Self-as-an-End
SAE Theory of the University · Paper 6

University Funding
大学的经费

Han Qin (秦汉) · Independent Researcher · 2026
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24293753 · Full PDF on Zenodo · CC BY 4.0
Abstract

A university has to earn money to keep going; this cannot be avoided, and it is no stain. This paper begins with a California law of 2019: a school may not refuse to issue a transcript because a student owes it money, nor use the issuing of transcripts as a tool for collecting debts. A transcript records what a person has done; why would it be used to collect a debt? Because once the record is in the school's hands, it becomes a door others cannot get around. This paper writes about money. It states five propositions. The price falls on what is done, not on the person: persons are not within the price; money cannot buy the record that is a degree, nor the judgment "has passed"; a commission can buy research work and reports, not predetermined conclusions; being unable to pay and so unable to enter or to finish belongs to the side of chokepoints. Money carries requirements, not direction. The athlete sits in two positions. Among the gates where resources are divided, at least one entrance that does not demand conversion is left, with a written account of how it is kept from becoming another door. When it can no longer be sustained, the first thing secured is that those enrolled can finish; if that cannot be secured, they are given the conditions to go on studying at another university, and the judgment "cannot be secured" can be questioned.

Writing Declaration: This paper was co-drafted with Claude (Anthropic). All intellectual decisions, framework design, and final editorial judgments were made by the author.

Introduction

California's Assembly Bill 1313 of 2019 was signed on 4 October and became Chapter 518 of that year's statutes. It added a section to the Civil Code: a school may not "Refuse to provide a transcript for a current or former student on the grounds that the student owes a debt," nor "Use transcript issuance as a tool for debt collection."

The opening asks one question only: a transcript records what a person has done; why would it be used to collect a debt?

Because once the record is in the school's hands, it becomes a door others cannot get around. Transferring needs it, seeking work needs it, applying to graduate school needs it. Hold it back, and the student's road is stuck there; the school knows this, and so holding it back works.

This law proves only one point: this line can be written into rules. It also has another face. Section 66022 of the Education Code, amended by the same bill, in its current text still lets the state's public institutions adopt regulations under which, when a student defaults on a kind of federal student loan, certain services, grades and diplomas among them, can be withheld after written notice; registration and transcripts are not among what may be withheld.1 How the law makes its trade-offs, this paper does not judge.

This paper writes about money: a university has to earn money, and cannot avoid it; the price falls on what is done, not on the person; how money is kept from becoming a door for people. The paper has seven sections. §1 says a university has to earn money; §2, that the price falls on what is done; §3, that money carries requirements; §4, athletes; §5, an entrance that does not demand conversion; §6, the money for the advising system; §7, when it can no longer be sustained. Sections 2 to 5 and §7 each state one proposition at the end, and all are listed together at the end of the paper.


§1 A University Has to Earn Money, and Cannot Avoid It

A university has to earn money to keep going. This cannot be avoided, and it is no stain. Tuition, donations, sports, commissioned research, facilities and services are all ways of earning. Teachers have to be paid, laboratories have to buy instruments, libraries have to buy books. A university that cannot earn money will not hold out long; when it cannot hold out, those enrolled are the first to lose (§7).

Public funding is another source. The Prequel of Political Economy says: "The Base Layer is to be secured, the Emergence Layer supported." Education has a share in both layers. When public funding goes into a university, the one who states its grounds is the public position that gives the support. The Theory of the Market wrote: "Public funding is to be able to state its grounds; it is not an endorsement." (Theory of the Market, SC11) What supply this money secures, and what development it supports, are explained separately; securing a supply and keeping one particular university in being as an operating position each have their grounds explained separately too. What falls on the university is one sentence: obtaining support does not issue legitimacy for its existing acts and its continued existence. Taking public money does not mean everything the university does has been approved.

In the introduction to Paper 3, Norway took publication points out of its funding. That was exactly one ground of public funding, once written into the rules and later withdrawn.

Dividing resources is also power. Deciding who gets funding, places or leave is changing the paths open to others. By Power Theory, Paper 1's definition, it is power; it is subject to checks on the grounds of the two sentences of the Prequel of Political Economy, power itself is not the problem and the arrangements that check it are themselves open to questioning. It stands alongside the evaluation of Paper 5, and is not renamed evaluation.

This section states no proposition. The propositions below all ask the same thing: when money enters the university, what is within the price, and what is not.


§2 The Price Falls on What Is Done, Not on the Person

The main line of the Theory of the Company is: "a person has no equivalent: a company buys what people do, not people; the price falls on what is done, not on the person." Brought down to the university, it gives four sentences, each with its own grounds.

First: a person has no equivalent; persons themselves are not within the price. When the university pays wages, what it buys is what teachers, staff and teaching assistants do, not these people; when students pay tuition, what they buy is courses, services, and the conditions for using laboratories and libraries. The university can pay people to do things, and can charge students; neither side treats persons as goods.

Second: a degree records what he himself did; payment cannot buy this record, nor the judgment "has passed." Paper 5 already said that a degree has to state what work was verified, and on what materials and by what standards what evaluation was made (DX26); Political Economy says: "a record must have a clear scope and a reviewable provenance" (Political Economy E22). Money can buy the conditions for attending classes and being assessed; it cannot replace the work that is recorded, nor the grounds on which the judgment of passing is made. Having paid tuition, one can ask to be assessed seriously; one cannot on that account ask to be assessed as passing.

Third: the conclusions of research follow the evidence, and are not rewritten to suit the funder's needs. A commission can buy research work and its report; it cannot buy predetermined conclusions. A company pays a laboratory to test a material; what it buys is the measurement, the report, and the report's deadline; what the measurement turns out to be is not among the things it bought.

Fourth: being unable to pay and so unable to enter or to finish belongs to the side of chokepoints. When fees become a door one cannot get around on the way to continuing study or obtaining a degree, they are explained and questioned separately as a chokepoint; arrangements such as scholarships and grants are registered here. Political Economy says: "Chokepoint: the position others cannot get around." (Political Economy E7) When a degree becomes a door others cannot get around, it too is a chokepoint (Political Economy E31). Fees themselves are not a chokepoint; they become one where they are the door some people cannot get around. It does not follow that teaching has to be free; how the side of admission is designed belongs to a separate dedicated paper.

The case of the introduction falls between the second sentence and the fourth. A transcript records what a student has done; holding it back because he owes money turns this record into a door for collecting debts. Debts are handled separately, by the grounds and procedures of debt collection; making access to an existing academic record conditional on repayment is a further act, and its grounds have to be explained separately.

There is also a newer form of payment, the income share agreement for tuition. This paper has not obtained particular contract terms, and does not judge; this form by itself is not enough to conclude that the road has been sealed.

The strongest opponents come in two kinds. One says: a university is a business, and students are customers. The answer: courses, services and facilities can be priced, and the accounts can be stated; persons, the record of a degree and the conclusions of research are not within the price. The other says: holding back transcripts is one of the few effective means of collecting debts, and other methods cost more. The answer: the grounds and procedures of debt collection are explained separately; even if holding back records really does help collect debts, that effect alone cannot explain how the university may turn existing academic records into a door for collecting debts. The answer here is given by this series' own normative claims; the California case shows only that this line can be written into rules.

DX29 The price falls on what is done, not on the person. A person has no equivalent: persons themselves are not within the price. A degree records what he himself did; payment cannot buy this record, nor the judgment "has passed." The conclusions of research follow the evidence, and are not rewritten to suit the funder's needs; a commission can buy research work and its report, not predetermined conclusions. Being unable to pay and so unable to enter or to finish belongs to the side of chokepoints: when fees become a door one cannot get around on the way to continuing study or obtaining a degree, they are explained and questioned separately as a chokepoint; arrangements such as scholarships and grants are registered here. It does not follow that teaching has to be free.


§3 Money Carries Requirements, Not Direction

Donations often come with conditions. Take a gift for an endowed chair stating that it is for teaching and research in a certain field: that is a use; it can be stated, and it can be accepted. Take another, stating that who holds the chair needs the donor's consent, and that certain views may not be taught in class: that is no longer just a use.

The Theory of the Market says: "Funding may carry requirements; it does not thereby acquire the authority to decide a person's direction. Funding may expect output, and may attach agreements on use, action and governance that have a source." (Theory of the Market, SC10) Brought down to the university: money can carry requirements, expect output, and set agreements on use, action and governance; it does not thereby acquire the authority to decide the direction of people in the university, nor a standing that overrides questioning.

Three things have to be checked separately: agreements on use, the authority of academic decisions, and personal avowal. Use can be set by money; who is appointed, what is taught, and what research finds are set by academic positions; what a funded scholar himself avows, no one can set. The three are not all covered by one word, "non-interference": saying "the donor does not interfere with academic matters" does not say how far the agreement on use goes, whether the donor has a seat in selection, or who reviews the conditions.

Yale's Office of the Provost has a 2022 "Gift Acceptance and Review Policy." It states that gifts and conditions that interfere with the university's autonomous decisions are not accepted; the areas listed include admissions, appointment and promotion, the conduct of research, facilities, curriculum and financial aid. Nor does it accept gifts that "otherwise infringe a faculty member’s academic freedom in teaching, scholarship, research, or practice." Gifts above a specified amount are reviewed and approved by the provost or the provost's designee. This text is read only for the authority and procedure of accepting gifts: it does not say that every restriction on content is prohibited, and gifts with a stated use are still accepted.

Several practices are offered only as suggestions: a gift review policy that states which conditions are not accepted, such as interfering with appointment, curriculum, the conduct and conclusions of research, or infringing academic freedom; a position within the university that reviews the conditions and keeps a record. Three facts can be checked: whether gift agreements can be looked up; whether the funder has a seat or a veto in selection; where the position that reviews conditions sits.

DX30 Money carries requirements, not direction. Money can carry requirements: expecting output, and agreements on use, action and governance that have a source; it does not thereby acquire the authority to decide the direction of people in the university, nor a standing that overrides questioning. Agreements on use, the authority of academic decisions and personal avowal are checked separately, and the one word "non-interference" is not used to cover all three.


§4 The Athlete Sits in Two Positions

An athlete is a student, and also in the position of competing. Competition can be priced: tickets, broadcasting, sponsorship, and the accounts can be stated. Paper 2 said that several positions are registered separately (DX9). Brought down to athletes: the two positions are registered separately; requirements in the position of competing are not used, beyond their authority, to decide requirements and consequences in the academic position.

Money earned by sports does not entitle the university to remove the actual conditions for athletes to complete their studies as students. The requirements of study, training, competition and employment are explained separately; where they conflict, there is a usable way of handling it and of questioning.

Among the "core guarantees" of NCAA Division I is one item: for students who received athletics aid at the school in their first year and remain eligible to compete, "the scholarship cannot be reduced, canceled or not renewed for athletics-related reasons," reasons that include injury, mental health, athletic performance, contribution to the team and roster changes. Reducing, canceling or not renewing aid requires "written notice and an opportunity to appeal." This item puts some distance between the conditions of study and current athletic contribution. It has conditions of application, and is not generalized into a guarantee for all aid.

Three facts can be checked: whether aid can be withdrawn because of injury or athletic performance; whether training hours have a cap, and who checks it; how conflicts between classes and competition are handled, and who decides.

Whether athletes are employees is under litigation. This paper does not judge it, and takes only the structure: whatever the ruling, the two positions have to be registered separately.

DX31 The athlete sits in two positions. An athlete is a student, and also in the position of competing, and the two positions are registered separately; competition can be priced, and the accounts can be stated; requirements in the position of competing are not used, beyond their authority, to decide requirements and consequences in the academic position. Revenue from sports does not entitle the university to remove the actual conditions for athletes to complete their studies as students; the requirements of study, training, competition and employment are explained separately, and conflicts have a usable way of handling and of questioning.


§5 An Entrance That Does Not Demand Conversion

The gates where resources are divided, funding, places, leave and review, mostly ask for an account: is this proposal worth it? The Second Enlightenment says that answering truthfully at the gate whether something is worth it is not translation; having answered, one carries the use, deliverables and deadlines actually promised in the application (The Second Enlightenment, Paper 5, §1). This paper does not change that.

What it asks is something else. The Second Enlightenment, Paper 6, says: "a gate where resources are divided can leave an entrance that does not demand conversion. Whether to leave one, how large, and how to keep it from becoming another door, belong to dedicated papers on the institutional side." The university is one kind on the institutional side. This paper's answer: at least one ought to be left.

The step from "can" to "ought" is this series' own undertaking. The reason: if practicing judgment and exploring have first to prove themselves by known outputs, the university's accountability for giving conditions is exhausted by predetermined metrics. This reason supports leaving at least one, not leaving them everywhere. It points the same way as Paper 5's proposition (DX23) but differs from it: that one holds everywhere, saying that metrics do not replace judgment; this one asks for only one place, and there does not even take conversion as a precondition.

What the entrance is: the proposing and the consideration of study and research do not have, as a necessary precondition, first being converted into a predetermined return or a uniform output metric; the entrance accepts reasons that can be stated but not measured.

Once one is left, how it is kept from becoming another door has to be written down. At least these are checked. Not letting "this is mine" become the new only thing, nor turn into "you may not ask me": The Second Enlightenment says that breaking the unanimity of "it is worth it" is done "without letting 'this is mine' become the new only thing" (The Second Enlightenment, W35); whether it is worth it can still be asked, "only it is not made a threshold, nor does it turn into 'you may not ask me.'" (The Second Enlightenment, W36) Applicants' looking back on "is this really my own" is not set up as a checkpoint to pass before being let through: The Second Enlightenment says, "Looking back is something one can do, not a checkpoint to pass before being let through." (The Second Enlightenment, Paper 6, §5); this sentence does not cancel the reasons, conditions and trade-offs of allocating resources. It is not a matter of accepting the file in form and then still excluding it merely for lacking the same predetermined return or uniform metric. "Not demanding conversion" is not turned into a certification that the applicant "truly loves the work" or "has no thought of gain."

An entrance does not mean resources are surely obtained. How resources are divided still has its reasons stated; the use and deliverables actually promised in the application are carried. Where, and how large, are handed to the rule layer.

The Volkswagen Foundation's "Experiment!" made such an entrance. It funded bold, risky research ideas; "A short sketch is sufficient as an application"; an interdisciplinary jury looked only at anonymized sketches; "A concept failure as well as unexpected findings are an acceptable result." From 2017, the jury chose the most convincing batch, and a batch of similar size was drawn by lot from the eligible sketches. Both faces are there. An entrance that does not first demand proof of known outputs really has an example; before the lottery there was still the foundation's internal preselection and anonymous review, and only part of the funding no longer depended on the jury's ranking. It was set up at a foundation, not at a university's own gate, and the program has ended. It proves only that the form of such an entrance can be made; its actual effects are checked separately.

The strongest opponent will say: an entrance that does not demand conversion wastes resources. The answer: it asks for at least one, not for one everywhere; an entrance does not mean resources are surely obtained, reasons are still stated, and the use is still carried.

DX32 An entrance that does not demand conversion. Among the gates where the university divides resources (funding, places, leave, review), at least one ought to leave an entrance that does not demand conversion: the proposing and the consideration of study and research do not have, as a necessary precondition, first being converted into a predetermined return or a uniform output metric; the entrance accepts reasons that can be stated but not measured. Once one is left, how it is kept from becoming another door is written down: not letting "this is mine" become the new only thing, nor turn into "you may not ask me"; applicants' looking back on "is this really my own" is not set up as a checkpoint to pass before being let through; it is not a matter of accepting the file in form and then still excluding it merely for lacking the same predetermined return or uniform metric; "not demanding conversion" is not turned into a certification that the applicant "truly loves the work" or "has no thought of gain." An entrance does not mean resources are surely obtained: how resources are divided still has its reasons stated, and the use and deliverables actually promised in the application are carried; answering truthfully at the gate whether something is worth it goes on as usual. Where, and how large, are handed to the rule layer.


§6 The Money for the Advising System

Paper 1 said that every student has an advisor of his own (DX3), and its last sentence was: the university provides time and resources that make the advisory accountability actually possible to carry out; it does not let nominal pairing stand in for advising that can be used, and does not leave the work needed to unlimited bearing by those who take it on. The normative claim of that sentence is in Paper 1; this section says only how it lands on the side of funding, and states no proposition of its own.

Suppose thirty students are listed under one professor, and a student cannot find a usable stretch of advising time all term: the pairing is nominal. The university keeps handing students to him without leaving time for advising, and without saying what the upper limit of the burden is or who takes over the shortfall, asking only that he keep squeezing out time: here the university turns conditions it has not arranged into a burden the advisor has to absorb on his own. The Prequel of Cultivation Theory says of cultivation: "It is not unlimited burden." What is blocked here is the university's treating the one who gives as something that can also be used up.

In Paper 1 there was an objection: one advisor for every student costs too much. This paper does not rest its case on "winning": it does not say the advising system is more cost-effective, nor that, because it is expensive, it ought not to exist. What it says is: since it is to exist, put the money and the time into the accounts; where they cannot be put in, say so.

In Paper 2's constructed case, the doctoral student changes advisors, and the way out is not controlled by the original advisor alone (DX11); money for the transition that does not depend on the original advisor is that proposition's suggestion. This sum, too, is counted here: it does not come from the original advisor's funds; from which level it comes, its term and its limits are explained by the position that bears the arrangement of transitional resources.


§7 When It Can No Longer Be Sustained

Hampshire College's page on its closure (last updated 4 November 2026) says that the board of trustees voted to close the college permanently after the fall 2026 semester. The reasons the page gives are that efforts to increase enrollment and to refinance existing debt did not reach their goals, and that selling land would not change the long-term financial outlook; "The College no longer has the resources to sustain full operations." The arrangement under this decision is to let enrolled students complete their undergraduate studies "either here or at a partner institution."

There was an interval in between. In early June 2026 the college said that the money available was not enough to pay the expected costs of continuing for that semester; a few days later it said it had reached an agreement in principle with a donor on a loan that would let the continuation for remaining students go on until 31 December 2026.2

This case reads only the structure of ending and continuation; it does not infer the causes of the closure, nor prove that every student has continued smoothly.

The normative claim is here. When a university can no longer be sustained, the arrangements for ending first secure that those enrolled can finish their studies; if even this cannot be secured, they are given the conditions to go on studying at another university. The Theory of the Market says "that the supply must continue does not by itself imply that the original company must exist forever" (Theory of the Market, SC11). Extended to the university: what has to continue is the studies of those enrolled, not this university itself.

The judgment "the conditions of study at this university can no longer be secured" has its grounds, objects and costs explained by the position that makes the decision, and can be questioned independently. The arrangements for continuation are checked by the conditions actually available: transfer of credit, continuation of courses, access to materials, changes in cost, actual acceptance; students keep their choice. The preservation of grade and degree records, and the arrangements for professors and staff, are explained separately. "First secure that they can finish" is not read as guaranteeing that every student passes academic requirements not yet completed.

Suggestion: arrangements for ending are prepared before anything goes wrong. The Higher Learning Commission's policy on teach-out arrangements (revised February 2025) is one way of writing it at the level of accreditation. Where a teach-out plan is required, the plan has to ensure that students are "able to complete, within a reasonable period of time," the program they are in; a teach-out agreement has to give students "reasonable opportunities to complete their program of study," and state the tuition and additional charges of the receiving institution; when an institution closes without an approved plan or agreement, the Commission, "to the extent feasible," works with other bodies to help students "complete their education without additional charges." The statement of charges in a teach-out agreement and the assistance when an institution closes without a plan have to be read apart: this text does not guarantee that every student can graduate without paying additional charges. How these provisions are carried out, this paper has not checked.

DX33 When it can no longer be sustained. When a university can no longer be sustained, the arrangements for ending first secure that those enrolled can finish their studies; if even this cannot be secured, they are given the conditions to go on studying at another university. The judgment "the conditions of study at this university can no longer be secured" has its grounds, objects and costs explained by the position that makes the decision, and can be questioned independently. The arrangements for continuation are checked by the conditions actually available (transfer of credit, continuation of courses, access to materials, changes in cost, actual acceptance), and students keep their choice; the preservation of grade and degree records, and the arrangements for professors and staff, are explained separately. "First secure that they can finish" is not read as guaranteeing that every student passes academic requirements not yet completed.


Where This Paper Stops

What it has not done: it has not said what level of tuition is reasonable; it has not written about the taxation of donations; it has not written about the amounts and conditions of government research funding; it has not written about the design of athletic conference rules; it has not judged whether athletes are employees; it has not written about the causes of closure; it has not judged whether the trade-offs of the California law are right.


Notes

  1. The default meant by Section 66022 is failure to make installment payments when due, more than 180 days late for monthly installments or more than 240 days for longer intervals, or failure to comply with other terms of the promissory note, such that the guarantee agency reasonably concludes the borrower no longer intends to repay; services may continue to be provided where the facts are in dispute, where the student shows reasonable progress in repayment, or where there is reasonable cause for the delay; for the University of California and similar bodies, it applies only once their governing board adopts a resolution. The text follows the transcription on a statutes website; the official text of the state legislature governs. ↩︎
  2. According to a Higher Ed Dive report of 9 June 2026. Whether the loan was later finalized, and whether the continuation went ahead as planned, this paper has not checked. ↩︎

The Five Propositions of This Paper

  • DX29 The price falls on what is done, not on the person. A person has no equivalent: persons themselves are not within the price. A degree records what he himself did; payment cannot buy this record, nor the judgment "has passed." The conclusions of research follow the evidence, and are not rewritten to suit the funder's needs; a commission can buy research work and its report, not predetermined conclusions. Being unable to pay and so unable to enter or to finish belongs to the side of chokepoints: when fees become a door one cannot get around on the way to continuing study or obtaining a degree, they are explained and questioned separately as a chokepoint; arrangements such as scholarships and grants are registered here. It does not follow that teaching has to be free. (Normative, the four sentences each with their own grounds: the first takes over the main line of the Theory of the Company, both paying and charging being read by it; the second takes over DX26 and Political Economy E22; the third is this series' own undertaking; the fourth takes over Political Economy E7 and E31, with the side of admission belonging to a dedicated paper)
  • DX30 Money carries requirements, not direction. Money can carry requirements: expecting output, and agreements on use, action and governance that have a source; it does not thereby acquire the authority to decide the direction of people in the university, nor a standing that overrides questioning. Agreements on use, the authority of academic decisions and personal avowal are checked separately, and the one word "non-interference" is not used to cover all three. (Normative; taking over Theory of the Market SC10)
  • DX31 The athlete sits in two positions. An athlete is a student, and also in the position of competing, and the two positions are registered separately; competition can be priced, and the accounts can be stated; requirements in the position of competing are not used, beyond their authority, to decide requirements and consequences in the academic position. Revenue from sports does not entitle the university to remove the actual conditions for athletes to complete their studies as students; the requirements of study, training, competition and employment are explained separately, and conflicts have a usable way of handling and of questioning. (Normative; extending DX9 and DX29, this series' own undertaking)
  • DX32 An entrance that does not demand conversion. Among the gates where the university divides resources, at least one ought to leave an entrance that does not demand conversion: the proposing and the consideration of study and research do not have, as a necessary precondition, first being converted into a predetermined return or a uniform output metric; the entrance accepts reasons that can be stated but not measured. Once one is left, how it is kept from becoming another door is written down. An entrance does not mean resources are surely obtained; answering truthfully at the gate whether something is worth it goes on as usual. Where, and how large, are handed to the rule layer. (Normative; answering The Second Enlightenment, Paper 5, §8, and Paper 6, §6, for the university's kind of gate only; the original sentence says "can," and the step from can to ought is this series' own undertaking, the reason supporting at least one place, not every place; pointing the same way as DX23 but differing from it; the four checks take over The Second Enlightenment W35, W36 and Paper 6, §5)
  • DX33 When it can no longer be sustained. When a university can no longer be sustained, the arrangements for ending first secure that those enrolled can finish their studies; if even this cannot be secured, they are given the conditions to go on studying at another university. The judgment "the conditions of study at this university can no longer be secured" has its grounds, objects and costs explained by the position that makes the decision, and can be questioned independently. The arrangements for continuation are checked by the conditions actually available, and students keep their choice; the preservation of grade and degree records, and the arrangements for professors and staff, are explained separately. "First secure that they can finish" is not read as guaranteeing that every student passes academic requirements not yet completed. (Normative; extending Theory of the Market SC11, which speaks of basic supply, to the studies of those enrolled, this series' own undertaking)

References

All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version.

I · This system

  • Qin, H. (2026). University Teaching (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293737
  • Qin, H. (2026). University Students (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293740
  • Qin, H. (2026). University Research (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293742
  • Qin, H. (2026). University Evaluation (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293751
  • Qin, H. (2026). What a Company Is Not (SAE Theory of the Company, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24045716
  • Qin, H. (2026). What an Economy Is Not (SAE Political Economy, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874133
  • Qin, H. (2026). Chokepoints (SAE Political Economy, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874140
  • Qin, H. (2026). Conversion (SAE Political Economy, Paper 4) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874146
  • Qin, H. (2026). Growth (SAE Political Economy, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874150
  • Qin, H. (2026). The Market: Funding (SAE Theory of the Market, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24183378
  • Qin, H. (2026). Calling It Worth It (SAE The Second Enlightenment, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24030411
  • Qin, H. (2026). No Longer Asking for Proof of Worth First (SAE The Second Enlightenment, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24030413
  • Qin, H. (2026). What Cultivation Is Not (SAE Cultivation Theory, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154492

II · Rule texts and institutional documents (original language)

  • California Assembly Bill 1313 (2019), Chapter 518, Statutes of 2019. Chaptered text via LegiScan. https://legiscan.com/CA/text/AB1313/2019
  • California Education Code § 66022. Transcription via california.public.law. https://california.public.law/codes/education_code_section_66022
  • Yale University, Office of the Provost. "Gift Acceptance and Review Policy." 2022. https://provost.yale.edu/node/3594
  • NCAA. "Student-Athlete Core Guarantees." https://www.ncaa.org/student-athletes/student-athlete-experience/core-guarantees/
  • VolkswagenStiftung. "Experiment! In search of bold research ideas (completed)." https://www.volkswagenstiftung.de/en/funding/funding-offer/experiment-search-bold-research-ideas-completed
  • Hampshire College. "Closure Information." Updated 2026-11-04. https://hampshire.edu/closure-information
  • Higher Learning Commission. "Teach-Out Arrangements" (FDCR.B.10.010). Revised February 2025. https://www.hlcommission.org/accreditation/policies/teach-out-arrangements/

III · External literature

  • Schwartz, N. (2026, June 9). Hampshire College secures loan agreement to hold final fall semester. Higher Ed Dive. https://www.highereddive.com/news/hampshire-college-secures-loan-agreement-hold-final-fall-semester/822436/

Interfaces

This series: DX29 to DX33.

Handed to Paper 7: who sets these rules: who sets fees, who reviews the conditions of gifts, who judges "cannot be secured," who arranges and continues advising relationships.