Self-as-an-End
SAE Propagation of Cultivation · Paper 0

The Place of the Propagation of Cultivation
涵育的传播的位置

Han Qin (秦汉) · Independent Researcher · 2026
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24351749 · Full PDF on Zenodo · CC BY 4.0
Abstract

This series reads one thing: how cultivation passes downstream through the relations between people. What it reads is the person in the middle of two connected relations: in the earlier one he is at the receiving end, and in the later one at the giving end. This is the series' Paper 0, written last and placed first. It sets out no new propositions; it says where the series stands within SAE, what it reads and does not read, and how it reads, and it gathers the propositions of the seven papers in one place.

The main line is three sentences. Propagation is not anyone's purpose; it is a result of people having come into relation. On the side of cultivation it is unsought, and read only in looking back. What passes on can go toward colonization or toward cultivation. A person who is willing to receive, whose own judgment opens up, and who then goes on to cultivate another is a link in the chain along which cultivation propagates. A practice carrying the direction of colonization repeats downstream without requiring that the person in the middle first open up a judgment of his own, and whether it takes hold in the next person is read separately; for cultivation to pass downstream by one link, three things of the middle person's own have to happen. What can be taught is content; what can be given is conditions; what can be seen is how a person stands. At every link, the step downstream starts again from the person in the middle.

The series is against the propagation of colonization, and "against" falls only on two things in the first person: not letting it occupy oneself, and not doing it to others. It identifies no person and no tradition. It reads only adults, and only the road that runs through relations; propaganda and the rules of platforms lie on the institutional side. It reads one link at a time, and no link is guaranteed; the level of the community and trends across generations are another scale, read by the Moral Law series, and the two are not on one level and do not cancel.

§1 Place

SAE writes about the single person, about institutions, and about what passes between people. On that third side, Relation Theory set down what all relations have, and its branches read love, marriage, cooperation, parent and child, teacher and student. Cultivation Theory opened a separate line, reading how one person gives conditions for another person's own law.

All of these read one relation: two ends, and what happens between them. One thing falls into the gap between them. Cultivation Theory handed it over in its abstract: the sources of cultivation are written at both ends, while its setting and the way it is passed on belong to the side that writes about what passes between people.1 Teacher-Student Theory registered it: how the one who was taught later teaches others, and how cultivation is passed on between people, are subjects for afterward.2 A special paper of Relation Theory registered it too: the spread of cultivation is to be treated separately.3

This series takes up those three registrations. What they call the way cultivation is passed on, or its spread, is what is called propagation here. It does not read one relation; it reads the point at which two relations join in one person. It is therefore not one more branch of Relation Theory: it does not read a kind of relation, and reads something that lies between any two relations. Nor is it a sequel to Cultivation Theory: that series reads how to give; this one reads what, after the giving, arrives at the next person by way of the one who received.

§2 Range

What is read. A toward B, and later B toward C; B is read.

Adults only. In the two relations this series reads, the receiver is already an adult; the lower bound is university students. The Theory of the University has said that cultivation has no end point, and occurs between adults too.4 If a person's earlier relation took place before he was an adult, that stretch is not read here: Parent-Child Theory and Teacher-Student Theory have written it, and it is acknowledged as they read it. He can be a link all the same; the reading picks up from his adulthood, and uses only material he wrote as an adult. A childhood memoir written in adulthood does not bring the childhood events it describes into the range read here.

The side of colonization, for contrast only. One paper, Paper 2.

Three units. One act: which way this end is headed in this matter, and what was actually opened or sealed. One relation: which acts took place between two positions. One link, spoken of by person: how those acts join up in one person as being willing to receive, judgment opening up, and going on to give. The giving and receiving positions are recorded by a single operation; A, B and C are not presupposed to be three different people, nor three generations. C can be A; the structure does not exclude it; the series takes its examples only from cases where C is not A.

What is not read.

Not read Where it lies
Propaganda: one-to-many as an institutional arrangement; the algorithms and rules of platforms A theory of propaganda on the institutional side, not yet written. The provisions themselves are acknowledged but not judged, and registered as conditions
Accounts run by institutions; how an institution arranges for a craft to be carried on The institutional side. This is a narrowing of the range of examples
How a construct gives conditions for cultivation Written in the Theory of the University
How institutions conscript individuals by way of the relational layer Foundation Paper 5; Relation Theory, Paper 5. Used as they stand, not rewritten
How a message spreads through a population Not read. This series reads the road that runs through relations
Preservation and transmission at the scale of civilizations Anthropology Series, Paper III; Meaning Theory, Paper 0
The level of the community and trends across generations; cultivation and colonization at the scale of institutions Moral Law, Papers 6 and 9. For the boundary, see §6
Minors; parent and child, teacher and pupil in school Parent-Child Theory; Teacher-Student Theory
B giving back to A Positive-Sum, Unsought. Registered only
What is passed on by way of AI Cultivation Theory, Paper 8. A tool has no law of its own and does not occupy the middle position;5 registered, not developed

§3 Stance

This series has a stance: against the propagation of colonization.

"Against" falls only on two things in the first person. Against being colonized oneself: not letting what lands on one come to occupy the place of one's own judgment. Against colonizing others oneself: not pouring it in as it was received, and not pouring in its opposite either. Together, Paper 3 calls these two breaking.

So the series pins no labels. It does not attach "colonization" to a person, a tradition, a trade or an account, and is not written as criticism of how others pass things on. Paper 2 uses made-up examples, no historical ones, and identifies no actual person. Directions are not labels;6 there is no criterion guaranteed to settle which place has taken hold of a person, and others do not judge it for him.

Nor does the stance issue oughts. The series does not say that a person who received cultivation ought to give onward, nor that anyone ought to break anything. It reads structure: what each side requires of the person in the middle when it goes downstream.

§4 How It Reads

The ways of reading used across the seven papers are gathered here.

Three things pass through a person. Content: knowledge, skill, sayings, rules; it can be taught and written down. An occupied place: what was poured in and has come to occupy the place of judgment. A way of standing: giving to another person without doing it for him. The three can be present in one person together; they are read apart and do not cancel one another.

A chain can be spoken of; it is not a bearer. A chain is broken down into acts between pairs, entered on separate accounts; passing through a third person does not release the earlier stretch.7 No overall direction is totalled for a chain and no overall account is kept; a school of masters and pupils, a school of thought, a tradition, a generation is not made the subject of a sentence.

How relations connect requires material. That two relations each hold and are alike in direction is not enough to say that the earlier one entered the later by way of B. Historical material is read by this rule: where there are only a few names and a few meetings, no link is recorded.

Conclusions in made-up examples are stipulations. Whether conditions opened, whether a judgment was formed, whether a place was occupied, are given by the example; a sentence, an operation, or the absence of something can be material, and does not by itself yield those readings. Where the material is not enough to divide the cases, "not yet known" is recorded. Where there is no suitable actual case, the series uses made-up examples.

Records, and no summing. Content being carried on can be arranged, checked and recorded; such records do not measure, certify or sum what is gained on the ontological side. The body papers do not speak of the layer of cultivation in headcounts.

Downstream is not used to rejudge upstream. How B later acts toward C does not rejudge what A did toward B at the time. New material that appears later can correct a reading; that is not rejudging.

No necessity written, no comparison of strength. It is not written that colonization necessarily passes downstream, nor that it necessarily takes hold in the next person; it is not written that cultivation cannot be passed on, nor that it always will be. The body papers do not compare the two sides as easier or harder, faster or slower, stronger or weaker. One sentence in the foundation papers speaks of an asymmetry between the two sides;8 this series uses it only as a citation, and what it writes itself is the structure at that point: the difference lies in the person in the middle; one side does not wait for him, and the other waits for three things of his.

Carried over from upstream. DD names a stance, not a label on a person, and layers are recorded by a single operation; the payoff layer and the ontological layer are two books, each kept on its own; provisions themselves are acknowledged but not judged; a reading states toward whom, in which matter, over which period, on what material, and where material is lacking it stays undetermined; no mind-reading; historical material is limited to what an adult author wrote and made public, and only how he wrote it is read.

§5 Shared Words

  • Propagation / transmission. Propagation in this series means from one relation to the next, by way of a person. The "transmission chain" of the foundation papers means an effect passing from the institutional layer through the relational layer to a person.9 The two words are not interchanged. "Propagation" in the information-theory and physics papers, and transmission at the scale of civilizations in the Anthropology series, are other senses.
  • Chain, link, starting point. A link means that receiving and giving have joined up in one person. On the path being read, the way of standing of the person at the starting point was not received from an earlier act of cultivation; he is not a link, and what he may have received elsewhere is read separately. A chain is not a bearer.
  • Three sets of three. The three things in a link are the middle person's own: being willing to receive, judgment opening up, going on to give. Two other sets of three appear: in Cultivation Theory and Action Theory, the three a giver does not answer in the other's place when assessing, namely whether he is willing, whether he is suited, whether the time is ripe; and, in this series, the three that pass through B: content, an occupied place, a way of standing.
  • Colonization. Two senses. Relation Theory takes the wider sense, the direction of an act; Value Theory takes a narrow sense in the field where value occurs, a state, and states that the narrow sense is one particular way the wider one falls in that field.10 When this series contrasts colonization with cultivation it uses the wider sense; when it speaks of the place that has taken hold in a person it borrows the narrow one, as an extension. Value Theory says in the same place that the opposite of cultivation is not colonization; that is said on the narrow sense's table, which is not the table of the contrast drawn here.
  • Indoctrination. Reserved for the special sense of Teacher-Student Theory: where the act has already written for the other and crowded out his own unfolding, which is violation. This series' main material is what has not crossed that line; for direction it says "pouring in and occupying."
  • Breaking. Its two first-person sides. Upstream writes of a breaking of intergenerational transmission that falls at the first choice, in a conflict, not to colonize; the two connect and are not the same.
  • Seek. The narrow sense only: fixing in advance, producing to that specification, inspecting against it. What has to be checked is what is being inspected: whether the other's own judgment and way of standing have been made into a standard for inspection. Settling, doing and checking that are aimed at conditions, technical content, or particular arrangements both have avowed are not called seeking. Open hoping is not included.
  • A way of standing. As the Theory of the University uses the phrase in speaking of leading. Two other places upstream use it for a stance the author himself has set up; the sense differs.
  • Being seen / observation at a distance. Being seen is the side that leading is, and lands on the seer's knowing of one more position. Observation at a distance, in the Moral Law series, is discernment, and lands on a judgment about the person observed.
  • Cultivation. As in Cultivation Theory: one person giving conditions to another. The education paper divides teaching, nurturing and leading into three, and "nurturing" there is a special sense of the same Chinese word; where this series cites that passage, it says so on the spot.
  • Gain. On the ontological side, the unfolding of legislative activity; gains and losses at the payoff layer are entered as payoff.

§6 The Boundary with Growth Necessity

The Moral Law series makes a strong claim: that the growth of 14DD toward 15DD is structurally necessary at long, cross-generational scales.11 Every paper of this series says "not guaranteed": a person who received is not necessarily willing to receive; one who is willing does not necessarily find his judgment opening up; one whose judgment opens up does not necessarily go on to give; and when he gives, the other does not necessarily take it up. How do the two sit together?

Three sentences only.

The first: this series reads one link, and no link is guaranteed. That is said at the scale of one person and two relations.

The second: what that Moral Law paper speaks of is an aggregate tendency at the level of the community and across generations, and it states its own scale: many generations, not an individual lifetime; and "Growth necessity is a cross-generational statistical operator — not necessity at every specific node or specific era".12 Its necessity rests on four roots: the inexhaustibility of the thing-in-itself, the structure of recognition, subjectivity as activity, and an economic a priori mechanism.13 None of the four is that every act of cultivation is passed on. At the cross-generational layer what it writes is that the next generation grows up in an environment where 15DD is denser; there is person-to-person accumulation in that layer, and it is spoken of at the scale of the aggregate, not brought down to any one link.

The third: the two are not on one level and do not cancel. From one link's not being guaranteed it does not follow that the tendency fails; from the tendency's holding it does not follow that any one link succeeds. This series does not prove that paper's claim a second time, and does not revise it from a single link. How many links aggregate into a tendency, and what lies in between, this series has not read. The Moral Law series speaks of person-to-person accumulation in two places, both at the scale of the aggregate.14

Moral Law, Paper 9, at the scale of institutional architecture, has one more sentence that can stand here as the other side of the boundary: "macroscopic phase transition requires waiting, but microscopic recognition is never delayed."15 Everything this series reads lies on the microscopic side: this time, toward this person.

§7 Division of Labor

With Cultivation Theory. Cultivation Theory reads how to give: how far, how without doing it for the other, when not to give. This series reads what comes after the giving. It uses Cultivation Theory's three questions, its assessing first, and its "inwardly a cannot-not, toward the other not a debt" as they stand, and does not set them up again.

With Teacher-Student Theory and Parent-Child Theory. Each reads one kind of relation, with the stretch before adulthood as its home ground. This series picks up from adulthood, acknowledges what they have read, and does not go back over it. Teacher-Student Theory handed over leading, and Paper 5 takes it up.

With Relation Theory and Positive-Sum, Unsought. Relation Theory supplies the threshold of relation, the two directions, pairwise accounting, and the reading of sediment; this series uses them as they stand. Positive-Sum, Unsought supplies the narrow sense of seeking, "carried out," the separation of two layers, and no book-keeping and no offsetting; this series carries them over to "passing on," marks each extension, and bears each itself. B giving back to A is that paper's business.

With the Theory of the University. That series reads how a construct leaves room for cultivation and leading; this one reads the level of persons. Its definition of judgment, its point that judgment cannot be handed over along with rules, and its point that leading is not registered or assessed are used here as they stand.

With the institutional side. Propaganda, the rules of platforms, and the operations and succession arrangements of institutions are all handed over. The theory of propaganda has not been written; what is handed over is only registered, and none of its conclusions are borrowed.

§8 Interfaces and Historical Material, Gathered

The interfaces of each paper with traditions and with historical material are gathered here. Each goes only as far as the division of labor, and none is an interface with a whole body of work.

Paper Interface and material How far it is read
1 The closing line of the Zhuangzi chapter on caring for life, Yangsheng zhu (the fire passes on), as read upstream; a passage of self-description in Chapter 1 of Rogers, On Becoming a Person The shape of succession is taken, and the figure is not used to supply a way of standing handed over intact; only that the path he wrote down ran through something that did not work
2 None Made-up examples only; no one identified
3 One passage in Douglass, Life and Times, Part II, Chapter 3 His end only: afterward he did not go on limiting what he said by that division; whether it was refusal before it took hold or loosening after is not settled; the other party is not judged
4 Lu Xun, "Mr. Fujino"; Xiao Hong, "Remembering Our Teacher" He set down what he received, that he received without taking everything as given, and that the earlier relation entered his writing; whether it entered his treatment of the young stays undetermined
5 Xiao Hong's passage again; Rilke's letters as read in Cultivation Theory She saw and wrote it down, and what a reader today reads is an account; the letters are an act itself left behind; what is seen through a book is not read back into something the author did toward later readers
6 None Made-up examples only; no living creator identified
7 Wittgenstein's preface to the Philosophical Investigations, as cited upstream; one remark in Culture and Value; one sentence of "Mr. Fujino" again A hope with no inspection behind it; a remark carrying his own qualification; that the road of medicine was not carried on does not mean nothing was left

What was and was not checked in the external works each paper uses is stated after that paper's references. Corrections from readers, to the paraphrases and to the readings, are welcome.

The Anthropology series, at the scale of civilizations, writes of how 15DD spreads through literature, one reader at a time.16 That is another matter at another scale: what is read there is a work reaching a reader, which upstream classes as evocation; what is read here is a link between one person and another. The two are neighbours and do not join.

§9 Remainders and Open Questions

When the series has been read through, these remain.

  1. Collision at the starting point. A chain has a starting point, and the person there came by his way of standing through collision in actual dealings. How collision brings a person to stand in that direction, this series only cites from upstream and has not read.
  2. The receiving side: loosening afterward. Upstream says that internal colonization cannot be broken from within alone, and lists three conditions under which an intervention from outside can work. How those three conditions hold between adults, this series has not checked one by one.
  3. How the stretch before adulthood connects to what comes after. This series acknowledges that stretch and does not read it. How what a person received before adulthood entered his giving as an adult requires material for the connection; how such material is to be read remains open.
  4. Giving back. B giving back to A is registered only.
  5. The limits of the historical material. A link takes three kinds of material: the stretch of receiving, the stretch of giving, and how they connect, each written down by the person himself or by someone present. Among the material this series found, none has all three. Whether this is because such material is hard to come by, or because few people have ever written such a thing down, is not judged here.
  6. Many links and a tendency. No link is guaranteed, and the tendency lies at another scale. How one gets from the one to the other has not been read. The note to §6 points to two places upstream that speak of person-to-person accumulation.
  7. The theory of propaganda is unwritten. What that theory would read is the provisions themselves. For an actual case, the method for checking apart the prescribed part and what a person added is already upstream: first find out what the provision is; where it cannot be obtained, register that the background is unchecked. What is lacking is particular material, not that theory.
  8. AI. A tool does not occupy the middle position. Where a person gives by way of AI, what passes through him is registered and not developed.

§10 The Propositions of the Series

Paper 1 Propagation Is a Result

CB1 Propagation is a result, not a purpose. Once people have relations with one another, what an earlier relation left in a person enters his dealings with someone else. What enters can head toward colonization or toward cultivation.

CB2 Three things pass through the person in the middle, and they are read apart: content can be taught and written down; the downstream repetition of an occupied place does not require that his own judgment has first opened up; a way of standing cannot be taught. The three can be present in one person, and none cancels another.

CB3 A chain has a starting point. On the path being read, the starting person's way of standing was not received from an earlier act of cultivation; he is not a link in the sense of Paper 4. Its source is collision in actual dealings. What he received in other relations and other matters is read separately. So the propagation of cultivation is not the only path to this direction, and a chain that breaks off does not mean there is nothing afterward.

CB4 The unit of reading is the place where two relations meet in one person. A acts toward B; B later acts toward C; B is read. The positions of giver and receiver are recorded by a single operation; A, B and C are positions in two relations, and presuppose neither three different people nor three generations. B is one person: at the receiving end the first time, at the giving end the second. A link is spoken of by person, and the opening of judgment in between is read in looking back.

CB5 One may speak of a chain, but a chain is not a bearer. A chain is broken down into effects between pairs, each entered on its own account; passing through B does not release A from his part; a chain is given no overall direction and no overall account.

CB6 That two relations each hold and head in similar directions is not yet enough to say the earlier one passed through B into the later one; material is needed that shows how they connect. It need not be the only source, and B need not copy A.

CB7 The handing-on of content can be arranged, whether it was learned can be checked, and where it has reached can be recorded; such records do not measure, certify, or add up what is gained on the ontological side. A way of standing and each single effect are read one by one, and "how many people were cultivated" is not used as a measure of completion. That content has spread widely does not show the way of standing arrived with it; that no one took up the content does not show nothing was left.

CB8 What happens downstream is not used to rejudge what happened upstream. How B later acts toward C does not rejudge what A did toward B; A's gain from that occasion lies in that occasion, and is neither increased nor reduced by whether anything was passed on. New material that surfaces later can correct a misreading of that occasion.

Paper 2 How Colonization Propagates

CB9 Colonization has two senses. Value Theory Paper 3, on the field where value occurs, takes the narrow sense: colonization describes a state, in which some content occupies a position. This series borrows that sense for what has taken hold in a person (an extension, on this series' own account); when it says which way an act is headed, it follows Relation Theory H8: a direction, not a label.

CB10 A practice headed toward colonization can be repeated downstream without B first opening up his own judgment, avowing what is passed on, or having any motive to pass it on. B may do the same to C, or may not; whether it comes to occupy C's position of judgment is read separately, at C's end.

CB11 What was poured in can carry with it a line that says "this is how people are to be treated": content and practice travel downstream together. "Indoctrination" keeps the sense of Teacher-Student Theory TS11, where the subject is the teacher's position; applied between adults it is an extension.

CB12 An occupied place is read by positions: which are open and which are sealed, written by content-domain and period, with no overall direction assigned to a person or a relation. It can come about without conflict; that a stretch of dealings shows no dispute is not evidence that no place has been occupied.

Paper 3 The Propagation of Cultivation: Breaking

CB13 Breaking has two sides, both in the first person: not letting what lands on me occupy the place of my own judgment; and not colonizing others, whether by pouring in the same thing or its opposite. Merely having no occasion, pausing for a while, or switching to another way of managing people is not recorded as breaking on appearance alone.

CB14 The two sides need not arrive together. What took hold in a person may still be there while he no longer pours it into the next person: the giving side can come first. Not pouring in does not by itself mean being able to recognize the other.

CB15 The sources of the two sides are read apart, and do not exclude each other. The giving side is a choice a person makes when facing another person; declining to pass it on this time need not come from having been cultivated earlier. On the receiving side, where something has already taken hold, upstream writes that internal colonization cannot be broken from within alone; here conditions given by another person can be read. Either side may have conditions given by someone else, and on either side the step remains the person's own.

CB16 Breaking is not, in itself, cultivation; structurally it is read as a step in the 15DD direction. The breaking that upstream describes falls within a conflict: choosing, for the first time, not to colonize and not to withdraw recognition of the other; it requires only the entry, not maturity. Breaking in this series is further divided into a receiving side and a giving side, with direction read by one operation at a time; no single instance of declining to repeat certifies which layer the whole person is at. His own end is for him to confirm.

CB17 On the receiving side, there is no criterion guaranteed to close the question of how one knows that such a place in oneself has been occupied. The way of looking back follows Aesthetics Ray 13: try taking away the yardstick that person gave; this can be mistaken. No one else makes the judgment for him.

Paper 4 The Propagation of Cultivation: A Link

CB18 A person who is willing to receive, whose own judgment opens up, and who then goes on to cultivate another person is a link in the chain along which cultivation propagates.

CB19 All three rest with the person in the middle: whether he is willing to receive, whether his judgment opens up, whether he goes on to give and, in giving, whether he takes over the step that is the other's to take. They are not the three things Cultivation Theory speaks of (whether the other is willing, whether he is suited, whether the time is ripe): those are what a giver, in assessing, does not answer in the other's place; these are what a link requires.

CB20 Being willing to receive is not taking everything as given. The receiver can disagree, can change it, can take only part.

CB21 Judgment is read by Action Theory's definition. It cannot be delivered along with rules; it can only be practised. Doing as told, or arriving at the same conclusion, does not prove that it has formed.

CB22 A link is reckoned up to "carried out": he took on the direction of cultivation, and his act actually opened conditions for another person. That B's giving toward C was carried out does not mean C has become the next link; whether C is willing to receive, whether his judgment opens up, whether he later gives, are each read separately. Where something was given and the conditions did not actually open, it is recorded as it is.

CB23 A single act of B's toward C can carry both directions: making space in one place, pouring in and occupying in another. The two are recorded separately and are not netted out.

CB24 Giving is also practice: to give to someone, one has to judge where he is stuck and how far to give. The third of the three returns to the second.

CB25 Giving onward is not a debt: having received, one does not thereby owe anyone. For a person standing in the 15DD direction, cultivation is inwardly his own cannot-not; toward the other it is a direction, not a debt. Whether to give this time, to this person, is first assessed, and what is judged is conditions; that the time is not ripe means not doing it this time, and does not mean he no longer stands in this direction. Where he did not give and, looking back, the judgment was wrong, or where he judged that this was his to give, the judgment still stood, and he did not give, Cultivation Theory records it as failing to do his part; this entry comes from his own judgment, not from having received. That his judgment opened up and he did not go on to give does not rejudge the earlier cultivation as having come to nothing, and says nothing about anyone's character.

CB26 Each link has a separate account of time and effort, and this end's gain is not used to offset it.

Paper 5 The Propagation of Cultivation: Leading

CB27 Leading is the side of a person's living out recognition, in his own life and dealings, that another person sees. Having activities of one's own is not in itself leading.

CB28 Leading lets someone know that the position exists; it does not produce 15DD. Giving conditions, being seen, and collision in actual dealings are read apart, and are not assumed to come from the same person in the same encounter; the later person's step remains his own.

CB29 Leading is not registered, not assessed, not inspected. When a practice is fixed as a template for the other to follow, what is passed on is content that can be followed. When a person deliberately makes public how he judges and how he answers disagreement, whether there is leading in it still depends on the actual effect and on what the other saw.

CB30 What is seen includes how one turns back after falling back.

CB31 What is seen through particular practices is a way of standing that need not be copied: the later person need not treat people the way the earlier one did. Through a book or a screen a way of standing may also be seen: in how the author treats the reader here and now, in an act that has itself been left behind, and also by way of an account of an actual encounter; an account has to be checked for its grounds. That a later reader saw something is not read back into something the author did toward that reader at the time. How a person treats others as mere means is seen just the same; that is not called leading, and belongs to Paper 2.

Paper 6 The Propagation of Cultivation: Independent Creators

CB32 Where a person's speech, writing, or something he leaves behind identifiably and actually enters the conditions of occurrence of a reader or viewer, there is a relation between the two ends; a one-way relation counts. Where one person addresses many, each relation holds separately and is entered on its own account. The same goes for writing books, giving talks, and the work of independent creators.

CB33 An independent creator stands in the middle position: what he receives and what he gives are read apart. On his side, what is read is whether the yardstick of traffic has come to occupy the place where he himself judges what to make and how. What he has really avowed is not for others to judge; whether positions are open or sealed in his public work and dealings can be read. This paper takes its material from made-up examples only. The line between person and institution is drawn not by account but by a single operation: the part of the content an institution prescribes goes to the institutional side; what the person on camera adds of his own is looked at separately.

CB34 Traffic lies at the payoff layer; it can be recorded and can be sought. The layer of cultivation is not on that table. Seeking traffic, seeking commercial success, or using retention data does not by itself show that the audience enters his table only as an item; what matters is how the particular work and dealings treat the audience's judgment.

CB35 "How many people were cultivated" is not used as a measure. What he can settle, do and check is whether each piece leaves room: whether it gives reasons, whether it leaves a place for the viewer's disagreement, whether it answers in the viewer's place.

CB36 A single act can open conditions in many relations. In each relation where it actually opens conditions, the act is recorded as carried out; whether a viewer later becomes a link rests with each viewer. Where there is no feedback, the matter stays undetermined, and it is not turned round into a claim that nothing happened.

CB37 On a platform, too, one may be seen: how he treats his audience, how he owns a mistake. This connects to Paper 5.

Paper 7 The Propagation of Cultivation: Unsought

CB38 Cultivation does not seek success. Whether the other's judgment opens up, whether he gives onward, is neither fixed in advance nor inspected. What can be settled, done and checked is possibility: whether this act of mine left room, and what it opened.

CB39 Carried over to propagation: one does not seek that it be passed on; what one can do is see that the conditions for its being passed on are there. On the side of cultivation, propagation is read only in looking back, in the same form as the "unsought" of Positive-Sum, Unsought: where it can be read, it is recorded as it is; where it cannot, that too is recorded as it is; looking back can be mistaken.

CB40 The seeking excluded here is taken in the narrow sense: fixing in advance, producing to that specification, inspecting against it. What has to be checked is what is being inspected: whether the other's own judgment and way of standing have been made, in advance, into a standard for production and inspection; if so, calling it by another name leaves it excluded. Checking conditions, technical content, and particular arrangements both have avowed is read separately. Hoping that involves no inspection is not included.

CB41 Fixing in advance how the other is to treat the next person carries the direction of colonization at that point, and motive does not change this reading. The giver does not, for having given, hold a share in how the other acts toward the next person.

CB42 The handing-on of a craft can be discussed and arranged, and whether its content was learned can be checked; none of this fixes in advance how the other is to treat the next person. To fix that in advance, produce to it and inspect against it falls within the seeking excluded here. Tying it to a conferred title is one way of doing so; whether there is a title is not itself the criterion. Seeking, and getting, someone to carry the content on does not show that the way of standing arrived too.

CB43 That something was passed on does not offset the harm done at any link; what was not passed on is said, as it is, not to have been, and is not topped up into "some influence always remains"; no one is certified as being at any layer.

CB44 Not seeking is not a mark of anything. Not seeking guarantees nothing in itself, direction included; colonization, too, can pass downstream without being anyone's purpose. The difference lies not in whether there is a wish for it to be passed on, but in where the step downstream falls.

Acknowledgments

This paper is signed by Han Qin alone; the author decided every argument and choice and bears sole responsibility for the text. In drafting, the author used AI models from various developers as tools. The English edition is an independent rewrite of the Chinese text, not a translation; where the two differ, the Chinese governs.

Notes

  1. Cultivation Theory, Prequel, Abstract: "The sources of cultivation are written at both ends; its setting, and the way it is passed on, belong to the side of this framework that writes about what passes between people." ↩︎
  2. Teacher-Student Theory, Paper 0: "how it is passed on, how the one who was taught later teaches others, and how cultivation is passed on between people, are subjects for after this series, and are only registered here." ↩︎
  3. Positive-Sum, Unsought, §9: "The spread of cultivation is left for separate treatment, outside this paper." The same section says that how the growth necessity of Moral Law, Paper 6, connects with that paper is not in that paper. ↩︎
  4. Theory of the University, Prequel, §5. ↩︎
  5. Cultivation Theory HY42: "A tool has no law of its own, and the direction of cultivation lies with the person using it: when giving to others, with the giver; when giving to oneself, with oneself." ↩︎
  6. Relation Theory H8: "they are directions, not labels". ↩︎
  7. Relation Theory H12: "Where three or more are involved, dealings that do not pass through an institution are broken down into effects between pairs and entered on separate accounts; passing through a third person does not release the instigator from his part; a little circle of two does not form a third bearer". ↩︎
  8. Foundation Paper 5, §4.3: "Colonization is easy; nurturing is hard. This is not accidental but structural." The foundation papers render the term this series calls cultivation as "nurturing." ↩︎
  9. Foundation Paper 5: "it must trace the complete transmission chain: institution → relationship → subject." ↩︎
  10. Value Theory, Paper 3, the section on V42: "Each sense holds in its own scope, and the narrow sense here is one particular way the wider one falls in the field of value-occurrence." ↩︎
  11. Moral Law, Paper 6, §2.1: "14DD growing toward 15DD is structurally necessary at long cross-generational scales". ↩︎
  12. Moral Law, Paper 6, §2.1: "multi-generational scale, not individual lifetime"; the sentence quoted is from §2.3. ↩︎
  13. Moral Law, Paper 6, §2.2, Roots One to Four. ↩︎
  14. Moral Law, Paper 6, §2.3: "If parents operate more at 15DD, children experience more 15DD mutual-chiseling activation". Moral Law, Paper 9, §2.5, lists "the intergenerational accumulation of cultivation" among the ways the number of 14DDs increases. ↩︎
  15. Moral Law, Paper 9, Abstract. ↩︎
  16. Anthropology Series, Paper III, §4. ↩︎

References

All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version.

I · This series

Qin, H. (2026). Propagation Is a Result (SAE Propagation of Cultivation, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24351759

Qin, H. (2026). How Colonization Propagates (SAE Propagation of Cultivation, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24351761

Qin, H. (2026). The Propagation of Cultivation: Breaking (SAE Propagation of Cultivation, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24351765

Qin, H. (2026). The Propagation of Cultivation: A Link (SAE Propagation of Cultivation, Paper 4) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24351771

Qin, H. (2026). The Propagation of Cultivation: Leading (SAE Propagation of Cultivation, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24351777

Qin, H. (2026). The Propagation of Cultivation: Independent Creators (SAE Propagation of Cultivation, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24351783

Qin, H. (2026). The Propagation of Cultivation: Unsought (SAE Propagation of Cultivation, Paper 7) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24351788

II · SAE works directly cited in this paper

Qin, H. (2026). What Cultivation Is Not (SAE Cultivation Theory, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154492

Qin, H. (2026). Borrowing Tools (SAE Cultivation Theory, Paper 8) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154525

Qin, H. (2026). The Place of Teacher-Student Theory (SAE Teacher-Student Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24267256

Qin, H. (2026). Positive-Sum, Unsought (SAE Relation Theory, Special Paper) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24270580

Qin, H. (2026). What a Relation Is, and What It Is Not (SAE Relation Theory, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545047

Qin, H. (2026). What a University Is Not (SAE Theory of the University, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293733

Qin, H. (2026). On the Colonization of Value (SAE Value Theory, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21611154

Qin, H. (2026). How Is the Inter-Ontological Possible: The Subjective Conditions and Emergent Structure of Freedom (SAE Foundation Papers, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19297847

Qin, H. (2026). Mixed Reality: The Intermediate State of 14DD Growing toward 15DD (SAE Moral Law Series, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20108658

Qin, H. (2026). The Institutional Architecture of Mixed Reality (SAE Moral Law Series, Paper 9) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20262737

Qin, H. (2026). 15DD: The Emergence of "Humanity as an End" (SAE Anthropology Series, Paper III) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19559566

Interfaces

Main upstream: Cultivation Theory, Prequel (Abstract); Teacher-Student Theory, Paper 0; Positive-Sum, Unsought (§9); Moral Law, Paper 6 (§2.1, §2.2, §2.3).

Also used: Relation Theory H8, H12; Value Theory, Paper 3 (the section on V42); Foundation Paper 5 (§4.3); Moral Law, Paper 9 (Abstract, §2.5); Theory of the University, Prequel (§5); Cultivation Theory, Paper 8 (HY42); Anthropology Series, Paper III (another scale).

This series: gathers CB1 to CB44 from Papers 1 to 7.