Each Bears a Share
各担
This paper reads how the judgment layer falls within cooperation. When one thing is done together, the step that rules and arrangements do not cover has to be judged by people themselves; in the cooperation this series reads, the judgment layer has two shares: each judges his own share and answers for his own share. Neither party holds alone the adjudication of how this undertaking is done, and neither can declare agreement in the other's place; two judgments that fit together do not merge into a third judge either. Paper 1 has read that computation cannot stand in for judgment; this paper reads on whom the account falls once a judgment has been made.
Answering for, as this paper means it, faces inward: each one's judgments and what he has done cannot be acknowledged by someone else in his place, and the account falls on the one who judges; that is, the subject answers to its own law. It stands alongside commitment's not turning into a duty to the other party, and is not owing the other party a duty. The accountability registered in an institution, and the cell of liability, in which a position can be altered, do not sit in the same cell as answering for here, and are registered as background; how causation, fault and remedy are allocated is not given by this. What a person has done himself cannot be acknowledged by someone else in his place: a thing done was done by the one who did it; how it is told can change, the one who did it cannot; doing things together does not let what one has done oneself turn into something "we" did, something no one did. This sentence says only who did it, and does not judge who is at fault.
Contribution is not used to possess the other: trading "I have contributed" for the other's share of judgment, and recording the other's share as one's own, both carry the direction of colonization; writing one's giving as an account the other must repay is read in Paper 2; credit and authorship have an account of their own, and this series does not settle it. Breaking a commitment is entered on the books at the layer between person and person: breach of faith is entered apart, and from outside only non-fulfillment, obstruction and joint revision of the agreement are reported; it enters the other party's later conditions of occurrence, and expectation changes accordingly; the stretch that spreads through third parties is entered by pairwise accounting. Being entered on the books is not the same as having caused some visible loss; the face in which reputation, or a score taken as standing for it, is used by a position as a chokepoint belongs to Political Economy. This paper interfaces with Weber, Arendt and the Analects. It does not prove whose contribution is greater, nor does it lay down how what went wrong ought to be shared out.
Introduction
Lu Ding and Gu An work at the same small firm of transport planning consultants, and have been colleagues for six years. Last autumn the firm took on a commission from a district in the south of the city: in the old town, three bus routes run for most of their length along the same streets, and the district wanted to know whether two of them could be merged into one. The firm gave this job to the two of them to write together. The commission contract states that the report is delivered by the project team and signed with both their names. The firm also has a checker, who checks the method and structure of reports according to the firm's procedures; the procedures state that the raw data are not among the things checked. The firm's assignment was this: Gu An was in charge of the ridership data, taking six months of fare-card records from the bus company, cleaning them, merging the tables and compiling the counts; Lu Ding was in charge of the interviews along the routes, and of writing the conclusions. Whether the two had also agreed between themselves to look over each other's part before handing in the draft is written two ways below.
After the report was handed in, the district held an evaluation meeting. At the meeting an engineer from the district pointed out that the weekend ridership the report gave for Route 7 was nearly double the figure the bus company publishes. After the meeting it was found that the weekend data the bus company had sent were split across two tables, and a stretch of dates appeared in both; when Gu An merged the tables, that stretch went in twice. The sentence in the report, "Route 7's ridership is insufficient; it can be merged into Route 12," no longer stood on firm ground.
The engineer had barely finished when Lu Ding spoke first: "We didn't check it properly." Gu An said nothing at the meeting. That evening she wrote an email to the firm's checker and to Lu Ding: "The duplicated weekend stretch: I'm the one who merged it wrongly, when merging the tables." The day before the meeting, Lu Ding had asked her whether the weekend tables had been checked, and she had said: "I'll go over them once more tonight."
The two spent a week recomputing the weekend figures, and the conclusion was changed to this: Route 7's weekday ridership is insufficient; the weekend is to be looked at separately. After the recomputing, the weekend ridership was lower than the report had given, but the routes run fewer services at weekends to begin with, so whether the weekend is insufficient too has to be looked at separately. The district accepted the revised report, and from then on, when it gave the firm work, it required the raw statistical tables to be handed in along with it. In the firm's project ledger, this job was entered as "reworked once."
In this one matter there are several things that are ordinarily all called "responsibility." The step of merging the tables is something Gu An did; "We didn't check it properly" is something Lu Ding said out loud; the range of checking stated in the firm's procedures and the delivery stated in the contract are registered by institutions; the district's later requirement is the other party's expectation having changed; the entry in the ledger is a record. What this paper asks is this: what each of two people doing things together bears.
What this paper reads. It reads five things. First, the judgment layer: when one thing is done together, who judges the step that rules and arrangements do not cover. Second, answering for: which way answering for, as this paper means it, faces, and how it is kept apart from duty, accountability and liability. Third, what has been done: whether what one has done oneself can be acknowledged by someone else in one's place. Fourth, contribution: whether the effort a person has put into this undertaking can be used to possess the other. Fifth, breach of faith: how what was promised and not done is entered on the books between person and person. On each of these the direction of colonization can be read: passing what one has done to someone else to acknowledge, or turning it into something "we" did; trading contribution for the other's share of judgment; recording the other's share as one's own.
Paper 3 reads the rules of division of labor: how division of labor is set and how it is changed, and what a procedure both parties have already recognized governs.1 This paper does not repeat those rules; it reads on whom the step that remains falls once rules and arrangements have been set.
Colonization, in this series, names the direction of one effect: toward pouring in and occupying; the other direction is cultivation, toward making space. The two are not the two extremes of one scale; the same act can carry both directions, and can also carry no direction at all; the direction is read on this one effect, and whether it took hold is seen in the other party's later understanding and action.2 "Carries the direction of colonization" and "slides in the direction of colonization" both speak of a direction, and are not read as its having already taken hold.
Shared words. "Answering for," in this paper, is the inward one: the account falls on the one who judges, and the subject answers to its own law.3 It is not owing the other party a duty.
"Accountability" and "liability" are taken in the sense of On Accountability. Accountability is a demand standing at a position and awaiting an answer; its source lies in the power that converges upon the position, and what it binds is the position. Liability is the bearing of that position itself: it says that the position can be altered, and is not conditioned on fault.4 Both cells lie on the institutional side; this paper uses them as background and does not establish them again. Everyday speech, in saying "whose responsibility is it," often lumps these several things together; this paper uses neither "liability" nor the everyday "responsibility" for the inward share. When the Conflict Treatise says that "first-person responsibility cannot be borne by proxy," it uses the word in its everyday sense, and what it says is just the sentence of §3.5
"The judgment layer." The Theory of Inter-State Cooperation and Political Economy both speak in three layers, and there the judgment layer is handed to those in positions: "The judgment layer is how a particular act is judged under the rules; this layer is left to the judgment of those in positions, and the account falls on positions and persons."6 That is the institutional side, speaking to constructs. This series issues no ought to persons; the judgment layer here falls on each person himself.
"Reputation" and "fame" are used apart, as in Political Economy Prequel: "Fame is a medium on the 14DD side; it concerns how many people know of someone and how he is talked about. Reputation is the state that recognition relations naturally show within a community."7 §5 says more.
"Breach of faith" is entered, as in Relation Theory, as five kinds: dropping, falsity, non-fulfillment, obstruction, joint revision of the agreement.8
Method. As in the earlier papers: the conclusions of upstream papers are said in plain words; sources, the proposition numbers of other papers, and the places where upstream words are carried beyond their original place all go in the notes, and where something is extended, this series takes it on as its own undertaking. What has already been said at the relational layer is used here directly, not rewritten. This paper speaks only of structure, not of good and bad, and issues no ought: it does not judge who was more in the wrong, nor does it lay down how what went wrong is to be shared out.
Lu Ding and Gu An's job runs through the whole paper. The cooperation this series reads has as its premise that at least one party is headed in the 15DD direction, and further requires that both avow this undertaking and actually take part, and that the other is not, in this undertaking, reduced to calculation.9 The example is stipulated accordingly: both have avowed this report, and each does his own share; what Gu An cares about is that the figures stand up to scrutiny, and what Lu Ding cares about is whether the residents along the routes can get about conveniently by bus; what the two are for is not one thing, and what they do is one thing. This is a made-up example, used only to see structure; from outside, the two people's words and deeds are only clues, and do not certify who is at which layer. The procedures of the firm and of the district serve only as the factual record of this example; what the example does not write is recorded as not checked.
§1 Two Shares of Judgment
CO28 The judgment layer in cooperation has two shares: each judges his own share and answers for his own share; neither party holds alone the adjudication of how this undertaking is done, and neither can declare agreement in the other's place
The Step the Rules Do Not Cover
The firm's procedures set out how data are archived, how reports are divided into chapters, and which items the checker looks at; the contract sets out the date and format of delivery. These are the rules of this job. They decide a great deal, and leave not a little undecided. Three days in the six months of fare-card records are public holidays: are they counted in with the weekends? Where the two tables overlap, which one is taken as authoritative? In an interview an old man said, "Route 12 goes the long way round; I'd rather walk": does this go into the conclusions? The procedures do not say, the contract does not say, and the two did not touch on it when the job was opened.
The step that rules and arrangements do not cover is the remainder, and the remainder has to be judged by people. This series calls this layer the judgment layer: the remainder that neither norms nor rules cover falls on each person's own judgment.10 Paper 1 has read that computation cannot stand in for judgment: whether the given premises are enough to represent one's own situation, and whether one accepts them as the ground of one's action, has to be judged by oneself, and the computation cannot do it for one.11 This paper reads the other side: when two people do one thing together and the remainder falls, on whom it falls.
Exercises and Games of Judgment III reads two people dancing. The steps fix a turn on this beat; they do not fix which way to turn or how far to lead; the half step the partner leads further to the right is not fully taken in by the construct, and is remainder. That paper says: "That judgment is hers, and is owned by her; his half step is his, and she did not claim it on his behalf".12 The judgment layer in cooperation falls in this way: whoever's share the remainder falls on, that judgment is his.
Each Judges His Own
Whether the holidays count, and which table is taken for the overlapping stretch, fall on Gu An's share, and are judged by her. Whether the old man's words go into the conclusions falls on Lu Ding's share, and is judged by him. The two people's judgments are two shares, not one.
Two shares does not mean that each judges his own with no bearing on the other. When Lu Ding writes the conclusions, he uses Gu An's figures; whether Gu An separates weekend from weekday in her counts depends on the travel times Lu Ding's interviews brought out. What one share of judgment produces enters the conditions of occurrence of the other: each of the two is material for the other's judgment.13 Only, when the material comes in, the judging is still done by each. Lu Ding's writing the conclusions from Gu An's figures does not mean that he has thereby acknowledged in her place that those figures are right; Gu An's grouping by Lu Ding's times does not mean that she has thereby acknowledged the conclusions in his place. Each one's judgment is owned by each himself.
Having Used the Other's Material
When the weekend stretch was merged wrongly, Lu Ding's sentence "it can be merged into Route 12" lost the ground it had had. The error in the merging means that the conclusion drawn from it has to be checked again; whether the conclusion was in the end wrong is not decided by the material's error alone: the two later recomputed and changed the conclusion, and that is the result of checking again, not something the material's error by itself yields. There are two steps here, not one. The step of merging the tables is Gu An's; the step of drawing a conclusion from that table is Lu Ding's. Merging the tables, using this material and drawing the conclusion are several different acts, each recorded with the one who actually performed it; this does not directly give how causation, fault and remedy are divided. The judgment that drew the conclusion is still Lu Ding's, and the account is still with him.
Neither of the two can skip this point. If Lu Ding were to say, "If the conclusion has a problem, it's because the data were wrong; it's nothing to do with me," this sentence would be passing his own judgment in drawing the conclusion over to Gu An's table: that sentence of conclusion is one he wrote, and whether to use that table, and whether to ask before using it, are also judgments within his share. If Gu An were to say, "He wrote the conclusion; it's nothing to do with me," this sentence would be turning the table she handed over into something that counts only within Lu Ding's judgment: that table is one she handed over, and it entered his conditions of occurrence. One share of judgment built on what the other has produced is still one of two shares; an error passing from one share to the other does not turn the later share's judgment into the earlier one's, nor does it make the earlier share's step lighter because there is a further judgment after it. Which share was more in the wrong, this paper does not measure; it records only that both steps are there, each with its own person.
There is one place here that is easily misread. Two shares of judgment does not mean that every matter has to be judged once by each of the two. Lu Ding can say, "How the data are cleaned, you decide"; Gu An can say, "How the conclusions are worded, you write it first." This is the two placing a step within the other's share; it is an arrangement, and the step handed over is judged by the one who takes it up. It does not leave the one who hands it over without his own share of judgment from then on: whether to hand it over, how far, and when to take it back are still judged by himself. Handing over, as meant here, is placing one step of the thing both have avowed and are both doing within the other's share. When a person asks someone else for help and entrusts a whole matter to him, whether to hand it over and how far are likewise the judgment of the one who hands it over; whether that occasion is help or doing together is read as in Paper 1, and is not decided by this judgment alone.
How It Is Done Is Not Held by One Party Alone
How the report finally draws its conclusion is the thing the two do together. When Action Theory sets out doing things together, this is just what it says: the thing is one both avow and in which each has a share, "whose purpose and adjudication neither side holds alone".14 How that sentence of conclusion is written is not Lu Ding's alone to decide, nor Gu An's alone to decide; when the two sit down and go over it, what they go over is whether this sentence holds up for both of them.
What comes out of going over it is the two people's consensus. The consensus is real; it is not sameness. Action Theory states plainly that a concrete consensus can form without swallowing differences, and that "neither side can declare agreement in the other's place".15 If Lu Ding were to say to the district at the meeting, "We both agree on this sentence," when Gu An had not agreed, he would be declaring agreement in her place. From outside, this is only a sentence; what effect it comes to have is seen in how Gu An responds afterward, and how the two people's arrangement falls.
If the two had agreed beforehand that, when they judged the conclusions differently, the matter would go to the firm's checker to decide, that would be a procedure both had already recognized; what it governs is how this one matter is ordered, and Paper 3 reads it.16 When the judgment the procedure makes comes down and the two act on it, each one's judgment is still with each: acting on it is not the same as the two having come to judge alike.
Two Judgments Do Not Merge into a Third
When the two have gone over it once and decided on the conclusions, there are two people's judgments in the conclusions, yet no third party judging for the two. The sentence in the report, "This report judges Route 7's ridership to be insufficient," says that each of the two has judged and that their judgments fit together; it does not say that a "we" above the two has made this judgment.17 Paper 4 reads "we"; here only one thing is recorded: the two shares of the judgment layer do not merge into one because they fit together.
This point has its weight. Once two shares of judgment merge into one, the next step is two accounts merging into one book: this judgment was made by the "we," the account belongs to the "we" too, and who judged that particular step is lost. What §3 reads is just such a road.
The Judgment Layer on the Institutional Side
The firm's checker is in a position. He checks method and structure; what he judges is how this job is judged under the procedures, and the account falls on his position and on him as a person; that is the judgment layer of the institutional side, read as Political Economy reads it: "The judgment layer is the particular case; it is handed to judgment in positions, and the account falls on positions and persons."18 This series reads only the side that the institution does not provide for, or that goes beyond its provisions: what passes between person and person; the checker's position is registered as a condition, and how he judges is not read.19
Between Lu Ding and Gu An, neither sits in a position over the other. What the firm assigned was a division of labor; it did not assign one person to adjudicate the other's share. The judgment layer between the two falls on each himself.
§2 Answering For
CO29 Answering for, as this paper means it, is this: each one's judgments and what he has done cannot be acknowledged by someone else in his place, and the account falls on the one who judges; it faces inward: the subject answers to its own law. This stands alongside commitment's not turning into a duty to the other party, and is not owing the other party a duty. Existing institutional accountability is registered as background; how causation, fault and remedy are allocated is not given by this, and is not unfolded in this series
The Account Falls on the One Who Judges
The remainder has to be judged by people, and so it has to be borne by people too: for the step judged, the account falls on the one who judges. Gu An judged how the overlapping stretch was to be merged; this judgment is hers, and the step of merging was done by her; its account is with her. Lu Ding judged that the old man's words would not go into the conclusions; this judgment is his, and the account is with him. Answering for, as this paper means it, is just this: each one's judgments and what he has done cannot be acknowledged by someone else in his place; the account falls on the one who judges, and faces inward.
Rights Theory puts this layer most tightly: "SAE Rights Theory has no concept of a duty toward others; it has only one inward duty, the subject's answerability to its own law".20 Answering for in this paper is read by this: answering for is answering to one's own law, not owing anyone something.
Inward does not mean only in one's heart. Gu An's email was written out and sent to the checker and to Lu Ding; the step she acknowledged lands in the firm's records, and in the two people's later dealings too. Inward speaks of where the account falls: that step is hers, and her acknowledging it is an acknowledging within her own law; it is not that she came to owe it because Lu Ding demanded it of her.
Not Owing the Other Party a Duty
Read in this way, Gu An's merging the tables wrongly is not her owing Lu Ding a duty she has failed to discharge. Relation Theory writes of commitment that it does not turn into a duty to the other party, and that it binds a person "by where I myself stand and by the effects already left, not by my owing the other party something".21 Answering for within doing things together stands alongside this sentence. Gu An promised to do the data, and that promise is where she stands on her side; merging the tables wrongly left effects with Lu Ding and in the report. These are all there, and all are entered on the books, read in §5. Only, they are not written as something she owes Lu Ding, nor does Lu Ding thereby gain a position from which to demand repayment of her.
It may be said: if nothing is owed to the other party, then when something goes wrong, on what ground can the other ask? The weight of this objection is that people doing things together do need to be able to ask each other. But being able to ask does not require that the ground of asking lie in a duty. When Lu Ding asks, "Have those weekend tables been checked?", what he asks about is material his own share is to use; Gu An's answering is her avowing her share within her own law. Asking and answering are both there, and no account of what the other owes me has first to be set up before the question can be put. Relation Theory also states plainly, at the same place, that the promise spoken and the arrangements the other has made on its strength change the conditions afterward, and later judgment must count them in; only, this change is not written as a duty owed to the other party.22
Accountability and Liability: Two Other Cells
In the firm there are several more things bearing on this job, none of them answering for as this paper means it.
The procedures state that the checker checks method and structure, and the contract states that the project team delivers the report: these are demands standing at positions. On Accountability calls this cell accountability: its source lies in the power that converges upon the position, what it binds is the position, and once that registration is exited it is held no longer.23 Construct and subject alike can hold accountability: the firm, as a construct, holds the accountability of the contract toward the district; the checker, in his position, holds his.24 The firm can alter the checker's cell and have someone else check: the checker's position lies within the reach of the firm's power to assign checkers, and can be altered; the bearing of this cell itself is what that study calls liability, which says that the position can be altered and is "not conditioned on fault".25
Both these cells lie on the institutional side. This series registers them as background, does not establish them again, and does not read whether they are warranted. Answering for, as this paper means it, does not sit in the same cell as they do. Accountability falls on the position and is released by exit: if Gu An left this firm, the accountability the firm's procedures assigned her would, along with the registration, no longer be held by her. Answering for falls on the person's own law: the step of merging the tables, once she had left the firm, would still be something she did.
Nor does the one stand in for the other. That the firm's procedures assigned Lu Ding no accountability for checking the data does not mean that, between the two, he has no share of his own; if he had promised to look over Gu An's tables, that share is one he avowed himself (§3). Conversely, the checker's having checked the method according to the procedures, so that his share of accountability is discharged, does not acknowledge the step of merging the tables in Gu An's place either.
Causation, Fault and Remedy: Not Here
The weekend stretch went in twice; among the causes are the format in which the bus company split its tables, the overlap of dates between the two tables, the step Gu An took in merging them, and perhaps also too little time before the draft was due. This is causation. Whether this step counts as fault, how great the fault is, who pays for the week of rework, and, if the district delayed its decision because of it, how that delay is made good: these are several other accounts.
Answering for, in this paper, does not give these. The inward share says: whose that judgment is, who did that step, on whom the account falls. From this it cannot be derived who should compensate for what, or how fault is divided. On Accountability also states plainly that performance blocked, performance impossible, whether the accountability continues to stand, and how the attendant consequences are handled "do not follow automatically one from another".26 Each of these is checked separately by its own sources; this series does not unfold them, and what has not been closed out is recorded as it stands, as not closed out.
§3 What Has Been Done
CO30 What a person has done himself cannot be acknowledged by someone else in his place; a thing done was done by the one who did it: how it is told can change; the one who did it cannot. Doing things together does not let what one has done oneself turn into something "we" did, something no one did. This sentence says only who did it; it does not on its own judge who is at fault, or which consequences are borne by whom; what others each bear, and who is in charge of what within institutions, are checked separately per On Accountability, and are not closed out in this paper
Several Roads to Having Someone Else Acknowledge It
After the evaluation meeting, this matter was told in several ways. One could say, "The time on this job was too tight"; one could say, "The bus company's tables were split in a muddle"; one could say, "The checker didn't catch it either"; and one could also say, "We didn't check it properly." There may be a little truth in each of these. But what put that stretch in twice was the step of merging the tables, and that step is one Gu An did.
Action Theory Paper 8 has read a report, and says the same thing: "a thing done was done by the one who did it; the account of it can change, the one who did it cannot"; and also: "Doing things together does not let what one has done oneself turn into something 'we' did, something no one did".27 The Conflict Treatise, at its own place, writes the same sentence: "I cannot have my own action's first-person responsibility borne by someone else."28
Having it acknowledged by someone else takes two shapes. One passes it to another person: "Lu Ding had me merge it this way." One passes it to a "we," or to no one: "Everyone on this job had problems," "Something went wrong in the workflow." The latter is less conspicuous. Doing things together gives it a ready-made place: to call what two people did together something "we" did seems quite natural; and who merged that stretch is lost within this "we."
This sentence governs the one who did it himself: what he has done himself he does not pass to someone else to acknowledge. It governs others too: what someone else has done, I do not acknowledge in his place, nor excuse in his place. Gu An's step is hers; Lu Ding cannot acknowledge it in her place, nor can he excuse it in her place by saying "It wasn't you."
"We Didn't Check It Properly"
How Lu Ding's sentence at the meeting is read depends on the two people's prior arrangement. It is written here two ways.
In one, on the day the job was opened, the two agreed that before handing in the draft each would look over the other's part. The checking is an arrangement the two avowed together, in which each has a share: Gu An looks at whether Lu Ding's conclusions say too much, and Lu Ding at whether Gu An's tables fail to tally. Under this arrangement, "We didn't check it properly" says that neither share of the checking caught the error. Lu Ding is acknowledging his own share: he looked over those tables and did not catch it. This sentence acknowledges nothing in Gu An's place, and the step of merging the tables is still one she did; it speaks of another step, the step of checking, which both did, and in which neither caught the error.
In the other, the two never spoke of checking each other's parts: the data belonged to Gu An, the conclusions to Lu Ding, and the firm's checker, by the procedures, does not look at the raw data. Under this arrangement, the thing done together to which the "we" in "We didn't check it properly" points is not in the two people's arrangement at all. The sentence can come to have several different effects. It can be only a way of holding the situation steady at the meeting first, without singling anyone out in public: a public statement, after which who did which step is recorded as it stands. It can also speak of the step Gu An did as something "we" did, something no one did. It can further be Lu Ding's acknowledging her step in Gu An's place: her own share, acknowledged by him before the district.
Which of these it is cannot be decided from this one sentence at the meeting; it depends on how the arrangement falls afterward. Gu An's email that evening, "I'm the one who merged it wrongly, when merging the tables," is her acknowledging her own step; this acknowledging is hers, not Lu Ding's to do in her place, nor his to excuse in her place. If the firm's records afterward are kept according to her email, Lu Ding's sentence stops at a public statement. If Lu Ding afterward insisted to the firm that the two had been wrong together, and kept her email out of the records, he would be acknowledging in her place, and also turning her step into something "we" did; this effect falls on her, deciding for her what what she did counts as, and slides in the direction of colonization. The example goes only as far as her email; the later conditions are insufficient, and this point is left undetermined.
In the two arrangements the word "we" is the same, and what it points to is not. In the first, it points to a checking the two avowed together; in the second, there is no such thing for it to point to. The "we" in a sentence is read by where it lands in that arrangement, not by the letter.
The same sentence spoken by Gu An is read differently again. Under the second arrangement, if she had said "We didn't check it properly" at the meeting, and afterward no longer said that she herself had merged it wrongly, she would have put the step she did into a "we"; that step would be lost within this "we," while what this "we" points to is not in the arrangement. The speaker changes, the sentence does not, and the effect it comes to have changes: when Lu Ding says it, it may be acknowledging in her place; when she says it, it may be pushing her own step away. Both touch one and the same thing: who did that step.
Saying Only Who Did It
This sentence goes only this far: who did that step. It does not on its own judge who is at fault. If the format in which the bus company split its tables made duplication easy to begin with, that step is still one Gu An did, and how great the fault is, is checked separately; under the first arrangement Lu Ding did not catch it either, and he too did the step of checking, which is something he did; whether there is fault there, and how great, is also checked separately.
Who did it, and which consequences are borne by whom, are not one thing either. Action Theory states plainly at the same place: what others each bear in the matter, and who is in charge of what within institutions, are referred back to what On Accountability has established, and the rest is registered openly.29 On whose hours the week of rework is booked, how the firm accounts for itself to the district, whether the checker's procedures are to be changed: these are checked separately by the firm's procedures and by On Accountability, and this paper does not close them out.
There is one more thing not closed out: what comes after acknowledging. Gu An has acknowledged the step of merging the tables; how she regards this judgment of hers afterward, and how she merges tables on the next job, are matters within her own law, and this paper does not speak for her. Acknowledging is not a ritual, nor a settling of the account; it only lets that step stay with the one who did it.
The Name of "We"
On the institutional side there is a sentence of the same form. Political Economy says: "The construct's name does not shield an individual responsibility that has independent grounds"; "particular operations that have been established can be attributed to the positions and persons that made them".30 That is said of constructs: under a company's name, a particular operation can still be attributed to the one who did it. Two people doing things together have no construct, yet they too have a name: "we." This paper reads by the shape of that sentence, taking only its form and not borrowing its institutional judgment: the name of "we" does not shield the one who did that step either.
Whether "we" can separately come to hold as a bearer that bears things for the two is read in Paper 4; Relation Theory has established only that a little circle of two does not form a third bearer.31 This paper records only one thing: the "we" in doing things together is not where that step goes.
§4 Contribution
CO31 Others are not possessed under "I have contributed"; recording the other's share as one's own carries the direction of colonization; writing one's own giving as an account the other must repay is read as in Paper 2. What these read is one effect within the process; how credit and authorship are reckoned is a separate account, and this series does not settle it
Trading Contribution for Adjudication
In the week of recomputing the weekend figures, Gu An stayed up three nights running. The next spring the firm gave the two another job, and when it was opened Gu An said: "Last time I was the one who stayed up and saved it; this time, how the conclusions are written, we do it my way."
The first half of this sentence is fact: the recomputing was mostly hers. The second half trades this fact for adjudication over the thing done together. Action Theory Paper 9, writing that guarding comes back to the individual, has among its three sentences one that is just this: "not possessing others under 'I have contributed'".32 The effort she put in is hers; what she asks for with it is that Lu Ding's share of judgment be yielded to her. §1 has read that neither party holds alone the adjudication of how this undertaking is done; this sentence, borrowing contribution, speaks of holding alone as something deserved. Read by the effect of this one occasion, it carries the direction of colonization: toward pouring into and occupying Lu Ding's share of judgment. Whether it took hold is seen in how Lu Ding responds afterward, and how the two people's arrangement falls.
This sentence is to be kept apart from another. Gu An could also say: "There's a lot of data on this job; I'd like to do a first draft of the conclusions, and you change it after you've looked at it." This is proposing an arrangement, which Lu Ding can agree to, change, or not agree to; it does not use contribution as a bargaining chip, and does not decide his share for him. Both sentences say that the conclusions start with her, and the effects they come to have differ; the difference lies in whether the sentence takes away along with it Lu Ding's road to changing, refusing and revising.
Contribution in itself carries no direction. The three nights she stayed up are something she did, and are hers; she can remember them, say so, and be glad of them. What carries a direction is the step of trading them for the other's share. Meaning Theory, at its own place, has a sentence of the same form: having provided conditions does not make the step by which the other becomes himself something I completed on his behalf.33
Recording the Other's Share as One's Own
Another kind runs the other way. After the evaluation meeting, Lu Ding said at the firm's weekly meeting that it was he who had later found the weekend problem and had Gu An recompute. The fact is: the problem was pointed out by the district's engineer, and it was Gu An who found which stretch the duplication lay in. This sentence records Gu An's share as his own.
This sentence falls on Gu An: how the firm regards her share from then on, and what she is assigned on the next job, may both change with this sentence. It goes toward her share, occupies it and enters it under his own name, and carries the direction of colonization.34 If Lu Ding misremembered, the effect this sentence comes to have is still this; whether he misremembered is another question. From outside only what he said and what the facts are is reported; what he thinks in his heart is not judged.
This kind and the kind in §3 run in opposite directions and have the same shape. In §3 one's own step is pushed out, onto someone else, onto a "we"; here someone else's step is pulled in and entered under one's own name. Both touch the one matter of "whose that step is"; one pushes, one pulls, and they land in the same place: the one who did it has been changed.
Writing Giving as an Account
Gu An could also say: "I stayed up three nights for you; you owe me one." This is writing one's own giving as an account the other must repay. Paper 2 has read this kind: it lies at the normative layer, it and an arrangement of reciprocal exchange are two things, and it is not exempted because the relation is called cooperation.35 This paper records only that it appears here too, where each bears a share: the effort one person puts in does not become, with the other, a debt.
The three are to be kept apart. Trading contribution for adjudication touches the other's share of judgment; recording the other's share as one's own touches who did that step; writing giving as an account touches whether the other owes something afterward. The three can appear at once in one sentence; when it is read, each is recorded in turn, and none stands in for another.
Credit and Authorship Have an Account of Their Own
That the report is signed with both names is set by the firm's procedures; when the firm picks its outstanding staff at the end of the year, who is picked also has its own method. These are on the institutional side, acknowledged but not judged. Between the two, who put in more effort can perhaps be seen in part from outside; this paper does not measure it.
Meaning Theory, at its own place, has drawn a boundary of settlement: "This proposition settles one account only, the attribution of constitution. Ownership of things, authorship, causal contribution, credit, proceeds and responsibility each have their own accounts".36 Action Theory Paper 8 writes accordingly that how credit and authorship are reckoned "is a separate account, and this paper does not settle it".37 This paper does not settle it either. What this paper reads is one effect within the process: a sentence that trades contribution for adjudication, a sentence that enters the other's share under one's own name. However credit is finally reckoned, even if it is reckoned clearly, that does not go back and change the effect these two sentences had at the time; conversely, the direction of these two sentences does not produce a figure that clears the books on the account of credit either.
§5 Breach of Faith
CO32 Breaking a commitment is entered on the books at the layer between person and person: breach of faith is entered apart; it enters the other party's later conditions of occurrence, and expectation changes accordingly; the stretch that spreads through third parties is entered by pairwise accounting. Being entered on the books is not the same as having caused some visible loss; the face in which reputation, or a score taken as standing for it, is used by a position as a condition of a chokepoint decision belongs to Political Economy Paper 1, and records and scores belong to its Paper 4
Breach of Faith Is Entered Apart
The day before the meeting, Lu Ding asked whether the weekend tables had been checked, and Gu An said: "I'll go over them once more tonight." At the meeting the next day, that error was still in the tables. What can be confirmed is that the material handed over still contained this error; whether she went over them that once, as promised, has to be checked separately. What she promised was to go over them once more, not to guarantee that every error would be found: if that night she did go over them once and did not catch it, this promise is not entered as non-fulfillment because the result contained an error; the error is entered as an item of its own, and how well that going-over was done can be asked separately; only if she did not go over them that night is a further division made: whether it was non-fulfillment, obstruction, or the two having revised their agreement.
Relation Theory enters breach of faith apart: dropping, falsity, non-fulfillment, obstruction, joint revision of the agreement; "dropping and falsity are first-person matters, and from outside only non-fulfillment, obstruction and joint revision of the agreement are reported, together with traces".38 The same place states: "To describe a breach of faith, first check what was promised, its conditions and the words and deeds that followed; then sort it into non-fulfillment, obstruction, joint revision of the agreement, dropping and falsity." Whether that night Gu An went over them and did not catch it, or had something else come up and did not get to it, or had not meant to go over them when she promised, cannot be seen from Lu Ding's side; nor does the example write what she did that night, and this point is left undetermined. What he can report is that she promised to go over them once more and that the next day the error was still in the tables, together with the traces those tables left; these do not on their own report that she did not go over them. Dropping and falsity can be confirmed only at Gu An's own end.
This division has its use. The word "breach of faith," in everyday speech, often carries a characterization with it: this person cannot be relied on. Entering it apart is not characterizing first. Going over them and not catching it is the promised thing having been done; the error is entered separately, and it is not a breach of faith; not going over them can be obstruction, can be the two having revised their agreement, and can also be simply non-fulfillment. What is entered from outside is this one occasion, not this person. That the error enters the later conditions, and whether that promise was fulfilled, are entered as two separate items.
Joint revision of the agreement is another kind. If that evening Gu An had sent Lu Ding a message, "Can't do it tonight; I'll go over them tomorrow morning before the meeting," and Lu Ding had replied "Fine," that promise would have been revised by the two together; not getting to it the next morning would be the revised promise unfulfilled, not the original one. If Gu An had only changed the time in her own mind and not said so, what Lu Ding had received would still be the original promise: one party's change in his own mind does not revise the agreement for the two.39 How a promise made between two people is changed has the same shape as how a division of labor is changed: changing it into a new one requires that each of the two avow it; withdrawing on one side does not impose the new one on the other, nor does it erase the effects the old one has already left.40
Entering the Later Conditions of Occurrence
That error does not vanish once the recomputing is done and the report corrected. It entered Lu Ding's later conditions of occurrence: on the job the next spring, before writing the conclusions, Lu Ding first asked for a copy of the raw statistical tables to look at. Expectation grows out of repeated dealings, and the occasion on which an error occurred is material too; if that night's promise was indeed not fulfilled, the non-fulfillment is material too, entered as an item separate from the error. Expectation changes the conditions of what can later be said and done.41 It is the same on the district's side: requiring the firm from then on to hand in the raw statistical tables along with the report is the district's expectation having changed.
This is entering on the books, not settling the account. The other party's response is material, not a settling of the account:42 Lu Ding's wanting to see the raw tables is not demanding repayment from Gu An, nor punishing her. If Gu An feels she is being thought less of, she can say so; this is her response, and is material too. The account is entered in the two people's later dealings, not in one reckoning.
Nor is entering on the books only the other party's affair. That sentence, "I'll go over them once more tonight," is where Gu An stands on her own side; if it was not fulfilled, that stays with her too. Relation Theory writes that commitment binds a person in two places: on my side, by where I stand; on the other party's side, by the effects already left.43 The changed expectation with Lu Ding is an effect left; with Gu An herself, it is how she regards a promise of hers from then on. The latter cannot be seen from outside; this paper records only that it is there, and does not speak for her.
The Stretch That Spreads Through Third Parties
The district's engineer later ran into someone from another firm, who asked about the job in the south of the city, and he said: "That report counted a stretch of the weekend ridership twice; it was recomputed afterward and put right." This sentence does not pass through Lu Ding and Gu An, yet it is about them. Relation Theory writes of dealings among three or more that do not pass through an institution: they are broken down into effects between pairs and entered on separate accounts.44 The stretch in which the engineer told that person this is entered between the engineer and that person; if it afterward enters the conditions of occurrence of how that person regards Lu Ding and Gu An, that is another stretch, entered pairwise again. The item of the error, or the item of the breach of faith, does not, because it has spread, become an account between one person and a crowd.
Nor is the direction of the stretch that spreads decided by that one error alone; the direction is read on the sentence that passes it on. This example stipulates that he stated this one error as it was, when the other asked, without enlarging it into a final judgment on the two, and without using it to tell people not to go to them again; this branch is read as ordinary feedback. If he turned "this job was reworked" into "those two can't do the work," that sentence of his would be deciding for the two who they are, and the direction is read on that sentence of his. That a sentence states the facts does not on its own certify each of its uses: whether the facts are accurate, whether the sentence bears on his position and on the person who asked, and whether it has been used to block other roads, are checked separately.
Being Entered on the Books Is Not the Same as a Visible Loss
Being entered on the books is this error, or the promise that was not fulfilled, having entered the later conditions; it is not the same as having already caused some visible loss. The district went on giving work to this firm as usual; Lu Ding and Gu An were still working together the next year. This item was entered on the books all the same: Lu Ding wants to see the raw tables, and the district wants the firm to hand in the raw tables. Conversely, even if nothing at all changed afterward, if what was promised was indeed not done, this matter is recorded all the same.
When everyday speech says "break faith and you lose your reputation," what it speaks of has to be taken apart. Reputation, as in Moral Law P3, is the displaying of recognition structure within the communal field; the scope that paper sets for it is the ideal type of a pure 15DD community.45 Of two people doing things together, one end often leans toward 14DD, and that is not the field of that paper. When this paper says that breach of faith is entered on the books, it speaks of the layer between the two, and between pairs; it does not speak of how reputation flows within a community. How many people know of someone and how he is talked about is, as in Political Economy Prequel, fame.46 The engineer's sentence, passed on, touches the side of fame; it works in others' several choices, and this series records only the stretch between pairs.
The Face Used as a Chokepoint
The item "reworked once" in the firm's ledger is a record. If the district had a score sheet for suppliers, and whom the next job went to depended on the scores, that item would then have been used by a position as a condition of a chokepoint decision. Political Economy Paper 1 reads this face: when reputation, or a score taken as standing for it, is used by a position as a condition of a chokepoint decision, so that the paths of those the decision reaches are thereby converged, it shows a power-face; it also states plainly: "Where fame works in others' several choices and no one uses it as a chokepoint, it is exchange in the Emergence Layer".47 Records and scores themselves belong to its Paper 4: rating, record-keeping and adjudication may have particular positions in charge of them, and the party questioned cannot on its own close off questioning of itself.48
That is a matter for the institutional side. Cooperation Theory only registers it, and does not read how score sheets are designed or how chokepoints are used; what it reads is the stretch before the score sheet comes in: between two people, what an unfulfilled promise has left with the other.
§6 Interfacing with Tradition
The interfacing in this paper goes in four steps: first the common question is written, then whether it is the same thing is looked at, where they shed light on each other and where they part, and last how far agreement goes. Where they part is written only at the strength of the original as quoted; a counter-thesis the original does not contain is not made up for it.
The ethic of responsibility (Weber). In "Politics as a Vocation," Weber distinguishes two ethics, an ethic of ultimate ends and an ethic of responsibility; acting by the latter, "one has to give an account of the foreseeable results of one's action."49 The common question: where the account of what a person has done falls. Where they shed light on each other: the account falls on the one who acts, and is pushed neither onto the world nor onto others. Where they part lies in the weight of the question: the weight of Weber's sentence lies in results, requiring the one who acts to give an account of the foreseeable results; the weight of answering for in this paper lies in whose that judgment and that step are: it faces inward, answering to one's own law. Giving an account, attribution and concrete remedy are several things; the sentence quoted asks for an account, and draws no conclusion on the allocation of causation, fault and remedy; this paper does not supply one for it, nor does it give that allocation itself. How far agreement goes: as far as the account's falling on the one who acts; beyond that, the two places weigh their questions differently, and are only compared. The scene Weber speaks of is politics; here it is one thing two people do together; what is compared is only the layer of where the account falls.
Guilt and collective responsibility (Arendt). In "Collective Responsibility," Arendt says: "Where all are guilty, nobody is"; and: "Guilt, unlike responsibility, always singles out; it is strictly personal. It refers to an act, not to intentions or potentialities."50 The common question: within what many people have done together, whether the step one person did is still there. Where they shed light on each other: her first sentence comes closest to "does not let what one has done oneself turn into something 'we' did, something no one did"; her saying that guilt refers to an act comes closest to this paper's saying only who did it. Where they part: in the same essay she sets up another kind of responsibility, by which a person, because he belongs to a community, has to bear things he did not do himself; this paper does not set up that kind; the "we" here is only one thing two people do together, not a political community. How far agreement goes: as far as the step that was done being able to fall only on the one who did it. Her saying that that kind of responsibility is not conditioned on one's having done the thing oneself can be read against On Accountability's saying that liability is "not conditioned on fault"; the two things compared lie at different layers, and this paper does not rest anything on it.
Heavy on oneself (the Analects). Analects, "Wei Linggong": 躬自厚而薄责于人,则远怨矣 ("Be heavy in reproaching yourself and light in reproaching others, and resentment is kept far off"). In "Xue'er," Master Zeng says: 吾日三省吾身:为人谋而不忠乎?与朋友交而不信乎?传不习乎? ("Each day I examine myself on three counts: in planning for others, have I not done my utmost? In dealing with friends, have I not kept faith? What has been passed on to me, have I not practiced?")51 The common question: in doing things together and in dealing with others, which way the question first faces. Where they shed light on each other: both passages turn the question toward oneself. Planning for others is doing things for others and with others, and what is asked is whether one has done one's utmost in one's own share; in dealing with friends, what is asked is whether one has kept one's word. This comes closest to this paper's inward. Where they part: these two passages of the Analects are precepts of self-discipline; heavy and light are one scale, and "resentment is kept far off" is the result it offers; this series makes no demands, and promises no results. One more point has to be made clear: if "light in reproaching others" were read as meaning that the other's share is then no longer entered, that does not fit this paper. What the other has done is still what the other has done, and what was not done is still entered on the books as it stands; only, this book is not written as what the other owes me (§2, §5). How far agreement goes: as far as the question first facing oneself.
Hume and Gilbert (pointed back to). Hume says that a person who has used the words of a promise, once he fails to keep it, places himself under the penalty of never being trusted again; Relation Theory has read this, taking the sentence to be "closest to the effects already left," and parting where a duty to the other party is derived from it.52 Gilbert says that a joint commitment puts the parties under a duty to one another to act as it requires; Relation Theory has engaged this too.53 This paper reads by those two places, and does not rewrite them.
§7 Drawing Together and Downstream
This paper has set out five propositions. Taken together, they say: when one thing is done together, the step that rules and arrangements do not cover has to be judged by people; in the cooperation this series reads, the judgment layer has two shares: each judges his own share and answers for his own share; neither party holds alone the adjudication of how this undertaking is done, neither can declare agreement in the other's place, and two judgments that fit together do not merge into a third judge. Answering for, as this paper means it, faces inward: judgments and what has been done cannot be acknowledged by someone else in one's place, the account falls on the one who judges, and the subject answers to its own law; it stands alongside commitment's not turning into a duty to the other party, and is not owing the other party something; accountability and liability are two further cells on the institutional side, registered as background; causation, fault and remedy are not given by it. What a person has done himself cannot be acknowledged by someone else in his place, nor does it, in doing things together, turn into something "we" did, something no one did; this sentence says only who did it, and does not judge fault. Contribution is not used to possess the other: trading it for the other's share of judgment, and recording the other's share as one's own, carry the direction of colonization; writing giving as an account is read in Paper 2; credit and authorship have an account of their own. Breach of faith is entered apart, and from outside only non-fulfillment, obstruction and joint revision of the agreement are reported; an error in one result does not on its own prove that what was promised was not done, and the error and whether the promise was fulfilled are entered as two items; they enter the other party's later conditions of occurrence, and expectation changes accordingly; the stretch that spreads through third parties is entered by pairwise accounting; being entered on the books is not the same as a visible loss, and the face in which reputation or scores serve as a chokepoint belongs to Political Economy.
This paper does not prove whose contribution is greater, nor does it lay down how what went wrong ought to be shared out.
Questions left open. What Lu Ding said at the meeting was "We didn't check it properly." The "we" in this sentence is, under the first arrangement, the checking the two avowed together, and under the second has no thing to point to. When people doing things together say "we," when are they speaking of the thing done together, and when are they borrowing a name that bears things for the two and judges for the two? Which branch "we" itself is in, Paper 4 has read; this paper has read only one point: "we" does not shield the one who did that step.
Downstream. What this paper has set out is used as follows, later and elsewhere. The two shares of the judgment layer are used when Paper 4 reads "we": judging one party's law for him in the name of "for the team" crosses precisely his share of judgment. Breach of faith entered on the books, and expectation changing accordingly: Paper 7 reads how these effects sediment over time: Lu Ding's wanting to see the raw tables from then on, and what it leaves, year after year, in the two people's dealings; and, once the work is done, how each looks back on this job. Writing giving as an account goes back to Paper 2; how division of labor is set, and what a procedure both parties have already recognized governs, go back to Paper 3. Answering for, accountability, liability and duty, these shared words, are listed together once in Paper 0.
Acknowledgments
This paper is signed by Han Qin alone; the author decided every argument and choice and bears sole responsibility for the text. In drafting, the author used AI models from various developers as tools.
Notes
- Paper 3, CO12 to CO16. ↩︎
- Relation Theory H8: "Cultivation and colonization are two directions: cultivation goes toward making space, colonization toward pouring in and occupying; the direction is read on this one effect, and whether it took hold is seen in the other party's later understanding and action; the two are not the two extremes of one scale, and the same act can carry both directions, and can also carry no direction at all; they are directions, not labels" (listed together in Relation Theory Paper 0, §15). ↩︎
- Rights Theory P0, M1; see §2 and note 20. ↩︎
- On Accountability, F36, F38, F44, F46. F38: "Accountability has its source in the power that converges upon the position, binds the position, and is released by exit: to exit that registration is to hold it no longer"; F44: "Liability says that a position can be altered; it does not say what the alteration contains. It is conditioned neither on fault nor on whether a channel of exit is available"; the section on F46: "Liability governs bearing, accountability governs answering." ↩︎
- Conflict Treatise §10: "First, first-person responsibility cannot be borne by proxy." See §3 and note 28. ↩︎
- What Cooperation Is Not (the Prequel to the Theory of Inter-State Cooperation), §11. Political Economy Prequel, §8, says the same; see note 18. ↩︎
- Political Economy Prequel, §1: "So fame and reputation are used apart." ↩︎
- Relation Theory H28; see §5 and note 38. ↩︎
- Paper 1, CO1, CO4. ↩︎
- How the three layers, the normative layer, the rule layer and the judgment layer, are read is written once in Paper 0. The judgment layer here issues no ought, and falls on each person himself. ↩︎
- Paper 1, the passage that reads the prisoner's dilemma. ↩︎
- Exercises and Games of Judgment III, §1.3. In §1.1 of the same paper: "The remainder of the cooperative game can show itself in the partner's next step and in what he wants". ↩︎
- Relation Theory H3: a relation is "the construct left when the effect of one side enters the conditions of occurrence of the other side"; H33: the other party's response "enters my conditions of occurrence and becomes material for the next expectation". The use made here of this, that what one share of judgment produces enters another share of judgment, is an extension, this series' own undertaking. ↩︎
- Action Theory D47: "One person is for purpose A, another for purpose B, and the two cannot not do C: C is something both of them avow and both are able to do, whose purpose and adjudication neither side holds alone; it is doing something together, not a shared law" (Action Theory Paper 8, §5). ↩︎
- Action Theory D45: "Consensus is not sameness: a shared direction holds different values, a concrete consensus can form without swallowing differences, and neither side can declare agreement in the other's place" (Action Theory Paper 8, §3). ↩︎
- Paper 3, CO16. Action Theory Paper 8, §5: "This is a limited shared procedure: what it governs is how this one matter is ordered, and its binding force comes from both of them having accepted this way of doing things beforehand". ↩︎
- Action Theory D48: "Doing things together does not automatically produce a position that legislates each side's own law for them"; Value Theory P5 V71, title: "A Joint Decision Does Not Generate a Third Position of Value Adjudication". ↩︎
- Political Economy Prequel, §8. ↩︎
- Relation Theory H11: "within an institution, the part of what passes between persons that the institution does not provide for, or that goes beyond its provisions, is within range"; "the provisions themselves are acknowledged but not judged". H52: "the authority that comes with a position is acknowledged but not judged". Paper 3, CO15. ↩︎
- Rights Theory P0, Abstract (M1). ↩︎
- Relation Theory H27: "Commitment does not turn into a duty to the other party; it binds a person by where I myself stand and by the effects already left, not by my owing the other party something". ↩︎
- Relation Theory Paper 0, §11.1: "This series recognizes that the promise spoken, and the arrangements the other has made on its strength, change the conditions afterward, and that later judgment must count them in"; "it does not write this change as a duty owed to the other party". ↩︎
- On Accountability, F36, F38. ↩︎
- On Accountability, F39: "Only a subject can hold a duty; construct and subject alike can hold accountability". ↩︎
- On Accountability, F44: "liability is the bearing of that position itself"; "Liability says that a position can be altered; it does not say what the alteration contains." The same section states that liability is not conditioned on fault. ↩︎
- On Accountability, F54: "Performance blocked, performance impossible, whether the accountability continues to stand, and how the attendant consequences are handled do not follow automatically one from another". ↩︎
- Action Theory Paper 8, §6. ↩︎
- Conflict Treatise §10: "I cannot have my own action's first-person responsibility borne by someone else." Action Theory Paper 8, §6, takes up this point. ↩︎
- Action Theory D49: "What a person has done himself cannot be acknowledged by someone else in his place; what others each bear in the matter, and who is in charge of what within institutions, this paper does not establish again: what On Accountability has established is referred back to, and the rest is registered openly". In the same section, of the doing being blocked, the doing being impossible, whether that duty still stands, and how the consequences are handled: On Accountability "also states plainly that these are four things, none following automatically from another". ↩︎
- Political Economy Prequel, §8; the original sentence comes from Institution Theory Z6. Carrying it here to the "we" between two people, taking only its form, is an extension, this series' own undertaking. ↩︎
- Relation Theory H12: "a little circle of two does not form a third bearer". ↩︎
- Action Theory D56: "Guarding comes back to the individual: not handing over one's judgment under 'we decided together,' not possessing others under 'I have contributed,' not cancelling recognition of concrete people for the sake of a shared ideal" (Action Theory Paper 9). ↩︎
- Meaning Theory P3, the section on Y26: "This proposition does not forbid me to be glad for him, does not deny actual causal effect, and does not prejudge the authorship of joint work; it refuses one sentence only: that because I provided conditions, the step by which he became himself was completed by me on his behalf." The original speaks of the one who supports and the one supported; carrying it here to two people doing things together, taking only its form, is an extension, this series' own undertaking. ↩︎
- Relation Theory H8. The direction is read by the effect of this one occasion; Lu Ding's mind is not judged. ↩︎
- Paper 2, CO9, CO11. Marriage Theory Paper 4, MA25: "if on this occasion one has already said out loud something that writes one's own giving as an account the other must repay, the direction is read by the effect of this one occasion". ↩︎
- Meaning Theory P3, the section on Y26. ↩︎
- Action Theory Paper 8, §6: "How the credit and authorship for this are reckoned is a separate account, and this paper does not settle it". ↩︎
- Relation Theory H28: "Breach of faith is entered apart, as dropping, falsity, non-fulfillment, obstruction and joint revision of the agreement; dropping and falsity are first-person matters, and from outside only non-fulfillment, obstruction and joint revision of the agreement are reported, together with traces" (listed together in Relation Theory Paper 0, §15). The sentence beginning "To describe a breach of faith" is in Relation Theory Paper 3, under H28; the same section also writes that falsity or dropping is not inferred from one non-fulfillment. ↩︎
- Relation Theory H28 lists joint revision of the agreement as a kind of its own, apart from dropping, falsity, non-fulfillment and obstruction; H23: "Leaving is entered on the books, and revising keeps the books on the change"; H25: where the promise has been made to another, or has entered his conditions of occurrence as a promise to him, a change on one's own side does not clear the books on the other party's side. ↩︎
- Paper 3, CO13. The original speaks of division of labor; carrying it here to a promise made between two people is an extension, this series' own undertaking. ↩︎
- Relation Theory H34: "Expectation grows out of repeated dealings: response and non-response, on time and not on time, all become material"; H35: "Expectation changes the conditions of what can later be said and done". ↩︎
- Relation Theory H33: "The other party's response is material, not a settling of the account". ↩︎
- Relation Theory H23: "It binds a person in two places, and neither rests on locking tomorrow: on my side, it rests on where I stand; on the other party's side, on the effects already left". ↩︎
- Relation Theory H12: "Where three or more are involved, dealings that do not pass through an institution are broken down into effects between pairs and entered on separate accounts; passing through a third person does not release the instigator from his part". ↩︎
- Moral Law P3, §0.6: "Paper 3's primary scope is the pure 15DD community — an idealized case in which all members are 15DD legislative subjects"; at the same place: "Reputation is the displaying of recognition structure within the communal field". ↩︎
- Political Economy Prequel, §1; see the Introduction and note 7. ↩︎
- Political Economy Paper 1, E5. The original: reputation, "or a score taken as standing for it, is used by a position as a condition of a chokepoint decision (lending, hiring, assigning work, admission), so that the paths of those the decision reaches are thereby converged, it shows a power-face by way of Rights Theory P4 F15". ↩︎
- Political Economy Paper 4, E22: "Rating, record-keeping and adjudication may have positions particularly responsible for them"; "Accumulation may not be converted into a standing in which the party questioned can on its own close off questioning of itself, correction, or necessary delivery". ↩︎
- Weber, "Politics as a Vocation" (a lecture of 1919), per the English translation by H. H. Gerth and C. Wright Mills (From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology, 1946, pp. 77–128; this sentence on p. 120). The sentence has been checked against a web transcription of that translation; the page number is as cited in secondary literature, and the pages of the book and the German original have not been checked. Just after, of one who acts by an ethic of ultimate ends: if bad results follow, then in his eyes "not he but the world, or the stupidity of other men" is responsible for them; one who acts by an ethic of responsibility does not push the foreseeable results of his own action onto others, and will say: "these results are ascribed to my action." "Pushed neither onto the world nor onto others" in the text rests on this. ↩︎
- Arendt, "Collective Responsibility," in J. W. Bernauer (ed.), Amor Mundi (Springer, 1987), pp. 43–50; also collected in J. Kohn (ed.), Responsibility and Judgment (New York: Schocken, 2003). Per the excerpt recorded at contemporarythinkers.org; neither book has been checked in the original, and the page numbers have not been checked. In the same essay she also says: "there is such a thing as responsibility for things one has not done; one can be held liable for them." This responsibility is conditioned on belonging to a group, a "membership in a group (a collective) which no voluntary act of mine can dissolve"; this phrase is not in the excerpt relied on, and follows the Amor Mundi text, p. 45, as cited in secondary literature. ↩︎
- Lunyu [Analects], "Wei Linggong," chapter 15; "Xue'er," chapter 4. From the ctext.org transcription; the English renderings in the text are this paper's own. ↩︎
- Relation Theory Paper 0, §11.1; Hume, A Treatise of Human Nature, T 3.2.5.10, as quoted in Relation Theory Paper 0. ↩︎
- Relation Theory Paper 0, §7. ↩︎
References
All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version. Quotations are checked item by item in the accompanying audit table.
I · SAE works directly cited in this paper
Qin, H. (2026). Finding One Another (SAE Action Theory, Paper 8) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22970783
Qin, H. (2026). One's Own Share of Strength, and Guarding (SAE Action Theory, Paper 9) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22970787
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Conflict Treatise: How Subjecthood Is Not Swallowed by Conflict Itself [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22313628
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Relation Theory Paper 0: The Place of Relation Theory [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545115
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Relation Theory Paper 1: What a Relation Is, and What It Is Not [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545047
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Relation Theory Paper 3: Commitment [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545023
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Relation Theory Paper 4: Dealings and Expectation [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545057
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Relation Theory Paper 6: Asymmetry, Divergence and Ending [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545087
Qin, H. (2026). On How Rights Presuppose No Duty (SAE Rights Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21285136
Qin, H. (2026). On Accountability · Wei (SAE Rights Theory, Specialist Paper) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22853810
Qin, H. (2026). The Half That Is Not Mine to Settle (SAE Meaning Theory, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22731235
Qin, H. (2026). The Reputation Economy · Dao (SAE Moral Law, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20046168
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Exercises and Games of Judgment · III: The Cooperative Game (15DD) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23609864
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Theory of Inter-State Cooperation · Prequel: What Cooperation Is Not [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23815735
Qin, H. (2026). What an Economy Is Not (SAE Political Economy, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874133
Qin, H. (2026). Accumulation (SAE Political Economy, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874138
Qin, H. (2026). Conversion (SAE Political Economy, Paper 4) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874146
Qin, H. (2026). On the Conflict of Value (SAE Value Theory, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22122819
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Marriage Theory Paper 4: The Years [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23819238
II · External works
Arendt, H. (1987). Collective Responsibility. In J. W. Bernauer (Ed.), Amor Mundi: Explorations in the Faith and Thought of Hannah Arendt (pp. 43–50). Dordrecht: Martinus Nijhoff / Springer. Reprinted in J. Kohn (Ed.), Responsibility and Judgment. New York: Schocken Books, 2003. (per the excerpt recorded at contemporarythinkers.org; the layer of membership follows the Amor Mundi text, p. 45, as cited in secondary literature; neither book has been checked in the original)
Weber, M. (1946). Politics as a Vocation. In H. H. Gerth & C. Wright Mills (Trans. & Eds.), From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology (pp. 77–128). New York: Oxford University Press. (sentences checked against a web transcription of this translation, on a Columbia University course page; p. 120 as cited in secondary literature; the pages of the book and the German original, Politik als Beruf, 1919, have not been checked)
Lunyu [Analects]. ctext.org transcription ("Wei Linggong," "Xue'er").
Hume, D. (1739–1740). A Treatise of Human Nature, 3.2.5. As quoted in Relation Theory Paper 0, §11.
Interfaces
- Main upstream: Action Theory Paper 8 (D45, D47, D48; §5, §6; D49), Paper 9 (D56); Rights Theory P0, Abstract (M1); On Accountability (F36, F38, F39, F44, F46, F54); Relation Theory Paper 3 (H23, H25, H27, H28), Paper 4 (H33 to H35).
- Also used: Relation Theory Paper 1 (H3, H8, H11, H12), Paper 6 (H52), Paper 0 (§7, §11, §15); the Conflict Treatise (§10); Exercises and Games of Judgment III (§1.1, §1.3); Meaning Theory P3 (Y26); Value Theory P5 (V71); Moral Law P3 (§0.6); the Prequel to the Theory of Inter-State Cooperation (§11); Political Economy Prequel (§1, §8), Paper 1 (E5), Paper 4 (E22); Institution Theory Z6 (by way of Political Economy Prequel, §8); Marriage Theory Paper 4 (MA25).
- This series: Paper 1, its scope and its passage reading the prisoner's dilemma (judgment cannot be done for one by computation); Paper 2 takes up writing giving as an account (CO9, CO11); Paper 3 takes up division of labor and the procedure both parties have already recognized (CO12 to CO16); Paper 4 takes up "we" and the two shares of the judgment layer; Paper 7 takes up how breach of faith and expectation sediment over time, together with completion and looking back.