Self-as-an-End
SAE Cooperation Theory · Paper 4

"We"
「我们」

Han Qin (秦汉) · Independent Researcher · 2026
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24029143 · Full PDF on Zenodo · CC BY 4.0
Abstract

This paper reads the "we" in cooperation. People who do things together say "we" every day: our team, this project of ours, our company, all our years of friendship. Following Relation Theory, this series first asks one question: when "we" is said, which branch is it? One branch is doing things together; the other is mutual recognition. Which branch occurs is checked case by case; it is not assigned in advance by the kind of relation, nor assigned in advance to the branch of doing things together because the matter is cooperation. Neither branch comes before the persons, nor stands above them; doing things together does not automatically produce a position that legislates each side's own law for the two. The ordinary plural holds as usual: "We taught twelve people this week" puts into one sentence what each person has done, and sets up no third party.

Judging one party's law for him in the name of "for the team," "for the project" or "for the company," that is, using the name of "we" or of a construct to take in and replace one party's direction, has the same form as judging one party's law for her in the name of "this household" or "for our sake," which Marriage Theory has read, and carries the direction of colonization. That the one who takes the lead puts forward a request concerning an arrangement is not, in itself, of this kind; whether it is, is checked first against the existing authority and commitments. One and the same sentence, "For this project, everyone has to come in this weekend," is a request in one arrangement, an authority that comes with a position in another, and only in a third the taking in and replacing under a borrowed name. A company is a construct; it is the address of attribution, not the subject of the act, nor a third bearer; what is said in its name is traced back to the person who said it and the position he is in. Guarding comes back to the individual: not handing over one's judgment under "we decided together," not possessing others under "I have contributed," not cancelling recognition of concrete people for the sake of a shared ideal.

Mutual recognition occurs in cooperation too, and can be real. "We're friends, so you have to agree" has the same form as "We love each other, so you have to agree": it borrows the branch of mutual recognition to pass final judgment on something done together; the one who borrows it can be on either side. When several people do one thing together, it is read by pairwise accounting; passing through a third person does not release the instigator from his part; a little circle of several people does not form a third bearer; where a little circle maintains an arrangement premised on "outsiders are merely means," it is read by Paper 1's reading of collusion; formal organizations and their staffing structures belong to the institutional side; "each has a share," in something done together, is carried to several people and read in the same way. This paper interfaces with Rousseau's general will and Searle's collective intentionality, stating the level of each comparison, and takes up the line of the Analects on being sociable without being partisan (群而不党); Gilbert's plural subject is pointed back to Relation Theory. This paper does not prove that a team ought not to have a shared goal, nor that people who do things together ought not to recognize each other.

Introduction

Xia Chi and Kuang Ming have known each other for twenty years. At university they shared a dormitory room, and after graduating each found work in the city: Xia Chi spent a dozen-odd years as a woodworker in a furniture factory; Kuang Ming changed jobs several times, and the one he kept longest was organizing events for a bookshop. Four years ago the two jointly rented an old warehouse on the edge of the city and began running a woodworking class every weekend, teaching people from the neighborhood to make small stools and bookshelves. The class was something the two started together: Xia Chi saw to the craft, and Kuang Ming to the running of it, finding students, scheduling lessons, taking the money, keeping the books. The class was never registered as a company, and the two never signed a partnership agreement; only in the first year did Kuang Ming write two lines on a sheet of paper, and both of them signed it: income, after rent and timber, is split half and half between the two; whether to take on new classes, the two decide by talking it over.

This spring a company phoned, wanting to book four weekends as team-building for its staff, at three times the usual price of a weekend. Kuang Ming wanted to take it: the lease on the warehouse runs out at the end of the year, and the landlord has said the rent is going up. Xia Chi did not: for those four weekends the regular students would have to stop, and among them are a few old people who have come since the year the class opened and have not missed a single weekend. The two talked it over for a whole afternoon at the warehouse door, and neither could bring the other round. Just before dark, Kuang Ming said: "We've been friends all these years; on this one, do as I say."

In the same month, at the other end of the city, Pang Licheng was leading a small team of five at a company that makes educational software, racing to finish an online-course platform for schools in mountain areas. Ten days before launch, a serious problem turned up in testing. That night he posted one line in the team's group chat: "For this project, everyone has to come in this weekend."

In both sentences there is a "we," or a name that speaks for "we." What Kuang Ming borrows is the two men's twenty years of friendship; what Pang Licheng borrows is the project. These two things are what this paper asks about: when "we" is said in cooperation, what is being said; and when someone speaks under the name of "we," what is being borrowed, what the borrowing can move, and what it cannot.

What this paper reads. The earlier papers read how two people do one thing together: what the cooperation this series reads has as its premise, and what it looks like (Paper 1); two people, each for his own purpose, with reciprocal exchange, with one end giving conditions, with both giving (Paper 2); division of labor as an arrangement the two avow together, which can be changed, and whose binding force passes through each one's own law, or comes from a procedure both parties have already recognized (Paper 3). This paper reads the names of that undertaking: the team, the project, the company, and "we."

This paper reads five things. First, which branch the "we" in cooperation is. Second, how judging one party's law for him in the name of the team, the project or the company is told apart from the one who takes the lead putting forward a request. Third, guarding coming back to the individual. Fourth, how mutual recognition occurs in cooperation, and how it gets borrowed as adjudication. Fifth, several people: when several people do one thing together, how the accounts are kept, and what a little circle is.

On each of these, the direction of colonization can be read. Colonization, in this series, names the direction of one effect: toward pouring in and occupying; the other direction is cultivation, toward making space. The direction is read on this one effect, and whether it took hold is seen in the other party's later understanding and action.1

Shared words. "We" has three uses in everyday speech. The first is speaking of things together: putting into one sentence what several people have each done, or each gone through. The second is one of the branches Relation Theory divides, doing things together; the third is the other branch, mutual recognition.2 Neither of the latter two is a "we" standing above several people and making decisions for them.

"Team" and "project" are used in everyday speech to name something done together, or the few people who do it together; this paper uses them in this sense, and does not read them as something with a law of its own. "Company" is different: a company is a construct, and has institutional status.

"Construct" has two uses in this paper. When Relation Theory says that "a relation is a construct," it takes the broad sense: the construct left when the effect of one side enters the conditions of occurrence of the other side, which does not legislate and bears nothing.3 The construct the Political Economy series speaks of is an arrangement with institutional status: "a company, a foundation and a level of government are all constructs".4 When this paper says "a company is a construct," it takes the second sense; when it speaks of what doing things together leaves between two people, it takes the first.

"Bearer" and "address of attribution" are used apart. A bearer, as in Relation Theory, is the one at one end of a relation, who has a law of his own and bears what he himself has done; the other side of a relation must be a bearer.5 The address of attribution, as in the Political Economy series and On Accountability, is a construct taken as the place where the account falls first.6 When two friends register their small shop as a company, the company is the address of attribution, not a third bearer.

Method. As in the earlier papers: the conclusions of upstream papers are said in plain words; sources, the proposition numbers of other papers, and the places where upstream words are carried beyond their original place all go in the notes, and where something is extended, this series takes it on as its own undertaking. What has already been said at the relational layer is used here directly, not rewritten; that doing things together does not automatically produce a position that legislates for both has been established in Action Theory, and this paper calls on it, without establishing it again. Contracts, organizations, employment and positions are acknowledged but not judged, and are registered as conditions of the effects; this paper reads only the side the institution does not provide for, or that goes beyond its provisions: what lies between persons. This paper speaks only of structure, not of good and bad, and issues no ought.

Xia Chi and Kuang Ming, and Pang Licheng's team, are made-up examples; everyone in them is an adult, and they are used only to see structure. Xia Chi and Kuang Ming are a case of cooperation between friends; Pang Licheng's example is set in the workplace, and there a factual record of the relevant provisions is given first; what it does not give is recorded as unchecked, and is not filled in. From outside, a person's words and deeds are only clues, and do not certify who is at which layer.

§1 Which Branch "We" Is

CO17 Doing things together does not automatically produce a position that legislates each side's own law for them. When "we" is said in cooperation, it is checked first which branch it is: doing things together, or mutual recognition; which branch occurs is checked case by case, and is not assigned in advance by the kind of relation. The ordinary plural "we" holds as usual

Two Branches

Whenever Relation Theory says "we," it must state which branch it means.7 One branch is doing things together; the other is mutual recognition.

Doing things together. The example stipulates: Xia Chi runs this class so that his craft has people outside the factory to carry it on; Kuang Ming, so that there is a place in the city he has got going himself, where people with nowhere to go at weekends have somewhere to go. What the two have to do is one and the same thing: keep the class going. Action Theory writes this shape as: "One person is for purpose A, another for purpose B, and the two cannot not do C: C is something both of them avow and both are able to do, whose purpose and adjudication neither side holds alone; it is doing something together, not a shared law."8 The class is C. Xia Chi's share is the craft, Kuang Ming's the running of it; if either share is missing, there is no class.

Mutual recognition. The example also stipulates: in the winter of the first year, an old man whose hands shook badly came to learn to plane wood, and Xia Chi stayed beside him and planed with him a whole afternoon, without one word more than was needed. Kuang Ming stood by, watching. What he saw was not only a patient master; he saw that this was Xia Chi's, that it came out from Xia Chi's side, and that it was not his to give. That afternoon Kuang Ming moved the other students' lessons out of the way; Xia Chi learned of it later, and made out, too, that this was Kuang Ming's own arranging, not something done for him. Value Theory writes this as mutual recognition: resonance is a mutual recognition between the two, "and what is recognised is that the other has values of his own. It does not constitute a third value, a third source or a third bearer".9 If that moment was like this, there is a "we" between the two; it is the two recognizing in each other what is the other's, not the two merging into one. What can be seen from outside is only two people standing for a while in the warehouse, and a few words exchanged as they packed up.

What both branches give is only the minimal bound past which "we" does not stand in for anyone, not a sufficient theory of any kind of cooperation.10 Which branch is met in a stretch of cooperation is checked case by case: running the class is doing things together; one winter afternoon like that, in twenty years, is mutual recognition; one and the same "we" falls on this branch on one occasion and on that branch on another. What this series chiefly reads is doing things together; mutual recognition occurs in cooperation too, and §4 reads it. Nothing is assigned in advance by the kind of relation: one does not say that, because the two went in together on a class, there is only doing things together between them; nor that, because the two are old friends, every "we" between them is mutual recognition.

Not Before, Not Above

Neither branch comes before the two people, nor stands above them.

Not before: doing things together exists only when both have avowed it; mutual recognition exists only when each of the two makes out that what is the other's is the other's. Without these two people, there is neither.

Not above: "Doing things together does not automatically produce a position that legislates each side's own law for them."11 What is done together has its rules, and the rules remain valid as usual. The two lines Kuang Ming wrote on that sheet of paper bind Xia Chi, and bind Kuang Ming too. By what do they bind? Reading two people who live together as they agree on a household rule, the Conflict Treatise wrote two sentences: "Consensus does not automatically generate a third first-person legislator"; "that rule's binding force must pass separately through each party's own law, or come from a procedure both have acknowledged".12 "Split half and half" binds Xia Chi by way of his signing it, and binds Kuang Ming by way of his signing it. "Whether to take on new classes, the two decide by talking it over" speaks of exactly a way of deciding that both have recognized. That sheet of paper was not handed down by "we" as a third party.

Value Theory draws the edge of this sentence more finely. Of something two people have agreed on: "What it binds here is the arrangement of action they have agreed on and the responsibility that follows; it has not thereby acquired the authority to rank either party's value standing"; and: "If some other kind of collective subject can hold, it must be shown by its own conditions of constitution; it does not follow from this one joint decision".13 This paper follows this. Whether a team or a project can come to stand separately as a bearer, this series does not judge; it says only that doing things together does not yield one.

The Ordinary Plural

"We taught twelve people this week." Kuang Ming writes this in the account book at the end of the year. The "we" in this sentence is speaking of things together: those Xia Chi taught and those Kuang Ming brought in, said in one sentence. It sets up no third party, and decides nothing for anyone.

Action Theory has read a sentence that looks weightier. In a small Dutch village, in the years of the occupation, almost every household hid someone at some point; one of those who did the coordinating later looked back: "What we did was nothing special. We did what had to be done. If we hadn't done it, who would have?" Action Theory reads it this way: "The 'we' in these words is many people's separate deeds spoken of together, not a 'we' standing above those people and deciding for them."14

So what this proposition blocks is not the word "we." When people in cooperation say "we," what they mean, by far the greater part of the time, is just this: the thing done together, or what several people have each done. What it blocks is the word's being used to occupy a position: a position that legislates for the two, and passes final judgment on each one's own law on their behalf. Which branch a sentence falls in, or whether it is only speaking of things together, is checked case by case.

One Question First

So when "we" is said in cooperation, one question comes first: which branch is meant this time? "We've decided to take those four weekends": if both have avowed it, this is the branch of doing things together, and there is a C; if only Kuang Ming has avowed it, it is one person's decision, under the name of "we." Action Theory wrote in the same paper: "neither side can declare agreement in the other's place".15 This question is not hair-splitting. It separates what each of two people has avowed in a sentence from what one person has said on another's behalf. As for the sentence Paper 1 left open, Yu Ping saying to others "the fence we mended": the fence is the thing both avowed and in which each had a share, so this "we" falls on the branch of doing things together; it sets up no third party.

§2 In the Name of the Team, the Project, the Company

CO18 Judging one party's law for him in the name of "for the team," "for the project" or "for the company," that is, using the name of "we" or of a construct to take in and replace one party's direction, has the same form as judging one party's law for her in the name of "this household" or "for our sake," which Marriage Theory has read, and carries the direction of colonization. That the one who takes the lead puts forward a request concerning an arrangement is not, in itself, of this kind; whether it is, is checked first against the existing authority and commitments

The Factual Record

For Pang Licheng's sentence, the factual record has to be laid out first. The facts this example stipulates are as follows.

Pang Licheng's team has five people: himself; his deputy, Wei Zhou; Wu Qing; Bao Ning; and a colleague who joined half a year ago. Pang Licheng is the person in charge of this team, and the duties of his post are set out in the job description the company gave him: managing the scheduling and division of labor for this project, and reporting progress to the department. All five employment contracts state that weekends are rest days. The company's employee handbook states: weekend overtime is to be applied for in advance, requires the employee's own consent, and is made up afterward with time off in lieu or extra pay. At the project meeting at the start of the year, the five agreed on one line, which went into the minutes: in the two weeks before launch, everyone shoulders the work together, and whoever can come in at the weekend comes in.

Wu Qing attends a weekend program at a university every Saturday morning, studying for a degree she began only after she started working; she said so when she joined, and everyone on the team knows it. Pang Licheng's job description gives him no authority to schedule weekend overtime without the person's own consent. Other facts the example does not give: whether the company has further rules about urgent launches, what this project means to the company, whether Pang Licheng himself has been asked for anything from above; all are recorded as unchecked, and not filled in.

That night Pang Licheng posted in the group chat: "For this project, everyone has to come in this weekend." The next morning Wu Qing replied: "I have class Saturday morning; I can come in on Sunday."

One Sentence, Three Arrangements

This sentence takes on different effects in different arrangements.

In one, it is a request. By the record above, weekend overtime requires the person's own consent. Pang Licheng's line in the group chat was strongly put, but as it reaches each person it is a request: he puts it forward, and each person separately agrees or does not. Wu Qing's saying Saturday is no good and Sunday is fine is her share; when Pang Licheng then schedules her for Sunday, as she said, the sentence stays a request. That the one who takes the lead puts forward a request concerning an arrangement is not, in itself, judging for someone under a borrowed name. Putting forward requests is his share in this thing done together; the other's response enters his later conditions of occurrence, and is material, not a settling of the account.16

In another, it is an authority that comes with a position. Suppose a different institutional background, unlike the record above: in this variant of the example, the rules currently applying give the person in charge this authority to set schedules; the weekends before a project launches are scheduled by the person in charge, and employees work as scheduled; the clause in the original record that weekend overtime requires the person's own consent does not apply in this variant. These are institutional facts stipulated for this variant, registered as facts, without judging whether this institutional arrangement is in itself legitimate; how it fits with the other clauses of the employment contract and the employee handbook belongs to the institutional side, and this variant stipulates only the result. Then the binding force of the sentence comes from those rules: it is an authority that comes with the position. This side belongs to institution: the provisions themselves are acknowledged but not judged, and the authority that comes with a position is acknowledged but not judged as well; both are registered as conditions of the effects.17 Acknowledging but not judging marks out the range this paper reads: registering an authority is not vouching for its legitimacy, nor is it saying that the effects within the institution are all already without problems; how that side is assessed belongs to the institutional side. The Conflict Treatise has written: "Other authorities of role, of law, or of procedure settle separately within their own domains".18 What this paper reads is still the side the institution does not provide for, or that goes beyond its provisions: Pang Licheng sets the schedule by those rules, and how he then speaks to Wu Qing is still a matter between persons.

The third: taking in and replacing under a borrowed name. Back to the original record: Pang Licheng has no such authority, and Wu Qing has already said she will not come in on Saturday. He replies in the group chat: "The project belongs to all of us, not just to you. For this project, put that class of yours aside for now."

What this sentence does differs from the first two. It is not putting forward a request and waiting for her to agree; nor is it invoking a rule. It takes "the project" as its name, and judges Wu Qing's law for her: whether she goes to her class on Saturday is not for her to decide but for the project. Marriage Theory has read a sentence of the same form. A mother-in-law says to her daughter-in-law: "for the sake of this household, don't go looking for that conservation room"; Marriage Theory reads this as using "this household" to judge her law for her, taking where she is going into "the household," and then having "the household" decide it for her.19 Pang Licheng's sentence has just this shape: taking where Wu Qing is going into the project, and then having the project decide it for her. This is using "we," or a name, to take in and replace one party's direction, and it carries the direction of colonization. Whether it took hold is seen in her course afterward: if from then on she treats her weekend class as something that first has to get past the project, this direction has taken hold.20

The line in the minutes from the start of the year needs checking here too. "Whoever can come in at the weekend comes in" is what all five avowed; what Wu Qing avowed is this line, not "everyone has to come in." If Pang Licheng says "We agreed on this at the start of the year," what he borrows is a joint decision that was never made: what the five agreed was that whoever can come in comes in, and he has turned it into everyone having to come in, avowing on Wu Qing's behalf something she never avowed.21

A Name Does Not Speak

The project is the name of something done together. It does not legislate, bears nothing, and does not pass final judgment on anyone's own law on his behalf.22 The one who says "for this project" is always a person. He can be genuinely anxious for the project, and the sentence can also be telling how hard things are on his side; those are material. What this paper reads is what the sentence is used to do: if it is used to judge another person's law for him, then the one speaking is still he, using the project's name.

So too with the team. The words "for the team" fall at a point that Action Theory's paper on guarding has named: guarding has two faces; the outward face blocks colonization coming from outside, and the inward face blocks, on one's own side, "treating people as means again from inside, in the name of efficiency, solidarity, development or security".23 What "for the team" borrows is often the word solidarity. Action Theory writes plainly that treating people as means need not come from outside; it can grow out of the guarding side too, under changing names.24 This paper reads by structure: a "for the team" used to take in and replace a person's direction carries the direction of colonization, however much the speaker values the team.

The Name of the Company

"For the company" adds one more layer: a company is a construct, and has institutional status.

The Political Economy Prequel writes of the construct: "A construct is an arrangement with institutional status: a company, a foundation and a level of government are all constructs; it is the address of attribution, not the subject of the act".25 Power Theory says it more briefly: "the apparatus does not exercise power; individuals exercise power by invoking the apparatus."26 The account for what a company does falls first at the company as its address; the positions and persons who did it each have their own accountability, checked separately. The Political Economy Prequel uses a sentence of Institution Theory: "The construct's name does not shield an individual responsibility that has independent grounds, and the construct's failure is not automatically transferred onto any one person."27

So if Pang Licheng says "for the company," the check goes in two steps. First, whether the sentence lies within his authority as checked: put forward within that authority, it is a matter of position, read as in the second arrangement above, belonging to the institutional side, acknowledged but not judged; this says only that his use of the company's name does not certify the sentence as judging for someone under a borrowed name; how the authority itself, and its exercise, are assessed belongs to the institutional side. Second, for the part that goes beyond his authority, the one speaking is he, and what he borrows is the company's name. A company is the address of attribution, not the subject of the act; it does not say this sentence; nor is it a third bearer, and it cannot bear this sentence for Pang Licheng.28 What a person has done himself cannot be acknowledged by someone else in his place,29 nor handed over to the company to acknowledge.

This sits in the same place as Marriage Theory's reading of borrowing "the household": what is borrowed is a name, what is said is "we," what is done is one person judging for another. Marriage Theory says that marriage, like other institutions, cannot produce a "we" that gathers each person into one;30 a company is the same. Institutions can let people find each other and can protect them, but "cannot produce a 'we' on behalf of both".31 The Theory of Inter-State Cooperation has written a sentence of the same form at the layer of construct and construct: what is done in the system's name is traced back to the member states that made it, to their positions and their votes.32 Brought down into a team: what is said in the name of the team, the project or the company is traced back to the person who said it and the position he is in.

Not by Sentence Form

The sentence form "For the team, you have to ..." is hard to judge across the board in cooperation. What it actually borrows is checked by its use on that occasion, not assigned by its sentence form.

It can be only a reminder. "For the team, get your weekly report in by this Friday." The weekly report is a rule the five agreed on at the start of the year, and Wu Qing avowed it; Pang Licheng, reminding her, speaks from the share she avowed, and on this occasion the rule's binding force passes through her own law.

It can be invoking the authority that comes with a position, read as in the second arrangement above.

It can also be taking in and replacing under a borrowed name, read as in the third arrangement above.

The three have the same sentence form and different structures. So this paper does not say that the words "for the team," "for the project" or "for the company" carry the direction of colonization; it says that what they are used to do is read on that occasion.

§3 Guarding Comes Back to the Individual

CO19 Guarding comes back to the individual: not handing over one's judgment under "we decided together," not possessing others under "I have contributed," not cancelling recognition of concrete people for the sake of a shared ideal

Action Theory, reading guarding, lands in the end on one sentence: guarding comes back to the individual.33 This section brings it down to three places in cooperation.

Not Handing Over One's Judgment under "We Decided Together"

After Wu Qing replied "I have class Saturday morning," the other three in the group chat each replied "OK." Wei Zhou took her aside and said: "Everyone's agreed; you're the only one left."

There are two things in this sentence, to be kept apart.

One concerns Wu Qing. The other three each agreed, and that is each one's own; three people added together do not make a "we" that judges for her. Action Theory's paper on guarding has a weightier scene: a dozen or so people had signed a list, and one person had not; "However many sign, they cannot stand in for one's own judgment".34 Whether Wu Qing comes in on Saturday is still hers to judge.

The other concerns those three themselves. Each one's replying "OK" is each one's own judgment; if any of them replied "OK" only because the others had, he has handed his own judgment over to "everyone." This is a first-person matter, which cannot be seen from outside; this paper does not judge it, and records only this point of structure: a joint decision does not make, for any one person, his share of judgment.

There is another case to be kept apart from this one. Suppose the five had agreed on a procedure at the start of the year: who comes in on the weekends before launch is decided by a vote, the minority going along with the majority; and Wu Qing too recognized this procedure at the time. Then the result of the vote governs how this weekend is arranged, and its binding force comes from the procedure all five recognized in advance; it is read as Paper 3 reads a procedure already recognized.35 In acting by a procedure one has recognized oneself, the judgment is still one's own: recognizing that procedure was her own judgment. Handing over one's judgment means that there is no such recognized procedure, and she is decided for only on the strength of "everyone's agreed"; or that the procedure is there, but a person, in voting, no longer judges, and simply votes with the side that has more people; this is a first-person matter, which cannot be seen from outside.

Not Possessing Others under "I Have Contributed"

The project made it in the end. After the wrap-up meeting, Pang Licheng said to Wu Qing: "I'm the one who brought you onto this team; you've come on so much these two years, and think how much work I've put into you. When you didn't come in this Saturday, it hurt."

The first half of this is fact, and the second half is how hard things are on his side; both are material. What this paper reads is another use: if the sentence is used to say "so you owe the team a Saturday," or "so from now on, your weekends are mine to decide," that is using one's own giving to possess the other. Action Theory has written of this point: "One is not fuel for the phase transition, and others are not contributors to be trained"; one who has provided conditions does not thereby become the one who completed that step for the other.36 Wu Qing has come on these two years, and her coming on is her own; Pang Licheng provided conditions, which is what he himself did, and it is entered with him. Using one's giving to possess the other, recording the other's share as one's own: Paper 2 and Paper 6 each read one instance of this.37

Not Cancelling Recognition of Concrete People for the Sake of a Shared Ideal

What Pang Licheng's team is building is an online-course platform for schools in mountain areas. This is a real shared ideal: more than one of the five came for this.

"This is for thousands of children; what's one Saturday of yours?" If this sentence were said, it would use a large and real ideal to cancel recognition of one concrete person: her Saturday does not count before this ideal. In its paper on guarding, Action Theory writes: "However great a shared ideal, when it comes down to the ground, it is still concrete people, one by one."38 The same paper also sets down a sentence, said originally of a large phase transition, which is carried here to the ideal of one project: a shared direction "is a direction that can be faced together, not a higher end entitled to requisition a person".39 The online-course platform is a direction the five can face together; it is not thereby entitled to requisition Wu Qing's Saturday.

This point differs from the last section. The last section read borrowing the name of a team, a project or a company; this point reads borrowing an ideal. An ideal is not a name; it can be real, and can be something everyone has avowed. Avowing it still does not give it the authority to judge a person's law for him.

On Whom It Falls

That guarding comes back to the individual means that guarding, where there is any, falls with each person himself: on Wu Qing's side; on whether Pang Licheng borrows a name; on whether Wei Zhou, passing a message on, adds the words "everyone's agreed." There is no "team" guarding for them. Action Theory says: "So what is guarded cannot be quietly swapped for the survival of an organization, the survival of a rule, the survival of a small group"; "What is guarded has always been those people not being reduced to means".40

This section does not say that a team ought not to have a shared goal. The goal is real, the launch deadline is real, and that some of the five worked through two weekends for it is real too. This section says only that none of this hands over a person's judgment for him, records his coming on for him, or cancels his Saturday for him.

§4 Mutual Recognition

CO20 Mutual recognition occurs in cooperation too; not borrowing mutual recognition as adjudication: "We're friends, so you have to agree" has the same form as "We love each other, so you have to agree," and borrows the branch of mutual recognition to pass final judgment on something done together

Mutual Recognition in Cooperation

What Cooperation Theory chiefly reads is doing things together. Yet people who do things together also recognize each other. The winter afternoon stipulated in §1 was one such time. Action Theory, reading the year two people worked together, also writes that each gained something from the other: "Mutual cultivation is two people illuminating each other: each one's unfolding also illuminates the other".41 In Xia Chi and Kuang Ming's twenty years there was more than one such time. This series does not count them, nor does it infer from them at which layer this cooperation is: mutual recognition is recorded one occasion at a time; a stretch of cooperation is not recorded as mutual recognition.

"We've Been Friends All These Years; on This One, Do as I Say"

Back to the sentence at the warehouse door in the Introduction. This sentence takes on different effects in different arrangements.

In one, it is an appeal, carrying the weight of his side. Having said it, Kuang Ming goes on to the rent: the lease runs out at the end of the year, the landlord wants thirty percent more, and the money from those four weekends would just cover it. If, after this, the two go on talking it over as before, Xia Chi can still say no, and Kuang Ming answers the company according to that no, then "friendship" in this sentence is his way of setting out the weight of his side: in twenty years he has given way, helped, waited, and he asks Xia Chi to give way to him this once. As it reaches Xia Chi, this sentence is material.42 This is not borrowing mutual recognition as adjudication.

In another, it is used to pass final judgment. If, having said this, Kuang Ming calls the company back the next day, says all four weekends are booked, and does not ask Xia Chi again; or, when Xia Chi raises it again, says "So you don't count me as a friend?": then what this sentence does is use twenty years of friendship to pass final judgment on something done together. Whether to take these four weekends is, by that sheet of paper, for the two to decide by talking it over; in that case Kuang Ming has decided it alone, and the name he has used is friendship. Relation Theory has read a sentence of the same form: "'We love each other, so you have to agree': this sentence borrows mutual recognition to pass final judgment on a matter done together."43 "We're friends, so you have to agree" has the same shape: what it borrows is the branch of mutual recognition, to make an adjudication for the branch of doing things together.

This can also come from the other side. Suppose Xia Chi says: "If you really count me as a friend, don't take this job." This too borrows mutual recognition as adjudication; only the one who borrows it has changed. Mutual recognition does not stand on either side; the one who borrows it can be on either side.

Mutual Recognition Can Be Real

To borrow it as adjudication is not to say that the friendship is false. By the stipulation in §1, that winter afternoon the two really did recognize in each other what was the other's. Even so, mutual recognition generates no third party that could decide for the two whether something done together is to be done. The branch of mutual recognition follows Value Theory: it constitutes no third value, no third source and no third bearer;44 in the branch of doing things together, binding force still passes separately through each of the two people's own law, or comes from a way of deciding both have already recognized.45 Love Theory has set down the same between two people who love each other: "'We' does not legislate, and does not pass final judgment on either party's own law; 'We love each other, so you have to agree' borrows mutual recognition to pass final judgment on a matter done together".46 Friendship in cooperation does not pass final judgment either.

Nor are twenty years of friendship something that can be drawn on to offset an account. What the two have done toward each other over twenty years has left effects: Xia Chi knows how hard those years were for Kuang Ming, Kuang Ming knows what Xia Chi put up with at the factory; these enter every judgment they make afterward.47 But the effects left are material, not a qualification,48 and do not make either party, from then on, qualified to decide something done together on the other's behalf.

Not Turning to Judge

If Kuang Ming's sentence is borrowed as adjudication, nothing is inferred backward from it: neither that he is, from then on, not headed in the 15DD direction, nor that the friendship was never there. The direction is read on this one effect;49 this time it carries the direction of colonization, and it is entered for this occasion. How the two later decided about those four weekends, the example does not say.

§5 Several People

CO21 When several people do one thing together, it is read by pairwise accounting; passing through a third person does not release the instigator from his part; a little circle of several people does not form a third bearer; where a little circle maintains an arrangement premised on "outsiders are merely means," it is read by Paper 1's reading of collusion. Formal organizations and their staffing structures belong to the institutional side. "Each has a share," in something done together, is carried to several people and read in the same way

Pairwise Accounting

Pang Licheng's team has five people. Among the five, effects still occur pair by pair: Pang Licheng on Wu Qing, Pang Licheng on Bao Ning, Wei Zhou on Wu Qing, Wu Qing on Bao Ning, one stretch after another. Relation Theory records them this way: "Where three or more are involved, dealings that do not pass through an institution are broken down into effects between pairs and entered on separate accounts".50 The five are not merged into one "team" to keep one combined account.

The team is in a company, and the company is an institution. By §2, the part the institution provides for, posts, the authority to schedule, the procedure for overtime, belongs to the institutional side, acknowledged but not judged; the part it does not provide for, or that goes beyond its provisions, lies between persons, and is entered pair by pair.51 Of Pang Licheng's sentence in the group chat, what falls within his authority is a matter of position; the part that goes beyond it is one stretch toward Wu Qing, one toward Bao Ning, one toward each person.

Passing Through a Third Person

After Wu Qing replied "I have class Saturday morning," Pang Licheng did not answer in the group chat, but had Wei Zhou go and find her. Wei Zhou said to Wu Qing: "Pang says you have to come in Saturday, and everyone's agreed."

This sentence passed through a third person. Relation Theory writes: "passing through a third person does not release the instigator from his part"; and: "If A has C tell B something, and the words reach B, A's effect on B remains on A's account, and C's passing it on is on C's account; both entries stand."52 "You have to come in Saturday" is Pang Licheng's, entered in Pang Licheng's stretch toward Wu Qing; the "everyone's agreed" that Wei Zhou added in passing it on is Wei Zhou's, entered in Wei Zhou's stretch toward Wu Qing. Pang Licheng still has that stretch, though he did not say it himself; Wei Zhou still has the words he added, though he was only passing a message on.

A Little Circle Does Not Form a Third Bearer

When the weekend was over, Bao Ning posted in the group chat: "The four of us pulled it off." This sentence is speaking of things together: four people each came in, each worked through it, said in one sentence.

Go one step further: "The four of us think Wu Qing let us down this time." This sentence looks like a "four of us" judging Wu Qing; in structure it is still four people's separate judgments said together, and each one's stretch toward Wu Qing is entered on that person's account. Relation Theory says that a little circle of two does not form a third bearer;53 a little circle of four is the same: it does not, because there are more people, produce a third party that judges for the four and bears for the four.54 A person who puts his own judgment into "the four of us" to say it still has his stretch as his own.

A Little Circle That Takes Outsiders as Means

There is one more kind, which needs to be pointed out on its own. Suppose Bao Ning, Wei Zhou and the colleague who joined recently agree privately among the three: from now on, whatever piece of weekend work each of them has to rush is first passed to Wu Qing, and passing it on with a word counts as handing it in. What they agree on comes to this: her weekends do not count; it is enough that someone takes the work off their hands. This is an arrangement the three jointly avow and maintain, and its premise is written into what they agreed: in this arrangement, Wu Qing appears only as the one who takes the work off their hands; what she herself would do with her weekends is not among the things the arrangement counts. None of the three is in charge of scheduling or division of labor in the team; by the record in §2, that belongs to Pang Licheng's post; scheduling, division of labor and the procedure for weekend overtime belong to position and institution, and are acknowledged but not judged. What is read here is the arrangement agreed among the three.

Paper 1 has already read this kind in reading collusion: an arrangement premised on a third person's being merely a means, and maintained jointly, is read for the premise of that arrangement, not for the persons.55 By the reading there: 15DD recognizes that the other, too, is an end in itself, and does not recognize him on the strength of who he is or what he has; Wu Qing is a person too, yet in this arrangement she is treated merely as a means; then the recognition among the three, in this undertaking, does not rest on the other's being a person, or else Wu Qing would be included too; it rests on some other item, such as whether one is inside this circle. Which item it rests on, this paper does not decide, nor does it decide it for them from outside; what can be decided is only this: on the strength of this item, people are ranked high and low, and the one outside the circle is laid out toward the side of means; recognition of this kind is not in the direction of recognizing the other as an end too, and so in this undertaking none of the three is headed in the 15DD direction. This speaks of the premise of that arrangement, not of the three people's inner lives; nor does it say how long this arrangement can last, nor that once that item changes the recognition is bound to be withdrawn. This paper does not rewrite that passage, and records only two things more. One is the stretch toward Wu Qing, entered pair by pair: each of the three has a stretch of effect on her. The other is the shape this arrangement takes here: it is not outside the team but inside it; the one treated as a means sits at the same table. Relation Theory, reading calls to isolate someone, has written: toward the one isolated, it is directed at his path to third parties and carries the direction of colonization; toward those who are called on not to deal with him, a separate entry is made.56

"Each Has a Share," Carried to Several People

Doing things together, as Action Theory speaks of it, has the shape of two people: A and B, doing C together. When several people do one thing together, this shape is carried to several people and read in the same way: each person has his own purpose, each has a share of his own, and neither the purpose nor the adjudication of this undertaking is held by any one person alone.57 Nor does "each has a share" mean that every share is the same size, or that each person alone could do the whole thing; Action Theory writes clearly that the words "both are able to do" in D47 "mean that each side has a share it can do itself, and only when these are put together can the thing be done".58 In the team of five, Wu Qing's share lies in the part she fixed on Sunday, Pang Licheng's in the scheduling, Wei Zhou's in the testing; only when these were put together could the platform go live.

When several people do one thing together, there is often someone who coordinates. Pang Licheng is the person in charge of this team; that Dutch village too had two people who did the coordinating. Action Theory reads that village: one coordinator was arrested and executed, and the village went on hiding people until the liberation; "A coordinator was taken away and the work remained, because there had never been a center making decisions for everyone".59 The one who coordinates sees to scheduling, to division of labor, to dealing with the outside; that is his share, and within a construct it is also a position; it does not make him a center that legislates for everyone.

Formal Organizations

Formal organizations and their staffing structures belong to the institutional side. A company's departments and posts, a team's staffing: this paper registers them only as conditions of the effects. Within a construct, registered partners and persons in charge are in positions, and what is said to them is accountability; the Political Economy Prequel writes: "Directors, trustees, partners and reviewers are in positions, and accountability is said to them."60 If one day Xia Chi and Kuang Ming register the class as a company, the company is the address of attribution, not a third bearer; the side between the two that the institution does not provide for, or that goes beyond its provisions, is still within this series.

Whether a team or a project can, under other conditions, come to stand separately as a bearer, with a law of its own as a person has, this series does not judge, and registers it as a remainder. What is not judged is this question. The "for the team" this paper reads does not depend on how that question is answered: doing things together does not yield one; and in this paper's examples, what is said in the name of the team is traced back to the person who said it and the position he is in.

§6 Interfacing with Tradition

Several have asked, one after another, about the things this paper reads. For each, this paper writes faithfully what he sees and why he looks; where the original quoted really does conflict with this paper at some point, it writes that point at the original's strength, and then where they meet and where they part; where there is no real conflict, it writes only where they shed light on each other and how the questions are divided, and does not manufacture for the original a counter-thesis it does not contain. The level of comparison is stated for each. Gilbert's plural subject Relation Theory has already conversed with; it is pointed back to here, and only the layer of cooperation is taken up.61

The general will (Rousseau). In The Social Contract Rousseau first states the problem he means to solve: to find a form of union that uses the whole common strength to defend and protect each member's person and property, and in which each, though united with all, still obeys no one but himself, and stays as free as he was.62 The solution he gives is a compact: each places his person and the whole of his strength under the supreme direction of the general will, and the members, as one body, take in each member as an indivisible part of the whole; this union brings into being a moral, collective body.63 In the next chapter he says that, so that the compact may not be empty words, it implicitly contains an undertaking: whoever refuses to obey the general will is to be made to obey by the whole body; which says no more than that he will be compelled to be free.64 He looks in order to answer by what right a body politic binds each of its members. What he sees: union can be real, and once united, people really do act as "we"; union also has to protect each person, so that no one loses himself in it.

The level of comparison has to be stated first. What he reads is the body politic, which in this framework is an object on the institutional side, a matter between a construct and its members; what this paper reads is the "we" said between persons in a small team. The two are not directly the same, and are compared only as neighbors.65 The two chapters quoted speak of how a body politic is constituted and by what it binds its members; they say nothing of how a small team is; the conditions of constitution of a body politic lie outside this paper's scope, and this paper does not borrow them to set up a counter-thesis for a small team either. So only where they shed light on each other and how the questions are divided are written here. They shed light on each other in this: the problem he means to solve is each person's still obeying only himself after the union; this paper's saying that "we" does not come before and does not stand above each person asks after the same point. The questions are divided in this: whether a body politic can have a general will, how the general will binds its members, whether one who refuses to obey and is compelled by the whole body to obey is being compelled to be free, he answers at the level of the body politic, which belongs to the institutional side and which this paper does not judge; what this paper answers is the side between persons in a small team: "we" produces no position that legislates for people, and the binding force of what is done together passes through each one's own law, or comes from a procedure each has recognized (§1).

Collective intentionality (Searle). Searle asks what kind of intention the "we intend to do" is when several people do one thing together. As the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy reports him, he holds that collective intentions cannot be reduced to individual intentions plus beliefs about one another; at the same time, all intentionality is in the heads of individuals: when two people go somewhere together, each has in his head a thought with "we" as its subject.66 He looks in order to explain how social reality grows out of individual minds. What he sees: "we intend to do" is not the same as "I intend to do" plus "I know you intend to do it too"; and this "we" is not anywhere outside the individuals either. The level of comparison differs: what he asks after is the structure of intention in the mind; this paper does not read minds, and reads only words and deeds and the structure they leave. At this level he presses on this paper at one point: if intentions with "we" as their subject are primitive, then the two branches spoken of in §1 seem to be only how things look from outside, with an irreducible "we" inside. They meet in this: he places "we" in each person's head, not above several people; this is on the same side as this paper's saying that neither branch comes before or stands above each person. They part in this: whether "we" is primitive in each person's head, this paper does not judge; it says only that, whatever is in the head, a "we" does not obtain a position that legislates for either party (§1).

The plural subject (Gilbert). Gilbert says that when several people commit together, they form a joint commitment; the "we" constituted by a joint commitment she calls a plural subject. Relation Theory has already conversed with her: it first tells apart the plural subject and the third first person raised above the two laws who passes final judgment on each party's own law on their behalf, not judging by the name alone; the two views collide over where the binding comes from, over duty and over rescission.67 This paper takes up the layer of cooperation, and answers at one point. For her, those who take part in a joint commitment owe one another a duty to act as it requires, and have the qualification to demand it of one who does not; when someone on a team does not come in, the others' demanding it of him in the team's name seems to have a source. This series follows Relation Theory: commitment does not turn into a duty to the other party;68 a demand the other party voices is material, not a qualification. So "For the team, you have to come," in this paper, does not get its binding force from a joint commitment; if it has binding force, this comes from the share that person himself has avowed, or from a procedure he has recognized and the provisions of a position.

Sociable, but not partisan (the Analects). Confucius said: "君子矜而不争,群而不党。" ("The superior man is dignified, but does not wrangle. He is sociable, but not a partizan.")69 He looks in order to say how the superior man is with others. What he sees: being with others and forming a private faction that draws its boundary by inside and outside are two things. Where this sentence is not at the same layer as this paper is its evaluation: it says how the superior man is to be, and that is a sentence this series does not issue; this paper does not take up that layer. They meet in structure: qun (群), several people together, can do one thing together; dang (党), several people forming a circle, draws inside and outside by the circle. The little circle that §5 reads as not forming a third bearer, and the arrangement that takes outsiders as means, fall at exactly the point that needs to be told apart from dang. They part in this: this paper does not judge who is a superior man, nor does it say that people who do things together are not to have some who are closer to them than others; it reads only what an arrangement is premised on, and what a "we" borrows.

§7 Drawing Together and Downstream

This paper has set out five propositions. Taken together, they say: when "we" is said in cooperation, which branch it is, doing things together or mutual recognition, is checked first, case by case, and is not assigned in advance by the kind of relation; neither branch comes before or stands above each person, and doing things together does not automatically produce a position that legislates for both; the ordinary plural holds as usual. Judging one party's law for him in the name of the team, the project or the company, using the name of "we" or of a construct to take in and replace one party's direction, has the same form as borrowing "the household" in marriage, and carries the direction of colonization; that the one who takes the lead puts forward a request is not, in itself, of this kind; nor does the use of the team's or the company's name certify an arrangement put forward within authority as checked as being of this kind, and how the authority itself and its exercise are assessed belongs to the institutional side; whether something is of this kind is checked first against the existing authority and commitments; a company is the address of attribution, not the subject of the act, nor a third bearer, and what is said in its name is traced back to the person who said it and his position. Guarding comes back to the individual: not handing over one's judgment under "we decided together," not possessing others under "I have contributed," not cancelling recognition of concrete people for the sake of a shared ideal. Mutual recognition occurs in cooperation too, and can be real; to use it to pass final judgment on something done together is borrowing mutual recognition as adjudication, and the one who borrows it can be on either side. Several people are read by pairwise accounting; passing through a third person does not release the instigator from his part; a little circle of several people does not form a third bearer; an arrangement that takes outsiders as means is read by Paper 1; formal organizations belong to the institutional side; "each has a share" is carried to several people and read in the same way.

This paper does not prove that a team ought not to have a shared goal, nor that people who do things together ought not to recognize each other.

Questions left open. The online-course platform went live on schedule. That Saturday Wu Qing went to her class; on Sunday she came in and fixed the part she was responsible for. At the wrap-up meeting Pang Licheng said: "This time we pulled it off together." This sentence is speaking of things together. But in the third week after launch the platform had an error, and when they tracked it down, it was a spot missed in testing during the Sunday rush. Whose share was that spot? Someone at a meeting said "We didn't test it properly": was this sentence acknowledging his own share, or acknowledging on others' behalf? That is for Paper 6. At the warehouse, how Xia Chi and Kuang Ming finally decided about those four weekends, the example does not say; what twenty years of friendship and four years of classes have left between the two, how that changes afterward, and whether, once it is done, a "we" is left behind: that is for Paper 7.

Downstream. What this paper has set out, the later papers use as follows. The two branches of "we" and the ordinary plural are used by the later papers as they stand. The three arrangements separated in §2, putting forward a request, the authority that comes with a position, and taking in and replacing under a borrowed name, are checked apart in this way wherever a sentence borrows a name. How "we decided together" is told apart from a procedure already recognized is taken up in Paper 3. "I have contributed," and recording the other's share as one's own, and what one has done oneself not being handed over to "we" or to the company to acknowledge, are taken up in Paper 6. That once something is done no "we" is left behind to legislate for the two is read in Paper 7. The arrangement of a little circle that takes outsiders as means goes back to Paper 1. The shared-words check on the three uses of "we," the two uses of "construct," and the pair "bearer" and "address of attribution," together with the remainder of whether a team or a project can come to stand separately as a bearer, is listed together in Paper 0.

Acknowledgments

This paper is signed by Han Qin alone; the author decided every argument and choice and bears sole responsibility for the text. In drafting, the author used AI models from various developers as tools.

Notes

  1. Relation Theory H8: cultivation and colonization are two directions, cultivation going toward making space and colonization toward pouring in and occupying; the direction is read on this one effect, and whether it took hold is seen in the other party's later understanding and action. ↩︎
  2. Relation Theory Paper 1, under H3: "Whenever Relation Theory says 'we,' it must state which branch it means." ↩︎
  3. Relation Theory H3: "A relation is a construct: the construct left when the effect of one side enters the conditions of occurrence of the other side; it does not legislate, bears nothing, and does not pass final judgment on either party's own law on their behalf". ↩︎
  4. Political Economy Prequel, Introduction, under "How to read": "A construct is an arrangement with institutional status: a company, a foundation and a level of government are all constructs; it is the address of attribution, not the subject of the act". ↩︎
  5. Relation Theory H2: "The other side of a relation must be a bearer; between a subject and a stone there is no relation". ↩︎
  6. Political Economy Prequel, §6: "A construct does not hold a recognition-based right in its own name; the power-face shown by the terms, permits or positions a construct holds is borrowed from the right held by those who invoke it, and the construct is the address of attribution (On Accountability F42)". To say that a construct is the address of attribution and not a third bearer is to read this sentence together with Relation Theory H3 and H12; this step is this series' own undertaking. ↩︎
  7. Relation Theory Paper 1, under H3. ↩︎
  8. Action Theory Paper 8, D47. ↩︎
  9. Value Theory P6 V77; quoted in Relation Theory Paper 1, under H3. The original proposition is restricted to "two bearers each able to run outward recognition at the fifteenth row," and its Chinese heading adds "in that relational domain"; this stipulation in the example serves only to show structure, and does not certify at which layer the two are. ↩︎
  10. Relation Theory Paper 1, under H3: "What both branches give is only the minimal bound past which 'we' does not stand in for anyone; neither is a sufficient theory of any kind of relation"; "which branch is actually in play is checked case by case, and is not assigned in advance by the kind of relation". ↩︎
  11. Action Theory Paper 8, D48. ↩︎
  12. Conflict Treatise §24; quoted in Relation Theory Paper 1, under H3. The original place is the rule two people living together made after sorting household matters into three kinds; carried to a class two people run together, it has the same form. ↩︎
  13. Value Theory P5 V71. Action Theory Paper 8, §5, cites the same place, and cites Value Theory P6 V76 as well. ↩︎
  14. Action Theory Paper 8, §5, after Arnold Douwes's retrospect as recorded in Moral Law P8 §3.3.6. The original place reads the village of Nieuwlande, in the section on doing things together. ↩︎
  15. Action Theory Paper 8, D45. ↩︎
  16. Relation Theory H33: "The other party's response is material, not a settling of the account". The original proposition speaks of response in dealings; carried to the response to a request, it has the same form. ↩︎
  17. Relation Theory H11: within an institution, "the part of what passes between persons that the institution does not provide for, or that goes beyond its provisions, is within range," and the provisions themselves are acknowledged but not judged; Relation Theory H52: "the authority that comes with a position is acknowledged but not judged". ↩︎
  18. Conflict Treatise §21. The original place speaks of the kind on the unilateral path that changes the situation, which does not acquire authority to arrange the other's life unilaterally; the authorities that exist besides, of role, of law and of procedure, each settle within its own domain. ↩︎
  19. Marriage Theory Paper 2, MA15, the subsection "Taking In and Replacing in the Name of 'This Household' or 'For Our Sake'". ↩︎
  20. Relation Theory H8. ↩︎
  21. For the same form, see Marriage Theory Paper 2, MA15, the subsection "Which Branch Is Borrowed Is Checked Each Time": there, if what "for the sake of this household" borrows is a rule the other party never avowed, it borrows a joint decision that does not exist, and avows it on her behalf. ↩︎
  22. Relation Theory H3. That the project is the name of something done together, and that by H3 it does not legislate and bears nothing, is an extension, this series' own undertaking. ↩︎
  23. Action Theory Paper 9, D55: "Guarding has two faces: colonization from outside, and treating people as means again from inside, in the name of efficiency, solidarity, development or security". ↩︎
  24. Action Theory Paper 9, §6: "The way of treating people as means does not always come from outside; it can also grow out of the guarding side itself, under changing names: efficiency, solidarity, development, security." ↩︎
  25. Political Economy Prequel, Introduction, under "How to read". ↩︎
  26. Power Theory P3 §V.5 (also quoted in What Cooperation Is Not, the Prequel to the Theory of Inter-State Cooperation, §4). ↩︎
  27. Political Economy Prequel, §6, citing Institution Theory Z6. ↩︎
  28. Relation Theory H12: "a little circle of two does not form a third bearer"; Political Economy Prequel, Introduction. To read the company as the address of attribution, and not as a third bearer, is to read the two places together; this is this series' own undertaking. ↩︎
  29. Action Theory Paper 8, D49: "What a person has done himself cannot be acknowledged by someone else in his place". ↩︎
  30. Marriage Theory Paper 2, MA15. ↩︎
  31. Action Theory Paper 8, D48. ↩︎
  32. The Prequel to the Theory of Inter-State Cooperation, §4: "what is made in the system's name is traced back to the positions and votes of the member states that made it (own undertaking)". The original place is at the layer of construct and construct; carrying it into a team serves only as a reference of the same form, and is an extension, this series' own undertaking. ↩︎
  33. Action Theory Paper 9, D56. ↩︎
  34. Action Theory Paper 9, §8; the original place points back to Action Theory Paper 1, D6. ↩︎
  35. Paper 3, CO16: a procedure both have recognized beforehand is handing this one matter over, not a position that legislates for the two; the judgment made by a procedure already recognized and applicable governs how this one matter is ordered. ↩︎
  36. Action Theory Paper 9, D52; in §8 the same paper points back to Action Theory Paper 6, D36: one who has provided the conditions does not thereby become the one who completed that step for the other. The original proposition speaks of phase transition and of cultivating a newcomer; carrying it to bringing people along in a team is an extension, this series' own undertaking. ↩︎
  37. Paper 2, CO11; Paper 6, CO31. ↩︎
  38. Action Theory Paper 9, §8. ↩︎
  39. Action Theory Paper 9, D50: "A shared phase transition is a direction that can be faced together, not a higher end entitled to requisition a person". The original place speaks of macroscopic phase transition; carrying it to the ideal of one project is an extension, this series' own undertaking. ↩︎
  40. Action Theory Paper 9, §7. ↩︎
  41. Action Theory Paper 8, D46. ↩︎
  42. Relation Theory H33. ↩︎
  43. Relation Theory Paper 1, under H3. ↩︎
  44. Value Theory P6 V77. ↩︎
  45. Relation Theory Paper 1, under H3: "Mutual recognition generates no third bearer; the binding force of doing things together still passes separately through each party's own law". Conflict Treatise §24. ↩︎
  46. Love Theory L46. ↩︎
  47. Relation Theory H23: commitment binds a person "on the other party's side, on the effects already left"; H24: the effects left are the arrangements, reliance and expectations the other party makes on the strength of the commitment. Carrying this to what the two have done toward each other over twenty years, taking only the layer at which the effects left enter later judgment, is an extension, this series' own undertaking. ↩︎
  48. Relation Theory Paper 0, §7, at the place where it reads Darwall: the other party's saying an expectation out loud, the questioning, enters my conditions of occurrence as material, not as a qualification (Relation Theory Paper 4, H33). ↩︎
  49. Relation Theory H8. ↩︎
  50. Relation Theory H12. ↩︎
  51. Relation Theory H11, H52. ↩︎
  52. Relation Theory, under H12. The original example uses A, B and C. ↩︎
  53. Relation Theory H12. ↩︎
  54. The original sentence speaks of a little circle of two; carrying it to several people is an extension, this series' own undertaking. Relation Theory, under H12: doing things together "does not produce a position that legislates for both, still less a position that bears for both". ↩︎
  55. Paper 1, CO5, and the place where it reads collusion. What Paper 1 reads is an arrangement two people maintain jointly; carrying it to several people is an extension, this series' own undertaking. What Relation Theory Paper 4, under H40 ("The false glance"), reads from the same dependency condition is only that that moment does not count as the moment of two-way 15DD; to read that in this undertaking no end is headed in the 15DD direction goes one step further, on the ground of the premise of that arrangement, and this step is this series' own undertaking (Paper 1). Power Theory P3 §VII.2 has written, at the layer of apparatus and apparatus: apparatuses registering one another forward and superposing their gradient fields is, "in a severing context, collusion"; that is the layer of constructs, and serves only as a reference of the same form. ↩︎
  56. Relation Theory, under H12: "Calling on others to isolate someone is broken down the same way: toward the one isolated, it is aimed at his path to third parties and carries the direction of colonization; toward those who are told not to deal with him, a separate entry is made". ↩︎
  57. Action Theory Paper 8, D47, writes the shape of two people; carrying it to several people is an extension, this series' own undertaking. Action Theory Paper 8, §5, reads the three men at My Lai and the many households of Nieuwlande, which are examples of several people ready to hand upstream. ↩︎
  58. Action Theory Paper 8, §5, the explanation before D47. ↩︎
  59. Action Theory Paper 8, §5, after Moral Law P8 §3.3.6 and Moral Law P9 §5.5. ↩︎
  60. Political Economy Prequel, §6. ↩︎
  61. Relation Theory Paper 0, §7. ↩︎
  62. The Social Contract, Book I, Chapter 6. English translation by G. D. H. Cole (Everyman's Library), checked word for word against the text recorded by Project Gutenberg; the English translation given on marxists.org (the page names no translator) reads the same: "The problem is to find a form of association which will defend and protect with the whole common force the person and goods of each associate, and in which each, while uniting himself with all, may still obey himself alone, and remain as free as before." ↩︎
  63. Same: "Each of us puts his person and all his power in common under the supreme direction of the general will, and, in our corporate capacity, we receive each member as an indivisible part of the whole."; "this act of association creates a moral and collective body". ↩︎
  64. Same, Book I, Chapter 7: "In order then that the social compact may not be an empty formula, it tacitly includes the undertaking, which alone can give force to the rest, that whoever refuses to obey the general will shall be compelled to do so by the whole body. This means nothing less than that he will be forced to be free". ↩︎
  65. The institutional side speaks to constructs; the relational side reads only the collisions between persons. The comparison here takes only the structure of "we," and does not carry the reading of a body politic into a team, nor the other way round. ↩︎
  66. As reported in SEP, "Collective Intentionality" (Schweikard and Schmid), §3.2, which cites Searle 1990, "Collective Intentions and Actions," and Searle 2010, Making the Social World; the entry also records critics' saying that his explanation leans to the solipsistic side. The originals have not been checked. ↩︎
  67. Relation Theory Paper 0, §7. ↩︎
  68. Relation Theory H27: "Commitment does not turn into a duty to the other party". ↩︎
  69. Analects, "Wei Ling Gong" (Chapter XXI in Legge). Legge's translation: "The superior man is dignified, but does not wrangle. He is sociable, but not a partizan." (from Legge, The Chinese Classics, Vol. 1, as recorded by Project Gutenberg #4094; the Chinese original is from the same edition, its characters converted to simplified form; the text given on yellowbridge.com reads the same) ↩︎

References

All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version. Quotations are checked item by item in the accompanying audit table.

I · SAE works directly cited in this paper

Qin, H. (2026). On the Recognition of Power · Shi (SAE Power Theory, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20480134

Qin, H. (2026). On the Conflict of Value (SAE Value Theory, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22122819

Qin, H. (2026). On Value and the Other (SAE Value Theory, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22191071

Qin, H. (2026). SAE Conflict Treatise: How Subjecthood Is Not Swallowed by Conflict Itself [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22313628

Qin, H. (2026). On Accountability · Wei (SAE Rights Theory, Specialist Paper) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22853810

Qin, H. (2026). Finding One Another (SAE Action Theory, Paper 8) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22970783

Qin, H. (2026). One's Own Share of Strength, and Guarding (SAE Action Theory, Paper 9) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22970787

Qin, H. (2026). SAE Relation Theory Paper 0: The Place of Relation Theory [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545115

Qin, H. (2026). SAE Relation Theory Paper 1: What a Relation Is, and What It Is Not [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545047

Qin, H. (2026). SAE Relation Theory Paper 3: Commitment [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545023

Qin, H. (2026). SAE Relation Theory Paper 4: Dealings and Expectation [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545057

Qin, H. (2026). SAE Relation Theory Paper 6: Asymmetry, Divergence and Ending [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545087

Qin, H. (2026). SAE Love Theory Paper 6: That Moment [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23627781

Qin, H. (2026). SAE Theory of Inter-State Cooperation · Prequel: What Cooperation Is Not [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23815735

Qin, H. (2026). SAE Marriage Theory Paper 2: Each Their Own [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23819224

Qin, H. (2026). What an Economy Is Not (SAE Political Economy, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874133

II · External works

Rousseau, J.-J. (1762). Du contrat social, I.6–7. English: The Social Contract, trans. G. D. H. Cole, in The Social Contract & Discourses. London: J. M. Dent; New York: E. P. Dutton (Everyman's Library). (checked against the Cole translation as recorded by Project Gutenberg; the English translation given on marxists.org reads the same; the edition used prints no year of publication; the printed page numbers and the French original have not been checked)

Searle, J. R. (1990). Collective Intentions and Actions. In P. R. Cohen, J. Morgan & M. E. Pollack (Eds.), Intentions in Communication. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. (as reported in SEP, "Collective Intentionality," §3.2; the original has not been checked)

Searle, J. R. (2010). Making the Social World: The Structure of Human Civilization. New York: Oxford University Press. (as reported in SEP, "Collective Intentionality," §3.2; the original has not been checked)

Schweikard, D. P., & Schmid, H. B. (2013; substantive revision 9 December 2020). Collective Intentionality. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, §3.2 "Mode".

Lunyu (the Analects), "Wei Ling Gong." English: The Analects, in James Legge, The Chinese Classics, Vol. 1. Project Gutenberg #4094. (the text given on yellowbridge.com reads the same)

Interfaces

  • Main upstream: Action Theory Paper 8 (D45, D46, D47, D48, D49; §5), Paper 9 (D50, D52, D55, D56; §6 to §8); Relation Theory Paper 1 (H2, H3, H11, H12; the two branches of "we," under H3); Value Theory P5 (V71), P6 (V77); Marriage Theory Paper 2 (MA15).
  • Also used: the Conflict Treatise (§21, §24); Relation Theory H8, H23, H24, H27, H33, H40, H52, and Relation Theory Paper 0, §7; Love Theory L46; the Political Economy Prequel (the Introduction, "How to read"; §6, with Institution Theory Z6 and On Accountability F42 as cited there); Power Theory P3 (§V.5, §VII.2); the Prequel to the Theory of Inter-State Cooperation (§4); Moral Law P8 §3.3.6, P9 §5.5 (by way of Action Theory Paper 8, §5).
  • This series: continues from Paper 1 (scope; the place where it reads collusion), Paper 2 (CO11), Paper 3 (CO16, a procedure already recognized); Paper 6 takes up what one has done oneself not being handed over to "we" or to the company to acknowledge, and "I have contributed"; Paper 7 takes up that once something is done no "we" is left behind; Paper 0 lists together the three uses of "we," the two uses of "construct," the pair "bearer" and "address of attribution," and the remainder of whether a team or a project can come to stand separately as a bearer.