University Governance
大学的治理
The first six papers each stated who makes a decision and who bears its consequences. This paper brings them together and asks one last thing: who sets these rules, and how are the positions that set rules questioned? It begins with Oxford's Congregation: the university's ultimate legislative body, in which twenty members can submit a resolution on any topic and two members can oppose a legislative proposal. Its members are academics and staff above a certain grade; students are not among them. How, then, do those who are not members, yet bear the consequences of these rules, initiate questioning that reaches their problems? The paper first brings each "who decides" handed over by the first six papers down to positions of accountability, and then states four propositions. The positions that set rules can be questioned, through channels that meet three conditions, with students, staff, and those kept out by a door they cannot get around all on the inside. Academic judgment is completed by positions with the corresponding competence that bear the relevant accountability, and can still be questioned; the right to question does not confer the power to replace academic conclusions, and the positions of academic judgment do not monopolize shutting the door either. Leaving space for leading: it is not written into rules, and it is not assessed. The university itself is also a construct: decisions can be final, positions cannot. The whole series is brought together here.
Writing Declaration: This paper was co-drafted with Claude (Anthropic). All intellectual decisions, framework design, and final editorial judgments were made by the author.
Introduction
On Oxford's governance website there is a page titled "What is Congregation?" It says: "Congregation is the ultimate legislative body of the University of Oxford." It considers major questions of policy put to it by Council or by members, elects members of Council and other bodies, and approves changes to statutes and regulations. Members have several ways of initiating: "20 members of Congregation may submit a resolution on any topic"; two members can oppose a legislative proposal or propose an amendment; one member can ask a question about the university's policy or administration at a meeting during term.
Another page sets out membership: Congregation consists of all of Oxford's academic staff and of academic-related staff of higher grades; those listed include members of the faculties, the principal officers of the university, the heads of colleges and societies, staff in university departments in posts at grade 8 and above, and others. Students are not among those listed.
The opening asks one question only: how do those who are not members, yet bear the consequences of these rules, initiate questioning that reaches their problems?
These two pages prove only one point: members have channels through which they can initiate and change rules, written into the rules. Whether those who are not members have other channels, such as the student union, complaints and appeals procedures, or outside adjudicating bodies, these two pages do not say, and this paper has not checked them one by one; this question is not a judgment on Oxford. How it is actually questioned is checked separately.
The first six papers each stated who makes a decision and who bears its consequences; this paper brings them together. The paper has six sections. §1 takes up, item by item, the "who decides" handed over by the first six papers; §2 says the positions that set rules can be questioned; §3, the accountability of academic judgment and its being questioned; §4, leaving space for leading; §5, the advising relationship and the positions that bear the accountability of advising; §6, the university itself is also a construct. Sections 2, 3, 4 and 6 each state one proposition at the end, and all are listed together at the end of the paper. Last comes where this series stops.
§1 The "Who Decides" Handed Over by the First Six Papers
Each proposition the first six papers stated said which kind of position is to do a thing, and on what basis. This section gathers them into one table. The table names only kinds of accountability, not the names and composition of bodies: which committee, which office, is at the rule layer.
There is a division of labor here that Paper 5 already fixed: Paper 5 deals with the power of evaluation and its checks; this paper deals with the positions that set rules and the positions of academic judgment. Setting rules, dividing resources and checking are not evaluation, and are all power: by Power Theory, Paper 1's definition, they change the paths open to others; they are subject to checks on the grounds of the two sentences of the Prequel of Political Economy, power itself is not the problem and the arrangements that check it are themselves open to questioning.
| Matter | Who does it, and on what basis | Where it lands |
|---|---|---|
| Wages and employment tasks | The position accountable for hiring, assigning tasks and deciding pay, stating consequences by the requirements of employment and the work done; wages cannot be docked solely because someone refuses to put his name to a paper | DX9; DX18 |
| Course grades | The position accountable for course evaluation, evaluating by the course requirements and the actual work; objections in research do not directly decide course grades, and objections are handled by a position other than the instructor | DX9; DX18; DX22 |
| Authorship and the record of contributions | Each person puts his name to the judgments he can be responsible for; the position handling disputes checks contributions, procedures and the application of rules (this clause is added by this paper), and does not avow in his place conclusions he is unwilling to bear | DX15; DX17; DX18; this paper |
| Progress toward degrees and qualifications | Assessing positions separate from the advisor, assessing by the degree requirements and materials; the advisor submits an opinion and does not control the conclusion and review alone | DX26; DX22 |
| Changing advisors and continuity of advising | The position accountable for arranging advising, stating who takes over, when it is available, and who answers when the arrangement is unavailable; the original advisor does not control exit alone | DX3; DX11; §5 of this paper |
| Transitional support | The position that bears the arrangement of transitional resources, stating the conditions, term and limits of support; funding is not controlled by the original advisor alone | DX11; Paper 6, §6 |
| The division into departments and home units | The position that sets the establishment, questioned by DX34 | DX19; DX20; DX34 |
| Fees and the conditions of gifts | The position that sets the rules on fees is questioned by DX34; who reviews the conditions of gifts, see the suggestion in Paper 6, §3 | DX29; DX30; DX34 |
| Ending and continuation | The position that makes the judgment "the conditions of study at this university can no longer be secured," stating grounds, objects and costs, and open to independent questioning | DX33; DX34 |
| Objection and appeal | The position able to handle the matter in question, stating who can activate it and what actual effect it has on the decision; when the party questioned changes to a department, the administration or a reviewing position, independence is checked again | DX13; DX34; DX35 |
The constructed case of Paper 2 is fully gathered here: the doctoral student who refused to put his name to the paper and applied to change advisors has a row in the table for each of his wage, course grades, authorship, degree progress, transitional support and channel for dispute. Each row lands on a position that can be named; each position can be questioned. The next section says how.
§2 The Positions That Set Rules Can Be Questioned
The positions that set the rules of teaching, evaluation, research and funding, and the positions that set the establishment, such as the division into departments and home units, are all open to questioning. The channels of questioning meet three conditions, in Institution Theory's wording: "it is independent of the party questioned, internal subjects can actually initiate it, and initiating it brings no retaliation" (Institution Theory Z34). The party questioned has to answer the very matter it was asked about.
Who is on the inside? Institution Theory says: "The interior is drawn by entanglement: those in the entanglement the construct handles, together with those its acts reach who have no way to avoid it by exiting, make up the interior" (Institution Theory Z4). Brought down to the university: students and staff are inside; they are in the entanglement these rules handle. There is also another kind of person, kept out by the door of a degree or an evaluation, yet unable to get around that door: the Theory of Disciplines says, "those the door reaches and who cannot get around it are inside by the second branch" (Theory of Disciplines, S46). Political Economy speaks of the same kind: when a degree becomes a door others cannot get around, those the door reaches and who cannot get around it can question the door (Political Economy E31).
The question of the introduction here takes the shape of an answer. Membership is one channel; it is not the only one. Those who are not members need a channel that meets the three conditions, and the channel has to reach their problems: it can be initiated, it has actual efficacy, and the party questioned cannot cancel it on its own (Political Economy E16). What the channel looks like is a matter for the rule layer; this paper does not say it has to be a seat in Congregation.
The party questioned changes. From the advisor to the department, from the department to the administration, to the board of trustees, or to the position of appeal itself: independence has to be checked again against the party actually questioned. A position of appeal that is independent of the advisor is not necessarily independent of the administration that set it up.
Setting rules is also power. The Prequel of Political Economy says: "the arrangements that check it are themselves open to questioning." The positions that set rules are subject to checks; the arrangements that check them are themselves open to questioning. When the university adopts automated arrangements of evaluation or allocation, it answers by Paper 5's proposition (DX24).
The Office of the Independent Adjudicator for Higher Education (OIA) in England and Wales, cited in Paper 2, is outside the universities; students can go there after completing internal procedures; it does not review academic judgment itself, but can review the marking process. This is an independent channel outside the university; that it does not review academic judgment shows exactly one of the two lines of boundary in §3.
Several practices are offered only as suggestions. A position for appeal and mediation that students, professors and staff can all go to, and that does not belong to the party complained against. How informal consultation, mediation and referral are combined with formal appeal is left to the rule layer. A position of the ombuds kind, by the International Ombudsman Association's Standards of Practice revised in October 2009, "does not participate in any formal investigative or adjudicative procedures"; "does not make binding decisions, mandate policies, or formally adjudicate issues"; communications to it "are not notice to the organization"; and it "supplements, but does not replace, any formal channels."1 So the mere existence of such a position cannot prove that the related objections already have adequate channels of handling and answering; what it can handle, how it refers, and who answers for formal decisions have to be checked separately.
The strongest opponent will say: if every position of decision and review can still be questioned, will the same dispute never end, and who will dare make decisions that need timely execution? The answer: particular matters can be closed by procedures that have grounds. Institution Theory says: "what persists is the conditions of the channel and of the burden of explanation, not the endless re-asking of the same matter." (Institution Theory Z35a) That positions can be questioned does not mean that the same request can be started again and again without condition. Nor does this proposition prescribe a structure of governance; timely execution and being open to questioning do not cancel each other.
Another says: outside accountability, governments and accrediting bodies, is enough. The answer: outside accountability is also a construct, and is also questioned; channels that internal subjects can actually initiate are still needed.
DX34 The positions that set rules can be questioned. The positions that set the rules of teaching, evaluation, research and funding, and the establishment (the division into departments and home units), are questioned through channels that meet three conditions: independent of the party questioned, actually open to initiation by internal subjects, and bringing no retaliation on those who initiate them; the party questioned has to answer the very matter it was asked about. The interior is drawn by entanglement: students and staff are inside, and so are those the door reaches and who cannot get around it (those kept out by the door of a degree or an evaluation). When the party questioned changes from the advisor to the department, the administration, the board of trustees or the position of appeal itself, independence is checked again against the party actually questioned. Setting rules is also power, subject to checks, and the arrangements that check it are themselves questioned. When the university adopts automated arrangements of evaluation or allocation, DX24 applies.
§3 The Accountability of Academic Judgment, and Its Being Questioned
Whether a thesis passes, what a course teaches, whether the method of a study holds up: these are academic judgments. Who makes them?
The Theory of Government says: "Rules can enter a judgment, yet applying, weighing and taking up remain the work of the one who judges; rules cannot do judgment in anyone's place." (Theory of Government G3) Action Theory says the same thing (Action Theory D6). Extended to academic matters: academic judgment is completed by positions with the corresponding competence that bear the relevant accountability. The qualification "with the corresponding competence" is added by this series: the two upstream sentences speak of those present, and say nothing of competence; academic judgment needs it, and that is this series' own undertaking. Competence is recognized by the peer credentials of the discipline; this recognition too can be questioned.
The positions that make judgments can still be questioned: the division of labor, the grounds and the consequences can all be asked about. There are two lines of boundary here.
The first: the right to question does not automatically confer the power to replace academic conclusions. A student can ask about the grounds of a mark and can appeal on procedure; he does not thereby acquire the power to change the mark to the one he wants. The outside adjudicating office of §2, which does not review academic judgment itself, is one form of this line.
The second: primary authority to make academic judgments does not confer the power to monopolize intake, review or the ending of questioning either. The Theory of Government says: "no position may monopolize the power to shut the door" (Theory of Government G36). That the faculty has primary authority to make academic judgments about the curriculum does not mean that objections to the curriculum can only be taken in by the faculty itself, reviewed by itself, and closed by its own say.
Between the two lines there is one more point. What students know of the conditions of learning, and what staff know of the conditions of carrying things out, are not excluded by the words "that is a matter of teaching." When a course's workload crushes a year's cohort, students know it first; when an examination arrangement cannot work in the laboratory, staff know it first. What they know needs a way to come in. Nor does it follow that every matter is turned into a vote of all.
The 1966 Statement on Government of Colleges and Universities, jointly formulated by the American Association of University Professors, the American Council on Education and the Association of Governing Boards, is an example at the rule layer. It says the faculty has primary responsibility for "such fundamental areas as curriculum, subject matter and methods of instruction"; the original sentence does not end there, and goes on to list research, faculty status, and those aspects of student life which relate to the educational process. The board retains the power of review or final decision, but this power "should be exercised adversely only in exceptional circumstances," and the reasons are to be communicated to the faculty. When students wish to take part responsibly in governance, their desire "should be recognized as a claim to opportunity." This is a normative text, used as an example, not taken as a division of labor already derived upstream in this series.
Paper 5 left one point: how outside opinion and internal rulings divide their labor. Read by the two lines of boundary: independent opinion of the external examiner kind can ask whether the rules were followed, and can give views on academic judgment; it does not thereby acquire the power to replace academic conclusions. What reaches the conclusion is still the position within the institution that bears the corresponding accountability; how it responds to outside opinion is at the rule layer.
Paper 4 left a layer of Kant, which connects here, as a limited analogy only. Kant wanted the university to have one place which, in its teaching, is not under the commands of the government, one that "keine Befehle zu geben, aber doch alle zu beurtheilen die Freiheit habe": that gives no commands, yet has the freedom to judge all (Akademie-Ausgabe VII, 19–20). Where they point the same way: allowing criticism does not thereby confer the authority to command; this points the same way as the first line of boundary. Who bears academic conclusions, this series argues separately on its own conditions of accountability and competence, not by Kant. Where they part: Kant gave this place to one faculty only; this series places every position under a channel it cannot close itself, the positions of academic judgment included. The relation between university and government, this series does not write.
The strongest opponent will say: student participation will erode academic standards. The answer: the two lines of boundary have already said that the right to question does not confer the power to replace academic conclusions; conversely, the positions of academic judgment do not monopolize shutting the door either.
DX35 The accountability of academic judgment, and its being questioned. Academic judgment is completed by positions with the corresponding competence that bear the relevant accountability; the division of labor, the grounds and the consequences can still be questioned. Two lines of boundary: the right to question does not automatically confer the power to replace academic conclusions; primary authority to make academic judgments does not confer the power to monopolize intake, review or the ending of questioning either. What students know of the conditions of learning, and what staff know of the conditions of carrying things out, are not excluded by the words "a matter of teaching"; nor is every matter thereby turned into a vote of all.
§4 Leaving Space for Leading
Education left an open question: leading needs adults themselves to stand there, which cannot be mass-produced; "How can education reform leave space at the institutional level for what cannot be institutionalized?" The Prequel said that Paper 1 lays the premises and Paper 7 answers. The answer is given here.
The premises are in Paper 1. Leading is neither a power of the teaching position nor its accountability: it can happen only by personal demonstration, it is not registered as an accountability, and it is not assessed (DX6). The teaching position's own judgment is not stood in for by rules either (DX7). The advisor gives leading one place where it can be shown by personal demonstration (DX3), and leading is not on that account registered as the advisor's accountability.
So what the positions that set rules can do is one not-doing and one doing. What they do not do: they do not write leading into the rules of appointment, promotion and course evaluation, and do not assess it. Suppose an appointment rule lists "demonstrating by personal example, so that students see a direction" as an item, asks students to rate it on a five-point scale, and counts it toward promotion: this rule lists leading as a performance to be delivered; the conduct the ratings record cannot vouch that anyone thereby avowed a direction. Behavioral items in course evaluation such as "whether students are respected" are different: they are accountabilities of the teaching position, can be checked, and do not count as leading. What they do: they leave conditions for the teaching position to show its own judgment and bearing, without rules standing in for it; time, latitude, the part of a course not filled up by rubrics.
Whether anyone thereby sees a direction is not made an output of the university, is not inspected and accepted, and is not guaranteed by these arrangements. In the matter of whether anyone thereby sees a direction, what the university bears is the conditions it gives; it cannot guarantee the other's step.
DX36 Leaving space for leading. The positions that set rules do not write leading into the rules of appointment, promotion and course evaluation, and do not assess it; they leave conditions for the teaching position to show its own judgment and bearing, without rules standing in for it; whether anyone thereby sees a direction is not made an output of the university, is not inspected and accepted, and is not guaranteed by these arrangements.
§5 The Advising Relationship and the Positions That Bear the Accountability of Advising
The earlier papers handed over two things, which are placed here. This section states no proposition of its own.
The first: the arrangement, changing and continuation of advising relationships land on a position that can be named. A student who wants to change advisors knows whom to go to; who states when a new advisor can take over; when the arrangement is unavailable, the position responsible for arranging it answers. MIT's transitional support, cited in Paper 2, with a coordinator in each department, is one form of this.
The second: the advising work this arrangement needs is counted in the workload of the position that bears this accountability. Reducing other duties and adding staff are both means the rule layer can use. Not leaving the work needed to unlimited bearing by those who take it on: the normative claim of this sentence belongs to Paper 1 (DX3), and its funding side is in Paper 6. The Prequel of Cultivation Theory says (following Action Theory, Paper 4, D23): "Self-preservation rests first of all on one's also being an end: not cultivating to excess, and not wearing oneself out in a relationship one cannot cultivate." That speaks of one person; extended to the university, it means the university does not wear out those who give. Those who bear this accountability can be professors, and can also be employed graduate students (Paper 2).
There is one more layer. Institution Theory says: "An institution provides conditions for the cultivation of its internal subjects according to relational thickness; it is concerned with conditions, not with outcomes." (Institution Theory Z23) The people inside a university include professors and staff, not only students. Action Theory says: "The one who cultivates can also be cultivated; the two sides are not fixed as giver and receiver" (Action Theory D37). The teacher judges in a course, and also practices in it. From this, Paper 1's saying that the teaching position's own judgment is not stood in for by rules (DX7), and Paper 6's saying that an entrance that does not demand conversion is left among the gates where resources are divided (DX32), each gain one more root: they are also conditions the university gives to those who teach.
§6 The University Itself Is Also a Construct
All along, this series has spoken of other constructs: departments, committees, the advisor's position, the gates where resources are divided. Last, it has to speak of the university itself.
The university is not its own end. It is a construct, and has a remainder too; there is no one final master design. A university that has finished one round of revising its rules is not thereby spared from revising them again; however thorough a scheme of governance is, it will leave places uncovered when it is used.
The Theory of Government says: "Decisions can be final: a particular matter can be answered and closed. Positions cannot be final: no position may monopolize the power to shut the door" (Theory of Government G36). Institution Theory says: "An institution cannot acquire the standing of permanent exemption from questioning" (Institution Theory Z37). The Theory of Disciplines, of its seats, said a sentence of the same shape: "questioning needs no unquestionable end point." (Theory of Disciplines, S52) Brought down to the university: particular matters, an appeal, an assessment, a revision of a rule, can be answered and closed; no position, whether the board of trustees, the faculty or the office of appeals, may monopolize the power to shut the door. Under new evidence and new questions, it can be questioned again.
The whole series is brought together here. Every ought the first six papers stated lands on some position that can be questioned: the teaching position, the advisor's position, the positions of evaluation, the positions that divide resources, the positions that set rules. Every position stands under some channel it cannot close itself. This is what the series means by saying that the university itself is also a construct.
DX37 The university itself is also a construct. The university is not its own end, and has a remainder too; there is no one final master design. Decisions can be final; positions cannot.
Where This Series Stops
What it has not written: how boards of trustees are composed; whether tenure ought to be kept or abolished; the legal status of student organizations and unions; the form of positions of appeal, which is offered only as suggestion; the relation between university and government.
Handed downstream: the design of admission qualifications, admission and certification is handed to later dedicated papers, and the item handed over by Political Economy goes with it; student-to-teacher ratios in primary and secondary schools, compulsory enrollment and public provision are handed to a later Theory of Schools; particular forms of governance are at the rule layer; how those present judge is in Action Theory; institutions organizing games, the item left by the Overview of Exercises and Games of Judgment, still awaits separate treatment.
This series began from one sentence: the university fosters judgment; knowledge is the material of judgment, not the end of the university. Written out over seven papers, it has not given an ideal university. What it gives is a set of conditions, together with where each condition lands, who answers for it, and who can question it.
Notes
- These four phrases follow the revision of October 2009, Standards 4.5, 4.3, 3.8 and 4.4 in that order. The Association has a further revision of 2022, whose corresponding provisions this paper has not checked one by one. ↩︎
The Four Propositions of This Paper
- DX34 The positions that set rules can be questioned. The positions that set the rules of teaching, evaluation, research and funding, and the establishment (the division into departments and home units), are questioned through channels that meet three conditions: independent of the party questioned, actually open to initiation by internal subjects, and bringing no retaliation on those who initiate them; the party questioned has to answer the very matter it was asked about. The interior is drawn by entanglement: students and staff are inside, and so are those the door reaches and who cannot get around it. When the party questioned changes level, independence is checked again against the party actually questioned. Setting rules is also power, subject to checks, and the arrangements that check it are themselves questioned. When the university adopts automated arrangements of evaluation or allocation, DX24 applies. (Normative; taking over Institution Theory Z34 and Z4; Theory of Disciplines S46, those the door reaches and who cannot get around it being inside by the second branch; Political Economy E31, E16, and the Prequel's "the arrangements that check it are themselves open to questioning"; DX24)
- DX35 The accountability of academic judgment, and its being questioned. Academic judgment is completed by positions with the corresponding competence that bear the relevant accountability; the division of labor, the grounds and the consequences can still be questioned. Two lines of boundary: the right to question does not automatically confer the power to replace academic conclusions; primary authority to make academic judgments does not confer the power to monopolize intake, review or the ending of questioning either. What students know of the conditions of learning, and what staff know of the conditions of carrying things out, are not excluded by the words "a matter of teaching"; nor is every matter thereby turned into a vote of all. (Normative; the first half extends Action Theory D6 and Theory of Government G3, which speak of the judgment of those present, with the subject changed to academic positions, this series' own undertaking; the qualification "with the corresponding competence" is newly added by this series, this series' own undertaking; the second half takes over Theory of Government G36; the American statement of 1966 on governance serves as an example at the rule layer)
- DX36 Leaving space for leading. The positions that set rules do not write leading into the rules of appointment, promotion and course evaluation, and do not assess it; they leave conditions for the teaching position to show its own judgment and bearing, without rules standing in for it; whether anyone thereby sees a direction is not made an output of the university, is not inspected and accepted, and is not guaranteed by these arrangements. (Normative; answering Education's open question V, this series' own undertaking; the premises are in DX6 and DX7)
- DX37 The university itself is also a construct. The university is not its own end, and has a remainder too; there is no one final master design. Decisions can be final; positions cannot. (Normative; taking over Theory of Government G36 and Institution Theory Z35a, Z37; of the same shape as Theory of Disciplines S52)
References
All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version.
I · This system
- Qin, H. (2026). What a University Is Not (SAE Theory of the University, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293733
- Qin, H. (2026). University Teaching (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293737
- Qin, H. (2026). University Students (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293740
- Qin, H. (2026). University Research (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293742
- Qin, H. (2026). University Disciplines (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 4) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293746
- Qin, H. (2026). University Evaluation (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293751
- Qin, H. (2026). University Funding (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293753
- Qin, H. (2026). Education as Subject-Condition: A Philosophy of Education [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18867389
- Qin, H. (2026). Not Doing and Cannot-Not-Doing (SAE Action Theory, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22970752
- Qin, H. (2026). Not Legislating for Others (SAE Action Theory, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22970777
- Qin, H. (2026). What Cultivation Is Not (SAE Cultivation Theory, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154492
- Qin, H. (2026). To Whom the Ought Is Addressed (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23269635
- Qin, H. (2026). Conditions (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 4) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23270922
- Qin, H. (2026). Open to Questioning (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23271324
- Qin, H. (2026). Judgment (SAE Theory of Government, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23412130
- Qin, H. (2026). Questioning and Bearing (SAE Theory of Government, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23413511
- Qin, H. (2026). Non-Substitution (SAE Theory of Disciplines, Paper 9) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24177799
- Qin, H. (2026). What an Economy Is Not (SAE Political Economy, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874133
- Qin, H. (2026). Checks (SAE Political Economy, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874142
- Qin, H. (2026). Growth (SAE Political Economy, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874150
- Qin, H. (2026). SAE Exercises and Games of Judgment · Overview [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23609837
II · Rule texts and institutional documents (original language)
- University of Oxford, Governance. "What is Congregation?" https://governance.admin.ox.ac.uk/node/4408176
- University of Oxford, Governance. "Criteria for Congregation membership." https://governance.admin.ox.ac.uk/node/1349926
- AAUP, ACE, AGB. "Statement on Government of Colleges and Universities." 1966. https://www.aaup.org/report/statement-government-colleges-and-universities
- International Ombudsman Association. IOA Standards of Practice. Rev. October 2009. https://live-wp-sa-sa-1.pantheon.berkeley.edu/wp-content/uploads/IOA_Standards_of_Practice_Oct09.pdf
- Office of the Independent Adjudicator for Higher Education (OIA). "Quick guide for new student advisers." https://www.oiahe.org.uk/media/vxhgo54a/quick-guide-for-new-student-advisers.pdf
- MIT Office of Graduate Education. "Guaranteed Transitional Support." https://oge.mit.edu/finances/financial-assist/guaranteed-transitional-support/
III · External literature
- Kant, I. (1798). Der Streit der Facultäten. Königsberg: Nicolovius. Akademie-Ausgabe VII. German text, Projekt Gutenberg.
Interfaces
This series: DX34 to DX37. The whole series, DX1 to DX37, is brought together here and handed to no further paper.
Handed downstream: see "Where This Series Stops."