Self-as-an-End
SAE Propagation of Cultivation · Paper 5

The Propagation of Cultivation: Leading
涵育的传播:引领

Han Qin (秦汉) · Independent Researcher · 2026
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24351777 · Full PDF on Zenodo · CC BY 4.0
Abstract

Paper 1 said that three things pass through a person, and that one of them, a way of standing, cannot be taught but can be seen. This paper reads the side that is seen: leading. Leading is the side of a person's living out recognition, in his own life and dealings, that another person sees. Having activities of one's own is not in itself leading.

Leading lets someone know that the position exists; it does not produce 15DD. At the earlier person's end there are three things: giving conditions, being seen, and collision in actual dealings. They are read apart, and are not assumed to come from the same person in the same encounter; the later person's step remains his own. Leading is not registered, not assessed, not inspected. When a practice is fixed as a template for the other to follow, what is passed on is content that can be followed. When a person deliberately makes public how he judges and how he answers disagreement, whether there is leading in it still depends on the actual effect and on what the other saw. What is seen includes how one turns back after falling back.

What is seen through particular practices is a way of standing that need not be copied: the later person need not treat people the way the earlier one did. Through a book or a screen a way of standing may also be seen: in how the author treats the reader here and now, in an act that has itself been left behind, and by way of an account of an actual encounter; an account has to be checked for its grounds. That a later reader saw something is not read back into something the author did toward that reader at the time.

The paper refers back to Xiao Hong's passage on Lu Xun used in the previous paper, and to Rilke's letters as read in Cultivation Theory. It does not show that a person who has seen will come to stand there, gives no method for leading, does not rate what anyone has lived out, and certifies no one's layer.

Introduction

One day Cheng Xi goes with Su Yao to a client. In front of Cheng Xi, the client's technician says that Su Yao's diagnosis last time was wrong: the fault was not in the power supply; it was in a sensor. Su Yao does not bristle. She says: "Pull up the log from last time and let's look at it together." Having looked, she goes through the machine again, turns to the technician and says: "You're right on this one. I missed this line last time." On the way back she does not draw any lesson for Cheng Xi.

Another time it goes differently. A client is pressing hard and is rude on the phone. Su Yao answers: "If you think we're not good enough, go somewhere else." She hangs up and sits for a while. The next day she calls back and says: "I went too far yesterday. About the machine: I'll come over this afternoon." Cheng Xi is beside her this time too.

The company hears that Su Yao is good at training people and wants her method written up. First she is asked to fill in a form: how many conversations with the newcomer each week, and how long. Then a Training Standard is issued, one clause of which reads: "When a newcomer asks a question, the trainer shall first ask back 'What do you think?' and shall not give the answer directly." At year's end a "Trainer of the Year" is chosen by scoring against the standard.

At a crew meeting Su Yao once goes through, from beginning to end, the occasion on which her diagnosis was wrong: what she saw, why she settled on the power supply, which line she missed. It is her own idea to tell it; no one asked.

Two years later Cheng Xi has a newcomer of his own. He does not train the way Su Yao does. He says little; when the newcomer asks, he does not ask back; he lays out two paths: "You could check here first, or there first. Think about what each costs, and pick one."

And one person from the other example. In Paper 3, Zhu Cheng had the line on her tongue and did not say it to the intern, and her hands were empty. Suppose that later, on a cross-team project, she spends a month with another team. That team's lead asks the person at the bottom: "Where did you get stuck this week?" The person says; the team lead listens and says: "Then next week I'll go to that client with you once." Zhu Cheng is nearby. No one is teaching her.

Several things here need to be read apart. Su Yao's "you're right on this one" was said to the technician, not to Cheng Xi: what did Cheng Xi get from it? Does it count as something she gave him? She lost her temper and then called back: what did Cheng Xi see that time? The Training Standard turned "What do you think?" into a clause: what is passed on by it? Su Yao deliberately told the crew about her own mistake: is that doing it for show? Cheng Xi does not train the way Su Yao does: did he fail to learn, or is it something else? Zhu Cheng saw that team lead: what will she do next?

What this paper reads. Teacher-Student Theory handed leading over to this series.1 The education paper divides teaching, nurturing and leading into three, and says that leading is possible only by personal demonstration.2 Parent-Child Theory and the Theory of the University each read what leading looks like in one kind of relation and one kind of construct.34 This paper reads its place in propagation: between one link and the next there is, besides the conditions given, the side that is seen. Five things are read: what leading is; what it can and cannot do; where it borders on templates and on making public; what happens after falling back; and what exactly is seen, including through a book or a screen.

Stipulations. The example stipulates that when Su Yao answered the technician, called the client back, and told the crew about her mistake, she was headed in the 15DD direction; likewise the team lead on the occasion of "Where did you get stuck this week?" This is given by the example, not inferred from the look of the words. One further stipulation: when Su Yao said "go somewhere else" to the pressing client, that sentence removed his place to go on objecting, and at that moment she was not treating him as an end.

Shared words. Leading follows the education paper and the upstream series; §1 gives this series' own wording. A way of standing is as in Paper 1: giving to another person without doing it for him; the Theory of the University uses the phrase where it speaks of leading.5 Being seen is the side that leading is; the Moral Law series has "observation at a distance," which is discernment,6 and the two are not interchanged (§1). A template is a practice fixed for the other to follow.

§1 What Leading Is

CB27 Leading is the side of a person's living out recognition, in his own life and dealings, that another person sees. Having activities of one's own is not in itself leading

The side that is seen

The education paper writes: "There is only one way to lead: the adult stands at the 15DD position, and the child, seeing this, knows that position exists."2 That is said of adult and child. This series reads between adults and takes the same shape.

Su Yao says to the technician, "You're right on this one." The sentence is addressed to the technician. It is something she does within her own dealings: the other disagrees with her, the other has a point, and she owns it. Cheng Xi is beside her and sees it.

So this series words leading thus: it is the side of a person's living out recognition, in his own life and dealings, that another person sees. It is a side, not a separate thing. Su Yao did nothing extra; what she did was still what passed between her and the technician. The side of it that Cheng Xi saw is called leading.

There has to be recognition

One word in that wording cannot be dropped: recognition.

A person acting as he pleases, vividly, in full view of others, is not thereby leading. In Paper 2, Wei Heng, when he first joined the team, also saw how Lao Guo treated the person at the bottom; that too was "being seen," and it is not called leading. What is seen has to be recognition: treating the person in front of one as an end. Su Yao owns that the technician has a point: she takes his judgment as a judgment, not as an affront.

Parent-Child Theory reads something nearby. A grown son sees his mother take up painting and have an activity of her own. That paper writes that whether there is also leading depends on how she lives out recognition in her own life and dealings, and is not settled directly by her having an activity of her own.3 This series does the same: having activities of one's own is not in itself leading. A person can live very much in his own way without any of it touching how he treats people.

Not observation, and not an act

Two things are kept apart from it.

One is observation at a distance. The Moral Law series writes that one can discern a person from how he treats a third party.6 There the observer is doing something: discerning, in order to decide how to deal with him. Leading is not that. Cheng Xi was not assessing Su Yao; he saw, and came to know that such a way of standing exists. The first lands on a judgment about the person seen; the second lands on the seer's knowing of one more position.

The other is an act directed at someone. Cultivation is directed at a person: it gives him conditions. Leading is not directed at the one who sees it. Su Yao's sentence was directed at the technician. The case where she afterward turns to Cheng Xi with a requirement is read in §3.

§2 What It Can Do

CB28 Leading lets someone know that the position exists; it does not produce 15DD. Giving conditions, being seen, and collision in actual dealings are read apart, and are not assumed to come from the same person in the same encounter; the later person's step remains his own

Knowing that the position exists

The Theory of the University writes: how a teacher treats a student who disagrees with him, the student can see; "Having seen it, he knows that such a way of standing exists."5

Knowing that it exists is the whole of what leading can do. Consider the weight of that for Zhu Cheng. In Paper 3 she had put down Wei Heng's line, and her hands were empty: she did not know what, other than that line, could be said to a person at the bottom. On the other team she sees the team lead ask, "Where did you get stuck this week?" and, having listened, say, "Next week I'll go with you once." She had not known this could be done. Now she knows.

Not having seen it does not rule out coming to stand there through collision in actual dealings. The starting point of a chain says only this: the way of standing being read was not received from an earlier act of cultivation; what the person at the start may have seen elsewhere is read separately. A person who has seen has one more thing he knows.

It does not produce 15DD

Knowing that the position exists is not having come to stand there.

The education paper is plain: 15DD cannot be taught, and is not chiseled out; it "emerges in the collision with another 14DD."7 Paper 1 already set this down: the source of coming to stand there is collision in actual dealings. Zhu Cheng saw that team lead. Next time the intern is at the bottom and stands in front of her with the table, whether she can bring herself to ask "where did you get stuck," and whether, having asked, she can take in the answer, is her own affair in that encounter. She may be unable to get the question out.

The Theory of the University writes in the same place that whether a student avows that way of standing "is not a result to be obtained by compulsion; if he avows it, he can also take it back."8 The one who is led is led of his own will, and can withdraw.

Three things, read apart

At this point what lies at the earlier person's end can be counted. There are three things.

Giving conditions. Su Yao's "this step is yours to decide" is directed at Cheng Xi; it is cultivation. The previous paper read it.

Being seen. Su Yao owns her mistake to the technician, with Cheng Xi beside her. This paper reads it.

Collision in actual dealings. Suppose Cheng Xi later argues with Su Yao over how to repair a machine: he wants to replace a part, she wants to repair it, each has reasons he or she cannot set aside, and neither gives way. On that occasion Su Yao is not giving conditions and is not being seen; she is another person with a direction of her own whom Cheng Xi has run into.

The three can come from one person, as with Su Yao here. They need not come from one person, nor fall in one encounter. For Zhu Cheng the three are not all present, and seeing and collision come from different people: in the matter of how to treat a person at the bottom, no one in the example gave her conditions; the one she saw was the lead of another team; the one she ran into was the intern holding the table.

One encounter can also hold more than one of them. The occasion when Su Yao said "this step is yours to decide" was a giving of conditions; Cheng Xi also saw, on that same occasion, how she treats a newcomer's idea. Reading them apart means reading each for what it is, not saying they cannot be together.

Hence the proposition: the three are read apart, and are not assumed to come from the same person in the same encounter. It also follows that a person who was seen is not thereby answerable for whether the one who saw him later came to stand there. That team lead does not know Zhu Cheng was watching.

The later person's step

With all three present, the later person's step is still his own. Conditions can go unused; what was seen can go unavowed; a collision can be sidestepped or pushed back down. The series keeps this sentence in every paper. Here it means: however clear the leading, it reaches only as far as "now he knows."

§3 Templates and Making Public

CB29 Leading is not registered, not assessed, not inspected. When a practice is fixed as a template for the other to follow, what is passed on is content that can be followed. When a person deliberately makes public how he judges and how he answers disagreement, whether there is leading in it still depends on the actual effect and on what the other saw

Not registered, not assessed, not inspected

The Theory of the University holds that leading is neither a power of the teaching position nor its accountability; it is possible only by personal demonstration, is not registered as an accountability of the position, and is not assessed.4 It also writes that where space is left for leading, whether anyone thereby comes to see a direction is not counted as output and is not inspected.9 Those propositions are about how a construct treats leading. Here the matter is between people; the conclusion is the same, and so is the reason.

The company asks Su Yao to fill in a form: how many conversations with the newcomer per week. That is registering. Once registered, what is wanted is the count. The occasion when Su Yao owned her mistake to the technician is in no column; nor could it be entered, since it was not done for the newcomer.

Scoring against the Training Standard at year's end is assessing and inspecting. What can be assessed is "did the trainer ask back first." The education paper says what comes of doing leading in the manner of teaching, with "respect others" assessed as a rule: compliance, not recognition.10

Fixed as a template

The standard says: "When a newcomer asks a question, the trainer shall first ask back 'What do you think?' and shall not give the answer directly."

Su Yao's "What do you think?" was read in the previous paper: it was her judgment about this person, this time; she first had to judge whether Cheng Xi could take the question. Written as a clause it becomes a practice that can simply be followed: whoever asks, whatever is asked, ask back first. The one who follows it does not need to judge.

That is a template. This series reads it thus: when a practice is fixed as a template for the other to follow, what is passed on is content that can be followed. Content has its uses; Paper 1 said content can be taught and written down. But it is the first of the three things, not the third. The standard goes out to every trainer, and "What do you think?" travels far; what Su Yao was doing when she said those words did not travel with the clause.

Cheng Xi does not ask back; he lays out two paths and lets the newcomer choose. By the standard he fails. By this paper's reading, whether in doing so he is giving without doing it for the other depends on what those occasions actually opened, not on whether he resembles Su Yao.

Deliberately making public

At the crew meeting Su Yao told the whole story of her wrong diagnosis. She did it deliberately: she wanted to tell it, and knew people would listen. Is this "doing it for show," and therefore only content?

The line here is not drawn at whether it was deliberate. It is drawn at whether it was fixed as a template for the other to follow. Once fixed, what is passed on is content, and it is teaching; and if, further, the other's own judgment and way of standing are made in advance into a standard and people are inspected against it, it falls within the seeking that Paper 7 excludes.

In telling that story Su Yao did not say, "from now on, when you make a mistake, you too will tell it at the crew meeting like this." She laid out how she had judged, where she went wrong, and how she owned it. Among the listeners, some took away only "that sensor line is easy to miss": content reached them. Some saw something else: a person who has trained people for ten years saying before the whole crew that she missed a line. What the latter saw lies with them.

Hence the proposition: when a person deliberately makes public how he judges and how he answers disagreement, whether there is leading in it still depends on the actual effect and on what the other saw. Making public deliberately is not automatically leading, and not automatically not.

Stipulate one more case. Su Yao owns her mistake to the technician, and on the way back says to Cheng Xi: "Did you see how I handled that? From now on you do the same." There are three things here, read apart.

How she treated the technician at the time: by stipulation, she owned that he had a point.

What she afterward required of Cheng Xi: the later sentence is teaching, and what it teaches is a practice. Add "in every situation, without exception," and come back to inspect him against the pattern, and it has become a template.

What Cheng Xi actually saw: that lies with him.

The later sentence does not cancel the earlier scene. The side of the earlier scene that was seen is still there; a lesson has been added after it. Whether in her own mind she was thinking "let Cheng Xi learn from this" is not read here, and is not used to draw the line. To read the earlier scene itself as not counting, a different stipulation would be needed: that she was only acting toward the technician, and that at that moment he was merely a prop. That is another example.

§4 After Falling Back

CB30 What is seen includes how one turns back after falling back

Su Yao said to that client, "If you think we're not good enough, go somewhere else." By stipulation she was not, at that moment, treating him as an end: the sentence removed his place to go on objecting. Taken at the letter, "go somewhere else" could also be a statement of the limits of the service; what is read here is the stipulated case. The upstream series read by scope: there is no one who stands purely at that position; "the direction is read by one operation at a time, falling back is read as it occurs, and it does not overturn the direction; after falling back, this end can turn back."11

The next day she calls back and says, "I went too far yesterday."

Cheng Xi was beside her both times. What he saw was not a person who never loses her temper. He saw this: she lost her temper; she did not treat it as not having happened; she did not wait for the other to speak first; and in turning back she did not add "but you were out of line yesterday too."

What is seen in this scene is precisely how one turns back after falling back. It is the same kind of thing as "you're right on this one" in the earlier scene: recognition, this time just after having failed at it.

The proposition carries weight. If a person lets others see only the times he held, what is seen is a figure no one can match: the one watching can suppose that people at that position do not fall back, whereas he himself does, and so can feel that the position has nothing to do with him. When falling back and turning back are part of what is seen, the one watching comes to know that the position is one stood in by people who drop out of it and walk back.

This does not say that falling back is good, or that one is to let it be seen on purpose. Only: it is there, and it is seen too.

§5 What Is Seen

CB31 What is seen through particular practices is a way of standing that need not be copied: the later person need not treat people the way the earlier one did. Through a book or a screen a way of standing may also be seen: in how the author treats the reader here and now, in an act that has itself been left behind, and also by way of an account of an actual encounter; an account has to be checked for its grounds. That a later reader saw something is not read back into something the author did toward that reader at the time. How a person treats others as mere means is seen just the same; that is not called leading, and belongs to Paper 2

A way of standing, not a practice

Cheng Xi does not train the way Su Yao does. She asks back; he does not, and lays out two paths.

If what leading passes on were a practice, Cheng Xi would simply not have learned it. This series reads the other way: what is seen through particular practices is a way of standing that need not be copied. What Cheng Xi saw in "What do you think?", "this step is yours to decide," "you're right on this one" is giving to a person without doing it for him, and taking the other's judgment as a judgment. A way of standing can only be seen by way of particular practices; there is no other road. But what is seen is not those sentences.

So the later person need not treat people the way the earlier one did. Cheng Xi says little, and has his own practice. Suppose that when he lays out two paths the newcomer picks the one he himself would not, and he says, "Fine, try it; I'm here if it goes wrong": the way of standing is in that. Suppose he lays out two paths and, whenever the newcomer picks the one he disapproves of, says "think again" until the newcomer picks correctly: the two paths are still there, and the way of standing is gone.

The reverse case was read in Paper 1: a practice copied word for word, with the way of standing not arriving.

Through a book or a screen

A person who is not present can also be seen: through a book, through a screen. There are then three things through which something can be seen, and each is checked separately.

The first is how the author treats the reader here and now. Suppose Su Yao later writes the procedure up as a booklet containing these words: "What follows is the sequence I use. The machine in your hands I have not seen, and you know it better than I do; where a step does not fit, go by what you see." What the reader sees here is how the author, in the book, treats him as a reader. Cultivation Theory, reading writing addressed to many, sets down two points among others: the author cannot ask whether the reader is willing, whether it suits him, whether the time is right, "so he does not answer the three in advance for the reader"; and "The reader's objection is not written down in advance as a symptom."12 That passage does exactly this: in the book, it leaves a place for the reader.

The second is an act that has itself been left behind. Letters exchanged, a record made at the time, a recording: these are what an actual encounter left. A person reading them stands where Cheng Xi stood at the client's site: looking on. He was not treated that way himself; neither was Cheng Xi.

The third is an account of an actual encounter. The booklet could also contain: "Once a client told me my diagnosis was wrong. I did not bristle; I went through the machine again and owned the mistake to him." This is an account, and it is content. It can also be a medium through which a way of standing is seen; the Anthropology series, at the scale of civilizations, writes that showing goes deeper than telling.13 It is one remove further than the first two: what the reader sees is what the person giving the account wrote down. So an account has to be checked for its grounds: whether the writer was present, which occasion is described, whether it agrees with other material. And a reliable account still does not certify which layer the person described is at as a whole.

The three do not exclude one another, and one booklet can contain all of them. Suppose that after that story the next line reads, "So all of you are to follow my sequence exactly and not go deciding things for yourselves." How the reader is being treated here and now is read from that line; the story remains an account, and its grounds can be checked as before.

Attribution

Through a book there is one more boundary. That a later reader saw something is not read back into something the author did toward that reader at the time.

Cultivation Theory reads Rilke's letters. They were letters to one person, directed at that one person; the recipient later made them into a book, and many strangers read it. That paper writes: "for these readers the book was an occasion for evocation. That one act directed toward many was not Rilke's."14 This is the second of the three above: the letters are an act itself left behind. Later readers do see in them how Rilke treated a young man, and that is real; to say that Rilke thereby cultivated each later reader would be to read it back.

This series keeps the account accordingly. Seeing is a matter at the seer's end. The writing left behind is a medium, not the other end of a relation; the entry is made at the seer's end, and not as something the author once did toward him.

Treating people as mere means is seen too

A last sentence, so as not to tilt the matter. Being seen does not pick a direction. Wei Heng, years ago, saw how Lao Guo made the person at the bottom stand through the meeting; had Cheng Xi been with someone else, what he saw could have been how to push back at a client and never turn round. How a person treats others as mere means is seen by those nearby just the same, and likewise lets them "know there is such a way of doing things."

That is not called leading. It is what Paper 2 reads: the line about how people are to be treated travels downstream inside content, and one of its roads is precisely being seen. Here again the two sides have the same shape: both pass through being seen. The difference lies in what is seen.

§6 Two References Back

Xiao Hong writes what she saw. The previous paper used a passage of Xiao Hong on Lu Xun: he detested the careless letters young people wrote, and still opened and read them one by one, late into the night.15 The previous paper read it for how he treated what young people wrote to him, as set down by Xiao Hong, who was present. Here it is read from another side: this is what Xiao Hong saw. The letters were not written to her; she gave an account of what she saw: he detested the carelessness, and still read each one. All that is read here is that she saw it and wrote it down. What she later did is not supplied from this passage.

A person reading her piece today is reading the third of the three in §5: an account. Its ground is that she was present.

Rilke's letters. Referred to in §5. They are the second of the three, an act itself left behind. Their use here is for the boundary of attribution: what is seen through a book is real, and is not read back into something the author did toward later readers.

§7 Drawing Together, and Downstream

This paper has set out five propositions. Together they say: leading is the side of a person's living out recognition, in his own life and dealings, that another person sees, and having activities of one's own is not in itself leading. It lets someone know that the position exists and does not produce 15DD; giving conditions, being seen, and collision in actual dealings are read apart, and are not assumed to come from the same person in the same encounter; the later person's step remains his own. Leading is not registered, not assessed, not inspected; fixed as a template for the other to follow, what is passed on is content; where a person deliberately makes public how he judges, whether there is leading still depends on the actual effect and on what the other saw. What is seen includes how one turns back after falling back. What is seen through particular practices is a way of standing that need not be copied; through a book or a screen it may also be seen, in how the author treats the reader, in an act itself left behind, and by way of an account of an encounter, the account to be checked for its grounds; that a later reader saw something is not read back into something the author did toward him; treating people as mere means is seen just the same, and is not called leading.

The paper does not show that a person who has seen will come to stand there, gives no method for leading, does not rate what anyone has lived out, and certifies no one's layer.

What the next paper reads. Su Yao films the procedure and posts the videos online. She knows none of the people watching. The first few get little attention; one, with a pressing title, gets ten times the views. The platform shows her a chart: the second at which viewers leave. How does she cut the next one? And the people on the other side of the screen: is there a relation between her and them?

Downstream. One person addressing many: Paper 6. Not fixing the step downstream in advance: Paper 7.

Acknowledgments

This paper is signed by Han Qin alone; the author decided every argument and choice and bears sole responsibility for the text. In drafting, the author used AI models from various developers as tools. The English edition is an independent rewrite of the Chinese text, not a translation; where the two differ, the Chinese governs.

Notes

  1. Teacher-Student Theory, Paper 0. ↩︎
  2. The education paper. The same passage continues: "Leading is possible only by personal demonstration." The original speaks of adult and child; this series reads between adults and takes its shape. ↩︎
  3. Parent-Child Theory, Paper 7, the section on PC41. ↩︎
  4. Theory of the University, DX6. ↩︎
  5. Theory of the University, Paper 1, §7. ↩︎
  6. Moral Law, Paper 6, §5.7. The original speaks of discernment in mixed reality. ↩︎
  7. The education paper. "Nurtured" there is the special sense in that paper's threefold division. ↩︎
  8. Theory of the University, Paper 1, §7. ↩︎
  9. Theory of the University, DX36. ↩︎
  10. The education paper. ↩︎
  11. Teacher-Student Theory TS1. Parent-Child Theory PC1 has the same shape. ↩︎
  12. Cultivation Theory HY38 and HY39. ↩︎
  13. Anthropology Series, Paper III, §3. The original speaks of what literature does at the scale of civilizations. ↩︎
  14. Cultivation Theory, Paper 7. ↩︎
  15. Xiao Hong, "Remembering Our Teacher" (1939). See Paper 4, §8. ↩︎

References

All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version.

I · SAE works directly cited in this paper

Qin, H. (2026). Education as Subject-Condition: A Philosophy of Education [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18867389

Qin, H. (2026). Handing Over and Leading (SAE Parent-Child Theory, Paper 7) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24121559

Qin, H. (2026). University Teaching (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293737

Qin, H. (2026). University Governance (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 7) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293757

Qin, H. (2026). The Place of Teacher-Student Theory (SAE Teacher-Student Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24267256

Qin, H. (2026). Writing for Many (SAE Cultivation Theory, Paper 7) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154522

Qin, H. (2026). Mixed Reality: The Intermediate State of 14DD Growing toward 15DD (SAE Moral Law Series, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20108658

Qin, H. (2026). 15DD: The Emergence of "Humanity as an End" (SAE Anthropology Series, Paper III) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19559566

II · External works

Xiao Hong. (1939). "Ji women de daoshi: Lu Xun xiansheng shenghuo de pianduan" [Remembering Our Teacher: Fragments of Mr. Lu Xun's Life]. Zhongxuesheng (wartime semi-monthly), no. 10. (After the text on Chinese Wikisource.)

A note on this source. External works are paraphrased here, not quoted. The paraphrases were made from the Chinese text of this paper and have not been checked word by word against published English editions or translations. What was and was not checked is stated after the references of Paper 4. Corrections from readers are welcome.

Interfaces

Main upstream: the education paper; Parent-Child Theory, Paper 7 (the section on PC41); Theory of the University, Paper 1 (DX6; §7) and Paper 7 (DX36); Cultivation Theory, Paper 7 (HY38, HY39; the passage on Rilke).

Also used: Teacher-Student Theory, Paper 0 and TS1; Moral Law, Paper 6 (§5.7, for the distinction); Anthropology Series, Paper III (another scale, for comparison).

This series: follows Paper 1 (CB2, a way of standing; CB3, the source is collision), Paper 2 (CB11), Paper 3 (CB14), Paper 4 (CB22, CB24). Paper 6 takes up being seen on a screen; Paper 7, not inspecting.