Self-as-an-End
SAE Cultivation Theory · Paper 5

When One Holds Power
手里有权的时候

Han Qin (秦汉) · Independent Researcher · 2026
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24154515 · Full PDF on Zenodo · CC BY 4.0
Abstract

When the giving side holds a position, as a superior, a teacher, a parent, a platform, does cultivation still hold? This paper answers: it holds, but the position changes the way what is given lands on the other. One does not borrow an existing position to add enforcement to one's own wish to cultivate. If he does not accept, one does not add disadvantages in other matters; the cost of refusal is not added by the giving side. Outward compliance cannot vouch for avowal: under one's position, the other's "yes" is only a clue. A person cannot, by a sincere declaration, remove all the pressure a position brings; separating assessment from those who give conditions, providing a route of appeal, and providing a way to exit belong to the institutional side. Demands at work and avowal in one's life are kept apart: that a demand holds does not show that it cultivated anyone. The direction is to make him no longer held by this one position of mine; this is only a direction, not a measuring stick. Toni Morrison editing Angela Davis's autobiography, Maxwell Perkins's reply to the departing Thomas Wolfe, Cai Yuanpei's letter answering Lin Shu, and the proofs between Hardy and Ramanujan are the historical cases of this paper.

This is an independent English rewrite, not a translation, of the Chinese final text v1.0. Terminology and framing are recomposed for an English-reading audience; the philosophical content is the same.

Introduction

In the small incident at the opening of the Prequel, the one who gave the book was a company's CTO, who held a position. What the author recorded is that he gave a book and did not lecture, and that the book really did open the author's view. Whether the position he held added weight to this giving, the author did not say, and this paper does not supply it for him; what is to be looked at is what refusal would have cost, which is written below.

The position is often in the giver's hands: superior, teacher, parent, supervisor, editor, platform. When one holds a position, what one gives arrives at the other carrying the weight of the position. "You might take a look at this book," said by a friend, and said by the person who decides whether you stay next year, are not the same sentence.

Does cultivation still hold, then, when one holds a position? This paper answers: it holds; only the giver has a few more places to look.

§1 Not Borrowing a Position to Add Enforcement

The first place is not borrowing an existing position to add enforcement to one's own wish to cultivate.

Action Theory wrote of a person who holds a position. He wants to ask a newcomer whether he is willing to hear him tell an old story; he holds a sentence in the newcomer's year-end evaluation, and whether this question carries a cost for the newcomer is not his to decide; what he can do is not add the cost: if the newcomer says no, really accept it, and not give less afterward because of it. It also says there which things occupy: the newcomer says no and he goes on pushing; the newcomer has not avowed and he avows for him first; the newcomer does not comply and loses out elsewhere (Action Theory, Paper 6, §3).

The theory of rights puts this point as structure: a cultivator could, from its position, form convergence over the cultivated and close the relation into power; but cultivation, being cultivation, keeps the recipient's positions of refusal, interruption and self-reconstitution; the moment it redraws those positions and seals exit shut, it is no longer cultivation (Rights, Special Study, F29). This does not rest on the giver's goodwill: whether this giving relation has closed into power is seen only by whether the loop has closed, not by what anyone had in mind (Rights, Special Study, F28, F29).

Angela Davis later spoke of her autobiography: "Toni Morrison persuaded me that I could write it the way I wanted to"; the book's use of flashback "was thanks to input from my editor, Toni Morrison"; and she said, "I wasn't so much interested in writing an autobiography" (Davis, interview, 2014). The editor held a position: whether and how the book came out lay on the publisher's side. Only Davis's own words are read here: the editor gave her views, and the book was written the way its author wanted.

§2 The Cost of Refusal Is Not Added by the Giver

The second place is that if he does not accept, one does not add disadvantages in other matters. The cost of refusal is not added by the giving side.

This is the reverse of the first. The first says one does not push with the position; this one says that if he does not accept, one does not punish with the position either. Not punishing includes not punishing openly, and also not quietly giving less in other matters: one fewer opportunity, one fewer recommendation, a slower reply.

In 1936 the writer Thomas Wolfe was leaving the publisher that had brought out his books, and leaving his editor, Maxwell Perkins. Perkins wrote in reply that the kind of "exerting control of a man's future" Wolfe referred to was something "which we have no intention of doing at all"; that "no further agreement of any sort exists between us with respect to the future"; that the relations between an author and his publisher "are not such as to give any sort of rights" to the publisher over that author's future work (Perkins to Wolfe, November 1936). In another letter he wrote: "You seem to think I have tried to control you. I only did that when you asked my help and then I did the best I could." At the end of the letter he said: "I hope you don't mean it to keep us from seeing each other" (ibid.).

Whether there had in fact been control between the two, the two sides tell differently, and this paper does not judge. One point in the replies only is read: he was leaving, and Perkins wrote in the formal reply that the publisher had no rights over his future work; at the end of the other letter, he said he hoped this did not mean they would no longer see each other. What these two letters leave is a statement of a boundary; the other costs of exit cannot all be judged from them.

§3 Outward Compliance Cannot Vouch for Avowal

The third place is that outward compliance cannot vouch for avowal.

Under one's position, the other's "yes" is only a clue. The Second Enlightenment said that seen from outside, the results are of three kinds: can be confirmed, only a clue, cannot yet be judged; the outer table does not yield the inner table (Second Enlightenment, Paper 3). What a person gains from others is his only once avowed by his own law (Value Theory P3, V28; Action Theory, Paper 6, D36); a nod given under a position is not by itself enough to confirm that this step has happened.

Suppose a graduate student is given a topic by her supervisor. She has not taken the topic up as her own; she goes on with it only because she cannot afford the cost of refusing. She says yes, works on it for two years, and finishes the thesis. After graduating, looking back on one occasion, she says: I never took that topic up as mine; I only knew that saying no at the time was not something I could afford. Her "yes" back then was really said, and the topic was really finished; but that "yes" was not her avowal.

What the giver can do here is not much: not take "yes" as avowal; not use its having been completed to prove afterward that the giving was right; and, at the time of giving, keep the road of not accepting open, and make it one that can really be walked.

§4 A Sincere Declaration Is Not Enough

The fourth place is that a person cannot, by a sincere declaration, remove all the pressure a position brings.

"It's only a suggestion; you don't have to take it." This can be said with complete sincerity, and the pressure is still there: the one saying it will be grading him next year. The weight of a position is not decided by the speaker's intentions. Action Theory's sentence puts it exactly: whether this question carries a cost for the newcomer is not his to decide (Action Theory, Paper 6, §3).

So there are some things an individual cannot finish, which have to be handed to the institutional side: separating assessment from those who give conditions, having somewhere to appeal, having a way to exit. An institution provides conditions for the cultivation of those within it, concerned with conditions and not with outcomes (Institution Theory, Paper 4, Z23); what it bears is a responsibility for conditions, and it is to keep refusal and change of direction open (Political Economy, Paper 6, E38). This paper does not write how institutions are to arrange this, and says only one thing: the institution's responsibility is not shrunk into an individual's goodwill.

In 1919 Lin Shu wrote a letter attacking Peking University, and Cai Yuanpei replied in a letter published in the Gongyan bao. He wrote that, as to doctrines, the university followed the common practice of universities around the world, the principle of freedom of thought, and the policy of embracing all; that whatever the school of thought, so long as what it said was reasoned and what it held was grounded, and it had not yet met its fate of natural elimination, then even if schools contradicted one another, all were left free to develop (Cai Yuanpei, Letter to the Gongyan bao, with a Reply to Lin Qinnan, 1919).

He was the president. In this letter, "agreeing with my doctrines" is not at the threshold; the threshold is something else: reasoned in what it says, grounded in what it holds. This is not leaving every view unjudged: what is not reasoned, and cannot bring grounds, still does not pass. He wrote the accommodation of different doctrines as a public principle, and wrote it as "the common practice of universities around the world," not appealing only to his own likes and dislikes. This gave those who came after a standard by which they could press questions; whether it could bind the president in concrete appointments depends on how it was actually carried out, and this letter cannot certify that as well.

§5 Demands at Work, Avowal in One's Life

The fifth place is keeping demands at work and avowal in one's life apart.

A position carries accountabilities, and accountabilities carry demands: hand in reports, meet standards, keep to rules. On Accountability says: "the name accountability does not distinguish nurturing from suppression from colonization" ("nurturing" is that paper's English for the same Chinese word); "that a demand is found to be an accountability says only that it has a source, has content, and has landed by registration at some position" (On Accountability, F56). It gives an example there: a company has him write a review every quarter; this may force him to think through one layer more of what he has done, or may only leave his superiors a file to hold him to account by (ibid.).

So that a demand holds does not show that it cultivated anyone. Conversely, the share the giver wants to give beyond the demand is not pressed through under the name of the demand: one can require him to hand in the review; one cannot require him to take up "this job is the meaning of your life."

In 1913 Ramanujan wrote from India to Hardy at Cambridge, with many results stated without proof. Hardy wrote back, asking him again and again for proofs (Ramanujan Archives, Institute of Mathematical Sciences, Chennai). In his reply in April, Ramanujan wrote: "I have tried this time to give you a proof," and "in this letter I have attempted to give a demonstration which would be acceptable to you all" (Ramanujan to Hardy, 17 April 1913).

Proof is the threshold of that field; this demand in itself did not ask Ramanujan to take up Hardy the person, nor to think about mathematics along Hardy's road. That Ramanujan tried, in his reply, to give a demonstration meeting this demand was his own affair. This incident is not read as intuition against rigor: the demand is at the threshold of that field, the avowal is with Ramanujan himself, and the two are kept apart.

§6 The Direction: No Longer Held by This One Position of Mine

The last place is direction. When a person who holds a position gives, the direction is to make the other no longer held by this one position of mine: he has other roads, other people he can ask, and can one day get through without passing through me.

This is only a direction, not a measuring stick. That he later left does not prove I gave rightly; that he stayed all along does not prove I gave wrongly. Taking results as the criterion is exactly what this framework has refused throughout (Value Theory P3, V42). Paper 3 said: what matters is that he is no longer held by any single supporter, not that from now on he needs no one.

This framework has an earlier sentence of a similar shape: the decay of cultivating power is self-dissolution once the positional difference has discharged its function (Power Theory, Paper 5, C3). That is said in the language of power; here only its shape is borrowed: the share a position gives out runs toward no longer needing this position.

§7 Where This Paper Stops

This paper has written the few more places a person who holds a position looks at when giving. How positions are arranged, how assessment is separated, how appeal and exit are set up, belong to the institutional side.

The guardianship of the previous paper is the heaviest kind of position; the places in this paper are all present there. The branch directed toward oneself, Paper 6 takes up.

A Few for Oneself

The lines below are only for one's own use, and are not used to measure others.

  • Not borrowing the position I hold to add enforcement to what I want to give.
  • If he does not accept, not adding disadvantages in other matters.
  • Not taking the "yes" said under my position as his avowal.
  • Not taking "it's only a suggestion" as having removed the pressure.
  • Not using the name of a demand to require him to take up something beyond the demand.

Propositions of This Paper

  • HY26 One does not borrow an existing position to add enforcement to one's own wish to cultivate.
  • HY27 If he does not accept, one does not add disadvantages in other matters; the cost of refusal is not added by the giving side.
  • HY28 Outward compliance cannot vouch for avowal: under one's position, the other's "yes" is only a clue.
  • HY29 A person cannot, by a sincere declaration, remove all the pressure a position brings; separating assessment from those who give conditions, providing a route of appeal, and providing a way to exit belong to the institutional side.
  • HY30 Demands at work and avowal in one's life are kept apart: the name accountability does not distinguish cultivation, suppression and colonization, and that a demand holds does not show that it cultivated anyone.
  • HY31 The direction is to make him no longer held by this one position of mine. This is only a direction, not a measuring stick.

Acknowledgments

This paper is Paper 5 of the Cultivation Theory series of the SAE (Self-as-an-End) philosophical system, and is signed by Han Qin alone. All philosophical argument and all decisions between alternatives were finally adjudicated by the author, who bears sole responsibility for the final text.

The writing and review of this paper were assisted by Anthropic's Claude and OpenAI's ChatGPT. Thanks are due to these companies and to their research and engineering teams.


References

Group I lists works of this system, archived on Zenodo with Chinese and English versions under the same record, all single-authored (Han Qin); DOIs follow those listed at the head of each paper on the author's site. The text restates upstream work in plain words, with the title, paper and proposition number noted in parentheses at the place of use. The Prequel and Papers 3 and 6 in the text are the papers of this series. The original wording, sources and verification status of the historical cases are recorded separately in the case verification table for Cultivation Theory. Chinese texts are rendered into English by the author.

I · Works of this system

Qin, H. (2026). On the Development of Power · Shi (SAE Power Theory, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20582210

Qin, H. (2026). On Rights and Entitlements (SAE Rights, Special Study) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21314907

Qin, H. (2026). On the Colonization of Value (SAE Value Theory, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21611154

Qin, H. (2026). On Accountability · Wei [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22853810

Qin, H. (2026). Not Legislating for Others (SAE Action Theory, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22970777

Qin, H. (2026). Conditions (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 4) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23270922

Qin, H. (2026). Support (SAE Political Economy, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874154

Qin, H. (2026). Reading Structure, Not Minds (SAE The Second Enlightenment, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24030401

II · Other works

Cai Yuanpei. (1919). Zhi Gongyan bao han bing da Lin Qinnan han [Letter to the Gongyan bao, with a Reply to Lin Qinnan]. Gongyan bao, 1 April 1919. (Quoted as cited from Cai Yuanpei quanji, vol. 3, Hangzhou: Zhejiang Education Publishing House, 1997, p. 576.)

Davis, A. (2014, October 29). Interview by D. White. UC Santa Cruz News.

Perkins, M., to T. Wolfe, 16–18 November 1936. (Quoted from the transcription in The American Reader.)

Ramanujan, S., to G. H. Hardy, 17 April 1913. (Quoted from the Ramanujan archive pages of the Institute of Mathematical Sciences, Chennai.)