Division of Labor
分工
This paper reads division of labor in cooperation. In the cooperation this series reads, division of labor is an arrangement the two have avowed together; it is consensus, not calculation: neither law has changed; what has changed is time, resources, roles, procedure and the conditions of action. The binding force of division of labor passes separately through each party's own law, or comes from a procedure both parties have already recognized; it is not a third law standing above the two. Division of labor is a present arrangement; it can be avowed anew, and it can be changed. A change into a new shared division of labor must be avowed by both parties separately, or be made by a procedure both have recognized and that applies; this does not make either party the approver of the other's own revision and exit. Unilateral withdrawal does not impose a new arrangement on the other party, nor does it erase the effects already left.
Where division of labor slides into a fixed requirement aimed at the other, by being treated as something the other may not change, by being hung on who the other is, or by being swapped out within habit, there is a tendency toward colonization: saying out loud a characterization of the division of labor slides in the direction of colonization; making it unchangeable for the other in running carries the direction of colonization. One party's own treating the division of labor as unchangeable is his self-relation; structurally it has no outward direction. This point has the same form as Marriage Theory's reading of division of labor in marriage; the two series are parallel, and each reads by this shape.
Organizations, contracts, employment, and the authority that comes with positions are acknowledged but not judged, and are registered as conditions of effects; this paper reads only the side the institution does not provide for, or that goes beyond its provisions: what passes between persons. A registered partner is in a position, and belongs to the institutional side; the construct two people register is the address of attribution, not a third bearer. The non-compete agreement, which stipulates that one party may not, after leaving, go in a certain direction, is read as Political Economy reads it; the other party to the cooperation is himself the party that sets the agreement. A procedure both have recognized beforehand is handing this one matter over, not a position that legislates for the two; whether a procedure has grounds, and whether, in running, it is still controlled by the party questioned, are checked apart. This paper interfaces with Plato, Durkheim and Smith. It does not prove which division of labor is right, does not prescribe for anyone how division of labor is to be divided, and does not judge whether the obligations in a contract are legitimate.
Introduction
Wei An and Jing He were at university together; after graduating each was busy with his own affairs, and through those ten years they remained friends. In the year they turned thirty-three, the two went in together on a secondhand bookshop on an old street. On the night before it opened, sitting in the empty shop, they agreed on how things would go: Jing He knew books, so buying in stock, pricing, shelving and dealing with the people who came to sell books would be his, and the stock went to him; Wei An had worked some years as an accountant, so keeping the accounts, paying the rent, filing the taxes and dealing with the bank would be his, and the accounts went to him. The two put in the same amount of money.
For the first two years the shop was something the two had gone into together, without registering it. In the third year, so as to be able to issue invoices, they registered it as a limited company, each holding half. The articles of association set down that each held half, and who represents the company externally; who keeps the accounts and who looks after the stock, the articles did not set down. Whether the shop had any other written agreement, the facts this paper relies on do not record; it is recorded as not checked.
In the sixth year, Wei An signed up for a course in book repair at a night school, two evenings a week; he wanted to learn to mend, himself, the damaged books they bought in. He talked it over with Jing He: could half of the accounts be handed off, by hiring a bookkeeper, or by the two of them taking turns? That day Jing He was put out because someone had beaten him down on the price of a batch of books, and he said: "The accounts were your job to begin with."
That evening the two said no more about it. The remark can be only a reminder of the arrangement agreed on that night six years before: the accounts went to you back then; if you want to change that now, we have to talk it over again. It can also be something else: the accounts are Wei An's not because it was agreed that night, but because he is Wei An, someone who studied accounting, who can sit still; this person simply is the one who keeps the accounts. Which it is depends on how the arrangement falls from here on; from this one remark alone, it cannot be told. This is what this paper asks: how a division of labor two people have agreed on binds the two, and how it does not; how it can be changed, and how it slides into a requirement that may not be changed.
What this paper reads. Paper 1 has read that the cooperation this series reads has as its premise that at least one party is headed in the 15DD direction: two people, each for his own purpose, do together one thing that both avow and in which each has a share; neither party holds the purpose and adjudication of this undertaking alone.1 "Each has a share," once carried into daily life, is often just division of labor: who does what, when, and how the work passes from one to the other. This paper reads five things. First, what division of labor is: at which layer it lies, and by what it binds people. Second, how division of labor is changed. Third, how division of labor slides into a fixed requirement aimed at the other. Fourth, how what institutions give, such as organizations, contracts and positions, is read when it enters what lies between the two. Fifth, a procedure the two have recognized beforehand: when a matter is handed to it to decide, what is handed over, and when it has in fact not been handed over.
On each of these, the direction of colonization can be read: division of labor hung on who the other is; making it unchangeable for the other in running; a "procedure" controlled by the party questioned and yet called a third party. Colonization, in this series, names the direction of one effect: toward pouring in and occupying; the other direction is cultivation, toward making space. The two are not the two extremes of one scale; the same act can carry both directions, and can also carry no direction at all; the direction is read on this one effect, and whether it took hold is seen in the other party's later understanding and action.2 "A tendency toward colonization" and "slides in the direction of colonization" both speak of direction, and are not read as its having taken hold.
Shared words. "Law" and "arrangement" are used apart. A person's own law is the layer that he bears in the first person and by which he goes on organizing his action; an arrangement is how time, resources, roles, procedure and the conditions of action are laid out.3 Division of labor lies at the layer of arrangement.
"Procedure" in this paper means specifically the method the two have recognized beforehand, to which a certain class of matters is handed to decide, and an external mechanism that has lawful authority, or legitimate authority for the protection of basic rights.4 What is called a "workflow" in everyday speech, such as the day of each month on which the shop reconciles its accounts, is part of division of labor, and is not within this sense.
"Accountability" is taken as in How Is Institution Possible (Foundational Paper 6; cited as F6): the contentful requirement that falls on a member's position when a construct exercises power over that member; it binds the position, not the subject itself.5 When this paper says that a person is "in a position," it is in this sense. At the layer between persons, commitment does not turn into a duty to the other party;6 the two are not mixed.
Going in together covers two things. In everyday speech, two friends going in together on a shop means their doing this thing together; once the shop is registered, there are a "registered partner," a "shareholder," "the one who represents the company externally": positions an institution gives. Where this paper means the latter, it says so.
Method. As in Paper 1: the conclusions of upstream papers are said in plain words; sources, the proposition numbers of other papers, and the places where upstream words are carried beyond their original place all go in the notes, and where something is extended, this series takes it on as its own undertaking. What has already been said at the relational layer is used here directly, not rewritten. This paper speaks only of structure, not of good and bad, and issues no ought: it does not say which division of labor is right, nor does it decide for the two how the work is to be divided.
The two friends Wei An and Jing He run through the whole paper. This is a made-up example, used only to see structure. The two are friends; the face of mutual recognition in their friendship is read as Relation Theory reads it; this paper reads only the one thing they do together, running the shop.7 Whether the two are within this series' scope in this undertaking is read as in Paper 1; from outside, only words, deeds and arrangements can be seen, and they do not certify who is at which layer. The person in the Conflict Treatise who has a long disagreement with someone above him is borrowed in this paper as well, to read division of labor and procedure at work.
§1 Division of Labor Is Consensus
CO12 Division of labor in cooperation is an arrangement the two have avowed together; it is consensus, not calculation; its binding force passes separately through each party's own law, or comes from a procedure both parties have already recognized
The Layer of Arrangement
The Conflict Treatise has read two people who live together. The two had been stuck for a long time over household matters; later they stopped arguing about whether things should be discussed first, and sorted household matters into three kinds: some each finishes first and mentions afterwards, some are mentioned before doing, some are decided only by the two together. After the sorting, that thing no longer happened every day. The Conflict Treatise states exactly what happened there: "Neither law changed at all"; what changed was time, resources, roles, procedure and the conditions of action; "the arrangement itself neither generates a third law of one's own nor, on its own strength, rewrites either party's law."8
What Wei An and Jing He agreed on the night before the opening lies at this layer too. The stock to Jing He, the accounts to Wei An: this is an arrangement both have avowed; what it lays out is who does what, when, and in whose hands things are kept; it does not touch either one's own law. Jing He may have opened this shop so that good books would not be sold off as waste paper; Wei An may have opened it so as to have a place where his own word counts, and no longer keep accounts for others. Two concerns came to rest on the same shop, and what each of the two cared about did not thereby merge into one.9 Whether this is what they had in mind, this paper does not say for them; what can be seen is that what was agreed that night was how to divide the doing, not that from then on the two cared about the same thing.
This layer has to be set up on its own, because without it a division of labor is often misread: read as one party's having changed his own law, as the two people's having acquired a shared law, or as one party's having legislated for the other. The Conflict Treatise says that such misreadings arise because there is no position that can hold "neither law changed and the problem is solved."10 Division of labor stands in just such a position.
Consensus, Not Calculation
What was agreed that night is a consensus. The Conflict Treatise separates two histories of consensus: in one, neither law changes, and the two jointly form an arrangement under which what each requires can be met together; in the other, one or both of them revise themselves, and what they require comes to fit.11 The division of labor agreed on that night, read as above, is the first kind.
Where consensus rests, the Conflict Treatise has also written exactly: "What constitutes consensus is the first-person acknowledgment each party completes, or an action arrangement jointly formed and separately acknowledged"; persuasion can give reasons, and can bring one party to change, but the persuader's success does not itself constitute consensus.12 So whether that night's division of labor is a consensus does not turn on who talked whom round, but on whether each of the two avowed it. Jing He said "The stock's mine," Wei An said "Then the accounts are mine": each avowed his own share, and each also avowed this whole way of dividing things. Neither side can declare agreement in the other's place.13
Calculation has a special sense here: treating the other only as a strategy set, so that how he will move next is derived by me from my own payoffs.14 Division of labor is an arrangement; calculation is a stance; the two are not in the same place (Paper 2). Where both parties treat each other only as a strategy set, they too can each avow a very finely divided share of work, each doing one stretch. Some call this kind cooperation as well; this series does not define all cooperation, and says only that it is not within the cooperation this series reads, as Paper 1 has read; that it is not within rests on the premise of scope, not on their not having avowed.15 In the cooperation this series reads, division of labor is consensus, and also does not lie on the side of calculation: the two avow it together, at least one end is headed in the 15DD direction, and the other end, in this undertaking, is not reduced to calculation either (Paper 1).
From outside, whether a division of labor is a consensus or a balance within calculation cannot always be told apart: both can be divided just as finely and carried out just as precisely. Paper 1 has given three structural clues: whether not holding alone is having recognized that the other's share is the other's, or only that neither can hold it alone; whether the other's share is still borne by him himself; whether the existing arrangement makes room for his refusal and revision.16 In division of labor, the third is the most visible. If a division of labor can accommodate the other's saying "I don't want to do this share any more" or "I want to do this share another way," and, once this has been said, there is a way for it to reach the step at which the two arrange things anew, then this division of labor makes room for his refusal and revision. What has to be checked is whether this can really be said, and whether, once said, it is forced back down; not whether this division of labor is kept going after any change whatever: the other party can disagree with the new way of dividing things; when the two no longer agree on one way of dividing things, they can also stop doing this thing together; stopping does not by itself show that the arrangement before or after carries the direction of colonization. What the clues tell apart is whether or not one is reduced to calculation; whether at least one party is headed in the 15DD direction only that end itself can confirm; the clues do not certify it on its behalf, nor do they prove that that kind is not cooperation.
Where the Binding Force Comes From
A division of labor two people have agreed on can go on being used. After consensus, the Conflict Treatise adds a qualification: "that rule's binding force must pass separately through each party's own law, or come from a procedure both have acknowledged. It is not a third law above the two."17
The binding force of division of labor comes this way too. For six years Jing He went every week to the secondhand book market to buy stock, and that binding passed through his own law: he had avowed this. Wei An balanced the accounts every month, and that passed through his own. There is no third law called "division of labor" standing above the two and requiring them to comply; nor is there a third party called "this shop" that avows each one's share on behalf of the two. The Second Critique puts this boundary, at the level of the individual, in one sentence: "What two people agree on is a shared procedure, a thing done together, not a shared law; no third legislating position arises from it".18
The other route is a procedure: the two recognize a method beforehand, and hand a certain class of matters to it to decide. That binding comes from both having recognized this method beforehand; §5 reads it.
Neither route is the other's will landing directly on me. If Jing He were to say "I want you to keep the accounts, so you have to," he would have replaced the route of the binding with his own will; "The accounts went to you back then, and you took it on" points to the step at which Wei An himself avowed it. This distinction will be needed in §3, where it is read how division of labor slides into a fixed requirement.
Division of Labor and Exchange
Division of labor speaks of who does which stretch within a shared undertaking; exchange speaks of your giving me this and my giving you that. The two can be tangled together, and are read apart. A division of labor can be unequal: one party does more, the other less; one does the heavy work, the other the fine work. Inequality does not make it exchange, nor does it make it a debt. Wei An keeps the accounts not in order to get Jing He's buying stock; Jing He's buying stock is not paying Wei An back. The two are arrangements the two have avowed together, not requirements of each other.19 Where the two have, besides, an arrangement of reciprocal exchange, for instance this month you mind the shop two days for me and next month I do it for you, that is reciprocal exchange, read in Paper 2; where a division of labor carries such an exchange within it, that part is read by Paper 2, and it does not change the division of labor's own lying at the layer of arrangement.
§2 Changing the Division of Labor
CO13 Division of labor is a present arrangement; it can be avowed anew, and it can be changed. A change into a new shared division of labor must be avowed by both parties separately, or be made by a procedure both have recognized and that applies; this does not make either party the approver of the other's own revision and exit. Unilateral withdrawal does not impose a new arrangement on the other party, nor does it erase the effects already left
A Present Arrangement
Reading a person's commitment today to tomorrow, Relation Theory has said: a commitment marked as a present arrangement that tomorrow can avow anew, with revising and exit actually reachable, does not fall into locking.20 Division of labor is such a present arrangement: avowed on the night before the opening, it can be avowed once more six years later, and it can also be changed.
Being able to be avowed anew does not mean being said over again every day. An agreed division of labor, used for years in the two people's daily life, does not require being avowed anew each time; how it sediments in time is read in Paper 7.21 Being able to be avowed anew says that this road is there: whichever party wants to raise the question again, the question can get in.
Avowed by Both, Separately
That day Wei An put forward two options: hiring a bookkeeper, or the two taking turns. Suppose that Jing He, after thinking it over for a few days, says: "Hiring someone is fine. The money comes out of the shop, the bookkeeper does the accounts, and you look them over once a month, and so do I." Wei An says yes. This is a new shared division of labor. It holds because the two have each avowed it, as on that night six years before; and, as on that night, it has not produced a law standing above the two.
A new shared division of labor has one more route: being made by a procedure the two have recognized beforehand and that applies to this matter. Suppose the two had said, at the opening, that major matters of the shop on which the two cannot agree go to Cai Qingsheng, an old book dealer whom both respect, to decide. If the question of whether to change who keeps the accounts falls within the "major matters" the two recognized, it goes to him to decide, and what he decides is the arrangement by which the two order things from then on. This route is read in §5.
Beyond these two routes there is no third. One party's announcing "From next month, the accounts are yours" is not a new shared division of labor: at most it is one party's proposal, or notice that one party is going to withdraw his own side. Neither side can declare agreement in the other's place.22
Not Becoming the Other's Approver
One misreading has to be guarded against here. To say that a new shared division of labor must be avowed by both parties separately is not to say that whenever one party wants to change himself, or to leave, the other's approval is needed. A shared division of labor is the two people's matter, and is for the two to avow; a person's revising his own law, or withdrawing his own side, is his matter alone. Jing He can disagree with hiring a bookkeeper, and then that new division of labor has not come about; but this does not make him the one who approves whether Wei An goes to night school or learns book repair, nor, at the layer between the two, the one who approves Wei An's exiting this undertaking. Exit here means withdrawing his own side, that of going on taking part (Paper 1, CO2); how the half of the shares in his name is transferred and how the company is wound up follow company law and the articles of association, and belong to the institutional side (§4); in this example they have not been checked. Commitment cannot lock tomorrow: that it cannot lock lies in the layer of qualification, and is necessary; where tomorrow is locked in running, what is violated is the exit right, which is a person's basic right.23
Between two people, this point often gets tangled. If Jing He were to say "If you want to go and learn book repair, you need my agreement," what he speaks of is no longer division of labor but a matter of Wei An's own; he has pushed the "both have to avow it" of a shared arrangement onto Wei An's own side. Whether Wei An goes to night school is a matter within his law; how the shop's accounts are laid out once he goes is what is the two people's matter.
Unilateral Withdrawal
Suppose Jing He disagrees, and the two talk it over twice without coming to agreement. Wei An has several roads. He can go on keeping the accounts as before, moving the Tuesday and Thursday evening accounts to other times; this is an arrangement on his own side, which the Conflict Treatise places at the layer of action arrangement, and which does not require the other party's taking part.24 He can also withdraw his own side of keeping the accounts: from some day on, he no longer keeps them. Withdrawing one's own side is exit, and does not carry the direction of colonization, even if the other party's cost rises as a result.25
Withdrawal has its bounds. First, unilateral withdrawal does not impose a new arrangement on the other party: Wei An's withdrawing from keeping the accounts does not mean that the accounts are Jing He's from then on; whether Jing He avows that share is Jing He's affair. Accounts that no one keeps are something the two face together from then on, not a new division of labor Wei An has decided on alone for the two. Second, unilateral withdrawal does not erase the effects already left: six years of accounts were done by Wei An; with the landlord and with the bank, it was he who went in person and came to terms; after he withdraws, these effects remain as before. Commitment binds a person in two places: on my side, it rests on where I stand; on the other party's side, on the effects already left; leaving is entered on the books, and revising keeps the books on the change.26 Wei An's withdrawing is his no longer standing on the share of keeping the accounts; what he has done remains what he has done, read in Paper 6. Third, the shop has been registered as a company; if the position Wei An holds under the articles of association has to do with the accounts, that slot carries its accountability, read by the provisions on that side; what he withdraws is the share between the two, and this does not automatically release the share he holds in the position; exiting that position is another matter.27
§3 Sliding into a Fixed Requirement
CO14 Where division of labor slides into a fixed requirement aimed at the other, by being treated as something the other may not change, by being hung on who the other is, or by being swapped out within habit, there is a tendency toward colonization: saying out loud a characterization of the division of labor slides in the direction of colonization; making it unchangeable for the other in running carries the direction of colonization. One party's own treating the division of labor as unchangeable is his self-relation; structurally it has no outward direction
A Fixed Requirement Aimed at the Other
Division of labor slides. A fixed requirement, as spoken of here, is a requirement aimed at the other: an arrangement the two have avowed, taken up by one party against the other as something the other has no choice but to comply with. Marriage Theory, reading division of labor in marriage, reads three shapes that sliding into such a requirement takes: being treated as something the other may not change, being hung on who the other is, being swapped out within habit.28 The two series are parallel, and at the normative layer this point has the same form; in cooperation it is read by the same shape, and is not derived from Marriage Theory. The three can be tangled together.
Treated as Something the Other May Not Change
First the layers have to be set right. If Wei An himself treats keeping the accounts as something that may not be changed, so that each time he thinks of setting it down he overrules himself with "I've always done them," and no one says anything to him, that is his self-relation. Read as Relation Theory reads a person's today and tomorrow, that is locking; locking speaks of being out of reach, not of something pouring in and occupying, so locking in itself carries no direction of colonization.29 Structurally it has no outward direction either, and is not within this tendency.
What is aimed at the other comes in two kinds, separated as Relation Theory separates what is done to exit.30 If Jing He says "Haven't you done them all these years? And now you just stop, like that?", he is setting what has already been the case against Wei An's avowing anew: it has been this way, so this is the only way it can be. This is saying out loud a characterization of the division of labor, treating this arrangement, on Wei An's behalf, as an irrefutable final ground, and it slides in the direction of colonization. If Jing He, in running, makes the step of Wei An's changing it unreachable, that is the other kind. The two had agreed that the shop's bank account could be drawn on only with both their signatures; Wei An has found a bookkeeper, and every authorization the bookkeeper needs Jing He holds back unsigned, without saying why. Here it must first be made clear on what ground, if any, the hiring of this bookkeeper has already come about. If it is still only Wei An's proposal, and Jing He does not avow it, the new shared division of labor has not come about; his not signing is his not avowing this item, in the same place as the disagreement spoken of in §2, and does not by itself prove that he has taken away the place of Wei An's revision and exit. His not saying why can be material for the two to ask further about; Wei An's own side is still there: he can go on keeping the accounts as before, or he can withdraw (§2). Only if the hiring has already been avowed by the two separately, or decided by a procedure the two have recognized and that applies, and Jing He uses the step of signing to hold down this change, or uses that step to seal off even Wei An's actual channel for withdrawing his own side, is this blocking checked separately by its effect: actually making the step of Wei An's changing it unreachable is sealing his path, and carries the direction of colonization; where the path is sealed until he actually cannot withdraw his own side, what is sealed off is exit itself, and at the layer of basic rights it is judged separately as violation;31 the two lines are both present.
Hung on Who the Other Is
Back to that remark, "The accounts were your job to begin with." Where it differs from what Wei An said on the night before the opening, "Then the accounts are mine," lies in the ground. That night's ground was the conditions of the time: Wei An had worked some years as an accountant, and Jing He knew books. "Your job to begin with" can still have these conditions as its ground; its ground can also have been replaced by who Wei An is: someone who studied accounting, who can sit still; this person simply is the one who keeps the accounts.
Reading expectation, Relation Theory has written this shape: to attach a qualifying condition to an expectation, fixing for the other party what something means to him, for instance by hanging it as a criterion on who he is or what he cares about, is to slide in the direction of colonization.32 Once division of labor is hung on who the other is, changing the division of labor becomes changing who he is: if Wei An does not keep the accounts, it is as if he were no longer quite Wei An, or as if he were letting a friend down. What slides away is exactly the route of binding force spoken of in §1: it no longer passes through the step at which Wei An himself avowed it, and has been replaced by "That's just the kind of person you are."
In cooperation, what it is hung on is often not a status of the kind found in marriage, but expertise, background, temperament, or the friendship between the two: "You studied accounting"; "You're the careful type"; "All these years we've been friends, and you're still keeping score with me over this?" The last remark has a further layer: it borrows the mutual recognition between friends to decide a thing done together, read in Paper 4.33
Swapped Out Within Habit
As Action Theory puts it, "a law is held in place by habit, and is also swapped out within habit";34 maintaining with grounds can be swapped out within habit, and staying on only by conditions can also grow grounds.35 Over the six years Jing He too has learned to read the accounts, and Wei An has come to know a good many books; the conditions on which the work was first divided have changed, yet the one who keeps the accounts is still Wei An, and the one who buys stock is still Jing He. This arrangement may still be one the two avow now, or it may already have been swapped out: its grounds long gone, it has simply always been this way. It is not judged so on the strength of no one's having asked about it again in six years. Habit in itself is not a swap, for a law is held in place by habit to begin with; to read a swap, one has to check separately whether this arrangement has already been treated as a final ground not open to revision. Whether each of the two has avowed it anew, these appearances cannot answer on their behalf.
A Tendency, Not Having Taken Hold
These three all speak of division of labor sliding into a fixed requirement aimed at the other. Where it has slid, there is a tendency toward colonization: it heads toward fixing for one party what he should do and who he is, toward occupying his own step of avowing anew and arranging anew.36 A tendency is not having taken hold. Whether it took hold is seen in that party's later understanding and action: if from then on Wei An feels that not keeping the accounts would mean letting down this shop and letting down Jing He, and never raises it again, that direction has taken hold; if he goes on thinking for himself what keeping the accounts is, for him, and a few days later sits down with Jing He to talk again, that direction has not taken hold of him. What can be seen from outside is the half that is action; the half that is understanding needs him himself.
The kind that is swapped out has one more place to be read apart. At Wei An's own end, the original grounds are gone and he still balances the accounts every month: whether that is his own habit running, or Jing He's "your job to begin with" running, cannot be told apart from outside. The former is his own affair, like his own treating it as unchangeable spoken of above, and is not within this tendency; what had its origin outside and was reconsidered and avowed by him himself does not count as a swap either.37 The latter is a requirement aimed at him that has used his habit to judge in his place, and only that is within this tendency. This place needs the first person.
"The Accounts Were Your Job to Begin With"
Back to that evening in the Introduction. From this one remark alone, it cannot be told which kind it is. By how the arrangement falls from here on, it is read apart:
- Suppose that the remark that evening said just the old arrangement: the accounts went to Wei An back then, and changing that needs the two to talk it over again. What it points to is the step at which Wei An himself avowed it back then; the route of binding force has not been replaced; in this branch, this one effect carries no direction toward Wei An. The next day Jing He says: "I spoke too sharply yesterday. The accounts did go to you back then; if you want to change that, let's think about how." Later the two hire a bookkeeper. This run of words and deeds fits this branch, but does not by itself prove it: that the remark that evening only recalled the old agreement and the talk went on from there is one history; that the remark that evening had already slid in the direction of colonization and was taken back the next day is another. The later repair does not rewrite the effect of that remark that evening; while the material reaches only words and deeds, both histories remain open.
- From then on, each time Jing He hears Wei An bring up a bookkeeper, he says the same thing: "You studied accounting; the accounts were your job to begin with." This remark, said out loud again and again, hangs the division of labor on who Wei An is, and slides in the direction of colonization; whether it took hold is seen in Wei An afterward.
- Jing He has said this, and of the authorizations the bookkeeper needs he signs not one, so the bookkeeper cannot get in. This branch is read by the two branches separated earlier in this section, where sealing the path was read: if the hiring is still only Wei An's proposal, not signing is Jing He's not avowing this item, and the new division of labor has not come about; on this alone, it is not read as sealing the path; if the hiring has already been avowed by the two, or decided by a procedure the two have recognized and that applies, it is only then that his using the step of signing to hold it down makes it unchangeable for Wei An in running, which carries the direction of colonization; whether the path is sealed until Wei An actually cannot withdraw his own side is checked separately.
While the material is only that one remark of that evening, all three readings make sense. This paper leaves it undetermined, and does not fill it in with intentions added afterward.
Division of Labor Given by a Construct
The division of labor in a shop is sometimes not decided wholly by the two. The customs of the trade, the old habits of doing business in a place, the articles of association of the company the two registered: each decides part of it for them in advance: who signs for the company to outside parties, who deals with the tax office and the bank. These are given by constructs; this paper acknowledges them but does not judge them, and does not say which rule is right;38 it reads only the stretch at which they enter what lies between the two, read in the next section.
§4 Organizations, Contracts and Positions
CO15 Organizations, contracts, employment, superiors and subordinates: the provisions, and the authority that comes with positions, are acknowledged but not judged, and are registered as conditions of effects; Cooperation Theory reads only the side the institution does not provide for, or that goes beyond its provisions: what passes between persons. Within a construct, a registered partner is in a position, and belongs to the institutional side; an agreement backed by liquidated damages, injunction or compulsory enforcement that forbids one party, after leaving, to go in a certain direction, that is, a non-compete agreement, is read by Political Economy Paper 2, E12a, and a conditional payment is read differently, also by E12a; the other party to the cooperation is himself the party that sets the agreement, and if what the agreement protects is his own share, it is not among those "set to protect others." The obligations a contract gives belong to the institutional side; at the layer between persons, commitment does not turn into a duty to the other party, and the other party's response is material, not a settling of the account
Acknowledged but Not Judged, Registered as Conditions
F6 takes "institution" in a broad sense: "any stable rule-framework formed for the recurring handling of entangled intersections counts as an institution"; a corporation is an organizational institution, and friendship is a micro-relational institution.39 Retroducing from interstellar civilizations all the way down to two persons, it says of the corporate tier that the relations of employment, capital and users cross one another there and that interest conflicts are densest, so that "Institution is the thickest in the entire chain"; the early-stage startup has the same conditions, is smaller and changes faster, and "five people do not need four-branch separation".40 A small shop two friends go in together on has this layer once it is registered as a company: articles of association, shareholders, the one who represents the company externally, the rules of the tax office and the bank.
This paper acknowledges this layer but does not judge it: the provisions themselves are not judged, the authority that comes with positions is not judged; they are only registered as conditions of effects.41 Whether Wei An can go to the bank alone and change the account, whether Jing He can decide alone to buy a whole warehouse of books, is first a matter of how the provisions are written. This paper reads only the side the institution does not provide for, or that goes beyond its provisions: what passes between persons. The articles set down who represents the company externally, and do not set down who keeps the accounts; that the accounts went to Wei An is an arrangement between the two, and lies within this paper.
At work the division runs the same way. The Conflict Treatise has read a person who has done a job in one place for many years and has a long-unresolved disagreement with someone above him: "the person above reads every disagreement as a problem of attitude".42 A superior's authority to assign work and set workflows comes with the position, and this paper acknowledges it but does not judge it; the Conflict Treatise also states that other authorities of role, of law or of procedure settle separately within their own domains.43 What this paper reads is the side the provisions do not provide for: reading every disagreement as a problem of attitude hangs a disagreement over how a thing is done on who that person is. Examples from work carry one more condition: first a factual record of the relevant provisions, with what is unknown recorded as not checked. The Conflict Treatise does not write what the provisions were in that place, and this paper does not supply them for it.
A Registered Partner Is in a Position
The Political Economy Prequel has a sentence: "The construct takes the ought, the position takes accountability, the person takes his own law." The same section says: "Directors, trustees, partners and reviewers are in positions, and accountability is said to them."44 Once Wei An and Jing He have registered the shop as a company, each is in a position: shareholder, and the slot the articles set down, who represents the company externally. What is spoken of in that slot is accountability; it binds the position, not the subject itself.45 That side belongs to the institutional side, and this paper does not read it.
The construct the two make up is read as Political Economy reads it: "A construct does not hold a recognition-based right in its own name; the power-face shown by the terms, permits or positions a construct holds is borrowed from the right held by those who invoke it, and the construct is the address of attribution"; a construct "is the address of attribution, not the subject of the act".46 This company is the address of attribution: the rent it owes, the invoices it issues, are booked first to it; the positions and persons that did these things each have their own accountability, examined separately.47 It is not a third bearer. Relation Theory has set down that a relation does not legislate and bears nothing, and that a little circle of two does not form a third bearer;48 registering as a company adds an address of attribution, and does not add someone who bears on Wei An's and Jing He's behalf, or who avows each one's share for them. F6 also writes that a construct is not a shell that insulates individuals from bearing.49 This sentence is an extension, this series' own undertaking: what Relation Theory spoke of was a little circle that does not pass through an institution; what Political Economy spoke of was constructs and rights; reading the two sentences together onto the company two friends registered is something this series answers for.
Non-Compete Agreements
In the fifth year of the shop, Jing He once raised the idea: if the two ever part, the one who leaves does not open a secondhand bookshop near this street for three years, and whoever breaks this pays the one who stays a sum of money. The two only talked this over; they did not sign it. Suppose it has been signed, and is backed by liquidated damages, injunction or compulsory enforcement.
Political Economy has already read such an agreement, and calls it a non-compete agreement: an agreement backed by liquidated damages, injunction or compulsory enforcement that forbids a person, after leaving, to go in a certain direction. Its reading is: "So a non-compete agreement is violation, with compensation as without"; its gravity depends on the territory, trade and term it reaches.50 This reading lies at the normative layer; this paper follows it, and does not set up another.
In cooperation there is one more thing to check. A constraint set to protect others is not among non-compete agreements; and the other party to the cooperation is precisely the party that sets the agreement. Political Economy writes of this kind of constraint: "What it protects is a third party's rights or the public's channels for questioning, not the contracting party's own advantage".51 The clause Jing He raised protects the business of the one who stays: it keeps the one who leaves from opening another shop next door and taking the old customers with him. What it protects is the share of the party that sets the agreement, his own, and it is not among those "set to protect others." That the other is a partner does not put him among "others."
Even a constraint truly set to protect others does not obtain this reading by its name. Political Economy requires that it be able to say "which exercise it limits, whom it protects, why nothing less will do, and how wide its scope is"; merely claiming to protect people does not earn this reading; where it limits beyond what protecting others requires, that part is still violation.52
Another arrangement has to be kept apart from non-compete agreements. Suppose the two agree: if the one who leaves does not open a secondhand bookshop near this street for three years, the shop gives him an extra sum; if he opens one nearby, he does not get this sum, and is not penalized either. Political Economy calls this kind a conditional payment: it "forbids nothing, but only ties an additional payment to a choice"; the normative layer "does not judge it a strict violation".53 The criteria of the division are three, each asking whether the person still has this choice: is the backing prohibition and compulsory enforcement, or only no longer paying; is what is tied to "not going" an additional payment, or money he has already earned, deferred to him, or paid out and then clawed back; taken together with other constraints, or under deep dependence, does refusing this payment amount to being unable to live. The three are to be used together: "the three are used together, and that the backing is only no longer paying is not yet enough to recognize that the choice is actually there."54 So on the strength of "it's only that the money isn't paid, there's no penalty" alone, it is not judged which side it falls on.
Appendix C of F6 is a working demonstration at the corporate tier, and its Article 6 (d) reads: "Non-compete agreements must be reasonably scoped, time-limited, and accompanied by commensurate compensation." That article lies at the rule layer, and speaks of a non-compete agreement with compensation; Political Economy has stated that it does not take this article, and this paper does not take it either.55 Sentences at the normative layer in Appendix C can be cited; before citing them, the items F6 lists as "not inherited by this version" are checked first.56
Political Economy has one more sentence, which this paper says after it: what is judged is the clause, not the person.57 That Jing He raised this clause does not show what kind of friend he is.
Contractual Obligations, and the Layer Between Persons
The obligations written into a contract belong to the institutional side: they are given by that contract and by the rules of that institution, and how they are performed, and what follows if they are broken, are read on that side. If the two had signed a partnership agreement setting down how much each puts in and what each looks after, those would be obligations of this kind.
The layer between persons is another matter. Relation Theory has set down: commitment does not turn into a duty to the other party; it binds a person by where I myself stand and by the effects already left, not by my owing the other party something.58 The other party's response is material, not a settling of the account: it enters my conditions of occurrence and becomes material for the next expectation.59 If Jing He's remark "The accounts were your job to begin with" means "The agreement says you keep the accounts," what he points to is the institutional side, read by the agreement. If it means "You promised me," what he points to is the layer between the two: Wei An avowed it back then, and that binding lies in where Wei An himself stands and in the effects he has already left; it is not a debt Wei An owes Jing He that Jing He can come and collect. The two can fall on the same matter at once, and are entered separately.
§5 A Procedure Already Recognized
CO16 A procedure both have recognized beforehand is handing this one matter over, not a position that legislates for the two; a judgment made by a procedure both have recognized and that applies governs how this one matter is ordered, is valid for the action arrangement, and does not turn every outcome into something that needs consent obtained anew. Whether a procedure has already been recognized by both parties, or has some other fit ground, is checked apart from whether, in running, it is still controlled by the party questioned. A third party selected unilaterally by the stronger side may be only an extension of that side's power: unilateral nomination is a clue to be checked, and does not by itself prove unfitness; nor does having once been recognized, or having been set up by law, by itself prove that this dispute has been removed from the original control. If the party questioned can still, on its own, seal off review of itself, or controls the related adjudication and its delivery, it cannot be held, on the strength of "handed to a third party" alone, that the dispute has been removed; that is the same thing continuing under another name. Ordinary dissatisfaction does not directly prove that the procedure has been captured
Handing This One Matter Over
Action Theory Paper 8 has an example. Two people work together in a group at a company, and judge differently which department to take on first in the second quarter; they had agreed beforehand that a matter like this would go to the group's convener to decide. The convener decided, and the two went along with it. Action Theory says: "This is a limited shared procedure: what it governs is how this one matter is ordered, and its binding force comes from both of them having accepted this way of doing things beforehand; it does not thereby become a position that legislates their own law for the two of them".60
What Wei An and Jing He said at the opening is like this too: major matters of the shop on which the two cannot agree go to Cai Qingsheng to decide. Cai Qingsheng has run a secondhand bookshop for thirty years, and both respect him. Such a method the Conflict Treatise counts as one form of removal: the original relation no longer carries this handling, and a fit external procedure carries it.61 What is handed over, the Conflict Treatise has written exactly: "What is ceded is the procedural power of adjudication over disputes about action, not the constitutive power over one's own law." A procedure of arbitration can decide who uses which resource when, and which action may be carried out; it cannot decide which law is truer in the first person, nor whose subject standing is higher.62 Cai Qingsheng can decide whether this shop buys that whole warehouse of books; he cannot decide why Jing He opened this shop, or what Wei An cares about. Nor does he thereby become a position that legislates for the two.
Valid for the Action Arrangement
A judgment made by a procedure that has been recognized and that applies is valid for how this one matter is ordered. Suppose the two cannot agree on whether to buy a whole warehouse of books, hand it to Cai Qingsheng, and he says to buy. Wei An is not satisfied; he thinks the price is too high. This judgment does not lose its validity because Wei An is not satisfied. It does not turn every outcome into something that needs the two people's consent obtained anew; if it did, the procedure would have handed nothing over. Wei An's dissatisfaction can be said out loud, can be recorded, can be raised the next time the two talk this method over again; ordinary dissatisfaction does not directly prove that something has gone wrong with this procedure.
Whether it applies is checked separately: whether this matter falls within the class the two handed to him in the first place. What the two said was "major matters of the shop"; whether Wei An goes to night school is not within this class, and if it were taken to Cai Qingsheng, what he decided would not reach this matter either. A procedure governs only what the two handed over.
Two Questions, Checked Apart
Of a procedure, two things have to be asked apart. First, whether it has grounds: whether the two have both recognized it, or whether it has some other fit ground, such as lawful authority, or legitimate authority for the protection of basic rights.63 Second, whether in running it is still controlled by the party questioned: whether the party questioned can, on his own, replace the one who judges, keep material from getting in, declare by himself that review stops here this time, or whether, once it is judged, it rests with him whether the judgment is carried out.
The Conflict Treatise lists these two apart in two places. It writes of the external avenue of questioning: "only an institution fit for purpose, available and not controlled by a party to the dispute has standing to bear the principal screening";64 being fit for purpose is one thing, not being controlled by a party to the dispute is another. It writes of arbitration: "A third party selected unilaterally by the stronger side may be only an extension of that side's power"; where one is required to hand the disagreement to an arbitrator designated by one's superior, "that is not removal; that is the same thing continuing under another name."65
The two questions cannot stand in for each other: having grounds does not prove not being controlled; clues of being controlled do not by themselves prove having no grounds. Three situations are read below.
Three Situations
Suppose that in the seventh year the two again cannot agree over buying a whole warehouse of books. Wei An thinks the price Jing He has offered is too high, and wants to question whether this money is well spent; in this matter, the party questioned is Jing He.
- As they said at the opening, the two hand it to Cai Qingsheng. He is someone the two chose together; he looks at the books, hears both of them out, and decides; what reaches him is the material each of the two hands in, and once he has decided, the two act on it. This is a procedure the two recognized beforehand and that applies, and in running it is not controlled by Jing He either. What he decides is valid for this matter.
- Jing He says: "Let my cousin decide; he's been in the antiquarian book trade for twenty years, he knows the business." The cousin was put forward by Jing He alone, and Wei An has never recognized this. Unilateral nomination of a third party is a clue to be checked, and does not by itself prove that this person is unfit: the cousin may truly know the business, and may have nothing at all to do with this purchase. Two things are to be checked: whether Wei An recognizes this method, or whether this person has some other fit ground; and whether, when the cousin decides this matter, it is still controlled by Jing He. On the strength of his being Jing He's cousin alone, nothing is judged; on the strength of his knowing the business alone, nothing is judged either.66
- It is still handed to Cai Qingsheng, the one both recognized. But this time, in the seventh year, Jing He has decided on a method: all material sent to Cai Qingsheng is put in order and passed on by Jing He, and what Wei An wants to hand in goes through Jing He's hands; once Cai Qingsheng has decided, when the money is paid, and whether it is paid, is for Jing He to see to. Then the fact that the two recognized this method back then does not by itself prove that this dispute has been removed from Jing He's control. If the party questioned can still, on his own, seal off review of himself, or controls the related adjudication and its delivery, it cannot be held, on the strength of "handed to a third party" alone, that the dispute has been removed; that is the same thing continuing under another name.
In the last situation, what was recognized back then remains what was recognized back then: it is neither ratified after the fact nor erased; what has to be asked separately is in whose hands control lies in this run. Whether to find another method is the two people's affair from then on; recognizing another method is read by §2, and still needs each of the two to recognize it separately.
Political Economy has a sentence of the same form on the institutional side, used here only for reference: accumulation "may not be converted into a standing in which the party questioned can on its own close off questioning of itself, correction, or necessary delivery"; it also states that "relations such as nomination and party membership do not automatically prove capture".67 That sentence speaks of economic positions and the channels of questioning, on the institutional side; what is read here is a method recognized between two people. The shape is the same; the grounds lie each in its own place.
§6 Interfacing with Tradition
Several thinkers have asked, at different times, about the things this paper reads. For each, what he looked in order to see, and what he saw, is written as it is; where the original text really runs counter to this paper, where it runs counter is written, and then where they meet and where they part; where it does not, only where they shed light on each other is written, or which question each of the two asks and at what scale; a counter-thesis the original text does not contain is not made up on its behalf. Aristotle on rule and division of labor in the household, in Book I of the Politics, has already been taken up in Marriage Theory Paper 4, and is not rewritten here.68
One man, one thing (Plato). In Book II of the Republic, Socrates begins from the origin of the city: a city arises from human needs, since no one is sufficient for himself. He goes on to say that people differ from one another: "there are diversities of natures among us which are adapted to different occupations"; and so "all things are produced more plentifully and easily and of a better quality when one man does one thing which is natural to him and does it at the right time, and leaves other things".69 He looks in order to see clearly how a city comes into being and where justice falls within it. What he sees: people differ; division of labor comes out of their differences, and what is done together gets done because of it. The passage cited supports people's differing and each doing what he is good at; it does not yield that a person's share can never be changed from then on; fixed status, with no changing allowed, would need other passages and antecedents from the original, and this paper does not derive it on his behalf. From here this paper puts one question to it: if the ground of division of labor is nature, where is a person's place for changing his share? §3 says that where division of labor is hung on who the other is, there is a tendency toward colonization; nature and who the other is lie very close together, and so this question has to be asked. They meet in: he sees that people are not alike, and that division of labor grows out of difference, rather than whittling people down to sameness. When §1 of this paper says that two concerns came to rest on the same shop and that what each of the two cared about did not merge into one, it sees the same place; on the night before the opening, Jing He's taking the stock and Wei An's taking the accounts were also divided by what each was good at. They part at: what he reads is how a city is built, and one man, one thing is a principle of that construct, and does not lie at the layer this paper reads. What this paper reads lies between two people: what each is good at is a condition of division of labor, and when the conditions change, division of labor can be avowed anew. The passage cited does not answer the question above, and this paper does not answer it on its behalf.
Organic solidarity (Durkheim). In Book I, Chapter 3 of The Division of Labor in Society, Durkheim separates two kinds of solidarity. What follows reports it after Simpson's English translation:70 one solidarity presupposes that individuals are like one another; the other presupposes that they differ, and is possible only where each person has a domain of action that belongs to him alone, that is, a personality; the more finely labor is divided, the more closely each person depends on society. This kind of solidarity is like the kind to be seen in the higher animals; by this analogy he names it organic solidarity. He looks in order to explain how a society holds together and how division of labor becomes a source of social solidarity. What he sees: division of labor makes people differ from one another, and also makes them depend on one another. The two do not ask at the same scale: he reads how a society holds together by division of labor; this paper reads how a division of labor two people have avowed binds them, and how it is changed; the few sentences reported do not run counter to this paper. They meet in: neither he nor this paper reads difference as something to be done away with; he says that the latter solidarity needs each person to have a domain of action of his own, and this paper says that each of the two has a share; Action Theory writes that "difference is not an impurity to be removed".71 They part at: what he reads is the solidarity of a society, at the layer of institutions and community; this paper reads what lies between two people, where doing things together does not automatically produce a "we" that legislates for both. How solidarity and "we" are borrowed between two people is read in Paper 4.
The pin manufactory (Smith). Book I, Chapter 1 of the Wealth of Nations opens by saying that the greatest advances in the productive powers of labor appear to have come from the division of labor. He takes a very small trade, pin-making: one man draws the wire, a second straightens it, a third cuts it; "the important business of making a pin is, in this manner, divided into about eighteen distinct operations"; he had seen a small manufactory of this kind "where ten men only were employed".72 He looks in order to explain where the wealth of nations comes from. What he sees: once the work is divided, the same people make far more. They meet at one place only: a thing gets done only by being done in divided parts, and this paper too starts from here. They part at: division of labor in the pin manufactory is division of labor within a manufactory, where employment and positions stand, belonging to the institutional side, which this paper acknowledges but does not judge; what this paper reads is the kind two people avow together. The two are placed only as neighbors.
§7 Drawing Together and Downstream
This paper has set out five propositions. Taken together, they say: in the cooperation this series reads, division of labor is an arrangement the two have avowed together; it is consensus, not calculation; neither law has changed, and what has changed lies at the layer of arrangement; the binding force of division of labor passes separately through each party's own law, or comes from a procedure both parties have already recognized, and is not a third law standing above the two. Division of labor is a present arrangement; it can be avowed anew, and it can be changed; a new shared division of labor must be avowed by both parties separately, or be made by a procedure both have recognized and that applies, and this does not make either party the approver of the other's own revision and exit; unilateral withdrawal does not impose a new arrangement on the other party, nor does it erase the effects already left. Where division of labor slides into a fixed requirement aimed at the other, by being treated as something the other may not change, by being hung on who the other is, or by being swapped out within habit, there is a tendency toward colonization: saying out loud a characterization slides in that direction, and making it unchangeable for the other in running carries it; one party's own treating it as unchangeable is his self-relation. Organizations, contracts and positions are acknowledged but not judged, and registered as conditions; a registered partner is in a position, and the construct is the address of attribution, not a third bearer; the non-compete agreement is read as Political Economy reads it, and the other party to the cooperation is the party that sets the agreement, not among "others"; the obligations of a contract lie on the institutional side, and between persons commitment does not turn into a duty. In a procedure the two have recognized beforehand, what is handed over is how this one matter is ordered; a procedure's grounds and who controls it in running are checked apart.
This paper does not prove which division of labor is right, does not prescribe for anyone how division of labor is to be divided, and does not judge whether the obligations in a contract are legitimate.
Questions left open. Suppose Wei An has withdrawn from keeping the accounts, and Jing He has not avowed that share either, so that for a while no one keeps the accounts. The rent is paid a month late, and the landlord comes to ask. Whose is this month: is it what Wei An's withdrawal left, what Jing He's not avowing left, or a thing the two both left undone? This paper has gone only as far as saying that withdrawal does not impose a new arrangement on the other party, nor erase the effects already left. Who actually did what, and who acknowledges it, this paper does not read.
Downstream. What this paper has set out, the later papers use as follows. "For the sake of this shop" and "for the company" used to judge one party's law for him, and the friendship between two friends borrowed as adjudication, are read in Paper 4. Where one end is headed in the 15DD direction and one leans toward 14DD, the clues visible in division of labor, and withdrawing one's own side, are read in Paper 5. Who in a division of labor actually did what, and who acknowledges a mistake, are read in Paper 6. How a division of labor sediments and changes over the long years, and the shared matters that remain after the two part, are read in Paper 7. The check on the shared words "law" and "arrangement," "procedure," "accountability," "bearer" and "address of attribution," "non-compete agreement" and "conditional payment" is listed together in Paper 0.
Acknowledgments
This paper is signed by Han Qin alone; the author decided every argument and choice and bears sole responsibility for the text. In drafting, the author used AI models from various developers as tools.
Notes
- Paper 1, CO1, CO2; Action Theory D47: "One person is for purpose A, another for purpose B, and the two cannot not do C: C is something both of them avow and both are able to do, whose purpose and adjudication neither side holds alone; it is doing something together, not a shared law". ↩︎
- Relation Theory H8, as listed together in Relation Theory Paper 0: "Cultivation and colonization are two directions: cultivation goes toward making space, colonization toward pouring in and occupying; the direction is read on this one effect, and whether it took hold is seen in the other party's later understanding and action; the two are not the two extremes of one scale, and the same act can carry both directions, and can also carry no direction at all; they are directions, not labels". ↩︎
- Conflict Treatise §8: "Time, resources, roles, procedure and the conditions of action were rearranged"; "the arrangement itself neither generates a third law of one's own nor, on its own strength, rewrites either party's law". The Introduction of Marriage Theory Paper 4 uses the two words apart in the same way. ↩︎
- Conflict Treatise §27: ceding the power of adjudication to something external "holds only for a certain class of external body: a procedure both parties have acknowledged, a mechanism with lawful authority, or an institution with legitimate authority for the protection of basic rights". ↩︎
- F6 §1.3: accountability is "The contentful requirement that falls on a member's position when a construct exercises power over that member. It binds the position and not the subject itself". ↩︎
- Relation Theory H27: "Commitment does not turn into a duty to the other party; it binds a person by where I myself stand and by the effects already left, not by my owing the other party something". ↩︎
- Among what Relation Theory Paper 0, §16, hands to Cooperation Theory: friendship is not given a series of its own, but serves as a running example. The branch of mutual recognition within friendship is read as Relation Theory reads it; this paper reads only the thing done together. ↩︎
- Conflict Treatise §8: "Neither law changed at all"; "What changed is something else. Time, resources, roles, procedure and the conditions of action were rearranged, so that the current incompatibility of action was dissolved or deactivated. And the arrangement itself neither generates a third law of one's own nor, on its own strength, rewrites either party's law". The Conflict Treatise says only that "those two people" live together, and does not say whether they are friends or husband and wife; it is borrowed here only to see the layer of arrangement. ↩︎
- Action Theory Paper 8, §3: "Two concerns came to rest on the same practice, and what each of them cared about did not thereby merge into one". ↩︎
- Conflict Treatise §8: the four misreadings "arise because there is no position that can hold 'neither law changed and the problem is solved.'" ↩︎
- Conflict Treatise §24: "The first is arrangement consensus. Neither law changed; the two jointly formed a solution under which the current action requirements can be jointly realized"; "The second is revision consensus. One party or both separately completed first-person revisions, and the new action requirements attained compatibility". ↩︎
- Conflict Treatise §24: "Neither is completed by an act of persuasion. Persuasion may supply reasons and may causally promote one party's revision; the persuader's success does not itself constitute the consensus." ↩︎
- Action Theory D45: "Consensus is not sameness: a shared direction holds different values, a concrete consensus can form without swallowing differences, and neither side can declare agreement in the other's place". ↩︎
- Economics P2, §4.0: "In the 14DD world, the person across from you is a strategy set". ↩︎
- Paper 1, CO5: of the three kinds commonly met outside scope, the first is that in which neither party is headed in the 15DD direction, whose ideal type is the case in which both parties treat each other only as a strategy set and reach a balance by mutual calculation. ↩︎
- Paper 1, CO6. ↩︎
- Conflict Treatise §24: "Consensus does not automatically generate a third first-person legislator. The two may perfectly well have a standing rule from then on, sorting household matters into three kinds. But that rule's binding force must pass separately through each party's own law, or come from a procedure both have acknowledged. It is not a third law above the two." ↩︎
- The Second Critique, Chapter Six, Section 5. The same section cites Conflict Treatise §24 and Action Theory Paper 8, §5, as the same form on the side of law. ↩︎
- Marriage Theory Paper 4, under MA24, reading division of labor in marriage, has the same: "The two are arrangements the two acknowledged together, not requirements of each other." In cooperation exchange can hold; how an arrangement of reciprocal exchange is read belongs to Paper 2. ↩︎
- Relation Theory H32: "A commitment marked as a present arrangement that tomorrow can avow anew, with revising and exit actually reachable, does not fall into locking". The original sentence speaks of commitment; carrying it to a division of labor the two have avowed together is an extension, this series' own undertaking. Marriage Theory Paper 4 makes the same extension. ↩︎
- Paper 7 reads what a thing done together sediments into in time, by Relation Theory H29 and H49. ↩︎
- Action Theory D45. ↩︎
- Relation Theory H26: "Commitment cannot lock tomorrow: that it cannot lock lies in the layer of qualification, and is necessary; locking lies in the layer of running, and is possible; where tomorrow is locked in running, what is violated is the exit right, which is a person's basic right". ↩︎
- Conflict Treatise §8: "One-sided adjustment on my own side, protective arrangement, adjudication by external procedure — all belong to the layer of action arrangement"; §26: a stopping point may come from an arrangement on one's own side: "he alone changed how he does things, and the other took no part". ↩︎
- Relation Theory H56: "Withdrawing one's own side is exit and does not carry the direction of colonization, even if the other party's cost rises as a result". The original speaks of exiting a relation; here it speaks of withdrawing one's own share in a division of labor while the person is still in this undertaking, which is an extension, this series' own undertaking. ↩︎
- Relation Theory H23: "Commitment does not bind exit, and it does not sign for tomorrow. It binds a person in two places, and neither rests on locking tomorrow: on my side, it rests on where I stand; on the other party's side, on the effects already left. Leaving is entered on the books, and revising keeps the books on the change". ↩︎
- F6 §1.3: accountability "binds the position and not the subject itself"; as for exiting that position, "Exit terminates the answering load the position currently carries"; how one exits is read by the provisions on that side. What that slot in the articles of association is, the facts of this example record only as far as who represents the company externally; the rest is recorded as not checked. ↩︎
- Marriage Theory MA24: "Division of labor is a present arrangement the two have acknowledged together; it can be avowed anew, and it can be changed; its binding force passes separately through each party's own law. Where division of labor slides into a fixed requirement aimed at the other, by being treated as something the other may not change, by being hung on who the other is, or by being swapped out within habit, there is a tendency toward colonization". The two series are parallel, and this point has the same form at the normative layer; it is written here after its shape, and not derived from it. ↩︎
- Relation Theory H18: "Locking is only at the layer of running: the positions of avowal, revision and exit still belong to this person, and an earlier position cannot seal off a later one"; Relation Theory Paper 2, under H18: "Locking speaks of being out of reach, not of something pouring in and occupying, so locking in itself carries no direction of colonization". ↩︎
- Relation Theory Paper 3, under H26: what is done to exit at the layer of running is "read as three kinds, divided by structure, not by means"; a characterization spoken aloud is the first kind, and slides in the direction of colonization; raising the cost outward, making the way hard to travel, carries the direction of colonization; sealing off exit itself is, at the layer of basic rights, violation. The original speaks of exit; carrying it to avowing a division of labor anew is an extension, this series' own undertaking; Marriage Theory Paper 4 makes the same extension. ↩︎
- Relation Theory H9: "Violation is judged separately, and only at the layer of basic rights; it and the direction of colonization are two lines"; Relation Theory Paper 3, under H26, on sealing off exit itself: "at the layer of basic rights it is a violation, and it also carries the direction of colonization; the two lines are both present". ↩︎
- Relation Theory H37: "Saying an expectation out loud is a form of questioning; to attach a qualifying condition to an expectation, fixing for the other party what something means to him, for instance by hanging it as a criterion on who he is or what he cares about, is to slide in the direction of colonization, and whether that takes hold depends on the other party's later understanding and action". ↩︎
- Relation Theory Paper 1, under H3, reads "We love each other, so you have to agree": borrowing mutual recognition to pass final judgment on a thing done together. The same form between friends is read in Paper 4. ↩︎
- Action Theory Paper 4, D20, cited at second hand, by way of Relation Theory Paper 2, under H16, and Paper 3, under H31. ↩︎
- Relation Theory H49: "The cells of stability sediment in time, and one cell can become another: maintaining with grounds can be surreptitiously swapped out within habit, and staying on only by conditions can also grow grounds". ↩︎
- Relation Theory H8. ↩︎
- Relation Theory Paper 2, under H16: "what had its origin outside and was avowed by her after reconsideration is not a swap". The original sentence speaks of her; here it speaks of him; the shape is the same. ↩︎
- Relation Theory H11: within an institution, the part of what passes between persons that the institution does not provide for, or that goes beyond its provisions, is within range, while "the relation between persons and constructs is not; the provisions themselves are acknowledged but not judged". ↩︎
- F6 §1.3: "any stable rule-framework formed for the recurring handling of entangled intersections counts as an institution. A nation-state is a macro-institution; a corporation is an organizational institution; a community is a voluntary institution; marriage and friendship are micro-relational institutions". ↩︎
- F6 §3.1 (d), (e). ↩︎
- Relation Theory H11; H52: "the authority that comes with a position is acknowledged but not judged". ↩︎
- Conflict Treatise §20. ↩︎
- Conflict Treatise §21: "Other authorities of role, of law, or of procedure settle separately within their own domains and have nothing to do with this path". ↩︎
- Political Economy Prequel, §6. The first sentence is taken from Institution Theory. ↩︎
- F6 §1.3. ↩︎
- Political Economy Prequel, §6; the "How to read" paragraph of the Prequel's Introduction: a construct "is the address of attribution, not the subject of the act". The sentence in §6 cites On Accountability F42. ↩︎
- Political Economy Prequel, §6: "What a company does is booked first at the address of the company; the positions and persons that did it each have their own accountability, examined separately, neither shielded by the company's name nor replaced by it". ↩︎
- Relation Theory H3: "A relation is a construct: the construct left when the effect of one side enters the conditions of occurrence of the other side; it does not legislate, bears nothing, and does not pass final judgment on either party's own law on their behalf"; H12: "a little circle of two does not form a third bearer". ↩︎
- F6 §1.3: "A construct is not a shell that insulates individuals from bearing". ↩︎
- Political Economy Paper 2, E12a: "A non-compete agreement, that is, an agreement backed by liquidated damages, injunction or compulsory enforcement that forbids a person, after leaving, to go in a certain direction"; "It is non-exit suppression, and its gravity depends on the territory, trade and term it reaches"; "So a non-compete agreement is violation, with compensation as without". ↩︎
- Political Economy Paper 2, E12a: "A constraint set to protect others is not among non-compete agreements"; "What it protects is a third party's rights or the public's channels for questioning, not the contracting party's own advantage". §8 also writes that the workshop's apprenticeship contract and the like "protect the contracting party itself: keeping people, keeping out competition; they are not of this kind". ↩︎
- Political Economy Paper 2, E12a: "for a constraint protecting others, the rule layer states which exercise it limits, whom it protects, why nothing less will do, and how wide its scope is"; "where it limits beyond what protecting others requires, what it strikes out is still where he goes, and that part is still violation". §8: "merely claiming to protect people does not earn this reading". ↩︎
- Political Economy Paper 2, E12a: a conditional payment "forbids nothing, but only ties an additional payment to a choice; the choice is still in the person's hands, and accepting the payment is itself an exercise of that choice; the normative layer does not judge it a strict violation, and the rule layer may permit it or not". ↩︎
- Political Economy Paper 2, E12a: "The criterion of the division lies at the normative layer, in three items, each asking whether the person still has this choice: is the backing prohibition and compulsory enforcement, or only no longer paying; is what is tied to 'not going' an additional payment, or wages already earned, deferred pay, or money paid out and then clawed back; taken together with other constraints, or under deep dependence, does refusing the payment amount to being unable to live; the three are used together, and that the backing is only no longer paying is not yet enough to recognize that the choice is actually there". Which side a particular clause falls on lies at the rule layer and the judgment layer. ↩︎
- F6, Appendix C, Article 6 (d); Political Economy Paper 2, §8: "That is a non-compete agreement with compensation; this series does not take this article". ↩︎
- F6, appendix preamble: "The following are not inherited by this version". Appendix C, besides, was already revised along with the body in three places in the previous version; in citing, these are handled separately, as the appendix preamble says. ↩︎
- Political Economy Paper 2, §8: "This reading judges the clause, not the person." ↩︎
- Relation Theory H27. ↩︎
- Relation Theory H33: "The other party's response is material, not a settling of the account: it enters my conditions of occurrence and becomes material for the next expectation; the mere fact that a response has occurred settles nothing, and does not certify that the other party has avowed anything". ↩︎
- Action Theory Paper 8, §5. ↩︎
- Conflict Treatise §27: in removal, "the original relation no longer carries this handling, or a fit external procedure carries it"; "It is not called a terminus. External arbitration is one form of removal." ↩︎
- Conflict Treatise §27: "Arbitration may decide who uses which resource when, which action may be carried out, how procedure is arranged. It cannot decide which law is truer in the first person, and it cannot decide whose subject standing is higher." ↩︎
- Conflict Treatise §27; see note 4. ↩︎
- Conflict Treatise §15. The same section: "What is needed is not necessarily the channel running from the original other party directly to me"; the external avenue of questioning may be borne by a fit third party, by procedure, or by later public review. ↩︎
- Conflict Treatise §27. The original sentence says "may": unilateral selection is a possible extension, not a proven one. ↩︎
- Checking the two questions apart is this series' way of reading: Conflict Treatise §15 lists "fit for purpose" and "not controlled by one party to the dispute" as two items, and §27 writes that a third party selected unilaterally "may be only an extension" of that side's power; putting the two places together and reading them onto a procedure two people have recognized is an extension, this series' own undertaking. ↩︎
- Political Economy Paper 4, E22. On the institutional side, used only as a reference of the same form. ↩︎
- Marriage Theory Paper 4, §5. ↩︎
- Plato, Republic, Book II, 369b–370c, per Benjamin Jowett's English translation, as transcribed at literaturepage.com; the two passages in the body are quoted from it as they stand. The Greek original has not been checked. ↩︎
- Durkheim, The Division of Labor in Society, Book I, Chapter 3. Reported from the wording of G. Simpson's English translation (The Division of Labor in Society, 1933), pp. 129–131; these sentences were checked as recorded in the University of Regina sociology course notes (Gingrich); Simpson's book itself has not been checked, nor have the Halls translation and the French original. The page numbers follow the edition the course notes cite (the notes give it as The Free Press, 1933). ↩︎
- Action Theory D46: "Mutual cultivation is two people illuminating each other: each one's unfolding also illuminates the other; difference is not an impurity to be removed, and consensus is not a contract to stop asking". ↩︎
- Smith, Wealth of Nations, Book I, Chapter 1, per the marxists.org transcription; the two passages in the body are quoted from it as they stand. ↩︎
References
All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version. Quotations are checked item by item in the accompanying audit table.
I · SAE works directly cited in this paper
Qin, H. (2026). How Is Institution Possible: From Inter-Ontological Remainder to Co-Constructive Framework (SAE Foundational Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19328662
Qin, H. (2026). The Other End of the Bridge: Economic Rationality When 15DD Faces a Party Who Does Not Enter 15DD (SAE Economics, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19381666
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Conflict Treatise: How Subjecthood Is Not Swallowed by Conflict Itself [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22313628
Qin, H. (2026). Finding One Another (SAE Action Theory, Paper 8) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22970783
Qin, H. (2026). SAE: The Second Critique [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23250387
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Relation Theory Paper 0: The Place of Relation Theory [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545115
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Relation Theory Paper 1: What a Relation Is, and What It Is Not [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545047
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Relation Theory Paper 2: Yesterday, Today, Tomorrow [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23541778
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Relation Theory Paper 3: Commitment [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545023
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Relation Theory Paper 4: Dealings and Expectation [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545057
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Relation Theory Paper 5: The Sediment of Dealings [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545076
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Relation Theory Paper 6: Asymmetry, Divergence and Ending [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545087
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Marriage Theory Paper 4: The Years [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23819238
Qin, H. (2026). What an Economy Is Not (SAE Political Economy, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874133
Qin, H. (2026). Chokepoints (SAE Political Economy, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874140
Qin, H. (2026). Conversion (SAE Political Economy, Paper 4) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874146
II · External works
Plato. The Republic, Book II (369b–370c). Trans. Benjamin Jowett. literaturepage.com transcription. (the Greek original has not been checked)
Durkheim, É. (1893). The Division of Labor in Society, Book I, ch. 3. Trans. G. Simpson. New York: Macmillan, 1933, pp. 129–131. (reported at second hand, as recorded in the University of Regina sociology course notes (Gingrich); the book itself has not been checked)
Smith, A. (1776). An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, Book I, Chapter 1. marxists.org transcription.
Aristotle. Politics, Book I. In the edition Marriage Theory Paper 4 relies on; this paper only points back to it.
Interfaces
- Main upstream: the Conflict Treatise (§8, §15, §20, §21, §24, §26, §27); Action Theory Paper 8 (§3, §5; D45, D47); Marriage Theory Paper 4 (MA24, of the same form at the normative layer); Political Economy Prequel (the "How to read" paragraph of the Introduction, §6) and Paper 2 (E12a, §8).
- Also used: Relation Theory Paper 1 (H3, H8, H9, H11, H12; under H3), Paper 2 (H18; under H16), Paper 3 (H23, H26, H27, H29, H32; under H26, under H31), Paper 4 (H33, H37), Paper 5 (H49), Paper 6 (H52, H56), Paper 0 (the list of propositions in §15, and §16); F6 (§1.3; §3.1 (d)(e); the appendix preamble; Appendix C, Article 6 (d), not taken); the Second Critique, Chapter Six, Section 5; Economics P2 (§4.0); Political Economy Paper 4 (E22, only as a reference of the same form); Action Theory Paper 4, D20 (cited at second hand, by way of Relation Theory), and Paper 8, D46; Institution Theory (by way of the Political Economy Prequel, §6).
- This series: continues from Paper 1 (scope, the three kinds outside scope, the three structural clues) and Paper 2 (reciprocal exchange); Paper 4 takes up "for the sake of this shop" and the friendship between two friends borrowed as adjudication; Paper 5 takes up division of labor and withdrawal where one end is headed in the 15DD direction and one leans toward 14DD; Paper 6 takes up who actually did what, and who acknowledges it; Paper 7 takes up the sedimenting of division of labor over the long years, and the shared matters that remain after parting; Paper 0 lists the shared words together.