Self-as-an-End
SAE Theory of the School · Paper 7

School Funding
学校的经费

Han Qin (秦汉) · Independent Researcher · 2026
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24382589 · Full PDF on Zenodo · CC BY 4.0
Abstract

Part of the matter of schooling lies in the Base Layer: enrollment, safety and care, teaching, and the number and quality of teachers. This paper states five propositions. What lies in the Base Layer is to be secured; securing is a public matter, and is not given in exchange for the compliance of the child or the family, for grades, or for taking a certain road. Enrollment means having a place at school, and which school one enters is a gate; a child who learns elsewhere by his family's arrangement does not lose his eligibility to return to public provision. What is secured is the supply, not any particular school. The two layers are not traded: a sufficient Base Layer does not prove that support in the Emergence Layer has been given in full, and how much support is given is not used to make up for gaps in the Base Layer. Money may carry requirements, not direction. When a school can no longer be sustained, the first thing secured is that the children enrolled have a school to continue in. Which stages the Base Layer covers is at the rule layer; this series suggests that it cover every stage before university. This paper does not say what share education funding ought to take, what level of fees is reasonable, or whether private schools ought to exist, and takes no side in policies such as school choice.

Writing Declaration: This paper was co-drafted with Claude (Anthropic). All intellectual decisions, framework design, and final editorial judgments were made by the author.

Introduction

China's Compulsory Education Law, Article 2, says: "The state implements a system of nine-year compulsory education." (my translation; 国家实行九年义务教育制度。) It goes on: "Compulsory education is education implemented uniformly by the state that all children and adolescents of school age must receive; it is a public-welfare undertaking that the state must secure." (my translation; 义务教育是国家统一实施的所有适龄儿童、少年必须接受的教育,是国家必须予以保障的公益性事业。)

Political Economy divides supply in a society into two layers: "the Base Layer is to be secured, the Emergence Layer supported". The Prequel said that this series takes the pair in the sense of Political Economy.

This paper writes which parts of the matter of schooling lie in the Base Layer, what is secured, and where the requirements money brings stop.


§1 Four Things in the Base Layer

Four things. Enrollment, safety and care, teaching, and the number and quality of teachers are supplies of the Base Layer. Enrollment is having a place at school (Prequel, §5); safety and care are Paper 3; teaching is Paper 1; teachers are Paper 5. Political Economy said that which matters count as the Base Layer lies at the rule layer; this paper says one step more for it at the normative layer, writing what of schooling lies in the Base Layer as these four. This is this series' judgment, and this series undertakes it.

Securing is a public matter. Institution Theory says: "Securing is a set of conditions given public form: making the line explicit and concrete, giving it institutional backing, and having real capacity of enforcement." The original speaks of basic rights; Political Economy extended it to the supply undertaken by a construct that does the work of the Base Layer. The school's four things are read this way: securing them for everyone's children is a public matter, and cannot be left to the luck of each family.1

Not in exchange. Between parents and a child, Parent-Child Theory said: "Securing is not exchanged for the child's compliance, nor made conditional on his taking some particular road; how much support is given is not used to make up for a lack of securing; the two layers are not traded." This paper extends it to public securing, and that step is this series' own undertaking: the school's four things are not given in exchange for the compliance of the child or the family, for grades, or for taking a certain road. A child who did badly in a test does not get less teaching; a family that does not go along with some arrangement of the school does not see the child's care discounted.

Usable, not only nominal. Whether a supply can be used is not proved by nominal enrollment, or by the existence of a place. A child is on the roll, yet cannot reach that teaching, because the assistance he needs is not there, for instance; then that supply has not yet reached him. How reaching is measured is handed to the Theory of Fairness, now being written; this paper says only that the nominal does not prove reaching.

The stretch of the kindergarten. In the kindergarten the four things weigh differently: care and the conditions for play as the basic activity are the main items, and teaching is not (Paper 1).

XX31 What lies in the Base Layer is to be secured. Enrollment, safety and care, teaching, and the number and quality of teachers are supplies of the Base Layer; securing them is a public matter, and is not given in exchange for the compliance of the child or the family, for grades, or for taking a certain road.


§2 A Place at School, and the Gate

Which stages. Which stages the Base Layer covers is set at the rule layer. Among the stages the rule layer sets within the Base Layer: in the compulsory stretch, schools do not pick their children; in the stages outside compulsory education, everyone can reach some school of that stage, and which school one enters is a gate, read as a gate; how admission is designed is handed to dedicated papers.

Roads besides the gate. A particular school may set conditions of entry. Public arrangements still have to ensure that a child who did not pass these gates has a road through his stage that he can actually use. Being sorted by a gate into one school or another does not cut short the teaching of his stage, nor close his road to changing direction later. Institution Theory said that conditions do not carry the demand "accept this direction of development," and that support may not use conditions to "seal off his position for changing direction"; being sorted into one school or another likewise does not fix his direction.

Whether the provision of vocational education counts toward this stage is defined at the rule layer; where it counts, it is checked by whether it can actually be used. Receiving the supply of this stage does not prove that he has avowed any vocational direction.

Children who learn elsewhere. The Prequel has said: where a family arranges for a child to learn elsewhere, at a school that takes no public funds or at home, this is a choice in the Emergence Layer; the child does not thereby lose his eligibility to return to public provision. The original sentence in Political Economy is: "Securing in the Base Layer is not conditional on a person's taking some particular road". The original speaks of the road taken by the person who receives a payment; here the one who receives is the child, and the road was chosen for him by his family, perhaps with some part of his own; either way, it is read by this sentence. This extension is this series' own undertaking. The eligibility is in the child's name; where he himself wants to come back, it is read by Paper 4's ways of asking and by what he can do on his own. Whether home schooling is permitted is at the rule layer, and this series acknowledges but does not judge; whether he learned anything elsewhere this series does not judge, and hands to Parent-Child Theory.

Not yet found. Rule texts on having a place in upper secondary school and kindergarten; rules on switching tracks and changing direction after streaming; rules on returning to public school for children schooled at home or at schools that take no public funds; minimum requirements for, and inspection of, schools that take no public funds and home schooling. For none of these has this paper yet found a suitable text; they are left open.

XX31 (continued) Enrollment means having a place at school. Among the stages the rule layer sets within the Base Layer: in the compulsory stretch, schools do not pick their children; in the stages outside compulsory education, everyone can reach some school of that stage, and which school one enters is a gate, read as a gate, the design of admission being handed to dedicated papers. A particular school may set conditions of entry; public arrangements still have to ensure that those who did not pass these gates have a path of education through their stage that they can actually use. Being sorted by a gate into one school or another does not cut short the teaching of his stage, nor close his road to changing direction. A child who learns elsewhere by his family's arrangement does not thereby lose his eligibility to return to public provision; the eligibility is in the child's name.

Suggestion. This series suggests that the Base Layer cover every stage before university, upper secondary school and kindergarten both included; the ages at which it begins and ends are at the rule layer. This is a suggestion and is not written into a proposition. The four things are this series' judgment; the range is a suggestion (Prequel, §8). Both say one step more, at the normative layer, on "which matters count as the Base Layer," and their standings differ.


§3 What Is Secured Is the Supply

Not that particular school. Political Economy says: "The object of securing is the supply, not that construct. Securing the water in one place secures that the people there have water, not the perpetual existence of that company". In the school: what public money secures is the enrollment, care, teaching and teachers children receive, not the survival of any particular school. The Theory of Government says: "A guarantee is not an endorsement." The Theory of the Market says that public funding is to be able to state its grounds, and that "obtaining support does not issue legitimacy to the existing acts and continued existence of those supported".

Grounds that can be stated. Public funds have to be able to state their grounds: what supply they secure and what development they support, explained separately. Obtaining securing does not issue legitimacy to a school's existing acts and continued existence: a school that takes public money still has limits on its compulsion (Paper 3), and its evaluation is still subject to checks (Paper 6).

How per-pupil funding is secured, this paper has not yet found a suitable rule text to show.

An objection. One objection runs: money goes in and no results are seen; "securing" turns into a subsidy for existing schools.2 This paper agrees with half of it: obtaining securing does not in any case issue legitimacy to a school's survival. What is secured is the supply, so it is checked by reaching, not by input: money reaching the school is not teaching and care reaching the child. Nor does this paper argue from "securing will bring results"; what the results are is checked separately and does not change the ground of this proposition.

A stronger question remains, a structural one, and it takes this series' own words: "the object of securing is the supply, not that construct"; if so, why does the money not follow the child, and why does the supply have to be given by a public position? This paper's answer: that it is to be secured is a public matter; who runs it, and how, is at the rule layer. A private school can carry part of the supply (Prequel); where it carries it, it is read by the stretch it carries. Where the requirements money brings stop is written in §5 below. Of the dispute over school choice behind this question, this paper takes only this structure, and takes no side in the policy.

XX32 What is secured is the supply, not any particular school. Public funds can state their grounds: what supply they secure and what development they support, explained separately; obtaining securing does not issue legitimacy to a school's existing acts and continued existence.


§4 The Two Layers Are Not Traded

Sufficient securing does not prove support given. A sufficient Base Layer does not prove that support in the Emergence Layer has been given in full. A school may have enough teaching, care and teachers, and a child may still have no stretch of time that is not laid out, and no one who asks him anything. Support means this: within the same sum of staffing and time, the share kept for questioning is not filled up by teaching and administration (Papers 2 and 5).

Much support does not make up for gaps in securing. Conversely, how much support is given is not used to make up for gaps in the Base Layer. That a school's clubs, activities and study trips are lively does not exempt from questioning the stretch where its care falls short.

One sum, two readings. Political Economy says: "One and the same payment can be read two ways". An afternoon of a teacher's that holds up teaching is the face of the Base Layer; using that afternoon to ask a child what he is thinking is the face of the Emergence Layer. The two readings are not two sums of money; they are two faces of one sum of staffing and time. This extension is this series' own undertaking.

The thicker, the stronger the support. This series' judgment is: the thicker the Base Layer, the stronger the support for education. This is a comparison, not a threshold; whether support is actually given is still checked separately, by the conditions of questioning, leaving room and unfolding. This is not trading one layer for the other.

XX33 The two layers are not traded. A sufficient Base Layer does not prove that support in the Emergence Layer has been given in full; how much support is given is not used to make up for gaps in the Base Layer. Support means this: within the same sum of staffing and time, the share kept for questioning is not filled up by teaching and administration. The thicker the Base Layer, the stronger the support for education; whether support is actually given is still checked separately by the conditions of questioning, leaving room and unfolding; this is not trading one layer for the other.


§5 Money Carries Requirements, Not Direction

It may carry requirements. Public money and private money may both carry requirements: reports to be submitted, enrollment limits to be kept, funds to be spent as earmarked. The Theory of the Market says: "Funding may carry requirements; it does not thereby acquire the authority to decide a person's direction." The Theory of the University said a proposition of the same shape at the level of the university.

Not direction. The requirements money brings do not thereby acquire the authority to decide the direction of the people in the school. The paying side may require the school to submit accounts; it does not thereby acquire the authority to avow a direction for teachers, still less to decide for a child where he is to grow. Requirements on the content of the curriculum are still checked separately by accountabilities that have a source (Paper 8, §1). Requirements brought by fees a family pays are read the same way; school and home are written in Paper 8.

One way of writing it. Japan's Act on Subsidies for Private Schools, Article 12, allows the competent authority to require reports from school corporations receiving subsidies and to inspect them; where enrollment markedly exceeds the capacity set in the school regulations, to order correction; where the budget is inappropriate in light of the purpose of the subsidy, to recommend the necessary changes; where an officer or councilor has broken the law, to recommend dismissal. In the article as checked, no provision directing the content of education appears. The money brought requirements of the kind of reports, enrollment capacity and budget; direction is not among them.

Of private schools and school choice, this paper takes only this structure.

XX34 Money carries requirements, not direction. Public and private funds may both carry requirements; they do not thereby acquire the authority to decide the direction of the people in the school.


§6 When It Can No Longer Be Sustained

The enrolled children come first. When a school closes or merges, the first thing secured is that the children enrolled have a school to continue in. Continuation is checked by conditions that can actually be used: distance, class size, care, continuity of study; it is not conditional on the child's grades. At the level of the university the Theory of the University said: "When a university can no longer be sustained, the arrangements for ending first secure that those enrolled can finish their studies". The Theory of the Market says "that the supply must continue does not by itself imply that the original company must exist forever". This paper extends the two to the school, and that step is this series' own undertaking.

The judgment can be questioned. The judgment "it can no longer be sustained" has its grounds, objects and costs stated by the position that makes the decision, and can be questioned independently. For a child who cannot walk away, this sentence matters all the more: when his school is withdrawn, he cannot find another on his own.

A Chinese rule. In 2012 the General Office of the State Council's opinions on the adjustment of the layout of rural compulsory-education schools said: "in closing and merging schools, the receiving school is to be built before the old one is withdrawn, ensuring a smooth transition" (my translation; 学校撤并应先建后撤,保证平稳过渡。). It went on: "where most parents of students object or most representatives at a hearing object, where after closing or merging the safety of students' travel to school cannot be secured, where the boarding and dining conditions of the receiving school cannot meet needs, or where closing or merging would make the school oversized or make the problem of 'large classes' acute, existing schools or teaching sites may not be forcibly closed or merged" (my translation; 多数学生家长反对或听证会多数代表反对,学校撤并后学生上学交通安全得不到保障,并入学校住宿和就餐条件不能满足需要,以及撤并后将造成学校超大规模或“大班额”问题突出的,均不得强行撤并现有学校或教学点。). Continuation checked by conditions that can actually be used, distance, boarding and dining, class size, is written here as a precondition of closing and merging. The views of parents, teachers and students enter through hearings; that is the side of oversight (Paper 8).

An English guidance. The statutory guidance on closing maintained schools issued by England's Department for Education in May 2026 says that the representation period "must last for four weeks", and that "anybody can object to, or comment on, the proposal"; the decision-maker "should be satisfied that there is sufficient capacity elsewhere in the local area to accommodate displaced pupils", and considers "whether the proposal will result in unreasonably long journey times or increased travel costs". Two sides: continuation is written as a condition of the decision; this procedure does not give parents the power to block a closure directly by objecting. The guidance applies to maintained schools.

A Japanese guide. In 2026 Japan's Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology revised its guide on the appropriate size and placement of public primary and lower secondary schools; the page says: "the basic approach to the appropriate size and appropriate placement of schools set out in the 2015 guide, including the point that each municipality needs to make its own judgment, remains valid today; nevertheless, in light of changes in circumstances, it was deemed appropriate to revise the 2015 guide" (my translation; 平成27年手引きで示された学校の適正規模・適正配置の在り方についての基本的な考え方は、各市町村において主体的な判断を行う必要があるという点を含め、現在においても引き続き妥当であるものの、状況の変化を踏まえ平成27年手引きを改訂することが適切とされました。).3

XX35 When it can no longer be sustained. When a school closes or merges, the first thing secured is that the children enrolled have a school to continue in; continuation is checked by conditions that can actually be used (distance, class size, care, continuity of study), and is not conditional on the child's grades. The judgment "it can no longer be sustained" has its grounds, objects and costs stated by the position that makes the decision, and can be questioned independently; for children who cannot walk away, this sentence matters all the more.


§7 Differences Between Schools

This section states no proposition; it only registers the division of labor.

Differences in the Base Layer between schools are read by the measure of the Theory of Fairness; this series does not set up a measure of its own. The Theory of Fairness is still being written; until it is published, this series registers only the division of labor and does not cite its propositions. Reaching for children with disabilities is likewise read by the measure of the Theory of Fairness.

A private school that takes no public funds is outside the Base Layer's securing and is not a position that carries universal public supply; this sentence only divides the positions that carry, and does not waive the accountabilities it carries under existing arrangements (Prequel, §5). One that takes public funds is read by the part of it that lies close to the Base Layer.


§8 Funding in Three Stages

This section follows the axis of stages and writes only the arrangements the school mainly handles at each stage. That a matter is written at some stage does not mean it appears only there, nor is the stage used to judge where a particular child has got to.

Kindergarten. Having a place at school falls within this series' suggestion; which kindergarten one enters is a gate; the four things weigh differently, care and the conditions for play being the main items.

Primary and lower secondary school. In the compulsory stretch, schools do not pick their children; the securing of a place near home and not being able to walk away are two faces of one thing (Paper 4).

Upper secondary school. The gate; how vocational education is defined; the roads for changing direction after streaming.


Where This Paper Stops

What it has not done: it has not said what share education funding ought to take; it has not said what level of fees is reasonable; it has not said whether private schools ought to exist; it has taken no side in policies such as school choice; the measure for differences between schools is handed to the Theory of Fairness.


Notes

  1. The idea of running schools for everyone's children was already stated in Comenius's Great Didactic; this paper has not gone back to the original text and lists it only as a lead. ↩︎
  2. This paper writes only the structure of this objection, and does not report any particular author's words. ↩︎
  3. The guide's reference figures on distance and time of travel to school, and on gaining the understanding of guardians and local residents, are known to this paper through secondary material; it has not gone back to the original annexes and does not write them. ↩︎

The Five Propositions of This Paper

XX31 What lies in the Base Layer is to be secured. Enrollment, safety and care, teaching, and the number and quality of teachers are supplies of the Base Layer; securing them is a public matter, and is not given in exchange for the compliance of the child or the family, for grades, or for taking a certain road. Enrollment means having a place at school. Among the stages the rule layer sets within the Base Layer: in the compulsory stretch, schools do not pick their children; in the stages outside compulsory education, everyone can reach some school of that stage, and which school one enters is a gate, read as a gate, the design of admission being handed to dedicated papers. A particular school may set conditions of entry; public arrangements still have to ensure that those who did not pass these gates have a path of education through their stage that they can actually use. Being sorted by a gate into one school or another does not cut short the teaching of his stage, nor close his road to changing direction. A child who learns elsewhere by his family's arrangement does not thereby lose his eligibility to return to public provision; the eligibility is in the child's name. (Normative. The dependencies fall into two groups. The four things: that these four are the four is this series' judgment, making concrete the last sentence of Political Economy E14a, "which matters count as the Base Layer lies at the rule layer," this series' own undertaking; taking over Political Economy E35, the Prequel of Political Economy, §7, and Institution Theory Z17; Parent-Child Theory PC11, which speaks of parents, extended to public securing, this series' own undertaking. A place at school: the sentence on returning to public provision, where Political Economy E35 speaks of the road taken by the person who receives a payment, while here that road may have been chosen for the child by his family, this series' own undertaking; the sentence on being sorted takes over Institution Theory Z27)

Suggestion (not a proposition): this series suggests that the Base Layer cover every stage before university, upper secondary school and kindergarten both included; the ages at which it begins and ends are at the rule layer.

XX32 What is secured is the supply, not any particular school. Public funds can state their grounds: what supply they secure and what development they support, explained separately; obtaining securing does not issue legitimacy to a school's existing acts and continued existence. (Normative; taking over the Prequel of Political Economy, §7, Theory of Government G22, and Theory of the Market SC11)

XX33 The two layers are not traded. A sufficient Base Layer does not prove that support in the Emergence Layer has been given in full; how much support is given is not used to make up for gaps in the Base Layer. Support means this: within the same sum of staffing and time, the share kept for questioning is not filled up by teaching and administration. The thicker the Base Layer, the stronger the support for education; whether support is actually given is still checked separately by the conditions of questioning, leaving room and unfolding; this is not trading one layer for the other. (Normative; taking over the Prequel of Political Economy, §7, and Parent-Child Theory PC8 and PC11; "the same sum" extends Political Economy E35, this series' own undertaking; "the thicker, the stronger" is this series' judgment, written as a comparison, not as a threshold)

XX34 Money carries requirements, not direction. Public and private funds may both carry requirements; they do not thereby acquire the authority to decide the direction of the people in the school. (Normative; taking over Theory of the Market SC10 and Theory of the University DX30)

XX35 When it can no longer be sustained. When a school closes or merges, the first thing secured is that the children enrolled have a school to continue in; continuation is checked by conditions that can actually be used (distance, class size, care, continuity of study), and is not conditional on the child's grades. The judgment "it can no longer be sustained" has its grounds, objects and costs stated by the position that makes the decision, and can be questioned independently; for children who cannot walk away, this sentence matters all the more. (Normative; Theory of the University DX33 and Theory of the Market SC11, extended to the school, this series' own undertaking)


References

All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version.

I · This system

  • Qin, H. (2026). What a School Is Not (SAE Theory of the School, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24382559
  • Qin, H. (2026). School Students (SAE Theory of the School, Paper 4) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24382577
  • Qin, H. (2026). What an Economy Is Not (SAE Political Economy, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874133
  • Qin, H. (2026). Checks (SAE Political Economy, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874142
  • Qin, H. (2026). Support (SAE Political Economy, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874154
  • Qin, H. (2026). Guarding the Line (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23270766
  • Qin, H. (2026). Conditions (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 4) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23270922
  • Qin, H. (2026). Guarantee (SAE Theory of Government, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23413112
  • Qin, H. (2026). The Place of Parent-Child Theory (SAE Parent-Child Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24121569
  • Qin, H. (2026). The Market: Funding (SAE Theory of the Market, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24183378
  • Qin, H. (2026). University Funding (SAE Theory of the University, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293753

II · Rule texts

  • Compulsory Education Law of the People's Republic of China (中华人民共和国义务教育法), as amended for the second time in 2018, Article 2.
  • General Office of the State Council (China). 2012. Opinions on Regulating the Adjustment of the Layout of Rural Compulsory Education Schools (关于规范农村义务教育学校布局调整的意见), Guobanfa [2012] No. 48. 2012-09-06.
  • England. Department for Education. 2026. Closing maintained schools: statutory guidance.
  • Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology (Japan). 2026. Guide on the Appropriate Size and Placement of Public Primary and Lower Secondary Schools (公立小学校・中学校の適正規模・適正配置等に関する手引), 8文科初第1125号.
  • Japan. Act on Subsidies for Private Schools (私立学校振興助成法), Article 12.

Interfaces

This series: XX31 to XX35.

Handed to Paper 8: who sets these rules.

Handed to other papers: the measure of reaching and differences between schools, the Theory of Fairness (neighboring, unpublished); requirements brought by fees, and school and home, Paper 8 (XX37).