Securing in the Parent-Child Relation
亲子关系的保障
This paper reads the Base Layer in the parent-child relation this series reads: the securing a father or mother gives the child. It borrows the shape of the two layers already written out on the institutional side to read what lies between the parent and the child: the Base Layer is to be secured, the Emergence Layer supported; the two layers are written apart, matter equally, and neither is traded for the other. Protecting the child's basic rights lies on the side of anti-colonization and is not part of cultivation; acts of care and provision are not, in themselves, renamed cultivation; cultivation needs the two layers together, and the thickness of securing does not prove cultivation. The two layers are faces, not two heaps of things: one and the same giving can be read two ways. The original speaks of institutions toward persons; carrying it to the parent toward the child is this series' own undertaking.
The care and support a father or mother gives come from this end's own cannot-not: that the child needs someone to look after him is true; it enters the parent's conditions of occurrence and is avowed in his own law. This is this end's answering to its own law, not a duty owed to the child. The face of giving within it is read as entitlement, anchored in the giving the parent actually does; the child is the end this giving is directed at and does not hold it; the basic rights the child holds himself do not arise from this giving. How the child's basic rights are protected, and by what rules, belongs to the institutional side; on the occasion when a parent's effect crosses them, the relational side points out "this is a violation" and the boundary crossed; protection and disposition after the violation are handed over here, and what that effect left in the dealings is still read by this relation. Securing is not exchanged for the child's compliance, nor made conditional on his taking some particular road; the two layers are not traded.
The child's dependency on care is not a dependency that was made, and carries no direction of colonization; the kind that was made and that has locked the path to saying no carries the direction of colonization; where one first induces dependency and then withdraws, violation is checked separately at the layer of basic rights. Before 13DD, the child's crying and resistance are first read as signals to be answered: first check whether securing is lacking, and also check whether it is a prediction that has fallen through, or a negation that is coming into being; his crying alone does not certify which layer he is at. The content of the securing layer shifts with the child's phase transitions, and is not withdrawn with them; after the parents part, each one's relation with the child remains. This paper interfaces with the Analects, Locke and Hegel. It does not prove that parents owe the child some duty, nor that parents who give more care are better, nor that all dependency is harmless.
Introduction
The few days He Zhou had a fever, Lin Wan was away on a business trip, and He Chuan took leave and stayed home. The first night the fever ran very high; He Chuan got up every two hours to take his temperature, sponge him down and give him water; at daybreak he took him to the hospital, queued, had blood drawn, collected the medicine, and came home and cooked rice porridge. On the third day the fever broke; He Zhou sat up in bed wanting to watch cartoons, and He Chuan sat beside him, answering a few emails that had been waiting for two days.
Lin Wan phoned and asked He Chuan whether he was tired. He Chuan said: "Tired, sure. But with him burning up like that, what else was I going to do?"
Nothing needs saying about this as a rule: a child is ill, and the father looks after him. But what does He Chuan's "what else was I going to do" say? Were those nights of care something he owed He Zhou? If they were owed, could He Zhou claim them from him? If they were not owed, how is this care taken on? Where care is not delivered, how are the effects already left entered on the books? Had He Chuan not taken leave those days, and left He Zhou at home on his own, how would that be read, and by whom?
What this paper reads. The parent-child relation this series reads has as its premise that the end of the father or the mother is headed in the 15DD direction, and it is read relation by relation.1 This paper reads the Base Layer within such a relation: the securing a father or mother gives the child.
This paper reads seven things. First, the two layers: the Base Layer is to be secured, the Emergence Layer supported; where this shape is borrowed from, and how it is read once borrowed. Second, where securing comes from: this end's own cannot-not, and entitlement. Third, the child's standing and violation: what belongs to the institutional side, and how far the relational side reads. Fourth, that securing is not made conditional. Fifth, the two senses of dependency. Sixth, the child's signals before 13DD. Seventh, how securing shifts with the phase transitions, and what happens after the parents part.
On each of these, the direction of colonization can be read; violation is judged separately, and only at the layer of basic rights.2
Shared words. "Securing" and "support" are used apart, as on the institutional side: "securing" is used for supply in the Base Layer; giving conditions for a person's emergence is called "support."3 The institution's guarding of the child's basic rights this paper writes as "protection," not "securing," so that the two senses do not run together.
"Entitlement" follows the usage on the side of rights: it is anchored in the giving end; it is one person's giving to another, and the child is the end this giving is directed at.4 It is not something in the child's hands, nor a discounted right.
The word "duty" this series does not use between parents and child. What a father or mother gives is written as this end's own cannot-not. A legal duty of maintenance belongs to the institutional side.
Method. As in Paper 1. This paper borrows the two layers of the institutional side to read a relation between two persons; the original speaks of institutions toward persons, and carrying it to the parent toward the child is marked in the notes wherever it occurs, as this series' own undertaking.
§1 Two Layers
PC8 The shape of the two layers already written out on the institutional side is borrowed to read what lies between the parent and the child: the Base Layer is to be secured, the Emergence Layer supported. The two layers are written apart and matter equally, and neither is traded for the other; protecting the child's basic rights lies on the side of anti-colonization and is not part of cultivation; acts of care and provision are not, in themselves, renamed cultivation; cultivation needs the two layers together, and the thickness of securing does not prove cultivation. The two layers are faces, and one and the same giving can be read two ways. On the side of the person, cultivation has a further reading as stance, coming from the parent's own law. The original speaks of institutions toward persons; it is carried here to the parent toward the child
A borrowed shape
The institutional side reads how an institution treats the people within it and divides two layers: the Base Layer, where people must first live and be safe, is to be secured; the Emergence Layer, where people grow into themselves, is to be supported. The Base Layer does not rise or fall with assets and is not exchanged for achievement; what the Emergence Layer gives is conditions, the content being decided by people themselves. The demands of the two layers are written apart; the two layers matter equally, and neither is traded for the other.5
Borrowed into what lies between a parent and a child, this shape reads very directly: He Zhou needs to eat, to sleep, to be kept warm, to be seen to when ill; this is the Base Layer. He Zhou needs to learn things, to try things, to have things of his own; this is the Emergence Layer. The original speaks of institutions toward persons; here it is one person toward another; what is borrowed is the shape, and the step of carrying it over is this series' own undertaking.6
Securing is not part of cultivation
The institutional side has a sentence: securing basic rights lies on the side of anti-colonization and is not part of cultivation. The subject of this sentence is securing basic rights: guarding the line between person and person.7 Carried to what lies between parents and child: guarding the child's basic rights is the face that blocks colonization, and is not on that account entered as cultivation; acts of care and provision are not, in themselves, renamed cultivation either.8
So He Chuan's taking temperatures, sponging and cooking porridge through those nights, however thorough the care, is not on that account cultivation. This sentence does not diminish those nights. Cultivation needs the two layers together: securing in the Base Layer, support in the Emergence Layer; it fails if either is missing; securing is one of the preconditions of cultivation, not a part of it. The thickness of securing does not prove cultivation.9
Faces, not two heaps
What the two layers divide is two faces of one and the same effect, not the things of life sorted into two heaps. One and the same giving can be read two ways.10 With He Zhou's fever broken, He Chuan sits beside the bed watching cartoons with him: this afternoon holds up a child just past an illness who needs someone beside him, and that is the face of the Base; He Zhou asks why the sea in the cartoon is green, and He Chuan puts down his laptop and looks it up with him, which gives conditions for his unfolding, and that is the face of Emergence. The two faces are read separately, without first having to decide which heap this afternoon belongs to.
On the side of the person
When the institutional side reads the two layers, it reads conditions on the institution's side: whether they were given, whether enough was given, whether one layer was traded for the other. Cultivation on the side of the institution and on the side of the person are read apart.11 What this series reads is the side of the person: which way one effect of the parent is headed, coming from the parent's own law. So in reading securing this paper does not ask only how much was given; it also reads whether, in giving, this end was headed toward treating the child as an end, or merely as a means (Paper 1).
§2 Where Securing Comes From
PC9 In the parent-child relation this series reads, the care and support a father or mother gives come from this end's own cannot-not: that the child needs someone to look after him is true; it enters the parent's conditions of occurrence and is avowed in his own law. This is this end's answering to its own law, not a duty owed to the child. The face of giving within it is read as entitlement, anchored in the giving the parent actually does; the child is the end this giving is directed at and does not hold it; the face of giving in securing and in support alike can be read as entitlement, not only in the Base Layer. The basic rights the child holds himself do not arise from this giving, and how his standing is protected belongs to the institutional side
That the child needs looking after is true
He Chuan says: "With him burning up like that, what else was I going to do?" What this sentence speaks of is not a debt. That He Zhou, burning up like that, needs someone to look after him is true; this true thing enters He Chuan's conditions of occurrence, and he avows it in his own law: in this matter, he cannot not look after him.12 This cannot-not is He Chuan's. It goes out from He Chuan's end; it is not something He Zhou claimed from him.
This is said only within the parent-child relation this series reads. When the true thing that the child needs looking after is avowed in this end's own law, it becomes this end's own cannot-not. What is read here is how this one taking-on happens; a relation's direction premise does not guarantee that every piece of care has been delivered. Nor does the series say that this care is bound to be there: the face that must be there, how the child's basic rights are protected and the legal duty of maintenance, belongs to the institutional side (§3); what is said here is where, for a father or mother within scope, it comes from.
Not a duty owed
Writing this care as the parents' duty to the child looks weightier: the child has a right to demand it, the parents a responsibility to give it. This series has no concept of a duty toward others; it has only one inward duty: the subject's answerability to its own law.13 He Chuan's care through those nights is his answering to his own law, not his owing He Zhou something.
Written this way, the care is not made lighter. Commitment binds a person by where I myself stand and by the effects already left, not by my owing the other party something;14 parents looking after a child are the same: what binds this end is this end's own cannot-not, and the effects that have already landed on the child. The legal duty of maintenance is another matter, and belongs to the institutional side: whether the parents' duty holds is a matter of right.15
What is set out here is how He Chuan takes on care in his own law; it does not on this basis decide whether He Zhou can demand care. The looking after already taken on, and the actual dependency already formed, are not cleared from the books by writing them in another concept; whether He Zhou's basic rights are crossed is read by the next section; taking it on and then withdrawing is read by §5.
The face of giving is read as entitlement
What He Chuan gave through those nights has a face of giving: time, effort, the wages docked for his leave, that pot of porridge. This face is read as entitlement: entitlement is anchored in the giving end, in the giving, not in the end that receives.16 He Zhou is the end this giving is directed at, and does not hold it; it is not that he has one more thing in his hands, but that there is someone giving to him.
The face of giving is not only in the Base Layer. Feeding and rearing are giving; giving conditions for his unfolding, looking up with him why that sea is green, is giving too.17 In securing and in support alike, every face of giving can be read as entitlement, checked by the structure of each piece of giving.
Basic rights do not arise from giving
One thing is not in this giving: the child's own basic rights. He Zhou's share in not being harmed, not being starved, not being shut away is not something He Chuan gave, nor does it arise from He Chuan's care through those nights; its standing lies in He Zhou himself, he holds it himself, and it has been there from the start.18 How this share is protected, and by what rules, belongs to the institutional side (§3).
§3 Standing and Violation
PC10 The child's basic rights have their standing in himself and are not conferred by the parents; how they are protected and by what rules belongs to the institutional side, and applies whichever direction the parents are headed in. On the occasion when a parent's effect crosses them, the relational side points out "this is a violation" and the boundary crossed; protection and disposition after the violation are handed over here, and what that effect left in the parent-child dealings is still read on the relational side
Standing lies in himself
The child's basic rights have their standing in himself. This sentence runs the same way as the first book in Paper 1: his standing does not wait for him to grow up, and nor do his basic rights. They are not conferred by the parents, and so the parents cannot revoke them either.
How they are protected belongs to the institutional side
Who protects a child's basic rights, how a crossing is judged, whether to intervene and how: these belong to the institutional side, which has institutional rules. These rules apply whichever direction the parents are headed in: parents headed in the 15DD direction and parents not headed in it meet one and the same set of rules.19
The series does not write this set of rules, nor does it evaluate them. What it reads is the side between person and person: within an institution, the part of what passes between persons that the institution does not provide for, or that goes beyond its provisions.20
Reading as far as "this is a violation"
Violation and the direction of colonization are two lines; violation is judged only at the layer of basic rights.2 On the occasion when a parent's effect crosses the child's basic rights, the relational side reads out "this is a violation," and which boundary was crossed. Protection and disposition after the violation are handed over here to the institutional side.
What is handed over is protection and disposition, not what that effect left in the dealings. After that occasion, what the child is like when he sees this father, what this father did afterward, what that occasion left in this relation: these are still read on the relational side, and entered on the books within this relation. Where parents within scope fall back to this step, it is likewise a violation; after turning back, it is still a violation (Paper 1).
§4 Not Made Conditional
PC11 Securing is not exchanged for the child's compliance, nor made conditional on his taking some particular road; how much support is given is not used to make up for a lack of securing; the two layers are not traded
Securing is not traded for compliance
The Base Layer is not exchanged for achievement.5 Carried to what lies between parents and child: eating, sleeping, being kept warm, being seen to when ill are not traded for the child's doing as he is told. If the child does badly in an exam, there is still dinner; if he talks back, he is still taken to be seen when he falls ill.
This proposition speaks of the face of securing. Parents can make demands of a child, can set rules, can decline to agree to something else when he has not done what was asked (Paper 4); this proposition does not govern those. It says only: the Base Layer is not put on the scales.
Not conditional on any one road
Securing in the Base Layer is not conditional on a person's taking some particular road.5 What the child learns and where he goes are matters of the Emergence Layer; whether or not he takes the road his parents want, securing stays as it was. This proposition bears most weight once the child has grown a direction of his own (Paper 5): the direction differs, and securing is not withdrawn.
The two layers are not traded
That the two layers are not traded runs two ways. One way is trading securing away: trading food and clothing for compliance, trading safety for his taking a certain road. The other is making up with support: having signed him up for many classes and bought him many books, one need not look to whether he sleeps well at night. Both ways trade one layer for the other.
One evening He Zhou was slow over dinner, eating and looking out the window, and Lin Wan said: "If you don't eat properly, you're not going out to play." On this occasion, the meal on the table was not withdrawn; going out was made conditional. The arrangement linking these two matters is read in Paper 4. Whether it also touches securing depends on what going out held up at the time. On its face, it links going out with eating, as though it pressed against "the two layers are not traded"; but the two layers are faces, and are not sorted first by the names "going out" and "eating": what going out held up at the time, what the restriction rested on, and what it actually took away, all still have to be looked at. That evening, He Zhou finished his dinner and went down to ride his bike for half an hour, and Lin Wan did not bring it up again. These facts are not enough to judge this example a trading of the two layers.
To see securing traded away takes a structural fact. A child does not take the course of study his parents designated, and the parents therefore withdraw the basic provision for his living they had given him before: this is an arrangement that hangs the Base Layer on a road. This series only registers this arrangement, and does not unfold its details.
§5 The Two Senses of Dependency
PC12 The child's dependency on care is not a dependency that was made, and carries no direction of colonization; the kind that was made and that has locked the path to saying no carries the direction of colonization; where one first monopolizes, or first induces dependency, and then withdraws, violation is checked separately at the layer of basic rights. Actual dependency alone, or factual irreplaceability, does not on its own yield the conclusion of violation
The child depends on care
People depend on each other in any case: a child on care, a patient on treatment, an apprentice on a master.21 He Zhou's depending on He Chuan through those nights of fever is not a dependency He Chuan made; He Zhou needed looking after in any case. It carries no direction of colonization.
The kind that was made
What is judged to carry the direction of colonization is that kind alone: it was made, and it locked the channel of saying no.21 Something a child could do himself, the parents keep doing for him until he cannot, and then use his inability to stop him trying for himself; or the parents cut off, one by one, the child's dealings with other grown-ups until only they are left, and then use "you can't do without me" to block his "no." In these two, the dependency was made, and the path to saying no has been locked too.
This proposition reads the effect, not the mind. Parents doing something for a child can be no more than being short of time that day; to read out the kind that was made, one has to see where the arrangement has actually taken that path.
First inducing dependency, then withdrawing
There is one more kind, checked separately at the layer of basic rights: first monopolizing a person's dependency, or first inducing it, and then withdrawing.22 All of a child's care is in one person's hands, and this person withdraws while the child still cannot do without him, leaving no other care: this is checked for violation at the layer of basic rights.
Dependency is not in itself violation
Actual dependency alone, or factual irreplaceability, does not on its own yield the conclusion of violation.23 That He Zhou wants only He Chuan to tell him stories, and no one else will do, is not a violation; that in the year He Chuan was raising him alone he was in fact irreplaceable is not a violation either. To read out a violation takes an effect that crosses basic rights.
§6 Signals Before 13DD
PC13 Before 13DD, the child's crying and resistance are first read as signals to be answered, not as unreasonable fussing, nor brushed aside with "he's still little": first check whether care, safety and the rest of securing are lacking, and also check whether it is a prediction that has fallen through, or a negation coming into being; crying alone does not certify which layer he is at, or his particular reason
First read as signals to be answered
Before He Zhou could talk, he often woke in the night. For a while, even after being fed and changed he kept crying; Lin Wan walked him around a few times and the crying stopped, and as soon as she put him down he cried again. Later He Chuan found that the night-light had been broken those days, and the room was darker than usual. Once the light was replaced, he still woke in the night, but would whimper a little and go back to sleep.
For a child who cannot yet talk, crying and resistance are what he sends out. The series first reads them as signals to be answered: not as unreasonable fussing, nor brushed aside with "he's still little." Reading them as signals speaks of the parents' end: there is a sound to be answered, and someone must go and find out what has happened.
Checking all three
In answering, three things are all checked.
First, whether securing is lacking: hungry, cold, ill, uncomfortable somewhere. This is the Base Layer, and falls under securing.
Second, whether a prediction has fallen through: a familiar person has gone, a familiar thing has disappeared, something expected has not happened. That the night-light was broken and the room darker than usual is one clue bearing on a prediction falling through: once the light was replaced, he whimpered and went back to sleep; this is a clue, and cannot yet certify the particular reason He Zhou cried those nights. Refusing a specific object is, in the upstream decomposition, a predictive conflict, not a need of the Base Layer.24
Third, whether it is a negation coming into being: a slightly older child pushes away the spoon held out to him and turns his head aside. Negation first targeting the other is another matter (Paper 4).
The three are checked apart, but a single bout of crying is not first assigned to one class. Through those nights He Chuan and Lin Wan checked on his care and also changed his surroundings; these are things they did, and the child's particular reason at his end is still seen only in clues.
Crying does not certify
Crying itself certifies neither which layer the child is at nor his particular reason. A child crying can be hunger, can be the light, can be something else, can be all three at once. From the parents' end, only clues are seen (Paper 1).
Why not classify first
Reading crying at this time uniformly as a need of the Base Layer would mix the three into one. Being hungry, a familiar thing gone, pushing the spoon away: these three descriptions cannot stand in for one another; giving back the toy, holding out the spoon again, cannot on the strength of the act alone be called answering what he asked for. The upstream decomposition already writes securing safety apart from allowing predictions to fall through and leaving room for negation. At the other extreme, once he is fed and warm, the crying that remains is treated as nothing.
Checking the three first, and not classifying first, blocks these two extremes. Here how the parents check and how they answer are read apart, and no prediction about the child's later direction is made from these acts.
§7 Shifting with the Phase Transitions
PC14 The content of the securing layer shifts with the child's phase transitions, and is not withdrawn with them; how securing is drawn back once 14DD has come to stand is read in Paper 7. After the parents part, each one's relation with the child remains, and is not settled by the exit between the two; the side of shared child-rearing between the two belongs to Marriage Theory
Shifting, not withdrawing
What the securing layer has to do changes as the child grows. Taking the kind of order Paper 1 spoke of as an example: before 13DD, care, safety and answering his signals are what stands out on the face of securing, while support is there at the same time (the surroundings the parents give, read in Paper 3); once 13DD has emerged, safety gains one more thing: room for his "no" not to be punished; later still, as matters of his own multiply, securing gains one more thing: if something happens to him out there, there is a place he can come back to.25 The order is only an example; what shifts is the content, and the securing layer is not withdrawn with the phase transitions.
Later He Zhou took the bus to school on his own, and He Chuan no longer took him every day; when he ran a fever at night, he knew to get the thermometer from the bedside drawer himself. These shapes of care changed; that someone sees to He Zhou when he is ill, and that there is a place to come back to if something happens, did not.
How it is drawn back
Once the child's cannot-not has come to stand in one matter after another, how the securing layer is drawn back, Paper 7 reads. Here only one thing is said: drawing back, too, is not conditional on which road he takes (§4).
After the parents part
The parents' parting is a matter between two grown-ups. The side of shared child-rearing between the two is read in Marriage Theory.26 What this series reads is each one's relation with the child: He Chuan and He Zhou one relation, Lin Wan and He Zhou another. When the two part, these two relations remain, and are not settled by the exit between the two.27 Departure can happen; departure does not by itself settle that relation.28
§8 Interfacing with the Tradition
The Analects: nothing to worry about but illness. In the Analects, "Wei Zheng," Meng Wubo asks about filial conduct, and the Master answers: "Give your parents nothing to worry about but your illness." SAE's reading of the Analects has already annotated this chapter; it is pointed back to here, and not read again.29 The series and that chapter shed light on each other at one point only: a child's illness is something that falls at the parents' end and cannot be set down; He Chuan's "what else was I going to do" falls at the parents' end together with this sentence. Where they part: in its original place the chapter answers a question about filial conduct, and speaks from the child's end; this series does not read filial conduct, and reads only how the parents' end acts.
Locke: the parents' care. In Chapter 6 of the Second Treatise of Government, Locke says that parents take care of, nourish and educate their children out of the duty laid on them by nature, while the children cannot yet take care of themselves.30 The common question: where this care comes from. Where they shed light on each other: the care falls on the stretch in which the child cannot yet do things, and changes as he grows. Where they part: Locke writes it as a duty to the child; this series reads it as the parents' end's own cannot-not, and the legal duty of maintenance belongs to the institutional side.
Hegel: maintained from the family's common property. In the part of the Philosophy of Right on the family (§174), Hegel says that children have a right to be maintained and educated from the common property of the family.31 The common question: on what basis the child receives what he receives from the family. Where they shed light on each other: maintenance is not conditional on the child's first doing something. Where they part: Hegel writes it as a right of the child; this series leaves how the child's standing is protected, and the rules governing that protection, to the institutional side, and on the relational side reads the giving the parents' end does, as entitlement, which the child does not hold.
§9 Drawing Together, and Downstream
This paper has established seven propositions. Taken together, they say: the shape of the two layers is borrowed from the institutional side and carried to what lies between the parent and the child; the Base Layer is to be secured, the Emergence Layer supported; the two layers are written apart, matter equally, and are not traded; protecting the child's basic rights is not part of cultivation, acts of care are not renamed cultivation, and cultivation needs the two layers together; the two layers are faces, and one and the same giving can be read two ways; on the side of the person, cultivation has a further reading as stance. Securing comes from the parent's end's own cannot-not, is this end's answering to its own law, and is not a duty owed; the face of giving is read as entitlement, anchored in the giving, and the child does not hold it; the child's basic rights do not arise from the giving. How standing is protected belongs to the institutional side; the relational side reads as far as "this is a violation" and the boundary crossed; protection and disposition after the violation are handed over, and what that effect left is still read by this relation. Securing is not traded for compliance, nor hung on a road. Dependency has two senses: the child's dependency on care carries no direction of colonization, while the kind that was made and has locked the path to saying no does; first inducing dependency and then withdrawing is checked separately for violation; dependency is not in itself violation. Crying and resistance before 13DD are first read as signals to be answered; the three are all checked, and nothing is classified first. Securing shifts with the phase transitions, and is not withdrawn; when the parents part, each one's relation with the child remains.
This paper does not prove that parents owe the child some duty, nor that parents who give more care are better, nor that all dependency is harmless.
A question left open. Whether the crying and resistance of a child who cannot yet talk is a signal of need, a signal of a prediction falling through, or a boundary signal that cannot be overwritten: this paper has said only that the three are checked first and nothing is classified first; it has not said which of them cannot be overwritten, or in what sense.
What the next paper reads. He Zhou got better and began drawing a great deal; Lin Wan found him a teacher, and He Chuan said drawing won't put food on the table: what is it that this layer gives?
Downstream. Support in the Emergence Layer: teaching, nurturing and leading, the direct-write window, "for your own good," and support not being traded and not being used to possess, Paper 3 reads. The item in securing of "room for his 'no'," Paper 4 reads. How securing is drawn back, Paper 7 reads. Who among several caregivers looks after the child, and by way of whom, Paper 6 reads.
Acknowledgments
This paper is signed by Han Qin alone; the author decided every argument and choice and bears sole responsibility for the text. In drafting, the author used AI models from various developers as tools. The English edition is an independent rewrite of the Chinese text, not a translation; where the two differ, the Chinese governs.
Notes
- Parent-Child Theory Paper 1, PC1, PC2. ↩︎
- Relation Theory H9: "Violation is judged separately, and only at the layer of basic rights; it and the direction of colonization are two lines". ↩︎
- Political Economy Paper 3, E14a: "'Securing' is used for supply in the Base Layer, and kept apart from 'support,' which gives conditions for people's emergence." ↩︎
- On Rights and Entitlements, F27: "Entitlement is anchored in the giving of the granting end, not in the receiving end"; in the same study, entitlement "answers to the giving of another and is neither duty nor power". ↩︎
- Political Economy Paper 6, E35: "Two layers: the Base Layer is to be secured, the Emergence Layer supported. The Base Layer does not rise or fall with assets, and is not exchanged for achievement; securing basic rights lies on the side of anti-colonization and is not part of cultivation (Institution Theory Z15)"; the same proposition: "What the Emergence Layer gives is conditions, the content being decided by people themselves"; "The demands of the two layers are written apart; the two layers matter equally, and neither is traded for the other"; "Securing in the Base Layer is not conditional on a person's taking some particular road". ↩︎
- Political Economy Paper 6 reads institutions toward the people within them; this paper's carrying the shape of the two layers to what lies between the parent and the child is an extension, this series' own undertaking. The sentences from the institutional side cited in note 5 and notes 7 to 11, carried to what lies between parents and child, are likewise. E35 originally says "not exchanged for achievement"; §4 writes not exchanged for compliance, and this widening too is this series' own undertaking. ↩︎
- Institution Theory Paper 3, Z15: "An institution guards the lines between its internal subjects. Securing basic rights belongs here; it lies on the side of anti-colonization and is not part of cultivation." Political Economy Paper 6, E35, goes on at once: "the Base Layer is not the same as basic rights". ↩︎
- Political Economy Paper 6: "the act of securing is not itself renamed cultivation (Institution Theory Z15)". ↩︎
- Political Economy Paper 6, E36: "The thickness of securing does not prove cultivation. Cultivation needs the two layers together: securing in the Base Layer, support in the Emergence Layer; it fails if either is missing". ↩︎
- Political Economy Paper 6: "One and the same payment can be read two ways". ↩︎
- Political Economy Paper 6, Abstract: "Support may have particular content, but does not acquire the authority to decide a person's direction. Cultivation on the side of the institution and on the side of the person are read apart." ↩︎
- Marriage Theory Paper 6, in the section under MA36: "That the child needs someone to look after him is true; it enters each of the two people's conditions of occurrence, and each avows it in his own law, as each one's own cannot-not." That place reads husband and wife; here it is read relation by relation, by the same reading. ↩︎
- Rights Theory Paper 0, M1: "SAE Rights Theory has no concept of a duty toward others; it has only one inward duty, the subject's answerability to its own law". ↩︎
- Relation Theory Paper 3, H27: "Commitment does not turn into a duty to the other party; it binds a person by where I myself stand and by the effects already left, not by my owing the other party something". Carrying this from commitment to parents looking after a child is an extension, this series' own undertaking. ↩︎
- Marriage Theory Paper 5, reading the section of Kant's Doctrine of Right on parents, writes that "whether the parents' duty holds is a matter of right". ↩︎
- On Rights and Entitlements, F27; see note 4. ↩︎
- On Rights and Entitlements, F34: "Rearing, feeding, cultivation are all the caregiver's giving; the infant is the end it is directed at and does not thereby hold a thing." ↩︎
- On Rights and Entitlements, F34: "It holds basic rights of its own. This is anchored in its already, now, being an end; the host of standing is in itself, not to be violated". ↩︎
- Theory of Government Paper 2 reads a case in which a child is removed from the home and the matter goes to the family division of the court; Paper 3 goes on to read entitlements under the government's guardianship; that is the institutional side, and it is only registered here. ↩︎
- Relation Theory H11: "within an institution, the part of what passes between persons that the institution does not provide for, or that goes beyond its provisions, is within range; the relation between persons and constructs is not; the provisions themselves are acknowledged but not judged". ↩︎
- Conflict Treatise §20: "But not all dependency is colonization. People depend on each other in any case: a child on care, a patient on treatment, an apprentice on a master. Judged colonization is that kind alone: it was made, and it locked the channel of refusal." ↩︎
- Relation Theory H47: "Dependency has two senses: the dependency people have on one another in any case carries no direction of colonization; the kind that was made, and that has locked the path to saying no, carries the direction of colonization; where one first monopolizes, or first induces dependency, and then withdraws, violation is checked at the layer of basic rights by F20". F20 is in Rights Theory P5 (by way of Relation Theory H47). ↩︎
- Relation Theory Paper 5: "So actual dependency alone, or factual irreplaceability, does not on its own yield the conclusion of violation." ↩︎
- The Terrible Twos paper, in decomposing the steps by which negation occurs, writes: "The child is not refusing a specific object (that would be 12DD predictive conflict)". Relation Theory Paper 0, §16, hands to Parent-Child Theory, as a question awaiting proof, "whether an infant's crying and resistance can be read as a boundary signal that cannot be overwritten". ↩︎
- This passage is an example of one order, not a definition of development (Paper 1, §5). ↩︎
- Marriage Theory Paper 6, MA34: "What lies between the child and the parents is handed to Parent-Child Theory; where three or more are involved, dealings are entered on separate accounts, pair by pair". ↩︎
- Relation Theory H55: "unilateral exit does not settle the accounts"; H58: "shared matters that remain after parting are not settled by unilateral exit". ↩︎
- Conflict Treatise §2: "Departure can happen; departure does not by itself close those accounts"; the same section writes that, written this way, "it holds intimate relations, shared child-rearing, organizational role and public responsibility". ↩︎
- SAE's reading of the Analects, Part I, has annotated this chapter of "Wei Zheng" (2.6); the English rendering of the Master's answer follows it. ↩︎
- Locke, Two Treatises of Government, Second Treatise, ch. 6, §§56, 58, 67. Paraphrased after the Liberty Fund electronic text of the edition by T. Hollis (London: A. Millar et al., 1764). ↩︎
- Hegel, Grundlinien der Philosophie des Rechts, §174. Paraphrased. The English is checked against the electronic transcription of T. M. Knox's translation (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1952); located by section number. ↩︎
References
All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version.
I · SAE works directly cited in this paper
Qin, H. (2026). The Place of Relation Theory (SAE Relation Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545115
Qin, H. (2026). What a Relation Is, and What It Is Not (SAE Relation Theory, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545047
Qin, H. (2026). Commitment (SAE Relation Theory, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545023
Qin, H. (2026). The Sediment of Dealings (SAE Relation Theory, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545076
Qin, H. (2026). Asymmetry, Divergence and Ending (SAE Relation Theory, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545087
Qin, H. (2026). For One Not Yet Here (SAE Marriage Theory, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23819245
Qin, H. (2026). Three (SAE Marriage Theory, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23819255
Qin, H. (2026). How Subjecthood Is Not Swallowed by Conflict Itself (SAE Conflict Treatise) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22313628
Qin, H. (2026). On How Rights Presuppose No Duty (SAE Rights Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21285136
Qin, H. (2026). On Rights and Entitlements (SAE Rights Theory, Special Study) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21314907
Qin, H. (2026). Checks (SAE Political Economy, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874142
Qin, H. (2026). Support (SAE Political Economy, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874154
Qin, H. (2026). Guarding the Line (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23270766
Qin, H. (2026). Compulsion (SAE Theory of Government, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23413056
Qin, H. (2026). Guarantee (SAE Theory of Government, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23413112
Qin, H. (2026). What Terrible Twos Actually Is: The Structural Genesis of Self-Awareness [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19044827
Qin, H. (2026). Part I · The Instrument (Reading the Analects Through Self-as-an-End, Part I) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22656207
II · External works
Hegel, G. W. F. (1820). Grundlinien der Philosophie des Rechts. (cited by section number; English after Philosophy of Right, trans. T. M. Knox, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1952, electronic transcription)
Locke, J. (1764). Two Treatises of Government (T. Hollis, Ed.). London: A. Millar et al. (first published 1689; Liberty Fund electronic text)
Analects 论语, "Wei Zheng" 2.6. (Chinese text and English rendering as given in SAE's reading of the Analects, Part I)
Interfaces
- Main upstream: Political Economy Paper 6 (E35 to E38), Paper 3 (E14a); On Rights and Entitlements (F27, F34); Rights Theory Paper 0 (M1); Marriage Theory Paper 6 (the section under MA36); the Conflict Treatise (§2, §20); Relation Theory H47.
- Also used: Relation Theory H9, H11, H55, H58, Paper 3 (H27), Paper 5, Paper 0 (§16); Marriage Theory Paper 5 (the passage on Kant), Paper 6 (MA34); Institution Theory Paper 3 (Z15); Theory of Government Papers 2 and 3 (registered); the Terrible Twos paper; Rights Theory P5 (F20, by way of Relation Theory H47); SAE's reading of the Analects, Part I (pointed back to).
- This series: Takes up Paper 1, PC1, PC2, PC4. Paper 3 takes up support in the Emergence Layer; Paper 4 takes up the room left for "no"; Paper 6 takes up several caregivers; Paper 7 takes up how securing is drawn back.