Handing Over and Leading
交出与引领
This paper reads the last stretch of the parent-child relation this series reads: coming of age, handing over, and leading. Coming of age is read structurally as the child's 14DD coming to stand: his own cannot-not has taken shape; it arrives domain by domain, not all on one day; coming of age in law is acknowledged but not judged. Where, in some matter, his negation-gate can already run of itself, the position of raising and refusing in that matter becomes his own at once, and no one may seal it; this is not further conditioned on his 14DD already having come to stand. Being able to raise something is not the same as having it come to stand: whether the arrangement in that matter changes, if it also involves the parents' end or others, is read by each party's own law and by the dealings. In matters of his own direction, the parents do not interpret or avow in his place; how the securing layer is drawn back is not conditional on which road he takes, and in drawing back the two senses of dependency are checked.
On the child's side, the test is that he is able to unfold without revolving around his father, and also able to unfold without revolving around his mother, read person by person; this is a test, not that he must in fact leave; being able is limited to constitutive independence, not real-world self-sufficiency. Once 14DD has come to stand, what remains is mainly leading: the effect of leading can only be by personal demonstration; it is not a position with authority, and does not extend the structure of the parent-child relation; this does not widen into all later dealings being allowed only demonstration; ordinary exchange and things done together are read by Relation Theory and Cooperation Theory. The child's own 15DD is his own affair.
Leading is read until it becomes one face of family affection between adults; no endpoint is set. From then on, what lies between parents and adult children is read by Relation Theory and Cooperation Theory, and conflict by the Conflict Treatise; the case of long-term care needed after coming of age is handed to a future series on relations of care. This paper interfaces with Locke, Kant and Gibran, and registers the material of Fu Lei's Letters. It does not prove that a child ought to leave once grown, nor that leading is bound to be seen, nor that the parent-child relation has an endpoint.
Introduction
When He Zhou had finished his schooling, he went to a port city in the south and became an apprentice at a yard that built and repaired wooden boats. The day he left, Lin Wan packed two quilts for him, and He Chuan drove him to the station. At the station entrance, He Chuan said: "Call when you get there."
In the first few months, He Zhou once said on the phone that the yard paid its apprentices very little; the next day He Chuan phoned the owner of the yard himself, and asked whether the boy could be paid a bit more. The owner mentioned it to He Zhou. That evening He Zhou phoned home, his voice low: "Dad, this is my business." He Chuan was silent for a moment, then said: "I overstepped." He did not call again after that. In the first year, Lin Wan still sent him a little money every month; he also often asked her on the phone how to save money, and how to spend it.
More than a year later, He Zhou was about to sign a contract with a yacht company, and was unsure about one clause in it; he phoned He Chuan. He Chuan had handled contracts at his company for more than ten years, and could make sense of the clause; he gave his view, and then said: "Whether to sign is up to you."
That year, Lin Wan signed up for a drawing class at the cultural center near home, on Saturday mornings. On a video call she showed He Zhou the sea she had painted, said it wasn't good, and laughed at herself. He Zhou said: "Mom, the mast on that boat of yours is crooked." Lin Wan said: "It is crooked."
Several things in these have to be read apart. From what day was He Zhou "of age"; what was He Chuan's call to the owner of the yard; where does He Zhou's "this is my business" fall; was the contract a matter of He Chuan deciding for He Zhou, or something else; what does Lin Wan's learning to draw have to do with He Zhou; and are this family's later dealings still the parent-child relation this series reads?
What this paper reads. The parent-child relation this series reads has as its premise that the end of the father or the mother is headed in the 15DD direction, and it is read relation by relation.1 This paper reads the last stretch of this relation: once the child's cannot-not has come to stand in one matter after another, how the parents' end acts.
This paper reads five things. First, coming of age: what it is read as structurally, and where coming of age in law is placed. Second, raising and having it come to stand: when the position of raising and refusing becomes his, what is handed over, and how securing is drawn back. Third, how "being able to unfold without revolving around me" is read on the child's side. Fourth, leading. Fifth, this relation turning into family affection between adults.
Shared words. "Coming of age" has two senses in this series: coming of age structurally, read as the child's 14DD coming to stand; and coming of age in law, a line drawn by institutions, which this series acknowledges but does not judge. Where the main text says "coming of age" without further marking, it means the former.
"Handing over" means the interpretations and avowals the parents' end used to hold for the child being given back to him, domain by domain. The initiation of questioning is not within "handing over": it is not something the parents hand him; it is his as soon as the gate runs of itself.
"Leading" follows the education paper's usage: the adult lives out recognition, and the child sees the direction.2 It is not leadership, not a position with authority.
"Family affection" is only a name here: it means the dealings between parents and adult children, read by Relation Theory and Cooperation Theory; this series gives it no definition of its own.
Method. As in the previous six papers. This paper writes of the years after He Zhou left home; the main text gives no ages.
§1 Coming of Age
PC38 Coming of age is read structurally as the child's 14DD coming to stand: his own cannot-not has taken shape. It arrives domain by domain, not all on one day; coming of age in law is acknowledged but not judged
His own cannot-not has taken shape
The clues the parents' end has seen are these: stopped, quarrelled with, pressed down, it came back from elsewhere (Paper 5). What follows takes as its condition that He Zhou's cannot-not in boatbuilding has already taken shape, and reads how the parents' end acts; his sustained action before this is the clue the parents saw, and certification is not completed by the day he got on the train. The series reads coming of age as this: the child's 14DD comes to stand; his own cannot-not has taken shape.
This reading, like those of the earlier papers, reads the conditions at the parents' end: once the child's cannot-not has come to stand in a matter, how the parents act in that matter changes accordingly.
Domain by domain
Coming of age does not arrive all on one day. He Zhou's direction in boatbuilding cannot vouch for other matters as well. He asked Lin Wan how to save money, and asked He Chuan to look over a contract; these show only that he used other people's help, not that the position of raising, refusing and revising was still exercised by his parents on his behalf. How the position operates in each matter is still checked matter by matter. In a person who is still maturing, that gate can in some places already run of itself, while in others it must still be exercised by others for him.3 Using a line that is externally fixed, not defeasible by the facts of a case, and applied uniformly across matters, to judge in a single day that he has arrived in every matter, carries a risk of systematic misclassification.4 So when this series says "coming of age," it means coming of age in one matter after another.
Coming of age in law
How the law draws the line of coming of age, and how the corresponding authority changes, belongs to the institutional side; this series acknowledges but does not judge. Nor does it rule on whether any particular age set by a ruling is right: that is left to the specific disciplines and to social judgment.5 Coming of age in law and coming of age structurally need not fall on the same day; this series reads the latter, and does not use it to change the former.
§2 Raising, and Having It Come to Stand
PC39 Where, in some matter, his negation-gate can already run of itself, the position of raising and refusing in that matter becomes his own at once, and no one may seal it; this is not further conditioned on his 14DD already having come to stand. Being able to raise something is not the same as having it come to stand: whether the arrangement in that matter changes, if it also involves the parents' end or others, is read by each party's own law and by the dealings, and is not decided by any one party alone. In matters of his own direction, the parents do not interpret or avow in his place; once his cannot-not has come to stand in that matter, leading takes up from there. How the securing layer is drawn back is not conditional on which road he takes; in drawing back, actual dependency, the arrangements already formed, and the two senses of dependency are checked. On the side that has already turned into a relation between adults, what the parents give from then on is read as help between adults, or as something done together
When the gate runs of itself, the position is his
In a matter, once a child's negation-gate takes a stable first-person ownership, the initiation of questioning in that matter becomes his own at once.6 This position does not wait for his cannot-not to come to stand: before He Zhou had set out on the road of boatbuilding, he could already say "not wearing it" to that coat, and ask "why can't I watch for ten minutes." In these matters, the position of raising and refusing was already his, and no one may seal it; whoever seals his position of expression or channel of exit commits a violation.7
So handing over does not begin on the day of coming of age. The position of raising and refusing, in one matter after another, became his long before coming of age; what the parents' end hands over is something else: the interpretations and avowals it used to hold for him (Paper 4).
Raising, and having it come to stand
Being able to raise something is not the same as having it come to stand.8 For a while He Zhou talked of giving up his schooling and going straight to the yard. He could raise this, and no one could stop him saying it. But the matter involved other things: the family's money, the law at the parents' end, whether the yard would take an apprentice who had not finished his schooling. Whether the arrangement in that matter changes is read by each party's own law and by the dealings, and is not decided by any one party alone. That time, the three parties talked it over for a long while, and the result was that he finished. He Zhou raised it, and it did not come to stand; his position of raising was not sealed because of that.
It runs the other way too: that the gate runs of itself does not mean the child should decide everything himself; that would be counting the having-it-come-to-stand to him as well.8
His own direction
In matters of He Zhou's own direction, the parents do not interpret or avow in his place. What the yard pays its apprentices falls on the road he chose himself; it is a matter on that road. He Chuan's call to the owner of the yard raised on He Zhou's behalf something He Zhou had not raised himself: more pay. This matter, for He Zhou, was already his own; He Chuan raising it for him was avowing a matter of his own in his place, and was a falling back. He Zhou said "this is my business": this sentence falls exactly on this matter. He Chuan said "I overstepped," and did not call again: owning up to that occasion, and changing what he did afterward; this is a turning back (Paper 1).
Once his cannot-not has come to stand in that matter, leading takes up from there (§4).
How securing is drawn back
After He Zhou went to the yard, Lin Wan still sent him a little money every month; for the first half year or more, then less, then later he said there was no need. How these payments changed is checked against his actual dependency, the arrangements already formed, and how those arrangements changed; it is not inferred directly from his having come to stand in boatbuilding that securing may be drawn back.
Drawing back has two lines. First, it is not conditional on which road he takes: Lin Wan's giving this share is not conditional on He Zhou switching to engineering, nor is it withdrawn because he keeps on with boatbuilding; the particular payments are still checked against actual dependency and the arrangements already formed. Securing in the Base Layer is not conditional on a person's taking some particular road.9 Second, it is checked against dependency: in drawing back, one looks at whether he still actually relies on this share, and at what arrangements have already formed. Where one first induces dependency and then withdraws, violation is checked separately at the layer of basic rights (Paper 2).10 Had Lin Wan, in He Zhou's first month at the yard, suddenly given nothing at all, without a word, that would be checked by these two lines.
The side that has turned into a relation between adults
The contract: He Zhou came to ask He Chuan; He Chuan gave his view, and then said "whether to sign is up to you." This matter is no longer something the parents hold for the child; it is one adult asking another adult for help looking over a contract. On the side that has already turned into a relation between adults, what the parents give from then on is read as help between adults, or as something done together: of a thing parents and their adult children do together, the face of doing it together is in Cooperation Theory.11
§3 Being Able to Unfold Without Revolving Around Me
PC40 On the child's side, the test is that he is able to unfold without revolving around his father, and also able to unfold without revolving around his mother, read person by person; this is a test, not that he must in fact leave; being able is limited to constitutive independence, not real-world self-sufficiency
The test is on the child's side
The layer of meaning has a test: that the other is able to unfold without revolving around me is the hardest test in this row.12 Marriage Theory, reading two people and their child, left how this test is read on the child's side to Parent-Child Theory.13
Read on the child's side, the test is: He Zhou is able to unfold without revolving around He Chuan, and also able to unfold without revolving around Lin Wan. Reading person by person means checking separately whether He Chuan and Lin Wan, each in their own relation, occupy the constitutive position of He Zhou's value.14 That He Zhou still asks Lin Wan's advice and still takes her support is not enough to judge that he still revolves around her; what is checked is whether his direction and his first-person revision are still decided for him by her. Two relations, two readings.
Being able, not having to leave
This is a test, not that he must in fact leave.15 That He Zhou went south is his own affair; had he stayed at a yard near home and come back for dinner every weekend, the test could be read just the same: whether his affairs are able to unfold without revolving around his parents. Having left does not prove being able; not having left does not prove not being able.
Constitutive independence, not real-world self-sufficiency
Being able is limited to constitutive independence, not real-world self-sufficiency.16 In the first year, He Zhou's money did not go far enough and he asked home for some; when there was an accident at the yard, he phoned home. These do not make the test fail: that he cannot do without some real-world support does not give his parents the constitutive right over his value. What is read is whether who he is, and how his affairs go, are still decided by his parents.
§4 Leading
PC41 Once 14DD has come to stand, what remains is mainly leading: the effect of leading can only be by personal demonstration; it is not a position with authority, and does not extend the structure of the parent-child relation. This does not widen into all later dealings between parents and adult children being allowed only demonstration; ordinary exchange and things done together are read by Relation Theory and Cooperation Theory. The child's own 15DD is his own affair
Only by personal demonstration
Of teaching, nurturing and leading, leading comes last: the window for leading is after 14DD has stabilized. There is only one way to lead: the adult stands at the 15DD position, and the child, seeing this, knows that position exists. Leading is possible only by personal demonstration.17
Lin Wan went to the cultural center to learn drawing. As a girl she had wanted to learn to draw, and her family had not allowed it (Paper 3); that year, she went herself. She showed He Zhou her painting, He Zhou said the mast was crooked, and she answered "It is crooked." In this, there is not one "you should" said to He Zhou. This scene is first read as dealings between adults; whether there is leading in it as well depends on how she lives out recognition in her own life and dealings, and is not settled directly by her having an activity of her own. What He Zhou's end can see, and whether he saw it, lie with him.
Read by scope, "standing at the 15DD position" is read as which way operations go, one after another, and falling back is read as it occurs (Paper 1).
Not a position with authority
Leading is not a position with authority. It gives parents no standing to decide matters for an adult child; nor does it extend the structure of the parent-child relation: when the child has come of age and the parent still settles his affairs with "I'm your father," that structure is being stretched out. He Chuan phoning the owner of the yard was, in a matter that was already He Zhou's own, treating him as a child not yet of age. Treating an adult as a child who cannot yet judge for himself what is good for him has been read at the political layer: government that decides people's happiness for them out of benevolence is the greatest conceivable despotism.18 What Kant criticizes is government built on this principle; what is borrowed here is only the shape: treating an adult as a child who cannot yet judge for himself what is good for him. He Chuan's phone call was one operation of this shape, not that kind of government.
Not widened into all dealings
That leading can only be by personal demonstration speaks of the effect of leading. It does not widen into all later dealings between parents and adult children being allowed only demonstration. He Chuan and He Zhou talk on the phone about contracts, the weather, the food at the yard; Lin Wan talks with He Zhou on video about the sea she painted. These are ordinary dealings, read by Relation Theory; should He Chuan and He Zhou one day repair a small boat together, that is something done together, read by Cooperation Theory.
The child's own 15DD
The child's own 15DD is his own affair. 15DD cannot be taught, and cannot be nurtured; it emerges in the collision with another 14DD.19 "Nurtured" here follows the special usage of the education paper's tripartite division, and does not cancel other possibilities of cultivation in Relation Theory's broad sense. What the parents can do is live out recognition, so that he sees that the position exists; whether he gets there, and when, and in which matter, lies with him. The door opens from the inside.20
§5 Turning into Family Affection
PC42 Leading is read until it becomes one face of family affection between adults; no endpoint is set. From then on, what lies between parents and adult children is read by Relation Theory and Cooperation Theory, and conflict by the Conflict Treatise; the case of long-term care needed after coming of age is handed to a future series on relations of care
No endpoint is set
Leading is read until it becomes one face of family affection between adults. There is no date here: there is no day on which the parents stop leading, nor a day on which family affection begins. The evening Lin Wan was learning to draw and He Zhou said the mast was crooked was dealings between adults; whether there was leading in it as well is still checked by the particular effect. The series reads as far as this, and sets no endpoint.
From then on
From then on, what lies between parents and adult children is read by Relation Theory and Cooperation Theory. Parents and an adult child can, in some particular matter, enter the same reciprocal process, and in that matter there may be mutual chiseling;21 of a thing the two do together, the face of doing it together is in Cooperation Theory.11 Whether a later collision enters the Conflict Treatise is still checked by the two gates Paper 5 spoke of; what has entered is read by the Conflict Treatise.
Long-term care
After coming of age, some people, because of severe disability or for other reasons, need long-term care; some parents, grown old, need care from their adult children. These cases this series does not read; they are handed to a future series on relations of care.
§6 Interfacing with the Tradition
Locke: paternal power ends with the maturity of reason. In Chapter 6 of the Second Treatise of Government, Locke says that the power parents have over their children ends when the children come to be able to use their own reason; after that, the children still owe their parents honor, which is another matter.22 The common question: when, and where, the parents' end draws back. Where they shed light on each other: the drawing back comes when the child can judge for himself, not when the parents wish. Where they part: Locke explains by the ability to use reason when parental government ends; this series instead reads, matter by matter, how the first-person position operates, and when the position of raising and refusing becomes the person's own.
Kant: paternal government. In his 1793 essay on the common saying, Kant says that a government aiming at its subjects' happiness, exercising benevolence toward them as a father toward his children, is the greatest conceivable despotism. Political Economy Paper 6 has already interfaced with this passage, and it is pointed back to here.18 This series adds only one point: Kant uses the father toward his children as a comparison, and what he criticizes is government built on this principle, which rules adults as children; what this series reads is literal parents and children: in one matter after another the child has already come of age, and the parents still treat him as a child not yet of age; what is borrowed is only the same shape, not that kind of government; it is read by §4.
Gibran: the bow and the arrow. In The Prophet, "On Children," Gibran says: your children come through you but not from you; you are the bows from which your children as living arrows are sent forth.23 Gibran makes the parents the bow and the children the arrows loosed from it; where they shed light on each other is that the child is not the parents' possession, which runs the same way as this paper's "being able to unfold without revolving around me." In the poem, the one who aims is an archer, and the parents are the bow he bends; this series sets up no such archer, and further reads apart giving conditions, deciding his direction for him, and personal demonstration; it does not take the poem's image directly as a structural criterion.
Material registered: Fu Lei's Letters. The many letters Fu Lei wrote to his son Fu Cong, studying the piano abroad and already grown, were not published in Fu Lei's lifetime, and were collected after his death. The letters talk of music, of how to conduct oneself, and also of very small matters of daily life, often at great length.24 They were originally private correspondence; both men have died, and the book has been published. Here this material is only registered. A particular reading would have to fall on a selected letter, checking separately the giving, the requiring and the room left at the time of writing; it does not judge a direction from the book as a whole, nor does it certify ordinary coming of age as 14DD having come to stand.
§7 Drawing Together, and Downstream
This paper has established five propositions. Taken together, they say: coming of age is read structurally as the child's 14DD coming to stand, arriving domain by domain; coming of age in law is acknowledged but not judged. The position of raising and refusing becomes his own as the gate runs of itself, without waiting for his 14DD to come to stand, and no one may seal it; being able to raise something is not having it come to stand, and an arrangement that involves others is read by each party's law and by the dealings; in matters of his own direction, the parents do not interpret or avow in his place; how securing is drawn back is not conditional on which road he takes, is checked against actual dependency and the arrangements already formed, and is not inferred directly from his having come to stand in one matter; the side that has turned into a relation between adults is read as help or as something done together. The test is on the child's side: that he is able to unfold without revolving around his father, and is also able to unfold without revolving around his mother, read person by person; not that he must leave; constitutive independence, not real-world self-sufficiency. Once 14DD has come to stand, what remains is mainly leading: only by personal demonstration, not a position with authority, not extending the structure of the parent-child relation, and not widening into all dealings being allowed only demonstration; the child's own 15DD is his own affair, and the door opens from the inside. Dealings between adults and leading are read apart, and whether there is leading as well is checked by the particular effect. Leading is read until it becomes one face of family affection, and no endpoint is set; from then on, things are read by Relation Theory and Cooperation Theory, and whether a collision enters the Conflict Treatise is checked by the two gates; long-term care is handed to a future series on relations of care.
This paper does not prove that a child ought to leave once grown, nor that leading is bound to be seen, nor that the parent-child relation has an endpoint.
Downstream. This paper is the last of the papers of this series. The seven papers are listed together in Paper 0; Paper 0 states this series' place on the relational side, lists the shared words, and registers the remainders. The dealings between parents and adult children go back to Relation Theory; things done together go back to Cooperation Theory; conflict goes back to the Conflict Treatise; long-term care after coming of age is left to a future series on relations of care.
Acknowledgments
This paper is signed by Han Qin alone; the author decided every argument and choice and bears sole responsibility for the text. In drafting, the author used AI models from various developers as tools. The English edition is an independent rewrite of the Chinese text, not a translation; where the two differ, the Chinese governs.
Notes
- Parent-Child Theory Paper 1, PC1, PC2. ↩︎
- Education as Subject-Condition: "leading (15DD, the adult embodies recognition, the child sees the direction, possible only by personal demonstration)". ↩︎
- On Rights and Entitlements, F34a, writes of a maturing child: "The child's gate can, at some place, already self-exercise"; "The child's gate at some place cannot yet self-exercise". ↩︎
- On Rights and Entitlements, F34a: "to impose on a maturing subject-to-be an externally fixed binary threshold systematically produces a risk of misclassification". ↩︎
- On Rights and Entitlements: "SAE here only sets them side by side, ruling no particular age, that left still to the specific disciplines and to social judgment". ↩︎
- On Rights and Entitlements, F35: "once the gate self-exercises the questioning-initiative returns at once to the self, while whether a particular recognition-based arrangement comes to stand must still pass a two-way check". The same place: "Once the gate takes a stable first-person ownership". That place speaks of the negation-gate of a recognition-based right passing from exercise by others to running of itself; carrying it here to what lies between parents and child is an extension, this series' own undertaking. ↩︎
- On Rights and Entitlements, F35: "whoever seals its position of expression or channel of exit commits a violation". ↩︎
- On Rights and Entitlements, in the section on F35, blocks one reading: "the gate self-exercising, the adolescent should decide everything of itself—which counts the having-it-come-to-stand to it as well". ↩︎
- Political Economy Paper 6, E35: "Securing in the Base Layer is not conditional on a person's taking some particular road". Carried to the share Lin Wan gives He Zhou, following Paper 2, PC11, and its note on extension. ↩︎
- Relation Theory H47: "where one first monopolizes, or first induces dependency, and then withdraws, violation is checked at the layer of basic rights by F20". ↩︎
- Cooperation Theory Paper 0, §1: "Of a thing parents and their adult children do together, the face of doing it together is here; what lies between parents and child belongs to Parent-Child Theory." ↩︎
- Meaning Theory P3, Y26: "That the other is able to unfold without revolving around me is the hardest test in this row". ↩︎
- Marriage Theory Paper 6, reading this test for two supporters: "How things stand on the child's side belongs to Parent-Child Theory." ↩︎
- Marriage Theory MA35: "the test is read person by person". ↩︎
- Meaning Theory P3, Y26: "the test is not that he must in fact leave me". ↩︎
- Meaning Theory P3, Y26: "Ability is limited to constitutive independence, not to real-world self-sufficiency. Infants, the severely disabled, and the subjects of long-term care cannot in reality do without those who support them, and this never gives the supporter the constitutive right over their values". ↩︎
- Education as Subject-Condition: "There is only one way to lead: the adult stands at the 15DD position, and the child, seeing this, knows that position exists. Leading is possible only by personal demonstration. The window for leading is after 14DD has stabilized." This series reads "stands," by its scope, as the direction of one operation, and falling back is read as it occurs. ↩︎
- Political Economy Paper 6 cites Kant's 1793 essay on the common saying (AA 8:290–291): such a government "is the greatest conceivable despotism" (ist der größte denkbare Despotismus). Carrying it here from government to parents and adult children is an extension, this series' own undertaking. ↩︎
- Education as Subject-Condition: "15DD cannot be taught ('you should respect others' is a 12DD rule, not 15DD) and cannot be nurtured (15DD is not chiseled out by the child alone but emerges in the collision with another 14DD)". "Nurtured" there is the special usage within the tripartite division of teaching, nurturing and leading. ↩︎
- Learning IV, §10: "This series brings the reader to the door of 15DD. There are people outside. The door opens from the inside." The subject of that sentence is that series; this is a borrowing of the same form, this series' own undertaking. The same paper: "15DD is the faith layer (non dubito), beyond what education or argument can accomplish". ↩︎
- Relation Theory Paper 1, in the section under H6: "Parents and an adult child can, in some particular matter, enter the same reciprocal process, and in that matter there may be mutual chiseling". ↩︎
- Locke, Two Treatises of Government, Second Treatise, ch. 6, §§58–61, 65–67. Paraphrased after the Liberty Fund electronic text of the edition by T. Hollis (London: A. Millar et al., 1764). ↩︎
- Gibran, The Prophet (first published by Alfred A. Knopf, New York, 1923), "On Children." Paraphrased from Project Gutenberg eBook No. 58585. ↩︎
- Fu Lei, Fu Lei's Letters (傅雷家书). Originally Fu Lei's private letters to Fu Cong; not published in Fu Lei's lifetime, and collected after his death. Registered as material only; the collection is cited from the bibliographic record of Fu Lei jia shu, ed. Fu Min (Beijing: SDX Joint Publishing, 1981), and no individual letter is verified from it. ↩︎
References
All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version.
I · SAE works directly cited in this paper
Qin, H. (2026). What a Relation Is, and What It Is Not (SAE Relation Theory, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545047
Qin, H. (2026). The Sediment of Dealings (SAE Relation Theory, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23545076
Qin, H. (2026). The Place of Marriage Theory (SAE Marriage Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23819201
Qin, H. (2026). Three (SAE Marriage Theory, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23819255
Qin, H. (2026). The Place of Cooperation Theory (SAE Cooperation Theory, Paper 0) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24029128
Qin, H. (2026). How Subjecthood Is Not Swallowed by Conflict Itself (SAE Conflict Treatise) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22313628
Qin, H. (2026). On Rights and Entitlements (SAE Rights Theory, Special Study) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21314907
Qin, H. (2026). The Half That Is Not Mine to Settle (SAE Meaning Theory, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22731235
Qin, H. (2026). Support (SAE Political Economy, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874154
Qin, H. (2026). Education as Subject-Condition: A Philosophy of Education [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18867389
Qin, H. (2026). Learning to Recognize the Other's Purpose: The Bridge from 14DD to 15DD (SAE Learning, IV) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19491926
II · External works
Fu Lei 傅雷. (1981). Fu Lei jia shu 傅雷家书 [Fu Lei's Letters]. Ed. Fu Min. Beijing: SDX Joint Publishing. [In Chinese] (registered as material; bibliographic record only)
Gibran, K. (1923). The Prophet. New York: Alfred A. Knopf. (first-publication details; text used: Project Gutenberg eBook No. 58585)
Locke, J. (1764). Two Treatises of Government (T. Hollis, Ed.). London: A. Millar et al. (first published 1689; Liberty Fund electronic text)
Interfaces
- Main upstream: On Rights and Entitlements (F34a, F35; the sentence on ages set by ruling); Meaning Theory P3 (Y26); Marriage Theory Paper 6 (the close), MA35; Education as Subject-Condition (leading); Learning IV.
- Also used: Political Economy Paper 6 (E35; Kant on paternal government, pointed back to); Relation Theory H47, and the section under H6 in Paper 1; Cooperation Theory Paper 0 (§1).
- This series: Takes up Paper 1, PC1, PC6, PC7; Paper 2, PC12, PC14; Paper 3, PC16; Paper 4, PC21 to PC23; Paper 5, PC27, PC28. Listed together in Paper 0.