Self-as-an-End
SAE Theory of Monopoly · Paper 1

Monopoly: Formation
垄断的形成

Han Qin (秦汉) · Independent Researcher · 2026
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24377542 · Full PDF on Zenodo · CC BY 4.0
Abstract

The Prequel set out the broad sense: where one firm or a few control a large-scale market, it falls within this series' diagnosis. This paper asks how a position that opened roads for people became, step by step, a place others cannot get around. Control is recognized by what is actual: being able to set the terms of this market, so that the people in the market cannot get around it; what counts is whether it can actually be got around, not whether there is nominally another way; shares and thresholds are signals and lie at the rule layer; entering the diagnosis is not judging that it crosses the line (LD1). In the Google search case, the United States District Court for the District of Columbia found that the default distribution contracts were exclusive in effect: nominally users could switch search engines; in fact the default position chose for them. Formation has several roads: network effects, data feedback loops, ecosystems and lock-in, defaults and exclusivity, standards and interfaces, buying substitutes that have not yet grown, and parallelism and tacit understanding among a few firms; these roads often run together, and all are examined by whether they leave people unable to get around, without presupposing that they must end in monopoly. Depth reaches not only prices and livelihoods but also information, attention and the materials of judgment (LD2). Last comes the time axis: the same power can be innovation early on and ossification later; the diagnosis goes by what it is doing now; once the effect of a position has changed, earlier conclusions cannot be carried over directly, and which of the original grounds still hold is examined again by the present relation; what once controlled and no longer does is also recognized as it is now; what is examined again is the present structure, and conduct that has already occurred, and its accounts, are not rewritten (LD3). In the case Federal Trade Commission v. Meta, the same court required the Commission to prove that Meta has monopoly power now. The constructed examples use two generations of road-openers: Crossways and Beacon.

Writing Declaration: This paper was co-drafted with Claude (Anthropic). All intellectual decisions, framework design, and final editorial judgments were made by the author.

Introduction

The Prequel used Crossways' thirty years. This paper sets another firm beside it.

In the spring of Year 27, four researchers who had come out of Oakgrove College founded a company in Apple City to make general-purpose models, and called it Beacon. In Year 28 Beacon's conversational assistant went online under the name Beacon Assistant; from Year 29 it charged companies and institutions, while individuals could use a basic tier free of charge.

Bluekiln is a town in the Kingdom State that makes kiln ware. According to the township office's records, from Year 29 to Year 31 about seventy percent of the town's workshops used Beacon Assistant to write product pages in foreign languages, keep accounts and answer letters from buyers elsewhere; among the workshops that used it, the share of orders from elsewhere rose from about fifteen percent to about thirty. Four clinics in Apple City, and the township offices of Willow Ferry and Bluekiln, also used it to issue queue numbers and answer questions.

More than twenty years earlier, Crossways had begun in the same way: in Year 2, four stalls, selling sundries on commission for small out-of-town workshops; by Year 20, forty thousand sellers sold through it, more than ten thousand of them small workshops of five people or fewer.

Two generations of road-openers. One in Year 2, one in Year 27; one opened a road for selling goods, the other a road for writing letters, keeping accounts and finding buyers elsewhere. The roads both firms opened were real.

This paper asks: how did a position that opened roads for people become, step by step, a place others cannot get around? Which steps were others' own choices, and which were roads being closed? At what point did the reading change?

What Beacon did later is examined item by item in the papers that follow; this paper takes only its early face and does not read ahead to what came after. For Crossways' later years, the Prequel has already laid out the dates; this paper reads how it got there.

§1 Control Is Recognized by What Is Actual

The Prequel fixed the scope: where one firm or a few control a large-scale market, it falls within this series' diagnosis; the name follows the direction, and what serves the controller rather than everyone is monopoly, what serves everyone is infrastructure. This section says how control is recognized.

Control is being able to set the terms of this market: prices, rules, access, and who stays or goes; the people in the market cannot get around it. It is recognized in the way Political Economy recognizes chokepoints: "Whether it is a chokepoint depends on whether it can actually be got around, not on whether there is nominally another way" (Political Economy Paper 2, E7).

"There is nominally another way" is the most common answer. Sellers need not sell on Crossways; users can switch search engines; workshops need not use Beacon Assistant. These statements are often true: the other way really exists, and no one is forbidden to take it. But what control asks is not whether the other way exists, but whether people can actually get through it: what leaving costs, what is left once one gets there, and whether the road on that side also runs through the same place.

In reality, a court's finding shows what this looks like. In United States v. Google (search), the United States District Court for the District of Columbia issued its liability judgment in August 2024, finding that Google had unlawfully maintained monopolies in two markets, general search services and general search text advertising. The court found that Google's default distribution contracts with phone makers and browsers were exclusive in effect, foreclosed a substantial share of the relevant markets, denied rivals scale, and depressed rivals' incentives to invest and innovate. On 2 September 2025 the same court issued its remedies opinion, and on 5 December its final judgment. Google has appealed to the United States Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit, and the Department of Justice and the states have also appealed, seeking stronger remedies; at the time of writing the appeal had not been decided.

This series uses only this layer of the court's findings, writes it as the court found it, and gives no verdict of its own on Google's character. It uses it to show one thing: nominally, a user can switch search engines by opening the settings and changing one; in fact, the default position has already chosen for him. The other way that exists in name and the way one can actually get through can lie very far apart. The court found this gap within its own legal framework; at the normative layer this series reads the same kind of structure: whether it can actually be got around.

Shares and thresholds are signals. The Prequel quoted Institution Theory: forms such as appraisal metrics, rankings and grades "are signals, not criteria" (Institution Theory Paper 2, Z13). How shares are measured and where thresholds lie, Political Economy says, belong to the rule layer (Political Economy Paper 3, E19). That Crossways held about sixty percent of the Kingdom State's online retail in Year 20 is a signal to look inside; what is seen inside is the material for judgment.

Entering the diagnosis is not judging that it crosses the line. When Political Economy identified a chokepoint, it said that this only identifies where questions are to be asked (Political Economy Paper 2, E7); the same series says that scale and power-face affect the form and strength of checks, and do not decide from what moment a construct must guard the line and be questioned (Political Economy Paper 3, E14). Once a place of control has entered the diagnosis, what it is doing is examined item by item, and where each of the three tests falls.

The direction is examined by effect. The Economics series says: "the ontological motivation of antitrust is: preventing one party from demoting others to means." (Economics P1 §5.1, as quoted in Political Economy Paper 3, E18) The direction is not read from minds; what is looked at is which side the three tests lean toward when the interests of the controller and of everyone else diverge. To read this step, one must first recognize where control lies.

LD1 Monopoly is recognized by control, structural influence and direction. Where one firm or a few control a large-scale market, it is within this series' diagnosis, Base Layer and Emergence Layer alike; where the direction of the structure serves the interest of those who control it rather than everyone's, it is monopoly, and where it serves everyone's, it is infrastructure (rooted in Economics P1 §5.1; the direction is examined by effect; own undertaking); shares and thresholds are signals and lie at the rule layer (the same form as Institution Theory Z13; per E19); entering the diagnosis is not judging that it crosses the line (per Political Economy E7, E14; the broad sense is this series' own undertaking).

§2 The Roads of Formation

There are several common roads by which a position becomes a place others cannot get around. Each is examined by what is actual: to what degree it leaves people unable to get around, without presupposing that it must end in monopoly.

Network effects. The more people use something, the more it is worth using. When a market has many buyers, sellers come; when it has many sellers, buyers come all the more. When both sides of buying and selling are in one place, leaving means both sides leaving together: when a seller leaves Crossways, his buyers are most likely still on Crossways; when a buyer leaves, the goods he wants are most likely still on Crossways too. Network effects are a benefit in themselves: people gather in one place and can find one another; they also make leaving expensive. This paper writes only how they leave people unable to get around, not that "network effects necessarily lead to monopoly": network effects are common, monopoly is not; between the two lie the other roads.

Data feedback loops. The more it is used, the better it understands people; the better it understands people, the more useful it is; the more useful, the harder to leave. Data is the fuel in this loop. How data about people relates to their leaving is examined in Paper 4; this paper only sets out this one road of "formation."

Ecosystems and lock-in. Records, formats and habits all sit in one place. In Year 31 Beacon Assistant introduced "Notes": it recorded users' conversations and preferences over the years, and kept a workshop's dealings with customers and its accounts. The fuller Notes became, the better the assistant understood its user; a workshop owner in Bluekiln later wanted to switch to another firm, found that three years of dealings with customers were all in Notes, that a new assistant could not read them, and that he would have to build everything again from scratch. He stayed. Paper 4 reads this face: whether exporting a file that no other firm can read counts as being able to export. This paper only points out that no one expressly forbids people to go, and yet the cost of leaving can still rise step by step; whether one is already locked in cannot be judged from a rising cost alone, but requires examining the actual roads of substitution and of carrying on elsewhere. Only what happened is recorded here; it is not said that Beacon intended to hold people fast through formats; minds are not read.

Defaults and exclusivity. The default position chooses for people. In the Google search case read in the previous section, this is what the court found: the contracts put Google in the default position on phones and browsers, exclusive in effect. A default is not a prohibition; people can still change it; but a default decides which road most people take when they do not change it.

Standards and interfaces. The side that writes the interface decides who can get in. When a firm writes its own interface as the sole entry point through which others connect, it stands at the door. This road is examined in Paper 5.

Buying substitutes that have not yet grown. Political Economy read Crossways' purchase of Willow Basket: in Year 20, three young people in Willow Ferry set up Willow Basket Market, selling only handicrafts from the townships, at a commission of five percent; in the summer of Year 22 Crossways made an offer, and the three founders accepted; in the spring of Year 23 Willow Basket stopped running. That paper says: "Buying a substitute that has not yet grown can close a road others could have taken; the seller's consent answers the seller's own affairs, and does not answer for those who depend on this road" (Political Economy Paper 3, E18). The Theory of the Market also read Crossways' offer in Year 29 for Ferry Crossing, a company that did cold-chain and small-batch delivery for township workshops (Theory of the Market Paper 4).

This paper asks only one new thing: the same position bought a newly grown market in Year 22, and in Year 29 made an offer for a newly grown logistics company. Each offer is a transaction in its own right; read as "formation," what do they show?

What they show is that, around one position, the roads were bid for one after another before they grew. Each offer can in itself be legitimate business; whether to sell is the seller's affair. But if a position can buy up its substitutes one by one before they grow, it is hard for a road that does not run through it to grow up around it. This reading goes only so far: Willow Basket's end is not taken as Ferry Crossing's end; Ferry Crossing has not been bought, what would happen once it was bought the example does not record, and the Theory of the Market has already kept this measure. Nor does this reading say that Crossways made its offers in order to close roads; what is read is what the two offers together look like on the road of "formation." The Theory of the Market also recorded one more matter: the Willow Basket purchase went unreviewed because its revenue fell below the filing threshold of the time; by the time of Ferry Crossing, the revised law had taken effect, and the position that asks was there. On the road of formation, whether there is a place that can question it is to be recorded along with this road.

Parallelism and tacit understanding among a few firms. Several firms coexist, their terms run in parallel, their defaults are the same. Whether they coordinate with one another or each grew that way on its own is examined separately under the Theory of the Market's way of examining (Theory of the Market Paper 4, SC8); Paper 4 examines it first. This paper only points out that control need not be in the hands of one firm: several firms side by side, with the same conditions, can also leave people unable, whichever firm they switch to, to take the road that could originally have been chosen.

These roads often run together. A position seldom takes only one. Crossways has network effects, its own logistics, the tie of the "Express" section, acquisitions, and the change in how the Appeals Committee is appointed; Beacon has data feedback loops, Notes, and later wrote interfaces as well. Taken together, they are "formation." Each is examined one by one in order to see clearly what effect each had; without examining them one by one, only the word "big" is left, and bigness by itself explains nothing.

In reality, a concluded historical case shows two settled matters, formation and breakup. In the Standard Oil case, the United States Supreme Court found in 1911 that it had restrained trade and sought monopoly through combination, and upheld the lower court's dissolution decree; the company was broken into more than thirty companies. The judgment and the "rule of reason" it established have been discussed at length in later legal scholarship; this series uses only two settled matters: a position that controlled a large-scale market through combination was found so by a court; and control can be taken apart by a court's finding. In this series breakup is the last resort; Paper 7 returns to it.

(LD2 is established by this section and the next together; the proposition is stated at the end of the next section.)

§3 Depth: Reaching the Materials of Judgment

Political Economy says that a chokepoint has two magnitudes: breadth, how many people must pass through it; depth, which dimension it presses on when one cannot get around it (Political Economy Paper 2, E7). At the level of relations depth is looked at; at the level of scale, breadth; small power can run deep.

The chokepoints that paper names are water sources, sole employers, hiring and admission, credit, and certification. What they press on are people's livelihoods, work, prospects and credit. This paper takes one step further (own undertaking): depth reaches not only prices and livelihoods but also information, attention and the materials of judgment. The positions through which people obtain information, allocate attention and form judgments can also be chokepoints; what they press on there is the material from which people themselves see, think and choose.

This step has an interface upstream. Reading users' entry into an exchange of data and attention, the Theory of the Company says: "A model is judged by its execution, not by its name"; users being informed, being able to refuse and not being held fast make it an exchange in the Emergence Layer, and where these are not met, the line is crossed (Theory of the Company Paper 3, GS9). Advertising and attention models are not the problem in themselves; the problem lies in whether people are informed, whether they can refuse, and whether, having refused, they still have an option that is not worse. This series takes up that sentence and looks one layer deeper: when an entry point is so large that many people obtain information through it, what it presses on is no longer just one user's one choice, but where many people's materials of judgment come from.

A constructed example shows what this depth looks like. In the spring of Year 30, Crossways Market launched a feature called "Crossways Ask-the-Way": the buyer says what he wants, and the assistant chooses for him and places the order. Ask-the-Way is driven by Beacon Assistant. It is the default entry on the market's front page, and the search box was moved to the bottom of the page; Ask-the-Way gives the buyer one or two items at a time, not a list, and to see a list the buyer has to click twice more. By Year 32, orders placed through Ask-the-Way made up about fifty-five percent of Crossways Market's orders.

This matter is examined in Paper 4: who makes the rules for choosing goods, who changes them, and who questions them. This paper only points out that it is one kind of depth: the buyer has handed over the "choosing." He no longer sees a list; he sees one or two things already chosen. The list is still there, and he can still go and look; this matter does not show that buyers have lost their judgment. What it shows is that a position can move from selling for people to choosing for people; from pressing on sellers' livelihoods to pressing on buyers' judgment.

How the materials of judgment are pressed on at a layer is examined in Paper 6. What is said there is that the entry point for obtaining information is held by one firm or a few; it does not say that machines replace human judgment or creativity. This paper only establishes the dimension: the depth of a chokepoint can reach the materials of judgment.

LD2 Whether it can be got around is examined by what is actual; depth reaches the materials of judgment. Network effects, data feedback loops, ecosystem lock-in, standards and interfaces, and parallel terms among several firms are all examined by whether they leave people unable to get around them, not by whether there is nominally another way (per E7). Depth reaches not only prices and livelihoods but also information, attention and the materials of judgment (extension of the depth of E7; own undertaking; connecting with Theory of the Company GS9).

§4 The Time Axis: Examined as It Is Now

From innovation to growing large, and on to ossification. The same power can be innovation early on and ossification later.

In Year 15 Crossways ran the Small Shop Starter Program, waiving a new seller's commission for the first year: it used its own accumulation to open a road for small workshops arriving new. In Year 25 it stopped the program; in the same year, the two seats on the Appeals Committee elected from among sellers were changed to appointment by management. In Year 29 it made an offer for Ferry Crossing. Three years, the same company, the same power; different effects.

The diagnosis goes by what it is doing now. Once the effect of a position has changed, earlier conclusions cannot be carried over directly: which of the original grounds still hold is examined again by the present relation.

Reading the independence of a reviewing position, the Theory of Disciplines said something of the same form: after the premises or duties change, "the previous round's conclusion on independence cannot be carried over directly; the existing evidence (protections on appointment and removal, funding arrangements, powers over the agenda, the right to publish reports) must be checked against the new relation, to settle which of it still holds and which is no longer enough" (Theory of Disciplines Paper 8, S41). The original speaks of the previous round's conclusion on independence; here it is extended to conclusions of diagnosis (own undertaking). The conclusion that recognized Crossways as opening roads in Year 15 cannot be carried over directly to Year 29; which of that year's grounds, waiving commission and giving newcomers a road, still hold in Year 29 is examined by the relations of Year 29.

There are two more places upstream. The Theory of Government says that a decision can be final and a case can be closed, yet "after a case is closed, it can be questioned again under new evidence or new problems" (Theory of Government Paper 6, G36). When Political Economy lists the uses that must be subject to checks, uses that "entrench positions" are among them (Political Economy Paper 3, E17). A position recognized in its early years as opening roads is not thereby exempt from examination for life; its effects once it has become entrenched are a new question.

What is examined again is the present structure; conduct that has already occurred, and its accounts, are not rewritten. Examining it as it is now does not re-enter the waived commissions of Year 15 as some other account, nor say what the purchase of Year 22 should have been at the time; it asks what the position is doing today. What has been done has its account in the year it was done.

This holds in both directions. What once controlled and no longer does is also recognized as it is now. The Prequel read this direction through a supposition: suppose that in Year 33 Crossways Market held only about twenty percent of the Kingdom State's online retail; is the Competition Review Division's recommendation of Year 24, "separating the marketplace from its own retail," still needed as it is now, and to what extent? When Paper 7 reads how early constraints and remedies are examined again as they are now, it returns to this.

In reality, one approach shows what "examined as it is now" looks like in a court. In Federal Trade Commission v. Meta, the United States District Court for the District of Columbia ruled for Meta on 18 November 2025. The Commission's suit concerned Meta's purchases of two apps many years earlier; the court said that whether there had been monopoly power in the past was not determinative, "the agency must show that it continues to hold such power now"; the court found that the Commission had not shown this, and found that TikTok and YouTube compete with Meta's apps. The Federal Trade Commission filed a notice of appeal on 20 January 2026; at the time of writing the appeal had not been decided.

This series uses this approach to show that "examined as it is now" also has a form in a court: what must be proved is the present. Using it has two limits. It is not filled out into the claim that Meta did have monopoly power in the past: what the court said is that the past is not determinative, not what the past was. Nor is a conclusion about a particular legal market taken to mean that structural influence in this series' broad sense has disappeared: the court defines markets and finds power within its legal framework; at the normative layer this series looks at whether there is a way out, whether there is a way forward, and whether questioning has effect, and the two frameworks differ. What this approach shares in form with this series is only the one direction of "looking at the present."

Back to Beacon. From Year 29 to Year 31 it opened a road to buyers elsewhere for Bluekiln's workshops; this is its early face. Its later effects are examined item by item in the papers that follow, and this paper does not read ahead. Examining it as it is now holds for Beacon in both directions too: the roads it opened early do not answer for its later effects; and if it later became a place that cannot be got around, that does not erase the roads it opened early.

LD3 The same power is examined as it is now. Early on it is innovation; later it can be ossification; the diagnosis goes by what it is doing now. Once the effect of a position has changed, earlier conclusions cannot be carried over directly: which of the original grounds still hold is examined again by the present relation (the same form as Theory of Disciplines S41: the original speaks of the previous round's conclusion on independence; here it is extended to conclusions of diagnosis; own undertaking; per Theory of Government G36, "it can be questioned again under new evidence or new problems"; E17, "entrench positions"). This proposition holds in both directions: what once controlled and no longer does is also recognized as it is now. What is examined again is the present structure; conduct that has already occurred, and its accounts, are not rewritten.

Where This Paper Stops

This paper has established three propositions: monopoly is recognized by control, structural influence and direction, shares and thresholds are signals, and entering the diagnosis is not judging that it crosses the line (LD1); whether it can be got around is examined by what is actual, and depth reaches the materials of judgment (LD2); the same power is examined as it is now, in both directions, without rewriting accounts already made (LD3).

What it has not shown: that network effects necessarily lead to monopoly; whether any present-day company is a monopoly; that early road-opening offsets later effects, or the reverse. Crossways' two offers, in Year 22 and Year 29, this paper has not judged; Beacon's later years it has not read.

The remainders it leaves: how shares and thresholds are measured lies at the rule layer; whether a few firms coordinate or each grew that way on its own is examined case by case under the Theory of the Market's way of examining, first in Paper 4; how the materials of judgment are pressed on at a layer is handed to Paper 6.

Handed to the next paper: once formed, is the road by which it is questioned still there; and if the road is there, does questioning have effect?

The Three Propositions of This Paper

LD1 Monopoly is recognized by control, structural influence and direction. Where one firm or a few control a large-scale market, it is within this series' diagnosis, Base Layer and Emergence Layer alike; where the direction of the structure serves the interest of those who control it rather than everyone's, it is monopoly, and where it serves everyone's, it is infrastructure (rooted in Economics P1 §5.1; the direction is examined by effect; own undertaking); shares and thresholds are signals and lie at the rule layer (the same form as Institution Theory Z13; per E19); entering the diagnosis is not judging that it crosses the line (per Political Economy E7, E14; the broad sense is this series' own undertaking).

LD2 Whether it can be got around is examined by what is actual; depth reaches the materials of judgment. Network effects, data feedback loops, ecosystem lock-in, standards and interfaces, and parallel terms among several firms are all examined by whether they leave people unable to get around them, not by whether there is nominally another way (per E7). Depth reaches not only prices and livelihoods but also information, attention and the materials of judgment (extension of the depth of E7; own undertaking; connecting with Theory of the Company GS9).

LD3 The same power is examined as it is now. Early on it is innovation; later it can be ossification; the diagnosis goes by what it is doing now. Once the effect of a position has changed, earlier conclusions cannot be carried over directly: which of the original grounds still hold is examined again by the present relation (the same form as Theory of Disciplines S41: the original speaks of the previous round's conclusion on independence; here it is extended to conclusions of diagnosis; own undertaking; per Theory of Government G36, "it can be questioned again under new evidence or new problems"; E17, "entrench positions"). This proposition holds in both directions: what once controlled and no longer does is also recognized as it is now. What is examined again is the present structure; conduct that has already occurred, and its accounts, are not rewritten.

References

All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version.

I · This system

Qin, H. (2026). Not Crossing the Line (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23270384

Qin, H. (2026). Questioning and Bearing (SAE Theory of Government, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23413511

Qin, H. (2026). Chokepoints (SAE Political Economy, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874140

Qin, H. (2026). Checks (SAE Political Economy, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874142

Qin, H. (2026). Service (SAE Theory of the Company, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24045731

Qin, H. (2026). The Market: Competition (SAE Theory of the Market, Paper 4) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24183376

Qin, H. (2026). Independence (SAE Theory of Disciplines, Paper 8) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24177795

Qin, H. (2026). Four Layers of Economic Rationality: A Diagnostic Extension of the Rational Agent from Dimensional Sequence Theory (SAE Economics, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19358010

II · This series

Qin, H. (2026). What a Monopoly Is Not (SAE Theory of Monopoly, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24377536

Qin, H. (2026). Monopoly: Exemption from Questioning (SAE Theory of Monopoly, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24377546

Qin, H. (2026). The Digital and Monopoly (SAE Theory of Monopoly, Paper 4) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24377556

Qin, H. (2026). Technology and Monopoly (SAE Theory of Monopoly, Paper 5) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24377558

Qin, H. (2026). AI and Monopoly (SAE Theory of Monopoly, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24377562

Qin, H. (2026). Monopoly: Remedies (SAE Theory of Monopoly, Paper 7) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24377564

III · Real-world cases

United States v. Google LLC, No. 1:20-cv-03010-APM (D.D.C.). Liability judgment August 2024; remedies opinion 2 September 2025; final judgment 5 December 2025; both sides have appealed to the D.C. Circuit, not yet decided. Per the judgment as cited in Congressional Research Service LSB11362 (2025-09-10); tier B.

Federal Trade Commission v. Meta Platforms, Inc. (D.D.C.). Judgment 18 November 2025; the Federal Trade Commission filed a notice of appeal on 20 January 2026 (D.C. Circuit No. 26-5028), not yet decided. The words of the judgment quoted are per the Associated Press report and the excerpts in Tech Policy Press; tier B.

Standard Oil Co. of New Jersey v. United States, 221 U.S. 1 (1911). Final. From general bibliographic knowledge; the text of the judgment is yet to be examined against the original.

Interfaces

Main upstream: Political Economy Paper 2, E7; Paper 3, E14, E17, E18, E19; Institution Theory Paper 2, Z13; Theory of the Company Paper 3, GS9; Theory of Disciplines Paper 8, S41 (the same form; extension, own undertaking); Theory of Government Paper 6, G36; Economics P1 §5.1 (by way of E18).

Also used: Theory of the Market Paper 4, SC8, and its reading of the two offers for Willow Basket and Ferry Crossing.

Examples: two generations of road-openers, Crossways and Beacon; Willow Basket and Ferry Crossing; Beacon Assistant's Notes; Crossways Ask-the-Way; the supposition that Crossways can be got around again. All are constructed examples. Real-world: United States v. Google (search); Federal Trade Commission v. Meta; the Standard Oil case.

This series: the Prequel (the broad sense; the name follows the direction; both directions of examining as it is now); Paper 4 (Notes; several firms side by side); Paper 5 (standards and interfaces); Paper 6 (the materials of judgment); Paper 7 (early constraints examined again as they are now).

Handed to Paper 2: once formed, is the road by which it is questioned still there; and if the road is there, does questioning have effect?