The Place of Teacher-Student Theory
师生论的位置
This is Paper 0 of Teacher-Student Theory, written last and placed first. It sets up no propositions, and does only a few things for the reader of this series: it says where the series stands within SAE, writes down how far it reads and what its main line is, sets out the way of reading and the shared words that the papers have in common, interfaces as a whole with several traditions, says once, together, the directions of colonization the papers read, lists together the thirty-eight propositions the series has set up, and registers the remainders it leaves unsettled and the questions still to be argued.
Teacher-Student Theory is on the relational side of SAE, and follows Parent-Child Theory; what it takes up is the half that Cultivation Theory handed on: the back-and-forth between two people. The series does not define all teacher-student relations; the teacher-student relation it reads has as its premise that the teacher's end is headed in the 15DD direction: across one matter after another, headed toward treating this student as an end, and not merely as a means; people are all mixed, falling back is read as it occurs, and after falling back this end can turn back. Where it can be read that the student is treated merely as a means, the relation is not within scope; where someone who teaches a course only teaches the course well, it cannot be read which kind this is; it is not judged, nor is it within scope. The teacher is a party in a relation, determined by the matter, not a post and not a title; schools and universities lie on the institutional side. The series follows the student up to coming of age. The main line, said plainly: some of what the teacher teaches he cannot test for the present, and he takes it in first: he remembers it, he can do it. Working out why, and going back to see whether it is right, he has to do himself; the teacher gives him the time for this, and also ways to examine and test what he has been taught. Where he himself is going, the teacher does not decide for him. The seven papers read in turn: the teacher in a relation; teaching; checking; expectation; space; collision; handing over.
This paper interfaces as a whole with the Analects, the "Record of Learning" in the Book of Rites, Han Yu, Xunzi, Zhu Xi, Plato, Augustine, Locke, Rousseau, Nietzsche and Freire; developmental psychology and research on education are not interfaced with, and are taken only as material. The directions of colonization the papers read borrow things that are already there, or may form, between teacher and student: the student's standing, not being able to check, the rightness of the content, questions, expectation, dependency, the road the teacher chooses, support, the teaching received. These things carry no direction in themselves; the direction is read on the one effect in which they are put to some use. This paper proves no proposition at the object layer.
Introduction
The seven papers that follow each read one thing. Paper 1, "The Teacher in a Relation," reads what the teacher-student relation this series speaks of looks like: scope, the teacher determined by the matter, provisions and authority, each relation, the two books at the student's end, his never having chosen and not being able to walk away, the object layer and the operation layer. Paper 2, "Teaching," reads teaching itself: the two layers it reaches, taking in first and checking later, where the direction of teaching is read, teaching and indoctrination, what is written in along with it, and teaching that was wrong. Paper 3, "Checking," reads what follows once the student begins to scrutinize what he has taken in: his questions, the three signals, what can be given and what cannot be done for him, the student's finding that the teacher was wrong, and what follows once he can check. Paper 4, "Expectation," reads what grows out of the back-and-forth: expectation, hanging an expectation on "what kind of person you are," compliance not standing as proof of avowal, the two senses of dependency, using one student as the measure of another. Paper 5, "Space," reads what follows once the thing the student himself cares about has come up: the one thing that cannot be taught, one teacher and many students, the three forms, negating a false cannot-not, not turning every time together into an occasion for growth. Paper 6, "Collision," reads the student's own cannot-not meeting the teacher's law: what the teacher's end looks like, mutual chiseling, the threshold of the Conflict Treatise, not agreeing and surpassing. Paper 7, "Handing Over," reads the last stretch: the boundary of coming of age, the test that lies on the student's side, having taught not being entered as repayment, ending early, and by whom what follows is read.
Written this way, several things are left with no paper to look after them: why this series is here, and how far it reads; how the main line strings the seven papers together; the way of reading the papers share, and what the same word means in which paper; several traditions whose question is put to the series as a whole; what the directions of colonization the papers read look like when set together; and which questions are still to be argued. This paper looks after these.
The method is that of the other papers: the conclusions of upstream papers are said in plain words; sources and extensions go in the notes. This paper sets up no propositions, and alters no sentence of the papers that follow. How the pieces upstream handed to this series are placed is given in the appendix at the end.
§1 Place
SAE has three sides: the side of the subject, the relational side, and the institutional side. The relational side is unfolded by Relation Theory, and downstream of it there are already Love Theory, Marriage Theory, Cooperation Theory and Parent-Child Theory. Teacher-Student Theory is a further branch on the relational side, following Parent-Child Theory.
The division of labor between the two levels Relation Theory has written down: Relation Theory in the abstract establishes only what all relations have; what holds only in one kind of relation is handed to the series on that kind of relation to argue.1 What has already been set up at the layer of relation this series uses directly and does not rewrite: the minimal conditions of a relation, the two directions of cultivation and colonization, expectation, the sediment of dealings, asymmetry, ending.
With Cultivation Theory. Cultivation Theory writes a single act from the giving end; the back-and-forth between two people it does not develop, and it writes that the setting belongs to the side that writes about what passes between people.2 It is exactly this half that Teacher-Student Theory takes up: a question has come in, how the teacher responds, and what conditions of the student's next asking the response has changed; how expectation grows after one sentence of praise; what the things taught turn into in his hands; how this relation comes to its end. What Cultivation Theory has already set up this series refers back to and does not rewrite; merely replacing the examples of upstream propositions with a teacher and a student is not what this series is for.
With Parent-Child Theory. Parents teaching their own child is read in Parent-Child Theory, and this series does not enter it. The two series use the same axis of stages and the same boundary of coming of age. They differ in the frame: Parent-Child Theory borrows the two layers of the institutional side and reads securing and support; between teacher and student there is no main business at the layer of securing, the teacher does not bear the student's base layer, and the main business is teaching. So the frame of this series is another one: taking in first, checking later.
With the example in Relation Theory. Relation Theory Paper 5 read a veteran technician at a mill and his apprentice; that is Relation Theory's example, and this series refers back to it and does not read it again.
With the institutional side. Schools and universities are constructs. Marking, promotion, streaming, the school system, appointment, are provisions of a construct, which this series acknowledges but does not judge; of the authority a construct gives the teacher, the source and the force are not judged. Guardianship belongs to the institutional side;3 where the teacher's effect crosses the student's basic rights, this series reads as far as "this is violation," and protection and disposition after the violation lie on the institutional side. What responsibility comes with the position of teaching a course also lies on the institutional side. The university is not in this series, and is handed to the institutional side.
With the papers on the developmental side. SAE has already read, from the side of development and learning, how a person grows: the paper on education divides teaching, nurturing and leading; the three papers on the Terrible Twos, the Terrible Teens and the Terrible Telos read the genesis of self-awareness, purpose and recognition; the Learning series reads how each layer learns.4 This series does not read these again, and calls on them where they are used; what it reads is how the teacher's end acts, and how far the student has grown serves only as a condition of that end's acting.
With the subject that comes after this series. How the teacher himself lives and how he treats people is seen by the student, and the education paper calls this leading. This face is there all along; how it is passed on, how the one who was taught later teaches others, and how cultivation is passed on between people, are subjects for after this series, and are only registered here.
§2 Scope and Main Line
Scope. There are seven items.
One, not defining all teacher-student relations. To say that a relation is not within the teacher-student relation this series reads is not to say that it is not a teacher-student relation (Paper 1, TS1).
Two, the teacher's end headed in the 15DD direction. In SAE's levels, the layer at which the other is recognized as an end too is written 15DD.5 The teacher-student relation this series reads has as its premise that the teacher's end is headed in this direction: across one matter after another, headed toward treating this student as an end, and not merely as a means. The direction is a premise, not a component of the teacher-student relation. Where it can be read that the student is treated merely as a means, that relation is not within scope. Where someone who teaches a course only teaches the course well, it cannot be read which kind this is; it is not judged, nor is it within scope: that is teaching, and teaching can carry no direction at all; a relation in which the course is only taught well is not what this series sets out to read. What cannot be read does not fall, by default, on the side of means. So there are two things this series does not read further: where the student is read as merely a means, something has been read; where the course is only taught well, and where material is insufficient, nothing has been read; only the first carries a reading (Paper 1, TS1).
Three, direction, falling back, and turning back. There is no teacher who stands purely at 15DD; people are all mixed; the direction is read by one operation at a time, falling back is read as it occurs, and does not overturn the direction. After falling back, this end can turn back; where there is persistent refusal to turn back, the direction is no longer at 15DD. Reflection is read from words and deeds; it does not cancel a violation already read, nor leave the student owing forgiveness (Paper 1, TS1).
Four, the teacher as a party in a relation. Determined by the matter: one party teaches, the other learns, the teaching actually enters the conditions of occurrence at the learner's end, and in that matter there is a teacher-student relation; once is enough. Titles do not define it (Paper 1, TS2).
Five, each relation. A teacher and each student form one relation apiece, entered on separate accounts, pair by pair; a class or a school of followers is not read as a further bearer. Among teacher, student and parents, only the relation between teacher and student is read (Paper 1, TS4).
Six, the series follows the student up to coming of age. Coming of age is read as his own cannot-not having taken shape, arriving domain by domain; domains are drawn by the matters of avowal, not by the subjects taught. The main text gives no ages and no school years, and does not use graduation or completing an apprenticeship as the boundary (Paper 7, TS34).
Seven, the object layer and the operation layer. The object layer reads the relation within scope; at the operation layer the teacher confirms only his own end, and the student's end is seen only by clues (Paper 1, TS7).
Main line. Said plainly:
Some of what the teacher teaches he cannot test for the present, and he takes it in first: he remembers it, he can do it. Working out why, and going back to see whether it is right, he has to do himself; the teacher gives him the time for this, and also ways to examine and test what he has been taught. Where he himself is going, the teacher does not decide for him.
The frame is "taking in first, checking later." Four things, divided between two sides. The side of taking in has two layers: remembering, and having learned. The other side also has two things: understanding, and checking, both of them his own turning back to scrutinize what he has already taken in. What teaching reaches is the former side; the latter side he has to walk himself, and what the teacher gives is conditions (Paper 2, TS8 and TS9; Paper 3, TS16).
This is a line through time, not a rule: some of what is taught first enters his learning, and only later becomes something he can check for himself; it does not say that all teaching must be accepted first and examined afterward. Taking in is not holding it to be true, nor avowing. This series writes "take in"; it does not write "believe."
The last sentence of the main line governs direction: the student's own purpose cannot be taught, and the teacher's end gives space and does not decide it for him (Paper 5, TS24; Paper 7, TS36).
§3 Way of Reading
Asymmetry: three are read. Of the asymmetries between teacher and student, this series reads three, none of which is authority given by a construct: in knowledge and ability; not being able to check for the present; not yet being able to say no. Asymmetry in itself is not crossing the line (Paper 1, TS3; Paper 2, TS9).
The axis of stages. The student's phase transitions are used as an axis. In SAE's levels, memory is written 11DD, prediction 12DD, self-awareness 13DD, purpose 14DD. The table below is an example of one order, not a set of boxes, and not a definition; the main text gives no ages. Each paper writes only how this axis runs in the one thing that paper reads.
| Stretch | The student, in this matter | What the teacher's end is mainly doing | Mainly in |
|---|---|---|---|
| Before 13DD | Memory and prediction are absorbing; what is taught is remembered and learned; there is no speaking of understanding | Teaching, only as far as having learned; in the stretch still within the direct-write window, situation and content are written in together, and the reading is by what was actually written in | Paper 2 |
| 13DD emerges | Begins to scrutinize what he has taken in: asks why, says that is not right | Teaching as before; giving conditions for reflecting and asking, responding to his questions, not evading | Paper 3 |
| 13DD operating, 14DD budding | The matters he can look up and test for himself grow in number one by one; the thing he himself cares about comes up | Withdrawing from the part exercised on his behalf; giving space | Papers 3, 4, 5 |
| The 14DD turn | His own cannot-not crystallizes, and meets the teacher's law and the teacher's plans for him | Giving space: not suppressing | Papers 5, 6 |
| 14DD comes to stand (coming of age) | His own cannot-not has taken shape | Not occupying his direction | Paper 7 |
There is no 15DD of the student's on the axis; in this series 15DD appears only at the teacher's end.
The two uses of DD; the two books. At the teacher's end, 15DD is a stance: the direction in which one operation goes. At the student's end, DD reads emergence and maturation, and does not become a label; the main text writes "in this matter, he can already check for himself," and does not write what layer of student he is. The student's standing as an end is full from the start; what he can do and how much he understands grow as he learns; the two books are kept apart (Paper 1, TS5).
Teaching and nurturing; leading is not read. The education paper divides three things: teaching, nurturing and leading.6 Teaching is in Paper 2. Nurturing in the tripartite division is read in two stretches: the stretch facing self-awareness in Paper 3, and the stretch facing purpose in Paper 5. The tripartite division says how the three things differ in what they do; it does not say that teaching has in it no direction of cultivation in the broad sense. Leading this series only registers.
What is not read, and what is. The provisions of schools, universities and posts are acknowledged but not judged; of the authority a construct gives, the source and the force are not judged, and how the teacher uses it is read. Position is not unfolded here. The household is not read: the parents' arrangements are registered only as conditions, and where the parents' requirement passes through the teacher, that act is entered in the teacher's relation. Guardianship, and disposition after the line is crossed, belong to the institutional side. What comes after coming of age is not read. How things will go for any kind of teacher or any one student is not written.
Examples. Made-up examples are the main ones: Fang Xu teaches mathematics to Lu Miao, a neighbor's child, set outside school, with no appointment and no marks; Master Zheng, with three boys learning carpentry, appears in Papers 1 to 5. When the student appears, only words and deeds are written. Historical material uses only the childhood that an adult, now dead, wrote down of himself and that has already been made public, and reads only how the adult author writes. Contrasting sentences in the examples are not judged for direction by the form of the words alone: which way that occasion headed is read by what it actually opened or sealed at the time; what it sediments into later is read separately, and is not used to judge the occasion backward; where material is insufficient, the matter stays undetermined.
The normative layer gives only direction. This series has a few sentences of direction, for instance "hurried teaching, and teaching filled to the brim, are not the direction of cultivation." A sentence of direction does not itself stand in for a particular judgment: no one act of teaching is judged on the strength of it. How this occasion counts for this one student is for the teacher's end to judge by his situation, and this series gives no algorithm; this judgment is open to questioning (Paper 2, TS11).
§4 Shared Words
Several words have a fixed usage in this series, and are listed together below.
| Word | Usage |
|---|---|
| Teacher | A party in a relation, determined by the matter; not a post, not a title |
| Student | The party who learns in that matter; in this series, one who has not yet come of age |
| Teaching | Following the tripartite division of the education paper: the passing on of knowledge, skill and predictive capacity |
| Cultivation | Unless otherwise marked, the broad sense of Relation Theory, the direction of one effect; where the tripartite division of the education paper is cited, that paper's special usage, for which the word is "nurturing"; where the reading reaches the layer of value, the narrow sense, marked on the spot |
| Leading | As in the education paper; not read in this series |
| Indoctrination | The cell in which the effect itself already writes for the student from the teacher's position and crowds out his own unfolding; it is violation; the kind of content written makes no difference. What is still only pushing that way is not called indoctrination, and is written "heading toward indoctrination" or "heading toward avowing for him" |
| Hurried, filled to the brim | Hurried: leaving no time for the passage from remembering to having learned; filled to the brim: leaving no moments of stopping to scrutinize. Both speak of whether room is left for this one student, not of teaching fast or teaching much. A delimitation of the words, not an algorithm |
| Taking in | In two layers, remembering and having learned; not holding it to be true, not avowing; "believe" is not written |
| Remembering, having learned | Following the Learning series: remembering is storing; having learned is that the model has been built, he can do it, and can use it on new problems of the same kind. Remembering does not of itself lead on to having learned |
| Understanding | Through reflecting and asking, this content has become something of which he can say why; on the same side as checking, the side of turning back to scrutinize |
| Checking | The student himself examines and tests what he has been taught. The ways of examining and testing can be taught; scrutiny itself cannot |
| The three signals | The set that Value Theory set up and that this series carries to teaching; the "three questions" of Cultivation Theory are a different set |
| Coming of age | Following Parent-Child Theory: his own cannot-not has taken shape; it arrives domain by domain |
| Handing over | The part the teacher had actually been exercising, arranging or holding on the student's behalf, withdrawn domain by domain. The position of asking and refusing is not handed over; it becomes his own as soon as he can run it himself |
| Position | Not unfolded in this series; of the authority a construct gives, the source and the force are not judged |
| Titles | Formally taking a master, appointment, forms of address, graduation, completing an apprenticeship; acknowledged but not judged |
| School, university | Constructs; on the institutional side |
The word "indoctrination" has several other uses upstream, each read in its own place, and a judgment of violation or of not violation is not filled in merely from the sameness of the word: the sentence in the Prequel of Cultivation Theory about a teacher who instills correct knowledge into a student follows Rights Theory, falls on using the rightness of the content to avow it in the other's place, and was originally an analogy; the Learning series uses, besides, "colonizing indoctrination"; and Cultivation Theory cites a sentence from the reading of the Analects, on speaking when one should not being indoctrination.7 The word "understanding" likewise has several other uses upstream: one place in Learning I where it stands in quotation marks, "understanding the other" in Learning IV, and "the other party's later understanding and action" in Relation Theory; each is its own.
§5 Interfacing as a Whole
Each paper has interfaced with one tradition or several; they are spoken of together here.
Pre-Qin and Confucian. The chapters of the Analects on teaching: walking three together; in teaching, no class of people is excluded; the bundle of dried meat; not opening the way until he is straining; not yielding even to one's teacher; Qiu holds back, so I urged him on; to take what you know as known. SAE's Reading the Analects has annotated these, and each paper refers back. The "Record of Learning" in the Book of Rites, on asking and awaiting the question, on leading without dragging, on the young listening and not asking, and on teaching and learning growing together, is divided among Papers 3, 4 and 6. The line on blue taken from the indigo plant, in Xunzi's "Exhortation to Learning," is in Paper 6. Han Yu's "On Teachers" is in Papers 1 and 6; Zhu Xi's division of lesser learning and greater learning is in Paper 2. In interfacing with the chapters of the Analects, only structure is read here.
Western. The geometry in Plato's Meno is in Paper 2, as a boundary case; Augustine's De Magistro is in Paper 3; Aristotle's passage on truth and friends is in Paper 6; Locke's section on reasoning with children is in Paper 4; the passage in Book II of Rousseau's Emile in which the tutor holds the conditions is in Paper 5; Nietzsche's "go away from me" is in Paper 7; Freire's criticism of banking education is in Paper 2. Rousseau and Kant on education have already been interfaced with in Parent-Child Theory and Cultivation Theory,8 and are referred back to here. Montessori, Pestalozzi, Tagore and Wang Shouren, with whom Cultivation Theory Paper 4 interfaced, are likewise referred back to.
Material. Developmental psychology and research on education are not interfaced with, and are taken only as material: research on teacher expectations is in Paper 4. The historical material in each paper reads only how an adult author writes of the teacher of his own childhood: Platter in Paper 1, Keller in Paper 2, Lu Xun in Paper 3, Carnegie in Paper 4, Hamerton in Papers 5 and 7, Lewis in Paper 6, and Camus's letter to Germain in Paper 7. One further piece of material has a different standing and is listed separately: Germain's letter to Camus of 1959 is a teacher's supplementary account of himself, does not fall under this rule, and is also in Paper 7.
The interfacing has one way of writing in common: the tension within the original is read along with it, and it is not excerpted into a set of well-known sentences that all head one way. The "Record of Learning" discusses asking well, and also says that the young only listen and do not ask; Locke argues for reasoning, and also lists the adult's displeasure as a reason; "On Teachers" says that the teacher is not determined by age, and also separates the teaching of sentence divisions from what it calls passing on the Way and resolving doubts.
One more thing has to be written down. That the student has to check for himself, that the student is not a vessel to be filled, that the teacher too is changed by the student: for each of these the traditions have very strong statements. This series does not write these general claims as if it were the first to make them. Its own work lies in three places: the reading by domain; keeping the accounts of different positions separately; and how the back-and-forth sediments.
§6 The Directions of Colonization the Papers Read, Said Once Together
The directions of colonization the papers read are read in the papers; only one layer is said together here: what they borrow are things that are already there, or may form, between teacher and student. These things carry no direction in themselves; whether there is one depends on that one effect, not on the name of the act:
- The student's standing: where "he doesn't understand yet" is used to lower his standing as an end, or to read all his questions and his "no" as signs of immaturity (Papers 1 and 3).
- The student as a condition: where it can be read that the student figures only as a condition of a signboard, of results, of labor, or of continuation; this kind has been read, lies outside scope, and is only registered. Only teaching the course well is a different case: nothing of means has been read, it is not judged, and the series does not read it further (Paper 1).
- Not being able to check: where the teacher's end creates or increases obstacles to checking, or goes on holding shut a particular path of checking; where "the teacher said so" is set up as a ground that cannot be refuted. The original gap carries no direction in itself (Paper 2).
- The rightness of the content: where the rightness of the content is used in heading toward avowing for him (Paper 2).
- The window: where the high plasticity of the window is used to force in the script the teacher wants. The occasion on which fear is taught in along with the content is read by what it actually wrote in, and is only registered (Paper 2).
- Questions: where the heading is toward making the student able to ask only this one teacher; where a cost is added to the speaking up that pointed out a mistake (Paper 3).
- Expectation: where an expectation is hung on what kind of person he is; where the teacher's approval has become the measure of the student's judgment. Expectation carries no direction in itself (Paper 4).
- Dependency: where it was made, and has locked the path to saying no; the student's depending on the teacher to teach carries no direction in itself (Paper 4).
- Another student: where one student is set up as the measure of another student's whole person (Paper 4).
- The road the teacher chooses: where it is treated as the direction the student cannot but take, or he is treated as the one to carry on the line; the teacher's deciding what to teach and what to teach first is not, in itself, this (Paper 5).
- Support: where both the difficulties and other people's objections are fended off on his behalf; the increase or decrease of a single item of support is not enough to establish it (Paper 5).
- Not agreeing, and surpassing: where not agreeing is read as betrayal, and surpassing as the teacher's achievement (Paper 6).
- The teaching received: where it is used to hold a share in the student's direction (Paper 7).
The same sentence "you don't understand yet," the same word of praise, the same page of exercises, is in one place a faithful description, a sound of gladness, an arrangement, and only in another place the lowering of standing, the replacing of a measure, the filling of time. The direction is read on the one effect in which they are put to some use; whether it took hold is seen in how the student understands and acts afterward.
Crossing the line is another line. The occasion on which the effect crosses the student's basic rights is violation; violation is judged only at the layer of basic rights, is read apart from the direction of colonization, and one does not jump from the one line to the other.
People are all mixed, and falling back is read on that occasion; whether this end can turn back after falling back is read separately, by the words and deeds that follow. What this series reads is direction; it does not on that account say that being a teacher is dangerous, nor advise anyone how to be a teacher; it only reads.
§7 Remainders
Several things this series registers and does not settle.
One, leading. The face of the teacher that the student sees is there all along; how it is passed on is a subject for after this series.
Two, one minor teaching another. Only registered.
Three, books, courses and tools as teacher. The teacher of this series is a person. Books written for many, and borrowing tools, Cultivation Theory has already read;9 the student's borrowing tools to check what the teacher taught is mentioned in Paper 3 in one sentence only.
Four, compulsion when the teacher temporarily looks after the student. Looking after a person who cannot yet say no cannot do without compulsion; this compulsion is not called cultivation, and belongs to the institutional side.3 The teacher-student relation is not in itself guardianship.
Five, between students. Dealings among fellow students are read by Relation Theory; an effect that reaches another student by way of the teacher is read as in Papers 3 and 4.
Six, the question of when a class becomes a collective subject. Upstream does not address it, and neither does this series.
Seven, teacher and student in the university. The side that is a construct lies on the institutional side.
Eight, after coming of age. The same teacher teaching an adult is read as between adults.
§8 Questions Left Open
Seven things the papers have argued only halfway, and they are listed here as they stand.
One, the two models borrowed are both hypotheses. The sequence on which "taking in first, checking later" relies the Learning series lists as a temporal hypothesis, and writes that direct experiments have not yet been seen; the direct-write window the original paper lists as a structural hypothesis. This series uses them within the limits of the original papers, and does not vouch for them; if these two places are rewritten, the relevant passages of Paper 2 will have to change with them. As soon as there is one content the student cannot at present check independently, the question at the level of the relation is already there; this point does not rest on these two models.
Two, the dividing line between the two entries. Paper 2 says that where he cannot check two entries are made, that the second entry has to account for three things, and that acting and falling short are kept apart, and gives the case of the answer pages cut out. What is left is: how, in particular material, to tell apart a gap in ability, conditions not given, what should have been given and was not, and the continued blocking of a path by means of an arrangement already in place. The things to be accounted for are there; the criteria item by item have not been argued.
Three, how far questioning of the teacher's judgment can go. Paper 2 says that how to teach this time is for the teacher to judge, and that this judgment is open to questioning. Who supervises, and how, has been handed to the institutional side, and is not counted as an argument this series owes. What remains in this series is the half at the level of the relation: how far questioning between the two can go while the student cannot yet say no has not been argued.
Four, one teacher and many students. Paper 5 reads by borrowing the cut of "creating conditions, and questioning"; in the original it divides a person who is present from one who has not yet come. How a shared arrangement facing many enters each relation separately has been read only in examples, and has not been argued.
Five, at the edge of scope. This series reads one kind only: where it can be read that the teacher heads toward treating the student as an end. Where it can be read that the student is treated merely as a means, the relation lies outside scope; where the course is only taught well, and where material is insufficient, there is no judgment, and no further reading. When what is not judged becomes readable, and on which side it comes out, has been given only in examples, and has not been argued. What is owed here is not an algorithm for assigning the undetermined to one side or the other.
Six, how "the matter" and "the domain" are fitted together. The teacher-student relation is determined by the matter taught; coming of age arrives by the domains of the matters of avowal. Paper 7 says that domains are drawn by the matters of avowal, and that a matter can be identified before the student's own direction in it has come to stand; how "the matters of avowal that bear on this relation" are identified has been given only in examples, and has not been argued.
Seven, extensions that borrow a shape. In several places this series carries an upstream proposition to an object the original does not speak of, each marked in its place as this series' own undertaking: the cut of "creating conditions, and questioning" from Marriage Theory, carried to one teacher and many students (Paper 5); superego internalization from the Learning series, used to read the measure of judgment (Paper 4); the third signal of Value Theory V38, used to read what is said in teaching (Paper 2); Conflict Treatise §15, carried to the teacher's judgment of one act of teaching (Paper 2); a distinction from Cooperation Theory and the deferral of Cultivation Theory HY4, carried to scope (Paper 1); the falling back and turning back of Parent-Child Theory PC1, carried to the teacher's end (Paper 1); Political Economy E36 and E37, carried to teacher and student (Paper 7). Whether the shape in these places carries over has not been separately argued.
§9 The Propositions of the Whole Series
The propositions of the papers are listed together as they stand in the main text of each paper, with only the final full stop added; the arguments and qualifications are in the main text of each paper. The parts still to be argued are not here; see §8.
Paper 1 The Teacher in a Relation
TS1 This series does not define all teacher-student relations. The teacher-student relation it reads has as its premise that the teacher's end is headed in the 15DD direction: across one matter after another, headed toward treating this student as an end, and not merely as a means. There is no teacher who stands purely at 15DD; the direction is read by one operation at a time, falling back is read as it occurs, and it does not overturn the direction; after falling back, this end can turn back; where there is persistent refusal to turn back, the direction is no longer at 15DD. Where it can be read that the student is treated merely as a means, that relation is not within the teacher-student relation this series reads. Where a teacher who teaches a course only teaches the course well, it cannot be read which kind this is; it is not judged, nor is it within the scope of this series: that is teaching, and teaching can carry no direction at all (TS8); a relation in which the course is only taught well is not what this series sets out to read. What cannot be read does not fall, by default, on the side of means.
TS2 The teacher is a party in a relation, not a post. Where, in some matter, one party teaches and the other learns, and the teaching actually enters the conditions of occurrence at the learner's end, there is a teacher-student relation in that matter; once is enough. It is read matter by matter: the same person is the teacher in this matter and may not be in another. Titles do not define it: where there is a title and teaching and learning do not actually occur, the series does not read it; where there is no title and they actually occur, it is read all the same. The main material of this series is repeated dealings; a single act of teaching does not fall by default into either kind, and it may precisely be heading toward cultivation.
TS3 Posts, schools and their provisions are acknowledged but not judged. Of the authority a construct gives, the source and the force are not judged; how the teacher uses it, and how it enters the dealings that follow, are read. The asymmetries this series reads are three: in knowledge and ability; not being able to check for the present; not yet being able to say no.
TS4 A teacher and each student form one relation apiece, entered on separate accounts, pair by pair. The series does not read a class or a school of followers as a further bearer, and does not address the question of when either becomes a collective subject. Among teacher, student and parents, the series reads only the relation between teacher and student; the parents' arrangements are registered only as conditions of this relation; where the parents' requirement reaches the student by way of the teacher, the teacher's passing it on is entered in the teacher's relation.
TS5 The student's standing as an end is full from the start, and is not conferred by the teacher; what he can do and how much he understands grow as he learns. The two books are kept apart: "he doesn't understand yet" at most describes what, in this matter, he cannot yet do; it does not lower his standing, nor is it used to read all his questions and his "no" as signs of immaturity.
TS6 Where the student never chose this teacher, that does not give the teacher the position of deciding his direction for him. Where the student cannot decide for himself to walk away, that does not place his asking, his refusing and his not avowing, in particular matters, at the teacher's disposal. Who made the arrangement is acknowledged but not judged: what belongs to the household is in Parent-Child Theory, what belongs to the school is on the institutional side. His no longer asking, his no longer learning, are words and deeds; where it can be read that he is taking back his own side, it is read as exit, and carries no direction of colonization. Silence, no longer asking, or going on doing as told do not by themselves show what he has taken back or what he has avowed; what has not been expressed in word or deed is not read. The teacher's end adds no cost to this taking back. Whether in his heart he takes this teacher as his teacher is a matter at his own end; the teacher does not demand it, and it is not used to settle accounts.
TS7 The object layer reads the relation in which the teacher's end is headed in the 15DD direction; at the operation layer the teacher confirms only his own end. Which layer the student has reached in some matter can, from the teacher's end, be seen only by clues.
Paper 2 Teaching
TS8 Teaching is passing knowledge, skill and predictive capacity on to the student. What teaching reaches has two layers: remembering, and having learned; remembering does not of itself lead on to having learned. Understanding is not given directly by teaching: that step he has to take himself, and what the teacher gives is conditions. Teaching can be designed, and can be done for many at once. Teaching can carry both directions, and can also carry no direction at all; that a skill has been learned does not by itself show which.
TS9 Taking in first, checking later. Some of what is taught the student cannot check for the present, and he takes it in first. Taking in has two layers: remembering, and having learned. Taking in is not holding it to be true, nor avowing it as his own. Understanding and checking lie on the other side, and need his own reflecting, asking and going back to look; the two advance back and forth, with neither necessarily coming first. Related material and a first model give checking somewhere to start; remembering alone has not prepared the conditions for the checking that comes later. This is a line through time: some of what is taught first enters his learning, and only later becomes something he can check for himself; it does not lay down that all teaching must be accepted first and examined afterward. Where the material itself can show right and wrong, it can be tested on the spot. Where he cannot check for the present, two entries are made: on the original gap alone, it is not read as carrying the direction of colonization; whether the teacher's end has created or increased obstacles to checking, or gone on holding shut a particular path of checking, is entered separately.
TS10 That the content is right does not by itself show that this teaching heads toward cultivation; to read its direction, one looks at what it actually opened or sealed. This paper reads the face of it that lies on the path of checking: whether the reasons, the sources and the way to test are laid out; whether the path by which he may later go back and look is left open; whether "the teacher said so" has been set up as a ground that cannot be refuted. Whether the content is right, and whether the path is left open, are entered separately and do not offset each other. Whether a condition of return is hung on the teaching, and whether his own share is left to him, are two further places, referred back to. Not yet having the ability to check does not count as the teacher's having sealed the path; "left open" requires particular conditions, not a sentence like "you'll understand when you're older."
TS11 "Indoctrination" in this series follows Rights Theory F21 and F26 and Relation Theory Paper 1: where the effect itself already writes for the student from the teacher's position and crowds out his own unfolding, it is indoctrination, it is violation, and it also carries the direction of colonization; this series reads only as far as "this is violation." Where it is still only pushing that way, and he can still take it and can also put it down, it is not called indoctrination; it carries only the direction of colonization and is not violation. The judgment lies in writing for him and crowding out, not in the kind of content written, nor in motive and feeling: that the content is right, that the teacher sincerely means him well, that the student feels he has benefited, none of these changes the reading. Hurried teaching, and teaching filled to the brim, are not the direction of cultivation; they are a direction that heads toward indoctrination. This is a sentence of direction at the normative layer, not a verdict on any one act of teaching. For this one student, whether this occasion counts as hurried or as filled to the brim, and how to teach this time, is for the teacher's end to judge by this student's situation; this series gives no algorithm. This judgment is not made at will: it is open to questioning, and is not exempt from being looked at again because it comes from the teacher himself; who supervises it, and how, belongs to the institutional side. The cell that crosses the line does not move with this judgment: what already writes for him from the teacher's position and crowds out his own unfolding is read, as upstream reads it, as violation, and the reading does not change with how the teacher describes himself. A teacher's saying what he himself judges of the student is not thereby heading this way; the difference lies in the form in which it is handed over.
TS12 In the stretch that is still within the direct-write window, situation and content are written in together when he is taught, and he can only take it in. The occasion on which fear is taught in along with the content is read by what it actually wrote in; it is not closed out on the strength of "he learned it." What this proposition borrows is the direct-write mode, kept within the limits the original paper sets.
TS13 Where the content was taught wrong, the teacher's end, as soon as it finds this, points it out and corrects it, and does not blame the student. Where he has already taken it in and used it, correcting it does not rewrite its having happened; the effects already left are entered as they are. What the teacher does not know, he says he does not know.
Paper 3 Checking
TS14 The student begins to scrutinize what he has taken in: he asks why, asks how you know, says that is not right. This is the beginning of his checking. One question does not by itself certify the emergence of 13DD; reading every question as talking back, inattention or immaturity is exactly what the second of the three signals guards against. What the teacher's end reads is whether his question can land: it is heard, not punished, not laughed at; and where the question reaches a place the teacher would rather not answer, it is not evaded. When one student's question is answered in front of other students, whoever that answer actually reaches, an entry is made in that one's relation.
TS15 A teacher's teaching in one matter is read by three signals: whether there are particular arrangements by which the student gradually becomes able to check for himself; whether his challenges are answered on their content and, where there is reason, really change what is said or how it is taught; whether the reasons for what is taught and the conditions under which it applies can be examined, or whether the teacher's identity as teacher has become a ground that cannot be refuted. A conclusion that already has sufficient proof can be taught as certain; its premises, its proof and its range of application remain open to examination. Where his objection is mistaken, and the teacher has answered it in full and the conclusion stands, his words have landed all the same: that something was changed on this occasion is not made the condition of his question's counting.
TS16 The methods, materials and exercises of checking can be taught; the conditions under which scrutiny and understanding happen can be given: there is something to scrutinize, a question can land, a mistake has somewhere to show itself, and there is room to stop. That act of scrutiny, that step of understanding, is still completed by the student himself. Where, in this matter, the student can already raise, refuse and revise for himself, that position becomes his own at once; it is not conferred by the teacher, and does not wait for his cannot-not to come to stand. Handing over means that the part the teacher had actually been exercising, arranging or holding on his behalf is withdrawn domain by domain, not all on one day. Heading toward making the student able to ask only this one teacher carries the direction of colonization.
TS17 Where the student finds that the teacher was wrong: it is entered that what was said was changed, that how it is taught was changed, not as anyone's winning or losing. The teacher's end does not on that account add disadvantage in other matters.
TS18 Once the student can check in this matter, the teacher may still teach. Being able to check is not having checked every time; how he takes in and how he scrutinizes from then on remain at his end. "He no longer asks me" is not taken as evidence that the teaching succeeded; "he keeps asking me" is not taken as evidence that it went wrong; whether he asks next time is only material.
Paper 4 Expectation
TS19 Expectation between teacher and student grows out of the dealings: what the teacher has praised and what he has frowned at, which time the student got it right and which time he did not, all become material. The teacher's expectation is a construct left at his own end; it does not turn into the student's duty, and does not certify that the student has avowed anything.
TS20 Saying an expectation out loud is a form of questioning. To hang an expectation on what kind of person the student is, for instance "a good student wouldn't do this" or "you have talent, you shouldn't be like this," is to fix for him what something means to him, and slides in the direction of colonization; whether that takes hold depends on his later understanding and action.
TS21 Compliance does not stand as proof of avowal: the student's saying "all right," doing as told, and doing it well are all only clues. Where the teacher's approval has become the measure of the student's own judgment, this is read by borrowing "superego internalization" from Learning III; from outside only clues are seen, and confirmation lies at his end.
TS22 The student's depending on the teacher to teach is the kind of dependency that is there in any case, and carries no direction of colonization. The kind that was made, and that has locked the path to saying no, for instance "without me you'll never learn it," or not letting him go to anyone else, carries the direction of colonization. The direction is to make him no longer held by this one teacher; this is only a direction, and is not used as a measure.
TS23 Where one student is used as the measure of another, for instance "look at so-and-so," what is read first is how the sentence lands with the student who hears it. If it also actually alters the situation of the one used as the measure, that relation is entered separately; the line is not drawn by whether he knows, nor is the effect entered as having reached him merely because his name was mentioned. Using a piece of homework to show one way of doing something, and setting up one student as the measure of another student's whole person, are read apart.
Paper 5 Space
TS24 The student's own purpose and his cannot-not cannot be taught; he has to chisel them out himself. What the teacher's end can do is give space: not suppress, and not block that signal. This is the 14DD stretch of the one thing that the tripartite division of the education paper specifically calls "nurturing"; the 13DD stretch is in Paper 3.
TS25 What is done facing many is creating conditions for cultivation. Creating conditions can face many; questioning is put to one person who can hear and can answer, and how one responds after he has answered falls in his relation. One act can reach many at once, and is read separately as it lands in each relation: withdrawing a requirement, giving out material, answering one student's question, can each act on several people at the same time. A shared arrangement cannot take the place of a response to a particular question, and one method cannot vouch for, or complete, the growing and the avowing of many. The teacher's time and strength are limited: whether the other is willing, whether it suits him, whether the moment is ripe; where these three do not all hold, or where he judges that this time he cannot give, not giving this time is not losing one's ground, and this judgment too can be questioned; nor is not giving the safer side in advance. Whether he would drain himself dry is for his own end to assess. Where the time in which everyone has class together is taken to give to this one, the other students' share is in it too.
TS26 The three forms of colonization at 14DD each have a shape between teacher and student. Direction substitution is treating the road of study or of life that the teacher has chosen for the student as the direction he himself cannot but take, or treating him as the one to carry on the teacher's own line; the teacher's deciding what to teach and what to teach first is not, in itself, this. Superego internalization: see TS21. Full-support resistance removal is fending off, on his behalf, both the difficulties and other people's objections; the increase or decrease of a single item of support is not enough to establish it. The student does not figure only as the teacher's continuation.
TS27 Cultivation in this stretch is negating a false cannot-not, not implanting a direction. The teacher can withdraw a requirement he himself added, and say "you need not," not "you should not"; which cannot-not is false is for the student to judge.
TS28 The teacher does not turn every time together into an occasion for growth. The student may refuse to be treated continually as someone yet to grow.
Paper 6 Collision
TS29 At the 14DD turn, the student's own cannot-not crystallizes and begins to meet the teacher's law and the teacher's plans for him. Rebellion is not the mechanism by which 14DD comes about; it is often its behavioral by-product.
TS30 In this stretch, the teacher's end heading toward 15DD in one operation is read, in this matter, as: acknowledging that this cannot-not is the student's own, even where, as the teacher sees it, that direction will fail. The teacher may state his disagreement in full; he does not hand it over as a piece of self-knowledge the student has already completed.
TS31 Mutual chiseling is judged by process, not by identity: where teacher and student, in some matter, enter one and the same reciprocal process and actually chisel open each other's judgments, there is mutual chiseling in that matter. The matter in which the teacher is chiseled open by the student is read by the process on that occasion. That there is mutual chiseling does not certify that the student is already headed in the 15DD direction.
TS32 Where the requirement at the student's end and the teacher's law require incompatible actions in the same situation: whether that matter enters the Conflict Treatise is checked item by item against its two gates, and is not settled by the teacher-student identity or by incompatibility itself. What does not enter is read as dealings and collision.
TS33 The student's not agreeing with the teacher in some matter, or surpassing him: this is not read as betrayal, nor is it used to certify that this relation heads toward cultivation or that the teacher's end is headed in the 15DD direction. That this skill was taught by this teacher is entered as fact. "The blue that comes from the indigo plant" is not used as the measure of this relation.
Paper 7 Handing Over
TS34 This series reads up to the student's coming of age: read as in Parent-Child Theory, by the person's domains, arriving domain by domain. Domains are drawn by the matters of avowal, not by the subjects taught, and a further domain is not drawn because he meets a problem he cannot yet do; a matter can be identified before the student's own direction in it has come to stand. Being able to check is not this boundary (TS16, TS18). If the relation ends before the student has come of age in the matters of avowal that bear on it, it is read by TS37; a relation is not kept on the near side of coming of age merely because what was taught has not become the student's own cannot-not. On the side that has come of age, what follows is read as giving and dealings between adults, and the same teacher may still teach him. Graduation, completing an apprenticeship, and coming of age in law are acknowledged but not judged. This is the boundary of how far this series reads; it does not say that teacher-student relations in reality stop here.
TS35 The test lies on the student's side: he is able to unfold without revolving around this one teacher. This is a test; it is not that he must in fact leave, nor that from now on he needs no one. What this test looks at is whether the teacher has occupied the student's own constitutive position; "no longer revolving around the teacher" is not used to certify that his cannot-not has come to stand, nor to settle the account of the teacher's teaching.
TS36 The student's thanks, his achievement, his staying are not entered as repayment for the teaching, and are not used to settle accounts; the teacher does not, for having taught, hold a share in the student's direction. This proposition settles only to whom the student's direction belongs; tuition fees and credit for the teacher's contribution are reckoned separately. One may remember, and one may be glad for him.
TS37 Where the relation ends before the student comes of age: the teacher leaves, the student leaves, the teacher is changed. Exit does not settle the accounts, nor pass final judgment on this person; leaving the shared matters between the two room for natural development when one exits points in the direction of cultivation. What the teacher had meant to finish teaching does not on that account become a shared matter that remains after he has gone; what has been taught stays in the student's hands, for him to use as it is, to change, or to put down. Who arranged the change is acknowledged but not judged.
TS38 What lies between these two people from then on is read by Relation Theory, Cooperation Theory and Cultivation Theory. The face of how the teacher himself lives, as seen by the student, is handed to the series on how cultivation is passed on; the stretch in the university, on its side as a construct, is handed to the Theory of the University.
§10 Drawing Together
This paper sets up no propositions, and proves no proposition at the object layer. What it says is: Teacher-Student Theory is on the relational side, follows Parent-Child Theory, and takes up the half that Cultivation Theory handed on; it does not define all teacher-student relations, and reads the teacher-student relation whose premise is that the teacher's end is headed in the 15DD direction; people are all mixed, falling back is read as it occurs, and after falling back this end can turn back; the relation in which it can be read that the student is treated merely as a means is not within scope, and where the course is only taught well there is no judgment, nor is the relation within scope; the teacher is a party in a relation, determined by the matter; the series reads relation by relation, up to the student's coming of age. The main line is: some of what the teacher teaches he cannot test for the present, and he takes it in first; working out why, and going back to see whether it is right, he has to do himself, and the teacher gives him the time for this and also ways to examine and test what he has been taught; where he himself is going, the teacher does not decide for him. The directions of colonization the papers read borrow things that are already there, or may form, between teacher and student; the direction is read on the one effect in which they are put to some use.
Appendix: The Pieces Handed Down from Upstream
The pieces in upstream papers that write of teacher and student, or that are handed to the side that writes about what passes between people, are placed as follows. This table is for the reader who wants to compare against upstream; in reading this series itself it can be skipped.
| Piece | Source | Placed in Teacher-Student Theory |
|---|---|---|
| The back-and-forth between two people is not developed; the setting belongs to the side that writes about what passes between people | Cultivation Theory Prequel, §1, §5 | The whole series |
| Provenance does not decide attribution; the negation within avowal can come afterward, in looking back | Cultivation Theory HY1, HY2 | Paper 2, TS9 |
| "Correct indoctrination is not cultivation either"; the case of knowledge | Cultivation Theory Prequel, §2 | Paper 2, TS10, TS11 |
| The case of a supervisor giving a book: making acceptance of the book's conclusions a condition of assessment | Cultivation Theory Paper 1 | Paper 1, TS3; Paper 2, TS10 |
| One-to-one and one-to-many: thirty students cannot be cultivated at once by one method | Cultivation Theory Prequel, §4 | Paper 5, TS25 |
| Those who cannot yet say no; the three signals within care | Cultivation Theory Paper 4, HY20 to HY25 | Paper 1, TS3, TS5; Paper 3, TS14, TS15 |
| How the side that holds a position gives | Cultivation Theory Paper 5, HY26 to HY31 | Paper 1, TS3; Paper 3, TS17; Paper 4, TS21, TS22 |
| A teacher explains one way thoroughly, and also presents a preference as the only conclusion | Relation Theory Paper 1, the section under H8 | Paper 2, TS8 |
| The dividing line between teaching and indoctrination | Relation Theory Paper 1, the section under H9; Rights Theory P5 F21, P6 F26 | Paper 2, TS11 |
| Teacher and student stand between relation and institution | Relation Theory Paper 1, the section under H11 | Paper 1, TS3 |
| Mutual chiseling is judged by process, and the same goes for teacher and student | Relation Theory Paper 1 | Paper 6, TS31 |
| A condition of repayment hung on teaching; how the veteran technician's veto is used | Relation Theory Paper 5 | Paper 1, TS3; Paper 2, TS10 |
| Asymmetries of capacity and knowledge; authority acknowledged but not judged | Relation Theory H52, H53 | Paper 1, TS3; Paper 2, TS9 |
| Teaching within the limit can carry the direction of colonization without being violation | Relation Theory H50 | Paper 2, TS11 |
| An apprentice depends on a master; the two senses of dependency | Conflict Treatise §20; Relation Theory H47 | Paper 4, TS22 |
| The tripartite division of teaching, nurturing and leading; self-awareness and purpose cannot be taught | Education as Subject-Condition | Paper 2, TS8; Paper 3, TS16; Paper 5, TS24 |
| Material first, then scrutiny; scrutiny cannot be taught; there must be moments of pause | Learning II, §6.1, §2.1, §6.3 | Paper 2, TS9, TS11; Paper 3, TS16 |
| The three forms of colonization at the layer of purpose; negating a false cannot-not | Learning III | Paper 4, TS21; Paper 5, TS26, TS27 |
| Teaching, too, can carry the direction of making space | Parent-Child Theory Paper 3 | Paper 2, TS8, TS10 |
| The parents' teaching | Parent-Child Theory PC16 | Paper 1, TS2 (not entered) |
| Coming of age read as the cannot-not having taken shape; where the gate can run of itself, the position becomes his own | Parent-Child Theory PC38, PC39 | Paper 3, TS16; Paper 7, TS34 |
| A teacher who never asks after his student; the teacher-student cases within the test | Meaning Theory P3, Y25, Y26 | Paper 7, TS35, TS36 |
| The student no longer needs the teacher (a precedent in the same direction, not a ground) | Power Theory P5, criterion C3 | Paper 7 (only registered) |
| The one who cultivates can also be cultivated | Action Theory D37 | Paper 6, TS31 |
When something is referred back to, the restrictions of the original place come with it.
Acknowledgments
This paper is signed by Han Qin alone; the author decided every argument and choice and bears sole responsibility for the text. In drafting, the author used AI models from various developers as tools. The English edition is an independent rewrite of the Chinese text, not a translation; where the two differ, the Chinese governs.
Notes
- Relation Theory Paper 0: "Relation Theory in the abstract establishes only what all relations have; a proposition that holds only in one kind of relation is handed to the series on that kind of relation to argue." ↩︎
- Cultivation Theory Prequel, §1: "The back-and-forth between two people is not developed"; §5: "This series writes the giving end; the setting, and the way cultivation is passed on between people, belong to the side that writes about what passes between people." ↩︎
- Cultivation Theory Paper 4, HY20: "Looking after a person who cannot yet say no cannot do without compulsion; this compulsion is not called cultivation, and guardianship belongs to the institutional side." ↩︎
- Education as Subject-Condition; the papers on the Terrible Twos, the Terrible Teens and the Terrible Telos; Learning I to IV. ↩︎
- Parent-Child Theory Paper 0, §2, citing the Abstract of Laughter IV: 15DD is non dubito, "it is not only I who am an end; the other, too, is an end in itself". ↩︎
- Education as Subject-Condition, Abstract: "teaching (10DD → 12DD, the transfer of knowledge and predictive capacity, scalable to groups), nurturing (13DD → 14DD, providing space for the subject to chisel out self-awareness and purpose on its own, possible only one-on-one), and leading (15DD, the adult embodies recognition, the child sees the direction, possible only by personal demonstration). The three cannot substitute for one another." ↩︎
- Cultivation Theory Prequel, §2: "a teacher who instills correct knowledge into a student, and the student's knowledge is not wrong, is still not cultivating". Learning I: "In adults, colonizing indoctrination is reversible". Cultivation Theory Paper 2, §6, citing the reading of the Analects: "speaking when one should not is indoctrination; not speaking when one should is abandoning teaching". ↩︎
- Parent-Child Theory Paper 3, §7 (Rousseau's negative education; Kant's On Education); Cultivation Theory Paper 4 (HY25). ↩︎
- Cultivation Theory Papers 7 and 8. ↩︎
References
All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version.
I · This series
Qin, H. (2026). The Teacher in a Relation (SAE Teacher-Student Theory, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24267229
Qin, H. (2026). Teaching (SAE Teacher-Student Theory, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24267232
Qin, H. (2026). Checking (SAE Teacher-Student Theory, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24267235
Qin, H. (2026). Expectation (SAE Teacher-Student Theory, Paper 4) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24267240
Qin, H. (2026). Space (SAE Teacher-Student Theory, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24267245
Qin, H. (2026). Collision (SAE Teacher-Student Theory, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24267250
Qin, H. (2026). Handing Over (SAE Teacher-Student Theory, Paper 7) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24267253
II · SAE works directly cited in this paper
Qin, H. (2026). The Place of Relation Theory (SAE Relation Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545115
Qin, H. (2026). What a Relation Is, and What It Is Not (SAE Relation Theory, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545047
Qin, H. (2026). The Sediment of Dealings (SAE Relation Theory, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545076
Qin, H. (2026). What Cultivation Is Not (SAE Cultivation Theory, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154492
Qin, H. (2026). How Is Cultivation Possible? (SAE Cultivation Theory, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154499
Qin, H. (2026). Once Seen, No Going Back (SAE Cultivation Theory, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154504
Qin, H. (2026). Those Who Cannot Yet Say No (SAE Cultivation Theory, Paper 4) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154511
Qin, H. (2026). When One Holds Power (SAE Cultivation Theory, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154515
Qin, H. (2026). Writing for Many (SAE Cultivation Theory, Paper 7) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154522
Qin, H. (2026). Borrowing Tools (SAE Cultivation Theory, Paper 8) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154525
Qin, H. (2026). The Place of Parent-Child Theory (SAE Parent-Child Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24121569
Qin, H. (2026). Support in the Parent-Child Relation (SAE Parent-Child Theory, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24121541
Qin, H. (2026). Handing Over and Leading (SAE Parent-Child Theory, Paper 7) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24121559
Qin, H. (2026). Education as Subject-Condition: A Philosophy of Education [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18867389
Qin, H. (2026). Learning Through Memory and Prediction: The Construction, Window, and Cost of 11DD and 12DD (SAE Learning, I) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19426123
Qin, H. (2026). Learning to Scrutinize and Correct: The Emergence, Operation, and Cost of 13DD (SAE Learning, II) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19436811
Qin, H. (2026). Purpose-Driven Learning (SAE Learning, III) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19490707
Qin, H. (2026). Learning to Recognize the Other's Purpose: The Bridge from 14DD to 15DD (SAE Learning, IV) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19491926
Qin, H. (2026). What Terrible Twos Actually Is: The Structural Genesis of Self-Awareness [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19044827
Qin, H. (2026). What Terrible Teens Actually Is: The Structural Genesis of Purpose [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19201631
Qin, H. (2026). What Terrible Telos Actually Is: The Structural Genesis of Non Dubito [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19248039
Qin, H. (2026). On the Colonization of Value (SAE Value Theory, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21611154
Qin, H. (2026). The Half That Is Not Mine to Settle (SAE Meaning Theory, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22731235
Qin, H. (2026). How Subjecthood Is Not Swallowed by Conflict Itself (SAE Conflict Treatise) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22313628
Qin, H. (2026). Not Legislating for Others (SAE Action Theory, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22970777
Qin, H. (2026). On the Limitation and Violation of Basic Rights (SAE Rights Theory, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21212595
Qin, H. (2026). On the Cultivation and Diachronic Unfolding of Rights (SAE Rights Theory, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21252863
Qin, H. (2026). On the Development of Power · Shi (SAE Power Theory, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20582210
Qin, H. (2026). Part I · The Instrument (Reading the Analects Through Self-as-an-End, Part I) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22656207
Qin, H. (2026). Part II · The Man Who Would Not Be a Sage (Reading the Analects Through Self-as-an-End, Part II) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22656223
Qin, H. (2026). Part III · In the Room (Reading the Analects Through Self-as-an-End, Part III) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22656232
III · External works
External works are listed in each paper where the interfacing is done; this paper cites none separately.
Interfaces
Main upstream: Cultivation Theory Prequel (§1, §5); Relation Theory Paper 0 (the division of labor between the two levels); Parent-Child Theory Paper 0 (the format).
Also used: Education as Subject-Condition; Learning I to IV; the papers on the Terrible Twos, Teens and Telos; Cultivation Theory Papers 2, 4, 5, 7 and 8; Rights Theory P5, P6; Value Theory P3; Meaning Theory P3; Action Theory Paper 6; the Conflict Treatise; Power Theory P5.
This series: lists together TS1 to TS38 of Papers 1 to 7; alters no sentence of any paper.