Self-as-an-End
SAE Theory of the Market · Paper 7

The Market: Borders
市场的国界

Han Qin (秦汉) · Independent Researcher · 2026
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24183384 · Full PDF on Zenodo · CC BY 4.0
Abstract

The first six papers wrote about the market within one state; this paper crosses borders. The line does not change at borders: that basic rights may not be violated holds against everyone. What changes across borders is who guards it, and how authority connects; line-crossing practices, or their costs, can also be moved abroad. Crossways Home buys from a porcelain factory in a district in the south of the NUT, at prices about forty percent below comparable goods made in the Kingdom State; a report of the UCSE's Office of Trade confirmed that the factory's dormitories are locked at night, that wages are paid yearly and those who leave in midyear are not paid that year's wages, and that the glazing stations have no dust protection. Crossways Home said: "We buy according to the law over there; the price is set by the market." From which costs the price gap comes has not been established; but without waiting for it to be established, each party has its own share to answer for. Responsibility goes with each party's own acts: the constructs that make and enforce rules on the importing side guard the line toward those whom their own acts reach and who have no way to avoid them by exiting, and letting goods in and keeping them out are both their acts; the purchasing company, under the Theory of the Company, cannot subcontract its accountability away; the account of the foreign supplier is kept in its own name, and keeping the account is not writing an ought for it; for constructs on the exporting side, this series writes no ought. Responsibility is not exempted by borders, nor is authority derived directly from the range of influence (SC14). At the level of state and state, there is no third party that legislates for both; treaties and common procedures bind the parties within their scope of application, and carrying out and questioning go through each party's own law. Farstream Water, under the Investment Protection Agreement between the UCSE and the NUT, brought an arbitration over the price rollback and the ban on winter cut-offs that followed the Kingdom State's lowering of the threshold, claiming compensation equivalent to about ten years of Springhollow Water Company's expected profits. An arbitral decision can be final in the case, and the positions that implement it are not final; a treaty binds this state, but carries nothing across the line. "The party questioned" is written out in three layers: whether a measure breaches the commitment of investment protection is asked of the state; supply, price and the stopping of supply are asked of the supplier and its regulator; the authority, entry, effect and implementation of arbitration are asked of the positions that make, accept and implement the procedure. The binding force of a common procedure and the procedure's own openness to questioning hold at the same time. The existing terms give the two villages of Upper Hollow and Lower Hollow no position from which to bring this arbitration themselves; the village committees may submit written material, and whether to take that material into account is for the tribunal to decide; what response this participation can require, and what actual efficacy it has, the example does not say, and it cannot be taken directly as their channel. A procedure that the people whose line it is cannot initiate is not their channel; this state may not use "there is already an arbitration, and the village committees can submit material too" as a reason to replace the two villages' questioning of supply, regulation and the implementation of the award, and this channel must be kept within this state (SC15).

Writing Declaration: This paper was co-drafted with Claude (Anthropic). All intellectual decisions, framework design, and final editorial judgments were made by the author.

Introduction

In Year 25, Crossways Group's own brand, Crossways Home, switched to buying its porcelain from elsewhere. The goods came from a porcelain factory in a district in the south of the Nation Union of Telos (NUT), at prices about forty percent below comparable goods from Bluekiln Porcelain Works. Some low-income households in Apple City could afford a full set of porcelain bowls for the first time, and the newspapers reported this side too.

In Year 27, an Apple City newspaper reported on this factory. In Year 28, an investigative report of the UCSE's Office of Trade confirmed three things: the factory's workers live in dormitories on the premises, and the dormitories are locked at night; wages are paid yearly, and those who leave in midyear are not paid that year's wages; the glazing stations have no dust-protection equipment. The report did not record who holds the keys, or whether residents can go out on their own at night. The Kingdom State's Wage Payment Act covers only employers who hire in the Kingdom State; of the law of that district, the Office of Trade's report said that it "places no restriction on the yearly payment of wages."

Crossways Home said: "We buy according to the law over there; the price is set by the market." In Year 28 it adopted a supplier code and engaged an audit firm to visit once a year, with the audit fee paid by the factory. By the end of Year 28, neither the UCSE nor the Kingdom State had taken measures concerning this factory's goods.

The Prequel said that this sentence, "the price is set by the market," holds two things: one is where to buy and whose goods to buy, and there is a position that decided it; the other is the price, which is indeed the result of many purchases and sales taken together. This paper returns to it.

There is one more matter. In Year 26, seventy percent of the shares of Springhollow Water Company, in the north of the Kingdom State, were bought by Farstream Water, a water group of the NUT. In Year 27 the Kingdom State lowered the threshold of the Public Utilities Act, and the Commission ruled for a price rollback, no cut-offs in winter, and restoring supply first; in the spring of Year 28, Farstream brought an arbitration against the UCSE under the Investment Protection Agreement between the UCSE and the NUT.

The NUT, the UCSE, the Kingdom State, and the factory, companies and arbitration here are all constructed examples of this series; this paper speaks of no real factory and no real arbitration.

Across borders, the question changes shape: whether the line is still there; who guards it; where there is no one above, to whom the channel of questioning belongs. This paper asks in turn: whether the line crosses borders (§1); once across borders, in which places responsibility lands (§2); at the level of state and state, whom a common procedure binds and who can use it to ask (§3); cross-border chokepoints and a road of questioning that has grown longer (§4).

§1 The Line Does Not Change at Borders

The Theory of Government has laid down that basic rights may not be violated, which "is derived from the subject's side and holds against everyone; it is not peculiar to government" (Theory of Government Paper 3, G17). The Theory of the State carried this sentence into the relations between states: toward the people of other states, follow the unified sentence; "It does not trade them for this state's safety" (Theory of the State Paper 5, N25).

So the line does not change at borders. Whether a person stands on this side of a border or that does not change whether his body is his own, or whether leaving a place of work is his own affair.

Across borders, two other things change. One is who guards: within one state, the line is guarded by that state's constructs that make and enforce rules; abroad, that place has its own constructs, and this state's constructs cannot reach there, nor should they legislate for it. The other is how authority connects: an import rule, a procurement contract, an arbitration under a treaty between two states, each made by whom, binding whom, governing what, and landing how.

One more thing is to be recorded: line-crossing practices, or the costs of crossing the line, can be moved abroad. What may not be done within one state can be handed to a place abroad to do; costs that would have to be paid within one state can be paid by people abroad. This is not to say that whatever is bought from abroad is suspect: cross-border buying and selling, like buying and selling within one state, is left open as usual (Paper 2). It is to say that the Base Layer of people elsewhere is not traded for the price in one market (extension: Theory of the State N25 originally says that the people of other states are not traded for this state's safety; here it is extended to the price in one market; own undertaking).

This paper takes up only the layer of the market. The Theory of Inter-State Cooperation stated at its close: "'Institutions between institutions' between companies, and between states and companies, this series does not take up" (Theory of Inter-State Cooperation Paper 8, §4); Political Economy, reading the departure of the strong, also registered the institutional relations between companies and states as a remainder (Political Economy Paper 3, E20). This paper takes up the remainders registered in these two places, and takes up only function: whose rules are made by whom, binding whom, landing how, and where the account falls (own undertaking). Tariffs and trade policy, and exchange rates, this paper does not take up; sanctions and blockades fall under the Theory of the State; the system of cooperation among states falls under the Theory of Inter-State Cooperation; how arbitration and cross-border mechanisms are to be designed, it does not take up.

Judgment layer: in whose authority a cross-border transaction, an import rule or a procedure under a treaty falls is recognized by each party's own judgment layer according to its law and the procedures it has acknowledged; those acted on can ask at the place where they themselves stand.

§2 Responsibility Goes with Each Party's Own Acts

Back to Crossways Home's sentence: "We buy according to the law over there; the price is set by the market."

The cause of the price gap is unclear; what each party must answer does not wait for it. Crossways Home's goods are about forty percent cheaper than comparable goods made in the Kingdom State. From which costs this forty percent comes, raw materials, wages, equipment, scale or exchange rates, the example has not established; one cannot supply from it that the whole forty percent comes from the arrangements the Office of Trade confirmed, nor that some part of it does. But what each party must answer does not wait until the cause of the gap is established: the three things the Office of Trade has confirmed are an entrance for asking; from here, each has its own share.

First read what each of the three is. Wages paid yearly, with those who leave in midyear not paid that year's wages: what is to be looked at is not the payment cycle of once a year, but that a person who leaves in midyear cannot get the money for the months he has already worked. Political Economy's first gate wrote: "nor may money, housing or the manner of paying wages be used to place people's ability to leave, refuse or revoke a standing bond under another party's control" (Political Economy Paper 4, E21). By structure, withholding a person's earned wages and tying them to whether he leaves is the very form that gate speaks of. The dormitories locked at night: who holds the keys and whether residents can go out on their own at night, the report does not record; one cannot supply from it that people are confined and cannot leave the factory. The glazing stations without dust protection: this falls on the bodies of those who work; where it presses must be examined by the judgment layer. What this factory's practices amount to under some particular law, their legal characterization, lies at the judgment layer, and this paper does not pronounce it.

Next, read who must answer. This paper divides four places.

The constructs that make and enforce rules on the importing side. The UCSE's Office of Trade and the Kingdom State's rule-makers each have their own acts: the rules and enforcement of access, procurement and import. The Theory of the State Prequel laid down: "those whom this state's acts reach and who have no way to avoid them by exiting are, as regards those acts, in this state's interior, whether or not they hold this state's membership and whether or not they are within its borders" (the Theory of the State Prequel, §6); how the five oughts apply to them follows the unified sentence of §8 of the same paper. The Theory of Government wrote within one state: "Jurisdiction is not the interior"; "reach of influence is not reach of authority" (Theory of Government Paper 4, G25). By these sentences, the constructs on the importing side guard the line by the unified sentence toward those whom their own acts reach and who have no way to avoid them by exiting (extension: the Theory of the State originally speaks of a state's acts, and the Theory of Government of a level of government; here it is extended to the constructs that make and enforce rules on the side of the importing market; own undertaking).

Letting goods in is their act; keeping them out is also their act. A constructed example makes this clear. Suppose that in Year 29 the UCSE's Office of Trade provided that goods may not be imported unless it can be shown that they do not come from arrangements such as "wages paid yearly, with those who leave in midyear not paid that year's wages"; Crossways Home switches to buying elsewhere, and that factory loses ten percent of its orders and lays off a group of workers. In this constructed example, the workers laid off are precisely the people this import rule reaches. Let the goods in, and those three things fall on them; keep them out, and the layoffs fall on them too. So the constructs on the importing side must answer not only "let in or not," but also what this act of theirs places on those people: they are not traded for the price in this state's market, nor for this state's peace of mind (the same form as N25, "It does not trade them for this state's safety"; extension; own undertaking). How this is achieved, a ban on entry, a deadline for correction, a requirement of checkable wage records, leaving a road for those laid off, lies at the rule layer; these are only examples, not ranked; this paper does not say which is better, nor that no longer buying from there is necessarily better.

By the end of Year 28, neither the UCSE nor the Kingdom State had taken measures concerning this factory's goods. Not taking new measures does not remove the existing arrangements of access and enforcement from questioning; not taking measures is also a form of acting (own undertaking). What is to be examined first is which of this side's arrangements continue to have effect, such as access and enforcement that routinely let this kind of goods through, on whom the effects fall, and which of the effects those people have no way to avoid by exiting; this side explains its own share, and does not book the foreign supplier's own share over to itself. What it must answer is the same as if it had taken measures: toward those it reaches, what it has done, and why.

The purchasing company. The Theory of the Company has laid down: "A person has no equivalent, all the way down the chain"; "The longer the chain, the more clearly it must be written who is accountable; accountability cannot be subcontracted away" (Theory of the Company Paper 4, GS10). Crossways Home's share in purchasing falls under this proposition, and this paper does not set it up anew. "Buy according to the law over there" answers whether the law over there permits it; it does not answer what this proposition asks: whether, along the chain of the goods Crossways Home buys in, costs have been pressed into the Base Layer of those who work. Adopting a code and engaging an auditor to visit once a year is one thing it has done; Paper 3 read that the party engaging the audit and the party paying the audit fee are both on the side being questioned; this does not prove that the audit's conclusions are controlled, nor does adopting a code count as having fulfilled this proposition (Paper 3, §4). Whether Crossways Home knew beforehand of this factory's practices, the example does not record, and this paper does not supply.

The foreign supplier. That factory's account is kept in its own name. Political Economy has laid down: "The construct is the address of attribution" (Political Economy Paper 1, E2). Dormitories, wages and dust protection are the factory's own acts; its share does not disappear because the party buying its goods has borne a share; nor is the buying party exempted from its own share because the factory has its own account. The two shares are each examined by their source, and not booked over to each other. Keeping the account is not writing an ought for it: here this series only records the address of this account, and does not tell a foreign construct what it ought to do (own undertaking).

Constructs on the exporting side. That district's government and the NUT have their own laws and their own channels. The Theory of the State says: "this series writes no ought for the other state, only how this state is to stand toward it" (the Theory of the State Prequel, §8). This series follows it, and writes no ought for constructs on the exporting side.

Responsibility is not exempted by borders, nor is authority derived from the range of influence. Taken together, these four places come to two sentences. One is that responsibility is not exempted by borders: the shares of the purchasing company and of the constructs on the importing side do not vanish because the goods come from abroad. The other is that authority is not derived directly from the range of influence: that the acts of the constructs on the importing side affect workers abroad does not give them the right to legislate for that district; Institution Theory says, "reach of influence is not reach of authority" (Institution Theory Z4). The two sentences hold at the same time. The particular scope and means go to the rule layer and the judgment layer respectively.

The face of low prices. Some low-income households in Apple City could afford a full set of porcelain bowls for the first time; this is true, and is recorded as it is; it does not offset the three things the Office of Trade confirmed, nor do the three erase it. Bluekiln Porcelain Works closed two kiln lines in Year 25; one cannot supply from this that the closure was caused wholly by this factory's low prices.

Judgment layer: where each of the three arrangements presses, and what the constructs on the importing side have done and ought to do toward those they reach, are answered by the judgment layer and the rule-makers on that side; the purchasing company answers under the Theory of the Company; whether those acted on can ask, §4.

SC14 The line does not change at borders; responsibility goes with each party's own acts. That basic rights may not be violated holds against everyone (per Theory of Government G17, by way of Theory of the State N25).

  • The constructs that make and enforce rules on the side of the importing market: toward those whom their own acts (the rules and enforcement of access, procurement and import) reach and who have no way to avoid them by exiting, they guard the line by the unified sentence (per Theory of Government G25: jurisdiction is not the interior; at the national level, extension of the Theory of the State Prequel, §§6 and 8, and N29; own undertaking); the Base Layer of people elsewhere is not traded for the price in one market (the same form as N25, "It does not trade them for this state's safety"; extension; own undertaking).
  • The purchasing company's share along the supply chain falls under Theory of the Company GS10, and is not set up anew.
  • The account of the foreign supplier is kept in its own name, and does not disappear because the purchasing party has borne a share (per Political Economy E2: the construct is the address of attribution); keeping the account is not writing an ought for it.
  • For constructs on the exporting side, this series writes no ought (the Theory of the State Prequel, §8: "this series writes no ought for the other state"; N25).

Responsibility is not exempted by borders, nor is authority derived directly from the range of influence (per Institution Theory Z4: reach of influence is not reach of authority); the particular scope and means go to the rule layer and the judgment layer respectively.

§3 Where There Is No One Above

In Year 21, the UCSE and the NUT signed an Investment Protection Agreement: an investor of one party who considers a measure of the other party "tantamount to expropriation" or "unfair" may bring an arbitration. The Agreement applies to measures of the contracting parties' governments at every level, member states included; the respondent is the contracting state. The tribunal has three members: the investor chooses one, the respondent chooses one, and the presiding arbitrator is chosen jointly by the two; hearings are not public, and awards may be made public; an award may order compensation, but may not order a measure to be revoked.

In Year 26, Farstream Water bought seventy percent of the shares of Springhollow Water Company; in Year 27 it paid to replace the equipment of the water treatment station, and both of the State Health Agency's spot checks that year were passed. The same year, the Kingdom State lowered the threshold of the Public Utilities Act from five thousand households to five hundred, and the State Public Utilities Commission ruled: the water price returns to its level before the Year 23 increase, plus ten percent; households in arrears are not cut off in winter; those still cut off have their supply restored first. In the spring of Year 28, Farstream brought an arbitration against the UCSE under the Agreement, saying these measures were "tantamount to expropriation," and claiming compensation equivalent to about ten years of Springhollow Water Company's expected profits. By the end of Year 28, the tribunal had not yet decided on jurisdiction, and had made no award.

The village committees of Upper Hollow and Lower Hollow wrote to the tribunal asking to present their views. The tribunal replied: the village committees are not parties to the arbitration; they may submit written material, and whether to take that material into account is for the tribunal to decide.

There is no third party that legislates for both. The Theory of the State has laid down that between states there is no third party that legislates for both; this does not exclude treaties and common procedures acquiring binding force within their scope of application: "they bind both parties through each party's own law, or through a procedure both parties have acknowledged"; there is no one above to compel one party on the other's behalf, so while they have binding force, carrying out and questioning must land through each party's own law (Theory of the State Paper 5, N24).

Arbitration between investors and states is a common procedure of this kind: it is set up by a treaty between two states, yet one of its parties is not a state but an investor of the other state (extension: N24 originally speaks of state and state; here one party is replaced by an investor; own undertaking). Farstream is a company of the NUT, and the respondent is the UCSE; the Agreement binds the two contracting states, and the Kingdom State, as a member state of the UCSE, has its measures within the Agreement's scope of application.

A decision can be final; the positions that implement it are not final. The Theory of the State wrote: "An arbitral award can be final in the case; the positions that implement it are not final." It also wrote: "a treaty binds this state, but carries nothing across the line" (Theory of the State Paper 5). An award, once made, can close this case; but the positions that implement it, whether and how to pay, whether and how to amend the law, each still lie under a channel they cannot themselves close. That a treaty binds this state is true: having signed it, the UCSE is bound by it; but this binding carries nothing across the line: it does not make it permissible for this state, in order to comply, to cross the line against its own people.

Reading Springhollow by this sentence, both ends must be guarded. At one end, one cannot say, because the treaty carries nothing across the line, that the Kingdom State may ignore this Agreement: the Agreement was signed by the UCSE, and is binding within its scope of application. At the other end, one cannot say, because the Agreement is binding, that the Kingdom State must withdraw the price rollback and the ban on winter cut-offs to avoid paying compensation: the Agreement can order only compensation, not revocation of a measure; and even if compensation is ordered, whether the only water of Springhollow's two villages is cut off in winter is not decided by an award, but by the positions on this side that guard the line.

"The party questioned," written out in three layers. In an investment arbitration, several things are asked and several places are questioned, and they are not to be merged into one:

  • Whether a measure breaches an investment-protection commitment already acknowledged: the party questioned is the state and its relevant positions: the UCSE as the respondent contracting state, the Kingdom State as the member state that made those measures, and the State Public Utilities Commission as the position that made the rulings.
  • Supply, price and the stopping of supply: the party questioned is the supplier and its regulatory position: Springhollow Water Company and its owners, and the State Public Utilities Commission. Paper 1 has already read this layer: the line is there; what changed is whether the Commission's standing review covers Springhollow Water Company.
  • The authority, the entry, the effect and the implementation of arbitration: the party questioned is the positions that make, accept and implement this procedural arrangement: the two contracting states that signed the Agreement; the tribunal; the positions that must implement an award.

The three layers are written apart because each has its own channel. The first layer's ruling on breach and compensation cannot answer for the second layer's supply and guarding of the line: whether the two villages' water is cut off in winter is not decided on this side's behalf by this arbitration's ruling on compensation. Nor can the second layer's line be used to cancel the first layer's commitments: the Kingdom State's guarding its line does not mean that its measures already conform to the Agreement; the two are examined separately.

Binding force and the procedure's own openness to questioning hold at the same time. A common procedure is binding on the contracting parties; it can itself also be questioned. Both hold at the same time. A state cannot exempt itself from existing constraints merely on the ground that it is being questioned: suspending or exiting a treaty is itself an act of this state, examined separately under the Theory of the State, with its reasons stated publicly (Theory of the State Paper 5, N24). Nor can the regulated party use a procedure to close off on its own the institution's questioning of its own acts (extension: Political Economy Paper 4, E22 originally says that the channels of questioning an economic position reaches are not closed off on its own by the party questioned; here it is extended to procedures set up by treaty; own undertaking). Farstream's bringing the arbitration is a right it exercises under the Agreement; it does not thereby make the State Public Utilities Commission's questioning of its supply, price and stopping of supply come to a halt.

Bringing an arbitration, a large claim, hearings not in public, the village committees' not being parties: none of these alone proves that the investor has seized questioning on its own; nor is the compensation claimed treated as already awarded. By the end of Year 28, this case had recorded only a claim, with no decision on jurisdiction and no award. Which side the tribunal will favor, this paper does not prejudge; whether Farstream bought Springhollow Water Company for the sake of arbitration, and whether the Kingdom State lowered the threshold with Farstream in view, this paper does not read minds to say.

A procedure that the people whose line it is cannot initiate is not their channel. The households of the two villages are the people whose line is at stake in this case: the winter water falls on them. They are not parties to the arbitration; the village committees may submit written material, and whether to take that material into account is for the tribunal to decide. By that proposition of Institution Theory, the channel of questioning must be independent of the party questioned, "internal subjects can actually initiate it," and initiating it brings no retaliation (Institution Theory Z34). Three things are to be kept apart here: whether the two villages can themselves bring the kind of claim an investor brings against a state; whether, in an arbitration already started, the material they submit can activate a response on the relevant issues; whether they can question the authority, entry, effect and implementation of the arbitral procedure itself. What the example gives is that the existing terms give the two villages no position from which to bring this investment arbitration themselves, and that the village committees may submit written material, and that whether to take that material into account is for the tribunal to decide. What it does not give is how the material is handled, whether a reply is required, what procedural effect it has, and whether there are other roads of asking about the procedure itself. That there is no guarantee that the tribunal will adopt their views does not mean that their questions necessarily lack actual efficacy; but this participation cannot be taken directly as a channel that already meets these conditions either. So this state may not use "there is already an arbitration, and the village committees can submit material too" as a reason to replace the two villages' questioning of supply, regulation and the implementation of the award; this channel must be kept at the positions in this state that implement it: the State Public Utilities Commission, the law of the Kingdom State, and other positions in the Kingdom State (own undertaking). "Their road remains within this state" is read as a responsibility this state must still take up, not as an inference from present facts that there is no channel at all abroad. That the tribunal accepts only written material does not in itself prove that the arbitration crosses the line.

What arbitration can do, and where its limits lie. Under this Agreement, what arbitration can do: rule whether a measure breaches the commitment of investment protection, and order compensation. What it cannot do: order a measure to be revoked. Its limits: hearings are not public, the people whose line it is are not parties, and the presiding arbitrator is chosen jointly by the two whom the two sides chose. Where it may fail: the risk of compensation makes rule-makers weigh, when making the next rule, whether they will be taken to arbitration again; Paper 6 read the proposal in the State Legislature, "so we don't get taken to arbitration again," which by the end of Year 28 had not been put to a vote. These are each written out, and not merged into a single sentence, "arbitration is good" or "arbitration is bad."

Cooperation among states. Cooperation among states arising over such an arbitration or such an agreement, how to amend the treaty, how to set up a common review, falls within the functional boundaries the Theory of Inter-State Cooperation already has (Theory of Inter-State Cooperation Paper 8, §4); when Political Economy read the conditions offered for relocation, it said the same sentence (Political Economy Paper 3, E20). This paper designs neither arbitration nor cross-border mechanisms.

Judgment layer: whether a measure breaches the Agreement is judged by the tribunal; whether the Kingdom State guards its line is answered by the Kingdom State's judgment layer and rule-makers; how an award is implemented is answered by the positions that implement it, each under its own channel; the two villages can question the positions in this state.

SC15 Where there is no one above, the channel of questioning does not belong to the party questioned either. At the level of state and state, there is no third party that legislates for both; treaties and common procedures bind the parties within their scope of application, and carrying out and questioning go through each party's own law (per Theory of the State N24). Arbitration between investors and states is a common procedure set up by a treaty between two states; one party to the arbitration is an investor of the other state (extension of N24: the original speaks of state and state; here one party is replaced by an investor; own undertaking): its decision can be final in the case, and the positions that implement it are not final; a treaty binds this state, but carries nothing across the line (per Theory of the State Paper 5; that paper's abstract has "can be final in the case," and its close has "is final in the case"). "The party questioned" is written out separately:

  • whether a measure breaches an investment-protection commitment already acknowledged: the party questioned is the state and its relevant positions;
  • supply, price and the stopping of supply: the party questioned is the supplier and its regulatory position;
  • the authority, the entry, the effect and the implementation of arbitration: the party questioned is the positions that make, accept and implement the procedural arrangement.

The binding force of the common procedure and the procedure's own openness to questioning hold at the same time: a state cannot exempt itself from existing constraints merely on the ground that it is being questioned, and suspension or exit is examined separately under N24; nor can the regulated party use the procedure to close off on its own the institution's questioning of its own acts (extension of E22: the original speaks of the channels of questioning an economic position reaches; here it is extended to procedures set up by treaty; own undertaking). A procedure that the people whose line it is cannot initiate is not their channel; their road remains within this state (per Institution Theory Z34). What arbitration can do, and where its limits and points of failure lie, is stated separately (per N24). Cooperation among states arising from this follows the functional boundaries the Theory of Inter-State Cooperation already has (per Theory of Inter-State Cooperation Paper 8, §4; E20 has the same sentence, where the original speaks of the conditions one state gives for relocation into it).

§4 Cross-Border Chokepoints and a Longer Road of Questioning

Cross-border chokepoints. The kinds of chokepoints Paper 3 read, settlement, rating and platforms, can all cross borders: a settlement network handles the money of several states, a rating agency rates another state's bonds, a platform ranks in several markets. Whether something is a chokepoint, who draws the scope of the rules it makes, and how those rules can be questioned fall under Paper 3; across borders, what is added is only this paper's question: who guards, how authority connects, where the account falls. This paper does not set up anything new.

A longer road of questioning. Political Economy read Crossways' relocation declaration, and also left a constructed example: suppose that in Year 25 Crossways had really moved its headquarters, and its business in the Kingdom State were run by a subsidiary of that NUT company; a seller who sued would have to go through cross-border service (Political Economy Paper 3, §8). That paper said that the road of questioning has grown longer; the change of procedure does not by itself prove that the road of suing has been closed.

Read by this paper, a longer road must be asked about in two respects. One is whether it is still within reach: the channel of questioning must be one that internal subjects can actually initiate (Institution Theory Z34); for a small seller who sells only in the Kingdom State, if he must go through cross-border service to ask, whether this road is still within his reach depends on how long service takes, what it costs, and where and how a judgment is enforced, none of which the constructed example gives. The other is who keeps the road within his reach: by §2, this is a share to be answered by the constructs on the side of import and access toward those their own acts reach; how to keep it, such as requiring an address in the locality at which one can be sued, lies at the rule layer, and is only an example.

Judgment layer: whether a cross-border road of questioning is within reach is examined according to fact by the position that takes it up; how to keep it within reach lies at the rule layer.

Where This Paper Stops

This paper has laid down two propositions: the line does not change at borders, responsibility goes with each party's own acts, responsibility is not exempted by borders, and authority is not derived directly from the range of influence (SC14); where there is no one above, the channel of questioning does not belong to the party questioned either, an arbitral decision can be final while the positions that implement it are not final, a treaty binds this state but carries nothing across the line, and a procedure that the people whose line it is cannot initiate is not their channel (SC15).

What it has not proved: tariffs and trade policy; exchange rates; sanctions and blockades; the system of cooperation among states; how arbitration and cross-border mechanisms are to be designed; oughts for the constructs of other states; where it is better to buy; the legal characterization of a practice in a given jurisdiction; where that forty percent price gap comes from; how that arbitration will be decided.

Remainders left: how to examine what the constructs on the importing side "have done" toward the people abroad whom they reach, for which this paper has given only an address and a direction; how a common procedure can be brought within reach of the people whose line it is, which is handed to the design of arbitration and cross-border mechanisms and is not within this series. This paper is the last of the papers of the Theory of the Market on the market within one state and across borders; the interfacing with the tradition is in Paper 0.

The Two Propositions of This Paper

SC14 The line does not change at borders; responsibility goes with each party's own acts. That basic rights may not be violated holds against everyone (per Theory of Government G17, by way of Theory of the State N25).

  • The constructs that make and enforce rules on the side of the importing market: toward those whom their own acts (the rules and enforcement of access, procurement and import) reach and who have no way to avoid them by exiting, they guard the line by the unified sentence (per Theory of Government G25: jurisdiction is not the interior; at the national level, extension of the Theory of the State Prequel, §§6 and 8, and N29; own undertaking); the Base Layer of people elsewhere is not traded for the price in one market (the same form as N25, "It does not trade them for this state's safety"; extension; own undertaking).
  • The purchasing company's share along the supply chain falls under Theory of the Company GS10, and is not set up anew.
  • The account of the foreign supplier is kept in its own name, and does not disappear because the purchasing party has borne a share (per Political Economy E2: the construct is the address of attribution); keeping the account is not writing an ought for it.
  • For constructs on the exporting side, this series writes no ought (the Theory of the State Prequel, §8: "this series writes no ought for the other state"; N25).

Responsibility is not exempted by borders, nor is authority derived directly from the range of influence (per Institution Theory Z4: reach of influence is not reach of authority); the particular scope and means go to the rule layer and the judgment layer respectively.

SC15 Where there is no one above, the channel of questioning does not belong to the party questioned either. At the level of state and state, there is no third party that legislates for both; treaties and common procedures bind the parties within their scope of application, and carrying out and questioning go through each party's own law (per Theory of the State N24). Arbitration between investors and states is a common procedure set up by a treaty between two states; one party to the arbitration is an investor of the other state (extension of N24: the original speaks of state and state; here one party is replaced by an investor; own undertaking): its decision can be final in the case, and the positions that implement it are not final; a treaty binds this state, but carries nothing across the line (per Theory of the State Paper 5; that paper's abstract has "can be final in the case," and its close has "is final in the case"). "The party questioned" is written out separately:

  • whether a measure breaches an investment-protection commitment already acknowledged: the party questioned is the state and its relevant positions;
  • supply, price and the stopping of supply: the party questioned is the supplier and its regulatory position;
  • the authority, the entry, the effect and the implementation of arbitration: the party questioned is the positions that make, accept and implement the procedural arrangement.

The binding force of the common procedure and the procedure's own openness to questioning hold at the same time: a state cannot exempt itself from existing constraints merely on the ground that it is being questioned, and suspension or exit is examined separately under N24; nor can the regulated party use the procedure to close off on its own the institution's questioning of its own acts (extension of E22: the original speaks of the channels of questioning an economic position reaches; here it is extended to procedures set up by treaty; own undertaking). A procedure that the people whose line it is cannot initiate is not their channel; their road remains within this state (per Institution Theory Z34). What arbitration can do, and where its limits and points of failure lie, is stated separately (per N24). Cooperation among states arising from this follows the functional boundaries the Theory of Inter-State Cooperation already has (per Theory of Inter-State Cooperation Paper 8, §4; E20 has the same sentence, where the original speaks of the conditions one state gives for relocation into it).

References

All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version.

I · This system

Qin, H. (2026). To Whom the Ought Is Addressed (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23269635

Qin, H. (2026). Open to Questioning (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23271324

Qin, H. (2026). Guarantee (SAE Theory of Government, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23413112

Qin, H. (2026). Levels (SAE Theory of Government, Paper 4) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23413192

Qin, H. (2026). What a State Is Not (SAE Theory of the State, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23584292

Qin, H. (2026). One Another, with No Superior (SAE Theory of the State, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23584346

Qin, H. (2026). The Close (SAE Theory of Inter-State Cooperation, Paper 8) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23815796

Qin, H. (2026). Accumulation (SAE Political Economy, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874138

Qin, H. (2026). Checks (SAE Political Economy, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874142

Qin, H. (2026). Conversion (SAE Political Economy, Paper 4) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874146

Qin, H. (2026). Partners (SAE Theory of the Company, Paper 4) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24045733

II · This series

Qin, H. (2026). What a Market Is Not (SAE Theory of the Market, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24183364

Qin, H. (2026). The Market: Securing (SAE Theory of the Market, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24183368

Qin, H. (2026). The Market: Space (SAE Theory of the Market, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24183370

Qin, H. (2026). The Market: Chokepoints (SAE Theory of the Market, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24183372

Qin, H. (2026). The Market: Regulation (SAE Theory of the Market, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24183380

Interfaces

Main upstream: Theory of Government Paper 3, G17; Theory of the State Paper 5, N24, N25 and two sentences of that paper; the Theory of the State Prequel, §§6, 8; Theory of Government Paper 4, G25; Institution Theory Z4, Z34; Political Economy Paper 1, E2; Theory of the Company Paper 4, GS10.

Also used: Political Economy Paper 4, E21, E22 (extended to procedures set up by treaty; own undertaking); Paper 3, E20 and §8; Theory of Inter-State Cooperation Paper 8, §4; Theory of the State N29.

Examples: porcelain from afar: Crossways Home and the porcelain factory in a district in the south of the NUT, the Office of Trade's report, the supposed ban on entry; the Springhollow arbitration, the Investment Protection Agreement, the village committees' written material; the constructed example of Crossways' relocation and cross-border service. All are constructed examples.

This series: the Prequel, Introduction ("the price is set by the market"); Paper 1 (Springhollow's threshold and price rollback); Paper 2 (cross-border buying and selling left open as usual); Paper 3 (cross-border chokepoints; payment for audits); Paper 6 (the proposal "so we don't get taken to arbitration again").

Handed to Paper 0: how the Theory of the Market interfaces with existing theories of the market; handover and remainders.