Self-as-an-End
SAE Teacher-Student Theory · Paper 7

Handing Over
交出

Han Qin (秦汉) · Independent Researcher · 2026
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24267253 · Full PDF on Zenodo · CC BY 4.0
Abstract

This is the last paper of Teacher-Student Theory. Being able to check, the direction's coming to stand, and the ending of the relation are three things; they can coincide, and they can come apart; this paper concludes by treating the three separately. The series reads up to the student's coming of age: read as in Parent-Child Theory, by the person's domains, arriving domain by domain; domains are drawn by the matters of avowal, not by the subjects taught. Being able to check is not this boundary. On the side that has come of age, what follows is read as giving and dealings between adults, and the same teacher may still teach him. Graduation, completing an apprenticeship, and coming of age in law are acknowledged but not judged. This is the boundary of how far this series reads; it does not say that teacher-student relations in reality stop here.

The test lies on the student's side: he is able to unfold without revolving around this one teacher. This is a test; it is not that he must in fact leave, nor that from now on he needs no one; what this test looks at is whether the teacher has occupied the student's own constitutive position, and it is not used to certify that the student's cannot-not has come to stand, nor to settle the account of the teacher's teaching. The student's thanks, his achievement, his staying are not entered as repayment for the teaching; the teacher does not, for having taught, hold a share in the student's direction; tuition fees and credit for the teacher's contribution are reckoned separately; one may remember, and one may be glad for him.

Where the relation ends before the student comes of age: exit does not settle the accounts, nor pass final judgment on this person; what the teacher had meant to finish teaching does not on that account become a shared matter that remains after he has gone; what has been taught stays in the student's hands, for him to use as it is, to change, or to put down. What lies between these two people from then on is read by Relation Theory, Cooperation Theory and Cultivation Theory. This paper interfaces with a passage of Nietzsche's Thus Spoke Zarathustra and with the saying "a teacher for a day, a father for life." It does not prove that there ought to be an end point between teacher and student, nor that students ought to be grateful, nor that students ought to leave, nor that a teacher whose students come to stand is a good teacher.

Introduction

Lu Miao got into a school where she could study drawing. In mathematics she still sometimes came to ask Fang Xu about a problem; whether a proof was right she could check for herself.

A year later Fang Xu was to move to another city. Before he left, Lu Miao said: "Uncle Fang, thank you for teaching me all these years." Fang Xu said: "These years, I've been glad to teach."

This is the one line the example follows, and by stipulation it falls in the third case of the table below: Fang Xu moves away only after she has come to stand in the matter of "what to study, and where to go." For the same Lu Miao, several other cases can be supposed:

Case Reading
She can already check a proof; where she herself is going has not yet taken shape Being able to check does not by itself certify coming of age; read as before
She has come to stand in the matter of "what to study, and where to go," and the road she is taking is mathematics; there are still proofs she cannot do and has to learn The boundary is reached; on this side Fang Xu still teaches her from then on, read as between adults
She has come to stand in the same matter, and the road she is taking is drawing; mathematics stops, or she goes on with it The boundary is reached; it is not read as ending before coming of age because what she chose is not mathematics; where she goes on with it, this side is read as between adults
She has not yet come to stand in this matter, Fang Xu moves away, and teaching and learning stop first Ending early, read as in §4

In all four, what Fang Xu's end does is the same: not occupying her direction.

For the fourth case a separate line is set, and §4 uses it: suppose that in the year when Lu Miao was still saying "what I'd really rather do is draw," Fang Xu had already moved away. Before leaving he took a few books across the landing: "I didn't get to these chapters. Read them if they're of use; if not, leave them."

These have to be read apart. She can check a proof: has this relation thereby been read to its end? The road she is taking is not mathematics: did this relation fail to teach her? "Thank you for teaching me all these years": what is it here? The sentence Fang Xu said in reply: whose side does it speak of? On the line that was supposed, are the chapters not got to something she owes? And once Fang Xu has moved away, by whom is what lies between these two people read?

What this paper reads. The first six papers began from how this relation comes to be, and read teaching, checking, expectation, space and collision. This paper reads the last stretch.

This paper reads five things. First, the boundary of coming of age, and how it is kept apart from being able to check and from the ending of the relation. Second, the test that lies on the student's side. Third, that what was taught is not entered as repayment. Fourth, ending early. Fifth, by whom what lies between these two people is read from then on.

Shared words. "Coming of age" follows Parent-Child Theory: the student's own cannot-not has taken shape, arriving domain by domain.1 "Domain" is drawn here by the matters of avowal: what to study, where to go. "Handing over" occurs in two places in this paper: in judging right and wrong, the teacher withdraws from the part he had been exercising on the student's behalf (set up in Paper 3, drawn together here); in direction, the teacher does not occupy the student's share. The position of asking and refusing is not within "handing over"; it was the student's all along.2 "Cannot-not" is as in Papers 5 and 6.

Method. As in the earlier papers. This paper does not write how Lu Miao's drawing later turned out.

§1 The Boundary of Coming of Age

TS34 This series reads up to the student's coming of age: read as in Parent-Child Theory, by the person's domains, arriving domain by domain. Domains are drawn by the matters of avowal, not by the subjects taught, and a further domain is not drawn because he meets a problem he cannot yet do; a matter can be identified before the student's own direction in it has come to stand. Being able to check is not this boundary (TS16, TS18). If the relation ends before the student has come of age in the matters of avowal that bear on it, it is read by TS37; a relation is not kept on the near side of coming of age merely because what was taught has not become the student's own cannot-not. On the side that has come of age, what follows is read as giving and dealings between adults, and the same teacher may still teach him. Graduation, completing an apprenticeship, and coming of age in law are acknowledged but not judged. This is the boundary of how far this series reads; it does not say that teacher-student relations in reality stop here

Three things, kept apart

Three things are entered separately in this series.

Being able to check: in this matter, she can already look up and test for herself. This was read in Paper 3: that position becomes her own at once, and what the teacher withdraws from is the part he had been exercising on her behalf.

The direction's coming to stand: her own cannot-not has taken shape. This is coming of age.

The ending of the relation: teaching and learning have stopped.

The three can coincide: a student can check, her direction has come to stand, and at this point the teacher leaves. They can also come apart: in the table in the Introduction, all four cases are cases of their coming apart.

There is only one boundary

This series reads up to the student's coming of age. Coming of age is read structurally as his own cannot-not having taken shape; it arrives domain by domain, not all on one day.1

This boundary is read by the person's domains. Domains are drawn by the matters of avowal: what to study, where to go. They are not drawn by the subjects taught: the question is not "has she come of age in the subject of mathematics?" The teacher-student relation is determined by the matter (Paper 1), and the matter is the thing taught; coming of age speaks of the cannot-not, of where she herself is going. In the thing taught she may never have a cannot-not at all: Lu Miao studied mathematics all these years, and what she cannot put down is drawing. If domains were drawn by subject, this relation would have to be kept forever on the near side of coming of age; this series does not read it so. Nor is a further domain drawn because she meets a problem she cannot yet do: that there are still proofs she cannot do after she has come to stand does not send her back in this matter.

A matter can be identified before the student's own direction in it has come to stand: the matter of "where she is going" could be pointed to when she said "what I'd really rather do is draw"; one need not wait until the cannot-not has taken shape and then draw the domain backward.

Being able to check is not the boundary

Being able to check is not this boundary. That Lu Miao can check a proof speaks of the position of judging right and wrong in one matter; it becomes her own at once, and does not wait for coming of age (Paper 3). Conversely, that she can check does not certify that her direction has come to stand. The first case of the table: read as before.

Handing over, in two places

"Handing over" occurs in two places in this series, and the two are drawn together separately.

In judging right and wrong: where, in a matter, she can already look up and test for herself, the position of raising, refusing and revising in that matter becomes her own at once; what the teacher withdraws from is the part he had been exercising on her behalf (Paper 3). This arrives one matter at a time, and does not wait for coming of age: in multiplication it arrived long ago, in proof only later. "Whether a proof was right she could check for herself," in the Introduction, is this place. After withdrawing, Fang Xu can still say "this step looks wrong to me": that is his judgment, to be tested, and is not judging for her.

In direction: where she is going is her own affair. "Handing over" here means that the teacher does not occupy that share (Paper 5; §3 of this paper); if he had earlier decided it for her, he draws back.

The position of asking and refusing is not within "handing over"; it was the student's all along.2

After the boundary is reached

On the side that has come of age, what follows is read as giving and dealings between adults. The same teacher may still teach her: in the second case of the table, the road Lu Miao is taking is mathematics, and Fang Xu goes on teaching her the proofs she cannot do; the teaching from then on is one adult teaching another.

Reaching the boundary does not look at what she chose. The third case of the table: she has come to stand, and the road she is taking is drawing. This is not read as "ended before coming of age," nor as this relation's having failed to teach her; "chose drawing" does not automatically certify anything, and what the example has to make clear is whether her position has come to stand in the same matter of avowal.

Acknowledged but not judged; how far the series reads

Graduation, completing an apprenticeship, and coming of age in law are titles and provisions, acknowledged but not judged. This series does not use them as the boundary.

This boundary is the boundary of how far this series reads; it does not say that teacher-student relations in reality stop here. Lu Miao still calls Fang Xu "Uncle Fang" afterward, and still comes with questions: all of this is there; it is only not read in this series.

§2 The Test Lies on the Student's Side

TS35 The test lies on the student's side: he is able to unfold without revolving around this one teacher. This is a test; it is not that he must in fact leave, nor that from now on he needs no one. What this test looks at is whether the teacher has occupied the student's own constitutive position; "no longer revolving around the teacher" is not used to certify that his cannot-not has come to stand, nor to settle the account of the teacher's teaching

Able to unfold without revolving around this one teacher

Upstream, at the layer of meaning, sets up a test: that the other is able to unfold without revolving around me.3 Between teacher and student the test lies on the student's side: she is able to unfold without revolving around this one teacher.

The words "is able to" have to be read exactly. The test is not that she must in fact leave.3 Upstream gives students as its example: that one student took a road the teacher did not approve is one shape; that another student walks the teacher's road all his life is another; both can pass this test.4 Lu Miao took the road of drawing and can pass this test; in the second case of the table she takes mathematics, still on the road Fang Xu taught, and can pass it too. Nor does it say that from now on she needs no one.5

What the test looks at

What this test looks at is whether the teacher has occupied the student's own constitutive position. Upstream gives the shape of failing it: after the student has changed direction, the teacher controls the channels by which he pursues his studies, and requires him to pass off the direction the teacher approves as his own.6 Treating the student's disagreement as "you are wrong to think so, so it does not count," and making acceptance of the teacher's final verdict the condition of going on recognizing her, are where it fails.

It is a negative boundary, not a certification. Not occupying is not the same as supporting: a teacher who never asks after his student is not occupying the student's position, and is not thereby supporting him.7

So there are two things it is not used for. "She no longer revolves around the teacher" is not used to certify that her cannot-not has come to stand: she may simply have changed whom she revolves around. Nor is it used to settle the account of the teacher's teaching: that she is able not to revolve around Fang Xu is not an achievement of Fang Xu's. Upstream has written elsewhere that when a relation of cultivation succeeds, the student no longer needs the teacher;8 the layer of meaning, in citing it, writes that it is taken only as a precedent in the same direction and not as a ground, and it is likewise only registered here.

§3 Not Entered as Repayment

TS36 The student's thanks, his achievement, his staying are not entered as repayment for the teaching, and are not used to settle accounts; the teacher does not, for having taught, hold a share in the student's direction. This proposition settles only to whom the student's direction belongs; tuition fees and credit for the teacher's contribution are reckoned separately. One may remember, and one may be glad for him

Not entered as repayment

"Thank you for teaching me all these years." This is Lu Miao's thanks. It is not entered as repayment for the teaching, and is not used to settle accounts: the account is not settled in thanks, obedience or joining.9 Her thanking him does not make Fang Xu gain anything more; had she not said it, what Fang Xu taught would be no less. The same holds for achievement and staying: what she later becomes, and whether she stays near Fang Xu, are not things given back to Fang Xu.

No share

The teacher does not, for having taught, hold a share in her direction. Giving thickly does not give the giver an authorization to decide the recipient's direction.10 The sentence in Paper 6, "I've taught you all these years, and this is how you repay me," uses what was taught to claim a share in her direction; that share does not exist.

Upstream writes at the layer of action: what a person gains from others, once avowed by his own law, is his; those who provided the conditions do not thereby become the ones who completed that step for him.11 Avowal lies at Lu Miao's end: which of the things taught she has avowed is settled at her end, and is not announced by Fang Xu.

The sentence Fang Xu said in reply

Lu Miao says thank you, and Fang Xu says: "These years, I've been glad to teach." This sentence speaks of his own side: he has been glad. It does not say what Lu Miao gained from him, nor what these years are to her. Upstream, at the point of exit, tells two things apart: stating the plans and reasons on one's own side is informing, and the other can still think for himself; deciding for the other what it is that he gained from oneself slides in the direction of colonization.12

Suppose Fang Xu replies with another sentence: "What I've taught you is yours now." This sentence has two faces. One is the teacher's end letting go: I keep no share in this. On the other, it speaks of Lu Miao's side: whether what was taught is "hers," for her, is a matter of her own avowal; said by Fang Xu, it says for her what it is that she gained from him. The upstream example is "you only know how to cook because of me," which enters it on one's own side; this sentence pushes it over to the other's side, in the opposite direction, and in deciding for the other the two are alike. By that upstream cut, this face heads toward deciding it for her.

Sliding is a direction, not an accomplished fact. What this sentence actually left with Lu Miao is seen in her later understanding and action. Suppose Lu Miao says "some of it I put down long ago": that is the response she herself gives; whether this has anywhere to land with Fang Xu is read separately, in the act of his that comes next.

Tuition and credit are reckoned separately

This proposition settles one account only: to whom her direction belongs. Tuition and credit are reckoned separately.11 Fang Xu never took a fee; a teacher who takes fees takes them as before, and that is another book. Fang Xu taught Lu Miao how to write a proof: this is a fact, and is entered as it is (Paper 6); if someone asks, saying "Fang Xu taught her that" is a matter for the book of credit.

One may remember, one may be glad

This proposition does not require the teacher to forget, nor to be unmoved. One may remember; one may be glad for her. Upstream says it plainly: this does not forbid being glad for him, and does not deny actual causal effect; it refuses one sentence only: that because I provided conditions, the step by which he became himself was completed by me on his behalf.13

§4 Ending Early

TS37 Where the relation ends before the student comes of age: the teacher leaves, the student leaves, the teacher is changed. Exit does not settle the accounts, nor pass final judgment on this person; leaving the shared matters between the two room for natural development when one exits points in the direction of cultivation. What the teacher had meant to finish teaching does not on that account become a shared matter that remains after he has gone; what has been taught stays in the student's hands, for him to use as it is, to change, or to put down. Who arranged the change is acknowledged but not judged

Not an anomaly

The relation ends before the student comes of age: the teacher leaves, the student leaves, the teacher is changed. This series reads it as one of the shapes the teacher-student relation has in any case, not as an anomaly, and not as a failure to teach. The fourth case of the table, the line separately set in the Introduction: Lu Miao is still saying "what I'd really rather do is draw," and Fang Xu moves away. This case is read by this section.

Who arranged the change, whether the family moved, the school assigned students to new classes, or the teacher was transferred, is acknowledged but not judged.

Not settled, no final judgment

Ending does not presuppose that every relation ought to endure. Unilateral exit does not settle the accounts; a relation may be terminated, but one cannot on that account pass final judgment on this person.14 On the line that was supposed, Fang Xu moves away, and the effects left by these years of dealings are not struck out at a stroke because he has gone; nor does he, on leaving, give Lu Miao a summing-up: "In the end, child, you are not one for mathematics." That would be final judgment.

The chapters not got to

Leaving the shared matters between the two room for natural development when one exits points in the direction of cultivation.15 What "shared matters" are has to be made clear here. Upstream, at this point, cites a sentence of the Conflict Treatise: where shared resources, third-party responsibility or procedural obligation remain, leaving does not close them out.16 On the material at hand, those chapters are none of these three: no shared resource is left hanging, no third person is waiting, and no procedure has been left halfway. What the teacher had meant to finish teaching does not on that account become a shared matter that remains after he has gone; the chapters not got to do not become something Lu Miao owes.

The teacher's end is seen separately. Suppose Fang Xu had promised Lu Miao, or promised her mother, to finish these chapters: that is an item he took on, and his moving away does not settle it. How it is discharged is a matter at his end, and it still does not turn into something Lu Miao owes.

How the books left behind are read, upstream also has a cut for: fixing what follows for the other, as something he must carry out and cannot change himself, heads toward deciding for the other; if what the handover leaves are conditions the other can still use as they are, revise or set aside, it does not point that way.16 "Read them if they're of use; if not, leave them": the books were left, and no requirement was left. Suppose another way of leaving them: "Read one of these chapters each week, and I'll test you when I come back in the winter holiday." What is left is an arrangement she cannot change herself. On which side a handover falls is judged in the circumstances of the time, and no rule is given here.

What has been taught stays in the student's hands, for her to use as it is, to change, or to put down.

§5 From Then On

TS38 What lies between these two people from then on is read by Relation Theory, Cooperation Theory and Cultivation Theory. The face of how the teacher himself lives, as seen by the student, is handed to the series on how cultivation is passed on; the stretch in the university, on its side as a construct, is handed to the Theory of the University

On the side that has come of age, what lies between these two people from then on is read as dealings between adults: dealings, by Relation Theory; doing something together, by Cooperation Theory; one giving conditions to the other, by Cultivation Theory. This series reads no further.

In the case of ending early, she has not yet reached the boundary: the ending is read by the preceding section; if teaching and learning occur again afterward, they are still read in this series.

Two things this series hands on. The face of how the teacher himself lives and how he treats people, as seen by the student, has been there all these years; how it is passed on, and how the one who was taught later goes on to teach others, is another subject. The stretch between teacher and student in the university, on its side as a construct, lies on the institutional side.

§6 Interfacing with the Tradition

Nietzsche: go away from me. At the end of Part One of Thus Spoke Zarathustra, Zarathustra says to his disciples: go away from me, and guard yourselves against me; one repays a teacher badly if one always remains only a pupil. The passage goes on to speak of belief: the disciples had not yet sought themselves when they found him; he bids them lose him and find themselves, and says that only when they have all denied him will he return to them, and that then they may become friends.17 Upstream has already read this passage;18 it is referred back to here, and only one comparison is added. Where the two reflect each other: not remaining forever in the position of a pupil is not, here, the teacher's loss. Where they part: the test in this series is "is able to," not "must leave"; actual staying, leaving and the road taken are read apart. One question is left: when "find yourselves" is said as a bidding, does this way of speaking in turn lay down for the other what independence is to look like? The form of a command does not by itself settle the direction of an act; the question is not answered here.

A saying: a teacher for a day, a father for life. This saying joins having taught for a day to a title that lasts a lifetime. Only structure is read here, and the tradition behind the saying is not assessed. It connects with §3 from the opposite side: having taught becomes, in this saying, a position that is never afterward dissolved; and the word "father" exchanges a relation between teacher and student that is determined by the matter for one that is not. This series reads in the opposite direction: what has been taught stays in the student's hands, and the teacher does not, for having taught, hold a share in the student's direction. Whether the student remembers this teacher, and whether he honors him, are matters at the student's end (Paper 1); if this saying comes from the student's mouth, it is his own acknowledgment; from the teacher's mouth, used to make a demand on the student, it is another matter.

Historical material: Camus on his primary-school teacher. After receiving the Nobel Prize, Camus wrote a letter to his primary-school teacher, Louis Germain, saying that without the hand the teacher had held out to the poor child he then was, without his teaching and his example, none of this would have happened.19 This is a grown student writing of the teacher of his childhood; only how he writes in this letter is read here. The student attributes all of this to the teacher. "Without you, none of this" is Camus's sentence, from the student's mouth, and is his own acknowledgment; this series does not enter it as an account. This connects with §3: thanks is not entered as repayment. It is not used here to certify which direction Germain was headed in.

A teacher's supplementary account of himself: Germain's letter of 1959. This item is not a student's looking back but a teacher speaking of himself; the standing of the material is different, and it is listed separately. In April 1959 Germain wrote Camus a long letter, first thanking him for a book he had sent, and saying that the gesture had given him a joy he could not express. Where the letter speaks of the secular school and of religious instruction, he looks back on how he taught: he believes that throughout his career he respected what is most sacred in the child, the right to seek his own truth; he did all he could not to show his own ideas, so as not to weigh on the young minds of his pupils. In the same letter he also advises Camus directly: he fears that Camus is overtaxing his strength.20 The not weighing spoken of in this passage has as its range the choice in matters of belief, not that the teacher does not say what he thinks in any matter at all. A teacher's saying how he taught is his own account; an account of oneself does not settle the student's side (Paper 1). It is only registered here.

Historical material: the death of Hamerton's teacher. Hamerton writes that he went back to Doncaster for his fourth half-year, and learned only on arriving that the headmaster, Mr. Cape (Paper 5), was gravely ill and past hope; the boys who had arrived were sent home, and not long afterward Cape died. He writes that he grieved for this teacher, though he had been caned by him many a time; and he writes that his three half-years there were not wasted.21 Only how the adult Hamerton writes is read here. A relation ended before the student came of age, and in his telling it is not a thing left undone; the cane and the grief he writes in one sentence. This connects with §4. As to the cane, this series does not on that basis judge that teacher, nor leave it out.

§7 Drawing Together, and Downstream

This paper sets up five propositions. Taken together they say: being able to check, the direction's coming to stand, and the ending of the relation are three things, entered separately. The series reads up to the student's coming of age; the boundary is read by the person's domains, and domains are drawn by the matters of avowal, not by the subjects taught; being able to check is not the boundary; the side that has come of age is read from then on as between adults; graduation and completing an apprenticeship, as titles, are acknowledged but not judged. The test lies on the student's side: he is able to unfold without revolving around this one teacher; this is not that he must leave; what the test looks at is whether the teacher has occupied his position; it is used neither to certify nor to settle accounts. The student's thanks, achievement and staying are not entered as repayment; the teacher does not, for having taught, hold a share in the student's direction; tuition fees and credit for the teacher's contribution are reckoned separately; one may remember, and one may be glad. "Handing over" occurs in two places: in judging right and wrong, the teacher withdraws from the part he had been exercising on the student's behalf, one matter at a time; in direction, the teacher does not occupy that share. What the teacher says on leaving about his own side decides nothing for the student; saying for the student what it is that he gained heads toward deciding it for him. Where the relation ends early, the accounts are not settled and no final judgment is passed; what the teacher did not finish teaching does not become something the student owes, and what was taught stays in the student's hands. On the side that has come of age, what lies between these two people from then on is handed to Relation Theory, Cooperation Theory and Cultivation Theory.

This paper does not prove that there ought to be an end point between teacher and student, nor that students ought to be grateful, nor that students ought to leave, nor that a teacher whose students come to stand is a good teacher, nor that the student's no longer revolving around the teacher is his having come to stand.

The seven papers together. A teacher headed in the 15DD direction teaches, in one matter after another, a student who has not yet come of age. Some of what is taught the student cannot check for the present, and he takes it in first: he remembers it, he learns to do it. Understanding and checking he has to walk himself: reflecting, asking, going back to look. The teacher's end leaves time and space for this step, neither creates obstacles to his checking nor goes on holding his path of checking shut; the ways of examining and testing are taught to him, and his questions can land. Where his own cannot-not grows, the teacher makes space, and does not decide his direction for him. The reading goes up to his coming of age.

Downstream. How cultivation is passed on between people, the face of the teacher that the student sees, and how the one who was taught later teaches others, are subjects for after this series. Schools and universities lie on the institutional side. The two people after coming of age are read by Relation Theory, Cooperation Theory and Cultivation Theory.

Acknowledgments

This paper is signed by Han Qin alone; the author decided every argument and choice and bears sole responsibility for the text. In drafting, the author used AI models from various developers as tools. The English edition is an independent rewrite of the Chinese text, not a translation; where the two differ, the Chinese governs.

Notes

  1. Parent-Child Theory Paper 7, PC38: "Coming of age is read structurally as the child's 14DD coming to stand: his own cannot-not has taken shape. It arrives domain by domain, not all on one day; coming of age in law is acknowledged but not judged". Carried to the student, it is the same boundary. ↩︎
  2. Parent-Child Theory Paper 7, PC39: "Where, in some matter, his negation-gate can already run of itself, the position of raising and refusing in that matter becomes his own at once, and no one may seal it; this is not further conditioned on his 14DD already having come to stand. Being able to raise something is not the same as having it come to stand". ↩︎
  3. Meaning Theory P3, Y26: "That the other is able to unfold without revolving around me is the hardest test in this row"; "the test is not that he must in fact leave me"; "Ability is limited to constitutive independence, not to real-world self-sufficiency". Parent-Child Theory Paper 7, PC40, places this test on the child's side; the shape is the same here. ↩︎
  4. Meaning Theory P3, the section under Y26: "That the student took a road the teacher did not approve is one shape; that another student walks the teacher's road all his life is another; both can pass this test; what would make either fail lies elsewhere." ↩︎
  5. Cultivation Theory Paper 3, HY17: "Autonomy need not end in 'no longer needing support': what matters is that he is no longer held by any single supporter, not that from now on he needs no one." ↩︎
  6. Meaning Theory P3, the section under Y26: "A teacher who, after his student changes direction, controls the student's channels of publication and study and demands that the student pass off the teacher's approved direction as his own — the student's constitutive position is still the student's, and the qualification layer is passed; the relation layer is not." ↩︎
  7. Meaning Theory P3, Y25 and its section: "A teacher who never asks after his student is not occupying the student's office of constitution, and is not thereby supporting him." ↩︎
  8. Power Theory P5, criterion C3, as cited in the section under Y26 of Meaning Theory P3: "when a cultivating relation succeeds, the one under power rises into a higher level, the positional difference dissolves, and the relation dissolves with it — the student no longer needs the teacher"; Meaning Theory lists it as a precedent in the same direction, "not as a ground". ↩︎
  9. Action Theory Paper 6, D31: "Not colonizing is not seeing another person as an unfinished version of oneself, not taking his coming to agree with oneself as the point of helping him, and not settling the account in thanks, obedience or joining." ↩︎
  10. Political Economy Paper 6, E36: "Giving thickly in the Emergence Layer does not give the giver an authorization to decide the recipient's direction either"; E37: "Support may have particular content; it does not acquire the authority to decide a person's direction." The original speaks of institutions toward persons; only its shape is borrowed here, as an extension, this series' own undertaking. Parent-Child Theory Paper 3, PC20, sets up a proposition of the same shape between parents and child. ↩︎
  11. Action Theory Paper 6, D36: "What a person gains from others, once avowed by his own law, is his; those who provided the conditions do not thereby become the ones who completed that step for him. This proposition settles only the attribution of constitution; credit and proceeds are reckoned separately." ↩︎
  12. Relation Theory Paper 6, the section under H57: "if Lao Shen says to Xiao Tang, 'You only know how to cook because of me,' he is deciding for Xiao Tang what it is that Xiao Tang gained from him, and that likewise slides in the direction of colonization"; stating the plans and reasons on one's own side "is informing". The original speaks of the time of exit; Fang Xu's moving away is exactly that. ↩︎
  13. Meaning Theory P3, the section under Y26: "This proposition does not forbid me to be glad for him, does not deny actual causal effect, and does not prejudge the authorship of joint work; it refuses one sentence only: that because I provided conditions, the step by which he became himself was completed by me on his behalf." ↩︎
  14. Relation Theory H55: "Ending does not presuppose that every relation ought to be repaired or to endure; unilateral exit does not settle the accounts; a relation may be terminated and a channel closed, but one cannot on that account pass final judgment on this person". ↩︎
  15. Relation Theory H58: "What continues after parting can be the conditions and effects that still exist; shared matters that remain after parting are not settled by unilateral exit; leaving the shared matters room for natural development when one exits points in the direction of cultivation; neither staying nor leaving certifies cultivation". ↩︎
  16. Relation Theory Paper 6, the section under H58, citing Conflict Treatise §12: "And where shared resources, third-party responsibility or procedural obligation remain, leaving does not close them out." The same section: "If what the handover leaves are conditions the other party can still use as they are, revise or set aside, it does not point that way." ↩︎
  17. Nietzsche, Also sprach Zarathustra, Part One, Von der schenkenden Tugend (On the Bestowing Virtue), §3. Retold here. ↩︎
  18. Cultivation Theory Paper 7, §3, reads this passage, as a comparison. ↩︎
  19. Camus to Germain, 19 November 1957. In the appendix to Camus, Le Premier Homme (Paris: Gallimard, 1994). Retold here. ↩︎
  20. Germain to Camus, 30 April 1959. In the appendix to the same book. The opening of the letter gives thanks for a book Camus had sent, the study of Camus inscribed by its author, J.-C. Brisville; the material cited does not establish that this letter is a reply to the letter of 1957. Retold here. ↩︎
  21. Hamerton, An Autobiography, 1834–1858, ch. IX. Retold from the Project Gutenberg electronic text (eBook No. 8536). ↩︎

References

All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version.

I · SAE works directly cited in this paper

Qin, H. (2026). The Place of Relation Theory (SAE Relation Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545115

Qin, H. (2026). Asymmetry, Divergence and Ending (SAE Relation Theory, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545087

Qin, H. (2026). How Far to Give (SAE Cultivation Theory, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154506

Qin, H. (2026). Writing for Many (SAE Cultivation Theory, Paper 7) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154522

Qin, H. (2026). The Place of Parent-Child Theory (SAE Parent-Child Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24121569

Qin, H. (2026). Support in the Parent-Child Relation (SAE Parent-Child Theory, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24121541

Qin, H. (2026). Handing Over and Leading (SAE Parent-Child Theory, Paper 7) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24121559

Qin, H. (2026). The Half That Is Not Mine to Settle (SAE Meaning Theory, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22731235

Qin, H. (2026). Not Legislating for Others (SAE Action Theory, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22970777

Qin, H. (2026). Support (SAE Political Economy, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874154

Qin, H. (2026). On the Development of Power · Shi (SAE Power Theory, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20582210

II · External works

Camus, A. (1994). Le Premier Homme. Paris: Gallimard.

Hamerton, P. G., & Hamerton, E. (1896). Philip Gilbert Hamerton: An Autobiography, 1834–1858, and a Memoir by His Wife, 1858–1894. (Project Gutenberg eBook No. 8536.)

Nietzsche, F. (1883). Also sprach Zarathustra. Part One.

Interfaces

Main upstream: Parent-Child Theory PC38, PC39, PC40; Meaning Theory P3 (Y25, Y26); Action Theory Paper 6 (D31, D36); Relation Theory H55, H58.

Also used: Cultivation Theory Paper 3 (HY17), Paper 7 (the passage on Nietzsche); Political Economy Paper 6 (E36, E37); Parent-Child Theory PC20; Power Theory P5 (criterion C3, as cited by Meaning Theory; only registered).

This series: takes up TS2 and TS6 from Paper 1; TS16 and TS18 from Paper 3; TS24 and TS27 from Paper 5; TS30 and TS33 from Paper 6. For the place of the whole series, its way of reading, its shared words and the full list of propositions, see Paper 0.