parents' letting go, which comes when the child can judge for himself. They part at two points too: Locke begins from the parents' power, while this series does not establish an authority of parents to govern the child, and reads the effects between person and person; Locke explains by the ability to use reason when parental government ends, while this series instead reads, matter by matter, how the first-person position operates, and when the position of raising and refusing becomes the person's own (Papers 1 and 7).
Rousseau: negative education; dependence on things alone. In Émile, Rousseau holds that the first education should be negative, and that the child should be made to depend on things alone, not on people.18 This series and Rousseau shed light on each other in leaving room (Paper 3); where they part is that Rousseau's tutor designs a whole "necessity of things" for the child, while what this series reads is exactly who sets an arrangement and whether the child can change it (Paper 4).
Kant: brought into the world without consent; freedom under constraint; paternal government. In the Doctrine of Right, Kant says that the parents, without the child's consent, have brought a person into the world, and thereby bear an obligation; the child, as a person, is not a thing; in On Pedagogy he asks how freedom is to be cultivated under constraint; in an essay of 1793 he says that a government that, as a father toward his children, decides its subjects' happiness for them out of benevolence is the greatest conceivable despotism.19 These three places this series reads in Papers 1, 3, 5 and 7: the child never chose to enter, and his constitutive position does not pass to the parents, while this series does not derive from this a duty toward others; two laws meeting in one matter; in a matter that is already an adult child's own, still treating him as a child, where what is borrowed is only the shape, not that kind of government. Marriage Theory and Political Economy have already interfaced with two of these places, and they are pointed back to.
Hegel: children are not things; discipline and self-will. In the sections on the family in the Philosophy of Right, Hegel says that children are in themselves free, and are not things; that children have a right to be maintained and educated from the common property of the family; and, in the main text of §174, that the parents' right over the children's arbitrary will has as its end to discipline and to educate them, while the Addition (Zusatz) to §174 says that the purpose of discipline is to break the child's self-will (Eigenwille).20 This series and Hegel shed light on each other at the first point (Paper 1); at the second, this series leaves how the child's standing is protected, and the rules governing that protection, to the institutional side, and on the relational side reads the giving the parents' end does (Paper 2); at the third, the antecedents of "self-will" and of "a cannot-not of one's own" are checked first, and the one is not translated directly into the other (Paper 5). Marriage Theory has already cited Hegel's sections on the family, and they are pointed back to.
The Analects and the Mencius. SAE's reading of the Analects has already annotated the chapters on filial conduct; this series sets them against itself at only two points: "give your parents nothing to worry about but your illness" falls on what the parents' end cannot set down (Paper 2); "in serving your parents, remonstrate gently": the child's "no" falls, in that chapter, as gentle remonstrance (Paper 4). The Mencius's "between father and son, affection," and the five relationships, Relation Theory Paper 0 has already set alongside the differential mode of association (Paper 6).21 Interfacing reads only structure, and does not evaluate traditions.
Gibran: on children. In The Prophet, "On Children," Gibran says that children come through their parents but not from them; you may give them your love but not your thoughts; the parents are the bows from which the children as living arrows are sent forth.22 These sentences and this series shed light on each other at three points: "from the start he is another end," "meaning is not copied," and "being able to unfold without revolving around me." In the poem, the parents are the bow and the one who aims is an archer; where they part is that Gibran writes counsel, and hands the aiming to an archer, while this series reads only structure, sets up no such archer, and reads apart giving conditions, deciding his direction for him and personal demonstration, without taking the poem's image directly as a structural criterion.
Developmental psychology: pointed back to. The Terrible Twos paper has already been in conversation with Spitz, Winnicott, Mahler, Piaget, Erikson and attachment research; the Terrible Teens paper with Erikson, Kohlberg and Marcia.23 This series does not interface again; where it uses research, it uses it only as material (§3).
§6 The Directions of Colonization Read in the Papers, Said Once Together
How the directions of colonization the papers have found are read lies in each paper; here only one layer is said together: what they borrow are things that are, or may come to be, between parents and child. These things carry no direction in themselves; whether they carry one is seen from the antecedents of that one effect, not from the name of the act:
- The child's standing: when "he's still little, he doesn't understand" is used to lower his standing as an end, or his refusals are read uniformly as not yet understanding (Papers 1 and 4).
- The child as a condition: when the child figures only as the parents' continuation, a link in continuing the line, a security for old age, or a condition for keeping or for using against the other party; a sentence is read by that sentence itself, and what is read is the arrangement (Papers 1 and 6).
- Securing: when securing is traded for compliance, hung on the child's taking some road, or a lack of securing is made up for by how much support is given (Paper 2).
- Dependency: when it was made and has locked the path to saying no; the child's depending on care carries no direction in itself, nor is dependency in itself a violation (Paper 2).
- The window: when the high plasticity of the window period is used to force-write a script the parents designate; the parents' choosing what to teach is not, on that account, this (Paper 3).
- "For your own good": when it is used to decide the child's direction for him; the difference lies in that one effect (Paper 3).
- The parents' meaning: when the meaning on the parents' side is copied onto the child (Paper 3).
- Giving: when the child's compliance or achievement is entered as repayment, or giving is used to possess him or to decide his direction for him; support can have content, a term and conditions (Paper 3).
- Arrangements: when a present arrangement is marked as a final content the child will be unable to refute in future, it is a signal of pre-occupation; reading pre-occupation further requires that the position be sealed shut before the gate runs of itself (Paper 4).
- Resistance: direction substitution, superego internalization, and full-support resistance removal, which appears in the guise of support (Paper 5).
- A third person: when effects on the child are had by way of another caregiver, taking oneself to have no part in that entry (Paper 6).
- Leading: when leading is made into a position with authority, and an adult child is still treated as a child in a matter that is already his own (Paper 7).
One and the same "for your own good," one and the same "no screens before bed," one and the same fee paid, is in one place a piece of support or an act of maintaining, and only in another the replacement of a direction or the pre-occupation of a position. The direction is read on the one effect in which they are taken up to do something; whether it took hold is seen in how the child afterward understands and acts.
These things do not in themselves decide the direction of an effect; the several effects within one relation are read separately. People are all mixed (Paper 1); falling back is read by that one occasion; whether, after falling back, one can turn back is read separately, by the words and deeds that follow. What this series reads is direction; it does not on this account say that being a parent is dangerous, nor does it advise anyone how to be a parent; it only reads.
§7 Remainders
Several things this series registers, and does not close out.
First, whether a family can separately be established as a bearer. Marriage Theory has already left this as a remainder; this series does not judge it, does not merge a family into one bearer for the purpose of keeping accounts, and reads only each person's relation with the child.
Second, whether the emergence of 13DD itself arrives at once, or domain by domain. This series does not settle it, and only cites the upstream description (Paper 1).
Third, adoption. Marriage Theory has read preparing to adopt; what lies between the adoptive father or mother and the child afterward is read by the same scope and the same reading; the papers have not written about it separately.
Fourth, between siblings. This is not a parent-child relation, and is read by Relation Theory; where it appears as a condition on the child's side, it is only registered.
Fifth, government protection of children. The Theory of Government has read a case in which a child is removed from the home and the matter goes to the family division of the court, and entitlements under government guardianship; that is the institutional side, and this series only registers it.24
Sixth, that the principles of marriage do not cover children. Foundational Paper 6, How Is Institution Possible, Appendix IV, writes that the side of children in a marriage is "a vast remainder, left for those who have children to chisel on their own";25 what this series reads is the side between person and person in one shape of what is chiseled out, and it does not set rules for that side.
Seventh, long-term care after coming of age, and parents grown old needing care from their children: handed to a future series on relations of care.
Eighth, care between humans and AI, and between humans and animals: a choice of range, not a determination about ontology.
§8 Questions Left Open
Two things the papers argue only halfway; they are listed here as they stand.
First, whether the crying and resistance of a child before 13DD can be read as a boundary signal that cannot be overwritten. Paper 2 says only this: they are first read as signals to be answered; first check whether securing is lacking, and also check whether it is a prediction that has fallen through, or a negation coming into being; crying alone does not certify which layer he is at (PC13). Which kind of signal it is, and in what sense it cannot be overwritten, has not been argued.26
Second, how far lateral cross-checking among several caregivers can go in the general case. Paper 6 says only this: a caregiver's reasons, interpretations and adjudications are not placed beyond examination, and being questioned is his own being questioned; another caregiver is one source of external questioning; where an institution exists that is fit for purpose, available, and not controlled by one party to the dispute, the principal screening may be borne by it, and where none is present, deferring, referring on and setting boundaries are not upgraded into a permanent exemption; when both parents are headed in the 15DD direction they can question each other; when there is no other co-caregiver, the external question is looked for among people and procedures actually available (PC35). How far lateral cross-checking among caregivers can generally go, between a person questioning himself and a fit institution, has not been argued.26
§9 The Propositions of the Whole Series
The propositions of the papers are listed together in the very words of each paper's propositions, with only a full stop added at the end; argument and qualification are in each paper. What still awaits proof is not here; see §8.
Paper 1, Another End
PC1 This series does not define all parent-child relations. The parent-child relation it reads has as its premise that the end of the father or the mother is headed in the 15DD direction: across one matter after another, headed toward treating the child as an end, and not merely as a means. The 15DD direction is a premise, not a component of the parent-child relation; the child never chose to enter, and no further requirement is made here that both sides avow it. There is no parent who stands purely at 15DD; people are all mixed; the direction is read by one operation at a time, falling back is read as it occurs, and it does not overturn the direction; after falling back, this end can turn back, own up to that occasion, and make some change in the arrangements and dealings that follow; where there is persistent refusal to turn back, the direction is no longer at 15DD.
PC2 Read relation by relation: father and child one relation, mother and child another; a single parent is read the same way. The relation headed in the 15DD direction is within scope; effects between the two relations are read by pairwise accounting, and the actual effect by which the other relation enters this one is entered in the instigator's relation.
PC3 The three kinds apply to a relation as a whole: a relation headed toward treating the child as an end is within scope, every matter within it is read, and the matter that falls back is read by its own direction and does not exit scope; a relation that treats the child merely as a means is not within scope, and the direction of colonization is read out by the reading of "only as"; a relation that does not treat him merely as a means, yet is not headed toward treating him as an end either, is also not within scope, and is only registered; these two kinds are both relations that on the whole remain in the 14DD direction and are not headed toward 15DD. In whichever kind, the occasion that crosses basic rights is, separately, a violation at the layer of basic rights. Scope is not the whole definition of the parent-child relation: not being unfolded in this series is no denial that it is a parent-child relation.
PC4 The child's standing as an end is full from the start; it is not conferred by the parents, nor revoked by them; what he can do grows, layer by layer, with his phase transitions. The two books are kept apart: "He's still little, he doesn't understand" at most describes what, in some matter, he cannot yet do; it does not lower his standing as an end, nor is it used to read his refusals uniformly as not yet understanding; nor, for the sake of recognizing the child, are the parents' own positions as subjects cancelled.
PC5 The child never chose to enter this relation, nor which conditions he would first enter; his own constitutive position does not on that account pass to the parents. That in reality he cannot do without the people who care for him does not give the caregivers the constitutive right over his value.
PC6 DD has two uses for parents and for the child: at the parent's end, 15DD is a stance, the direction in which one operation goes; at the child's end, DD reads emergence and maturation, and does not become a label. Whether the first-person position can already run of itself in a given domain is checked by domain; how a layer that has already emerged operates on the present occasion, facing this object, is read separately. The layer of a present operation is not used to judge maturation in its place, nor is it concluded from maturation by domain that the emergence of 13DD itself is by domain.
PC7 The object layer reads the relation in which the end of the father or the mother is headed in the 15DD direction; at the operation layer, the parent confirms only his own end. Which layer the child has reached in some matter is, from the parents' end, seen only in clues. If it is later confirmed that the direction premise of the relation being read did not obtain, the series does not unfold it as an object within scope, and does not turn and judge the other; one falling back within the relation is no ground for this exit, and the effects already read are kept on the books as before.
Paper 2, Securing in the Parent-Child Relation
PC8 The shape of the two layers already written out on the institutional side is borrowed to read what lies between the parent and the child: the Base Layer is to be secured, the Emergence Layer supported. The two layers are written apart and matter equally, and neither is traded for the other; protecting the child's basic rights lies on the side of anti-colonization and is not part of cultivation; acts of care and provision are not, in themselves, renamed cultivation; cultivation needs the two layers together, and the thickness of securing does not prove cultivation. The two layers are faces, and one and the same giving can be read two ways. On the side of the person, cultivation has a further reading as stance, coming from the parent's own law. The original speaks of institutions toward persons; it is carried here to the parent toward the child.
PC9 In the parent-child relation this series reads, the care and support a father or mother gives come from this end's own cannot-not: that the child needs someone to look after him is true; it enters the parent's conditions of occurrence and is avowed in his own law. This is this end's answering to its own law, not a duty owed to the child. The face of giving within it is read as entitlement, anchored in the giving the parent actually does; the child is the end this giving is directed at and does not hold it; the face of giving in securing and in support alike can be read as entitlement, not only in the Base Layer. The basic rights the child holds himself do not arise from this giving, and how his standing is protected belongs to the institutional side.
PC10 The child's basic rights have their standing in himself and are not conferred by the parents; how they are protected and by what rules belongs to the institutional side, and applies whichever direction the parents are headed in. On the occasion when a parent's effect crosses them, the relational side points out "this is a violation" and the boundary crossed; protection and disposition after the violation are handed over here, and what that effect left in the parent-child dealings is still read on the relational side.
PC11 Securing is not exchanged for the child's compliance, nor made conditional on his taking some particular road; how much support is given is not used to make up for a lack of securing; the two layers are not traded.
PC12 The child's dependency on care is not a dependency that was made, and carries no direction of colonization; the kind that was made and that has locked the path to saying no carries the direction of colonization; where one first monopolizes, or first induces dependency, and then withdraws, violation is checked separately at the layer of basic rights. Actual dependency alone, or factual irreplaceability, does not on its own yield the conclusion of violation.
PC13 Before 13DD, the child's crying and resistance are first read as signals to be answered, not as unreasonable fussing, nor brushed aside with "he's still little": first check whether care, safety and the rest of securing are lacking, and also check whether it is a prediction that has fallen through, or a negation coming into being; crying alone does not certify which layer he is at, or his particular reason.
PC14 The content of the securing layer shifts with the child's phase transitions, and is not withdrawn with them; how securing is drawn back once 14DD has come to stand is read in Paper 7. After the parents part, each one's relation with the child remains, and is not settled by the exit between the two; the side of shared child-rearing between the two belongs to Marriage Theory.
Paper 3, Support in the Parent-Child Relation
PC15 The parent-child relation is the setting in which cultivation may happen, not the source of cultivation. Support gives conditions, and the content grows out of the child himself; the completion of cultivation is not in the enactor's hands, and incomplete cultivation is not colonization (these two sentences belong to the value layer, and colonization here takes the value layer's narrow sense).
PC16 Support has three things in it: teaching, nurturing and leading, and the three cannot stand in for one another; with the child's phase transitions the emphasis shifts from one to the next, and the earlier is not on that account withdrawn. "Nurturing" in the tripartite division follows the special usage of the education paper; the tripartite division is not used to cancel the possibility of cultivation in the broad sense at other stages.
PC17 Learning before 13DD, if it is still within the direct-write window, is read by the model of the Learning series: content is written in together with the situation of the time; this model is a structural hypothesis, and is kept within the limits the original paper lists; the reading is borrowed here to read the environment the parents give and its effects. Support in this stretch is a rich and safe environment. Forcibly writing a script the parents designate by means of the window period's high plasticity is checked for the direction of colonization on that one effect; the judgment is not completed merely because the content was chosen by the parents.
PC18 "For your own good" can be cultivation's self-justification and can be colonization's disguise; the difference lies not in the wording but in that one effect. Cultivation at 14DD negates false cannot-nots and does not implant a direction: what can be negated is the necessity an external requirement claims over the child; parents can withdraw requirements they themselves imposed and put forward reasons, but cannot cancel a purpose the child avows merely by saying "that's false"; whether it is his own cannot-not is not certified by the parents.
PC19 The meaning predicates on the parents' side are not copied onto the child; the child does not figure only as the parents' continuation, a link in continuing the line, or a security for old age.
PC20 The support given does not enter the child's compliance or achievement as repayment, nor is it used afterward to possess him: however much has been given does not make the child's later direction pass to the parents, nor give the giving side an authorization to decide his direction. Support can have particular content, a term and conditions, and is checked separately by whether it seals refusal and change of direction, and whether it takes basic securing, or what is already due, in exchange.
Paper 4, Arrangements in the Parent-Child Relation
PC21 The arrangements parents set for a child, and the household's rules, are read here only on their side between person and person, the part the institution does not provide for or that goes beyond its provisions; provisions concerning guardianship, role authority and constructs are acknowledged but not judged. What is read is how they become today's arrangements for the child's tomorrow: the layer of relation reads one and the same bearer's today toward his tomorrow; here it is the parents' today toward the child's tomorrow.
PC22 An arrangement is read by three questions: whether there is an arrangement transferring the authority to interpret as the first-person position matures; whether the refusals, deviations and restructurings the child gradually produces can really alter that arrangement, or are uniformly read as not yet understanding; whether the present configuration is marked as a present arrangement open to revision, or as a final content irrefutable in future.
PC23 The authority to interpret is handed over domain by domain as the child matures in each matter, not all on one day. Using a line that is externally fixed, not defeasible by the facts of a case, and applied uniformly across matters, to determine once that he has arrived in every matter or in none, carries a risk of systematic misclassification; a judgment that can be overturned by the facts, made matter by matter, and kept open to appeal and review is not in this class.
PC24 When 13DD emerges, the child's "no" is where negation first targets the other and the "I" is chiseled out; one "no" does not by itself certify that 13DD has emerged. Reading it uniformly as not yet understanding is exactly what the second question blocks. At the end of the father or the mother, what is read here is: keeping one's own direction, while not maintaining it by pressing down the child's negation; how one answers on one occasion is read by words and deeds, and does not on that basis certify which layer the parent as a whole is at.
PC25 The ex ante structural condition of a cultivative intervention, carried to the child, is checked at the parent's end, without first judging which layer the child has reached: whether this end's arrangements compress his authority, channels and practical possibility of refusing, interrupting, revising, exiting and restating himself. Where there is something he cannot yet do, it is checked separately for pre-occupation: whether his position for later first-person running and revision is sealed in advance, before he can do it. That the child cannot do it for now neither falsely claims that he already has the real capacity, nor on that account hands that position to the parents to pre-occupy. Rules of guardianship, of exercise on his behalf and of particular disposition belong to the institutional side.
PC26 Marking a present arrangement as a final content the child will be unable to refute in future is a signal of pre-occupation; to read it as pre-occupation further requires that the not-yet-running position be sealed shut before the gate runs of itself: the difference between maintaining and fixing is what this whole judgment turns on. An arrangement does not become pre-occupation merely by constraining the child. Colonization here takes the value layer's narrow sense.
Paper 5, Collisions in the Parent-Child Relation
PC27 At the 14DD turn, the child's own cannot-not crystallizes out of the remainder of 13DD and begins to meet the parents' law. Rebellion is not the mechanism of 14DD's genesis, but frequently serves as its behavioral byproduct, and can function as one of its confirmation conditions in boundary encounters.
PC28 In this stretch, the end of the father or the mother heading toward 15DD in one operation is read, in this matter, as: acknowledging that the child's cannot-not is his own, even if, as the parents see it, that direction will fail. Upstream writes this as the condition of cultivation in this stretch; here it is read, by the series' scope, as the direction of one operation, and falling back is read as it occurs.
PC29 Colonization at 14DD takes three forms: direction substitution, superego internalization, and full-support resistance removal; the third appears in the guise of support.
PC30 When the child's end appears as a requirement he bears in the first person and by which he goes on organizing his action, and it requires action incompatible with the parents' law in the same situation: whether that matter enters the Conflict Treatise is checked item by item against its two gates: the first asks after structure, with the object layer and the operation layer kept apart; the second asks whether the handling of this matter would put at risk the parent's own capacity to go on making first-person revisions and to go on being open to questioning, or might put the parent in the position of constituting on the child's behalf; this is not settled by the parent-child identity or by incompatibility itself. The parents do not certify whether his end is already a law of his own, nor cancel it on his behalf for want of certification; if the object later fails to obtain, this matter is exited, and he is not turned on and judged as not qualifying. What has not entered is read as dealings and collision.
PC31 Mutual chiseling is judged by process, not by identity: where parents and child, in some matter, enter one and the same reciprocal process and actually chisel open each other's judgments, there is mutual chiseling in that matter; it is not established by the parent-child identity or by the name of a stage.
PC32 Collision runs two ways: parent-child dealings may also lead the parents to re-examine their own law; whether it is actually rewritten is read by the process on that occasion, and falling back is read as it occurs. Where the child's refusal really altered an arrangement, it is entered that the arrangement was changed, not as either side's winning or losing.
Paper 6, Several Caregivers
PC33 Father and child, mother and child, grandparents and other caregivers and the child, each form a relation of their own; an arrangement set jointly is still read person by person in each relation. "For the child's sake" does not legislate for the two grown-ups.
PC34 An effect one caregiver has on the child by way of another caregiver does not release the instigator from his part.
PC35 A caregiver's reasons, interpretations and adjudications toward the child are not placed beyond examination: there is at least one route of external review not wholly under his control; being questioned is his own being questioned, and gives him no standing to interrogate another caregiver. Another caregiver can be one source of external questioning; where an institution exists that is fit for purpose, available, and not controlled by one party to the dispute, the principal screening may be borne by the institution; where none is present, a caregiver may defer, refer on, set boundaries, but may not upgrade these arrangements into a permanent exemption. When both parents are headed in the 15DD direction, the two can question each other: each places his own reasons, interpretations and adjudications under the other's questions; this gives neither the standing to interrogate the other; reflection after falling back may also be brought out this way. If no other co-caregiver can provide questioning of this kind, the source of external review is looked for separately among people actually available, or in fit procedures; the independence and effect of the route are checked by the particular arrangement.
PC36 Where one end is headed in the 15DD direction and the other treats the child merely as a means: the relation headed in the 15DD direction is read, and the other is only registered; registering the other only does not mean that the conditions it creates for the child stay out of the main text; the actual effect by which it enters this relation is read by pairwise accounting. The other relation's effects are entered in the instigator's relation, and the end headed in the 15DD direction does not avow or settle it on its behalf; what he does to block the other's acts is read by the particular arrangements and effects, and protection has grounds of its own; the side involving the replacement of guardianship belongs to the institutional side. The party that uses the child against the other party, where it falls to "only as," carries the direction of colonization.
PC37 Between a child one party brings in on remarrying and the later party there is another relation, with a different starting point: what each has avowed, and from when, is read by that relation. Grandparents and other caregivers are read the same way.
Paper 7, Handing Over and Leading
PC38 Coming of age is read structurally as the child's 14DD coming to stand: his own cannot-not has taken shape. It arrives domain by domain, not all on one day; coming of age in law is acknowledged but not judged.
PC39 Where, in some matter, his negation-gate can already run of itself, the position of raising and refusing in that matter becomes his own at once, and no one may seal it; this is not further conditioned on his 14DD already having come to stand. Being able to raise something is not the same as having it come to stand: whether the arrangement in that matter changes, if it also involves the parents' end or others, is read by each party's own law and by the dealings, and is not decided by any one party alone. In matters of his own direction, the parents do not interpret or avow in his place; once his cannot-not has come to stand in that matter, leading takes up from there. How the securing layer is drawn back is not conditional on which road he takes; in drawing back, actual dependency, the arrangements already formed, and the two senses of dependency are checked. On the side that has already turned into a relation between adults, what the parents give from then on is read as help between adults, or as something done together.
PC40 On the child's side, the test is that he is able to unfold without revolving around his father, and also able to unfold without revolving around his mother, read person by person; this is a test, not that he must in fact leave; being able is limited to constitutive independence, not real-world self-sufficiency.
PC41 Once 14DD has come to stand, what remains is mainly leading: the effect of leading can only be by personal demonstration; it is not a position with authority, and does not extend the structure of the parent-child relation. This does not widen into all later dealings between parents and adult children being allowed only demonstration; ordinary exchange and things done together are read by Relation Theory and Cooperation Theory. The child's own 15DD is his own affair.
PC42 Leading is read until it becomes one face of family affection between adults; no endpoint is set. From then on, what lies between parents and adult children is read by Relation Theory and Cooperation Theory, and conflict by the Conflict Treatise; the case of long-term care needed after coming of age is handed to a future series on relations of care.
§10 Drawing Together
This paper lays down no propositions, and proves no proposition at the object layer. What it says is this: Parent-Child Theory lies downstream on the relational side, the branch written last; it does not define all parent-child relations, and reads the parent-child relation whose premise is that the end of the father or the mother is headed in the 15DD direction; people are all mixed, falling back is read as it occurs, and having fallen back, one can turn back; it reads relation by relation, with the three kinds applied to a relation; it borrows the two layers of the institutional side to read the securing and support parents give the child, and takes the child's phase transitions as one axis along which to read how the parents' end acts, the order being only an example; it reads until the child's cannot-not has come to stand in one matter after another, until handing over and leading, until this relation becomes one face of family affection between adults. The main line is: from the start he is another end; the parents guard him, give him conditions, and one matter at a time give back to him what they held for him. The directions of colonization read in the papers borrow things that are, or may come to be, between parents and child; the direction is read on the one effect in which they are taken up to do something.
Appendix: Pieces Handed Down from Upstream
The pieces Relation Theory Paper 0, §16, wrote for Parent-Child Theory, and the pieces Marriage Theory and Cooperation Theory handed over, are placed as follows. This table is for readers who want to check against upstream; to read this series itself, it can be skipped.
| Piece | Source | Placed in Parent-Child Theory |
|---|---|---|
| Value Theory P3, V38, the three signals of pre-occupation (the commitment paper borrows only their shape; their main use is in Parent-Child Theory) | Relation Theory Paper 0, §16 | Paper 4, PC22, PC23, PC26 |
| Value Theory V42, "an incomplete cultivation is not colonization" | Same | Paper 3, PC15 |
| Value Theory P1, V14, the subject-to-be included | Same | Paper 1, notes; shared words |
| Meaning Theory P3, Y26 | Same | Paper 1, PC4, PC5; Paper 3, PC19; Paper 7, PC40 |
| Conflict Treatise §20, dependency and the ex ante structural condition | Same | Paper 2, PC12; Paper 4, PC25 |
| Conflict Treatise §2, shared child-rearing not settled by unilateral exit | Same | Paper 2, PC14 |
| Rights Theory P2, standing and exercise-bandwidth | Same | Paper 1, PC4 |
| On Rights and Entitlements, F34, the infant holding basic rights itself | Same | Paper 1, PC4; Paper 2, PC9, PC10 |
| Acknowledgment that requires no qualification and the realization of recognition on separate books (H13) | Same (given first by Relation Theory) | Paper 1, PC4 |
| The two senses of dependency (H47) | Same (given first by Relation Theory) | Paper 2, PC12; Paper 7, PC39 |
| Today's arrangements for tomorrow (the paper on time) | Same (given first by Relation Theory) | Paper 4, PC21 |
| Effects that carry the direction of colonization without passing through conflict (H46) | Same (given first by Relation Theory) | Paper 4, PC26 |
| The layer of guardianship belongs to institutions | Same | §1; Paper 1, Introduction |
| Entitlements handed down to Parent-Child Theory | Same | Paper 2, PC9 |
| Whether an infant's crying and resistance can be read as a boundary signal that cannot be overwritten | Same (awaiting proof) | Paper 2, PC13; §8 |
| Lateral cross-checking among several caregivers | Same (awaiting proof) | Paper 6, PC35; §8 |
| What lies between the child and the parents; pairwise accounting where three or more are involved | Marriage Theory Paper 6, MA34 | Paper 1, PC2; Paper 6, PC33 |
| How the test of Meaning Theory is read on the child's side | Marriage Theory Paper 6, the close; MA35 | Paper 7, PC40 |
| The child one party brings into the marriage | Marriage Theory Paper 6 | Paper 6, PC37 |
| Whether the parents' duty holds is a matter of right | Marriage Theory Paper 5, the passage on Kant | Paper 1, interfacing; Paper 2, PC9 |
| The child's side ("only as") | Marriage Theory Paper 5, MA31 | Paper 1, PC3, PC5; Paper 3, PC19; Paper 6, PC36 |
| The face of doing things together between parents and adult children | Cooperation Theory Paper 0, §1 | Paper 7, PC39, PC42 |
| The principles of marriage do not cover children | Foundational Paper 6, Appendix IV (cited by way of Marriage Theory Paper 6) | §7, the sixth remainder |
When pointing back, the restrictions of that place come along.
Acknowledgments
This paper is signed by Han Qin alone; the author decided every argument and choice and bears sole responsibility for the text. In drafting, the author used AI models from various developers as tools. The English edition is an independent rewrite of the Chinese text, not a translation; where the two differ, the Chinese governs.
Notes
- Relation Theory Paper 0, §16, lists the branches downstream: Love Theory, Marriage Theory, Parent-Child Theory, Cooperation Theory. ↩︎
- Relation Theory Paper 0 writes the division of labor between the two layers: Relation Theory in the abstract establishes only what all relations have; what holds only in one kind of relation is handed to the series on that kind of relation to argue. ↩︎
- Marriage Theory Paper 6, MA34: "What lies between the child and the parents is handed to Parent-Child Theory; where three or more are involved, dealings are entered on separate accounts, pair by pair". Marriage Theory Paper 5, MA31: "the child's side is handed to Parent-Child Theory". ↩︎
- Cooperation Theory Paper 0, §1: "Of a thing parents and their adult children do together, the face of doing it together is here; what lies between parents and child belongs to Parent-Child Theory." ↩︎
- Relation Theory Paper 0, §16: "The layer of guardianship belongs to institutions; it is between person and construct." On Rights and Entitlements, F34, on the two faces of being reared: "this is a division of analysis, not the bisection of an empirical event"; "The decisions a caregiver makes for the infant, the signatures it gives, the destinations it fixes, really do converge the infant's vector of action, and that is a real power." ↩︎
- Political Economy Paper 6, E35: "Two layers: the Base Layer is to be secured, the Emergence Layer supported." The same paper, Abstract: "Support may have particular content, but does not acquire the authority to decide a person's direction. Cultivation on the side of the institution and on the side of the person are read apart." The original speaks of institutions toward persons; borrowing its shape here to read what lies between the parent and the child is an extension, this series' own undertaking. ↩︎
- Education as Subject-Condition; the papers on the Terrible Twos, the Terrible Teens and Terrible Telos; Learning I to IV. ↩︎
- Laughter IV, Abstract: "15DD is non dubito: it is not only I who am an end; the other, too, is an end in itself. This acknowledgment is unidirectional: it is one subject's not doubting that the other is an end in itself (Methodological Overview, §1.7)". ↩︎
- Relation Theory propositions, as listed together in Relation Theory Paper 0, §15: H8: cultivation and colonization are "directions, not labels"; H16: "where the reading reaches the value layer, the value layer's narrow sense is used instead and marked on the spot"; H45: "These two sentences belong to the value layer". ↩︎
- Political Economy Paper 3, E14a: "'Securing' is used for supply in the Base Layer, and kept apart from 'support,' which gives conditions for people's emergence." ↩︎
- On Rights and Entitlements, F27: "Entitlement is anchored in the giving of the granting end, not in the receiving end"; F34: "Rearing, feeding, cultivation are all the caregiver's giving; the infant is the end it is directed at and does not thereby hold a thing." ↩︎
- Rights Theory Paper 0, M1: "SAE Rights Theory has no concept of a duty toward others; it has only one inward duty, the subject's answerability to its own law". ↩︎
- Value Theory P1, V3: "The negation-gate is that structural juncture at which a subject, within its own law, says no to content laid upon it, and questions and negates the construct it has produced". ↩︎
- On Rights and Entitlements, F34a, writes of a maturing child: "The child's gate can, at some place, already self-exercise"; Theory of Government Paper 2 cites F33: "What is gradual is the negation-gate's function—the range of its self-exercise, its stability, its capacity to partition domains." ↩︎
- That Child (Interfaces with the Philosophy of War, Volume VIII), reading Nitobe: "he holds that the interests of a house and of its members are one and indivisible, and by that the child's standing as an independent end is cancelled". ↩︎
- Value Theory P1, V3: "A subject-to-be enters the domain of bearers on the equal standing of already being an end, its negation-gate's function still in genesis"; V14 includes the subject-to-be (by way of Relation Theory Paper 0, §16); On Rights and Entitlements, F33: "the rights of the subject-to-be are grounded in its already being an end, not in its coming-to-be". ↩︎
- Locke, Two Treatises of Government, Second Treatise, ch. 6, §§55, 58–61, 65. Paraphrased after the Liberty Fund electronic text of the edition by T. Hollis (London: A. Millar et al., 1764). ↩︎
- Rousseau, Émile, ou De l'éducation (1762), Book II: the passages on the two kinds of dependence, on the earliest education as merely negative, and on the tutor's ordering of the surroundings. Paraphrased after the Liberty Fund electronic text of B. Foxley's translation, Emile, or Education (London: J. M. Dent & Sons; New York: E. P. Dutton, 1921). ↩︎
- Kant, Metaphysik der Sitten, Rechtslehre, §28; Über Pädagogik; the 1793 essay on the common saying (by way of Political Economy Paper 6: such a government "is the greatest conceivable despotism"; ist der größte denkbare Despotismus). Marriage Theory Paper 5, reading this section of the Doctrine of Right: "whether the parents' duty holds is a matter of right". Locations in the Academy edition: §28, AA 6:280–281; Über Pädagogik, AA 9:453; the 1793 essay, AA 8:290–291. The rest is paraphrased. ↩︎
- Hegel, Grundlinien der Philosophie des Rechts, §174, including its Addition (Zusatz), and §175. The main text of §174 speaks of the parents' right over the children's Willkür, "in Zucht zu halten und zu erziehen"; the Addition speaks of breaking the child's Eigenwille. The English is checked against the electronic transcription of T. M. Knox's translation (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1952); located by section number. Otherwise paraphrased. ↩︎
- SAE's reading of the Analects, Part I, has annotated "Wei Zheng" 2.6 and "Li Ren" 4.18; the English renderings follow it. Relation Theory Paper 0 reads the five relationships and the differential mode of association. ↩︎
- Gibran, The Prophet (first published by Alfred A. Knopf, New York, 1923), "On Children." Paraphrased from Project Gutenberg eBook No. 58585. ↩︎
- The Terrible Twos paper interfaces with Spitz, Winnicott, Mahler, Piaget, Erikson and attachment research; the Terrible Teens paper with Erikson, Kohlberg and Marcia. ↩︎
- Theory of Government Papers 2 and 3. ↩︎
- How Is Institution Possible (Foundational Paper 6), Appendix IV: "This is a vast remainder, left for those who have children to chisel on their own" (also cited in Marriage Theory Paper 6). ↩︎
- Relation Theory Paper 0, §16, hands to Parent-Child Theory, as questions awaiting proof, "whether an infant's crying and resistance can be read as a boundary signal that cannot be overwritten, and lateral cross-checking among several caregivers". ↩︎
References
All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version.
I · This series
Qin, H. (2026). Another End (SAE Parent-Child Theory, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24121537
Qin, H. (2026). Securing in the Parent-Child Relation (SAE Parent-Child Theory, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24121539
Qin, H. (2026). Support in the Parent-Child Relation (SAE Parent-Child Theory, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24121541
Qin, H. (2026). Arrangements in the Parent-Child Relation (SAE Parent-Child Theory, Paper 4) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24121547
Qin, H. (2026). Collisions in the Parent-Child Relation (SAE Parent-Child Theory, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24121552
Qin, H. (2026). Several Caregivers (SAE Parent-Child Theory, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24121556
Qin, H. (2026). Handing Over and Leading (SAE Parent-Child Theory, Paper 7) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24121559
II · SAE works directly cited in this paper
Qin, H. (2026). The Place of Relation Theory (SAE Relation Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545115
Qin, H. (2026). For One Not Yet Here (SAE Marriage Theory, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23819245
Qin, H. (2026). Three (SAE Marriage Theory, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23819255
Qin, H. (2026). The Place of Cooperation Theory (SAE Cooperation Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24029128
Qin, H. (2026). How Subjecthood Is Not Swallowed by Conflict Itself (SAE Conflict Treatise) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22313628
Qin, H. (2026). On How Rights Presuppose No Duty (SAE Rights Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21285136
Qin, H. (2026). On the Thickness and Boundary of Basic Rights (SAE Rights Theory, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20769253
Qin, H. (2026). On Rights and Entitlements (SAE Rights Theory, Special Study) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21314907
Qin, H. (2026). On the Source of Value (SAE Value Theory, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21405207
Qin, H. (2026). On the Colonization of Value (SAE Value Theory, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21611154
Qin, H. (2026). The Half That Is Not Mine to Settle (SAE Meaning Theory, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22731235
Qin, H. (2026). Checks (SAE Political Economy, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874142
Qin, H. (2026). Support (SAE Political Economy, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874154
Qin, H. (2026). The Laughter of Despair and the Knowing Smile (SAE Laughter, IV) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23287669
Qin, H. (2026). Education as Subject-Condition: A Philosophy of Education [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18867389
Qin, H. (2026). What Terrible Twos Actually Is: The Structural Genesis of Self-Awareness [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19044827
Qin, H. (2026). What Terrible Teens Actually Is: The Structural Genesis of Purpose [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19201631
Qin, H. (2026). What Terrible Telos Actually Is: The Structural Genesis of Non Dubito [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19248039
Qin, H. (2026). Learning Through Memory and Prediction: The Construction, Window, and Cost of 11DD and 12DD (SAE Learning, I) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19426123
Qin, H. (2026). Learning to Scrutinize and Correct: The Emergence, Operation, and Cost of 13DD (SAE Learning, II) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19436811
Qin, H. (2026). Purpose-Driven Learning (SAE Learning, III) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19490707
Qin, H. (2026). Learning to Recognize the Other's Purpose: The Bridge from 14DD to 15DD (SAE Learning, IV) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19491926
Qin, H. (2026). That Child (SAE Interfaces with the Philosophy of War, Volume VIII) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22287173
Qin, H. (2026). Compulsion (SAE Theory of Government, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23413056
Qin, H. (2026). Guarantee (SAE Theory of Government, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23413112
Qin, H. (2026). How Is Institution Possible: From Inter-Ontological Remainder to Co-Constructive Framework (SAE Foundational Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19328662
Qin, H. (2026). Part I · The Instrument (Reading the Analects Through Self-as-an-End, Part I) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22656207
III · External works
Gibran, K. (1923). The Prophet. New York: Alfred A. Knopf. (first-publication details; text used: Project Gutenberg eBook No. 58585)
Hegel, G. W. F. (1820). Grundlinien der Philosophie des Rechts. (cited by section number; English after Philosophy of Right, trans. T. M. Knox, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1952, electronic transcription)
Kant, I. (1797). Die Metaphysik der Sitten. AA 6. (Academy edition)
Kant, I. (1793). Über den Gemeinspruch: Das mag in der Theorie richtig sein, taugt aber nicht für die Praxis. AA 8. (Academy edition; cited by way of Political Economy Paper 6)
Kant, I. (1803). Über Pädagogik. AA 9. (Academy edition)
Locke, J. (1764). Two Treatises of Government (T. Hollis, Ed.). London: A. Millar et al. (first published 1689; Liberty Fund electronic text)
Rousseau, J.-J. (1921). Emile, or Education (B. Foxley, Trans.). London: J. M. Dent & Sons; New York: E. P. Dutton. (originally Émile, ou De l'éducation, 1762; Liberty Fund electronic text)
Interfaces
- Main upstream: Relation Theory Paper 0 (§16); Marriage Theory Paper 5 (MA31), Paper 6 (MA34, the close); Cooperation Theory Paper 0 (§1); Political Economy Paper 6 (E35 to E38); On Rights and Entitlements (F27, F33, F34); Rights Theory Paper 0 (M1).
- Also used: Relation Theory H8, H16, H45; Political Economy Paper 3 (E14a); Value Theory P1 (V3; V14, by way of Relation Theory Paper 0); On Rights and Entitlements (F34a); Laughter IV (Abstract); Education as Subject-Condition; the papers on the Terrible Twos, Teens and Telos; Learning I to IV; Interfaces with the Philosophy of War, Volume VIII (Abstract); Theory of Government Paper 2 (registered; one sentence of F33), Paper 3 (registered); Foundational Paper 6 (Appendix IV, registered); SAE's reading of the Analects, Part I (pointed back to).
- This series: Lists together PC1 to PC42 of Papers 1 to 7.