The Digital and Monopoly
数字与垄断
This paper reads the digital: platforms, data and attention. The title uses "and" so as not to presuppose that this area is already monopolized. A platform makes rules as a chokepoint: ranking, access, steering, commission; once ranking is replaced by choosing on the buyer's behalf, who makes the rules of choosing, who changes them and who questions them is read by the way of examining in Paper 2. Data about a person is not material for placing his leaving under another's control: Political Economy's Gate One forbids using money, housing or the manner of paying wages to place people's ability to leave, refuse or revoke a standing bond under another party's control; here it is extended to data: one firm or a few do not use the data, relations and records a person has left with them to place his leaving under their control, nor use these to seal off the road by which another firm could take over; that a relation has terms, conditions, procedures or exit costs does not mean that exit has been sealed off; data portability and interoperability serve as examples at the rule layer (LD8). Several firms side by side do not by themselves prove a way forward: parallel terms and identical defaults are a signal to be examined; where, whichever firm one switches to, the road that could originally have been chosen still cannot be taken, the number of companies cannot be used to prove a way forward; coordination and collusion are examined separately (LD9). The constructed examples are four: "Ask-the-Way," a buying feature on Crossways Market driven by one firm's model; "Notes," in which that model company's assistant records users' dealings over many years; three model companies changing their terms in the same quarter so that records can be exported only in each firm's own format; and, in the far future, a Basic Payment issued through one firm's assistant, with the payment account tied to the assistant account. In reality, the European Commission found under the Digital Markets Act that Apple breached its anti-steering obligation and that Meta did not give users an option that uses less personal data; the court in the Google search case said that click and query data are the "raw material" Google uses to improve search. Advertising and attention models are not the problem in themselves; the problem lies in whether people are informed, whether they can refuse, and whether there is a way out.
Writing Declaration: This paper was co-drafted with Claude (Anthropic). All intellectual decisions, framework design, and final editorial judgments were made by the author.
Introduction
In the spring of Year 30, Crossways Market launched "Crossways Ask-the-Way": the buyer says what he wants, and the assistant chooses for him and places the order. Ask-the-Way is driven by Beacon Assistant, and Crossways pays Beacon by usage.
Ask-the-Way is the default entry on Crossways Market's front page; the search box is still there, moved to the bottom of the page. Ask-the-Way gives the buyer one or two items at a time, not a list; to see a list, the buyer has to click twice more.
Crossways Market's terms state that the only assistant that can place orders for buyers on Crossways Market is Ask-the-Way; buyers' own assistants, including the personal version of Beacon Assistant, cannot place orders for them on Crossways Market.
Sellers began "writing for the assistant": reworking their product pages into formats Ask-the-Way reads easily. From Year 31 Crossways sold sellers an "Ask-the-Way Preferred" badge, awarded according to the amount paid.
In Year 32, orders placed through Ask-the-Way made up about fifty-five percent of Crossways Market's orders (Crossways' annual report). That same year the statistician took another sample: where comparable goods had similar prices and ratings, Ask-the-Way recommended Crossways Home about four times as often as other sellers. Crossways' answer was: "Ask-the-Way looks at buyer satisfaction."
The rules for choosing goods are not public; they were changed once in Year 31 and once in Year 32, without notice to sellers. Sellers who object to recommendations go to the Seller Appeals Committee; from Year 25, all seven members have been appointed by management.
The other face: buyers saved time. Ask-the-Way placed orders for elderly people unfamiliar with online shopping; in Year 32 there were about thirty percent more buyers aged sixty-five or over than in Year 30.
Ten years earlier, Crossways Market's front page had a ranked list; what sellers asked was "why am I ranked lower." Now the front page has one or two items already chosen; what sellers have to ask is "why was I not chosen," and what buyers have handed over.
This paper reads three things in the digital: a platform making rules as a chokepoint (§1); data about people (§§2, 3); several firms side by side with no way forward (§4).
§1 A Platform Making Rules as a Chokepoint
A platform is a kind of chokepoint. The rules it makes, ranking, access, steering and commission, fall on the roads of many sellers and many buyers. Paper 2 has already established how this kind of rule is questioned: the scope is drawn by the institution, not fixed and changed by the platform on its own; changing rules is the same as making rules; the channel of questioning is functionally independent of it (LD4). This section reads only the new question Ask-the-Way adds: once ranking is replaced by choosing on the buyer's behalf, how do the rules differ?
Ranking replaced by choosing on the buyer's behalf. In a list, a buyer who scrolls down can still see the seller ranked tenth; Ask-the-Way gives only one or two items at a time, and what was not chosen the buyer does not see unless he clicks twice more to look at the list moved to the bottom. Ranking is a list in order; choosing on someone's behalf is a choice made in his place. If the rules of choosing are not public and are changed without notice, sellers cannot even know why they were not chosen, and so have no way to question it.
Who makes the rules of choosing, who changes them, who questions them. Crossways makes them; Crossways changes them, twice without notice; the road of questioning is the Appeals Committee, all seven of whose members are appointed by management. Political Economy has read this committee: an appeals arrangement whose majority is appointed by the party questioned is examined for independence in the functional sense, by whether it can be cancelled by the party questioned on its own (Political Economy Paper 3, E16; Institution Theory Z34). This section does not redo that, and only points out that the rules of choosing fall at a deeper place than ranking, while the road of questioning is still the old one.
"Ask-the-Way Preferred," awarded by amount paid. A badge is written beside the goods chosen; do buyers know how it is awarded? If a badge bought with payment affects what is chosen, the buyer thinks the assistant chose for him, when in fact part of it was bought by the seller. The example does not record whether the badge has any bearing on what is chosen, and this paper does not fill that in. What is to be examined is whether buyers are informed.
Only Ask-the-Way may place orders. Buyers' own assistants cannot place orders for them on Crossways Market. Is this a rule of the market, or a door at the layer of agents? If a buyer wants to use his own assistant, one he chose himself and that works for him, to come to Crossways and buy things for him, he cannot. Paper 5 takes up this question: control of one layer extended into the next.
The statistician's four times. The sample controlled only for price and rating; it does not show that Ask-the-Way deliberately favors Crossways Home. Crossways' answer, "Ask-the-Way looks at buyer satisfaction," is a reason that can be examined: how buyer satisfaction is measured, and whether Crossways Home's satisfaction is really higher, the example does not record. This paper does not read minds and does not judge. Four times is a signal; with the rules of choosing not public, the signal cannot be examined further. That the rules are not public does not by itself prove that the rules are illegitimate; it leaves the road of questioning nowhere to land.
Two faces. That elderly buyers increased by thirty percent is true; Ask-the-Way saved them the effort of searching through a list. One benefit does not offset another compression: more elderly buyers does not answer why a seller was not chosen; and the seller's question does not erase the convenience the elderly gained.
In reality, a regulatory decision shows what steering looks like. On 23 April 2025, the European Commission adopted a decision under the Digital Markets Act finding that Apple had breached its anti-steering obligation: app developers could not freely tell users about offers outside the app store and steer them there; the fine was 500 million euros. Apple has brought an action before the EU General Court. On the American side, in Epic v. Apple the district court found that Apple violated an injunction allowing steering by means of a new commission arrangement; the Ninth Circuit affirmed the contempt finding, reversing and remanding part of the sanctions; the Supreme Court granted certiorari on the question of contempt, with argument set for 11 January 2027; Paper 2 has already written this. This series writes these as the Commission and the courts have found, with their status marked, and gives no verdict of its own. It uses them to show one thing: the side holding the chokepoint can make rules that decide whether its users may be told that there is a road elsewhere; such a rule falls on the very matter of many people's "way forward."
§2 Data about People
In Year 31, Beacon Assistant introduced "Notes": it recorded users' conversations and preferences over the years, and kept a workshop's dealings with customers and its accounts. It was on by default.
Users can export Notes; what is exported is in Beacon's own format, and Beacon has published no description of the format. In Year 33, the assistants of two other model companies could not read this format.
In Year 34, a workshop owner in Bluekiln wanted to switch to another assistant. Three years of dealings with customers, quotations and habits of reply were all in Notes; a new assistant could not read them, and everything would have to be built again from scratch. He asked Beacon whether it could export them in a form other firms could read, and customer service answered: "That feature isn't available at present." He stayed.
In Year 35, Beacon's annual report said that among users who had had Notes on for two full years, the rate of switching to another firm in the third year was about a quarter of that among those who had not turned Notes on.
The other face: Notes made the assistant understand its user better the more it was used. That workshop owner said it "remembers better than I do"; many elderly people used it to keep their family's birthdays and appointments.
The question in this matter is: do the Notes about him place his leaving under another's control?
For the Emergence Layer half, there is a close sentence upstream. Reading users, the Theory of the Company says: "The difficulty of leaving counts only the part that can be examined: what switching to another provider costs, whether data can be taken along, whether a contract can be cancelled, whether there are other choices." The harder it is to leave, the more explanation and routes of questioning the company owes him (Theory of the Company Paper 3). Notes fall within exchange in the Emergence Layer: what assistant a person uses and what he records is a matter of his unfolding his own path; whether data can be taken along counts in the difficulty of his leaving.
Political Economy also set up Gate One: accumulation is not converted into domination over people's Base Layer; what people need to sustain their lives is not converted into control that compresses their life-substrate, "nor may money, housing or the manner of paying wages be used to place people's ability to leave, refuse or revoke a standing bond under another party's control" (Political Economy Paper 4, E21). That gate is a gate of the Base Layer: money, housing and wages are what people live on; tie people by the manner in which these are paid, and they cannot go.
This paper takes its structure, not its weight: one firm or a few do not use the data, relations and records a person has left with them to place his leaving under their control, nor use these to seal off the road by which another firm could take over. What is carried over is the same structure: one side holds something the other relies on, and ties his leaving by how it is given and how it can be taken away. The weight of the gate comes from the Base Layer and does not come along with the structure; being held fast through things like Notes is examined by that sentence of the Theory of the Company and by GS9, in the same form as Gate One; the manner of payment in the Base Layer, in the next section, is directly per Gate One. Reading supply at the life-substrate, Political Economy also said that the efficacy of exit does not by itself give the procedure of exit, and how to withdraw is examined separately, through a procedure that does not seal off others' way of taking over (Political Economy Paper 2, E11a); here the clause on taking over is taken: whether another firm can take up what he brings with him is part of whether there is a way out.
What is carried over must bring along the limit that gate carries with it. E21 says: "That a relation has terms, conditions, procedures or exit costs does not mean that exit has been sealed off"; sealing off means that the person no longer holds a structural channel for refusing, revoking a standing bond, or passing into a reviewable procedure (Political Economy Paper 4, E21). That workshop owner's story writes down the cost of rebuilding his records; this cost is not yet enough to establish that exit has been sealed off. Nor is it inferred backward from this that he is able to go: the standing to close an account and the channels actually available cannot stand in for each other. This paper does not say that Notes have sealed off anyone's exit, nor that everyone can leave.
What this paper reads is something else: does exporting a file other firms cannot read count as being able to export? Nominally, Notes can be exported; in fact, neither of the other two firms' assistants can read what is exported. By Paper 1's reading, what counts is whether it can actually be got around, not whether there is nominally another way: "can be exported" in name and "can be taken along" in fact lie very far apart.
Reading users' entry into an exchange of data and attention, the Theory of the Company says that being informed, being able to refuse and not being held fast make it an exchange in the Emergence Layer, and that where these are not met, the line is crossed (Theory of the Company Paper 3, GS9). Notes are on by default; whether users know what it records, whether they can turn it off, and whether, having turned it off, they still have an option that is not worse: this is the face of "being informed, being able to refuse." Recorded for three years and impossible to take along: this is the face of "not being held fast." This paper only sets out the reading, and does not judge that Notes cross the line: Notes are in themselves a capacity, and understanding its user better the more it is used is their benefit; they can at the same time be the road to being unable to leave. The two faces are examined separately.
The one ratio in the annual report, a quarter, is not caused by Notes alone: those who turn Notes on may already be people who use it more and want less to switch. One workshop owner's story does not stand for everyone either. This paper does not read minds from it, and does not say that Beacon intended to hold people fast through formats.
Data portability and interoperability are means the rule layer can use: records can be exported in a public format that other firms can read; or several firms can agree on a form they can all read. These serve as examples, and their form is examined by effect, cost and alternatives: interoperability takes engineering, and can also bring new problems of privacy and security; this series does not advocate any one way of writing it as best.
In reality, two findings show what data about people looks like at a large platform.
One is the European Commission's other decision of 23 April 2025: it found that Meta's "consent or pay" model of the time did not, as the Digital Markets Act requires, give users the choice of an equivalent service using less personal data, with a fine of 200 million euros; Meta has brought an action before the EU General Court (T-435/25, brought on 4 July 2025). It is written as the Commission found, limited to the model of the time. It connects with the item "being able to refuse": refusing to hand over more personal data, and still having an option that is not worse after refusing.
One is the remedy in United States v. Google (search) (remedies opinion 2 September 2025, final judgment 5 December 2025; both sides on appeal, not yet decided). The court said that users' click and query data are the "raw material" Google uses to improve search, fundamental to its advantage of scale; the remedy requires Google to share parts of its search index and user-interaction data with qualified competitors. It is written as the court found. What it shows is that data about many people can be part of where a position's scale comes from; by letting other firms obtain a part of it, the court opens a road on the side of taking over. This series does not judge whether this remedy is enough, nor does it fill it out into the claim that data must be transferred unconditionally.
§3 The Manner of Payment
This section uses an imagined far-future scenario, set from Year 48 to Year 55. After machines have taken over much of the Base Layer's work, many people's livelihoods no longer come from that work. This passage is imagined, not a prediction of the real future.
In Year 48 the Kingdom State set up a Basic Payment: one portion a month for each adult resident of the state, paid from taxes levied on machines; the state's estimate was that it was enough for one person's basic food and lodging for a month.
The state handed the issuing of the payment and the verification of eligibility to Beacon Assistant: applying, verifying and receiving the money were all done in the assistant; the state paid Beacon a service fee. Those who did not use Beacon Assistant could apply at a service window in the township offices. In Year 48, a hundred and twenty township offices in the state had service windows; by Year 52, eighteen remained; the state's explanation was "too few people use them."
In Year 52 Beacon changed its terms: the payment account was tied to the assistant account; anyone who closed the assistant account would have the payment moved to a service window, with verification done again, taking about six weeks.
In Year 53, an elderly man who wanted to switch to another firm's assistant had a two-hour journey by road to the nearest service window. In the end he did not switch.
In Year 54, a member of the State Legislature proposed that the payment must be issued through at least three roads, one of which does not pass through any company. The proposal is in committee.
The other face: from Year 48 to Year 55 the payment was never once late; from application to receipt took about three days; people in remote places could receive it; the state's cost of issuing it was about a tenth of what it had been in the era of service windows.
This matter is directly per Gate One: the manner in which money is paid is not used to place people's leaving under another's control (Political Economy Paper 4, E21). The money is the state's; the road by which it is issued is in one firm's assistant's hands. A person who wants to leave that assistant must first think about how he will receive his payment: if he closes the account, the payment moves to a service window, with verification done again, about six weeks; that elderly man had a two-hour journey by road to the nearest service window. How the payment is received during verification, the example does not record. His leaving has been tied to his payment.
Read by that gate's limit: the service windows are still there, eighteen of them; six weeks and two hours are costs of exit, and that there are costs does not mean exit has been sealed off. Sealing off means that the person no longer holds a structural channel for refusing, revoking a standing bond, or passing into a reviewable procedure (ibid.). In this imagined scenario the channel is still there, only narrower and narrower. This paper does not say that exit has been sealed off; what it reads is that a gate of the Base Layer is being approached: the manner of payment is beginning to become a cost of leaving.
Two acts must be recorded separately. The tying clause was Beacon's change. The withdrawal of service windows from a hundred and twenty to eighteen is the state's act, not Beacon's. The Prequel said that the construct that adopts one firm's product as a gate answers for its adoption: the state handed the issuing to Beacon Assistant and then withdrew the service windows, and this share it must answer for itself. The three-roads proposal asks exactly this of the state itself: the money is the state's; why should the road by which it is issued pass through only one firm?
Three days to receipt and a tenth of the cost are true; they fall on the efficiency of issuing. A two-hour journey by road and about six weeks of fresh verification fall on a person who wants to leave. The two fall in different places and do not offset each other.
LD8 Data about a person is not material for placing his leaving under another's control. Gate One forbids using money, housing or the manner of paying wages to place people's ability to leave, refuse or revoke a standing bond under another party's control (per E21). Extended to data: one firm or a few do not use the data, relations and records a person has left with them to place his leaving under their control, nor use these to seal off the road by which another firm could take over (being held fast in the Emergence Layer: per Theory of the Company Paper 3, which counts "whether data can be taken along" in the difficulty of leaving, and GS9, "being informed, being able to refuse and not being held fast"; the same form as E21: the weight of the gate comes from the Base Layer and does not come along with the structure; the manner of payment in the Base Layer is directly per E21; the clause on taking over is an extension of E11a; own undertaking). The limit E21 carries with it is carried along: "That a relation has terms, conditions, procedures or exit costs does not mean that exit has been sealed off". Data portability and interoperability serve as examples at the rule layer.
§4 Several Firms Side by Side, with No Way Forward
In the second quarter of Year 33, Beacon and the other two model companies changed their user terms one after another. There were three changes:
the records users leave in their assistants, which Beacon calls "Notes" and for which each of the other two has a similar feature, can all be exported only in each firm's own format, and the three cannot read one another's;
none of the three supports importing another firm's records;
the personal version's price was changed into three tiers, and the prices of the same tier at the three firms differ by less than ten percent.
The first and last of the three firms' announcements of the changed terms were eleven days apart. Together the three accounted for about ninety percent of the state's users of conversational assistants (the Office of Model Affairs' report for Year 34).
The Office asked the three whether they had consulted about the terms. All three answered that they had "each decided independently"; one of them said that this was "common industry practice."
The other face: all three firms' records were fuller than in Year 31; the price of the personal version was about forty percent lower than in Year 31.
Three firms coexist. Counted by firms, users have a choice: those dissatisfied with Beacon can go to the other two. But whichever firm one leaves, at the next one must start again from scratch: the records cannot be carried over, and the other firms do not take them.
The Political Economy specialist paper says that a way forward is the fork in the Emergence Layer: "after leaving there are places to choose among, and how many there are is a matter for the Emergence Layer; the right to choose, and the direction of choosing not being sealed off from outside, carry basic weight" (A Way Out, a Way Forward, E40). Reading non-compete agreements, Political Economy also said: "the direction-space sealed off from outside, that is, foreclosure, is the form of Fork Rights suppressed" (Political Economy Paper 2, E12a).
What is to be asked here is not how many places there are to go, but whether one direction has been kept open. That direction is: taking one's own records of many years along and continuing with another firm's assistant. Whether this road could be taken before the terms were changed, the example does not record; under the present terms, among these three firms, the road of carrying on directly with one's existing records cannot be taken. "There are three firms" therefore cannot by itself answer whether there is a way forward in this direction. Beyond the three, about ten percent of users use other assistants; whether there is an actual place to go there, and whether there are usable means of switching and carrying on, the example does not record, and this paper does not judge that the whole market has no way forward.
So several firms side by side do not by themselves prove a way forward. Parallel terms and identical defaults are a signal to be examined; what is to be looked at is whether, after leaving, there is somewhere one can actually go, and whether the direction concerned is sealed off by these arrangements together. Where, whichever firm one switches to, the road that could originally have been chosen still cannot be taken, the number of companies cannot be used to prove a way forward (extension of the second half of E40 and of E12a: the original speaks of a person's direction not being sealed off from outside; here it is extended to markets where several firms coexist; own undertaking).
This reading does not say that the three colluded. Identical conditions can come from coordination, and can also grow up on their own: one firm does it first, the other two see it, and each decides it is good for itself. That all three answered "each decided independently" does not prove there was no coordination; nor does "common industry practice" prove there was. The example records only the closeness in time and each firm's answer; which it was is not known.
The two cases are examined separately under the Theory of the Market's way of examining (Theory of the Market Paper 4, SC8). If it is coordination, it is examined by where it presses: closing others' roads through an association or a standard is examined as sealing off roads. If each grew that way on its own, the firms' terms taken together can also form a common structural limit; then what is asked about is this structure, not any firm's mind. This paper's proposition holds in the latter case too: without collusion, several firms side by side can still leave no way forward.
To whom is the ought addressed? Without collusion, no firm has to answer for another's terms. By the Prequel's addressing of four kinds of constructs: each firm answers for its own terms, why it allows export only in its own format, why it does not take other firms' records; the constructs that make and enforce rules answer for the rules of interoperability and portability. One firm cannot change another's terms, and no single firm can connect a complete road on its own; so each firm answers for the half it can change, and the side that makes the rules answers for the rules that connect the whole road, and neither can be pushed onto the other.
That the price fell by forty percent and that the records became fuller are true. They fall on price and on capacity; the road that cannot be taken among the three falls on "whether there is a way forward." These benefits do not offset that restriction, nor does the restriction offset the benefits.
This matter connects with Notes in §2: whether one firm's Notes hold a person fast is one firm's matter; when the three firms' Notes cannot be carried to one another, it is no longer only one firm's matter.
LD9 Several firms side by side do not by themselves prove a way forward. Parallel terms and identical defaults are a signal to be examined; what is to be looked at is whether, after leaving, there is somewhere one can actually go, and whether the direction concerned is sealed off by these arrangements together. Where, whichever firm one switches to, the road that could originally have been chosen still cannot be taken, the number of companies cannot be used to prove a way forward (extension of the second half of E40 and of E12a: the original speaks of a person's direction not being sealed off from outside; here it is extended to markets where several firms coexist; own undertaking). Coordination and collusion are examined separately under Theory of the Market SC8.
Where This Paper Stops
This paper has established two propositions: data about a person is not material for placing his leaving under another's control, that there are exit costs does not mean exit has been sealed off, and data portability and interoperability serve as examples at the rule layer (LD8); several firms side by side do not by themselves prove a way forward, and where, whichever firm one switches to, the road that could originally have been chosen cannot be taken, the number of firms cannot be used to prove a way forward (LD9). A platform making rules as a chokepoint is read under Paper 2's LD4; the new question added is who makes, who changes and who questions the rules of choosing once ranking is replaced by choosing on the buyer's behalf.
What it has not shown: that the platform model is itself a problem; that identical terms mean collusion; that switching costs mean being locked in; that data must be transferred unconditionally. Advertising and attention models are not the problem in themselves, under that sentence of the Theory of the Company: a model is judged by its execution, not by its name. Ask-the-Way has not been judged to favor anyone, Notes have not been judged to cross the line, the three firms have not been judged to collude nor to have left the whole market with no way forward, and the tying of the Basic Payment has not been judged to seal off exit.
Handed to Paper 5: whether allowing only Ask-the-Way to place orders is a rule of the market layer or a door at the layer of agents; how control of one layer is extended into the next.
Handed to Paper 6: buyers handing "choosing" to an assistant are handing over the materials of judgment; in the far future, the Basic Payment passes through the same firm's assistant and is joined in one place with food and water.
The remainders it leaves: the particular forms of data portability and interoperability lie at the rule layer; whether a few firms coordinate or each grew that way on its own is examined case by case under Theory of the Market SC8; how many roads the Basic Payment is issued through is set by the construct that makes the rules, which must be able to state its grounds.
The Two Propositions of This Paper
LD8 Data about a person is not material for placing his leaving under another's control. Gate One forbids using money, housing or the manner of paying wages to place people's ability to leave, refuse or revoke a standing bond under another party's control (per E21). Extended to data: one firm or a few do not use the data, relations and records a person has left with them to place his leaving under their control, nor use these to seal off the road by which another firm could take over (being held fast in the Emergence Layer: per Theory of the Company Paper 3, which counts "whether data can be taken along" in the difficulty of leaving, and GS9, "being informed, being able to refuse and not being held fast"; the same form as E21: the weight of the gate comes from the Base Layer and does not come along with the structure; the manner of payment in the Base Layer is directly per E21; the clause on taking over is an extension of E11a; own undertaking). The limit E21 carries with it is carried along: "That a relation has terms, conditions, procedures or exit costs does not mean that exit has been sealed off". Data portability and interoperability serve as examples at the rule layer.
LD9 Several firms side by side do not by themselves prove a way forward. Parallel terms and identical defaults are a signal to be examined; what is to be looked at is whether, after leaving, there is somewhere one can actually go, and whether the direction concerned is sealed off by these arrangements together. Where, whichever firm one switches to, the road that could originally have been chosen still cannot be taken, the number of companies cannot be used to prove a way forward (extension of the second half of E40 and of E12a: the original speaks of a person's direction not being sealed off from outside; here it is extended to markets where several firms coexist; own undertaking). Coordination and collusion are examined separately under Theory of the Market SC8.
References
All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version.
I · This system
Qin, H. (2026). Open to Questioning (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23271324
Qin, H. (2026). Chokepoints (SAE Political Economy, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874140
Qin, H. (2026). Checks (SAE Political Economy, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874142
Qin, H. (2026). Conversion (SAE Political Economy, Paper 4) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874146
Qin, H. (2026). A Way Out, a Way Forward (SAE Political Economy, Specialist Paper) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24021385
Qin, H. (2026). Service (SAE Theory of the Company, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24045731
Qin, H. (2026). The Market: Competition (SAE Theory of the Market, Paper 4) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24183376
II · This series
Qin, H. (2026). What a Monopoly Is Not (SAE Theory of Monopoly, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24377536
Qin, H. (2026). Monopoly: Formation (SAE Theory of Monopoly, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24377542
Qin, H. (2026). Monopoly: Exemption from Questioning (SAE Theory of Monopoly, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24377546
Qin, H. (2026). Technology and Monopoly (SAE Theory of Monopoly, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24377558
Qin, H. (2026). AI and Monopoly (SAE Theory of Monopoly, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24377562
III · Real-world cases
European Commission, Commission finds Apple and Meta in breach of the Digital Markets Act, 2025-04-23 (tier A, Commission press release); Apple has brought an action before the General Court (tier B); Meta Platforms v Commission, T-435/25, brought 2025-07-04 (tier A, EUR-Lex).
United States v. Google LLC, No. 1:20-cv-03010-APM (D.D.C.), remedies opinion 2 September 2025, final judgment 5 December 2025; both sides on appeal, not yet decided. The phrase "raw material" per the page citations of the judgment in Congressional Research Service LSB11362; tier B.
Epic Games, Inc. v. Apple Inc. (status as in Paper 2).
Interfaces
Main upstream: Theory of the Company Paper 3 (the sentence on "whether data can be taken along"); Political Economy Paper 4, E21 (directly per, in the Base Layer; the same form, in the Emergence Layer); Paper 2, E11a (the clause on taking over) and E12a (extension, own undertaking); A Way Out, a Way Forward, E40 (extension, own undertaking); Theory of the Company Paper 3, GS9; Theory of the Market Paper 4, SC8.
Also used: this series' Paper 2, LD4 (a platform making rules as a chokepoint); Political Economy Paper 3, E16 and Institution Theory Z34 (the reading of the Appeals Committee, pointed to).
Examples: Crossways Ask-the-Way; Beacon Assistant's Notes; the three firms alike; the Basic Payment (far future, imagined). All are constructed examples. Real-world: the European Commission's Digital Markets Act decisions concerning Apple and Meta; the data-sharing remedy in United States v. Google (search); Epic v. Apple (pointed to Paper 2).
This series: Paper 1 (data feedback loops and lock-in as one road of "formation"; depth reaching the materials of judgment); Paper 2 (the road of questioning); Paper 5 (allowing only Ask-the-Way to place orders as a door at the layer of agents); Paper 6 (the materials of judgment; the far future joined in one place); Paper 7 (how many roads the payment has; interoperability and data portability as examples at the rule layer).
Handed to Paper 5: how control of one layer is extended into the next.