Positive-Sum, Unsought
恰为正和
This paper reads where the sum in a relation can fall. There are two kinds of sum. Payoff positive-sum lies on the payoff table: to speak of it, one first states the baseline of comparison, which gains and costs are counted, and the single scale on which their change is recorded; it can be reckoned, and it can be sought. Ontological positive-sum is the legislative subjectivity of both ends becoming more active: it does not lie on the payoff table, cannot be reckoned, and is not summed. The positive-sum, unsought, that this paper speaks of is ontological positive-sum. The three cases, divided by the number of ends headed in the 15DD direction, are a stipulation at the object layer, not three kinds of people and not three kinds of relation; 15DD and 14DD here are stances, not labels, and the layer is recorded by a single operation.
In dealings where both ends read the other only as an item in their own tables, the payoff layer goes with the game: a zero-sum game lands at zero-sum, a standard one-shot prisoner's dilemma lands in the cell where both are worse off than under joint cooperation, and a game with a positive-sum cell in it can land at payoff positive-sum. The ontological positive-sum this paper reads cannot be read there: its antecedent is that at least one end recognizes the other as an end too. This paper does not on that account judge that nothing at all grew on that occasion. Among such dealings, those that contend for recognition as a finite resource are zero-sum at the ontological layer; those that oppose each other until both parties' subjectivity is consumed are negative-sum at the ontological layer. Between dealings in the 14DD direction and in the 15DD direction, the difference lies not in whether there is payoff but in where the sum can fall: payoff is not enough: growth is necessary for ontological positive-sum, but growth alone is not sufficient.
When one end is headed in the 15DD direction and the other leans toward 14DD, ontological positive-sum appears in the shape of cultivation. Cultivation carried out means that this end took on the direction of cultivation, and that his act also actually opened the conditions for the other's own forming, avowing and revising; once cultivation has been carried out, this end gains, and the gain lies in the exercise of the legislative activity of recognizing the other as an end, without waiting for anything to come back from the other, and without waiting for the other to grow. Where the other's own law has grown too, it is read as ontological positive-sum; where it has not, it is recorded as it is. Neither side's gain can be obtained by seeking it: producing and checking a result against a standard fixed in advance yields the result the standard records, and cannot stand in for the actual unfolding of legislative activity. So ontological positive-sum is read only in looking back: where it can be read, it came unsought; where it cannot, it is recorded as it is. Whether to make a cultivative intervention toward the other is first assessed as Cultivation Theory has it, and what is judged is conditions, not an expected sum. To say that a stretch of dealings has ontological positive-sum does not offset the account of harm.
This paper borrows the phrase "purposiveness without purpose" on the relation side and states its limits; it interfaces with Kant, Smith, von Neumann and Morgenstern, and the Laozi. It does not prove that 15DD pays at the payoff layer, does not prove that 14DD must lose at the payoff layer, does not prove that one ought to treat people from 15DD, and does not prove that cultivation is bound to succeed.
Introduction
Fang Yan and Su Yao work together at a company that repairs equipment. Fang Yan has been at it for more than ten years and has worked out a way of tracking down faults: what to check first, what to check next, which step can be skipped and which cannot. Su Yao is in her second year at the company, and the jobs in her hands are getting harder. Fang Yan teaches her this way of doing things, holding nothing back; he gives the reason for every step, and says that she need not follow it, and can change it. In this stretch of dealings there is nothing the two have jointly avowed: Fang Yan teaches, Su Yao learns, and each works on his or her own jobs.
What came after could go three ways. In one, Su Yao follows that way of doing things exactly, uses it to carry off a large project, and is promoted. In another, Su Yao uses it on a kind of equipment Fang Yan has never worked on, changes one of its steps, and tells Fang Yan the reason for the change; Fang Yan goes back over his own original order, and changes it too. In the third, in the report she hands to her supervisor, Su Yao writes this way of doing things up as her own, and also proposes that Fang Yan's re-check comments no longer be entered in the project from then on; later Fang Yan is no longer on that project either.
All three courses can be set out on a payoff table: in the first, Su Yao gained; in the second, both people's ways of working got somewhat better; in the third, Su Yao gained and Fang Yan lost. What this paper asks about is the layer beyond the payoff table: in these three courses, is there a sum that does not lie on the payoff table; if there is, where does it fall, how is it read; can it be taken as a target and made.
The point of this paper can first be put in two plain sentences: where ontological positive-sum is not sought, the result can turn out positive-sum, unsought; once it is sought, it becomes reckoning. Payoff is not enough; it takes growth. These two sentences speak of those dealings in which, looking back, both ends' gains can be read; not seeking does not by itself guarantee that both ends gain, and this end's gain alone is not ontological positive-sum. Where it can be read, it came unsought; where it cannot, it is recorded as it is.
What this paper reads. Relation Theory sets down only what all relations have; a proposition that holds only in one kind of relation is handed to the series on that kind of relation.1 What this paper reads is the layer at which the sum in a relation can fall: the payoff layer, or the ontological layer. This reading does not change with the kind of relation, so it is set down at the layer of Relation Theory, as a Relation Theory special paper, in the same way that Changing the Game is a Cooperation Theory special paper. How it falls in each branch is pointed back to the branches (§6). Cooperation Theory Paper 2 has written that writing one's giving as an account "lies at the normative layer and does not change with the kind of relation"; this paper's reading lies at the same layer.2 It sets up no theory of payoff, and gives relations no scores.
In SAE's layers, the layer at which the other is recognized as an end too is marked 15DD; the layer at which one has one's own direction and guards the things one cannot set down is marked 14DD. 15DD and 14DD here, as in the papers of Relation Theory, are stances, not labels for persons: to say that an end is headed in the 15DD direction is to say where this person operates toward in this matter.
Back to Fang Yan and Su Yao. Suppose that in this matter Fang Yan is headed in the 15DD direction and Su Yao leans toward 14DD; suppose that this teaching of Fang Yan's actually opened the conditions for Su Yao's own forming, avowing and revising of judgments. These two are stipulations given by the example, not inferences from the outward look of "teaching her, holding nothing back."
Three cases. This paper divides three cases by the number of ends headed in the 15DD direction. This is a stipulation at the object layer, not three kinds of people and not three kinds of relation.
| Case | How this paper reads it |
|---|---|
| Neither end is headed in the 15DD direction | Ideal type: both ends take the other into their own tables only as an item. The ontological positive-sum this paper reads cannot be read there, and it is not on that account judged that nothing at all grew; those that contend for recognition are zero-sum at the ontological layer; those that oppose each other are negative-sum at the ontological layer; where judgments are actually chiseled open, it is recorded separately by Relation Theory (§1) |
| One end is headed in the 15DD direction, the other leans toward 14DD | This paper's main object: once cultivation has been carried out, this end gains; whether the other has grown lies with the other; where the other has grown too, it is read as ontological positive-sum (§5) |
| Both ends are headed in the 15DD direction | Where mutual chiseling actually happened, this paper points back to Moral Law P5 and does not set it up again (§4) |
The ideal type of the first row has already been written in Cooperation Theory.3 What leans toward 14DD without reading the other only as an item is not read by the first row along with it; only those operations that really do read the other only as an item are read by it.4 The layer is recorded by a single operation: within one stretch of dealings, in this matter one end is there, in that matter both ends are there, in another matter it has fallen back, and the cases can interweave. Moral Law P6 writes that mixed reality is the normal state, and a pure 15DD community is only an ideal type.5 At the operation layer, each party can confirm only its own end, and no one certifies from outside who is at which layer.6
What is not read. Aggregation at the community layer is not read: how the sum among many people is read goes by Relation Theory's keeping of accounts pair by pair, and this paper goes only as far as two ends. Mechanism design is not read. What passes between people and animals, or between people and AI, is not read. The relation with oneself is not read: in this paper the "sum" is read only between two ends, and there is no talk of a sum within one person.
Shared words.
- "Sum": wherever this paper says "positive-sum," "zero-sum" or "negative-sum," it states whether it is at the payoff layer or the ontological layer; "positive-sum, unsought" on its own refers to ontological positive-sum. The difference between the two kinds of sum is read in §1.
- "Reckoning": a neutral word, naming operation at the payoff layer, not a person's stance. The end headed in the 15DD direction reckons as usual at the payoff layer too. The operation of treating the other only as a strategy set, only as a condition of one's own outcome, this paper writes by its structure, and does not use the word "calculation"; where an upstream sentence has that word, it is quoted as it stands.
- "Seek": taken in the narrow sense, naming only fixing a result in advance, producing it to that specification, and checking it against the same specification. Open hoping is not among these. Read in §3.
- "Unsought": not obtained by seeking in the narrow sense of "seek" above; it does not mean that no purpose, hope or prior specification was present. Ontological positive-sum is read only in looking back; where it can be read, it is said to be positive-sum, unsought. Read in §3.
- "Cultivation": as in Moral Law P9 and Cultivation Theory: not replacing the other's law with one's own purposes, only providing the context in which the other's law can unfold.7 Cultivation itself belongs to Cultivation Theory; this paper points back to it and does not set it up again.
- "Gain": when this paper speaks of one end's gain, it speaks of the ontological side, that is, the unfolding of his own legislative activity, not getting something at the payoff layer. Gains and losses at the payoff layer are recorded as payoff. In Chinese, the same word is also used for what is gained at the payoff layer. In this paper, the layer is distinguished by context; "gains and costs" and "gains and losses" refer to payoff.
- "Mutual chiseling": the mutual chiseling of Moral Law P5 is the kind in which both ends are headed in the 15DD direction; the mutual chiseling that Relation Theory reads by process is wider, and looks at whether the two sides' judgments have actually been chiseled open. The two senses are kept apart, and read in §1 and §4.
This paper reads seven things. First, the two kinds of sum, and where the sum falls when both ends read the other only as an item. Second, two purposes not merged into one table, and where the difference between dealings in the 14DD and the 15DD direction lies. Third, being unsought: why ontological positive-sum cannot be set as a goal. Fourth, standing not lying within the game, and the case where both ends are there. Fifth, one end there: cultivation and gain, confirming and keeping accounts. Sixth, first assessing, and the branches. Seventh, keeping no accounts, and offsetting none. Then comes interfacing with tradition.
§1 Two Kinds of Sum
PS1 The sum of payoffs and the gains and losses of each party are read apart: to speak of payoff positive-sum or zero-sum, one first states the baseline of comparison, which gains and costs are counted, and the single scale on which their change is recorded; to speak of both losing is to say that each party has become worse off relative to the stated baseline, and does not presuppose summing across persons. Improvement at the payoff layer can be reckoned, and can be sought. Ontological positive-sum is the legislative subjectivity of both ends becoming more active; it does not lie on this table, cannot be reckoned, and is not summed. The positive-sum, unsought, that this paper speaks of is ontological positive-sum
How Payoff Positive-Sum Is Spoken Of
To say that one occasion of dealings is positive-sum in payoff, three things have to be said first: what the baseline of comparison is, which gains and costs are counted, and on what scale their change is recorded. Without these three, the words "positive-sum" and "zero-sum" have nowhere to land.
For the stretch in which Fang Yan teaches Su Yao, take as the baseline the situation without this teaching and learning; count only the working hours the two spend, within the same period, completing the same amount of the same kind of repair, with the hours of teaching and learning counted in. Suppose that in the second course, relative to this baseline, both spend fewer net hours; then on this measure the payoff layer is positive-sum; the other gains and losses not counted here are recorded separately. In the third course, Su Yao gains the credit and the project and Fang Yan loses the project; whether this gain and loss is zero-sum depends on what is counted: counting only that one project, one person gains and one loses; counting also the hours Fang Yan spends less from then on, and the responsibility Su Yao carries more from then on, the reading is different again.
To speak of both losing is to say that each of the two has become worse off relative to the stated baseline; it is not first turning the two people's gains and losses into one unit and then adding them. Whenever this paper speaks of a sum of payoffs, it goes by this reading; the sum of payoffs and each person's gains and losses are read apart.
Improvement at the payoff layer can be reckoned, and can be sought. Two people jointly settling on a particular improvement and going on to make it is an ordinary matter at the payoff layer.
Ontological Positive-Sum
The positive-sum that Moral Law P5 sets down does not lie on this table. That paper's signature claim writes that mutual chiseling between 15DDs makes both parties' legislative subjectivity more active, and that this is the ontological ground of positive-sum; it also writes that positive-sum is always ontological positive-sum, not utilitarian positive-sum, legislative subjectivity more active, not utility higher.8 Moral Law P0 keeps the two apart: ontological positive-sum and utilitarian positive-sum are categorically distinct, the former saying that legislative subjectivity is more active, the latter that the total of utility has increased.9
This paper follows this division, and calls the two kinds of sum payoff positive-sum and ontological positive-sum. The utilitarian positive-sum of which P5 and P0 speak is what is here called payoff positive-sum.
Ontological positive-sum cannot be reckoned, and is not summed. P5 writes that recognition structure, as recognition of End, cannot be positively defined in its ontology, much less aggregated and quantified.10 Once it is summed, it is back on the payoff table. So when this paper speaks of ontological positive-sum, it speaks only of whether, on one occasion of dealings, each end's own legislative activity has become more active, not of how much more the two have put together.
The scope of P5 is the ontological argument at the dyad layer within pure 15DD context.11 What this paper reads is wider than that: in the row where one end is headed in the 15DD direction and the other leans toward 14DD, ontological positive-sum appears in the shape of cultivation, read in §5. This step is an extension, this paper's own undertaking.
The Two Layers Recorded Apart
The payoff layer and the ontological layer are recorded apart, neither added together nor offset against each other. Where the payoff table shows positive-sum, ontological positive-sum is not read off from it; where the payoff table shows zero-sum, it is not read off from it either that nothing at all is there at the ontological layer.
One point of wording needs care. On the path of joint deepening, the Conflict Treatise writes: "A kind of yield can form here, and it must be written as a possibility"; what follows is that mutual chiseling can make both parties' legislating more active.12 The "yield" there is on the ontological side; this paper's "payoff positive-sum" refers only to what lies on the payoff table. Where that sentence is quoted, it is quoted as it stands, with no word changed.
PS2 When the other enters one's table only as a strategy set, only as a condition of one's own outcome, then in this end's own share, of the two kinds of positive-sum this paper reads, only payoff positive-sum can be read. Where both ends are like this, the ontological positive-sum this paper reads cannot be read there, and it is not on that account judged that nothing at all grew on that occasion; among such dealings, those that contend for recognition as a finite resource are zero-sum at the ontological layer, and those that oppose each other until both parties' subjectivity is consumed are negative-sum at the ontological layer. The occasion on which the two sides' judgments are actually chiseled open is recorded, by Relation Theory, as mutual chiseling in the process sense
The Payoff Layer Goes with the Game
Suppose a buyer and a seller are haggling over a table at a secondhand market. Suppose that in this matter each takes the other into his own table only as a set of offers: the buyer looks at the most he will pay, the seller at the least he will take, and whatever the other says enters only as a condition of the next price.
An end like this can solve within the game, and can also change the game: the buyer can say he will come back tomorrow, the seller can throw in a chair along with the table, bringing about a cell the original table did not have. Changing the Game has written that the end that leans toward 14DD changes the game too, and may also bring about options there were not before; the difference lies not in whether one changes the game but in where the change heads.13 Once he has changed it, what he heads toward is still his own cell in the game.
At the payoff layer, the sum goes with the game. A zero-sum game lands at zero-sum: in the game where it is already settled that the table will be sold and only the price is in contention, counting only the selling price, every unit more the seller takes is a unit more the buyer pays. In a standard one-shot prisoner's dilemma, each side taking its dominant action lands in the cell where both are worse off than under joint cooperation. A game with a positive-sum cell in it can land at payoff positive-sum: the table is sold, the buyer saves something over buying elsewhere, the seller moves something that had been sitting in the shop; suppose that, on one money measure and with each one's counted costs deducted, both come out with a net gain relative to each party's own no-deal option. This reading is true on the payoff table.
Ontological Positive-Sum Cannot Be Read Here
The ontological positive-sum this paper reads cannot be read in dealings where both ends are like this. Its antecedent is that at least one end recognizes the other as an end too: where both ends are there, it is read in §4; where one end is there, in §5. Neither of the two haggling people, in this matter, recognizes the other as an end too, and this paper's argument cannot be carried over.
This sentence says only that this paper cannot read it there, not that nothing at all grew on that occasion. From this antecedent's not holding alone, it does not follow that neither of the two grew anything on this occasion. This paper's scope stops here.
Zero-Sum and Negative-Sum
In dealings where both ends read the other only as an item, what falls into zero-sum or negative-sum at the ontological layer is the cells where there is contention. The abstract of Moral Law P5 writes that the same situation in a 14DD context becomes zero-sum or negative-sum: going to court consumes both parties' subjectivity.14 §2.2 of the same paper writes that in the adversarial frame validation is treated as a finite resource: given to the winner, it is not given to the loser.15
This paper reads by these two places: those that contend for recognition as a finite resource are zero-sum at the ontological layer: to recognize this side as right is not to recognize that side; those that oppose each other until both parties' subjectivity is consumed are negative-sum at the ontological layer. What the original reads is the adversarial frame, and its subject is a dispute. At the table being haggled over, the two do not contend over who is right, and do not take recognition to be divided; this paper does not say that this is zero-sum at the ontological layer.
The Occasion on Which Judgments Are Chiseled Open
In dealings where both ends lean toward 14DD there can also be mutual chiseling. Relation Theory Paper 1 writes that entering the same process is the precondition of mutual chiseling.16 Relation Theory Paper 4 writes that the mutual chiseling Relation Theory reads by process is broader than the 15DD mutual chiseling spoken of in Moral Law P5: what it looks at is whether the two sides' judgments have actually been chiseled open; the moment of two-way 15DD requires that both sides recognize the other as an end in itself, and mutual chiseling does not require this; counterexamples to the converse exist, and conflict between 14DDs is one.17
Suppose that halfway through the haggling the seller says, "None of these joints needs mending." The buyer says, "The whole frame has to be redone." The two squat down to look. The buyer points out one joint that is loose; the seller feels it and says, "This one needs patching." He then asks the buyer to try the other three legs. The buyer shakes them and says, "These three are sound; the whole frame doesn't need redoing." After that, each changes his own price. On this occasion each of the two revised one earlier judgment: the seller's was pointed out by the buyer; the buyer's came out of the seller asking him to try. By Relation Theory, this occasion is recorded as mutual chiseling in the process sense; it is not on that basis said that the two recognized each other as ends on this occasion. Whether it is the ontological positive-sum this paper speaks of, this paper does not read; it is registered as a remainder (§9).
That the other has grown, that both parties' judgments are actually chiseled open, and that both recognize each other as ends on this occasion are three things, and none stands in for another.
One Sentence at the Entrance
So this paper's scope can be put in one plain sentence: at least one person, in a relation, does not read the other only as an item in his own table. This sentence is a summary at the entrance, not an equivalent replacement for all the conditions of scope; it does not change the readings at the payoff layer. Dealings in which both ends lean toward 14DD and neither reads the other only as an item are taken in by this sentence; this paper has not read them, and they are registered in §9.
§2 Where the Sum Can Fall
PS3 The end headed in the 15DD direction recognizes that the other's purposes are the other's: it only recognizes them as there, and cannot read out their content; it does not merge two purposes into one table; ontological positive-sum is neither its purpose nor its criterion. Matters at the payoff layer go on as usual: one reckons one's own gains and costs, and two people jointly settling on a particular improvement can also seek it
Only Recognizing Them as There
Fang Yan recognizes that Su Yao's purposes are hers. Why she is learning this way of doing things, and where she means to go once she has learned it, are her affair; Fang Yan recognizes them as there, and cannot read out their content. Marriage Theory has written a sentence of the same shape: the other has his own cannot-not, which I only recognize as there, and whose content I cannot read out.18
So Fang Yan has no table of "the two of us together." He can reckon for himself: every evening he stays an extra hour to explain this way of doing things, he completes one repair job fewer of his own; he can also make an estimate: once she has learned it, her jobs may go somewhat faster. All of this lies in each one's own share. Merging two purposes into one table amounts to having a position from which the two sides can be ranked. Reading two people coming to an agreement on a matter, Value Theory has written that this does not mean the two sets of value have merged into one common table, nor that a position has appeared that ranks the two sides.19 If that holds even for two people doing a thing together, then between Fang Yan teaching and Su Yao learning, where there is not even one jointly avowed matter, there is still less such a position.
Reckoning As Usual
The end headed in the 15DD direction reckons as usual at the payoff layer. Changing the Game writes: "Looking out for one's own concerns is not calculation."20 Fang Yan reckoning his own hours does not on that account cease to be headed in the 15DD direction; suppose Su Yao is also reckoning whether she can be promoted: she does not on that account read Fang Yan only as an item either. When two people jointly settle on a particular improvement, for instance agreeing to write each one's troubleshooting records into the same notebook, this matter can be sought, and is read by Cooperation Theory.
Ontological Positive-Sum Is Not the Criterion
Ontological positive-sum is not Fang Yan's purpose, nor his criterion. In this one teaching, the direction is read on this one effect; whether there is ontological positive-sum is read in looking back. Cooperation Theory writes that whether the other's capacity has increased is a measure of outcomes, and is not used to judge direction.21 By the same shape, this paper does not use the sum to judge direction either: where ontological positive-sum is read in looking back, it is not inferred backward that that occasion was headed in the 15DD direction; where it cannot be read, it is not inferred backward that it was not. This step is an extension by sameness of shape, this paper's own undertaking.
PS4 Between dealings in the 14DD direction and in the 15DD direction, the difference lies not in whether there is payoff but in where the sum can fall: in dealings where both ends read the other only as an item, of positive-sum only the payoff kind can be read, and the ontological positive-sum this paper reads cannot be read; in dealings in the 15DD direction, the sum can also fall on growth. Payoff is not enough: growth is necessary for ontological positive-sum, but growth alone is not sufficient. Direction is read on each single effect, growth is read in looking back, and the latter is not used to judge the former
The Difference Is Not Whether There Is Payoff
The two haggling people can be positive-sum at the payoff layer. Fang Yan teaching Su Yao can be positive-sum at the payoff layer too. Both have payoff; the difference is not there.
The difference lies in where the sum can fall. At the table being haggled over, of positive-sum only the payoff kind can be read; between Fang Yan and Su Yao, the sum can also fall on growth. This difference comes from the antecedent of the argument this paper uses: the arguments of §4 and §5 require that at least one end recognizes the other as an end too. Where the antecedent does not hold, this paper does not go on to judge; in dealings where both ends read the other only as an item, if mutual chiseling actually happened, how its ontological layer is read remains among the remainders spoken of in §1.
Payoff Is Not Enough
Take the first course. Su Yao follows that way of doing things exactly, without changing a step, uses it to carry off a large project, and is promoted. At the payoff layer, Su Yao gained; whether Fang Yan gained in payoff is as he himself says.
Promotion is a matter of the payoff layer; it does not show whether Su Yao has grown. Following it exactly does not show it either: Cultivation Theory Paper 1 writes that a content that comes from outside is not on that account not his; whether it is his depends on where avowal is accomplished.22 At this point, the example has not given whether Su Yao has formed judgments she herself avows and can herself change. So this paper does not add growth on the strength of following exactly or of promotion, nor infer backward from her not having changed anything that she has not grown.
If this course is to carry "she really did not grow," a further condition has to be stipulated: up to this looking back, Su Yao has still not formed judgments she herself avows and revises. With this stipulated, Su Yao has gained at the payoff layer, but at the ontological layer she has not grown. Payoff is not enough.
Growth Alone Does Not Establish Ontological Positive-Sum
Conversely, growth alone does not establish ontological positive-sum. In dealings where both ends read the other only as an item, if someone grew something, this paper does not read it (§1). Where one end is headed in the 15DD direction, and only this end gains while the other has not grown, it is not ontological positive-sum either (§5).
Direction and Growth Read Apart
Direction is read on each single effect, growth is read in looking back, and the latter is not used to judge the former. Whether Su Yao later grew does not go back and rejudge where that one teaching of Fang Yan's was headed. Aesthetics Ray 13 has written a way of looking back, and also written that this is a looking back after the fact, not a criterion.23 The growth read in looking back hangs on ontological positive-sum, not on direction.
§3 Unsought
PS5 "Seek," as this paper uses it, is taken in the narrow sense: fixing a result in advance, producing it to that specification, and checking it against the same specification; aimed at ontological positive-sum, it is setting up for it in advance an exhaustive, optimizable positive standard. In this sense, ontological positive-sum cannot be set as a goal. What the other grows into is for the other to decide. Open hoping, each one's own purposes, particular arrangements both have avowed, and providing conditions are not among these. So ontological positive-sum is read only in looking back: where it can be read, it came unsought; where it cannot, it is recorded as it is; looking back can be mistaken
The Narrow Sense of Seeking
"Seek," as this paper uses it, is taken in one narrow sense only: first fixing what is to be obtained, producing it to that specification, and once it is done checking it against the same specification. Aimed at ontological positive-sum, it is setting up for it in advance an exhaustive, optimizable positive standard, making it by this standard, and then checking it against this standard.
Moral Law P3 has set down this boundary for reputation: any positive definition collapses reputation into a thing, and once collapsed, 14DD optimization activates and falsifies what was supposed to be measured; that paper goes on to draw a limit: what is prohibited is exhaustive, centralized, optimizable definition, while distributed, local and approximate articulation remains legitimate.24 What the original speaks of is reputation; carrying it to ontological positive-sum is an extension, this paper's own undertaking.
Once Set, It Is Replaced
In this sense, ontological positive-sum cannot be set as a goal. Once it is set like this, each end's unfolding is replaced by a goal that can be checked and optimized; when it is made, what is obtained is the result this standard records, not the two ends' legislative activity becoming more active itself. In the two plain sentences at the opening of this paper, "once it is sought, it becomes reckoning" speaks of this step: once one fixes in advance and goes on to produce and check against it, ontological positive-sum is replaced by the kind that can be checked and reckoned. What is said is not that there is something wrong with seeking: what seeking obtains is the result the standard records, not ontological positive-sum; whether ontological positive-sum has happened is still checked separately by the actual unfolding, and it is not judged absent because there was fixing in advance.
Brought onto the other, it is fixing in advance what he ought to grow into. Suppose Fang Yan takes "in three months, doing everything exactly by my checklist" as proof that Su Yao has formed her own judgment. Su Yao proposes a different troubleshooting order, and gives reasons that can be checked; Fang Yan does not check these reasons, and judges whether her judgment holds only by whether it matches his own checklist; when the three months are up, whatever differs he reaches in and changes back for her. She says she does not agree with it herself, and he still records her carrying out the checklist as her having avowed it. What is decided for her here is already what counts as her having completed her own judgment; the times he changed it back for her have already exited the 15DD direction. Moral Law P9 writes that any operation of forced change, even when issuing from a 15DD legislative subject, has itself exited the cultivation posture; what cultivation provides is the context within which this unfolding can occur, not the direction of the unfolding itself.25 The Prequel to Cultivation Theory, borrowing Zhu Xi's gloss on "do not help it grow," reads the same place: what this item blocks is reaching out to grow for him when the expected result does not come.26
What the Other Grows into Is for the Other to Decide
What the other grows into, and whether he grows, cannot be fixed in advance by this end, nor completed by him for the other; nor can it become the standard by which the other is checked, or the condition for deciding whether to go on recognizing him. Among the items the Prequel to Cultivation Theory lists under "what it is not," one is: not setting the other's reaching the result I fixed in advance as the condition for continuing to treat him as an end.27
What cultivation heads toward is letting the other's law be able to develop; what lies in this end's hands is the one act of giving conditions. What that act actually opened is checked separately (§5).
What Is Not Among These
This boundary excludes only fixing in advance, producing and checking that are aimed at ontological positive-sum, or at what the other grows into. The following are not among these:
- Open hoping. Fang Yan hopes that Su Yao will one day find her own way of doing things; when, and in what shape, he has not fixed, nor does he check her by it. This is not seeking.
- Each one's own purposes. Su Yao wants to be promoted, Fang Yan wants to get his own repair jobs done, and each does by his or her own purposes.
- Particular arrangements both have avowed. Suppose the two have agreed on that records notebook; going by it is ordinary at the payoff layer.
- Providing conditions. Fang Yan giving reasons, giving material, leaving room for Su Yao not to follow him, is giving conditions, not seeking.
- Teaching an operation by a checklist, checking one repair by technical conditions. These in themselves are not the seeking excluded here; what is to be checked is whether the checklist is used to decide for the other what counts as his having completed his own judgment.
Renaming an arrangement of producing and checking against a standard fixed in advance as not seeking still falls within what is excluded here. If Fang Yan does not call that checklist a "standard" but "what I expect of you," and checks item by item by it whether her judgment holds, it is still the seeking spoken of here.
Looking Back
So ontological positive-sum is read only in looking back. Where it can be read, it came unsought; where it cannot, it is recorded as it is. The Conflict Treatise, writing of the kind of yield that can form in joint deepening, requires that it be written as a possibility.12 Whenever this paper says what can be read in looking back, it goes by this way of writing.
Looking back can also be mistaken. Aesthetics Ray 13 has given one way of looking back: take away the ruler that person gave you, and see; without that person, do you still acknowledge that place as yours, and can you change it yourself?23 This is a way of looking back, not a criterion; what is read by it can still be wrong.
Borrowing a Phrase
The point of this paper can be said by borrowing a phrase: purposiveness without purpose. SAE has used this phrase, and placed it on 15DD: To Forget the Self, in the Introspection series, writes that 15DD's non dubito is not a moral command but the direction that naturally emerges after completing observation and illumination, what Kant's Third Critique calls "purposiveness without purpose."28 Its destination has also been registered: Chapter Five of the Second Critique writes that this side belongs to the critique of judgment, and records there only its destination.29 SAE aesthetics reads the phrase another way: Kant's "purposiveness without purpose" is a description of the aesthetic emergent layer.30
This paper borrows this phrase only on the relation side. It borrows it only to keep apart a goal set in advance and a direction that is seen: 15DD is a direction, not a goal; ontological positive-sum is not something it sets out to make, and neither end's gain can be obtained by seeking it (§5). What Kant's account lacks is a determinate concept of a purpose; here there is none either: ontological positive-sum cannot be directly defined, and is read only in looking back.
This borrowing has three limits. First, Kant's reflective judgment is not the same as looking back after the fact: the Introduction to the Critique of Judgment writes that judgment is merely reflective only when the particular is given and the universal is to be found for it.31 This distinction does not go by before and after an action. Placing the sum on the side of looking back is this paper's own handling, this paper's own undertaking. Second, the phrase does not prescribe what results a relation will have; what can be read is borne by the particular dealings and by the argument that fits them. Third, this new use added by this paper is registered at that same place in the critique of judgment, and is revised along with it.
§4 Standing and Both Ends
PS6 A particular gain within a game can be allotted exclusively: when two people contend for the same thing of which there is only one share, that game is zero-sum, and the end headed in the 15DD direction contends for it just the same. Standing as an end does not lie within the game, and is not diminished by this. Zero-sum falls not only on what there is only one share of (at the payoff layer; a matter of the game, which either end contends for just the same), but also on what is treated as if there were only one share of it (at the ontological layer): who is right, whose word goes, who owes whom; when "my adjudication holds" is arranged into "your adjudication no longer counts," the mutual exclusion falls on this arrangement
What There Is Only One Share Of
Later the company is to promote a team lead, and both Fang Yan and Su Yao put their names forward. There is only one team lead, and at the payoff layer this game is zero-sum: if one gets it, the other does not. The end headed in the 15DD direction contends just the same: Fang Yan reports his jobs and his ways of working over these years as they are, and does not go to the supervisor to speak ill of Su Yao. Changing the Game has read a game of the same shape, two workshops each quoting to make bookcases, quoting honestly and not going to the school to speak ill of the other; competition can be just competition.32
Standing Does Not Lie within the Game
The team lead's post lies within the game; standing as an end does not. Recognizing Su Yao as an end too does not diminish Fang Yan's own standing as an end; the Rights Theory special paper writes that a basic right stands on standing; it is pre-relational, and comes to be with a single subject.33 Standing is not a finite pool, and does not lose a share because another person is recognized. Love Theory Paper 5 has written a sentence of the same shape: the share of recognizing her as an end too does not grow smaller because one loves this one.34 Carrying this shape onto standing is an extension, this paper's own undertaking.
How this recognition is realized has its own costs. The extra hour Fang Yan stays each evening is time; the reasons he gives Su Yao are care and effort. These are recorded by the actual relation. Relation Theory writes that acknowledgment that requires no qualification and the realization of recognition are kept on separate books.35 Recognition is not diminished in standing; the time, care and resources that realize recognition are reckoned as usual at the payoff layer.
What Is Treated as If There Were Only One Share of It
Zero-sum can also fall elsewhere: on what is treated as if there were only one share of it. Who is right, whose word goes, who owes whom are not, in themselves, things of which there is only one share: one judgment being adopted does not by itself make the other party's position for giving reasons and asking for a check disappear. Once they are treated as if there were only one share, and that latter position is excluded along with it, recognition becomes the pool that is divided up back and forth, and what Moral Law P5 calls being "given to the winner" and "not given to the loser" falls here.15
Take the third course. In the report she hands to her supervisor, Su Yao writes that way of doing things up as her own; the credit for that project, the signature on it, and the post that came later all fall to her. These gains and losses are each recorded as they are at the payoff layer: credit in the column for credit, signature in the column for signature, post in the column for post. From this gain and loss, no zero-sum is reckoned up for the ontological layer.
Suppose Su Yao goes a step further: she proposes to the supervisor that the troubleshooting conclusions on this project be signed off by her, and that Fang Yan's re-check comments from then on, whatever their reasons, no longer enter the project's records or its checking. The supervisor does so. At this step, Fang Yan's position for putting forward a re-check judgment on this project has been excluded by this arrangement: "her adjudication holds" has been arranged into "Fang Yan's adjudication no longer counts," and only now is recognition made mutually exclusive in this arrangement, read by this proposition. What is read here is the moment of Su Yao proposing this arrangement to the supervisor, read for where it heads. The supervisor's doing so is the company's provision; by Relation Theory Paper 1, the provisions themselves are acknowledged but not judged, and this paper only registers it as a condition of the dealings that follow.36 This paper does not add, from the allotment of credit, a gain and loss in the two ends' subjectivity, nor, on account of this arrangement, rejudge this whole stretch of dealings as the ideal type of §1. Later Fang Yan is no longer on that project either.
Parent-Child Theory Paper 7 has read a matter going the other way: the interpretations and avowals the parents' end used to hold for the child are given back to him, domain by domain.37 Read by this proposition, that is not losing something of which there is only one share; adjudication is not something there is only one share of.
The Minister's Post
Untangling Zhuangzi · Outer Chapters, Volume I reads the story in "Autumn Floods" of Huizi as minister of Liang: told that Zhuangzi had come to take his place as minister, Huizi was afraid, and searched the capital for three days and three nights.38 A minister's post is a thing of which there is only one share, and the scene of Huizi as minister of Liang falls on it. In this narrative, Zhuangzi denies taking the post as something he seeks. This paper takes only this structure. The Zhuangzi is a text, and what it records is not taken as history; the same pair of people, in other scenes, are each in different cases, read below.
PS7 Where both ends are headed in the 15DD direction, and mutual chiseling actually happened in this matter, this paper points back to Moral Law P5: mutual chiseling can make both parties' legislating more active, which is ontological positive-sum, not a summing of payoffs. That moment is recorded, by Relation Theory, as something that happens on an occasion, and does not grade a person or a relation
Pointing Back, Not Setting Up Again
Where both ends are headed in the 15DD direction and actually chisel each other in this matter, it is the kind Moral Law P5 sets down: mutual chiseling makes both parties' legislative subjectivity more active, and this is the ontological ground of positive-sum.8 This paper points back to it and does not set it up again. Its place in this paper is the last row of the three cases, used to set off the row of one end: where both ends are there, ontological positive-sum comes from both sides together; where one end is there, ontological positive-sum appears in the shape of cultivation, read in §5.
That moment is recorded, by Relation Theory, as something that happens on an occasion. Relation Theory writes that the moment of two-way 15DD is something that happens on an occasion, not a grade that a person or a relation is in.39 That two people once had such an occasion in some matter does not put all their later dealings in this row of itself. 16DD itself, this paper does not touch.
Above the Hao
Aesthetics Ray 13 reads the scene above the Hao together with the figure of Carpenter Shi, and writes that the evidence for mutuality is not in that figure but in the scene above the Hao: there both have axes in hand, each the other's Carpenter Shi, and each the other's counterpart.40 The scene of Zhuangzi and Hui Shi above the Hao is, by Ray 13, an occasion on which both ends are there; it is pointed back to, and this paper does not read it again. The same pair: the scene of Huizi as minister of Liang falls on a thing of which there is only one share, and in the scene above the Hao both ends are there. The layer is recorded by a single operation, and this paper does not fix Huizi as any kind of person.
§5 One End: Cultivation
PS8 Dealings in which one end is headed in the 15DD direction and the other leans toward 14DD can be the setting in which cultivation happens. Cultivation carried out means that this end took on the direction of cultivation, and that his act also actually opened the conditions for the other's own forming, avowing and revising; whether the other has completed his own step is not part of what "carried out" means. Once cultivation has been carried out, this end gains: the gain lies in the exercise of the legislative activity of recognizing the other as an end, without waiting for anything to come back from the other, and without waiting for the other to grow. Where the other's own law has grown too, both ends gain, and it is read as ontological positive-sum; where the other has not grown, this end has gained and the other has not, and it is recorded as it is. Neither side's gain can be obtained by seeking it in the sense defined in §3
The Setting, Not the Source
Dealings in which one end is headed in the 15DD direction and the other leans toward 14DD can be the setting in which cultivation happens. Cooperation Theory has written this sentence: such cooperation can be the setting in which cultivation happens, not the source of cultivation; the completion of cultivation is not in the enactor's hands.41 Nor is cultivation the general opening move of dealings with one end there: whether to make an active intervention on the other's side is this end's own choice, and he can simply do his own share well.42 Moral Law P6 writes that cultivation is not the core activity but secondary; the primary activity is mutual-chiseling cooperation with other 15DDs.43 That this paper takes the row of one end as its main object is a choice of scope, and does not change that sentence.
What cultivation is, how it is given, and how far, belong to Cultivation Theory; this paper points back to it, and reads only the sum.
Carried Out
Cultivation carried out is counted by the first two of Cultivation Theory Paper 1's three questions: this end took on the direction of cultivation, and his act also actually opened the conditions for the other's own forming, avowing and revising. What can be given from outside is exactly these conditions.44 The third question, whether the other has completed his own step, is not included in "carried out." How the three questions are asked apart is read in the next proposition.
What is opened is conditions, not the other's share. Action Theory Paper 6 writes that cultivation necessarily leaves a blank, and what is left is the other person's share: whether he accepts, how he judges, whether he changes, whether he leaves; reaching into his share is a failure.45
Giving is not necessarily carrying out. Cultivation Theory Paper 3 lists four cases in which this one time did not help, and two of them lie on the giving end: the giving did not fit: the time, the person or the manner was wrong; the conditions did not actually open: something was given, but those positions did not, because of it, come any further into his hands.46 These two do not count as carried out; the sentence "this end gains" below does not apply, and it is recorded as it is.
By the stipulation of the Introduction, this teaching of Fang Yan's took on the direction and also actually opened the conditions, and in all three courses it was carried out. The three courses part afterward: in how things stand at Su Yao's end, and in what happened next.
Where the Gain Comes From
Once cultivation has been carried out, this end gains. Where the gain comes from has to be made clear.
Recognizing the other as an end lies in this end's own law from the start. The Prequel to Cultivation Theory restates Value Theory: recognizing a concrete other as an end is a content of a person's own law; when he goes on to open dimensions for the other, this act of going on is cultivation, the way that content looks when it moves.47 In this one teaching of Fang Yan's to Su Yao, this content actually unfolded in his act. Whether it unfolded is read by what his act actually opened, not by what he meant.
This content is activity, not resource, and is not lessened by being in motion. Moral Law P5 writes that the ontological difference between resource and activity is the root of the difference between 15DD positive-sum and 14DD negative-sum; the same paper also writes that subjectivity flourishes in exercise.48 The exercises the original names are articulating one's own view, responding, internal review and judging; it does not speak of cultivation; carrying it to cultivation is an extension, this paper's own undertaking.
So the gain lies in the exercise of this legislative activity. It does not wait for anything to come back from the other, nor for the other to grow. The gain of this one teaching of Fang Yan's lies in this one teaching, not in how Su Yao goes on afterward.
The "ontological" here, as in Moral Law P5, speaks of legislative subjectivity. Value Theory writes that cultivation is a verb-position on the side of direction-value, not a fifth value-source, and does not enter the ontological figure of end-value.49 That is another figure, and this paper does not change that sentence. When this paper speaks of this end's gain, it speaks of the unfolding of legislative activity, not a reading of direction-value; Value Theory writes that direction-value appraises the transformation, not the bearer.50 So this paper does not say that a value-source has increased, nor that after a person has given, his value as an end is higher.
Whether the Other Has Grown
Whether the other grows lies with the other. Where the other's own law has grown too, both ends gain, and it is read as ontological positive-sum. Where the other has not grown, this end has gained and the other has not; it is recorded as it is, and not read as ontological positive-sum. Reading the row of one end as ontological positive-sum is an extension, this paper's own undertaking.
In the first course, Su Yao follows it exactly and is promoted, and the example has not given whether she has grown: Fang Yan's share of gain is read by this proposition, and recorded apart from whether Su Yao grew.
In the second course, Su Yao has grown one step. She uses that way of doing things on a kind of cold-storage refrigeration unit Fang Yan has never worked on. The first step of Fang Yan's way is to check the power supply first; on units of this kind, Su Yao first pulls up the fault log stored in the controller, and then decides whether to take the power supply apart. She tells Fang Yan the reason: the controllers on units of this kind record faults, so looking at the log first tells her whether the power supply needs to be taken apart. That change she can explain herself, and can herself change. By Cultivation Theory Paper 1, whether it is hers depends on where avowal is accomplished; for this step, avowal has been accomplished at her end. On this occasion both ends gain, and it is read as ontological positive-sum.
Cooperation Theory Paper 2 has read an example of the same shape: Ke Yuan teaching Liang Dong to mend bicycles; what that example reads is direction, and whether it took hold is seen in her later understanding and action.51 This paper points back to that example and does not read it again; the second course adds the payoff layer to it, and brings out one more thing, below.
This End Can Also Be Cultivated
There is one more thing in the second course. The reason Su Yao told him made Fang Yan go back over his own first step. He changed his own way of doing things: on any unit whose controller records faults, the first step became looking at the log. He said to Su Yao, "This step is the way you said."
On this occasion it is Fang Yan who is cultivated, read from the receiving side. Action Theory Paper 6 has written of the same kind of thing: when the new hire came to ask, he only wanted to understand one thing, but the question gave the man an opening through which to walk back; later the new hire pointed out that his notes on the counting method were too long, and he thought about it and from then on made them shorter. That paper writes that the one who cultivates can also be cultivated, the two sides not fixed as giver and receiver; the one who takes the new hire as an end also gains things from the new hire, and those things, once he himself avows them, are his own too.52 Cultivation Theory Paper 3 takes this up, and writes that this is not read as reciprocity: the time he is cultivated is the giver's gaining something from another; once he takes it up himself, that too is his own.53
This paper writes by these two places: this end can also be cultivated, getting something from the other, and once he himself avows it, it is his own; this is not read as reciprocity, nor is it said on this basis that the other took on the direction of cultivation. When Su Yao told him the reason, whether what she took on was the direction of cultivation the example has not given, and this paper does not read it.
After Fang Yan had avowed that step, he asked her one more question: "After a unit loses power, does the controller still keep the fault log?" Su Yao went and checked a unit that had lost power, and the log was gone. She changed her own step to this: first make sure the log is still there; where it is not, check the power supply first, in the original order. This step, too, she checked herself and changed herself.
On this occasion both sides' judgments have actually been chiseled open at one point: Fang Yan's first step was chiseled open by the reason Su Yao told him; Su Yao's step was chiseled open by Fang Yan's question. By Relation Theory, it is recorded as mutual chiseling in the process sense (§1). Whether Su Yao on this occasion also recognized Fang Yan as an end, the example has not given, so it is not recorded by the row of §4. Su Yao's growth and the further unfolding of Fang Yan's own judgment are described above in terms of the specific changes each made; how much faster that way of doing things became as a result is recorded at the payoff layer.
This end being cultivated can happen, and need not. Both sides actually recognizing each other and chiseling each other on this occasion can also happen, and need not; where it does, that occasion is recorded by §4. What the second course shows is one occasion on which this end is cultivated; it does not say that every cultivation has such an occasion.
Neither Gain Can Be Obtained by Seeking It
Neither side's gain can be obtained by seeking it. "Seek" here is in the narrow sense of §3: producing and checking a result against a standard fixed in advance yields the result the standard records, and cannot stand in for the actual unfolding of legislative activity.
What the other grows into is for the other to decide, and cannot be completed for him by this end. This end's gain is the same: whether there is any is checked by the first two questions, and is not settled by a standard of gain fixed in advance; nor is it judged not to have happened because there was fixing in advance. Relation Theory, reading a moment of laughing face to face, has written a sentence in the same direction: what demand and agreement can guarantee is at most the outward laugh; if that moment is there, it was not obtained by demand or agreement, nor is it ruled out because there was an agreement.54 Here this sentence serves only as a reminder.
If this end decides whether to go on recognizing the other by a gain of its own fixed in advance, it has hung going on recognizing the other on its own gain, and "treating him as an end" has become a conditional reward. That item of the Prequel to Cultivation Theory speaks of the other's result: not setting the other's reaching the result I fixed in advance as the condition for continuing to treat him as an end.27 Carrying it to this end's own gain is an extension by sameness of shape, this paper's own undertaking. This arrangement is judged by structure, not by original intention: it is no longer cultivation, and the sentence "this end gains" does not apply; what actually happened is read separately. The Prequel to Cultivation Theory writes that cultivation and colonization are both judged by structural effect, and neither asks after the original intention.55
PS9 Confirmation is divided into three questions: whether this end took on the direction of cultivation is borne by him toward himself; what his act actually opened or closed is judged by checkable acts and structural effects; whether the other has completed that step concerns a step only the other can complete; no side's own account settles the other two questions. The time and effort cultivation uses up are recorded separately, and this end's gain is not used to offset them; whether he can give, and whether it has come to the point of stopping, are reassessed by present conditions; a step already carried out is not rejudged on account of later exhaustion
The Three Questions Kept Apart
The last proposition spoke of gain; this one speaks of confirming and of keeping accounts.
Cultivation Theory Paper 1 asks the three questions apart: did I take on the direction of cultivation; what did my act actually open or close; did he himself complete that step.56 The first is borne by this end toward himself, the second is judged by checkable acts and structural effects; as for the third, only the other can complete the step. The three questions do not answer for one another: no side's own account settles the other two questions;57 each party can confirm only its own end,6 and this does not cancel the check on acts and their structural effects either.
In the second course, how Fang Yan's own judgment unfolded is for him to avow; how he speaks of the matter does not stand in for the check on his act and its structural effect. The avowal that makes Su Yao's step her own is hers to complete; suppose Fang Yan tells people, "She's someone I brought along": this sentence does not settle this question.
Two Ledgers
The time and effort cultivation uses up are recorded in a ledger of their own, and this end's gain is not used to offset them. The extra hour Fang Yan stays each evening is recorded under time; that this end gains does not make this hour stop counting.
That this end gains does not make going on investing unconditional either. Whether he can give, and whether it has come to the point of stopping, are reassessed by present conditions. Economics P2 writes that under sustained asymmetric drain 15DD operational quality declines, and that the cultivator's exhaustion is not moral failure but structural limit; it also writes that when the other's trajectory persistently does not move and the cultivator's resources persistently decline, continued cultivation is no longer 15DD rationality.58 Action Theory Paper 4 writes that self-preservation rests first of all on this: one is also an end; it includes not cultivating to excess, and not wearing oneself out in a relationship one cannot cultivate.59
Whether a step already carried out opened anything is read by that step's act and structural effect, and is not rejudged on account of later exhaustion. The same section of Action Theory Paper 4 has written of tiredness: tiredness entered his judgment; what it changed was whether he could do it this time and how far he could take it, not letting him off altogether.60 Suppose Fang Yan later grows tired and can no longer teach; the times already carried out in that year are read as those times.
§6 First Assessing, and the Branches
PS10 Whether to make a cultivative intervention on the other's side, this end first assesses, by Cultivation Theory: on the other's side, whether he is willing, whether he is suited, whether the time is ripe, and these three are not answered in his place; on one's own side, whether one can give, and whether one will wear oneself out. What is judged is whether one can give now and whether to go on giving; this judgment can be wrong, and can be revised. Not intervening, while keeping up dealings as usual, does not by itself mean that this end is not headed in the 15DD direction; the time not being ripe means not doing it this time; only where one cannot give in this matter does one keep one's distance, and in keeping one's distance the recognition stays
First Assessing
Whether to make a cultivative intervention on the other's side, this end first assesses. Cultivation Theory Paper 2 has set down this step: having seen, one first assesses whether one can cultivate.61 On the other's side, three things are looked at: whether he is willing, whether he is suited, whether the time is ripe; these three are not answered in his place.62 On one's own side, two things: whether one can give, and whether one will wear oneself out.
What Is Judged
What is judged is whether one can give now, and whether to go on giving. The changes that have already happened, the present conditions, what one might be able to help with, and whether one can go on bearing it can all enter the judgment. Cultivation Theory Paper 2 writes that judging that one cannot cultivate is judging that, under present conditions, the change one expects to buy by investing further here does not outweigh what has to be paid.63 What that sentence sets in its two pans is, in one, the change the other might have, and in the other, what this end has to pay. This judgment cannot be replaced by a net gain reckoned by converting the two pans onto one scale; the time and effort in it are still recorded separately, as in §5. Economics P2 writes that recognizing non-cultivability is not a judgment about returns but about possibility.64
This judgment can be wrong, and can be revised. It does not fix in advance, in the other's place, what he ought to grow into; nor does it take ontological positive-sum as a result that must be delivered; nor is it reckoning the sum first.
The Course of Not Intervening
Not intervening, keeping up dealings as usual, and doing one's own share well does not by itself mean that one is not headed in the 15DD direction. Cooperation Theory writes that that end can simply make the bookcases well.65 This is one way of doing things after having seen, not pretending not to see; pretending not to see, Cultivation Theory Paper 2 writes, is not among the things he can choose.66 Not giving is not inherently the safer course either.67
The Time Not Ripe, and Keeping One's Distance
The time not being ripe means not doing it this time. Cultivation Theory Paper 2 writes that waiting is not withdrawing: the person is still there, words can still be spoken; only this time one does not reach further in.68
Only where one cannot give in this matter does one keep one's distance. Keeping one's distance can fall on one matter, or on one relationship; it need not fall on the whole person.69 One can stop only the cultivation in this matter, and keep up other dealings as usual; in this matter the people part, and the recognition stays. When conditions change, one can look again. Economics P2 writes that ceasing cultivation does not equal ceasing 15DD; after ceasing, the possibility of reassessment should conditions change is preserved.70
Take the third course. Su Yao has taken the credit, and has also proposed that from then on Fang Yan's re-check comments no longer be entered into the project. Going by what has already happened, Fang Yan judges that in this matter he will no longer make this investment: he no longer tells her the reasons behind the troubleshooting, completes his own repair jobs as usual, and greets her as usual when they meet in the corridor. What he withdraws is his own side; he does not wear himself out. Cooperation Theory writes that withdrawing one's own side is inward, is exit, and does not carry the direction of colonization.71 This judgment can still be wrong; it does not on that basis certify what kind of person Su Yao is. Cultivation Theory Paper 2 writes that judging that one cannot cultivate is not passing a verdict on the other.72
Where It Did Not Help
Where one went ahead and did it, ontological positive-sum can be read in looking back afterward. Where it did not help, it is recorded, following Cultivation Theory, under four headings: the giving did not fit; the conditions did not actually open; the other did not complete; it is not yet known. The four can coexist and do not stand in for one another.46 From the result alone it is not inferred backward that the judgment then was wrong, nor that he was not then headed in the 15DD direction.
Not having given this time is the same. Action Theory Paper 6 writes that that one did not give this time does not by itself show whether the direction was cancelled, the judgment was wrong, or one judged and did not act.73
PS11 This judgment does not settle, in place of each branch, whether a relation holds and whether it goes on; the conditions and arrangements of each branch do not complete, in place of the parties, that one judgment
Cooperation
In cooperation, whether to go on cooperating is checked separately, by Cooperation Theory, by whether the three things for entering its scope still hold: "both avow this undertaking and actually take part, each having a share of his own; the other is not, in this undertaking, reduced to calculation; the arrangement the two jointly avow and actually maintain does not carry the direction of colonization toward a third person, and does not cross his basic rights."74 Where this end judges that the second of these no longer holds, his judgment and his side from then on are read by Cooperation Theory: this end's judgment "does not on that basis certify that the other is reduced to calculation".75 Cooperation can go on without a cultivative intervention; whether to intervene is still the judgment of the previous proposition.
Parent and Child, Love, Marriage
In the parent-child relation, the child's end is not read for its layer by this paper's three cases. Basic securing does not enter this judgment: Parent-Child Theory writes that securing is not exchanged for the child's compliance, nor made conditional on his taking some particular road.76 Support and particular arrangements are checked separately.
In love, one-way love does not presuppose a response; whether to take up some matter, and whether dealings go on, are judged separately by the person herself or himself (Love Theory Paper 5).
In marriage, love, commitment, joint matters, exit and institutional dissolution are each registered separately (Marriage Theory Paper 7).
The conditions and arrangements of each branch do not complete, in place of the parties, that one judgment. This proposition falls on the boundary between the normative layer and the rule layer: this paper reads, at the normative layer, where the sum falls; each branch reads, at the rule layer, how that kind of relation comes to hold and how it goes on.
§7 Keeping No Accounts, Offsetting None
PS12 The branches have read several operations that keep dealings as one book of accounts: using one's giving to set up, against the other, a debt on the person; declaring, on the mere fact that a response has occurred, that repayment has been received; demanding with one's own love that the other love oneself. These can be read alongside "merging into one table"; direction is still checked on that one effect, and is not settled by the form of an account, an exchange or a settlement alone. Exchanges avowed by both parties, checkable promises, the settlement of contracts and actual contributions are each recorded separately, where they belong
Several Kinds of Account
The branches have read several operations that keep dealings as one book of accounts. Cooperation Theory has read several directions of colonization, and one of them is writing one's own giving as an account the other must repay.77 Parent-Child Theory writes that the child's compliance or achievement is not entered as repayment for the support given, nor is that support used afterward to possess him.78 Relation Theory writes that the other party's response is material, not a settling of the account; the mere fact that a response has occurred settles nothing.79 Love Theory writes that loving each other is not exchange, and that "I love you, so you ought to love me" writes love as exchange.80
These can be read alongside the "merging into one table" spoken of in §2: a book of accounts between two people is also recording the two on the same table, only what it records is who owes whom. Suppose Fang Yan says to Su Yao, "I taught you this way of doing things; this time you ought to let me have the team lead's post." This sentence uses what he gave to trade for her share, and is read by Cooperation Theory.
Not Settled by the Form of an Account Alone
Direction is still checked on that one effect, and is not settled by the form of an account, an exchange or a settlement alone. Cooperation Theory writes: "Nor is exchange calculation."81 Exchanges avowed by both parties, checkable promises, the settlement of contracts and actual contributions are each recorded separately, where they belong: Marriage Theory, reading bringing each other into their own, writes that bringing each other into their own is not entered as an account of exchange awaiting the other's repayment, and that commitments, contributions and the effects already left are entered as before.82 Recording a contribution is not recording it as the other's debt.
Cooperation Theory Paper 2 reads Guan Zhong and Bao Shuya: the larger part Guan Zhong took when they divided the profits is not, in the passage cited, written as an account on the person.83 This paper points back to that reading, and does not read it again.
Treating the other only as the condition for getting something is the operation of §1, and is pointed back to.
PS13 Saying that a stretch of dealings has ontological positive-sum does not offset the account of harm, does not add an unseen payoff, and does not certify who is at which layer: what was not obtained is said, as it is, not to have been obtained; that what was just said wounded someone is recorded as it is. The payoff layer and the ontological layer are each recorded on their own, and do not offset each other
Not Offsetting Harm
The Conflict Treatise writes that one may not use "ours is positive-sum" to deny that what was just said did in fact wound.84 This paper writes by this sentence: saying that a stretch of dealings has ontological positive-sum does not offset the account of harm.
In the third course, Fang Yan has a gain: in those times he taught, cultivation was carried out. This gain is read by §5, and is not used to offset the project and the signature he lost; nor are the things he lost rewritten as the price of this gain of his. What was lost is recorded as it is.
Not Added, Not Certified
What was not obtained is said, as it is, not to have been obtained. Cooperation Theory writes that the kind in which in fact no one benefits is not made over into one that must carry a hidden gain.85 Nor does this paper, outside the payoff table, add an unseen payoff to a stretch of dealings. Relation Theory writes that need is not duty, nor does it mean that relation is always beneficial.86
Saying that a stretch of dealings has ontological positive-sum does not certify who is at which layer either. The occasion on which ontological positive-sum is read in looking back does not put the two of them, from then on, in the 15DD direction; the occasion on which it cannot be read does not make anyone, on that account, lean toward 14DD.
In the repair corner of Cooperation Theory Paper 2, Ke Yuan and Liang Dong have no pay and make no condition of mutual return; the place, the tools and the effort are recorded as they are. This paper points back to that example: whatever can be read at the ontological layer does not clear the account of those items at the payoff layer.
Passing the Tomb
Aesthetics Ray 13 has read the passage of Zhuangzi passing Huizi's tomb: what Cheng Xuanying joined to it is also only Zhuangzi's side; the emptiness after it is Zhuangzi's own.87 By this reading, the passage of passing the tomb serves only as a looking back after losing the counterpart one could talk with, and is Zhuangzi's side. This paper does not, on the strength of it alone, record ontological positive-sum for both, nor use what the loss brings to light to offset the loss itself.
§8 Interfacing with Tradition
Interfacing goes only as far as the point where the labor is divided: first the common question, then setting side by side; where they part, it writes only what this paper reads separately.
Kant: purposiveness without purpose. The phrase this paper borrows comes from the third moment of the Analytic of the Beautiful in the Critique of Judgment. SAE Judgment and Aesthetics has already interfaced with it; this paper borrows only one use of the phrase in relation, and its limits are in §3. A sentence of the Groundwork can also be read alongside: the human being as an end, "nicht als ein zu bewirkender, sondern selbstständiger Zweck," not as an end to be brought about, but as a self-standing end.88 The common question: whether an end can be treated as a thing to be made. Setting side by side: §3 says that ontological positive-sum cannot be set as a goal. This sentence serves only as a side light; this paper does not derive positive-sum in relation from it.
Smith: the invisible hand. This is the one this paper has to take up head-on. Smith writes that the owner of capital, arranging for his own security and gain, may bring about a public result that was not within his intention: "led by an invisible hand to promote an end which was no part of his intention".89 The common question: not aiming at the total, and yet the result can be positive-sum. This point shows that "not aiming at the total" is not in itself enough to identify 15DD. The original passage speaks of the annual revenue of the society, and cannot be rewritten as positive-sum between two particular people; nor does self-interest alone settle the stance in one particular stretch of dealings. Cooperation Theory, reading the butcher and the baker, has written that whether it is self-love, only that end can confirm; to speak to the other's own advantage is, structurally, already to acknowledge that the other has purposes of his own.90 Exchange in which each is for what he gets can land at payoff positive-sum, of the same shape as the reading when the table of §1 is sold; the fact that each exchanges for what he gets does not, by itself, establish that the exchange is the operation stipulated in §1: the two people at that table are as the example set them up. On this point at the payoff layer, Smith's account does not conflict with this paper; the ontological layer is read separately. In the same passage Smith goes on to write that a man pursuing his own interest "frequently promotes that of the society more effectually than when he really intends to promote it".91 This is an empirical judgment at the payoff layer; what §3 says is structure, and falls at the ontological layer. The two sentences look alike, but are not at one layer, and this paper does not take the former as the ground of the latter. The side of the public total is handed to the institutional side: Political Economy Paper 0 hangs the question of how aggregate gain compares with the boundary that holds for each person on Smith's taking the public interest as the measure of the dealers' proposals.92 This side of the invisible hand is newly handed over by this paper, not pointed back to.
Von Neumann and Morgenstern: zero-sum. The "zero-sum" spoken of at the payoff layer is a term of game theory. Von Neumann and Morgenstern's Theory of Games and Economic Behavior (1944) builds its theory from the zero-sum two-person game, and goes on from there to more persons. This paper takes it only as a reading at the payoff layer, and does not assess game theory.
Laozi, Chapter 81. Volume 9 of the Commentary on the Daodejing has read this chapter: the Wang Bi text reads 既以為人己愈有,既以與人己愈多, the silk text 既以為人,己愈有;既以予人,己愈多, "for instance, by doing for others, he himself has the more; for instance, by giving to others, he himself becomes the greater," read as the sage not erecting the "I-have" signboard.93 Setting side by side: having given, one also has, which is close to §5's "once cultivation has been carried out, this end gains." Where they part: that gain is not the reason for giving, nor can it be obtained by seeking it in this sense; the gain this paper speaks of is at the ontological layer, not the payoff layer; nor does it say that the more one gives, the more one has.
Goodhart's law and Zhu Xi's "do not help it grow." Moral Law P3 has already read Goodhart's law, and says it is not a contingent empirical regularity but a structural consequence.94 Zhu Xi's gloss on "do not help it grow" is cited by the Prequel to Cultivation Theory, which notes there that Zhu Xi speaks of nourishing one's vital energy, directed inward, and that only its shape is borrowed. §3 has already pointed back to both places, together with their limits, and they are not restated here.
Adjacent. Robert Wright's Nonzero (2000) discusses history and evolution in terms of non-zero-sum relations. This paper lists only its analyses of the payoffs of cooperation, on the side of the payoff layer, as adjacent; it does not take up here its argument about the direction and meaning of evolution.
§9 Drawing Together and Downstream
This paper has set out thirteen propositions. How payoff changes is reckoned by the stated baseline, what is counted, and the scale; how legislative activity unfolds is read by the two ends' actual dealings. In dealings where both ends read the other only as an item, the ontological positive-sum this paper reads cannot be read. Where one end is headed in the 15DD direction, once cultivation has been carried out, this end gains; only where the other has grown too is it read as ontological positive-sum. Ontological positive-sum cannot be produced and checked against a standard fixed in advance, nor does it clear the account of actual losses. Whether to go on giving is judged by present conditions; how each branch goes on is checked separately by that branch.
To close in two plain sentences: where ontological positive-sum is not sought, the result can turn out positive-sum, unsought; once it is sought, it becomes reckoning. Payoff is not enough; it takes growth. These two sentences speak of those dealings in which, looking back, both ends' gains can be read; not seeking does not by itself guarantee that both ends gain, and this end's gain alone is not ontological positive-sum. Where it can be read, it came unsought; where it cannot, it is recorded as it is.
This paper does not prove that 15DD pays at the payoff layer; it does not prove that 14DD must lose at the payoff layer; of the two kinds of positive-sum, it calls neither good; it does not prove that one ought to treat people from 15DD; it does not prove that cultivation is bound to succeed; nor does it prove that payoff positive-sum and ontological positive-sum can be exchanged for each other.
Questions left open.
- Payoff positive-sum and zero-sum on the institutional side: markets, prices, distribution; the side of the invisible hand on which what each person gets is pooled into a public total is handed to the institutional side. The question Political Economy Paper 0 has registered stays where it is. Market Theory does not use the words "positive-sum" and "zero-sum"; this paper only registers this, and does not point back.
- The community layer: how the sum among many people is read goes by Relation Theory's pairwise accounting; the growth necessity of Moral Law P6 speaks of a cross-generational tendency at the community layer, and how it connects with this paper is not in this paper.95 The spread of cultivation is left for separate treatment, outside this paper.
- Dealings in which both ends lean toward 14DD and neither reads the other only as an item: Changing the Game does not read them; this paper does not read them by the ideal type of §1, and has not read them separately either.
- Dealings in which both ends lean toward 14DD and judgments are actually chiseled open: how the ontological layer of that occasion in §1 is read, this paper does not read.
- After a wrong judgment: where this end judged that it could cultivate, and the other reads him only as an item, how the share already given is recorded is read by Cooperation Theory and Relation Theory on exit, and is not developed in this paper.
- The cultivator's exhaustion: Economics P2 and Cultivation Theory Paper 2 have set it down; this paper only points back.
With the other papers. This paper sits under the papers of Relation Theory, as a Relation Theory special paper. It points back to Moral Law P5, and extends that paper's ontological argument at the dyad layer within pure 15DD context to the row of one end; this extension is this paper's own undertaking. Cultivation itself belongs to Cultivation Theory; this paper reads only the sum. It neighbors Changing the Game: Changing the Game reads the threshold of cooperation; this paper is not confined to cooperation, and reads to which layer the sum can fall. It calls on the established parts of Relation Theory, Moral Law, Cultivation Theory, Cooperation Theory and the branches, and does not change them.
Acknowledgments
This paper is signed by Han Qin alone; the author decided every argument and choice and bears sole responsibility for the text. In drafting, the author used AI models from various developers as tools. The English edition is an independent rewrite of the Chinese text; where the two differ, the Chinese governs.
Notes
- Relation Theory Paper 0, §16: "Relation Theory in the abstract establishes only what all relations have; a proposition that holds only in one kind of relation is handed to the series on that kind of relation to argue". ↩︎
- Cooperation Theory Paper 2, CO9: "Writing one's own giving as an account the other must repay is another matter: it lies at the normative layer and does not change with the kind of relation". ↩︎
- Cooperation Theory Paper 1, CO5: "that in which neither party is headed in the 15DD direction, whose ideal type is the case in which both parties treat each other only as a strategy set and reach a balance by mutual calculation". ↩︎
- Changing the Game, CG2: where "both ends lean toward 14DD and neither is reduced to calculation, the case is also of this kind". That paper does not read this kind; nor does this paper read it by the first row. ↩︎
- Moral Law P6, §1: "Mixed reality is the normal state of community"; "pure 15DD community is only an ideal type". ↩︎
- Cooperation Theory Paper 1, abstract: "The object layer and the operation layer are kept apart: each party can confirm only his own end, and does not declare on the other end's behalf that it avows". ↩︎
- Moral Law P9, abstract: "Cultivation is the mode by which 15DD legislative subjects treat others — not replacing another's own law with one's own purposes, but providing the context within which another's own law can unfold". ↩︎
- Moral Law P5, signature claim: "15DD mutual chiseling makes both parties' legislative subjectivity more active — this is the ontological ground of positive-sum"; §5.3: "Positive-sum is always ontological positive-sum, not utilitarian positive-sum — it is "legislative subjectivity more active," not "utility higher"". ↩︎
- Moral Law P0: "Mutual chiseling positive-sum is not "better" in the utilitarian sense: ontological positive-sum and utilitarian positive-sum are categorically distinct—the former articulates that legislative-subjectivity is more active, while the latter articulates that the total of utility has increased (Paper 5 §2.1)". ↩︎
- Moral Law P5, §0.3: "Recognition structure as recognition of End cannot be positively defined in its ontology, much less aggregated and quantified". ↩︎
- Moral Law P5: "Paper 5's scope is the ontological argument at the dyad layer within pure 15DD context". ↩︎
- Conflict Treatise, §18, "The reciprocal path: joint deepening": "A kind of yield can form here, and it must be written as a possibility"; what follows directly is that mutual chiseling can make both parties' legislating more active. ↩︎
- Changing the Game, CG4: "The end that leans toward 14DD changes the game too, and may also bring about options there were not before"; "The difference lies not in whether one changes the game, nor in whether one goes beyond the original table, but in where the change of the game heads"; when the end that leans toward 14DD changes the game, what it heads toward is "still one's own cell in the game". ↩︎
- Moral Law P5, abstract: "the same situation in 14DD context becomes zero-sum or negative-sum (going to court consumes both parties' subjectivity)". The zero-sum or negative-sum here speaks of the consumption of subjectivity, not of payoff; what the original reads is a dispute. ↩︎
- Moral Law P5, §2.2: "Validation is treated as a finite resource — given to the winner, it is not given to the loser"; on the side of resource: "Two individuals competing for the same finite resource pool is structurally necessarily zero-sum — A taking more leaves B with less". What the original reads is the adversarial frame. ↩︎
- Relation Theory Paper 1, H6: "Entering the same process is the precondition of mutual chiseling". ↩︎
- Relation Theory Paper 4, §5: the mutual chiseling of this series is judged by process, as in Paper 1, and is "broader than the 15DD mutual chiseling spoken of in Moral Law P5: what it looks at is whether the two sides' judgments have actually been chiseled open"; the moment of two-way 15DD requires both sides to recognize the other as an end in itself, and mutual chiseling "does not require this"; "Counterexamples to the converse exist, and they are very common: conflict between 14DDs is one". ↩︎
- Marriage Theory, MA12: "the other has his own cannot-not, which I only recognize as there, and whose content I cannot read out". ↩︎
- Cooperation Theory Paper 2, CO10, citing Value Theory: "two people agreeing on something is not the same as two sets of values having merged into one common table, nor as a position having appeared that ranks the two sides". ↩︎
- Changing the Game, CG3: "Looking out for one's own concerns is not calculation; calculation is treating the other only as a strategy set." This paper does not itself use the word "calculation"; it is quoted here as in the original. ↩︎
- Cooperation Theory Paper 5, CO24: "whether the other's capacity has increased is a measure of outcomes, and is not used to judge direction". Carrying this shape to not using the sum as a criterion is an extension, this paper's own undertaking. ↩︎
- Cultivation Theory Paper 1, abstract: "A content that comes from outside is not on that account not his; whether it is his depends on where avowal is accomplished". ↩︎
- Aesthetics Ray 13, §7 (via Relation Theory Paper 0, §3): "This is a looking back after the fact, not a criterion"; the way of looking back: "take away the ruler that person gave you, and see; without that person, do you still acknowledge that place as yours, and can you change it yourself?" ↩︎
- Moral Law P3, abstract: "Any positive definition collapses reputation into a thing — and once collapsed, 14DD optimization activates and falsifies what was supposed to be measured"; directly after, the limit: what is prohibited is "exhaustive, centralized, optimizable definition. Distributed, local, and approximate articulation remains legitimate". ↩︎
- Moral Law P9, §2.2: "Any operation of forced change, even when issuing from a 15DD legislative subject, has itself exited the cultivation posture — that is, in the moment of its execution, the agent has exited 15DD operation and entered 14DD operation"; "What cultivation provides is the context within which this unfolding can occur — not the direction of the unfolding itself". ↩︎
- Prequel to Cultivation Theory, §2, the item "It is not settled by results," citing Zhu Xi: "one must not let a single thought of expectation sprout; for if the expectation is not met after a while, one will surely act out of private intention and go against the pattern of heaven, and that is helping it grow (Zhuzi yulei, juan 52)"; and: "What this item blocks is reaching out to grow for him when the expected result does not come". The original notes that Zhu Xi is speaking of nourishing one's vital energy, a person's work upon himself, and that there only its shape is borrowed. ↩︎
- Prequel to Cultivation Theory, §2: "It does not make the other's reaching the result I set a condition for going on taking him as an end"; in the same item: "Then "being taken as an end" becomes a conditional reward". The opening of that section says: "Each of the items below names which kind of standing-in it blocks". ↩︎
- To Forget the Self, Introspection series, abstract: "15DD's non dubito (not doubting that the other also has remainder) is not a moral command but the direction that naturally emerges after completing observation and illumination — what Kant's Third Critique calls "purposiveness without purpose."" ↩︎
- SAE: The Second Critique, Chapter 5: "the "direction" of To Forget the Self speaks of how 15DD is reached — it goes on to say "what Kant's Third Critique calls 'purposiveness without purpose'" — and this side belongs to the critique of judgment; here only its destination is recorded". ↩︎
- Aesthetics as a Structural Field of Subject-Conditions: "Kant's "purposiveness without purpose" (Zweckmäßigkeit ohne Zweck) is a precise description of the aesthetic emergent layer. Shenmei experience does not serve an external purpose (purposiveness without) but internally possesses directionality (purposiveness)". ↩︎
- Kant, Kritik der Urteilskraft, Einleitung IV, AA 5:179, lines 24–26: "Ist aber nur das Besondere gegeben, wozu sie das Allgemeine finden soll, so ist die Urtheilskraft bloß reflectirend". ↩︎
- Changing the Game, CG10: "competition can be just competition"; the example of quoting for bookcases: "quoting honestly, and not going to the school to speak ill of the other". ↩︎
- Rights Theory special paper: "A basic right stands on standing; it is pre-relational, comes to be with a single subject". ↩︎
- Love Theory Paper 5: "the share of recognizing her as an end too does not grow smaller because one loves this one". ↩︎
- Relation Theory, H13: "Acknowledgment that requires no qualification and the realization of recognition are kept on separate books". ↩︎
- Relation Theory Paper 1, H11: "Relation Theory reads only the collisions between one another: within an institution, the part of what passes between persons that the institution does not provide for, or that goes beyond its provisions, is within range; the relation between persons and constructs is not; the provisions themselves are acknowledged but not judged". Relation Theory Paper 0 restates it as: "the provisions themselves are acknowledged but not judged, and are registered as conditions of the effect". ↩︎
- Parent-Child Theory Paper 7, Introduction: ""Handing over" means the interpretations and avowals the parents' end used to hold for the child being given back to him, domain by domain". Reading handing over as not losing is this paper's reading. ↩︎
- Untangling Zhuangzi · Outer Chapters, Volume I, reading Huizi as minister of Liang in "Autumn Floods": "Someone told Huizi: "Zhuangzi has come, wanting to take your place as minister." At this Huizi was afraid, and searched the capital for three days and three nights." ↩︎
- Relation Theory, H39: "The moment of two-way 15DD is something that happens on an occasion, not a grade that a person or a relation is in". ↩︎
- Aesthetics Ray 13: "The evidence for mutuality is not in this figure but in the scene above the Hao: there both have axes in hand, each the other's Carpenter Shi, and each the other's counterpart". ↩︎
- Cooperation Theory Paper 5, CO23: "such cooperation can be the setting in which cultivation happens, not the source of cultivation"; abstract: "Cultivation is not instruction, not remaking; the completion of cultivation is not in the enactor's hands". ↩︎
- Cooperation Theory Paper 5, CO23: cultivation is "not the general opening move of such cooperation"; §2, under CO23, "Not the General Opening Move": "Whether to make an active intervention on the other's side is this end's own choice". This paper carries the sentence from cooperation to relations in which one end is there; this is an extension, this paper's own undertaking. ↩︎
- Moral Law P6, §5.6: "cultivation is providing the conditions for mutual-chiseling activation"; "cannot force growth — only 15DD mutual-chiseling activation can activate the other's own legislative subjectivity"; "secondary — the primary activity is mutual-chiseling cooperation with other 15DDs". ↩︎
- Cultivation Theory Paper 1, abstract: "Avowal is something only the person himself can do; what the outside can give is the conditions of forming, avowing and revising". ↩︎
- Action Theory Paper 6, D34: "So cultivation necessarily leaves a blank: what is left is not words but the other person's share, whether he accepts, how he judges, whether he changes, whether he leaves. Reaching into his share is a failure". ↩︎
- Cultivation Theory Paper 3, §6: "did not fit: the time, the person or the manner was wrong"; "The conditions did not actually open: something was given, but those positions did not, because of it, come any further into his hands"; the other two are that the other did not complete and that it is not yet known; "The four can coexist and do not stand in for one another". ↩︎
- Prequel to Cultivation Theory, restating Value Theory P1, V16: "recognizing a concrete other as an end is a content of a person's own law; when he goes on to open dimensions for the other, so that the other is fulfilled as an end, this act of going on is cultivation, the way that content looks when it moves". ↩︎
- Moral Law P5, §2.2: "The ontological difference between resource and activity is the root of the difference between 15DD positive-sum and 14DD negative-sum"; the same section: "Subjectivity flourishes in exercise"; the exercises the original names are articulating one's own view, responding, internal review and judging. Carrying this to cultivation is an extension, this paper's own undertaking. ↩︎
- Value Theory P1, V16, "The Three Layers of Recognition and Cultivation": "The third position is cultivation, a verb-position"; cultivation is "not a fifth value-source"; it "does not enter the ontological figure of end-value". ↩︎
- Value Theory P1: direction-value "appraises the transformation, not the bearer". ↩︎
- Cooperation Theory Paper 2, §5, Ke Yuan teaching Liang Dong to mend bicycles: "later she could mend them herself, could say how she wanted to mend them, and sometimes did not do it his way"; "whether it took hold is seen in her later understanding and action, and as for this one time he taught her, the direction is read on the effect of this one occasion". ↩︎
- Action Theory Paper 6, §5, on the one who cultivates also being cultivated: "When the new hire came to ask, he only wanted to understand one thing"; "the one who takes the new hire as an end also gains things from the new hire, and those things, once he himself avows them, are his own too". D37: "The one who cultivates can also be cultivated; the two sides are not fixed as giver and receiver". ↩︎
- Cultivation Theory Paper 3, §7, "The One Who Cultivates Is Also Cultivated": "This is not read as reciprocity"; "The time he is cultivated is the giver's gaining something from another; once he takes it up himself, that too is his own". ↩︎
- Relation Theory Paper 4, H40: "What demand and agreement can guarantee is at most the outward laugh; if that moment is there, it was not obtained by demand or agreement, nor is it ruled out because there was an agreement". The original speaks of the moment of laughing face to face; here it serves only as a reminder in the same direction. ↩︎
- Prequel to Cultivation Theory, §2: "Cultivation and colonization are both judged by structural effect, and neither asks after the original intention". ↩︎
- Cultivation Theory Paper 1, abstract: "three questions are asked separately: did I take on the direction of cultivation; what did my act actually open or close; did he himself complete that step"; "The first is borne by the giver toward himself; the second is judged by checkable acts and their structural effects; the third can only be completed by him". ↩︎
- Cultivation Theory Paper 1, abstract: "No side's own account settles the other two questions". ↩︎
- Economics P2, §4.3: under sustained asymmetric drain, "15DD operational quality declines. This is not moral failure; it is structural limit"; combining the two switching signals: "when the other's trajectory persistently does not move and the cultivator's resources persistently decline, continued cultivation is no longer 15DD rationality". ↩︎
- Action Theory Paper 4, abstract; see also §5, D23: "Self-preservation rests first of all on this: one is also an end. It includes not cultivating to excess, and not wearing oneself out in a relationship one cannot cultivate". ↩︎
- Action Theory Paper 4, §5: "Tiredness entered his judgment; what it changed was whether he could do it this time and how far he could take it, not letting him off altogether". ↩︎
- Cultivation Theory Paper 2: "Having seen, one first assesses whether one can cultivate". ↩︎
- Action Theory Paper 6, D34: "Cultivation depends on the other person being willing to receive it, being suited to receive it, and the time being ripe; these three cannot be answered in his place". ↩︎
- Cultivation Theory Paper 2, §3: judging that one cannot cultivate is a judgment that "under present conditions, the change one expects to buy by investing further here does not outweigh what has to be paid". ↩︎
- Economics P2, §4.5, on recognizing non-cultivability: "This is not a judgment about returns but about possibility". ↩︎
- Cooperation Theory Paper 5, under CO23: "he can simply make the bookcases well". ↩︎
- Cultivation Theory Paper 2, HY6: ""pretending not to see" is not among the things he can choose". ↩︎
- Cultivation Theory Paper 2, HY11: "Falling short also means failing to do one's part: not giving is not inherently the safer course". ↩︎
- Cultivation Theory Paper 2, §3: "The time not being ripe means not acting this time"; "Waiting is not withdrawing: the person is still there, words can still be spoken; only this time one does not reach further in". ↩︎
- Cultivation Theory Paper 2, §3: "This judgment can fall on one matter, or on one relationship; it need not fall on the whole person"; "One is that the people part and the recognition stays"; "the two no longer deal with each other in this matter". ↩︎
- Economics P2, §4.4: "ceasing cultivation does not equal ceasing 15DD"; after ceasing, "preserving the possibility of reassessment should conditions change". ↩︎
- Cooperation Theory Paper 5, CO26: "withdrawing one's own side is inward, is exit, and does not carry the direction of colonization". ↩︎
- Cultivation Theory Paper 2: "judging that one cannot cultivate is not passing a verdict on the other". ↩︎
- Action Theory Paper 6, D35: "That one did not give this time does not by itself show whether the direction was cancelled, the judgment was wrong, or one judged and did not act". ↩︎
- Cooperation Theory Paper 1, §1, "Direction Is Not Enough": the three things checked separately for entering scope. The abstract writes the third as "the arrangement the two jointly avow and maintain does not carry the direction of colonization toward a third person", without the latter half. ↩︎
- Cooperation Theory Paper 5, CO27: this end's judgment "does not on that basis certify that the other is reduced to calculation". ↩︎
- Parent-Child Theory, PC11: "Securing is not exchanged for the child's compliance, nor made conditional on his taking some particular road; how much support is given is not used to make up for a lack of securing; the two layers are not traded". ↩︎
- Cooperation Theory Paper 2, CO11: "The directions of colonization commonly met on these shapes: in reciprocal exchange, treating the other merely as the condition for getting something, or extending settlement from the side of the contract onto the person; writing one's own giving as an account the other must repay". ↩︎
- Parent-Child Theory, PC20: "The support given does not enter the child's compliance or achievement as repayment, nor is it used afterward to possess him". ↩︎
- Relation Theory, H33: "The other party's response is material, not a settling of the account"; "the mere fact that a response has occurred settles nothing". ↩︎
- Love Theory Paper 6, L42: "loving each other is not exchange, and "I love you, so you ought to love me" writes love as exchange". ↩︎
- Cooperation Theory Paper 2, CO9: "Nor is exchange calculation". ↩︎
- Marriage Theory, MA19: "Mutuality requires neither simultaneity nor equality, and keeps no accounts: bringing each other into their own is not entered as an account of exchange awaiting the other's repayment; commitments, contributions and the effects already left are entered as before". ↩︎
- Cooperation Theory Paper 2, §6, reading Guan Zhong and Bao Shuya: "the part taken in excess is not, in the passage cited, written as an account on the person"; the limit: "This paper reads structure only from the words and deeds recorded; it does not judge the two people's direction, and does not fill in an inner life beyond what is recorded". ↩︎
- Conflict Treatise, §18: "One may not use "ours is positive-sum" to deny that what was just said did in fact wound". ↩︎
- Cooperation Theory Paper 2, CO8: "the kind in which in fact no one benefits is not made over into one that must carry a hidden gain". ↩︎
- Relation Theory, H62: "need is not duty, nor does it mean that relation is always beneficial". ↩︎
- Aesthetics Ray 13, §4: "what Cheng Xuanying joined to it is also only Zhuangzi's side"; "the emptiness after it is Zhuangzi's own". ↩︎
- Kant, Grundlegung zur Metaphysik der Sitten, AA 4:437, lines 26–27: "nicht als ein zu bewirkender, sondern selbstständiger Zweck". ↩︎
- Smith, The Wealth of Nations, Book IV, Chapter II (Project Gutenberg e-text #3300): "led by an invisible hand to promote an end which was no part of his intention". ↩︎
- Cooperation Theory Paper 2, reading the butcher and the baker: "whether it is self-love, only that end can confirm"; to speak to the other's advantage "is, structurally, already to acknowledge that the other has purposes of his own". ↩︎
- Smith, The Wealth of Nations, Book IV, Chapter II (ibid.): "By pursuing his own interest, he frequently promotes that of the society more effectually than when he really intends to promote it". ↩︎
- Political Economy Paper 0: the question "How aggregate gain compares with the boundary that holds for each person" is hung on "Smith takes the public interest as the measure of the dealers' proposals". ↩︎
- Commentary on the Daodejing: Junzi-Bu-Qi, Volume 9, Chapter 81: the Wang Bi text "既以為人己愈有,既以與人己愈多"; the silk text "既以為人,己愈有;既以予人,己愈多"; and: "The sage does not hoard = the sage does not erect the "I-have / I-have-much / I-have-the-merit / I-have-the-name" signboard". ↩︎
- Moral Law P3: "Goodhart's Law is, in SAE's framing, not a contingent empirical regularity but a structural consequence of trying to positively define what is structurally unpositively-definable". ↩︎
- Moral Law P6, §2.1, on the reach of growth's necessity: "Long-term — multi-generational scale, not individual lifetime"; "Cross-generational — not just individual growth, but aggregate inter-generational tendency". ↩︎
References
All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version.
I · Relation Theory
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Relation Theory Paper 0: The Place of Relation Theory [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545115
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Relation Theory Paper 1: What a Relation Is, and What It Is Not [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545047
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Relation Theory Paper 4: Dealings and Expectation [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545057
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Relation Theory Paper 7: Why Still Relate [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545097
II · Other SAE works directly cited in this paper
Qin, H. (2026). The Way of the Legislative Subject (SAE Moral Law, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20298413
Qin, H. (2026). The Reputation Economy · Dao (SAE Moral Law, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20046168
Qin, H. (2026). Positive-Sum — The Ontological Ground of 15DD Mutual Chiseling (SAE Moral Law, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20081078
Qin, H. (2026). Mixed Reality — The Intermediate State of 14DD Growing toward 15DD (SAE Moral Law, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20108658
Qin, H. (2026). The Institutional Architecture of Mixed Reality (SAE Moral Law, Paper 9) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20262737
Qin, H. (2026). What Cultivation Is Not (SAE Cultivation Theory, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154492
Qin, H. (2026). How Is Cultivation Possible? (SAE Cultivation Theory, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154499
Qin, H. (2026). Once Seen, No Going Back (SAE Cultivation Theory, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154504
Qin, H. (2026). How Far to Give (SAE Cultivation Theory, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24154506
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Cooperation Theory Paper 1: Doing Together [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24029132
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Cooperation Theory Paper 2: Each for Their Own Ends [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24029135
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Cooperation Theory Paper 5: One Side [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24029145
Qin, H. (2026). Changing the Game (SAE Cooperation Theory, Special Paper) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24049720
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Marriage Theory Paper 2: Each Their Own [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23819224
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Marriage Theory Paper 3: Into One's Own [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23819232
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Marriage Theory Paper 7: Staying and Leaving [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23819263
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Love Theory Paper 5: Without Waiting for You [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23627779
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Love Theory Paper 6: That Moment [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23627781
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Parent-Child Theory Paper 2: Securing in the Parent-Child Relation [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24121539
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Parent-Child Theory Paper 3: Support in the Parent-Child Relation [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24121541
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Parent-Child Theory Paper 7: Handing Over and Leading [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24121559
Qin, H. (2026). On the Source of Value (SAE Value Theory, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21405207
Qin, H. (2026). Can and Cannot (SAE Action Theory, Paper 4) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22970769
Qin, H. (2026). Not Legislating for Others (SAE Action Theory, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22970777
Qin, H. (2026). The Other End of the Bridge: Economic Rationality When 15DD Faces a Party Who Does Not Enter 15DD (SAE Economics, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19381666
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Conflict Treatise: How Subjecthood Is Not Swallowed by Conflict Itself [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22313628
Qin, H. (2026). Political Economy and the Tradition: Accumulated Power (SAE Political Economy, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874158
Qin, H. (2026). On Rights and Entitlements (SAE Rights Theory, Special Paper) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21314907
Qin, H. (2026). The Beauty of Mutual Non Dubito (SAE Aesthetics, Ray 13) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23000910
Qin, H. (2026). Untangling Zhuangzi · Outer Chapters, Volume I (Exposition) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20578136
Qin, H. (2026). Commentary on the Daodejing: Junzi-Bu-Qi — Volume 9, Final Volume (Chapters 73–81) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20145192
Qin, H. (2026). To Forget the Self: From Self-Understanding to Structural Respect for the Other (SAE Introspection Series, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19059139
Qin, H. (2026). SAE: The Second Critique [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23250387
Qin, H. (2026). Aesthetics as a Structural Field of Subject-Conditions (SAE Applied Series, A2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18748930
Qin, H. (2026). SAE Judgment and Aesthetics: In Tribute to Kant [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19296710
III · External works
Kant, I. (1785). Grundlegung zur Metaphysik der Sitten. Akademie-Ausgabe, Vol. 4. (checked against the korpora.org text, AA 4:437)
Kant, I. (1790). Kritik der Urteilskraft. Akademie-Ausgabe, Vol. 5. (checked against the korpora.org text, AA 5:179)
Smith, A. (1776). An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations. (quotations from Project Gutenberg e-text #3300, Book IV, Chapter II)
von Neumann, J., & Morgenstern, O. (1944). Theory of Games and Economic Behavior. Princeton University Press.
Wright, R. (2000). Nonzero: The Logic of Human Destiny. Pantheon Books.
Li Jingde 黎靖德 (Ed.). Zhuzi yulei 朱子語類, juan 52. (as cited by way of the Prequel to Cultivation Theory)
Laozi 老子, Chapter 81. (Wang Bi text and silk text, as read by Volume 9 of the Commentary on the Daodejing)
Zhuangzi 莊子, "Qiushui" 秋水 ["Autumn Floods"]. (as read by Untangling Zhuangzi · Outer Chapters, Volume I)
Interfaces
- Main upstream: Relation Theory Paper 0 (§16), Paper 1 (H6, H13), Paper 4 (H33, H39, H40, §5), Paper 7 (H62); Moral Law P5 (Abstract, §0.3, §2.2, §5.3); Cultivation Theory, Prequel (§2), Paper 1 (Abstract), Paper 2 (HY6, HY11, §3), Paper 3 (§6, §7).
- Also used: Moral Law P0, P3 (Abstract), P6 (§1, §2.1, §5.6), P9 (Abstract, §2.2); Cooperation Theory Paper 1 (CO5, §1, Abstract), Paper 2 (CO8 to CO11, §5, §6), Paper 5 (CO23, CO24, CO26, CO27); Changing the Game (CG2, CG3, CG4, CG10); Marriage Theory (MA12, MA19, Paper 7); Love Theory (Paper 5, L42); Parent-Child Theory (PC11, PC20, Introduction to Paper 7); Value Theory P1 (V16); Action Theory Paper 4 (§5, D23), Paper 6 (D34, D35, D37, §5); Economics P2 (§4.3 to §4.5); the Conflict Treatise (§18); Political Economy Paper 0; the Rights Theory special paper; Aesthetics Ray 13 (§7, §4); Untangling Zhuangzi · Outer Chapters, Volume I; Volume 9 of the Commentary on the Daodejing; To Forget the Self; The Second Critique, Chapter 5; Aesthetics as a Structural Field of Subject-Conditions; SAE Judgment and Aesthetics.
- Downstream: this use, on the relation side, of "purposiveness without purpose" is registered at that place in the critique of judgment; the next version of Relation Theory Paper 0 adds a sentence pointing to this paper; "payoff positive-sum" and "ontological positive-sum" are put forward for Relation Theory's table of shared words.