Self-as-an-End
SAE Cooperation Theory · Paper 5

One Side
一端

Han Qin (秦汉) · Independent Researcher · 2026
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24029145 · Full PDF on Zenodo · CC BY 4.0
Abstract

This paper reads cooperation in which one end is headed in the 15DD direction and one leans toward 14DD. The cooperation this series reads has as its premise that at least one party is headed in the 15DD direction; cooperation in which one end is headed in this direction and the other leans toward 14DD is within scope, and is a proper object of this series. 15DD and 14DD here are stances, not labels for persons: they are read by the current relational condition, not by persons, and neither party is said to be lower. The end that leans toward 14DD and is within scope at least structurally acknowledges, in this undertaking, that the other has purposes of his own; being reduced to calculation is another matter.

Such cooperation can be the setting in which cultivation happens, not the source of cultivation. Cultivation is not the general opening move of such cooperation; if the person himself chooses to make a cultivative intervention, and the relevant boundaries hold, the first step is helping the other stand more firmly on the things he himself cannot set down; the intervention cannot compress the other's authority, channels or practical possibility of refusing, interrupting, revising, exiting and restating himself. Cultivation is not instruction, not remaking; the completion of cultivation is not in the enactor's hands. The direction is read on that one effect, and whether it took hold is looked at separately, in the other party's later understanding and action; whether the other's capacity has increased is a measure of outcomes, and is not used to judge direction.

The end headed in the 15DD direction can see more clues, and can discern whether the other is making use of him; clues are still only clues, and long-run relational fact can shift the weight of judgment but cannot complete a certification; whether to go on or to withdraw is his own judgment, on his own account. There is also a bias in the opposite direction: reading the other's strategic performance as awakening. Not being used, and not calculating in return: withdrawing one's own side is inward, is exit, and does not carry the direction of colonization, even if the other party's cost rises as a result; acting in a way directed at him that raises his cost is outward, and carries the direction of colonization. When, in this end's own fallible judgment, the other is in this undertaking reduced to calculation, this end from then on no longer does this undertaking as the cooperation this series reads; what this series reads is his judgment and his own side from then on, and it does not on that basis certify that the other is reduced to calculation; what this rests on is a condition of scope, not participation having come to nothing; the participation, facts and effects already there are entered as they stand; exit at the object layer goes separately by Paper 1. From then on, things are divided by the matters that actually remain: no longer doing this one thing together does not on that account become conflict; where it has become conflict and the reciprocal condition is currently unavailable, the unilateral path is read by the Conflict Treatise's safety check and stop gates; walking away takes no technical identity by itself, and leaving does not close out the shared matters that remain. This paper interfaces with the Analects' 以直报怨, repaying resentment with uprightness, and with Kant's "unsocial sociability." It does not prove that the party leaning toward 14DD is lower, does not prove that one ought to go and cultivate the other, does not prove that cultivation is bound to take hold, and does not prove that leaving is right.

Introduction

Shi Yan has done woodwork for twenty years. He rents a shopfront on an old street on the east side of town, makes cabinets and bookcases, and also takes on the woodwork for whole flats. You Jia has bought an old flat and wants a bookcase covering one entire wall, plus a worktable by the window. She draws plans at home; her drawing sheets are large, and her books are heavy. She went to three workshops, and Shi Yan was the second.

At their first meeting she spread the other two quotes on the table: one was thirty percent lower than Shi Yan's, the other a little higher. She asked: "Why are you so much dearer than him?" Shi Yan did not take that up; he laid out the list of materials item by item: which pieces would be solid wood and which could be board; how wide a shelf could span before it sagged; how thick the back panel would be; which kind of runner the drawers would use. He also said that the back and side panels bear no load, so using board for them would save a fair sum, and if her budget was tight she would lose nothing by doing it that way. You Jia heard him out and said she would go home and think about it. A week later she came back, chose one of the middle options, and asked for the schedule to be cut by a week. Shi Yan said he could not cut a week, but could cut three days. She agreed.

Halfway through, she came to the workshop to look, and wanted the worktable made twenty centimeters wider. Shi Yan said the wood had already been cut; widening it meant cutting new stock, and there would be an extra charge. You Jia said: "You people in this trade are all the same: quote low first, then add on." Shi Yan brought out the drawing he had first made, the version she had signed. She looked at it for a while, and said she would pay half of the extra charge and not the other half.

In this stretch of dealings there are several points that would ordinarily be taken to show "what kind of person this is." Does comparing prices show that she cares only about money? Do the haggling and that remark, "You people in this trade are all the same," show that she is just doing her sums? Do Shi Yan's laying out the list of materials, saving her money and bringing out the drawing show that he is decent? This paper does not read them that way. Comparing prices does not in itself prove anything: it proves neither that she is reduced to calculation nor that she has no purposes of her own. Nor does Shi Yan's conscientiousness certify in which direction he is headed. What this paper asks is something else: when two people do something together and, in this undertaking, one end operates in the 15DD direction and the other leans toward 14DD, how such cooperation is read; what the end headed in the 15DD direction can see, what it can do, and what it does not do.

What this paper reads. Paper 1 has read that the cooperation this series reads has as its premise that at least one party is headed in the 15DD direction; the direction is a premise, not a sufficient condition for entering scope: it is checked further that both avow this undertaking and actually take part, that the other is not, in this undertaking, reduced to calculation, and that the arrangement the two jointly maintain does not carry the direction of colonization toward a third person.1 Marriage Theory takes both parties; this series takes one. This is a difference at the rule layer: marriage has the love between the two as one thing it cannot do without; cooperation does not require love.2 So the kind that lies outside Marriage Theory's scope, one end headed in this direction and one leaning toward 14DD, is here a proper object.

In SAE's levels, the layer at which the other is recognized as an end too is written 15DD; the layer at which one has a direction of one's own and keeps to the things one cannot set down is written 14DD.3 Economics P2 says: "Bilateral 15DD is a rare and precious achievement, not the default setting of human economic activity." Of the case in which one end is there and the other is not, it says: "This is the norm, not a pathology."4 Cooperation in which one end is headed in this direction is the common case of cooperation.

This paper reads six things. First, stance: how 15DD and 14DD are read here, and why they are not labels for persons. Second, cultivation: why such cooperation is the setting in which cultivation happens and not its source; when the person himself chooses to make a cultivative intervention, what the first step is, and which condition cannot be crossed. Third, direction and outcomes: why the other's later changes are not used to judge direction. Fourth, discernment: what the end headed in the 15DD direction can see, why what it sees is still only clues, and the bias in the opposite direction. Fifth, not being used, and not calculating in return. Sixth, the time when, in this end's judgment, the other is in this undertaking reduced to calculation. On several of these the direction of colonization can be read: deciding the other's direction for him in the name of cultivation; making him dependent to the point where he cannot say no; calculating in return.

Colonization, in this series, names the direction of one effect: toward pouring in and occupying; the other direction is cultivation, toward making space. The two are not the two extremes of one scale; the same act can carry both directions, and can also carry no direction at all; the direction is read on this one effect, and whether it took hold is seen in the other party's later understanding and action.5 Violation is judged separately, and only at the layer of basic rights.6

Shared words. "Cultivation" is taken in the broad sense: the direction of one effect, not a project, nor anyone's identity. "Discernment" speaks of what the end headed in the 15DD direction reads, in his own judgment, from what he sees; it is a fallible judgment, not a certification. "Withdrawing" speaks of withdrawing one's own side, and refers to the same thing as "exit"; it differs from "walking away": walking away is only an external act, and takes no technical identity by itself; §6 reads this. "Calculation" speaks of the stance of treating the other only as a strategy set; exchange is not calculation, which Paper 2 has read.7

§1 Stances, Not Labels

CO22 15DD and 14DD here are stances, not labels for persons: they are read by the current relational condition, not by persons. What is spoken of is the end that operates in the 15DD direction in this undertaking, and the leaning toward 14DD; neither party is said to be lower

One Operation, Not One Person

When this paper says "one end is headed in the 15DD direction," it means that in this undertaking, in this stretch, that end's operation heads toward recognizing the other as an end too; when it says "leans toward 14DD," it means that the other end's operation in this undertaking leans toward guarding its own share, and has not yet gone as far as recognizing that the other's share is the other's own. Neither sentence sticks a label on a person. Love Theory has set down: "A layer is an aspect of asking, not a stage. A layer records one operation; it does not record a person, nor a love"; Marriage Theory, accordingly, does not record a marriage either.8 This series, accordingly, does not record a stretch of cooperation.

People are all mixed.9 The moment You Jia said in the workshop, "You people in this trade are all the same," and the moment she later said, item by item, what she wanted, are two operations of the same person in the same undertaking. So with Shi Yan: the moment he saved You Jia money, and the moment he looked at the drawing she had signed and worked out in his head how much profit was left in this job, are two as well. A layer records one operation, so to say that one end is "headed in the 15DD direction" is to speak of a direction, not a state; there are times of falling back, and falling back is read as it occurs, and does not overturn the direction.10

Read by the Current Relational Condition

Where the Conflict Treatise divides its two paths, it says: "The division of paths goes by the current relational condition, not by persons." In the same section: "Both definitions speak only of conditions, not of persons. Conditions are current, revisable, and shown by what has already happened in this relation."11 This paper reads cooperation in which one end is headed in the 15DD direction by this rule: what it reads is the conditions shown by what has already happened in these dealings, not what kind of person each of the two is. The Conflict Treatise states that "no test is given anywhere in this treatise for determining which layer the other is running on," and that what admits of diagnosis "is this operation on this occasion, not this person."12 This series gives none either.

So this paper writes "the end that operates in the 15DD direction in this undertaking" and "the leaning toward 14DD." It is written at this length so as not to shrink into "a 15DD person" and "a 14DD person." Once shortened, a reading about this undertaking becomes a verdict about this person.

Leaning Toward 14DD Is Not Being Reduced to Calculation

The leaning toward 14DD is not the same as being reduced to calculation. Learning IV says: "recognizing the other's independent 14DD is structural, not moral — it does not require assuming the other is benevolent, and includes detecting when the other's purpose is adverse to you."13 By this sentence, the end that leans toward 14DD and is within this series' scope at least structurally acknowledges, in this undertaking, that the other has purposes of his own: she can distrust him, can be on guard against him, can detect that his purpose is adverse to her, and still acknowledge that it is his purpose. You Jia's comparing three workshops' prices, cutting the schedule, and refusing to pay the other half can all lie on this side. Suppose she knows that Shi Yan makes his living by this work, knows that he has his materials and his schedule, and what she wants is to guard her own share alongside his; then these things all lie on this side. From outside, one cannot tell from comparing prices and cutting the schedule alone whether they lie on this side or are a matter of being reduced to calculation (§4).

Being reduced to calculation is another matter: treating the other only as a strategy set. Writing of the 14DD world, Economics P2 says that there "the person across from you is a strategy set".14 Learning IV comes at it from the opposite starting point: what it treats is "the bridge from 14DD to 15DD: learning to recognize that the other has a purpose independent of yours," and what it calls recognizing the other's independent 14DD is placed on this bridge.15 The end that leans toward 14DD and is within this series' scope has, in this undertaking, at least reached this step; the world Economics P2 speaks of falls, in this series, on the side of being reduced to calculation. Reading the two places against each other in this way is this series' own undertaking. Of the boundary between the two, Paper 1 has read the structural clues; what follows when the other is reduced to calculation is read in §6.16

The Conflict Treatise has a further structural explanation: "a position still running at 14DD has no structural reason to acknowledge that another law carries the same first-person absoluteness as its own." It makes clear right after that this "does not establish that in some current case the reciprocal condition is unavailable".17 This paper follows it: a structural explanation says why such asymmetry is common; it draws no conclusion on behalf of any concrete person or any concrete undertaking.

Neither Party Is Said to Be Lower

One end headed in the 15DD direction and the other leaning toward 14DD is not one high and one low. When the Conflict Treatise named its unilateral path, it deliberately kept the word cultivation out of the name: "once it is called the path of cultivation it will be read as 'I judge you lower, so I shall cultivate you.'"18 The name governs entry. This paper's way of writing governs entry too: it says "the leaning toward 14DD," not "the lower party"; it says "the end that operates in the 15DD direction in this undertaking," not "the higher one."

Nor does Shi Yan's conscientiousness count in his favor here. His laying out the list of materials, saving her money and bringing out the drawing can come from his taking You Jia as someone with business of her own to see to; it can also come from his not being able to set down his own craft; it can also be both. A person's conscientiousness about his own craft can in itself be his 14DD anchor: that is his own cannot-not. Economics P2 says that 15DD emerges from 14DD, bringing with it 14DD's full will and full capacity for computation and monitoring.19 A craftsman's conscientiousness does not automatically certify that he is headed in the 15DD direction in this undertaking. In this paper's example, wherever Shi Yan is written as operating in the 15DD direction, it is a stipulation, not something read from his conscientiousness.

§2 The Setting of Cultivation

CO23 Cooperation in which one end is headed in the 15DD direction and one leans toward 14DD is within scope; such cooperation can be the setting in which cultivation happens, not the source of cultivation. If the person himself chooses to make a cultivative intervention, and the relevant boundaries hold, the first step is helping the other stand more firmly on the things he himself cannot set down; the intervention cannot compress the other's authority, channels or practical possibility of refusing, interrupting, revising, exiting and restating himself. Cultivation is not instruction, not remaking, and not the general opening move of such cooperation; the completion of cultivation is not in the enactor's hands

The Setting, Not the Source

Relation Theory has set down: "A relation is the setting in which cultivation happens, not the source of cultivation".20 Carried over to cooperation: the undertaking two people do together can be the setting in which cultivation happens; the source of cultivation lies neither in this undertaking nor in the hands of the end that operates in the 15DD direction. Economics P2, speaking of the object of cultivation investment, says: "The object is creating conditions for the other party's 15DD to emerge from 14DD."21 The emergence happens in the other. Learning IV closes thus: "This series brings the reader to the door of 15DD." And: "The door opens from the inside."22 At most, the end that operates in the 15DD direction can create conditions.

Not the General Opening Move

Cooperation in which one end is headed in the 15DD direction does not thereby become a project of cultivation. Shi Yan took this job to make bookcases; he can simply make the bookcases well: do as agreed, speak up when they disagree, and, where they cannot talk it through, deal with it according to the agreement. This too is his share, and this too is within the cooperation this series reads. The Conflict Treatise says on its unilateral path: "Cultivation constitutes no duty to intervene and does not rewrite the unilateral path into a project for another person's growth."23 That sentence speaks of the unilateral path in conflict-handling; carried over to cooperation, this step is this series' own undertaking: one end's being headed in the 15DD direction does not make cultivation this end's general opening move. Whether to make an active intervention on the other's side is this end's own choice.

Choosing to intervene also needs the relevant boundaries to hold. The Conflict Treatise divides not-safe in two: where it is merely unsuitable to enter joint deepening at this moment, one can turn to the unilateral path; where the protective conditions have already been triggered, "one suspends, protects, or hands over first, and does not enter unilateral intervention".24 In cooperation, when this end's own conditions of exit, his safety and his basic conditions are being compressed, cultivative intervention is not under consideration; what is guarded first is one's own side.

The First Step

If the person himself chooses to make a cultivative intervention, the first step is not getting the other to see him. The Conflict Treatise: "the first step is not getting them to see me." It goes on to cite Economics P2: a more unfolded position can only grow out of a stable one; "The first step is therefore helping them stand more firmly on the things they themselves cannot set down".25 Economics P2 puts it more plainly for negotiation: "the first step in cultivating a 14DD negotiation counterpart may be helping him better guard his own interests."26

That day Shi Yan said that the back and side panels could be board and would save a fair sum; if this remark counts as an intervention, what it is directed at is You Jia's own share: her budget, the books she wants to shelve, the surface she draws on. It is not getting You Jia to sympathize with his costs, nor getting her to see the weight of the craft. The Conflict Treatise says that before the other stands firm, "efforts to have them consider my position carry a high risk of being translated as a strategic signal to make them yield."27 Had Shi Yan begun that day with a speech on how hard a craftsman has it, then by this sentence the speech would risk being translated as a bid for a higher price; how You Jia would hear it, this example does not give.

The same remark can also be translated into something else. You Jia can read "would save a fair sum" as a sweetener now and a higher price later. Taking the first step does not guarantee how it is heard.

A Structural Condition Ex Ante

The Conflict Treatise sets one structural condition ex ante for cultivative intervention, and makes clear that it is "checkable in the first person and requires no judgment of the other's layer or inner state":

An intervention may not compress the other's authority, channels or practical possibility of refusing, interrupting, revising, exiting and restating themselves.

In the same section: "Offering reasons may change whether they are willing to refuse; it cannot lower whether they are able to refuse."28 Carrying this condition over to cooperation as it stands is an extension, this series' own undertaking. Shi Yan's laying out the list of materials and explaining why that piece calls for solid wood is setting out reasons; if You Jia, having heard him, does not choose it, that is her refusal, and the way is still open. Suppose that the drawing already made is, by what the two agreed, to be handed over to her; if he holds it back and says she will not get it unless she chooses his way of doing it; or says that other workshops cannot make this kind of structure, when in fact they can; or puts into the design a kind of hardware only he can repair, so that afterward she cannot change it or change who does the work: what all of these compress is her authority, channels or practical possibility of saying no. However much they look like help, none of them is within cultivative intervention. Whom the drawing belongs to and whether it is to be handed over go by what the two agreed and by the contract, which this paper does not decide; if the drawing was not in the first place part of what was to be handed over to her, his not giving it is another matter, and is not read by this sentence.

Dependency is read in two parts. People depend on one another in any case: You Jia's going to a craftsman is depending on his craft; this kind carries no direction of colonization. The Conflict Treatise: "The kind of dependency manufactured and locked in by the intervention, such that the other cannot say no to the intervener, is the gentle form of colonization." Relation Theory accordingly distinguishes two senses: the kind that was made, and that has locked the path to saying no, carries the direction of colonization.29 With the hardware only Shi Yan can repair, what is read is this one operation, not what he was thinking when he put it in: whether that dependency was made, and locked her later path to saying no and to making a change. If she wanted it herself, he explained that afterward repairs could only come to him, and she understood and still chose it, this shows that there was an explanation at that point, and her avowal too; it does not on its own prove that she still has, afterward, a path of refusing and changing that can actually be walked. Whether that hardware has a technical reason, whether it can later be refitted, handed over or repaired by someone else, whether the actual dependency was made and locked in: these are still to be checked separately. From its being special-purpose alone, the direction of colonization cannot be read; from her having nodded at the start alone, this reading cannot be ruled out either.

Not Instruction, Not Remaking

Of the four things the Conflict Treatise says follow at once, the first is: "cultivation is not instruction, not remaking, not turning the other into something."30 If, when You Jia compared prices, Shi Yan gave her a lesson, saying that a person should know to respect craft, and treated her comparing prices as a fault to be corrected, this is instruction: it treats the other as material awaiting change, and also decides for You Jia what comparing prices means to her.

There is also a borrowing of a name: deciding the other's direction for him under "for your own good." Economics P2 says here: "'for your own good' is cultivation's most common self-justification and colonization's most common disguise." One kind it gives is wrapping 12DD manipulation in 15DD syntax: claiming to seek a win-win solution, "but 'win-win' is predefined by me, 'your win' is defined for you by me".31 A limitation in the Conflict Treatise says the same thing: "one cannot, merely on the strength of 'I am handling a conflict' or 'I am cultivating you,' acquire authority to arrange another's life unilaterally."32 If Shi Yan, in the name of "I'm doing this for your own good," refused to make the worktop at the width You Jia wanted, deciding for her what her study was to look like, that would be deciding the other's direction for him in the name of cultivation, and it carries the direction of colonization. He can explain what will happen if it is done that way; if after the explanation she still wants it done that way, the way is in her hands. What he himself will not do is his boundary, which is another matter, read in §5.

Completion Is Not in the Enactor's Hands

Relation Theory: "The completion of cultivation is not in the enactor's hands; incomplete cultivation is not colonization."33 The Conflict Treatise: "cultivation does not presuppose success, and it does not predict that the other will change."34 Taken together, these two sentences keep in check the story this paper could most easily be written as: the patient party holds on, and at last the other is cultivated into something. This paper does not write that story. Cooperation in which one end is headed in the 15DD direction can stay like this throughout: one end keeps up the conditions, the other goes on guarding its own share as before; the undertaking gets done together all the same, or does not. If the other changes, it is no one's work; if he does not, that does not make the earlier conditions colonization either.

§3 Direction, and the Measure of Outcomes

CO24 The direction is read on that one effect, and whether it took hold is looked at separately, in the other party's later understanding and action; whether the other's capacity has increased is a measure of outcomes, and is not used to judge direction

The Criterion of Economics P2

Economics P2 sets a criterion for cultivation: "after the intervention ends, has the other party's capacity increased?" Its self-test follows from this: "A 14DD who has been cultivated should, after the cultivation process, be more capable of saying 'no' to the cultivator herself".35 This criterion sees one thing exactly: cultivation heads toward the other's own capacity, not toward the other's output for me. Among its open questions the same paper keeps the two apart: "cultivation expenditure," increasing the other's capacity, "including the capacity to leave"; "investment expenditure," increasing the other's output for you.36 Among the capacities cultivation heads toward is the capacity to leave me. In this respect this series uses this criterion as it stands, as its own undertaking; reading this passage of Economics P2 in its §3, Relation Theory Paper 0 makes clear: "That is a measure of outcomes, and it is not used to judge direction; whether a direction took hold is looked at separately, in the other party's later understanding and action".37

Why Outcomes Are Not Used to Judge Direction

Outcomes are not used to judge direction, for two reasons.

One lies in direction itself. The direction is read on that one effect: where this effect heads, toward making space, or toward pouring in and occupying.38 The direction of one effect is there when the effect is made; what the other grows afterward is the other's later affair. If the later outcome were used to decide, looking back, the direction of that occasion, the reading of that effect would have to wait on the other.

The other lies in the accounts at the two ends. If outcomes could judge direction, the other's later growth would become the enactor's warrant; and if the other did not grow, the enactor's act on that occasion would turn out to be colonization. The first half the Conflict Treatise has sealed off: "One cannot write the other's later growth into one's own work".39 The second half Relation Theory has sealed off: incomplete cultivation is not colonization. Both halves need sealing, because both use what is on the other's side to clear the books for the enactor.

What Can Be Checked Is One's Own Occasion

Not using outcomes to judge direction does not mean that direction cannot be checked. The Conflict Treatise's condition ex ante is exactly what the enactor can check in the first person: whether this intervention compressed the other's authority, channels and practical possibility of refusing, interrupting, revising, exiting and restating himself. Of the indications after the fact, the Conflict Treatise has also stated their status: that the other becomes better able to account for himself, better able to refuse me, "can support a judgment that cultivation occurred. They are not necessary and sufficient criteria, still less my warrant for certifying their growth".40

Later You Jia said, item by item, what she wanted: the worktop was to take the largest size of drawing sheet, with room on the left-hand side for a lamp; the lower part of the bookcase was to hold file boxes, and they were to pull out all the way. She also turned down one of Shi Yan's suggestions, saying she wanted that compartment left empty. Suppose all this happened. It does not certify that You Jia grew something: she may have known all along and simply not said it before; she may have learned it at another workshop; or she may have thought it through herself over these months. Nor does it certify that Shi Yan's few interventions were cultivation: his direction is read on those few effects of his. Conversely, suppose You Jia said only those few remarks from beginning to end; that would not make Shi Yan's earlier interventions colonization either.

§4 What Can Be Seen, and What Cannot Be Certified

CO25 The end headed in the 15DD direction can see more clues, and can discern whether the other is making use of him; clues are still only clues, and long-run relational fact can shift the weight of judgment but cannot complete a certification. Whether to go on or to withdraw is his own judgment, on his own account. There is also a bias in the opposite direction: over-cultivation, reading the other's strategic performance as awakening

More Can Be Seen

Economics P2 says that 15DD opens not merely a moral capacity but a perceptual one: "Once 15DD opens, good and evil become simultaneously visible — you can distinguish genuine collaborators from disguised ones".41 When one end is there and the other is not, what the end headed in the 15DD direction directly perceives, the same paper also states: "What the 15DD party can immediately perceive is non-reciprocity, not the reason for non-reciprocity."42 Learning IV says the same thing from the opposite starting point: "those whose 14DD is not yet established are most vulnerable to being absorbed by another's strong 14DD, and the precondition for detecting this absorption is precisely recognizing that the other's 14DD is the other's own."43 Only by acknowledging that the other has purposes of his own can I see whether his purposes are, at this moment, making use of me.

So the end that operates in the 15DD direction in this undertaking can see more clues: whether "You people in this trade are all the same" is a guarded remark or a step of pressure; whether comparing prices is guarding her budget, or using his list of materials to press another workshop's price down. All of these he can set about discerning.

Clues Are Still Only Clues

Seeing more is not being able to certify. The Conflict Treatise: "Someone who has not yet come that far and someone who could and chooses not to may present the same behavioral signature in a single or local interaction. Long-run relational fact may shift the weight of my judgment; it cannot complete a certification."44 Economics P2 writes this layer as probability: signals accumulate over time, and the posterior probability moves, but "posterior probability never reaches certainty"; "Signals are probabilistic, not decisive."45

"You people in this trade are all the same" can be the guarded remark of someone who has been cheated before, and it can also be a deliberate move to push the price down. If You Jia later mentions that the year before, when she redid her kitchen, someone quoted her low and then doubled it, the weight of the remark changes; if from then on she uses the same remark to push down every time, the weight changes again. What changes is the weight in Shi Yan's judgment, not that the remark has been certified.

Here Economics P2 also separates "hasn't arrived" from "chooses not to," and says that the two are undecidable at the output level.46 This paper does not use this division to read the other: in cooperation, Shi Yan does not need first to determine which kind You Jia is before deciding how to do his own share. The Conflict Treatise, when it turns paths, also relies on only one thing: "The ground of turning is the fact that the current reciprocal process is unavailable."47

Understanding Is Not Settling

Later Shi Yan learned what had happened to You Jia the year before, and felt he understood: why she compared every workshop, why that remark came out so sharp. The Conflict Treatise has a sentence on its unilateral path: "That I have understood why they are like this does not mean they have agreed to my understanding, still less that the matter is thereby settled."48 That sentence speaks of the unilateral path in conflict; it holds in cooperation as well, and this step is this series' own undertaking. If Shi Yan arranged everything afterward on the strength of his understanding, fixing her budget for her and no longer asking what she wanted, because "I know what she's afraid of," that would be legislating for her with a one-sided understanding. The Conflict Treatise also says: "Understanding produces no exemption."49 "I've been so considerate of her" does not exempt his later arrangements from her questioning.

Going On or Withdrawing Is on His Own Account

What the clues are read as, and whether to go on or to withdraw afterward, is this end's own judgment. Economics P2 says that this judgment has no formula: "No formula tells you 'when confusion signals have appeared N times and avoidance signals M times, switch strategies.'"; it is "reflective judgment: judgment without a pre-given rule".50 The account of this judgment falls on the one who judges: if he judged wrongly, it was he who judged wrongly; if going on cost him, it was he who decided to go on; if after withdrawing he missed something, it was also he who withdrew. Each judging his own share and answering for his own share is read in Paper 6.

This paper does not judge for him, nor does it say whether he should go on or withdraw.

The Bias in the Opposite Direction

There is also a bias running the opposite way. Economics P2 marks it: "the over-cultivation tendency." The party headed in the 15DD direction, because he sees the other as an end too, may fall into "over-interpreting the other party's strategic performance as a glimmer of 15DD awakening".51

Once You Jia said: "You really put your heart into what you make." Shi Yan can read this as her having finally seen him, and he can also think that the next day she is going to ask for a change she does not want to pay for. Both are possible. Over-cultivation is reading every such remark as the former, and going on investing on that basis; the bias at the other extreme is reading every one as the latter: seeing it, and treating it as unseen. Both are biases within judgment, and neither is a certification. What this end can do is know that both biases are there.

§5 Not Being Used, and Not Calculating in Return

CO26 Not being used, and not calculating in return: withdrawing one's own side is inward, is exit, and does not carry the direction of colonization, even if the other party's cost rises as a result; acting in a way directed at him that raises his cost is outward, and carries the direction of colonization

Inward and Outward

Relation Theory: "Withdrawing one's own side is exit and does not carry the direction of colonization, even if the other party's cost rises as a result; when one party exits, whichever party acts outward, adding consequences, using the occasion to apply pressure and calling on others to isolate him all carry the direction of colonization".52

Suppose Shi Yan judges that if things go on like this, he will not be able to guard his share. Suppose the second phase, the bookcases, has not yet been agreed, and the later changes also go beyond the share the two originally avowed. He can withdraw his own side: from now on every new change is written down first and paid for before work starts; once the worktable is finished, he will not take on the second phase, the bookcases. You Jia will then have to find someone else and compare prices again; her cost rises. This withdrawal is inward, and does not carry the direction of colonization; her cost's rising does not change this reading. The deliveries already avowed, the things that by agreement are to be handed over to her, the warranty agreed for the first phase, and the other matters that remain are checked separately, each item as originally agreed, and do not disappear along with his withdrawing new investment (§6). If the second phase had already been agreed, or if what he held back were deliveries already avowed, that would be another matter, each of those items checked separately, and not read wholesale as withdrawal on the strength of the one sentence "This is my boundary."

Another way of doing it goes outward: saying in the trade's group chat that she does not pay what she owes, so that no other workshop will take her work; deliberately dragging her job out to the very end, until she has no choice but to pay more. These are acts directed at her that raise her cost, and they carry the direction of colonization. In the first way of doing it, what changes is Shi Yan's side; in the second, what Shi Yan sets about changing is You Jia's side. "Calculating in return," as said here, reads where an effect heads; it does not assign either end a stance of being reduced to calculation.

Relation Theory draws one more line: where one first monopolizes, or first induces dependency, and then withdraws, violation is checked separately at the layer of basic rights.53 The hardware from §2 that only Shi Yan can repair, if he first induced dependency and then withdrew and would not repair it, falls at the point this line is there to check; actual dependency alone, or its being in fact the case that only he can repair it, does not on its own yield the conclusion of violation.

Guarding One's Own Share

Not being used does not rest on calculating in return. Shi Yan's writing changes down, asking for a sum to be paid first, and saying in advance what he will not do are all on his own side: they are his boundary, his way of doing his share. Nor is exchange calculation: charging the price and delivering as agreed is an arrangement of reciprocal exchange both have avowed, which Paper 2 has read.54 Guarding one's own share can be very firm, and can refuse to give way; so long as what it moves is the side that, once the items are separated, still belongs to him, it does not pour into the other. Whether an act is on one's own side is seen from those items once separated, and is not decided by his calling it a boundary; Relation Theory, reading withdrawal, also reads by function: whether the withdrawal is being used to set a penalty on the other party's using a channel.55

When the Conflict Treatise lists the acts on the unilateral path, first among them are arrangements on one's own side: "The unilateral path is not a synonym for cultivation. It also includes arrangements on my own side, protection of boundaries, ceasing to apply, suspension and removal".56 There is not necessarily conflict in cooperation; in cooperation these acts are, likewise, this end's own share.

The Sentence on Downshifting, Only Registered

Before Economics P2 unfolds its two branches, cultivation and recognizing non-cultivability, it first sets a premise: "the 15DD party's strategy space does not include 'downshifting to 14DD' — not because the cost is too high, but because the chisel-construct cycle does not accept it."57 This paper only registers this sentence, and does not set it up as a proposition. What it speaks of is the structure of the end that operates in the 15DD direction, which holds in his first person; what this paper reads is the effects between two people, and from outside it reads only the direction of an effect. Downshifting to 14DD is not calculation either: what 14DD guards is the things one cannot set down; calculation is treating the other only as a strategy set. When this paper says "not calculating in return," it reads where one effect heads: drawing in toward one's own side, or going to the other's side to raise his cost; it does not read whether a person has downshifted. Downshifting speaks of taking a return to 14DD as a strategy one can choose; falling back is an operation's not being in that direction, and is not chosen. This distinction is this series' own undertaking.

§6 When the Other Is Reduced to Calculation

CO27 If, in this end's own fallible judgment, the existing relation no longer meets the condition of scope "the other is not, in this undertaking, reduced to calculation," this end from then on no longer does this undertaking as the cooperation this series reads; what this series reads is his judgment and his own side from then on, and it does not on that basis certify that the other is reduced to calculation; exit at the object layer still goes by CO4. The other may still be doing the existing division of labor; the participation, facts and effects already left are entered as they stand, and are not erased wholesale by this judgment. The direction premise is not thereby lost automatically, nor does this judgment turn and judge the other's inner grounds. Nor is it that one qualifies to withdraw only after first certifying that the other is purely calculating: this end can stop cooperating on the strength of the current conditions. From then on, things are divided by the matters that actually remain: merely no longer doing this one thing together does not on that account become conflict as the Conflict Treatise reads it; where it already is conflict as the Conflict Treatise reads it and the reciprocal condition is currently unavailable, the unilateral path is read by its safety check and stop gates, and the unilateral path includes arrangements on one's own side, protection of boundaries, ceasing to apply, suspension and removal, and is not the same as going on cultivating the other; walking away is only an external act, and takes no technical identity by itself; the shared matters that leaving does not close out, and the institutional dispositions, are each registered by their source

A Fork

Back to Shi Yan and You Jia. Suppose that, when the second phase comes, things can go two ways.

One goes like this: You Jia states her requirements for the worktop and the file boxes; for the disputed half of the widening charge, the two finally arrive at a compromise figure; the second-phase bookcases are made to the dimensions she has newly given. She still asks every workshop for prices, still says "you people in this trade," but the undertaking goes ahead as the two agreed.

The other goes like this: You Jia takes the drawings and list of materials Shi Yan made to the workshop that was thirty percent cheaper, and asks it to make the bookcases from them; then she comes back and asks Shi Yan to revise the worktable drawing once more, saying that since he has drawn it already there is no need to charge for it separately; when Shi Yan asks her to pay for the drawing, she says that if she has to pay she will go to someone else, since she already has the drawings in hand. Suppose Shi Yan, in his own judgment, reads it thus: in this undertaking You Jia treats him only as a set of things to draw on, the list of materials, the drawings, the schedule, using whichever can be used; whether his share is his no longer enters her consideration.

In the second way, this reading of Shi Yan's is his own fallible judgment. You Jia may have been driven into a corner by her budget; she may think that, having paid a deposit, she owns the drawings; she may really be just doing her sums. This paper decides it neither for Shi Yan nor for You Jia.

A Condition of Scope, Not a Conclusion About Participation

For the cooperation this series reads, entering scope is checked on further things: both avow this undertaking and actually take part; the other is not, in this undertaking, reduced to calculation; the arrangement does not carry the direction of colonization toward a third person.58 Participation and not being reduced to calculation are two things, listed apart. So if, in Shi Yan's own judgment, You Jia is in this undertaking reduced to calculation, then his no longer doing this undertaking from then on as the cooperation this series reads rests on the latter's no longer being met in his judgment, not on "her participation has come to nothing." This judgment is his; this series does not on that basis certify that she is reduced to calculation; exit at the object layer goes separately by Paper 1, CO4. Her participation has not come to nothing: she still pays, still makes requests, still takes delivery; she may even do her own share to the letter, as agreed. Exercises and Games of Judgment III has a sentence of the same form: whether treating him instrumentally "thereby suppresses his participation in the game is another question; my stance alone cannot change the structure of the game".59 One who is reduced to calculation can go on doing the existing division of labor just the same.

So this judgment does not erase what is already there. The deposit paid, the worktable made, the versions of the drawings the two revised, the half of the charge that was bargained over: all are entered as they stand; Paper 1 has read that a cooperation that later loses its premise is entered by period, and does not erase, backward, the shared process that has already happened.60 Nor is the direction premise thereby lost automatically: Shi Yan's direction in this undertaking is read on those few effects of his own; from the other's being reduced to calculation, it cannot be derived that he is no longer headed in that direction either.

A Fallible Judgment, Not Turning to Judge

This judgment is that of Shi Yan's end; it is fallible, and falls at the operation layer: what this series reads is his judgment and his own side from then on (Paper 1, CO4). The object layer is another layer. At its object gate the Conflict Treatise has set down: "If it is later confirmed that the object type never obtained, one exits — one does not turn and judge the other. Exiting says: this case does not belong here. Turning to judge says: the other end does not qualify. The first is about scope; the second is about a person, and the second is not within the powers exercised here."61 This series follows this at the object layer: if it is later confirmed that the object of this case did not obtain, this series exits this case, and does not turn and judge the other (Paper 1, CO4). Shi Yan's reading is not yet such a confirmation: Shi Yan from then on no longer does this undertaking as the cooperation this series reads; this series reads his side by his judgment, does not on that basis certify that You Jia is reduced to calculation, does not say what kind of person she is, and does not judge her inner grounds.

Nor is this judgment the ticket for withdrawing. Shi Yan does not need first to prove that You Jia is purely calculating before he qualifies to stop cooperating; he can stop cooperating on the strength of the current conditions. Economics P2 says that judging a situation non-cultivable is "not a moral judgment ('this person is bad'), not a capacity judgment ('this person is stupid'), but a relational diagnosis".62 Withdrawing one's own side does not even need this diagnosis first: it is a matter on his own side, which §5 has read.

The Share That Cannot Be Demanded

At the end of the branch of recognizing non-cultivability, Economics P2 marks a limit it cannot itself resolve: the other's "not entering 15DD" is itself his non-negotiable. It says that the 15DD party then respects his non-negotiable, because "you cannot force a person to treat you as an end, since force itself violates 15DD"; and his non-negotiable is precisely what prevents "we" from coming into being.63 This paper does not judge what the other's non-negotiable is: only his own end can confirm that. It registers only the one thing this limit makes clear: whether the other is headed in the 15DD direction is not something the end that operates in the 15DD direction can obtain by demanding it. Relation Theory, reading the moment of two-way 15DD, also says that it "does not make later dealings mutual automatically, nor does it let one party afterward demand mutuality of the other".64 Shi Yan can keep the conditions open, can do his own share well, can withdraw; the direction on You Jia's side he cannot obtain by demanding.

No Longer Doing It Together Is Not Conflict

Shi Yan does not take on the second phase; suppose things stop there: one person no longer does this one thing together with another. This does not on that account become conflict as the Conflict Treatise reads it. The Conflict Treatise's threshold is high: two already-formed laws require incompatible action in the same situation, and, further, the way that collision is handled would put at risk the position from which a person can go on making first-person revisions and go on being open to questioning. It says plainly: "A collision that touches that position under no handling at all may be trouble, may be loss, may be a thing that hurts badly, but it is not conflict in the sense used here."65 Not taking on this job does not thereby automatically reach the Conflict Treatise's object threshold; it can be trouble, it can be loss.

Only if things have in fact become conflict as the Conflict Treatise reads it, and the reciprocal condition is currently unavailable, does the Conflict Treatise's unilateral path come in. Safety is checked first then. The Conflict Treatise divides not-safe in two; where the protective conditions have been triggered, one suspends, protects, or hands over first; once asymmetric operations begin substantively to compress a person's capacity to interrupt, to exit, to speak, or his basic conditions, the Conflict Treatise "no longer hears the case alone," and "Protection may come before any reciprocal handling."66 Further along the unilateral path there are three stop gates: one's own subject position or conditions of exit are being actively compressed; one's own first-person position of rewriting is being taken by pressure, dependency or fear; non-cultivability has been judged in the current relational domain. Should any one of them be triggered, the path is suspended.67 Right after the first gate, the Conflict Treatise adds a sentence: "Lacking the reciprocal condition does not itself constitute evil." And what is suspended is only the path: "What is suspended is this path, not a final judgment on this person."68

Nor is the unilateral path the same as going on cultivating the other. The unilateral path is not a synonym for cultivation: it also includes arrangements on one's own side, protection of boundaries, ceasing to apply, suspension and removal, as §5 has read.69 On this path Shi Yan can do nothing at all to You Jia's side, and simply see to his own.

Walking Away, and Leaving Does Not Close the Accounts

Shi Yan no longer goes to You Jia's home, and no longer answers her messages: this is walking away. The Conflict Treatise, which calls it leaving: "Leaving is an external act and takes no technical identity by itself." One and the same leaving, according to the state the matter is in at the moment of leaving, can be avoidance, can be protective withdrawal, can be removal or suspension, and can also be each departing after both have obtained a terminus.70 This paper follows it, and does not read walking away in itself as anything.

Nor does leaving close out what remains. The Conflict Treatise: "Departure can happen; departure does not by itself close those accounts." "And where shared resources, third-party responsibility or procedural obligation remain, leaving does not close them out."71 The finished worktable in You Jia's home, the warranty agreed for the first phase, the half of the widening charge not yet paid: all are still there. The obligations a contract gives belong to the institutional side, which this series acknowledges but does not judge, and only registers, as Paper 3 has read;72 what remains between person and person, and the words said out loud on withdrawing, are read in Paper 7.

Economics P2 also reads another case: when one cannot get out. Where exit costs are so high as to be unaffordable, it places the institution's job in lowering the 15DD party's exit costs, not in forcing the other to become anything.73 That passage belongs to the institutional side, and this series only registers it.

§7 Interfacing with Tradition

Repaying resentment with uprightness. Analects, "Xian wen": 或曰:『以德报怨,何如?』子曰:『何以报德?以直报怨,以德报德。』 (Someone said: "What of repaying resentment with virtue?" The Master said: "With what, then, would you repay virtue? Repay resentment with uprightness, and repay virtue with virtue." English rendering this paper's own.)74 The common question: when the other does not treat me well, how I respond to him without becoming like him. Confucius does not take repaying resentment with virtue: that way, with what would one repay those who treat one with virtue? Nor does he say to repay resentment with resentment. What §5 of this paper reads, "not being used, and not calculating in return," fits with this: not calculating in return is close to not repaying resentment with resentment; not being used is close to not repaying resentment with virtue without reserve.

Where they part lies in bao 报, repaying. What Confucius's sentence asks is still a matter of repaying: with what to respond to the other. The withdrawal this paper reads is not repaying; it is withdrawing one's own side, on one's own account; it heads inward, not toward the other's side. Nor does this paper read repaying resentment with virtue as cultivation: cultivation is not the general opening move of cooperation in which one end is headed in the 15DD direction, and whether to make that move is this end's choice. The word zhi 直 has long been read in many ways; no one commentary is followed here.

Unsocial sociability. In the Fourth Proposition of Idea for a Universal History from a Cosmopolitan Point of View, Kant calls the antagonism of human beings in society their "unsocial sociability" (ungesellige Geselligkeit): human beings want to enter society, and yet constantly resist it; nature uses this antagonism to bring the capacities of human beings to development.75 The common question: how doing things together grows out of two ends that are asymmetric, even antagonistic. Kant's answer lies at the level of the species and of history, and draws on nature's intention. This paper reads one thing two people do together, not nature's plan; nor does it read the other's antagonism as a means of cultivation. To write the other's later progress as something I brought about by way of his antagonism would be to write his growth into my own work in advance, which §3 has already sealed off.

Hobbes. Paper 1 has already taken this up; this paper points back to it.

§8 Drawing Together and Downstream

This paper has set out six propositions. Taken together, they say: cooperation in which one end is headed in the 15DD direction and one leans toward 14DD is within this series' scope, and is a proper object of it; 15DD and 14DD here are stances, not labels for persons, read by the current relational condition, not by persons, and neither party is said to be lower; the end that leans toward 14DD and is within scope at least structurally acknowledges, in this undertaking, that the other has purposes of his own. Such cooperation can be the setting in which cultivation happens, not the source of cultivation; cultivation is not the general opening move of such cooperation; when the person himself chooses to intervene and the boundaries hold, the first step is helping the other stand more firmly on the things he himself cannot set down; the intervention cannot compress the other's authority, channels or practical possibility of refusing, interrupting, revising, exiting and restating himself; cultivation is not instruction, not remaking, and its completion is not in the enactor's hands. The direction is read on that one effect; whether the other's capacity has increased is a measure of outcomes, and is not used to judge direction. The end headed in the 15DD direction can see more clues; clues are still only clues, and long-run relational fact shifts the weight of judgment but does not complete a certification; a one-sided understanding is not settling; whether to go on or to withdraw is his own judgment, on his own account; there is also a bias in the opposite direction. Withdrawing one's own side is inward, and does not carry the direction of colonization; acting in a way directed at the other party that raises his cost is outward, and carries the direction of colonization; what is withdrawn is the side that, once the items are separated, still belongs to oneself, and the items already avowed are checked separately; where one first induces dependency and then withdraws, violation is checked separately at the layer of basic rights, by Relation Theory. When, in this end's own fallible judgment, the other is in this undertaking reduced to calculation, this end from then on no longer does this undertaking as the cooperation this series reads; this series reads his judgment and his own side from then on, and does not on that basis certify that the other is reduced to calculation; what this rests on is a condition of scope, not participation having come to nothing; what is already there is entered as it stands; no longer doing it together does not on that account become conflict; where it has become conflict, the unilateral path is read by the Conflict Treatise's safety check and stop gates; walking away takes no technical identity by itself, and leaving does not close out the shared matters that remain.

This paper does not prove that the party leaning toward 14DD is lower, does not prove that one ought to go and cultivate the other, does not prove that cultivation is bound to take hold, and does not prove that leaving is right.

Questions left open. In the first way things went, in the second year after the bookcases were finished, Shi Yan took on a big job, the woodwork for a whole flat, and needed someone to draw the plans. He remembered You Jia's drawings and looked her up. This time You Jia is the one doing the work; Shi Yan takes her quote to compare with others, cuts her schedule, and says: "You people who draw plans are all the same: quote low first, then revise the drawings and add on." The same two people: in this undertaking, who operates in the 15DD direction and who leans toward 14DD may have changed places exactly, and it may also be that neither is as before. This series reads by that undertaking, records case by case and stretch by stretch, and gives no one person an overall reading; how several undertakings tangled together between two people are to be read, this paper reads only as far as one.

Downstream. What this paper has set out, the later papers use as follows. Going on or withdrawing, and on whom the account falls when one has judged wrongly, are read in Paper 6; the shared matters that remain after withdrawing, the words said out loud on withdrawing, and how the effects already left remain over time, are read in Paper 7; the conditions of scope and the structural clues that Paper 1 has read are used here as they stand, and are not set up again. "Stance" and "label," "withdrawing" and "walking away," and "cultivation" in the broad sense are listed together in Paper 0.

Acknowledgments

This paper is signed by Han Qin alone; the author decided every argument and choice and bears sole responsibility for the text. In drafting, the author used AI models from various developers as tools.

Notes

  1. Paper 1 of this series, CO1, CO4, CO5. For the three further things checked beyond the direction premise, see the section of Paper 1 that reads scope. ↩︎
  2. Marriage Theory Paper 1, MA1: "The marriage this series reads has as its premise that both parties are headed in the 15DD direction"; Paper 1 of this series, in the section that reads scope, at the place where it differs from Marriage Theory by a single word. ↩︎
  3. The layer at which the other is recognized as an end too follows the table in Love Theory Paper 0, §2, and the Introduction to Marriage Theory Paper 1. 14DD anchoring and non-negotiables follow the usage of Learning IV, §1, and Economics P2, §1 and §2; this is only a paraphrase. ↩︎
  4. Economics P2, §1. ↩︎
  5. Relation Theory Paper 1, H8: "Cultivation and colonization are two directions: cultivation goes toward making space, colonization toward pouring in and occupying; the direction is read on this one effect, and whether it took hold is seen in the other party's later understanding and action; the two are not the two extremes of one scale, and the same act can carry both directions, and can also carry no direction at all; they are directions, not labels". ↩︎
  6. Relation Theory Paper 1, H9: "Violation is judged separately, and only at the layer of basic rights; it and the direction of colonization are two lines". ↩︎
  7. "Walking away" follows the Conflict Treatise, §12, whose English word there is leaving; for "exchange is not calculation," see Paper 2 of this series, CO9. ↩︎
  8. Love Theory Paper 0, §2; the Introduction to Marriage Theory Paper 1 accordingly writes "nor a marriage". ↩︎
  9. Marriage Theory Paper 1, MA2: "People are all mixed; a layer records one operation, and falling back is read as it occurs". ↩︎
  10. Marriage Theory Paper 1, MA2; Love Theory Paper 0, §4: "falling back is very likely". ↩︎
  11. Conflict Treatise §7. ↩︎
  12. Conflict Treatise §1: "no test is given anywhere in this treatise for determining which layer the other is running on"; in the same section: "what admits of diagnosis is this operation on this occasion, not this person". ↩︎
  13. Learning IV, Abstract. ↩︎
  14. Economics P2, §4.0: "In the 14DD world, the person across from you is a strategy set". In §2 the same paper, writing from the 14DD party's point of view, also says that it reads the other as a strategy set; this series places this reading on the side of being reduced to calculation; see the main text. ↩︎
  15. Learning IV, Abstract. At the same place: "recognizing the other's independent 14DD is structural, not moral"; see note 13. ↩︎
  16. Paper 1 of this series, CO6. ↩︎
  17. Conflict Treatise §7. ↩︎
  18. Conflict Treatise §20. ↩︎
  19. Economics P2, §4.3: "the 15DD party emerged from 14DD and possesses 14DD's full will and 12DD–13DD's full computational and monitoring capacity". ↩︎
  20. Relation Theory Paper 1, H4. ↩︎
  21. Economics P2, §4.1. ↩︎
  22. Learning IV, Abstract. The English Abstract closes on "but the door opens from the inside"; the two sentences quoted here stand in §10, "Series Recovery," with "There are people outside." between them. ↩︎
  23. Conflict Treatise §20. ↩︎
  24. Conflict Treatise §7. ↩︎
  25. Conflict Treatise §20, citing Economics P2, §4.1. ↩︎
  26. Economics P2, §4.1. ↩︎
  27. Conflict Treatise §20. ↩︎
  28. Conflict Treatise §20. ↩︎
  29. Conflict Treatise §20; Relation Theory Paper 5, H47: "Dependency has two senses: the dependency people have on one another in any case carries no direction of colonization; the kind that was made, and that has locked the path to saying no, carries the direction of colonization; where one first monopolizes, or first induces dependency, and then withdraws, violation is checked at the layer of basic rights by F20". For the latter half, see §5. ↩︎
  30. Conflict Treatise §20. ↩︎
  31. Economics P2, §4.2. ↩︎
  32. Conflict Treatise §21, the limitation on fa-mou (伐谋). ↩︎
  33. Relation Theory Paper 5, H45. ↩︎
  34. Conflict Treatise §20. ↩︎
  35. Economics P2, §4.2. ↩︎
  36. Economics P2, §6.2.1, the open question "Measuring cultivation in economics". ↩︎
  37. Relation Theory Paper 0, §3, the row reading Economics P2, §4.2; the parenthesis that follows there points to Relation Theory Paper 1, H8. ↩︎
  38. Relation Theory Paper 1, H8. ↩︎
  39. Conflict Treatise §28. ↩︎
  40. Conflict Treatise §20, the item on indications after the fact. ↩︎
  41. Economics P2, §4.0. ↩︎
  42. Economics P2, §2. ↩︎
  43. Learning IV, Abstract. ↩︎
  44. Conflict Treatise §7. ↩︎
  45. Economics P2, §3.4. ↩︎
  46. Economics P2, §1, §3.1. ↩︎
  47. Conflict Treatise §7. ↩︎
  48. Conflict Treatise §22. ↩︎
  49. Conflict Treatise §22. ↩︎
  50. Economics P2, §3.4, §4.4. ↩︎
  51. Economics P2, §4.3. ↩︎
  52. Relation Theory Paper 6, H56. ↩︎
  53. Relation Theory Paper 5, H47; see note 29. Under H47, Relation Theory Paper 5 reads Rights Theory P5, F20: where one first monopolizes exclusively, so that substitute circuits are sealed off, and then withdraws, or first induces dependency, closing the other's own pre-existing self-maintained circuit, and then withdraws, violation is checked by F20; the same section also writes: "actual dependency alone, or factual irreplaceability, does not on its own yield the conclusion of violation." H56 and H47 are in Relation Theory Paper 6 and Paper 5 respectively. ↩︎
  54. Paper 2 of this series, CO8, CO9. ↩︎
  55. Relation Theory Paper 6, under H56: "whether the withdrawal is being used to set a penalty on the other party's using a channel"; Relation Theory marks this test there as its own undertaking, and writes: "what is judged is this function, not the syntax." Conflict Treatise §2, §12: where shared resources, third-party responsibility or procedural obligation remain, leaving does not by itself close them out; see §6. ↩︎
  56. Conflict Treatise §20. ↩︎
  57. Economics P2, end of §3.4, before §4 unfolds the two branches. ↩︎
  58. Paper 1 of this series, CO4. ↩︎
  59. Exercises and Games of Judgment III, §3. The original speaks of "my treating him instrumentally"; it is used here for the case of the other's treating me instrumentally, taking the same form, not the direction of the original sentence. ↩︎
  60. Paper 1 of this series, §4 (the section under CO4): a cooperation that later loses its premise is entered by period, and does not erase, backward, the shared process that has already happened. ↩︎
  61. Conflict Treatise §2. ↩︎
  62. Economics P2, §4.3. The third stop gate of Conflict Treatise §28 cites this. ↩︎
  63. Economics P2, end of §4.3. ↩︎
  64. Relation Theory Paper 4, H41. The original speaks of what follows the moment of two-way 15DD; only the point that one party cannot demand mutuality of the other is taken here. ↩︎
  65. Conflict Treatise §1. ↩︎
  66. Conflict Treatise §7, §5. ↩︎
  67. Conflict Treatise §28, a paraphrase of the three stop gates. ↩︎
  68. Conflict Treatise §28. ↩︎
  69. Conflict Treatise §20. ↩︎
  70. Conflict Treatise §12. A paraphrase of the four kinds of leaving: leaving under another name without having faced it is avoidance; leaving first for safety, boundary or fact-checking is protective withdrawal; terminating the running of the handling within the original relation without having obtained a bilateral terminus is removal, and a temporary halt not yet handed over is suspension; each departing after both have obtained a terminus is action after the terminus. ↩︎
  71. Conflict Treatise §2, §12. ↩︎
  72. Paper 3 of this series, CO15. ↩︎
  73. A paraphrase of Economics P2, §5.1. ↩︎
  74. Analects, "Xian wen," per the Chinese Text Project (ctext) text, with the characters given in simplified form; not checked against a printed annotated edition. ↩︎
  75. Kant, Idee zu einer allgemeinen Geschichte in weltbürgerlicher Absicht, Fourth Proposition, Academy edition, vol. VIII, pp. 20 ff. The German "ungesellige Geselligkeit" has been checked against the Academy edition, vol. VIII, p. 20 (the Kant-Korpus electronic text), and agrees with the Projekt Gutenberg transcription. The English "unsocial sociability" follows Lewis White Beck's translation, as transcribed on marxists.org, where the proposition is headed "Fourth Thesis" ("By 'antagonism' I mean the unsocial sociability of men"); the printed edition of that translation has not been checked. The Chinese term 非社会的社会性 and the paraphrase of the Fourth Proposition follow what Shu Yuanzhao's article quotes; He Zhaowu's Chinese translation has not been checked in the original. ↩︎

References

All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version. Quotations are checked item by item in the accompanying audit table.

I · SAE works directly cited in this paper

Qin, H. (2026). The Other End of the Bridge: Economic Rationality When 15DD Faces a Party Who Does Not Enter 15DD (SAE Economics, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19381666

Qin, H. (2026). Learning to Recognize the Other's Purpose (Introduction to SAE Learning, Part Four: The Bridge from 14DD to 15DD) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19491926

Qin, H. (2026). SAE Conflict Treatise: How Subjecthood Is Not Swallowed by Conflict Itself [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22313628

Qin, H. (2026). SAE Relation Theory Paper 0: The Place of Relation Theory [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545115

Qin, H. (2026). SAE Relation Theory Paper 1: What a Relation Is, and What It Is Not [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545047

Qin, H. (2026). SAE Relation Theory Paper 4: Dealings and Expectation [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545057

Qin, H. (2026). SAE Relation Theory Paper 5: The Sediment of Dealings [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545076

Qin, H. (2026). SAE Relation Theory Paper 6: Asymmetry, Divergence and Ending [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545087

Qin, H. (2026). SAE Exercises and Games of Judgment · III: The Cooperative Game (15DD) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23609864

Qin, H. (2026). SAE Love Theory Paper 0: The Place of Love Theory [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23627790

Qin, H. (2026). SAE Marriage Theory Paper 1: Joined [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23819212

II · External works

Classical texts are given in simplified characters.

Analects 论语, "Xian wen" 宪问. Chinese Text Project (ctext), https://ctext.org/analects/xian-wen/zh. (original text; characters given in simplified form; not checked against a printed annotated edition)

Kant, I. (1784). Idee zu einer allgemeinen Geschichte in weltbürgerlicher Absicht, Vierter Satz. Akademie-Ausgabe, Bd. VIII, S. 20 ff. English: "Idea for a Universal History from a Cosmopolitan Point of View," trans. Lewis White Beck, in Kant, On History, Bobbs-Merrill, 1963 (the term as transcribed on marxists.org; the printed edition has not been checked). Chinese: 世界公民观点之下的普遍历史观念, trans. He Zhaowu 何兆武, in 历史理性批判文集. (German term checked against the Academy edition, vol. VIII, p. 20, electronic text, and agrees with the Projekt Gutenberg transcription; the Chinese term and the paraphrase follow Shu Yuanzhao's article as cited; He Zhaowu's translation has not been checked in the original)

III · Secondary literature

Shu Yuanzhao 舒远招. 从世界公民概念看康德的普世主义思想 [Kant's Universalism Seen from the Concept of the World Citizen]. Aisixiang, https://www.aisixiang.com/data/106523.html

Interfaces

  • Main upstream: the Conflict Treatise (§1, §2, §5, §7, §12, §20 to §22, §28); Economics P2 (§1, §2, §3.1, §3.4, §4.0 to §4.4, §5.1, §6.2.1); Learning IV (Abstract, §1, §10); Relation Theory Paper 1 (H4, H8, H9), Paper 4 (H41), Paper 5 (H45, H47; the section under H47), Paper 6 (H56; the section under H56); Relation Theory Paper 0 (§3).
  • Also used: Rights Theory P5 (F20, by way of Relation Theory Paper 5, the section under H47); Exercises and Games of Judgment III (§3); Love Theory Paper 0 (§2, §4); Marriage Theory Paper 1 (Introduction, MA1, MA2).
  • This series: continues from Paper 1, CO1, CO4 to CO6, and the three kinds outside scope; from Paper 2, CO8 and CO9, that exchange is not calculation; from Paper 3, CO15, what concerns the contract; Paper 6 takes up the account of going on or withdrawing, and the judgment layer's falling on each person himself; Paper 7 takes up the shared matters that remain after withdrawing, and the words said out loud on withdrawing; Paper 0 lists together the shared words and the six propositions.