Self-as-an-End
SAE Theory of the Company · Paper 3

Service
服务

Han Qin (秦汉) · Independent Researcher · 2026
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24045731 · Full PDF on Zenodo · CC BY 4.0
Abstract

This paper asks what users are taken to be by a company. In 1982, seven people in the Chicago area died after taking Tylenol; the medicine had been taken from store shelves by someone and laced with cyanide, and the danger was not caused by Johnson & Johnson, yet Johnson & Johnson stopped production and advertising and removed the product from shelves nationwide. Users are people, each with his own law; what a company sells them is what it does; the users themselves, their attention and the data about them are not the goods in this transaction. Users can leave: whether data can be taken along, and whether unsubscribing is no harder than subscribing, are the two places the normative layer asks about first; the costs and conditions the company sets do not seal off the channels for exiting, refusing, revoking, or passing into review. Recommending is permitted, and whether to choose is the user's own affair; interfaces are not designed to deceive him or to get around his judgment; the closer to a chokepoint, the stronger the checks (GS8). The EU's data portability, the reduction of switching charges to zero, Germany's cancellation button and the Digital Services Act's provisions on interfaces show how the rule layer writes this; the ranking on Crossways Market and the deletion of reviews on Echo Wall show what it is to judge the operation, not the person. Products do not trade harm to people's health and safety for profit; when a danger appears the company stops first, and the cost falls on what the company does; the accountability to stop first is not limited by fault (GS8a). Advertising, free services in exchange for data, subscriptions: the names are not judged, the execution is: as far as users enter an exchange of data and attention, being informed, being able to refuse and not being held fast make it an exchange in the Emergence Layer, and where these are not met the line is crossed; being able to refuse must be real (GS9). The European Commission's non-compliance decision against Meta in 2025 judged precisely a practice in which "being able to refuse" had not been made real. Finally the paper speaks of direction: giving the real thing, and giving users more of a way forward. The paper has three propositions (GS8, GS8a, GS9), each stated at the end of its section and listed together at the end.

Writing Declaration: This paper was co-drafted with Claude (Anthropic). All intellectual decisions, framework design, and final editorial judgments were made by the author.

Introduction

In 1982, seven people in the Chicago area died after taking Tylenol. Tylenol is a painkiller made by Johnson & Johnson. Johnson & Johnson "stopped production, suspended advertising, and removed products from shelves nationwide"; it recalled thirty-one million bottles, at a cost of about one hundred million dollars. It was later established that "Authorities discovered that the Tylenol had been removed from store shelves and laced with poisonous cyanide." (The Christian Science Monitor, 2012-12-12) The danger was not caused by Johnson & Johnson; it still bore the cost on its own side: what stopped was its production, its advertising and the goods on its shelves, and what was spent was its money.

Johnson & Johnson has a credo, Our Credo, written in 1943 and revised a number of times since; in 1987 "fathers" was added to its first paragraph (jnj.com, "8 fun facts about the Johnson & Johnson Credo"). The first sentence of the current text is about the people who use its things: "We believe our first responsibility is to the patients, doctors and nurses, to mothers and fathers and all others who use our products and services." (jnj.com, "Our Credo")

Only this one practice and the original text of the credo are taken here. Johnson & Johnson's later lawsuits and controversies are outside the judgment of this paper: the practice is judged, and no company is characterized. One more thing must be made clear: the credo ranks the parties, with shareholders last ("Our final responsibility is to our stockholders."); this series does not rank the parties. The credo serves here only as an example at the rule layer: how a company writes users into its documents.

Hence the question: what are users taken to be by a company? §1 says who users are; §2 and §3, no locking in, no manipulation, no deception; §4, that health and safety are not traded for profit; §5 takes up models; §6 speaks of direction.

The reading follows the Prequel: the construct takes the ought, the position takes accountability, the person takes his own law.

§1 Who Users Are

Users are people, each with his own law. This series writes no oughts for users: what they buy and do not buy, how long they use it, why they switch, is their own affair.

What a company sells users is what it does: products and services. The price falls on what is done. The user himself is not the goods in this transaction; nor are his attention and the data about him. Using them in an exchange is permitted, but only by the three things of §5: being informed, being able to refuse, not being held fast.

Whether users are inside the company is first identified by the two branches of the Prequel, §7. The difficulty of leaving counts only the part that can be examined: what switching to another provider costs, whether data can be taken along, whether a contract can be cancelled, whether there are other choices. The harder it is to leave, the more explanation and routes of questioning the company owes him (own undertaking); and the ease of leaving does not cancel his standing to have the line guarded and to question.

If a company becomes a place users cannot get around in going about their lives, so that paying, communicating and finding work all have to pass through it, it has come near a chokepoint. Political Economy has laid down: "A position others cannot get around on the way to sustaining their lives or unfolding their own paths is a chokepoint"; "Whether it is a chokepoint depends on whether it can actually be got around, not on whether there is nominally another way. To identify a chokepoint is only to identify where questions are to be asked, not to judge that it crosses the line" (Political Economy Paper 2, E7). As it comes near a chokepoint, the checks strengthen accordingly (Political Economy Paper 3, E14). How chokepoints are identified, and who reviews them, is handed to a later theory of the market; this paper uses the notion only to settle in which direction the checks are strengthened.

§2 No Locking In

Normative layer. Users can leave. Brought down to a company's relation with its users, the normative layer first asks about two places: whether data can be taken along; whether unsubscribing is no harder than subscribing.

Beyond these two places there is one general boundary: the costs and conditions the company sets do not seal off the channels for exiting, refusing, revoking, or passing into review. Political Economy's first gate states "sealing off" precisely: "That a relation has terms, conditions, procedures or exit costs does not mean that exit has been sealed off; sealing off means that the person no longer holds a structural channel for refusing, revoking a standing bond, or passing into a reviewable procedure" (Political Economy Paper 4, E21). An annual contract or an early-termination fee is not in itself a sealing off; what must be looked at is whether, taken together, they leave a person with actually no road out.

Two kinds of difficulty in leaving. A user may be unable to leave a company for two kinds of reason (own undertaking).

One comes from the thing itself. Everyone else is here; switching means learning afresh; all one's contacts are on one messaging app, and changing apps means finding people again. This kind is not, by its origin, judged a line-crossing by the company: no position made it happen; it is the combined result of many people's separate choices. But it brings the company nearer a chokepoint, and the checks and the accountability of supply strengthen accordingly.

The other kind is set up by the company. Data cannot be taken along, the way to unsubscribe is hidden, switching to another provider incurs a fee. This is the kind the normative layer governs. Whether the line has been crossed is examined by whether it seals off the channels for exiting, refusing, revoking, or passing into review; the word "artificial" does not settle it: terms, conditions and exit costs as such do not mean that exit has been sealed off (Political Economy Paper 4, E21; Paper 2, E12a).

Examples at the rule layer. The EU has written "being able to leave" into rules in several places.

Article 20(1) of the General Data Protection Regulation: where the processing of personal data is based on consent or on a contract and is carried out by automated means, the data subject has the right to receive the personal data concerning him that he has provided to a controller "in a structured, commonly used and machine-readable format and have the right to transmit those data to another controller without hindrance" (Regulation (EU) 2016/679, Art. 20(1)).

Article 6(9) of the Digital Markets Act requires more of the large platforms designated as "gatekeepers": at the end user's request, effective portability free of charge, covering not only the data the user has provided but also "data provided by the end user or generated through the activity of the end user" on the platform (Regulation (EU) 2022/1925, Art. 6(9)). The nearer a chokepoint, the heavier the obligation.

Article 29(1) of the Data Act: from January 12, 2027, providers of data processing services "shall not impose any switching charges on the customer for the switching process" (Regulation (EU) 2023/2854, Art. 29(1)).

Section 312k of the German Civil Code: except in the cases the section itself sets out, for continuing consumer contracts that can be concluded through a website and under which a business provides performance for payment, the business must ensure that the consumer can declare termination on the website through a "termination button"; the button may bear only the words "cancel contracts here" ("Verträge hier kündigen") or an equally unambiguous wording (BGB §312k Abs. 1, 2). Where one can sign up, one must also be able to get out.

Article 25(3) of the Digital Services Act lists the practices on which the European Commission may issue guidelines, among them, in point (c), "making the procedure for terminating a service more difficult than subscribing to it" (Regulation (EU) 2022/2065, Art. 25(3)(c)). This paragraph sets out the subjects of guidance, not a list of prohibitions; what it shows is where the rule layer puts its pen.

These provisions are all examples, not rules this series sets for any state.

Judgment layer. Whether the costs and conditions the company sets have sealed off the channels; the scope and format of what can be taken along; who decides, who is accountable.

§3 No Manipulation, No Deception

Normative layer. Recommending is permitted; whether to choose is the user's own affair (A Way Out, a Way Forward, E41). Interfaces and procedures are not designed to deceive him or to get around his own judgment. What the company tells users is the same story it tells investors and employees (Paper 1, GS2).

It judges the operation, not the person. This proposition looks at how the interface is designed, what the ranking is based on, whether reviews have been deleted or altered; it does not ask whether the company "meant to deceive."

The rule layer happens to be written in the same way. Article 25(1) of the Digital Services Act: providers of online platforms "shall not design, organise or operate their online interfaces in a way that deceives or manipulates the recipients of their service or in a way that otherwise materially distorts or impairs the ability of the recipients of their service to make free and informed decisions" (Regulation (EU) 2022/2065, Art. 25(1)). Paragraph 3 of the same article lists practices on which the European Commission may issue guidelines, such as giving one option more prominence when a choice is being made, or repeatedly requesting that the user make a choice already made. The provision too judges the interface, not the motive.

Two constructed examples show how the normative layer lands. For these two kinds of matter, ranking and the deletion of reviews, this paper has not found a usable judgment or regulatory finding, so constructed examples are used.

On Crossways Market in the Kingdom State, search results are ranked by Crossways. In Year 22 a statistician in Apple City took a sample: among goods of the same kind with similar prices and ratings, Crossways Home, Crossways' own brand, appeared on the first page at three times the rate of other sellers. Crossways answered: "Ranking looks at buyer satisfaction; Crossways Home has fewer returns." Ranking can have grounds; this proposition does not require a company not to rank, nor that its own brand be treated just like everyone else's. What it requires is that the grounds can be stated and can be questioned. Crossways stated a ground; whether it holds, and whether the threefold difference all comes from the return rate, must be examined further, and this one ratio is not filled out into a conclusion.

The review platform Echo Wall was acquired by Crossways Group in the spring of Year 23. In Year 24 the same statistician took another sample: the proportion of negative reviews on Crossways Home product pages on Echo Wall deleted on the ground of "violating community norms" rose from three percent before the acquisition to eleven percent. Reviews are information users give one another, and whether a person buys may depend on what others say. The ratio rose, and what remains are the places to ask: whether the grounds for deletion can be explained, whether they favor the company's own brand, whether the reasons and the outcomes of deletion can be questioned. It is not filled out into "all the deletions are stamping out questioning."

A conditional sentence can be written here: if review deletion is used to manufacture a false unanimity of praise, that is deceiving users through other people's mouths (own undertaking). This sentence is a reading at the normative layer, and does not reach a conclusion for this case.

GS8 No locking in, no manipulation, no deception. Whether data can be taken along, and whether unsubscribing is no harder than subscribing, are the two places the normative layer asks about first; the costs and conditions the company sets do not seal off the channels for exiting, refusing, revoking, or passing into review (per Political Economy E21, E12a). Recommending is permitted; whether to choose remains his own affair; interfaces are not designed to deceive him or to get around his judgment. The closer to a chokepoint, the stronger the checks (per Political Economy E7, A Way Out, a Way Forward, E41, E41a; own undertaking).

The root of the last sentence lies in the Specialist Paper's requirement on positions that cannot be got around: "A position others cannot get around (Paper 2, E7) makes rules for many people: how ranking, access, settlement and appeals are handled falls on their way to sustaining their lives or unfolding their own paths. The scope of these rules is drawn by the institution, not fixed and changed by the rule-making party on its own"; "The closer to a chokepoint, the stronger this requirement." (A Way Out, a Way Forward, E41a) The nearer a company is to a chokepoint, the more its ranking, its deletion of reviews and its appeals must be explicable and open to questioning.

§4 Health and Safety Are Not Traded for Profit

Normative layer. Products do not trade harm to people's health and safety for profit. This is a line, not weighed on the scale of profit; it is written in the same way as Paper 1, GS3: the line is there before any weighing (Institution Theory Z9).

Stopping first. When a danger appears, the company first stops and isolates the dangerous product, stage or practice, and does not let the danger continue for the sake of keeping its profit. The cost falls on what the company does, its output, its advertising, its shelves, its costs; not on users.

How to stop, and how supply is taken over. One situation must be taken up on its own. Political Economy has laid down a kind of position: "The sole position of supply that touches the life-substrate, for which others have no affordable substitute" (Political Economy Paper 2, E11a). If a company is such a position, say the sole supplier of piped water in a place, then when a danger appears what it must stop is the danger, not the supply. The arrangements for how to stop and how supply is taken over are examined together under E11a: "how to withdraw is examined separately, through a procedure that does not seal off others' way of taking over and in which the manager arranges succession" (ibid.). Stopping the danger is not read as withdrawing the necessary supply along with it.

The accountability to stop first is not limited by fault (own undertaking). That the original source of the danger is not the company does not by itself relieve it of its accountability, as provider, for protection and handling. The Tylenol was taken from the shelves by someone and poisoned, and the danger landed on Johnson & Johnson's product; in this series' reading, its stopping first, as a step, is within this proposition; stopping as far as removing the product nationwide and halting advertising is a matter for the judgment layer, "how far to stop," and this paper does not judge it. Acting first and the final allocation of compensation and losses are two separate things: the latter each have their own grounds, and are left to the rule layer and the judgment layer.

Tendencies at the rule layer. Recall mechanisms; disclosure on the company's own initiative; prompt notification once a danger is discovered. Only tendencies are written here; particular regulations are not cited.

Judgment layer. Whether the danger is real, and how great; when to stop, and how far; who decides, who is accountable, and how remedy is made afterwards; how compensation and recourse are divided.

Last, a discipline. Whether Johnson & Johnson's brand recovered after that recall, and how quickly, this paper does not use as argument. Stopping first is because of the line, not because companies that stop first do well afterwards. Outcomes are not taken as rules.

GS8a Health and safety are not traded for profit. Products do not trade harm to people's health and safety for profit; this is a line, not weighed on the scale of profit (per Institution Theory Z9). When a danger appears, the company first stops and isolates the dangerous product, stage or practice, and the cost falls on what the company does, not on users; where it is the sole position of supply at the life-substrate, how it stops and how supply is taken over are examined under Political Economy E11a. The accountability to stop first is not limited by fault: if the danger was not caused by the company but lands on its product, it still stops first; compensation and the allocation of losses have their own grounds (own undertaking).

§5 A Model Is Judged by Its Execution, Not by Its Name

Normative layer. Advertising, free services in exchange for data, subscriptions, memberships: none of these names does this series judge. The advertising and attention models as such are not the problem; the problem lies in how they are executed, and what their structural effects are.

As far as users enter an exchange of data and attention, three things are judged: being informed, being able to refuse, not being held fast. Where they are met, it is an exchange in the Emergence Layer, and is left open as usual; where they are not, the line is crossed.

This test governs the exchange itself. Other harms to the Base Layer, effects on third parties and chokepoint structures are examined separately under the corresponding lines; passing this test does not certify the model as warranted in every respect. This formulation has the same form as the sentence on Political Economy's two gates: "not running into the two gates does not certify a transaction as warranted in every respect" (Political Economy Paper 4, E24; own undertaking).

Attention, and data about a person, are not sold as commodities unless he is informed and able to refuse.

Being able to refuse must be real. Being able to refuse must be made real in three places: refusing is no harder than agreeing; a refusal still leaves an option that is not worse; those who have refused are not asked again and again.

Structural effects. The same model, used by a company that has already become a chokepoint, has a different reach, and the checks strengthen accordingly (Political Economy Paper 2, E7; Paper 3, E14).

Examples at the rule layer. Article 5(2) of the Digital Markets Act and its Recitals 36 and 37 match "being able to refuse must be real" almost point by point. A gatekeeper combining or cross-using personal data must first give the user the specific choice and obtain consent ("unless the end user has been presented with the specific choice and has given consent"); after the user refuses or withdraws, the request for the same purpose may not be made "more than once within a period of one year" (Art. 5(2)). A less personalized but equivalent option should be provided, and consent may not be made a condition of using the core platform service or some of its functions ("offering a less personalised but equivalent alternative, and without making the use of the core platform service or certain functionalities thereof conditional upon the end user's consent") (Recital 36); and: "Not giving consent should not be more difficult than giving consent." (Recital 37) The provisions do not prohibit the advertising model; they judge the execution.

A real case. In November 2023, Meta introduced in the EU a binary "Consent or Pay" advertising model: users of Facebook and Instagram could either consent to the combination of their personal data and see personalized ads, or pay a monthly fee and see no ads. On April 23, 2025, the European Commission announced its non-compliance decision on it: "Meta breached the DMA obligation to give consumers the choice of a service that uses less of their personal data," with a fine of two hundred million euros. The Commission's reason was that "it did not give users the required specific choice to opt for a service that uses less of their personal data but is otherwise equivalent to the 'personalised ads' service." The period found ran from March 2024, when these obligations became legally binding, to November 2024 (European Commission press release IP/25/1085, 2025-04-23).

What was judged was this one practice. Advertising was not judged, nor was paid subscription as such. In this series' reading, this is "being able to refuse" not made real: the road of refusal had only paying left on it, with no option that used less data and was otherwise equivalent (own undertaking). This reading does not extend to every arrangement in which refusal costs money crossing the line. It is stated as it stands: as of that announcement, the new version Meta introduced in November 2024 was still being assessed by the Commission.

GS9 A model is judged by its execution, not by its name. As far as users enter an exchange of data and attention, being informed, being able to refuse and not being held fast make it an exchange in the Emergence Layer; where these are not met, the line is crossed. Other harms to the Base Layer, effects on third parties and chokepoint structures are examined separately (the same form as Political Economy E24; own undertaking). Being able to refuse must be real: refusing is no harder than agreeing, a refusal still leaves an option that is not worse, and those who have refused are not asked again and again. Attention, and data about a person, are not sold as commodities unless he is informed and able to refuse.

§6 Direction: Giving the Real Thing, Giving More of a Way Forward

This section speaks of the direction of giving conditions, and also of the baseline that must still be kept while giving them.

Giving the real thing. The product does what it says. This is the plainest thing between users and a company, and also the company's main contribution to its users.

Giving more of a way forward. Give him information, give him comparisons, give him exit. A company that makes it easier for users to compare it with others, and easier to leave with their data, is giving them conditions.

AI helping users think clearly. Economics P6 has written of a direction: AI helping a person think clearly about what he really wants, rather than thinking for him and pushing him to buy. This paper takes that direction; that paper's judgment serves only as corroboration.

Users' voice. Users can question the company, and asking has efficacy; this is examined by the three questions: who can activate it, what actual efficacy it has, and how the party questioned cannot cancel it on its own (Political Economy Paper 3, E16). This is a tendency at the rule layer; the nearer a chokepoint, the more real appeals must be. There is one more case on Echo Wall. In the autumn of Year 23, the kiln workshop opened by the veteran kiln worker from Bluekiln received more than a hundred one-star reviews within a week, all from newly registered accounts; it appealed to Echo Wall, and three weeks later Echo Wall deleted sixty of them, saying that "the rest do not constitute violations." The appeal was handled by Echo Wall's own content review team, which gave no reasons. The appeal had some effect; whether this channel is functionally independent of the party questioned must still be examined by actual control (Institution Theory Z34). This case still does not by itself prove that the route of questioning has been sealed off.

In giving, the company does not set a person's direction for him. Paper 2 said that in giving conditions a company does not set a person's direction for him, and that deciding a person's own affairs for him under the guise of cultivation is colonization in the narrow sense. This is extended here to users (own undertaking): recommendations and "for your own good" designs that, in the form of cultivation, decide a user's own affairs for him are colonization in the narrow sense (A Way Out, a Way Forward, E41; Rights Theory P6 F26). The boundary must be made clear: an interface that gets around his judgment without passing itself off as cultivation is manipulation, belongs to §3, and is called line-crossing (the Prequel, §7).

Discipline. The content of contribution is a direction, not a duty; keeping promises, keeping open the channels of questioning and not setting a person's direction for him are still examined by the earlier sections and by Paper 2. Outcomes are not taken as rules.

Where This Paper Stops

This paper has laid down three propositions: no locking in, no manipulation, no deception (GS8); health and safety are not traded for profit, when a danger appears the company stops first, and the accountability to stop first is not limited by fault (GS8a); a model is judged by its execution, not by its name, and being able to refuse must be real (GS9).

What it has not proved: how data protection law should be designed; how chokepoints are identified and how competition is reviewed, which are handed to a later theory of the market; the particular regulations on recalls.

Handed to the later papers: the sellers on Crossways Market, in Paper 4; the accountability of the sole position of supply at the life-substrate on the side of society, in Paper 5, §4; how the channels that keep the direction are independent of the party questioned, in Paper 6, §2.

Remainders left: when the two kinds of difficulty in leaving are interwoven, which part the company has set up must be examined item by item, and there is no general way of dividing them (§2); how far to stop first, and how losses are divided, the normative layer has given only a direction (§4); how far "an option that is not worse" must be not worse is left to the rule layer and the judgment layer (§5).

The Three Propositions of This Paper

GS8 No locking in, no manipulation, no deception. Whether data can be taken along, and whether unsubscribing is no harder than subscribing, are the two places the normative layer asks about first; the costs and conditions the company sets do not seal off the channels for exiting, refusing, revoking, or passing into review (per Political Economy E21, E12a). Recommending is permitted; whether to choose remains his own affair; interfaces are not designed to deceive him or to get around his judgment. The closer to a chokepoint, the stronger the checks (per Political Economy E7, A Way Out, a Way Forward, E41, E41a; own undertaking).

GS8a Health and safety are not traded for profit. Products do not trade harm to people's health and safety for profit; this is a line, not weighed on the scale of profit (per Institution Theory Z9). When a danger appears, the company first stops and isolates the dangerous product, stage or practice, and the cost falls on what the company does, not on users; where it is the sole position of supply at the life-substrate, how it stops and how supply is taken over are examined under Political Economy E11a. The accountability to stop first is not limited by fault: if the danger was not caused by the company but lands on its product, it still stops first; compensation and the allocation of losses have their own grounds (own undertaking).

GS9 A model is judged by its execution, not by its name. As far as users enter an exchange of data and attention, being informed, being able to refuse and not being held fast make it an exchange in the Emergence Layer; where these are not met, the line is crossed. Other harms to the Base Layer, effects on third parties and chokepoint structures are examined separately (the same form as Political Economy E24; own undertaking). Being able to refuse must be real: refusing is no harder than agreeing, a refusal still leaves an option that is not worse, and those who have refused are not asked again and again. Attention, and data about a person, are not sold as commodities unless he is informed and able to refuse.

References

All SAE works below are cited by concept DOI, which always resolves to the latest version.

I · This system

Qin, H. (2026). Not Crossing the Line (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23270384

Qin, H. (2026). Open to Questioning (SAE Institution Theory, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23271324

Qin, H. (2026). Chokepoints (SAE Political Economy, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874140

Qin, H. (2026). Checks (SAE Political Economy, Paper 3) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874142

Qin, H. (2026). Conversion (SAE Political Economy, Paper 4) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23874146

Qin, H. (2026). A Way Out, a Way Forward (SAE Political Economy, Specialist Paper) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24021385

Qin, H. (2026). On the Cultivation and Diachronic Unfolding of Rights (SAE Rights Theory, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21252863

Qin, H. (2026). Kingdom of Ends vs Kingdom of Means: Phase-Transition Acceleration in the Age of AI (SAE Economics, Paper 6) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19396633

Qin, H. (2026). What a Company Is Not (SAE Theory of the Company, Prequel) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24045716

Qin, H. (2026). Investment (SAE Theory of the Company, Paper 1) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24045721

Qin, H. (2026). Working Together (SAE Theory of the Company, Paper 2) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24045723

II · Statutes and regulatory findings (originals, tier A)

Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (General Data Protection Regulation), Art. 20. EUR-Lex.

Regulation (EU) 2022/1925 (Digital Markets Act), Art. 5(2), Art. 6(9), Recitals 36–37. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:32022R1925

Regulation (EU) 2022/2065 (Digital Services Act), Art. 25. EUR-Lex.

Regulation (EU) 2023/2854 (Data Act), Art. 29. EUR-Lex.

Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch (BGB), §312k. https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bgb/__312k.html (accessed 2026-11-07)

European Commission. (2025, April 23). Press release IP/25/1085. https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_25_1085

III · Sources of the examples

Johnson & Johnson. Our Credo (current text). https://www.jnj.com/our-credo (tier A: the company's own credo in the original; accessed 2026-11-07)

Johnson & Johnson. 8 fun facts about the Johnson & Johnson Credo. https://www.jnj.com/our-heritage/8-fun-facts-about-the-johnson-johnson-credo (tier A: the company's own account of the revisions)

Velasco, S. (2012, December 12). [The five most important product recalls in U.S. history: Tylenol]. The Christian Science Monitor. https://csmonitor.com/Business/2012/1212/Top-5-most-important-product-recalls-in-US-history/Tylenol (tier B)

IV · Constructed examples

The Kingdom State, Apple City, Crossways Group, Crossways Market, Crossways Home, Echo Wall and the kiln workshop are carried over from the examples set up in the Political Economy series; they are not real places, companies or events.

Interfaces

Main upstream: Political Economy Paper 2, E7, E11a, E12a, Paper 3, E14, E16, Paper 4, E21, E24; A Way Out, a Way Forward, E41, E41a; Institution Theory Z9, Z34; Rights Theory P6 F26.

Also used: Economics P6 (corroboration).

Examples: Johnson & Johnson's recall of 1982 (B) and its current credo (A); GDPR Article 20, DMA Articles 5(2) and 6(9) and Recitals 36 and 37, Data Act Article 29, BGB §312k, DSA Article 25 (all A); the European Commission's non-compliance decision against Meta (A); the ranking on Crossways Market, and the deletion of reviews and the appeal on Echo Wall (constructed).

This series: the Prequel (colonization in the narrow sense; the boundary between line-crossing and colonization); Paper 1, GS2, GS3; Paper 2, GS6.

Handed to Paper 4: partners: the sellers on Crossways.